ss recent developments in corporate governance in asia
TRANSCRIPT
23rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
A common view on AsiaA common view on Asia
“My impression is that the prospects for CG are rather gloomy, that it will take a long, long time (decades) and right now all these activists and forums are just working on the form but not the substance. Where do you stand?”
-- A question recently asked of me by a foreign journalist in Asia.
33rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Two questionsTwo questions
Where have substantive changes or improvements occurred in Asia in recent years?
How can we facilitate the creation of substance in addition to form?
43rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Competition for capitalCompetition for capital
Listed companies becoming more transparent– Improved disclosure among international companies (HSBC,
Infosys) and local/regional companies (CLP Holdings, Kerry Properties, Good Morning Securities, DBS Bank).
– Study after study indicates a clear demand from institutional investors for better financial data, improved auditing, and more board independence.
Private companies restructuring their boards– Preparing for IPOs.– In response to demands of a new private equity investor.
Partially privatised state enterprises (?) Technology start-ups/second boards (?)
53rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Behaviour of intermediariesBehaviour of intermediaries Growing interest among investment banks,
brokers, and analysts in the commercial relevance of corporate governance:– Goldman Sachs: “Asia Restructuring Scorecard”, a quarterly
survey that includes corporate governance.– CLSA: Began ranking Asian companies in October 2000.– S&P: Developing a new company rating service.
Expansion into Asia of US and European consultancies: – Proxy voting/advisory: Institutional Shareholder Services
(ISS), Investor Responsibility Research Center (IRRC). – Company surveys: Deminor.
63rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Voting of sharesVoting of shares
Japan:– Pension funds are starting to vote their shares following years
of poor returns from companies. Participation is becoming a necessity.
Korea: – Elections of outside directors are being contested. Eg, PSPD
nominated a candidate for a seat on the board of Samsung Electronics in March 2001. They garnered 16.07% of the vote. Although most support came from foreign institutional investors, it was significant that several large Korean public pension funds also backed the PSPD. All private Korean institutional investors, except one, supported management.
73rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Shareholder actionShareholder action Korea:
– People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy (PSPD) Malaysia:
– Malaysian Investors Association (MIA) Singapore:
– Securities Investors Association (Singapore) Hong Kong:
– Proposed HK Association of Minority Shareholders (HAMS) Litigation:
– Malaysia: Palmco, a listed oleochemicals maker. Marking down shares:
– UBS Warburg: Market cap of certain Malaysian companies fell significantly due anti-minority proposals in last two years.
83rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Educational infrastructureEducational infrastructure New training programmes:
– For accountants, directors, company secretaries, internal auditors, lawyers and investment analysts.
– Being offered by private training firms.– Being undertaken by corporations for their staff.
New organisations:– Institutes of Directors: Singapore, Thailand, Philippines,
Indonesia. Revamped in Hong Kong.– Non-profit organizations: Indonesian Institute for Corporate
Governance, Malaysian Institute of Corporate Governance.– Academic centres: Asian Institute of Management, City
University of HK, Chinese University of HK (planned). New networks
– Institutes of Directors of East Asia Network (IDEA.Net)
93rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Better quality informationBetter quality information Media reporting: more nuanced (eg, SCMP in Hong Kong) Conference materials: OECD, APEC, ADB, Shanghai Stock
Exchange Professional journals/magazines:
– Corporate Governance International (CGI), Company Secretary magazine, Hong Kong Society of Accountants magazine
Webb-site.com RSC Asia regional report and articles Japan Investment Forum (www.japaninvest.com) International newsletters
– Global Proxy Watch (US)– Governance (UK)
103rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
2nd question2nd question
How can we facilitate the creation of substance in addition to form?
113rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Focus on the banking sector tooFocus on the banking sector too Banks are a neglected element in much discussion of corporate
governance in Asia, yet clearly they have a role to play in influencing the vast majority of (unlisted) companies.
Banks may face competitive limitations in promoting corporate governance to their borrowers, but could start by improving their own governance standards.
This probably needs to be done as a group, and initially under the guidance of a regulator. For example:
Hong Kong Monetary Authority new guidelines, May 2000: – The board should ensure that the bank properly manages risk (8
types of risk are specified).– The board should ensure that provisions on connected lending are
fully understood, and the bank sets a policy on such lending.– The board should receive the external auditor’s management letter,
with comments from management. – Higher number of independent directors (3), + possibility of more.– Etc
123rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Public-private partnershipsPublic-private partnerships Few would dispute there was a need for greater investor
involvement in corporate governance reform in Asia. Yet costs continue to outweigh the benefits for most funds.
A useful interim mechanism may be programme partnerships between private groups and public bodies, such as:– Research into strengths and weaknesses of local governance
regimes, especially as they affect different types of companies.
– Plain-language summaries of governance rules confusingly spread across company and securities laws, various regulations, listing rules, and codes of best practice.
– Joint training programmes among officials, directors, etc.– Joint litigation (in extreme cases, as in Taiwan).
The assumption here is that governments will remain the main drivers of governance reform for some time, hence it makes sense to work with them in “strategic” ways.
133rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Examine procedural rulesExamine procedural rules Most government effort in Asia in recent years has been
focussed on developing new codes of best practice, amending laws and listing rules, and drawing up new policies.
But it is also important to ensure that procedural rules do not stymie the exercise of minority shareholder rights--either by making it too difficult, too expensive or too risky.
Issues to consider:– Simpler mechanisms for derivative suits.– Class-action suits with contingency fees.– Lowering arbitrary limits on the right of minority shareholders
to call a meeting, nominate a director, file a shareholder proposal, and so on.
– Methods of voting at annual meetings (eg, the show-of- hands vote).
Taiwan has evolved a unique solution: “simulated class action”
143rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Balance quantity with qualityBalance quantity with quality Much corporate governance discussion focusses
on increasing the:– Number of independent directors and independent board
committees;– Fees paid to independent directors;– Space devoted to corporate governance in annual reports
and other public documents. All of this is important, but:
– What is the use of more independent directors if they are of poor quality? Ditto for board committees.
– What is the point of more words in annual reports if the language is largely formulaic or full of jargon?
Quality may count for more.
153rd Asian Roundtable
© RSC Asia Ltd
Where I standWhere I stand
“My impression is that the prospects for CG are rather good (over the medium to long term), that it will take a long time (two decades), and right now we are all still working on the foundations. But progress is rarely linear or evenly paced: reform will go forwards and backwards, and periods of apparent inaction could be followed by bursts of activity following external shocks.”