staking claim to community data for resident-led community change - 2013 cic summit
TRANSCRIPT
“It’s Ours to Begin With:”Staking Claim to Community Data for Resident-Led Community Change
Allison Pinto, Ph.D. and Tim Dutton, M.S.Sarasota Community Studio
2013 CIC SummitOctober 17, 2013
Today’s Presentation
Introduction(s)The Challenges:
Cultivating Ownership Acquiring Data Generating Data Sharing Data Developing Ongoing Reflective Process
Implications
A “Next-Generation” Place Based Effort
Current Era Initiatives
Common features: Place-based Priority on Community-Building Adopt a Comprehensive Lens
Differ in terms of: Primary Sponsor Primary Focus
Human Development / Social Services Physical Revitalization / Economic Development
Centrality of Community-Building to the Effort
Kubisch, Auspos, Brown & Dewar, 2010.Voices from the Field III: Lessons and Challenges from
Two Decades of Community Change Efforts
Next-Generation Place-Based Efforts
• Redefining Place• Demonstrating Value of Community-
Building• Defining Sustainability and How to
Achieve It• Promoting Mixed Income Communities
and Avoiding Displacement• Working Effectively in Weak Markets and
Communities with Weak Civic Infrastructure
• Uniting System Reform with Place-Based Change
• Addressing Power Imbalances-Voices from the Field III
As 2Chainz says…
We’re DIFFERENT:
Neighbor-initiated & led
Following the lead of NeighborKIDS
Aspects of a Community Change Initiative
community-building
programming / services
resident leadership
neighborhood self-organizing capacity
trusting relationships /social capital / sense of community
civic engagement
social educational
physical environment - built (e.g. housing) - natural (e.g. parks)
economic
mapping the “policy landscape”
community-institutional partnerships
community well-being
intentional change efforts(& also
unintentional) overall community change effort
policy (laws & rules) & systems
assigning resources
data (information) / evaluation
Ad
apte
d f
rom
Com
mu
nit
y C
han
ge I
nit
iati
ves f
rom
19
90
-20
10
:
Accom
pli
sh
men
ts a
nd
Im
plicati
on
s f
or
Fu
ture
Work
(2
01
0)
by
Kubis
ch, A
usp
os,
Bro
wn a
nd D
ew
ar.
Following the Lead of Kids Kids are naturally inclined to be:
Curious Playful Joyful Social Storytellers Boundary Crossers
…these are the qualities of leaders & social innovators!
Kids & Well-BeingThe evolution of child-oriented community indicators efforts
From a focus on… To a focus on…
A child’s mere survival
A child’s well-being
Negative aspects in children’s lives
Positive aspects in children’s lives
Well-becoming Well-being
Traditional domains of well-being
New domains of well-being
Ben-Arieh, 2006Measuring and monitoring the well-being of young children
around the world
Kids & Well-Being
“…the continuation of the trends described here will eventually lead to the creation of a ‘new’ role for children in measuring and monitoring their own well-being—as an active participant rather than subjects of research…children becoming active actors in the effort to measure and monitor their well-being rather than objects of study.”
-- Ben-Arieh, 2006
CENTRAL-COCOANUT NEIGHBORHOOD
North: Dr. MLK WaySouth: 10th StreetWest: Tamiami TrailEast: RR Tracks east of Central Ave.
16 streets long (1 mile)3 streets wide (.4 miles)
47 blocks
2100 people h 500 kids up to age 18 h 300 kids up to age 10 h 175 kids up to age 5
750 households
CENTRAL-COCOANUT NEIGHBORHOOD
Part of the greater Newtown community of Sarasota
CENTRAL-COCOANUT NEIGHBORHOOD
Location within the City of Sarasota
# Kids up to age 5
# Kids ages 5 - 17
# Adults ages 65+
Who are the people of our neighborhood?
Who are we?
Where do we live?
Single Family HomesPublic Housing Apartments
Condo TowersApartments
Assisted Living# renter occupied homes
Where do we live?
What special places are in our neighborhood?
Whitaker Bayou, 19th St Field, Ponytail Palm, Mary Dean Park, Whitaker Gateway Park,
Banyan Tree, Bayou Bridge, RR Tracks, Pioneer Park, Mary Dean Park, Whitaker Cemetery, Historical Society, Orange Trees, MLK Park, Pioneer Park
What special places are in our neighborhood?
What businesses and organizations are in our neighborhood?
Publix, Used Stuff, Central Pups, SCOPE, Ringling CollegeNick’s Snappy, Sarasota Architectural Salvage, Boat Yard, Living Hope
ChurchReef Ball Central, Race Car Restoration, ABC7, Payne Chapel, SHARE
What businesses & organizations are in our neighborhood?
Our Umpteenth Rodeo
Tim’s path:• Hospital Administration
• Ohio• Haiti
• WK Kellogg Leadership Fellowship
• Human Services Planning Association
• County-Scale Community Engagement Non-Profit
• Community Indicators• Community Study Groups• Asset-Based Community
Dev• Conversations That Matter
• Communiplexity• National Think Tank on Aging
• 2-County Non-Profit focused on Economic Well-Being of Families with Low Income
Allison’s path:• Children’s Mental Healthcare
• Clinical Psychology – Direct Service
• Training/Supervision• Administration
• Infant Mental Health• Systems of Care Consultation• Communiplexity• County-Scale Children’s Services
Council• Early Childhood Systems of
Care• State of the Child –
Communiplexified• 3-Neighborhood PBI• Public Housing Community
Organizing• County-Scale Community
Engagement Non-Profit• Community Data Initiative• Resident Community
Changemakers• Private Practice of Child/Community
WB
The Studio
Central-Cocoanut Signs of ThrivingRegarding NEIGHBORKIDS: We will find ways to notice signs that kids are: Happy and Emotionally Grounded Learning In Loving Relationships Contributing
Regarding THE NEIGHBORHOOD: We will find ways to notice signs of our neighborhood’s well-being in terms of: Housing Economics Social Justice The Vibe
Central-Cocoanut Signs of Thriving
Central-Cocoanut Signs of Thriving
Regarding THE NEIGHBORHOOD: We will find ways to notice signs of our neighborhood’s well-being in terms of:
Housing Homes that are in good shape and affordable so neighbors do not need to move so often Few vacant homes Renters rights respected and upheld
Economics High employment rate Enough family income
Social Justice Strong sense of fairness and justice Low crime and arrest rates
The Vibe Welcoming, kid-friendly atmosphere sensed by all neighborkids and fellow neighbors Deep recognition of the rich cultural history of our neighborhood and our Newtown
community Diversity of social opportunities open to all neighbors Enhanced beauty of the neighborhood
The Challenges
• Cultivating Ownership• Acquiring Data• Generating Data• Sharing Data• Developing Ongoing Reflective
Process
Cultivating Ownership
Whose tracks are these?
Cultivating Ownership
Regardless of who measures them, everybody seems to realize
They belong to the turtles!
[Community Data Efforts]when “implemented well and practiced intentionally can be the most critical ingredient of transformative community change.”
Tom Kelly, 2010Five Simple Rules for Evaluating Complex Community
Initiatives
Cultivating Ownership
So how to cultivate the perspective that together as neighbors:• We need the data!• We want the data!• (and when necessary,) We demand
the data!
Cultivating Ownership
Cultivating Ownership
Neighborhood Scavenger Hunting &
Neighborkid Dinners
Cultivating Ownership
Neighborhood Housing Efforts
Cultivating Ownership
Neighborhood Reading Efforts
NEIGHBORHOOD READING MEETING
Saturday, February 232:00 p.m. at the Studio
CHILD CARE & SNACKS PROVIDED
Hello!It is obvious that neighborkids are BIG-TIME readers here in Central-Cocoanut.
• What do KIDS here say about reading in our neighborhood?
• What do neighborhood MAPS show about neighborkids reading in school?
• What can we DO together as neighbors so that the kids of Central-Cocoanut are the BEST AT READING in all of Sarasota County?
1216 Central Avenue, Studio 101Sarasota, Florida 34236
941. 952.3197www.sarasotacommunitystudio.org
WELCOME!AGENDA: Introductions What do we notice? What maps show? What do kids & adults say? How does it make sense? What do ALL neighbors say? What can we DO together? How will we know? What NEXT?
INTRODUCTIONS What is your name? What street do you live on? What is the first thing you remember reading?
WHAT DO WE NOTICE IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD?
WHAT DO MAPS & DATA SHOW?
What percentage of 3rd graders in our neighborhood do you think are reading on grade level?
WHAT DO MAPS & DATA SHOW?
WHAT DO MAPS & DATA SHOW?
WHAT DO KIDS & ADULTS HERE SAY?
What do you think is the best age to be able to read by?
WHAT DO KIDS HERE SAY?Alicia 7Amorie 5Cameron 5Craig 3Cynthia 8Dalisha oldDareeona 40Dasani 8Deont'e 6Dillion 5Elan 7Fabrian 13India 10Jacorey 7Jadarius 11Jakaree 20James 9Juwella 4
Kahlil 11Katelynn 5Keon 5Keondre 8Kiamani 6.5Maria 15Missy 20Nihvea 2Niyah 4Quayvion 1Quinlan 5Ra'Quan 4Samir 1Tatiana 5Toby 5Tyasia 7Ty'tianna 5
Virginia 19Zamarion 10Zamora 4Ziyon 6Zytrellia 4There is wisdom in every answer!
Most Frequent Answer: Age 5
Over HALF of the neighborkids said younger than age 8
HOW DOES IT ALL MAKE SENSE?
Pictures & Stories School Maps & Data Views & Opinions
WHAT CAN WE DO TOGETHER AS NEIGHBORS?
…so that neighborkids of Central-Cocoanut are BEST AT
READING in ALL of Sarasota County?
HOW WILL WE KNOW WHEN CHANGES ARE HAPPENING?What will we
notice?What do we need to pay attention to?
WHAT DO ALL OUR NEIGHBORS THINK?
Central-Cocoanut Neighborhood
North: Dr. MLK WaySouth: 10th StreetWest: Tamiami TrailEast: RR Tracks east of Central Ave.
16 streets long (1 mile)3 streets wide (.4 miles)
47 blocks
2100 people h 500 kids up to age 18 h 300 kids up to age 10 h 175 kids up to age 5
750 households
READING MEETING #2
Saturday, May 42:00 p.m. at the Studio
CHILD CARE & SNACKS PROVIDED
Hello Central-Cocoanut Neighbors!
1216 Central Avenue, Studio 101Sarasota, Florida 34236
941. 952.3197www.sarasotacommunitystudio.org
NEIGHBORHOOD
INTRODUCTIONS What is your name? What street do you live on? What do you notice lately about reading in our
neighborhood?
NEIGHBORKIDS WHO CONTRIBUTED:
AliciaCraigDeont’eDooneyIndiaMarquezMiaNyqueriaQuinlanTaliaTatiana
NEIGHBORS WHO SHARED IDEAS
Ms BainHarold BarnesLarry BeggsGeorgeBoydKiamani CanadyNiqueria CarnesTrina CarrollEvelyn ChilsonJames ConawayO.D. DawsonFaith EvansTori FinleyReid GerlettiKristen Gish
Jackie PompeyBarbara
Powell Harris
Nene ReedCynthia ReichertSarah ScottRoland SmithTommy TryceShanice WhitefieldDavid WhitfieldAdelle WigginsLadarion WilliamsTommyCesarDawnWillie
Mattie GreenDestiny HamiltonKedra HarveyGregory HawkinsTy HayesCassandra HigdonRobert HollidayTommy JohnsonNovella LafffitteIda LeverettLiz (Music) MartinMarco MedinaDave MossCaridad O'FarrillAlicia Peterson
WHAT PERCENTAGE OF 3RD GRADERS
ARE READING ON GRADE LEVEL?2
410151518253131314040
454650505050505050505055
566060606060606065676775
757576808080808080808590
ONE PERSON SAID 100%
AVERAGE = 55%
WHAT DO NEIGHBORS THINK?Wow - bad.Wow - bad.It's amazing, the third graders.That a lot of grade levels are not up to par.
Ooh yeah. That the high schoolers should have higher percentages.What about grade 11? Really low.I guess they could be higher.It need help.
They're only at 31% - oh, that's not good! Us parents have to crack down more on the kids!20!
It's 31% when it should be 80…It's kind of sad. That's interesting - I always thought it was higher in third and went down. It shows a deficit of reading skills.That we need to read more.That's ridiculous - 11%!
I think thre's a lot of misconceptions because I thought it was a lot higher.I would expect it to be higher.
How low the percentage is - I think that this is kind of real low.
I would think they could read better than 31% because I know I could. My mama was a teacher. I was reading at 3 years old.They need to increase!That's a lot different than what I thought.That it's not that good.
12th Grade is missing. The kids need to get their grades up and schools need to be helping more. The teachers need to be more helpful.
That's okay - we're getting there - this helps. The chart - it doesn't seem we're doing as good as we could, but we're at least half-way there. I think if parents get involved more it will go up - very up.
That’s not so bad - I think it could improve - hope it goes up - needs to improve.Just do better.Look at 11th Grade - it is the lowest, but 6th is the highest.
Socioeconomically, I would put it there. The grade six thing, not surprising. Parents don't take advantage of good preschool opportunities for their kids. As the grades go up, the percentage goes down.
That they're really going from grade 3, by the time they get to grade 11, it's going down.
the fact that at the end of middle school it drops low and at the end of high school it drops low and there is no 12th grade.As they get older it goes down.It seems to improve until 10th grade.That we the 4th graders beat 11th gradeThe 6th graders are doing very good, definitely.the 6th graders at 47%It tells you how high your score is. The 6th grade scores! 6th Graders
The sixth graders are more interested in reading - I guess they're more curious and inquisitive about life - they want to know.If this is a true statistic, it's better than I thought.
Seems to go up when they start middle school and high school.
I think everything is important, especially what you are doing.I'm not that far off - halfway there.I wasn't too far off!
WHAT TO DO TOGETHER?
SAFE-FAIL EXPERIMENTS
“Without faith, hope and trust, there is no promise for the future,and without a promising future,life has no direction, no meaning, and no justification.”Adlin Sinclair, Humanitarian
Cultivating Ownership
Cultivating Ownership
Cultivating Ownership
Being Black is Not a Risk Factor: A Strengths Based Look at the State of the Black Child
2013, National Black Child Development Institute
BEING LABELED “AT RISK” IS LIKE BEING VOTEDLEAST LIKELY TO SUCCEED. FOR WHERE THEREIS NO FAITH IN YOUR FUTURE SUCCESS, THEREIS NO REAL EFFORT TO PREPARE YOU FOR IT.
Acquiring Data
LIBERATE THE DATA!“Innovation means challenging the status quo wherever it exists.”
-- Bryan Sivak Chief Technology Officer
U.S. Dept. of HHS2012 CIC Summit
Acquiring Data
Resource shared with attendees of the 2012 CIC
Summit
Acquiring Data
School Data
Neighborhood-specific data is critical in Sarasota because kids living in 1.2 square miles of the greater Newtown community are bused to EIGHT different elementary schools, none of which are located within the neighborhood.
Health Data for Community Change
“What color was your baby brother’s casket?
Was it white?”
-- comment made in conversation between two neighborkids,
while riding around together in the neighborhood
Following the lead of neighborkids includes listening and responding to what they say in everyday moments on the block…
Health Data for Community Change
“Disparities in birth outcomes are not just simply differential exposures during pregnancy, but really all the inequities that accumulated even before women get pregnant.”
Michael LuUCLA Obstetrician & Public Health Professor
Florida Department of HealthVital Records Data Use Agreement
Purpose:
The goal is a transformed neighborhood and community, such that all children who live in the neighborhood and the neighborhood itself are thriving.
In order to clarify the current state of collective well-being and track changes over time, it is important to know how children are faring with regard to their health and social well-being -- in relation to the neighborhood itself, surrounding neighborhoods, and the broader community.
Birth and fetal/neonatal/infant death rates as well as rates of marriage and divorce are important indicators of health and social-well-being that can be identified and tracked at the neighborhood scale.
How we described the rationale for the community data efforts to DOH:
Florida Department of HealthVital Records Data Use Agreement
Intended Use:
Birth and fetal/neonatal/infant death rates as well as rates of marriage and divorce will be used to establish a neighborhood baseline profile and to track changes in neighborhood well-being over time, in order to inform resident-led community decision making and local approaches to community-building, policy, and practice for improved child and neighborhood well-being.
How we described the rationale for the community data efforts to DOH:
Response from Health Department
What are your hypotheses?
Which specific variables do you want?
DOH response:
To track neighborhood well-being associated with births, we will examine:
# of live births (and relative to total population) # and % of healthy births: gestational age (37 weeks or more), birth weight (2500
grams or above), APGAR (score of 7 or above) birth demographics: # and % by gender, race/ethnicity of mother, race/ethnicity of
father to examine by neighborhood, we will need mother's address (house # & street, city,
state, zip) [or we can send the neighborhood shapefiles to DOH in order for neighborhood totals to be calculated by DOH]
to examine on a monthly basis, we will need date of birth [or monthly totals could be calculated by DOH]
# of fetal/neonatal/infant deaths (and relative to total number of live births) # and % by age at death (or gestational age / DOB if it must be calculated) # and % by cause of death demographics: # and % by gender, race/ethnicity of mother, race/ethnicity of father to examine by neighborhood, we will need infant or mother's address (house # &
street, city, state, zip) [or we can send the neighborhood shapefiles to DOH in order for neighborhood totals to be calculated by DOH]
to examine on a monthly basis, we will need date of death [or monthly totals could be calculated by DOH, presuming age at death can be provided]
To track neighborhood well-being associated with marriage, we will examine:
# of marriages (and relative to total population) demographics: # and % by age of bride & groom, race/ethnicity of
bride & groom to examine by neighborhood, we will need bride's address & groom's
address (house # & street, city, state, zip) [or we can send the neighborhood shapefiles to DOH in order for neighborhood totals to be calculated by DOH]
to examine on a monthly basis, we will need date of marriage [or monthly totals could be calculated by DOH]
# of dissolutions of marriage (and relative to total population) demographics: # and % by age of wife & husband, race/ethnicity of
wife & husband to examine by neighborhood, we will need wife's address & husband's
address (house # & street, city, state, zip) [or we can send the neighborhood shapefiles to DOH in order for neighborhood totals to be calculated by DOH]
to examine on a monthly basis, we will need date of dissolution of marriage [or monthly totals could be calculated by DOH]
Response from Health Department
Have you checked out the CHARTS tables on our website for the information you are requesting?
Why CHARTS Data is Not Helpful
Neighborhood boundaries do not correspond with census block group boundaries
Census tracts and zip codes are too huge to be meaningful as a way of understanding neighborhood well-being
Our response to DOH:
Response from Health Department
We will send you the data by either BLOCK or TRACT.
We will send you fetal death data for 2009 – 2011 but we only have birth data for 2011.
Review of Data Revealed:
For marriage data there is no street address
For divorce data there is: No house # No age No race/ethnicity data
Birth and fetal death data only provided in terms of total # of births / deaths per block
Our clarification to DOH:
Still needed this Census Block Data for Births:
births with gestational age of 37 weeks or more births with birth weight of 2500 grams or above births with APGAR score of 7 or above births: males births: females births with mother of race: black births with mother of race: white births with mother of race: american indian births with mother of race: asian births with mother of race: pacific islander births with mother of race: multiple races births with mother of ethnicity: hispanic births with mother of ethnicity: non-hispanic births with father of race: black births with father of race: white births with father of race: american indian births with father of race: asian births with father of race: pacific islander births with father of race: multiple races births with father of ethnicity: hispanic births with father of ethnicity: non-hispanic births in January births in February births in March births in April births in May births in June births in July births in August births in September births in October births in November births in December
Our clarification to DOH:
Still needed this Census Block Data for Fetal / Neonatal / Infant Deaths:
deaths: males deaths: females deaths with mother of race: black deaths with mother of race: white deaths with mother of race: american indian deaths with mother of race: asian deaths with mother of race: pacific islander deaths with mother of race: multiple races deaths with mother of ethnicity: hispanic deaths with mother of ethnicity: non-hispanic deaths with father of race: black deaths with father of race: white deaths with father of race: american indian deaths with father of race: asian deaths with father of race: pacific islander deaths with father of race: multiple races deaths with father of ethnicity: hispanic deaths with father of ethnicity: non-hispanic deaths in January deaths in February deaths in March deaths in April deaths in May deaths in June deaths in July deaths in August deaths in September deaths in October deaths in November deaths in December cause of death: diseases cause of death: perinatal period conditions cause of death: congenital / chromosomal anomalies cause of death: sudden infant death syndrome cause of death: symptoms,signs, clinical/lab findings cause of death: unintentional injury cause of death: homicide
Our clarification to DOH:
Response from Health Department
There will be a fee. It will take a month to join the
datasets. Given the detail and small level
geography, not likely to be approved for just any use.
Final Outcome
SUCCESS!…with a newfound appreciation for
what it takes to navigate the system to liberate the data!
Ongoing Efforts to Create a Community Data Collaborative
…so far with limited success…
Online Community Data Platform
Generating Data
Reading
Generating Data
Generating Data
Property Appraiser Data
Table1_ID PID
STREET NUMBER STREET ZIP
Single-Family
Multi-Family
Commercial VACANT BOARDED
FOR SALE-RENT SIGN
YARD IN NEED
VANDALIZED Historic OWNER NAME 1
603 2025-13-0027 1315 10TH ST 34236 1 1 1 CHAMBERLAIN J OHN601 2025-13-0023 1331 10TH ST 34236 1 1 1 1 214 MAIN STREET CORP470 2025-05-0008 1257 12TH ST 34236 1 1 KINNEY WAYNE R580 2025-12-0072 1322 12TH ST 34236 1 1 1 CARLSON SHANE R527 2025-05-0088 1326 13TH ST 34236 1 1 1 U S BANK NA TTEE520 2025-05-0078 1371 13TH ST 34236 1 1 SOCKWELL ALEXIS T401 2025-04-0007 1336 17TH ST 34236 1 1 1 1 BELL J R J OHNNY L290 2024-13-0080 1325 18TH ST 34234 1 1 1 J ONES MARY E296 2024-13-0086 1377 18TH ST 34234 1 1 1 KING CHARLES M330 2024-14-0041 1421 18TH ST 34234 1 1 1 SOUTHERN CROSSROADS HOLDINGS LLC302 2024-13-0092 1366 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 SARASOTA CAPTAINS TABLE INC235 2024-12-0102 1375 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 KREMPEL MICHAEL347 2024-14-0073 1428 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 1 HAYNES ROBERT L345 2024-14-0071 1446 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 1 GILMORE EST OF ANNIE343 2024-14-0069 1462 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 1 ROSSLER J OHN A350 2024-14-0078 1463 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 1 CAPICOTTE MORREY351 2024-14-0079 1469 19TH ST 34234 1 1 1 1 HERBERT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT SERVICES TTEE227 2024-12-0090 1334 20TH ST 34234 1 1 1 1 J OHNSON ALEX N217 2024-12-0079 1369 20TH ST 34234 1 1 LATHAM II WILLIAM G142 2024-11-0048 1439 20TH ST 34234 1 1 WHITFIELD SAM137 2024-11-0040 1422 21ST ST 34234 1 1 1 J OHNSON ARVIN J124 2024-11-0004 1429 21ST ST 34234 1 1 1 J OHNSON CHRISTOPHER A126 2024-11-0006 1445 21ST ST 34234 1 1 1 WHEELER MAUREEN120 2024-06-0047 1442 22ND ST 34234 1 1 1 BERGER MERRY98 2024-05-0059 1363 23RD ST 34234 1 1 1 1 SCHRAMM TTEE J OSEPH G91 2024-05-0049 1322 24TH ST 34234 1 1 1 SCHRAMM TTEE J OSEPH G7 2024-04-0004 1345 24TH ST 34234 1 1 1 PITTMAN DENISE C
88 2024-05-0045 1360 24TH ST 34234 1 1 J UERGENSEN ANNE17 2024-04-0021 1322 25TH ST 34234 1 1 1 BURNS SCOTT E
538 2025-05-0099 1201 CENTRAL AVE 34236 1 1 1 1 BRYANT SR CALVIN276 2024-13-0065 1703 CENTRAL AVE 34234 1 1 1 1 GREEN BOBBIE J308 2024-14-0003 1818 CENTRAL AVE 34234 1 1 1 1 J ONES CLARENCE307 2024-14-0001 1834 CENTRAL AVE 34234 1 1 1 1 1 GAETA J R J OSEPH A617 2025-13-0047 1030 COCOANUT AVE 34236 1 1 1 1 CHAMBERLAIN J OHN591 2025-12-0085 1106 COCOANUT AVE 34236 1 1 1 1 GULF COAST PROPERTY HOLDINGS LLC261 2024-13-0048 1818 COCOANUT AVE 34234 1 1 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSN160 2024-12-0004 1937 COCOANUT AVE 34234 1 1 1 O CONNER ANDRE A161 2024-12-0006 2009 COCOANUT AVE 34234 1 1 1 1 O CONNOR ANDRE A162 2024-12-0007 2023 COCOANUT AVE 34234 1 1 1 1 GRAHAM J AMES A209 2024-12-0069 2026 COCOANUT AVE 34234 1 1 1 1 SIMONS J ERALD44 2024-04-0060 2451 COCOANUT AVE 34234 1 1 1 SKINNER FRED C
574 2025-12-0064 1135 FLORIDA AVE 34236 1 1 LILLY KIM M562 2025-12-0049 1186 FLORIDA AVE 34236 1 1 1 1 ASBURY SCOTT
Neighbors Survey Housing
Central-Cocoanut Abandoned Housing SurveyPID Date Surv
eyorSt
Number
Street Yard Needs
Assistance
Boarded Windows or Doors
Evidence of
Dumping
For Sale Sign
For Rent Sign
How long has this been
abandonned?
Neighbor Surveyed
What impact does it have on the neighborhood?
1 617 1030COCOANUT AVE 1
2 591 1106COCOANUT AVE 2
3 574 1135 FLORIDA AVE 3
4 562 1186 FLORIDA AVE 4
5 538 1201 CENTRAL AVE 5
6 470 1257 12TH ST 6
Property Delinquency Data
ACCT GEO FOLIO YEAR OWNER NAME BIDDER NO STATUS-CDDELQ-YEARCERT-WRNTGROSS-TAX FACE-AMT INT-PCTTDA-NOLAS-DATE MONTHAMT-INT0001-04-0055 0001-04-0055 50 2011 DE JOURNETTE LISA 88908 2012 2 1966.32 2165.54 0.25 0 3 108.280002-05-0014 0002-05-0014 113 2011 SMITH SAUNDRA S 99903 2012 3 6371.21 6998.81 0.25 0 3 349.940003-03-1038 0003-03-1038 5020 2010 O BRIEN NEIL P 13439 2011 9 1435.93 1583.58 0.25 0 3 79.180003-03-1038 0003-03-1038 502 2011 O BRIEN NEIL P 84267 2012 10 1314.66 1450.51 0.25 0 3 72.530003-03-1052 0003-03-1052 516 2011 THIAS HANS H 83963 2012 11 1184.64 1307.85 0.25 0 3 65.390003-15-2021 0003-15-2021 967 2011 NOWAK BLANDYNA 113294 2012 21 2614.87 2877.17 0.25 0 3 143.860005-08-0057 0005-08-0057 1621 2011 BALK EST OF BRUCE 87042 2012 24 173.36 198.22 0.25 0 3 9.910005-16-0024 0005-16-0024 16710 2010 ARMSTRONG JAMES W 13413 BK 2011 25 2230.39 2455.3 0.25 0 3 122.770005-16-0024 0005-16-0024 1672 2011 ARMSTRONG JAMES W BK 0 0 2168.64 0 18 0 3 390.360006-07-1062 0006-07-1062 18440 2010 PARRISH ROBERT 13413 2011 26 2591.22 2851.21 4.75 0 3 248.290006-07-1062 0006-07-1062 1845 2011 PARRISH ROBERT 87183 2012 25 2247.93 2474.54 0.25 0 3 123.730006-07-1085 0006-07-1085 18670 2010 RENNER JOANNA 2267 NF 2011 29 720.41 798.47 0.25 0 3 39.920006-07-1085 0006-07-1085 1868 2011 RENNER JOANNA 91379 2012 28 2341.82 2577.56 0.25 0 3 128.880006-07-1114 0006-07-1114 18960 2010 SMITH ALEXANDER G 13413 2011 32 2519.93 2773 4.75 0 3 241.480006-07-1114 0006-07-1114 1897 2011 SMITH ALEXANDER G 88872 2012 30 2184.36 2404.79 0.25 0 3 120.240006-07-1191 0006-07-1191 1972 2011 THOMASON ELIZABETH 88893 2012 31 1645.49 1813.52 0.25 0 3 90.680007-05-1064 0007-05-1064 2221 2011 PINI FLORENCE Y 100642 2012 32 7120.82 7821.32 0.25 0 3 391.070007-05-2012 0007-05-2012 22560 2010 GOODRID GREGORY S 8321 2011 38 11205.26 12302.98 0.25 0 3 615.150007-05-2012 0007-05-2012 2257 2011 GOODRID GREGORY S 124546 2012 33 10317.92 11329.34 0.25 0 3 566.470007-12-1016 0007-12-1016 24840 2010 COHEN TTEE JANET W 7201 2011 40 6403.05 7033.75 0.25 0 3 351.690007-12-1016 0007-12-1016 2485 2011 COHEN TTEE JANET W 113294 2012 34 6928.69 7610.5 0.25 0 3 380.530008-02-0004 0008-02-0004 2723 2007 ARVIDA/J M B PARTNERS 4475 2008 42 13.62 22.94 5.75 0 3 6.380008-02-0004 0008-02-0004 2990 2008 ARVIDA/J M B PARTNERS 5326 2009 47 13.61 22.93 11.75 0 3 10.330008-02-0005 0008-02-0005 2991 2008 ARVIDA/J M B PARTNERS 5860 2009 48 5.44 13.96 18 0 3 9.630008-04-2009 0008-04-2009 3101 2011 BERNSTEIN TTEE STANLEY K 118776 2012 35 15475.41 16988.39 0.25 0 3 849.420008-06-1090 0008-06-1090 3240 2011 BAKER KATHY 81187 2012 37 1995.1 2197.12 0.25 0 3 109.860008-14-1014 0008-14-1014 3372 2011 WATERS ILLE A 113294 2012 38 2788.24 3067.4 0.25 0 3 153.370008-14-4030 0008-14-4030 3582 2011 SAUNDERS DAVID J 88943 2012 39 3098.84 3408.2 0.25 0 3 170.410009-04-1176 0009-04-1176 3854 2011 COFFEY JOHN M 5340 2012 48 343.83 385.27 7.75 0 3 24.880009-04-1221 0009-04-1221 38980 2010 KLAUBER MURRAY J 2267 2011 57 2840.7 3124.96 0.25 0 3 156.250009-04-1221 0009-04-1221 3899 2011 KLAUBER MURRAY J 79678 2012 49 2729.16 3002.57 0.25 0 3 150.130009-04-1222 0009-04-1222 38990 2010 KLAUBER MURRAY J 2267 2011 58 2613.48 2875.64 0.25 0 3 143.780009-04-1222 0009-04-1222 3900 2011 KLAUBER MURRAY J 81021 2012 50 2516.63 2769.37 0.25 0 3 138.470009-04-1233 0009-04-1233 39100 2010 KLAUBER MURRAY J 2267 2011 60 3534.13 3885.83 0.25 0 3 194.290009-04-1233 0009-04-1233 3911 2011 KLAUBER MURRAY J 89612 2012 51 3403.66 3742.66 0.25 0 3 187.130009-04-1240 0009-04-1240 39150 2010 COLONY BEACH & TENNIS CLUB INC BK 0 0 3318.83 0 18 0 3 1194.780009-04-1240 0009-04-1240 3916 2011 COLONY BEACH & TENNIS CLUB INC 81100 BK 2012 53 2900.91 3191.02 0.25 0 3 159.55
Sharing Data
Neighborhood Map Gallery at the Studio
Sharing Data
on front porches throughout the neighborhood
Sharing Data
online, especially on facebook
Sharing Data
in local neighborhood newspapers
Sharing Data
lesson learned: don’t crash neighborhood parties with data!
Ongoing Reflective Practice
…
Issues of Power Remain
Issues of Power Remain
Implications
…