state of california vs. association for firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.)...

20
- ,.- 1 .., = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) (.) (!) 0 0 g i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 J7 .l-8.:' .w 20 :$1 22 -Z3 2s: 46 !1,7 2R fi FILED SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF ORANGE . CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER SEP 3 0 2009· !>.LAN of t11e Cour! BY L BROWN ALAN CARLSON, Clerk of the Court SUPERIOR. OO:URT:OF"THE.STAT:E:·op: 'CALIFORNIA . . . . . . . . . .. . . .... .. .. . . ... .. . .. ·. CQUNT¥ :ov :.. ·THE:.'f.E'(i)'PLE.OF·TliF;-.STATE oF ·. ·· · · · · "'f . v. AiSSOCIATIONFORFJ.'REFIGHTERS: ·>::.CALL, · Uept:. ·extos. :·.I)EF.EN:D=ANTS :.Action Filed.:: 'May 22;-.2009

Upload: others

Post on 25-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

- shy

1 = oc 2w c 0 () ~-() ()

0 0 4middotg

i c 5

6 t3 w u 7

8

9

tO

11

12middot

l3

t4 15

middot-~~-

J7

l-8

w 20

$1

22

-Z3

~24

2s

46

17

2R fi

bull

FILED SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF ORANGE CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER

SEP 3 0 2009middot

gtLAN CAR~S~Ierk of t11e Cour

-t~ BY L BROWN

ALAN CARLSON Clerk of the Court

SUPERIOR OOURTOFTHESTATEmiddotop CALIFORNIA middot

CQUNTyen ov QRA~~e ~--

middotTHEfE(i)PLEOFmiddotTliF-STATE oF n(Lmiddotmiddot-ronn~lmiddotmiddotamplt middot middot middot middot middot middot middot ~ni tIUI(U~ f

P~JNflFF

v

AiSSOCIATIONFORFJREFIGHTERS

~1~~middoti~=fi~F~SPw~ ~~PQfI~Jl~(~COlJltfE middotgtCALL INC~rDopounds11fiOincent1ustn~middot middotUept middotextos

middotI)EFEND=ANTS Action Filed May 22-2009

I

Thcent ptmfes11aVesti]miated tQmiddotcenttrY ofthfsCoh~entJdgmef1t ThemiddotGourt approves

the partiesmiddot sfipulatiom Acconiinglylt lS uEREBYtiRDEREn XbJubGEUAND

DECSEEDmiddotEJS Jolluw$

t JURISDICTION ANIJSCOPE

middott middotAticentastSOsta~~sjo1~tlYh1vestigatednumeraumiddots -a11egations middotorviolationsmiddotof

State middotLaw1middotgp~emitampstslicltationsofcharitablemiddotcontributions~ AU ~aitio~patingmiddotstates I

naveQODtempo~aneou$1y filedmiddotUiis]11d~enfip th~irmiddot reSpecti-vemiddot-colirtS

2~ middotpeI14~~rmiddotco~Pn~~ ~~PP~~J~qls~N~ad~centQiPQi1tt~tfWithit$middot

pcltlcipalJJiate ofbusiness at3liE Wisconsilhltve- su1te4(i~ Mflwatik~e~ WiscollSm1

3 -Ccnnflluriicy Sugptfili$middot~S4~dil)ptof~$~fp~alnm$~si]1amp ~nl~centhalf1)f

middotcbari(aij1e()tgattiz~t$centlP$thtPJgltt~JAPhon~middotsolicitiitibl)~ ~P~~ti~~~~ attd is ~r ~~prqf~$io~l fund~t~iser-middotmiddotor ~~paidsuticitor~for~~professi~iLsolkitoti=fmiddotormiddotqommercitd

4~middot Th(s CoArtJr~sjPi~dicriqn over the partiesandmiddotthesubjectmatter orthis

11tiigat1onas setforth 1n the-stipulation~ middotmotiltm compWjt orpetitien riJ~d

pont~mPQt~~tislyWitltthisbull)i9igmcentjt

$ The rrtt~tptetao~-and centnfor9eJh~ntc)ffhis JudgmenfiShalfhe governed bymiddot

the iaws orttiestate inmiddot-which1Ust11ed

middot 6 middotThe terms ofthis Jtldgment shall~pplyto CommtmitySil~p9rt~lP9~~middotand itsmiddot

~middotoftie~rs~ directots e~ployregs poundlgtits~icentpre$entativesJ~$i8UQ~~Q($ an4~~iWsan9 All

PersotlS -~o~citnts p~tmet$h~p$~ ~no middot6thcentr entftieSJ~ng~g~ltfih -the~middotalicitatiortot

QO~l~ion of~Qnttibuthms on behalfofclientSmiddotofCommunityjSupport~ Inc

Defuiitions

7~ For piJiP~centsotthls Judgmen4middot thetOUowingmiddotd~fWtibri$~PPiy

a Commupiey $iJpporl1 meansCommnnitysupport Inc~ its offie~r ~it~~t()rs~ emplqyee~ ag_~nts representativesriis snecessors and assps andJulpersons~ ct1Jrpqrations~partnershipsmiddot~ and middototheifmiddotentiticentsmiddot middoteQg~geamp1n thesoicitat~on OIcollectiori of~c~rittJbitiQD$ QtLbcenth~fqf clientsJ)Gommuriity SupP~ttm~

l ltiffecent~ivcent o~~~~middot~11 beJ~XilY+Jt200~ middotc ~~tgtonatitm~~ ormiddot~~contribution~~ middotrneans~middotn1eneyor1tem~ofvalue

provided)lnr~sponsemiddotto middota=~S()Ucii~ti=on m~demiddotQn-bchalt pi ifiJJ-1~middot~( middotofany nonpr-ofieo~i~pn

a Dltmorfu~ns apypcentr$m otb1ls)fle$5-$p(~centiteampfot~middot 4p~~tj0JlQt contttbtJti~Ji

e~ ~iuuitYmcentregS any middotnqnpt(gtti_totcharitabl(iorganizatioomiddotonwhos_e behalfCommunity Supportmiddotsdiioits donations or-c~mtdbutions

f ~PersOn~middot in~$ natur~lperspn~Ar~~i~tiigt~ or othed~~l ~tit)k middotmcentludin~middot~a-coftPOrati0n lartrlcent~blp pt~prletorsl1ipmiddot association

=COOperatiVe gPvemment agenty~ Of any=ofhergroup er combimifion actingasaneritity

h middot~Sett11ngstat~~meansmiddotthestates that ltwiJiA1leAhisCOOsetii Judgment Asmiddotgtoffbe s~W1ingofthiS==Consent lJJ4gm~nithose(states may indlu$ Alaska Aikansa~~ CbloradQtFJqri~ GeQIgial~awaii lllinoist tn4ian~~middotlowt~ K~nas~ KentuckYLoAi$1~a~Miltyl~d~ Mirin saf~ MiSsissi i Missouri Mo trui middotNevitdamiddotmiddotNmiddotdmiddot~ middot ~~ pp n amp t (Yr

Ham shitemiddotNewJetsmiddot middotNew Me~i~o NotttrDakot Oldampbull p bull ~ middot middot ~ middot 9~1~()m~ 9tegprt Rhod~= Is~~dmiddotrcentx~$ Wasljfugta~~ Wf~ Vbgini~an4~Wi$COri$ii1l Filrthet GQ~uni~Supp()rt~ middotme cqnsentsmiddotlo fil~~ltienal $tates not i1stedAlerefillngmiddotthiscon5rent Ju~gment middotThis~oortsenijudgmenfis=vaHilasbelween donunutilirymiddot SYpof4)nc middotandany ~tateithatmiddote~~cutes angentevs it witlumfwgard

middot tp middotWb~fPeranyJltheimiddotst~te~ middot~ilso execentut~middot~4Qtmiddot~ntei=lt middot

8 IT IS HEREBYOIDEREDmiddottbat CommunioS~port=in comectitmmiddotwith

solioitingcoritributionsf middotisJllt~r~by ~permarien~ty resfraincent4an~ enjolncentd from middot

Amiddot middotMiscentPfe~cent1itiJ~g~ PrSsi~tingmiddotothersmiddotmiddot in middotmiddotm1$t~~$ettPg~middote~pres~1y-ormiddotby

iinpllcentationota1lymiddotot iii -writing any material fact through fatseotmfsleadiQg

siatwnentiorrepresentatt()ns Withouiliniitirigtllefqf~gqing~~s plfPJilbi~io~

l middotmfsrepresent~$e ~atJreor ptcentpo~e ofthemiddotcharitabi~middotprogram ~cent~iviti~ middotmiddot

2) middotmisreptesenilng middotthePortionorfhe donationmiddotthat-will b~middotr~~incentd bf middotmiddotthecentnaritr= middot middot

3) middotiDisr~prcents~p~middottllePOtfiltirqftl1e~riplltiOrfthfltmiddotWill bedirectly used fCJt-its~inlity~$ charhablepses

i

middot4) m1srepresentfug(eithermiddotspedficallymiddotorgenerall~ that themiddotcharitymiddot has 8Jly--connectibn middottomiddotor is affilialeifwithmiddotanmiddotorganizatiQnor~en~y~ includ~ngaJollcefi~ ormiddotothermiddotpJililicsafety tgtrg~izatioo middot

middot5) middotm1$r~pres~rttingth~t don~~ttts -W-tu g~ tp ~ SP~i~ltrpllP~$~middotmiddotor PrltgtgrammiddotmiddotqJiess th~ middotamountmiddoto(donations thatwiii aotuaityibeased for middotfuatpurpose orprogram or middotmiddota pottianisreasanab~y-in middotproportiontomiddotthe charitysmiddottntalprogram middotsemceexpenditures middot

middot6) mi~r~presenthlg tli~t domiq(ns wiflbcentncentfitpers()ns~middotor otgani~ti()~ ~nmiddottllcent (i()iiqtJsState ot localcQ~tnuri~cyQnl~s$ asregstanUill pcgtrtio~f middotonneChatizymiddotmiddot~middotprltgtgram middotseryenic~ areProvbull4cent4 jn tJ~t-stateorlq~f

COitlfuUli~tYmiddot

7) middotmisreptes~ntiDg that aresidentofamiddothousehold has previouslrmiddotmiddot donated totbeeharitmiddoto~ the amouritmiddotofanypreviousmiddotdonaix01~ and

~)middot tilis~i~premiddotsentin~that- a person hasmiddotalliea~tliadea _pleqgcent middot~cH~~ate to thcicharlty middot middot

B E~eeptmiddota$prov1dedfn p~graphC~fthls sectlonusng a lotalstateJOt

t~iional address ontetumenvelopesandothermiddotsolicitation ormiddotcol1ectiun-materials

Utilesstheraddresslg on~middotafwhich fue middotClient charity~middotctua1~Y ~~~inmiddotOng()ingmiddot

pbysic~tPte~eilccent and Qon41Jcentf$ $ufgt$tiint~~~ ~~tiyeni~icentsmiddot~~I~centdtomiddot~~~is~jjg

cent~Pept ~tCortregutiity Sttppo~shaifhave noffior~ thanmiddot90 days ftiommiddot-iite

EffectiveOaiemiddotmiddotofthis Jud~entto oontfuue touse suppUes ofWUtt~g ma~edalsJt

ha4 middotonhandonMay 12009 middotNtgtncentthel~s~ CoiDampUbUy S4ppqtt$~ampU middotc()lPIY

With th$ retj~ii~ment ~middot$0Qn ~$practicable

i CSfmay usemiddotthea44ress ofanatbnalmiddotora re~onatprocessingmiddotcenter

middotasneceSSatYiopromote costs~Ying~ whi~h mU$t middotb~ clearlymiddotmiddotand

middotcanspiCuP~sly identifie4gt~sbeingtlma1ipropessingmiddotaddresson

maflingsandple~gematerialsreceived~~r~cmiddotonsumersmiddotso-thatthemiddot

consurner~ouJfnoi misapprehendthatttie add~ampmiddot is middotth~ l~ati4yentmiddotPt

dOItations instates ormiddotlncai commlnities lnmiddotwhiehmiddotCQtmlltmify S11PfoiritJS

solicitingmiddotunlessthemiddotdlicentritcenth~llyacenttJ~~Y ]l~middotartongo~ti~~p~ySieaiptcent$~C~xand

eondlaquocts sub$tautiaJ~q~yiti~spnrel~te4 to~Q_~ai~iQgln such $taleor middot1ocar

cotiUiiregitY~ ComtnurtiiY Supi)ortmustccentas~middotmiddotthcentusemiddototattsuchmiddotpostofficemiddotboxesmiddot

orprivate maifbttxes~no middotlatetthart90daysmiddotfrom tbemiddotEfectiYemiddotDiiemiddotofthis

Judgsneni

middoto~ F~lmgt~fpfPvt~eth~foiiomngmiddotci~sdos~stNfrm FOLtowtNa

OlU)Eltafienl1~middot0penlnggreedngof1he catlan(tafter~disclosureofthe factth~

catlis beinmiddotrecordedor-middotin close llroximitrmiddot middottO middotthemiddot~(lJdng~~tiiL$ ~4

b~ginnin~tmgt~laterthailmiddotthtrTHIRJl$centJltcentnccent-idtermiddotthcentqp~ntpggrcenteJingqfUi~middot

Ptcentsen~~iotand lPAli Pt$11CCS lriot t() mereq~estfdNlQfJifianeiat support

1 ~~ 11am~9fUfein~ivi4uaJ ~l)Hci~or ~4middot ~eicentat~d unamb~~ous

idcentntifieatiortQfco(tipant-heor snewarks fer Fnrtherr Crim~unily

middot~tJpp9~7mcmiddotshaltmiddotavoidanyphrasill~peasonablylik~lymiddottPcall$e

cortfusion al~tween fuecompanyn~nn~~imdth~otdin~middot usageofth~

-middot)

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 2: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

I

Thcent ptmfes11aVesti]miated tQmiddotcenttrY ofthfsCoh~entJdgmef1t ThemiddotGourt approves

the partiesmiddot sfipulatiom Acconiinglylt lS uEREBYtiRDEREn XbJubGEUAND

DECSEEDmiddotEJS Jolluw$

t JURISDICTION ANIJSCOPE

middott middotAticentastSOsta~~sjo1~tlYh1vestigatednumeraumiddots -a11egations middotorviolationsmiddotof

State middotLaw1middotgp~emitampstslicltationsofcharitablemiddotcontributions~ AU ~aitio~patingmiddotstates I

naveQODtempo~aneou$1y filedmiddotUiis]11d~enfip th~irmiddot reSpecti-vemiddot-colirtS

2~ middotpeI14~~rmiddotco~Pn~~ ~~PP~~J~qls~N~ad~centQiPQi1tt~tfWithit$middot

pcltlcipalJJiate ofbusiness at3liE Wisconsilhltve- su1te4(i~ Mflwatik~e~ WiscollSm1

3 -Ccnnflluriicy Sugptfili$middot~S4~dil)ptof~$~fp~alnm$~si]1amp ~nl~centhalf1)f

middotcbari(aij1e()tgattiz~t$centlP$thtPJgltt~JAPhon~middotsolicitiitibl)~ ~P~~ti~~~~ attd is ~r ~~prqf~$io~l fund~t~iser-middotmiddotor ~~paidsuticitor~for~~professi~iLsolkitoti=fmiddotormiddotqommercitd

4~middot Th(s CoArtJr~sjPi~dicriqn over the partiesandmiddotthesubjectmatter orthis

11tiigat1onas setforth 1n the-stipulation~ middotmotiltm compWjt orpetitien riJ~d

pont~mPQt~~tislyWitltthisbull)i9igmcentjt

$ The rrtt~tptetao~-and centnfor9eJh~ntc)ffhis JudgmenfiShalfhe governed bymiddot

the iaws orttiestate inmiddot-which1Ust11ed

middot 6 middotThe terms ofthis Jtldgment shall~pplyto CommtmitySil~p9rt~lP9~~middotand itsmiddot

~middotoftie~rs~ directots e~ployregs poundlgtits~icentpre$entativesJ~$i8UQ~~Q($ an4~~iWsan9 All

PersotlS -~o~citnts p~tmet$h~p$~ ~no middot6thcentr entftieSJ~ng~g~ltfih -the~middotalicitatiortot

QO~l~ion of~Qnttibuthms on behalfofclientSmiddotofCommunityjSupport~ Inc

Defuiitions

7~ For piJiP~centsotthls Judgmen4middot thetOUowingmiddotd~fWtibri$~PPiy

a Commupiey $iJpporl1 meansCommnnitysupport Inc~ its offie~r ~it~~t()rs~ emplqyee~ ag_~nts representativesriis snecessors and assps andJulpersons~ ct1Jrpqrations~partnershipsmiddot~ and middototheifmiddotentiticentsmiddot middoteQg~geamp1n thesoicitat~on OIcollectiori of~c~rittJbitiQD$ QtLbcenth~fqf clientsJ)Gommuriity SupP~ttm~

l ltiffecent~ivcent o~~~~middot~11 beJ~XilY+Jt200~ middotc ~~tgtonatitm~~ ormiddot~~contribution~~ middotrneans~middotn1eneyor1tem~ofvalue

provided)lnr~sponsemiddotto middota=~S()Ucii~ti=on m~demiddotQn-bchalt pi ifiJJ-1~middot~( middotofany nonpr-ofieo~i~pn

a Dltmorfu~ns apypcentr$m otb1ls)fle$5-$p(~centiteampfot~middot 4p~~tj0JlQt contttbtJti~Ji

e~ ~iuuitYmcentregS any middotnqnpt(gtti_totcharitabl(iorganizatioomiddotonwhos_e behalfCommunity Supportmiddotsdiioits donations or-c~mtdbutions

f ~PersOn~middot in~$ natur~lperspn~Ar~~i~tiigt~ or othed~~l ~tit)k middotmcentludin~middot~a-coftPOrati0n lartrlcent~blp pt~prletorsl1ipmiddot association

=COOperatiVe gPvemment agenty~ Of any=ofhergroup er combimifion actingasaneritity

h middot~Sett11ngstat~~meansmiddotthestates that ltwiJiA1leAhisCOOsetii Judgment Asmiddotgtoffbe s~W1ingofthiS==Consent lJJ4gm~nithose(states may indlu$ Alaska Aikansa~~ CbloradQtFJqri~ GeQIgial~awaii lllinoist tn4ian~~middotlowt~ K~nas~ KentuckYLoAi$1~a~Miltyl~d~ Mirin saf~ MiSsissi i Missouri Mo trui middotNevitdamiddotmiddotNmiddotdmiddot~ middot ~~ pp n amp t (Yr

Ham shitemiddotNewJetsmiddot middotNew Me~i~o NotttrDakot Oldampbull p bull ~ middot middot ~ middot 9~1~()m~ 9tegprt Rhod~= Is~~dmiddotrcentx~$ Wasljfugta~~ Wf~ Vbgini~an4~Wi$COri$ii1l Filrthet GQ~uni~Supp()rt~ middotme cqnsentsmiddotlo fil~~ltienal $tates not i1stedAlerefillngmiddotthiscon5rent Ju~gment middotThis~oortsenijudgmenfis=vaHilasbelween donunutilirymiddot SYpof4)nc middotandany ~tateithatmiddote~~cutes angentevs it witlumfwgard

middot tp middotWb~fPeranyJltheimiddotst~te~ middot~ilso execentut~middot~4Qtmiddot~ntei=lt middot

8 IT IS HEREBYOIDEREDmiddottbat CommunioS~port=in comectitmmiddotwith

solioitingcoritributionsf middotisJllt~r~by ~permarien~ty resfraincent4an~ enjolncentd from middot

Amiddot middotMiscentPfe~cent1itiJ~g~ PrSsi~tingmiddotothersmiddotmiddot in middotmiddotm1$t~~$ettPg~middote~pres~1y-ormiddotby

iinpllcentationota1lymiddotot iii -writing any material fact through fatseotmfsleadiQg

siatwnentiorrepresentatt()ns Withouiliniitirigtllefqf~gqing~~s plfPJilbi~io~

l middotmfsrepresent~$e ~atJreor ptcentpo~e ofthemiddotcharitabi~middotprogram ~cent~iviti~ middotmiddot

2) middotmisreptesenilng middotthePortionorfhe donationmiddotthat-will b~middotr~~incentd bf middotmiddotthecentnaritr= middot middot

3) middotiDisr~prcents~p~middottllePOtfiltirqftl1e~riplltiOrfthfltmiddotWill bedirectly used fCJt-its~inlity~$ charhablepses

i

middot4) m1srepresentfug(eithermiddotspedficallymiddotorgenerall~ that themiddotcharitymiddot has 8Jly--connectibn middottomiddotor is affilialeifwithmiddotanmiddotorganizatiQnor~en~y~ includ~ngaJollcefi~ ormiddotothermiddotpJililicsafety tgtrg~izatioo middot

middot5) middotm1$r~pres~rttingth~t don~~ttts -W-tu g~ tp ~ SP~i~ltrpllP~$~middotmiddotor PrltgtgrammiddotmiddotqJiess th~ middotamountmiddoto(donations thatwiii aotuaityibeased for middotfuatpurpose orprogram or middotmiddota pottianisreasanab~y-in middotproportiontomiddotthe charitysmiddottntalprogram middotsemceexpenditures middot

middot6) mi~r~presenthlg tli~t domiq(ns wiflbcentncentfitpers()ns~middotor otgani~ti()~ ~nmiddottllcent (i()iiqtJsState ot localcQ~tnuri~cyQnl~s$ asregstanUill pcgtrtio~f middotonneChatizymiddotmiddot~middotprltgtgram middotseryenic~ areProvbull4cent4 jn tJ~t-stateorlq~f

COitlfuUli~tYmiddot

7) middotmisreptes~ntiDg that aresidentofamiddothousehold has previouslrmiddotmiddot donated totbeeharitmiddoto~ the amouritmiddotofanypreviousmiddotdonaix01~ and

~)middot tilis~i~premiddotsentin~that- a person hasmiddotalliea~tliadea _pleqgcent middot~cH~~ate to thcicharlty middot middot

B E~eeptmiddota$prov1dedfn p~graphC~fthls sectlonusng a lotalstateJOt

t~iional address ontetumenvelopesandothermiddotsolicitation ormiddotcol1ectiun-materials

Utilesstheraddresslg on~middotafwhich fue middotClient charity~middotctua1~Y ~~~inmiddotOng()ingmiddot

pbysic~tPte~eilccent and Qon41Jcentf$ $ufgt$tiint~~~ ~~tiyeni~icentsmiddot~~I~centdtomiddot~~~is~jjg

cent~Pept ~tCortregutiity Sttppo~shaifhave noffior~ thanmiddot90 days ftiommiddot-iite

EffectiveOaiemiddotmiddotofthis Jud~entto oontfuue touse suppUes ofWUtt~g ma~edalsJt

ha4 middotonhandonMay 12009 middotNtgtncentthel~s~ CoiDampUbUy S4ppqtt$~ampU middotc()lPIY

With th$ retj~ii~ment ~middot$0Qn ~$practicable

i CSfmay usemiddotthea44ress ofanatbnalmiddotora re~onatprocessingmiddotcenter

middotasneceSSatYiopromote costs~Ying~ whi~h mU$t middotb~ clearlymiddotmiddotand

middotcanspiCuP~sly identifie4gt~sbeingtlma1ipropessingmiddotaddresson

maflingsandple~gematerialsreceived~~r~cmiddotonsumersmiddotso-thatthemiddot

consurner~ouJfnoi misapprehendthatttie add~ampmiddot is middotth~ l~ati4yentmiddotPt

dOItations instates ormiddotlncai commlnities lnmiddotwhiehmiddotCQtmlltmify S11PfoiritJS

solicitingmiddotunlessthemiddotdlicentritcenth~llyacenttJ~~Y ]l~middotartongo~ti~~p~ySieaiptcent$~C~xand

eondlaquocts sub$tautiaJ~q~yiti~spnrel~te4 to~Q_~ai~iQgln such $taleor middot1ocar

cotiUiiregitY~ ComtnurtiiY Supi)ortmustccentas~middotmiddotthcentusemiddototattsuchmiddotpostofficemiddotboxesmiddot

orprivate maifbttxes~no middotlatetthart90daysmiddotfrom tbemiddotEfectiYemiddotDiiemiddotofthis

Judgsneni

middoto~ F~lmgt~fpfPvt~eth~foiiomngmiddotci~sdos~stNfrm FOLtowtNa

OlU)Eltafienl1~middot0penlnggreedngof1he catlan(tafter~disclosureofthe factth~

catlis beinmiddotrecordedor-middotin close llroximitrmiddot middottO middotthemiddot~(lJdng~~tiiL$ ~4

b~ginnin~tmgt~laterthailmiddotthtrTHIRJl$centJltcentnccent-idtermiddotthcentqp~ntpggrcenteJingqfUi~middot

Ptcentsen~~iotand lPAli Pt$11CCS lriot t() mereq~estfdNlQfJifianeiat support

1 ~~ 11am~9fUfein~ivi4uaJ ~l)Hci~or ~4middot ~eicentat~d unamb~~ous

idcentntifieatiortQfco(tipant-heor snewarks fer Fnrtherr Crim~unily

middot~tJpp9~7mcmiddotshaltmiddotavoidanyphrasill~peasonablylik~lymiddottPcall$e

cortfusion al~tween fuecompanyn~nn~~imdth~otdin~middot usageofth~

-middot)

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 3: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

4~middot Th(s CoArtJr~sjPi~dicriqn over the partiesandmiddotthesubjectmatter orthis

11tiigat1onas setforth 1n the-stipulation~ middotmotiltm compWjt orpetitien riJ~d

pont~mPQt~~tislyWitltthisbull)i9igmcentjt

$ The rrtt~tptetao~-and centnfor9eJh~ntc)ffhis JudgmenfiShalfhe governed bymiddot

the iaws orttiestate inmiddot-which1Ust11ed

middot 6 middotThe terms ofthis Jtldgment shall~pplyto CommtmitySil~p9rt~lP9~~middotand itsmiddot

~middotoftie~rs~ directots e~ployregs poundlgtits~icentpre$entativesJ~$i8UQ~~Q($ an4~~iWsan9 All

PersotlS -~o~citnts p~tmet$h~p$~ ~no middot6thcentr entftieSJ~ng~g~ltfih -the~middotalicitatiortot

QO~l~ion of~Qnttibuthms on behalfofclientSmiddotofCommunityjSupport~ Inc

Defuiitions

7~ For piJiP~centsotthls Judgmen4middot thetOUowingmiddotd~fWtibri$~PPiy

a Commupiey $iJpporl1 meansCommnnitysupport Inc~ its offie~r ~it~~t()rs~ emplqyee~ ag_~nts representativesriis snecessors and assps andJulpersons~ ct1Jrpqrations~partnershipsmiddot~ and middototheifmiddotentiticentsmiddot middoteQg~geamp1n thesoicitat~on OIcollectiori of~c~rittJbitiQD$ QtLbcenth~fqf clientsJ)Gommuriity SupP~ttm~

l ltiffecent~ivcent o~~~~middot~11 beJ~XilY+Jt200~ middotc ~~tgtonatitm~~ ormiddot~~contribution~~ middotrneans~middotn1eneyor1tem~ofvalue

provided)lnr~sponsemiddotto middota=~S()Ucii~ti=on m~demiddotQn-bchalt pi ifiJJ-1~middot~( middotofany nonpr-ofieo~i~pn

a Dltmorfu~ns apypcentr$m otb1ls)fle$5-$p(~centiteampfot~middot 4p~~tj0JlQt contttbtJti~Ji

e~ ~iuuitYmcentregS any middotnqnpt(gtti_totcharitabl(iorganizatioomiddotonwhos_e behalfCommunity Supportmiddotsdiioits donations or-c~mtdbutions

f ~PersOn~middot in~$ natur~lperspn~Ar~~i~tiigt~ or othed~~l ~tit)k middotmcentludin~middot~a-coftPOrati0n lartrlcent~blp pt~prletorsl1ipmiddot association

=COOperatiVe gPvemment agenty~ Of any=ofhergroup er combimifion actingasaneritity

h middot~Sett11ngstat~~meansmiddotthestates that ltwiJiA1leAhisCOOsetii Judgment Asmiddotgtoffbe s~W1ingofthiS==Consent lJJ4gm~nithose(states may indlu$ Alaska Aikansa~~ CbloradQtFJqri~ GeQIgial~awaii lllinoist tn4ian~~middotlowt~ K~nas~ KentuckYLoAi$1~a~Miltyl~d~ Mirin saf~ MiSsissi i Missouri Mo trui middotNevitdamiddotmiddotNmiddotdmiddot~ middot ~~ pp n amp t (Yr

Ham shitemiddotNewJetsmiddot middotNew Me~i~o NotttrDakot Oldampbull p bull ~ middot middot ~ middot 9~1~()m~ 9tegprt Rhod~= Is~~dmiddotrcentx~$ Wasljfugta~~ Wf~ Vbgini~an4~Wi$COri$ii1l Filrthet GQ~uni~Supp()rt~ middotme cqnsentsmiddotlo fil~~ltienal $tates not i1stedAlerefillngmiddotthiscon5rent Ju~gment middotThis~oortsenijudgmenfis=vaHilasbelween donunutilirymiddot SYpof4)nc middotandany ~tateithatmiddote~~cutes angentevs it witlumfwgard

middot tp middotWb~fPeranyJltheimiddotst~te~ middot~ilso execentut~middot~4Qtmiddot~ntei=lt middot

8 IT IS HEREBYOIDEREDmiddottbat CommunioS~port=in comectitmmiddotwith

solioitingcoritributionsf middotisJllt~r~by ~permarien~ty resfraincent4an~ enjolncentd from middot

Amiddot middotMiscentPfe~cent1itiJ~g~ PrSsi~tingmiddotothersmiddotmiddot in middotmiddotm1$t~~$ettPg~middote~pres~1y-ormiddotby

iinpllcentationota1lymiddotot iii -writing any material fact through fatseotmfsleadiQg

siatwnentiorrepresentatt()ns Withouiliniitirigtllefqf~gqing~~s plfPJilbi~io~

l middotmfsrepresent~$e ~atJreor ptcentpo~e ofthemiddotcharitabi~middotprogram ~cent~iviti~ middotmiddot

2) middotmisreptesenilng middotthePortionorfhe donationmiddotthat-will b~middotr~~incentd bf middotmiddotthecentnaritr= middot middot

3) middotiDisr~prcents~p~middottllePOtfiltirqftl1e~riplltiOrfthfltmiddotWill bedirectly used fCJt-its~inlity~$ charhablepses

i

middot4) m1srepresentfug(eithermiddotspedficallymiddotorgenerall~ that themiddotcharitymiddot has 8Jly--connectibn middottomiddotor is affilialeifwithmiddotanmiddotorganizatiQnor~en~y~ includ~ngaJollcefi~ ormiddotothermiddotpJililicsafety tgtrg~izatioo middot

middot5) middotm1$r~pres~rttingth~t don~~ttts -W-tu g~ tp ~ SP~i~ltrpllP~$~middotmiddotor PrltgtgrammiddotmiddotqJiess th~ middotamountmiddoto(donations thatwiii aotuaityibeased for middotfuatpurpose orprogram or middotmiddota pottianisreasanab~y-in middotproportiontomiddotthe charitysmiddottntalprogram middotsemceexpenditures middot

middot6) mi~r~presenthlg tli~t domiq(ns wiflbcentncentfitpers()ns~middotor otgani~ti()~ ~nmiddottllcent (i()iiqtJsState ot localcQ~tnuri~cyQnl~s$ asregstanUill pcgtrtio~f middotonneChatizymiddotmiddot~middotprltgtgram middotseryenic~ areProvbull4cent4 jn tJ~t-stateorlq~f

COitlfuUli~tYmiddot

7) middotmisreptes~ntiDg that aresidentofamiddothousehold has previouslrmiddotmiddot donated totbeeharitmiddoto~ the amouritmiddotofanypreviousmiddotdonaix01~ and

~)middot tilis~i~premiddotsentin~that- a person hasmiddotalliea~tliadea _pleqgcent middot~cH~~ate to thcicharlty middot middot

B E~eeptmiddota$prov1dedfn p~graphC~fthls sectlonusng a lotalstateJOt

t~iional address ontetumenvelopesandothermiddotsolicitation ormiddotcol1ectiun-materials

Utilesstheraddresslg on~middotafwhich fue middotClient charity~middotctua1~Y ~~~inmiddotOng()ingmiddot

pbysic~tPte~eilccent and Qon41Jcentf$ $ufgt$tiint~~~ ~~tiyeni~icentsmiddot~~I~centdtomiddot~~~is~jjg

cent~Pept ~tCortregutiity Sttppo~shaifhave noffior~ thanmiddot90 days ftiommiddot-iite

EffectiveOaiemiddotmiddotofthis Jud~entto oontfuue touse suppUes ofWUtt~g ma~edalsJt

ha4 middotonhandonMay 12009 middotNtgtncentthel~s~ CoiDampUbUy S4ppqtt$~ampU middotc()lPIY

With th$ retj~ii~ment ~middot$0Qn ~$practicable

i CSfmay usemiddotthea44ress ofanatbnalmiddotora re~onatprocessingmiddotcenter

middotasneceSSatYiopromote costs~Ying~ whi~h mU$t middotb~ clearlymiddotmiddotand

middotcanspiCuP~sly identifie4gt~sbeingtlma1ipropessingmiddotaddresson

maflingsandple~gematerialsreceived~~r~cmiddotonsumersmiddotso-thatthemiddot

consurner~ouJfnoi misapprehendthatttie add~ampmiddot is middotth~ l~ati4yentmiddotPt

dOItations instates ormiddotlncai commlnities lnmiddotwhiehmiddotCQtmlltmify S11PfoiritJS

solicitingmiddotunlessthemiddotdlicentritcenth~llyacenttJ~~Y ]l~middotartongo~ti~~p~ySieaiptcent$~C~xand

eondlaquocts sub$tautiaJ~q~yiti~spnrel~te4 to~Q_~ai~iQgln such $taleor middot1ocar

cotiUiiregitY~ ComtnurtiiY Supi)ortmustccentas~middotmiddotthcentusemiddototattsuchmiddotpostofficemiddotboxesmiddot

orprivate maifbttxes~no middotlatetthart90daysmiddotfrom tbemiddotEfectiYemiddotDiiemiddotofthis

Judgsneni

middoto~ F~lmgt~fpfPvt~eth~foiiomngmiddotci~sdos~stNfrm FOLtowtNa

OlU)Eltafienl1~middot0penlnggreedngof1he catlan(tafter~disclosureofthe factth~

catlis beinmiddotrecordedor-middotin close llroximitrmiddot middottO middotthemiddot~(lJdng~~tiiL$ ~4

b~ginnin~tmgt~laterthailmiddotthtrTHIRJl$centJltcentnccent-idtermiddotthcentqp~ntpggrcenteJingqfUi~middot

Ptcentsen~~iotand lPAli Pt$11CCS lriot t() mereq~estfdNlQfJifianeiat support

1 ~~ 11am~9fUfein~ivi4uaJ ~l)Hci~or ~4middot ~eicentat~d unamb~~ous

idcentntifieatiortQfco(tipant-heor snewarks fer Fnrtherr Crim~unily

middot~tJpp9~7mcmiddotshaltmiddotavoidanyphrasill~peasonablylik~lymiddottPcall$e

cortfusion al~tween fuecompanyn~nn~~imdth~otdin~middot usageofth~

-middot)

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 4: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

=COOperatiVe gPvemment agenty~ Of any=ofhergroup er combimifion actingasaneritity

h middot~Sett11ngstat~~meansmiddotthestates that ltwiJiA1leAhisCOOsetii Judgment Asmiddotgtoffbe s~W1ingofthiS==Consent lJJ4gm~nithose(states may indlu$ Alaska Aikansa~~ CbloradQtFJqri~ GeQIgial~awaii lllinoist tn4ian~~middotlowt~ K~nas~ KentuckYLoAi$1~a~Miltyl~d~ Mirin saf~ MiSsissi i Missouri Mo trui middotNevitdamiddotmiddotNmiddotdmiddot~ middot ~~ pp n amp t (Yr

Ham shitemiddotNewJetsmiddot middotNew Me~i~o NotttrDakot Oldampbull p bull ~ middot middot ~ middot 9~1~()m~ 9tegprt Rhod~= Is~~dmiddotrcentx~$ Wasljfugta~~ Wf~ Vbgini~an4~Wi$COri$ii1l Filrthet GQ~uni~Supp()rt~ middotme cqnsentsmiddotlo fil~~ltienal $tates not i1stedAlerefillngmiddotthiscon5rent Ju~gment middotThis~oortsenijudgmenfis=vaHilasbelween donunutilirymiddot SYpof4)nc middotandany ~tateithatmiddote~~cutes angentevs it witlumfwgard

middot tp middotWb~fPeranyJltheimiddotst~te~ middot~ilso execentut~middot~4Qtmiddot~ntei=lt middot

8 IT IS HEREBYOIDEREDmiddottbat CommunioS~port=in comectitmmiddotwith

solioitingcoritributionsf middotisJllt~r~by ~permarien~ty resfraincent4an~ enjolncentd from middot

Amiddot middotMiscentPfe~cent1itiJ~g~ PrSsi~tingmiddotothersmiddotmiddot in middotmiddotm1$t~~$ettPg~middote~pres~1y-ormiddotby

iinpllcentationota1lymiddotot iii -writing any material fact through fatseotmfsleadiQg

siatwnentiorrepresentatt()ns Withouiliniitirigtllefqf~gqing~~s plfPJilbi~io~

l middotmfsrepresent~$e ~atJreor ptcentpo~e ofthemiddotcharitabi~middotprogram ~cent~iviti~ middotmiddot

2) middotmisreptesenilng middotthePortionorfhe donationmiddotthat-will b~middotr~~incentd bf middotmiddotthecentnaritr= middot middot

3) middotiDisr~prcents~p~middottllePOtfiltirqftl1e~riplltiOrfthfltmiddotWill bedirectly used fCJt-its~inlity~$ charhablepses

i

middot4) m1srepresentfug(eithermiddotspedficallymiddotorgenerall~ that themiddotcharitymiddot has 8Jly--connectibn middottomiddotor is affilialeifwithmiddotanmiddotorganizatiQnor~en~y~ includ~ngaJollcefi~ ormiddotothermiddotpJililicsafety tgtrg~izatioo middot

middot5) middotm1$r~pres~rttingth~t don~~ttts -W-tu g~ tp ~ SP~i~ltrpllP~$~middotmiddotor PrltgtgrammiddotmiddotqJiess th~ middotamountmiddoto(donations thatwiii aotuaityibeased for middotfuatpurpose orprogram or middotmiddota pottianisreasanab~y-in middotproportiontomiddotthe charitysmiddottntalprogram middotsemceexpenditures middot

middot6) mi~r~presenthlg tli~t domiq(ns wiflbcentncentfitpers()ns~middotor otgani~ti()~ ~nmiddottllcent (i()iiqtJsState ot localcQ~tnuri~cyQnl~s$ asregstanUill pcgtrtio~f middotonneChatizymiddotmiddot~middotprltgtgram middotseryenic~ areProvbull4cent4 jn tJ~t-stateorlq~f

COitlfuUli~tYmiddot

7) middotmisreptes~ntiDg that aresidentofamiddothousehold has previouslrmiddotmiddot donated totbeeharitmiddoto~ the amouritmiddotofanypreviousmiddotdonaix01~ and

~)middot tilis~i~premiddotsentin~that- a person hasmiddotalliea~tliadea _pleqgcent middot~cH~~ate to thcicharlty middot middot

B E~eeptmiddota$prov1dedfn p~graphC~fthls sectlonusng a lotalstateJOt

t~iional address ontetumenvelopesandothermiddotsolicitation ormiddotcol1ectiun-materials

Utilesstheraddresslg on~middotafwhich fue middotClient charity~middotctua1~Y ~~~inmiddotOng()ingmiddot

pbysic~tPte~eilccent and Qon41Jcentf$ $ufgt$tiint~~~ ~~tiyeni~icentsmiddot~~I~centdtomiddot~~~is~jjg

cent~Pept ~tCortregutiity Sttppo~shaifhave noffior~ thanmiddot90 days ftiommiddot-iite

EffectiveOaiemiddotmiddotofthis Jud~entto oontfuue touse suppUes ofWUtt~g ma~edalsJt

ha4 middotonhandonMay 12009 middotNtgtncentthel~s~ CoiDampUbUy S4ppqtt$~ampU middotc()lPIY

With th$ retj~ii~ment ~middot$0Qn ~$practicable

i CSfmay usemiddotthea44ress ofanatbnalmiddotora re~onatprocessingmiddotcenter

middotasneceSSatYiopromote costs~Ying~ whi~h mU$t middotb~ clearlymiddotmiddotand

middotcanspiCuP~sly identifie4gt~sbeingtlma1ipropessingmiddotaddresson

maflingsandple~gematerialsreceived~~r~cmiddotonsumersmiddotso-thatthemiddot

consurner~ouJfnoi misapprehendthatttie add~ampmiddot is middotth~ l~ati4yentmiddotPt

dOItations instates ormiddotlncai commlnities lnmiddotwhiehmiddotCQtmlltmify S11PfoiritJS

solicitingmiddotunlessthemiddotdlicentritcenth~llyacenttJ~~Y ]l~middotartongo~ti~~p~ySieaiptcent$~C~xand

eondlaquocts sub$tautiaJ~q~yiti~spnrel~te4 to~Q_~ai~iQgln such $taleor middot1ocar

cotiUiiregitY~ ComtnurtiiY Supi)ortmustccentas~middotmiddotthcentusemiddototattsuchmiddotpostofficemiddotboxesmiddot

orprivate maifbttxes~no middotlatetthart90daysmiddotfrom tbemiddotEfectiYemiddotDiiemiddotofthis

Judgsneni

middoto~ F~lmgt~fpfPvt~eth~foiiomngmiddotci~sdos~stNfrm FOLtowtNa

OlU)Eltafienl1~middot0penlnggreedngof1he catlan(tafter~disclosureofthe factth~

catlis beinmiddotrecordedor-middotin close llroximitrmiddot middottO middotthemiddot~(lJdng~~tiiL$ ~4

b~ginnin~tmgt~laterthailmiddotthtrTHIRJl$centJltcentnccent-idtermiddotthcentqp~ntpggrcenteJingqfUi~middot

Ptcentsen~~iotand lPAli Pt$11CCS lriot t() mereq~estfdNlQfJifianeiat support

1 ~~ 11am~9fUfein~ivi4uaJ ~l)Hci~or ~4middot ~eicentat~d unamb~~ous

idcentntifieatiortQfco(tipant-heor snewarks fer Fnrtherr Crim~unily

middot~tJpp9~7mcmiddotshaltmiddotavoidanyphrasill~peasonablylik~lymiddottPcall$e

cortfusion al~tween fuecompanyn~nn~~imdth~otdin~middot usageofth~

-middot)

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 5: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

i

middot4) m1srepresentfug(eithermiddotspedficallymiddotorgenerall~ that themiddotcharitymiddot has 8Jly--connectibn middottomiddotor is affilialeifwithmiddotanmiddotorganizatiQnor~en~y~ includ~ngaJollcefi~ ormiddotothermiddotpJililicsafety tgtrg~izatioo middot

middot5) middotm1$r~pres~rttingth~t don~~ttts -W-tu g~ tp ~ SP~i~ltrpllP~$~middotmiddotor PrltgtgrammiddotmiddotqJiess th~ middotamountmiddoto(donations thatwiii aotuaityibeased for middotfuatpurpose orprogram or middotmiddota pottianisreasanab~y-in middotproportiontomiddotthe charitysmiddottntalprogram middotsemceexpenditures middot

middot6) mi~r~presenthlg tli~t domiq(ns wiflbcentncentfitpers()ns~middotor otgani~ti()~ ~nmiddottllcent (i()iiqtJsState ot localcQ~tnuri~cyQnl~s$ asregstanUill pcgtrtio~f middotonneChatizymiddotmiddot~middotprltgtgram middotseryenic~ areProvbull4cent4 jn tJ~t-stateorlq~f

COitlfuUli~tYmiddot

7) middotmisreptes~ntiDg that aresidentofamiddothousehold has previouslrmiddotmiddot donated totbeeharitmiddoto~ the amouritmiddotofanypreviousmiddotdonaix01~ and

~)middot tilis~i~premiddotsentin~that- a person hasmiddotalliea~tliadea _pleqgcent middot~cH~~ate to thcicharlty middot middot

B E~eeptmiddota$prov1dedfn p~graphC~fthls sectlonusng a lotalstateJOt

t~iional address ontetumenvelopesandothermiddotsolicitation ormiddotcol1ectiun-materials

Utilesstheraddresslg on~middotafwhich fue middotClient charity~middotctua1~Y ~~~inmiddotOng()ingmiddot

pbysic~tPte~eilccent and Qon41Jcentf$ $ufgt$tiint~~~ ~~tiyeni~icentsmiddot~~I~centdtomiddot~~~is~jjg

cent~Pept ~tCortregutiity Sttppo~shaifhave noffior~ thanmiddot90 days ftiommiddot-iite

EffectiveOaiemiddotmiddotofthis Jud~entto oontfuue touse suppUes ofWUtt~g ma~edalsJt

ha4 middotonhandonMay 12009 middotNtgtncentthel~s~ CoiDampUbUy S4ppqtt$~ampU middotc()lPIY

With th$ retj~ii~ment ~middot$0Qn ~$practicable

i CSfmay usemiddotthea44ress ofanatbnalmiddotora re~onatprocessingmiddotcenter

middotasneceSSatYiopromote costs~Ying~ whi~h mU$t middotb~ clearlymiddotmiddotand

middotcanspiCuP~sly identifie4gt~sbeingtlma1ipropessingmiddotaddresson

maflingsandple~gematerialsreceived~~r~cmiddotonsumersmiddotso-thatthemiddot

consurner~ouJfnoi misapprehendthatttie add~ampmiddot is middotth~ l~ati4yentmiddotPt

dOItations instates ormiddotlncai commlnities lnmiddotwhiehmiddotCQtmlltmify S11PfoiritJS

solicitingmiddotunlessthemiddotdlicentritcenth~llyacenttJ~~Y ]l~middotartongo~ti~~p~ySieaiptcent$~C~xand

eondlaquocts sub$tautiaJ~q~yiti~spnrel~te4 to~Q_~ai~iQgln such $taleor middot1ocar

cotiUiiregitY~ ComtnurtiiY Supi)ortmustccentas~middotmiddotthcentusemiddototattsuchmiddotpostofficemiddotboxesmiddot

orprivate maifbttxes~no middotlatetthart90daysmiddotfrom tbemiddotEfectiYemiddotDiiemiddotofthis

Judgsneni

middoto~ F~lmgt~fpfPvt~eth~foiiomngmiddotci~sdos~stNfrm FOLtowtNa

OlU)Eltafienl1~middot0penlnggreedngof1he catlan(tafter~disclosureofthe factth~

catlis beinmiddotrecordedor-middotin close llroximitrmiddot middottO middotthemiddot~(lJdng~~tiiL$ ~4

b~ginnin~tmgt~laterthailmiddotthtrTHIRJl$centJltcentnccent-idtermiddotthcentqp~ntpggrcenteJingqfUi~middot

Ptcentsen~~iotand lPAli Pt$11CCS lriot t() mereq~estfdNlQfJifianeiat support

1 ~~ 11am~9fUfein~ivi4uaJ ~l)Hci~or ~4middot ~eicentat~d unamb~~ous

idcentntifieatiortQfco(tipant-heor snewarks fer Fnrtherr Crim~unily

middot~tJpp9~7mcmiddotshaltmiddotavoidanyphrasill~peasonablylik~lymiddottPcall$e

cortfusion al~tween fuecompanyn~nn~~imdth~otdin~middot usageofth~

-middot)

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 6: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

maflingsandple~gematerialsreceived~~r~cmiddotonsumersmiddotso-thatthemiddot

consurner~ouJfnoi misapprehendthatttie add~ampmiddot is middotth~ l~ati4yentmiddotPt

dOItations instates ormiddotlncai commlnities lnmiddotwhiehmiddotCQtmlltmify S11PfoiritJS

solicitingmiddotunlessthemiddotdlicentritcenth~llyacenttJ~~Y ]l~middotartongo~ti~~p~ySieaiptcent$~C~xand

eondlaquocts sub$tautiaJ~q~yiti~spnrel~te4 to~Q_~ai~iQgln such $taleor middot1ocar

cotiUiiregitY~ ComtnurtiiY Supi)ortmustccentas~middotmiddotthcentusemiddototattsuchmiddotpostofficemiddotboxesmiddot

orprivate maifbttxes~no middotlatetthart90daysmiddotfrom tbemiddotEfectiYemiddotDiiemiddotofthis

Judgsneni

middoto~ F~lmgt~fpfPvt~eth~foiiomngmiddotci~sdos~stNfrm FOLtowtNa

OlU)Eltafienl1~middot0penlnggreedngof1he catlan(tafter~disclosureofthe factth~

catlis beinmiddotrecordedor-middotin close llroximitrmiddot middottO middotthemiddot~(lJdng~~tiiL$ ~4

b~ginnin~tmgt~laterthailmiddotthtrTHIRJl$centJltcentnccent-idtermiddotthcentqp~ntpggrcenteJingqfUi~middot

Ptcentsen~~iotand lPAli Pt$11CCS lriot t() mereq~estfdNlQfJifianeiat support

1 ~~ 11am~9fUfein~ivi4uaJ ~l)Hci~or ~4middot ~eicentat~d unamb~~ous

idcentntifieatiortQfco(tipant-heor snewarks fer Fnrtherr Crim~unily

middot~tJpp9~7mcmiddotshaltmiddotavoidanyphrasill~peasonablylik~lymiddottPcall$e

cortfusion al~tween fuecompanyn~nn~~imdth~otdin~middot usageofth~

-middot)

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 7: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

2 the paidandJoquofessionaJstatus~ftheindlVidualaml ilie companymiddot

makmgmiddotfuec~n usingthemiddottemrs ipai4 caJle~~upaidsoliCit9tl~ )~paid

middotfilrldiaiSeimiddotnoR middotlaquo middotrofessmiddot middotrri middotfundraiset middot less~s+~tei middotwe( esmiddot l middott p w ~ _ ~ middot ~~ Pr ~ y

QBFUSCATESORJgtlMINISaas nffi~INTENT OF TfiBi

DlSCLO$tffliEs~UCH AS nAs A)AllJ ClCLERrEgtEmiddot

middotCltJ~ITYSUPPOR1JMeYOU aAVErftampEg LElEL~middotmiddotOF

StwfORT tO cHOOSE FR04itOoEs~OTltOtvfPtymiddotW~rtH Tms

~RROVISlON~

middotmiddota FailingmiddotrQ clear~y aJt4=~CQutatelydisclo~e bowmiddot middotdt~ti~P~ middotwfii~~~arttiallymiddot

lie middotu~ecrby tb~middotebQ~yin ~~h soicitati0Umiddot C41l~middot

Fmiddot Failingtownspicuoustymiddotand accuratelymentify themiddotmiddotIocation ofthe

JteadqUa11laquos ofthecharityinallvroitt~ materi-al $~tto donoS

XJ Eftoil ilaJnan cbnductduriri ]bectf middot~ ofa tel 1itinetailthatfmtassmiddotes 0~ o- Y g ~amp~ ~

~trtitnidat~s~=qffrigh~centti$middotthei_ecjpip~t of~ middot~o~~citaticm middotcaU i-htrassm~ntshaU

=middotinolude=middot~ausin~=atelephonetomiddotrifi~ ~P~~ly or~eontinQopsJy with=iiitcentntto

~()y)abuse~ oi~s~Jietspnaftlte cent~lcent4truwhet

fl ~WHi~gtcent cQ~PlY wi$aii ~~atcentmiddotmiddot~g~ttitlregIaws middotand~ruiesmiddototiiheSettlinyen

middotStatesinc=iutling_wi~oUtUnUtatlltmthosereiatedto the foliowi~g

a the1dentincatkm andr~gistrationofsubccntra9t9rs middotofCQnirnJhity -SuRportmiddot

b the~middotus~middot qf~n~iiies=thatptoYidcentcent~~gmiddot$ervicp$

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 8: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

c requiredpr~andpost~oticitation disclosures

d affmniltiv~Hiiscl0sll~centmiddotmiddototth~middotchaiimblemiddotp)ltposcentsfot wnichfu~ qqn~ti9n WHl te sP~n~ middot

middote mlsrep~scentpti~gthe niitur~ qttJ~pseoft11t~ -cent~~-glcent-prp~aetivitiesvand middot

yearsmiddotun1ess middotstatelawmiddotwmddtequiteamiddotIonger periOd otthueormiddotihis Jlid~entspeoliies a

sbartermiddotpeciodbull Oommuni~-suppq~~hall makeall ~uchreQprdSavtlblbl~ upPIlJen ~y$~

notieemiddotto=anV$iertlihmiddotmiddot State~ middotmiddotwe recordsmiddottha Commllriihi su middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotrtmiddotmiddotlritkinUstke~~fmiddot include -~ g ~ bull ~ PP9- middot P

a aHrecordi~g$ofalfcallsmade by Ct)mmunity Support~middothowever middot ColllliluriitymiddotSupport middotis only-requiredmiddot tomiddotkeeptecordings for 12 months

middotb copil~rofcentaeh call script1etter_pleQgcentPpticente an~fa~I Q~~r splicenti~iion matcentrials~acmallt middotUS~trby-middotmiddotco~Qnity SPPIQ~middot middot

c reeo~fdendtYingmiddotmiddotaiimiddot~rsons solicit~dbymiddotfitgtmlrlunitymiddot SupPott-~cent1middot di~ltmiddotdonatlons 3

d middotcopiesofanmiddot complaint~~ emailsmiddot 1~tteramp andpth~rconnnun~at~pris fromd0norsqr oj1er persons $olieit~dmiddot IJYmiddot middotConiirtUllity Support Duringthcenti~lt~alycentaimiddotf(JU~wiig centxec~tionofd11s cq~~erti middot)uttglricentnr ~ycentcy ~o daysC()tomuniW S~PPQrt $tUrrorw~41trtJ1e iPp~opcia~e~~~te~g~nci~s all ~rnptaiQ~t~~ivedftommiddotresidentsof ~h~ ~Wt~~ alt)ttgwitilamiddot s~tementQfthe s~ps~ ifanl~middotmiddotGbllmumio Supgttttookto resolvethecompialrit Piovided~ middotthisobligatfunshyshalLcontfnuemiddotformiddotanmiddotadditionatyear middotup-on=arequestin-wiitingftom -~middot seitli~g s~~e to~cont4tu~ for -~othCfr_ycenttcent~ middot

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 9: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

e copies ofall Community middotSuppoWscorrespondeneemiddotwith any middoti9Vemmenia8ency inchidin~middotmiddotwlthout lim1tatiGilcopfesof~llt pomplaints~letters andmiddot emailsArom personssoHcited

g copies otaH correspondence r~rts~ andmiddotsummariesgivenmiddotto ormiddot r~eived ftomCorlununrtymiddotSupportsmiddotcentbarltiesfor whPm i(~oli~its chari~b1cent 4onatjpiJsmiddotand middot

J1 cqpi~~ omiddotta1lWjtt~ ~~prizatio~~J)rYcentTifi~(~middot~t)s ~ltgtmCo~mtmity Suppore~cbullrent~middott~~dimiddotngJ~Preseij~tion~1nmiddotthe ~itiiQ~e solic~t~~tlb~r ~a~eby centoJJlmunlty SuppQrt~

l~l ITIS FURTHER QJU)ERBD that Coln$iitYStippo~ Jnc sbiill~c~in

3P~ do~~tmiddotbe9tcent~oiicentltingformiddot~PY centMdiy ofb~fltite centntcenttiug ~~lo 1ltY ~giicenteti1enr1u

soiicit and again commencmgin June ot200~fand everymiddot6 months middotuntil Commuriitrmiddotmiddotmiddot

Suppcntstopssoficiting forthai middotchatflYmiddotthe following~

middotabull ~middotumiddot middoteka middotrmiddotmiddotsre middotmiddot tered lfmiddot1tJ ~remiddot middotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middot middotd ~~middotbmiddot st~r d and that~ -4e n Yl gts sq~ middot~ cent ~ ~ ~

it9Pcenttate$middot ~~middot~i~centntlyli~l(it$ ~~t~dJ)QJPQs~ middot

middotb m~talim1tial ~bPttalcmiddotmiddotand otherscript$~btochures~and othermiddot Soticitationniatedalsuseltfhybemmurii~ Supportfor the middotcharity~ iw notmiddotmisveptcentsenfmiddot

1 th~ldentjzy ofilicent~s91i~k)f ~~ li~middotpr9~m~pimiddotmiddotSYi~s wndMPtiliemiddot$oJitit~d

~piltfib~~ioti~ middot 3 middotmiddotitiegCOgtaphi(~e~lt)tfUeasmiddot~tlifu WJJiqhmiddotth~~eprggr~s or

setvices~~te]gtrevldeaand middot middot 4~ iheJ)ortlmr ofctonatibnsmiddotormiddotcontiibutionsthatwtlibcentor has

previously middotbeen1 appiiedmiddot io themiddotcharihibb~Purpose middotc

c lbattb~cbarteyh~middotptqyiqe4middotmiddottb~j~togi1unsotselVjte~ desltrib~middotin tbemiddotmiddotsqlid~~tjoit scriptS and-in tithermiddotiol1centltatibn mt=Jteai~lised bYmiddot Csgtmttitmlty middotSmiddot4pport ~g themQstrecentfiscaVormiddotmiddotmiddotcalendat-yeat

bull 8 shy

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 10: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

providedthat)1fmiddotsuch Progtamsmiddotmiddotmiddototmiddots~rvicesmiddotwiUibe-ormiddotmiddothavemiddotbeen _ proyenidedtor fuefllSttimemiddotdudngthe currentmiddotciden~ orfiscalyear~ middotiheisubstaritiation shaltbe sufficient1f1tmiddotid~tifiesor describesthe middot program~smiddotmiddotmtencleCI ben~ficiadesmiddot-andintd~d1oo~l- ~mmllliti~s

d bull l d tlf eli bull I bull middot middottmiddot dl i- d 1- d t1 reg middot me u ~s cent_ middot J~r-~o s ~~~p aiY~ _-t ~~ ze~u middotget middotof 4centliy~~g th~e betu~middotfits-Ctcentng_~ iltiiliicentiJtcental~il~middotQr fi~~ly~~i

For purposes oftiiisprovision ibullsubstantiationbullmean-s copies -or ampank you letters-dbnationreceipts_middotcantelbdmiddotbullcbeCksormiddotOtber

~- evidence- show-ing th~tftbemiddot charity tmdeitakesorwill ~ndcentrtake ~th~ middotptogr~dcentserllcentd hithemiddot$QliPit~ti6rf_il)~tetiftJsuscentdbymiddotmiddotCQiriiritlill~middotS4ppPtt ~P-9 middot

amp middottlu1t-middot rnoremiddotJflan--_ middotfucid~ntatmiddotft$9-~Pmiddottitthe O(tltri~uonsteceiv~d ~yshytQ~-9naiiity~espentonmiddotthe progJ~mfot $~rviemiddot~sdeScentn~d mmiddotmiddotrhcent s_o1icitatiott seriJ)tS andin tJtner--soH6itatihrt materials middotused hy

CommunitSlIPPort durihgjheJiostrecent~s~ or ealendatyeru inoluding ~yreviewingmiddota financial statement ofmiddotthecentbaritymiddotformiddotea~h-shymiddotyeafan~facoountmg(pcentrlod ditingmiddotth~P~~tw9 (aJlt~Qdarmiddotormiddotti~Qar middotyearsor f9rmiddottbe Pcent~lott(of1he-centbait$opetatiolb iflCSs middottllan~~-shyYeat$J qr ifthe ()~ganiz~laquoonti~s filettatFotm~9tVQf ~th~t ta~-r~utn V4Utthemiddotihte~tRevenue$entice~t all)rnme~-durirtgthemiddotpastftrree cai~ndarOr~fiscatyears~-by-review$g-oop1esltofeacfimiddotForrt199o_or-shyothertaxtetorn filedlgtY middotor on- behalfo(middotthemiddotcllaritymiddotdlning_middotthattim~ provided middottha4 if such pr~gramsmiddototservicesmiddotwittbeor havebeen provrdedmiddotfor middotthemiddotfirst-time---during the ~ntmiddotcal~ndar or]iltscatye~~-shyihesubsUtntiantm $hairmiddotbemiddot-$ufficientmiddotifif i4centtItines-ot deSetireg$middot iltcent middot middot tno~~sint~np~lti ben~acentfarie~an4 mte~4edJ6cal-90qifuWJ(tiesmiddot 1A~ JdcentlJ)tl~iHle-charicy$ Wtittettila~(~dttem1~centd blidgcenttmiddotf0r d~i~tigmiddotih~~--middot6-~nefi~~lng the cuttentcalendtfi or-middotfiscalyear~shy

e middotthatfuemiddotcharityhasmiddotprovlded -wrlttcentnconftnnatio~middotJtiutnss~f~p~~shyrebudaLs~clP~-~ lha~youle~lcentis~-~nypiq-e~middothr9~h~icents an~otbcentimiddot ampoJjcit~tiQti imlt~~ials1atetru~)l~d-tj()t4centcenteptile IlltgtWevcentt~ tPis requitedQonAtmati~rti$ ppt ~Y 1ts~lf$tiffici~no oomJiiy---~i~ttbemiddot teRtifemen~~fth1s secltgtmiddot ~fCocentmuwwmiddotS1Jppot1middot-hasmiddotr~$0nable grounds ~o-~-~ubU4~ ver~city 9f-~ucenth~co1l~rmatton itmusttake rcent~_opabtemiddot $ttm$ to ascertain-tliemiddottruth othfrrepresentaiionsshy

9shy

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 11: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

lL ~CommunitmiddotmiddotJ~hlPPorl sha1LmeetmiddotmiddotWithmiddoteachmiddotcHentmiddotcharity everysbnnon~sto

verifymiddotaltiinfunnationRuses hr1ts middotsolicitations is accurate and- Communizy Supp~Jncmiddot

shall-docUinent such middotvetifications ana meetift middot middotinwdtiti middotand sntm mairttaiiisuch ~ _g

ll~ No Iaft-than)ulfl 200middot9~ Q(gtnmttilitYmiddot$u~~-o~ -sball ob~iti ff9m-middot centach

middotch~tYlormiddotWifichltiSmiddot~ently middotsoli~itbtg) orwlth whicil ithasi~co~ttact middotWrittep

confumationmiddotlhat themiddotspeciiic script therebuttal scrlptandQampAsmiddot~~ all

middotcom~ttion Eff4JrtS

13 rr rsmiddotlURTHER ORDBREUthatCottitnunicy $~pPOrl Jilt~ wiflmiddotnQ~ m~e

~Y a~~itionar ~centlePh~)l~C~lsJo centIfcentct coUectioxi thirfY d~Y$ ttter -~-~ middot~~tirij~at~gtr ot~1tY

~greement With any cliept lrta~dition in any ~greenle~tsigneq-~tter~y- f$~ middot2()99~

CommuniiySupport~fnc- shail not include any ternrthabilluwsittocontinue--torecehfeshy

middotana is$qemiddotmiddotthe_prQc~eds ~oll~cted in ac~orqan9e)vith the tetm~Qf~y ~icent~~m~Pt-Wilbmiddotmiddotatl)

die~trilor~th~ 96d~ytL~er tenriitla~i6n ofthamp-ra~~merit-

middot lO

l I

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 12: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

Iit ENF6RQENrm~T

14 Every ~~ttlinsmiddot stat~ shall bavelb~middotai]hqricy to middotehfot~e bfscentek~~CtiQnSmiddotf6t middot

violationsofthen~ii~frns omiddotmiddotr+w~ Jud bull middotnmiddottmiddot t~middot Qmiddot rt y~v~ ~ yen uJs gme lnJtlS- QU

-)5 EacluftheSettlihgS~tesmiddotshall be abre-iO enforcemiddot the tertnH~fffiis ronsent

p~tti~iJlHlihg middot-~~tcent5~

l6 middotmiddotCommpni~ S~ppott tnc shctlLmiddotpaymiddot$5~etnfto middot$19~000 t~~ach i~4ivimiddotdu~

Vtdl~ti(lrt of thisJ~gmentto the stateJnwhichthemiddot vi~lationtookplaceor wherefue

reetptentofthesolicitationmiddotislocated BufCommunitymiddotmiddotsupJ)ltnt1Inc sh~UnQtlgt~ lil1iblemiddotw

thatsettljt)g $tate r~middotthaf~t)dfit

middota ~upplf~recotdi~gs_middotdocutrients~ 8tf4ptfi~evidenee~andmiddot makesmiddotmiddot

-employeesmiddot availableJorcinterviews~orltlfher middotstatements attheireqpeatmiddot of

ameurolmiddottomiddotthesatisfaetio~middot Of$uchsettling middotampta~)middot ibullcludin~ but notJjmitcentdt(l

tcentcpr(Urigs oftltcent -~RHs ~p_qliestlot1~4Qthpoundt$~~fqcentlln~tcentmiddotbY emiddot bullmiddot

settfu1 state and g middotmiddotmiddot

b Cteatly andconvinCin~Iy middotd~qnstratesmiddotther~bY thatimiddotasP~of

CQmro~it)t $uppq~~Jnc~~$ t()q~~rbll$~n~~spta~c~=middot

i~ ~-~$~$falgtHshetlmiddotmiddot~cl plem~nt-cent~-~i~enJrooedures~fomiddotcomplY

bullmiddot th thbull amiddot d middot bull ~~ twtth etelll1sof middot lSJUqgmentan ~PmmunrcatJiUIlJeln

- llmiddot

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 13: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

c middot u middot tb middot--~~ 1iJ middotmiddotb1 bull middotmiddot middot middot middotjl middot omp ance ln middotmiddotjtprowuures e~tav lS ~Pur~mtllttomiddotmiddots

-fit Commun1ty Support~)nchas maintaineclrliorau~ tecorets ot sucbpQfci~sjh~iJ i~plemeritatimiddoto~an(Lth~progritm ofttaiwqg

middot~plpye~ltmmiddottho$tPoliciestmiddot

iv Cort)m~tymiddot $~ppert1 lrtc+ middot~oriitofsand QtioreesmiddotcompHance Witih

~e~~middotproeedilresmiddotestabHshedpursuanftio ilitsmiddotsection and keepsand

middotmallaquosavailahlemiddottomiddot~ySettlingS~teJ~pQn~NqlJ~t~omp~centtcentmiddotmiddot bull

l~ecoidBmiddotmiddotofallsuQh middotmonit0~middoti1tiand enfOr~$etiGmiddot t$d

v ampylt~pndllcentt-middotviampatingbullthis oonsciitjudgmentlsmiddot aumqueiand

isdlatedaberrationmiddotfrom llie normbull

17 Theabttve Paragr~phmiddot 16 andmiddot itsmiddot=subjgtd ~Plr Qrily ~llie eve~t ~h~ settlmg

middot~)tate invbkcentsJgtaragrPb uiii PliY~~fitProvi~imiddototj~ middotTncent fptcentgl)jng p~ytnenrmiddotfqtvfq~jti_ogof

Jb~~ JUdg~~rtt ts middotint~ndetftigtmiddotSuPPlem~nr~ivti-J)~nahiesmiddotan-tiLoiliertemed1es a1ready

availabieto-fhe middotstatemiddotundet-itsmiddottOOnsumerprotectionlawsand charftablesolicitatiorilaws~

lnmiddotthemiddot~v-eutColilin_utiitrSupp9rl~Jl)cmiddotC9AUn~ts~ViQ~19fVdfthi$-JU4grnenl ~4Jt~ymiddot

middotmiddotaml~ble amp~ttte awsmiddotthe ~ettji~trstat~Jltltsmiddot opti~q-~y invokef11emiddotp~yment-middotpr-ovisi)no-f

tbis Judg~ent ormaymiddotpursuemiddotany othertemedies -avatlablcentby laW Pr both

imiddotS Commuriity Slpporl~ lncShall pay middotallcOstsmiddot~$QRiatreg witlii y (9~P~

-nec~saryto middotenfur~thcent middotterinSmiddotmiddot9fthi$Jld~~tit ifit ismiddot foundJo~vcentmiddotYi9i~reci~th1s

Judmiddot middotmiddotmatampWl

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 14: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

e

l9 Th~middotS~ttling Stat~sshallrecov~r anampCommqnity middotsupport Inc shillpaymiddot

middotS200~oomiddoto 3ccnrdih~ tQmiddot th~ fulloWing_~middotaymen~ ~cb~tm~~=

a middot$5Vi9ooOO onJvky 5 ~oo~i

cmiddot middot$smiddoto~pomiddotctQOreg Janu~ 15 2~JlOand

middot $25middot~oopoQ=oP ~Y 1sgt ztnomiddot middote~ middot$smiddotoooo~ooonNovertio~rt-s~ zo fo

G~~~t ofmiddotfheStatemiddotqf=Mis$0url middotOn hebalfof the SettlitlsmiddotStatcent$~ Th~=$2()()OQO bull OOmiddot~hair r

hcent~di$td(iU~cent~imiddotto themiddotmiddotSettlingmiddot~Wcentsw-pcentif~middotligreement~~eny~n th~ro towhiob

CommunitymiddotSupparttlnc~isnotaparty

21 In iheevent such fUndsare not=paid bytb~rspeciuea 4ates~middotmiddot middotinterest=Onanf 1 I un~dbal-~ShaJlaccm~middotattnetatc=ofnme petcentWlt 9orrlfmiddotrmiddot~regi tifqm~emiddot(~t~dYc I

liJitU p~id ipfuil I a44lqn w$~$w~centr~stCo~ity$Jpport$h~pay~eS~ttling

middotStates an additionaL$300~0QOtflt failsto paymiddotany ofthefourmiddotpaymentsmiddotmiddot~pecifiedabov~

withinmiddotthirty (30) middotdaysofJh~due ~ate bull

2-z ~()mmq~itymiddot~iippottI~pmiddot~hilti-middotimrncent4i~~centiyp~ytheseilngmiddotState$

$500~0oo S~ouidanYofthef]naqciaimiddotinformationitpro~ided to the SdtlingStatesmiddotinr

negotfatingthismiddot Judgmentprovemiddotto beinaccurate 1n anymat~riatrespe9t

~23 Asmiddotmiddotsoon as~~racticablemiddotfollowingtcentccentiptofthe middotaj()V~ ft414~ iJi( Attqmeymiddot

Gencent11ilo(tbcentState ofMi~sQlfsh~tl middotPtUSe~uch ftin~middotmiddottpmiddot~middot~distrlbutemiddotcLamon~ the

13 middot

--lt1 i

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 15: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

s-ettHh~lStatesmiddot~pursuaritbtanagreernentbetween andmiddotamongthemiddotSettllngmiddotmiddotmiddotStates-to=which

communit)rSupporl Incis nota-party Thefunds may he=used attile -discretion of~

i~ccentWlilgmiddot~~centilcY itteacltsttite centPnsi~nt with StateI~w fofpuijgtQscent~middothf~iilibut$etncentnt middot

ofthe stat~s=costsmiddot an4 f~es ass9(iat~~middotwith the i~y~tigation ~middotdHtfg~ti(n oftili~~t

consurner protection law enrorc(Mentmiddoteducation~ litigation fimamp~lOcat eltJnsumer aid

24 eteservationAgtftawliiiforoementActionNot~g middot~eiprepllid~smiddotthe

Suites fromAmfordngmiddotthe~provisions middototmiddotfuismiddot ConsentJu4mnent orJrom middotpursuinamp=~)-law

~nforeement actionwith respecititomiddot ~e acts ormiddot practicesofCom~unio-middot s~pPort~ memiddot uot

oov~tcentdl1y tliis Qt)n$~ntJUqgnlent middototmiddot~Py middot~centfS otmiddotp~te~$ cotiducentteda~t tile Eff~ite

2S Co~pliancewithmiddotandApplicationmiddot(fStatemiddotand Fmiddoted~rarLaw Ndtbiiljgdh pd$ I

1udgrnentmiddotwiitlbe consimedtQlfrriitth~middot~utho-dtY qfanycpiriticipati~g=~$ePcentY toprptecent~

middot t)eji)l~test$ -ofthCiif cop$~t~cent11~- APCQtdlngfy~ n9thing hcentreinmiddotrel~evcent~ -CotPmliiiifr

S~pp~~middotmiddotlrtc middotmiddoteftheir-middot~~utpgduo to ootnplymiddotwitirappHcablelawsmiddotefmiddotalliStatesnor

oonstiiutes authorl~at1on by th~ St~te Jor-CltnnmJInitymiddotltsupport Inc toengag~ih)~ct$-~Ut~f

ptiicentii~$JgtrobiQitedb~ st~cent1) ~W$~

middotmiddot 2~ ltGommuriity S~ppott=titc ~haii-complywiila11 statemiddotand federaiUaw~ as

fll~Y cutrentlycentxist middotorf m~ybeimnendedjrrmiddotthemiddot future~ pertaini~g_to unfampr anddec~ptivemiddot

middottradepracticemiddot~imiddot telernBrketin~ or MY form of-charitablemiddot$qlieitat~OPmiddot FwfucentiJipth)ngib

thisJ~~ettt$h~lUn-aDy way tcentamp~~-tmiddotarty~tatemiddotftQtiienforcentmg its DoNovC~ll iaws)

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 16: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

bull federal t~lemarketing sales rules~reaiStratiOn laws orconsumerp~tection laws against

middotCommuriitr Suppof4lilc Pr ~Yofiismiddotcli~n~~ ~ffiiiates Ptsubregnhaetors themiddotpenalties

~4iPJ~~tiQn$ regr~l~ are intenlticentdto ~uppietnetil $laquoltr~rAAd f~regralJ~wsmiddottmdJ~~tng

Notiifug1nthis lUdgJnentsiuilt b(fdeerned-tomiddotprecludeanYidonor middotormiddot ltnaritrmiddotfiiom bdg

My~tjbrii~tna)f n~Yd~~Jtst-Coirititmily SPPpcgtt(~~a(at~Ses QUtofC9minregitY

SOppprtmiddot$soHei~tiQJimiddoteffO$

27- NGn-ACJtnissmiddotion_ This= Jhdgment shaJLnotbe~~~tmed a~ot dee~middotto bemiddot middot

evidenreof_anmiddotadmissiltntorconeession on the parlufCommunity S~JgtPO~lnc ofany

U~bili~middotmiddotormiddotwron~iloin~--w~tsoevmiddoter_ whiChis middothereby e~iiesly d~ti~e~-ddi~centliiiiledmiddotby

eoliui1umcymiddot-s~PPort~~cent This Judgmemiddotntis)imiddotcopiproti)~$-scenttttem~titwiti)middottto fiud~ng9f

anywrongttpingwhatsocwer~middotincludingbutnot limitedmiddottoanymiddotvfdlatiOn offederal orState

-28 Pa8tannFutlml _Practiees~middotmiddotwpmj~gJ)~~etn~ri41~4$appttivaiJ~YmiddotmiddotanYampt~~e

Commun1 S omiddotmiddot middot middot c~middot~iL- a tmiddot middot~middotmiddott f middotltmiddotcmiddot middotmiddot middot Oomntunrmiddotmiddot Siimiddot middotort lhc~ shall9f 1 11J~ ttll1 middot p s~t~-~ttP ~reg~middotmiddotmiddot tYPP ~ middot

(iot ~tUWmiddotmiddotr~pre$entationcorttraeymiddot-to thismiddotmiddotparagmph

-2~t middotNo ChmlgeitoSubstaritiveRights NPtJiingJ~centteiri$halfhcent centPn$~to

lMiiYcent~ m()diffmiddot~fcenth~gcentahy~$UbSWtfjmiddotV~tt$(f~th~tpe~~m$ or~~~~ijcent~ ~gahis~

CofuinlJnity S1Jp]gto1~Inc middotor -~gafn~oth~ middotpersons orentiiies_ whh respecfto -the acts and

practiltesClt)veredbymiddotthisConsenfJudgment

~ I

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 17: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

10~~ Revi~w Connnunity Stppor(has readmiddot and understandSihis-ludgmerit-and

~nters into ityolmitatilymiddothaVingbeen advis~dmiddotby Jtsmiddotundersiampn~ coUJ1~cl ofth~ mcentanin~

$~ ~ffcentqt CJf~cPpr(Yi$~on ~ftlit$ ~udgJ1lent

1-31 ApprovaL middotCon)nl~ltymiddotSupport1 inc~ andmiddotaU $~tHnltS~~~~haif

recon1mend thaLthislodgrnenfbe approved by a coutt witlvapproprlateju~dicfion middotin all Scenttt~iQgJ~tate~ In a4diU9n CotiUliunity Suppbrt Inc~ con~ilttHtdh~~ J~dgri)cent~t b~in~

pr~s~nted~middot submitte(l and filed ex Partcent ~d centntere4 1n-ait ScentttlingStat~smiddot-whhout=then~

middotfor an eritiYmiddotmiddotofappe~nceCommunity S(lppo~t~iilc oranyoiheirsotrofoansentbEfyond

CommunifYSupport~sltsjgnature onthis Jud~ment Furih-er~middotmiddotCommunl~ Support me

oonsentsJoadditionatstates notli$tcentdh~re fili~$lhis cent9ri~~ljud~ricentnt Thjs~orisent

)u4ginejtt i$ valid asJ~etWcentcentn CommunitYmiddots-uppqttlfi(amtany$tatethatcentx~rege$ and

enters 1t withouhegard towhetherany middotother statesalso exemiddotcutemiddotandlor entedt

middota2 Contiiutin~JmdsdictioncommuniomiddotiSupporland fhe middotSettIi~middot StateSshy

acknowle4g~middotthatthcs(ate coutt Mtftpraquotov~s tliimiddotsJuqgitient~11J~y~middot~Pntiti4m$shy

J~rl$tJl~ppfiov~rmiddot~UmattcenttsCoiicentecentingtjji$ J4t(gmcentntJ4middotmiddottfi~t~~te

$3 C~~ity $upport~Ii1CShalfsignand agtteetomiddot~anymiddot documentnecessary

toeffictuat~ihis iudgmeDt

34~ Fot PPn~os~9tthts dqcent~ent a s~gn~~~p~g~ sent vmiddot~middotf~or eiecttonlci

maii sh~il be=~eated~eS~eAA an prigimitsignatm~ andsigmtures mayaffJXed

middottJntoughco1lntetpartS

35 Communi~y Supportmiddotw~ivtS scentrviQemiddot~fptoce$~ ~dbcentregty a4$QJiZcent$ Jt$ middot

middotmiddottsshy

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 18: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

SignaUtesand Accept3n~byll~POnde~trmiddot~~

fhe UndersjgQ-~4 ~haL~ acentli~ty middot~ ctgt~ertt ~ middot~itcent on Penaff qfmiddotC~ininllllity

su~~cA~thiSmatt~tmiddot~d(locentSmiddotcent9Dyen~Mp f~nnandmiddot co~tentdflliis JU4pentmiddotand to

1tsmiddoten1t)rbullmiddot

rI

A~provmiddotetfasto fonm

middotmiddotei~middot--middotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~middot

Sbullmiddotpmiddotport Incmiddot

Date~middot ~~7 ifiSamp ~ttqrp~yen~f tol P~fE~~tiant ConUI1UniPtmiddot sUFPort tna

middot17-shy

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 19: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

~lte~pectfull)lmiddotsubmitt~

middotmiddotEDMmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotUNDmiddotmiddotG middotatittfmiddotihrm bull ~~Jyrl~middot~middotimiddot

Attomcenty()centfie~8tltgtfcaljfotmaBELNbAJ triHNsbull middotS~wmiddot~~s~~t Attotneymiddot(aen~~ middot-u~tmiddotr1middot ~rAilttH middot middot middotmiddotromiddot middot1middot i~ ~11tWmiddot

middotsq~i~~llmiddot~P11Y~At1ofu~f~ra~~

U$F~QreglNG 1C()N$~TmiddotJlUJ)GMiENTPERTAINWGmiddotTQVEFENDANT middot OO~IT1tstliP0RT~ m~middotlstliEREBVltNTEREtl~DSOdRDEltEDmiddot

middot18shy

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw

Page 20: State of California vs. Association for Firefighters and ... · .., 1 = .... o:c 2: w c 0 (.) ~-(.) (!) 0 g 0 4· i c 5 6 t3 w u.. 7' 8 '9, 'tO: '.11 :1'2· l3 t4 15 ·-~~-J7 .l-8.:

Case Nam~ PeQPyenbull v AssociaOn -for FirefighJ~rsan4 Pumediej~ Inc~ etcmiddotltmiddot ~ial~ ocsecueNcr 3n-2bM 0027zjQ6middot

ldedate

Jmiddotarp~PtbYedmiddotinmiddotcentcentOfficentcent-o~~middote~~om~ymiddotGeiu~r~~~~amp ttnhemiddotQflicent pfw$licentrof~~ CaliforniaState BarmiddotmiddotatmiddotwhichJletnbcnJsmiddotmiddotdjrectionfuis$ervl9-Cismade iam t~smiddotmiddotyearsof~middotge9l dl4centtbullaP4notapaifY tQ tliismiddotjxui~laquo)riy ~business addi~smiddotls 3QQ$ ~pprig SQcentet ljo~middot~ng~T~s CA 90013middot I am-fanrlllarmiddotWfth~thebusihessptacticemiddotafthe OfficemiddotottheAttomeyflenetaJtor COncentcf~9iimiddotandmiddotproc~$higmiddotPfmiddot~n~~P4l4centnce Inmiddot middota~ampl1~PW~~~~lp$ipra~cet middotcentqit~~~q~ placetlinmiddottheintem81 manmiddoto0Uectibnsystem atthe()fficeoftheAttomeyOenetalis depesited th~t$~~middot~~r in th~middot~rdinacy oourseofbusiness

on8entemher29bull 1~iserved fuestrtPtiLAitltncoNSENTmiddotJti1gtGMJttrfANU [PROfoSED DIIDEll ~bullllEFEDAT middotCOMMlJNmmiddotSUPPOJlT-lNCbull middotbrpkiClngmiddotatltl~middot~Stnete~pound~~lo~eainmiddotmiddot~~~ed enveireg~~~hiifu~irii~t n1aig~middototfufQffi~~ripoundt1l~ middotmiddot shyAttomeymiddot~efa1~ ihrgtdielllv~as follows middot

~pJI~yt~middot~Canter LLC ~-rOtCQPilWU Attorneys atLaw 3ttnv~ middotmiddoto~ $t~ecentpound swt~middot3oo

middot middot imiddot middot Mmiddot middot middotomiddotmiddotKansas middotOttY~ 0641 smiddot

ft~XHmiddotmiddot Sll)tnefiEscJbullmiddot Mtup~yRosenmiddotampmiddotMeylanLCP lOOWiishire middotBlvd middotSuite f300

SantaMoni~~middotCA 9040li-ll42

lmiddotdmiddoteelareunderpenaltymiddotofperjtllY underihe lawsmiddotoffuestatemiddot otdatifom11tdleJoreso1n~middotJs ifU~ ana~wmebmd UlaHh~s d~l-ar~tiQt~ WAAmiddot~xecUtyenon Sep~~~ 2~20Q9~fl9$middot~ge[~s Cali~foihia

iUaer ~Iigt middot Dbc~mcn(ib frolaw