south china seas trading co. limited...online gift certificates are offered on the website, and when...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Life's Too Short for Boring Food.©
South China Seas Trading Co. Limited
2
3
Background and
Overview
Summary
We are offering for sale the shares of South
China Seas Trading Co. Limited, a company
was incorporated in British Columbia in
1987, the year it opened its first retail store
in Vancouver’s internationally celebrated
Granville Island Public Market. The
company sells spices and other specialty
cooking ingredients from around the world
at the flagship Public Market location,
a second retail outlet in Vancouver’s
hip Commercial Drive neighbourhood,
through a small number of specialty
food resellers, and online across Canada
through southchinaseas.ca and globavore.
ca. The second retail store also serves
as a commissary for the preparation and
packaging of an extensive and growing
range of proprietary herb and spice blends
and other products.
Concept
South China Seas has been the primary
agent for the introduction of the
exhilarating tastes and exotic fragrances of
the World’s cuisines to West Coast chefs
and adventurous home cooks for more
than 30 years. The Company is known
for the unrivaled extent of the hard-to-find
culinary essentials it stocks and for the
superior quality of its herbs and spices.
Many of the Vancouver’s top restaurants
and innovative chefs are amongst its
customers.
The South China Seas name alludes to an
original focus on the foods of South East
Asia – which were all but impossible to
source when the company was founded.
Over time, the range of products has
broadened in response to increasing
sophistication of the local culinary scene.
The Victoria Drive location incorporates a commercial kitchen
where herbs and spices ground, blended and packaged.
South China Seas carries a broad selection of exotic
fruits, vegetables, and herbs.
Life's Too Short for Boring Food.©
The South China Seas trademark reflects an initial focus on the
cuisine of South East Asia.
4
Offerings now include the essential
ingredients of Asian, Indian, Middle
Eastern, Mediterranean, Caribbean and
Latin American cuisines – fresh and
fragrant herbs and rare spices, sauces and
condiments, fresh and dried chiles, exotic
fruits, vegetables and mushrooms, curries,
chutneys and pickles, exquisite EVOOs and
wine and fruit vinegars, fragrant teas, fresh
and dried noodles, heirloom rice varieties,
seaweeds & sushi ingredients, dim sum,
dumplings and tamales, fresh tortillas, and
much, much more.
An extensive selection of cookbooks
with a focus on global culinary traditions,
and the work of ground-breaking chefs
are also stocked – to support the sale of
unfamiliar ingredients, and as a profitable
product category in and of itself. For the
same reasons, specialty cookware and
tableware, which enhance the experience
of preparing and sharing meals from other
cultures, is also on offer.
The eclectic product mix is supported by
a culture of product-knowledge-based
customer service. Culinary knowledge,
experience and, most importantly, passion,
are key factors in hiring. Informative
store signage, packaging text, and the
encyclopedic culinary content of the South
China Seas website also play a strong role
in driving sales.
Professionally executed retail design,
signage, packaging and merchandizing
are key elements of the South China
Seas brand. When the prime location at
the heart of the Public Market became
available in 2014, CMHC, the federal
agency that administers Granville Island,
selected South China Seas to take over the
space. The $250,000 refit of the flagship
store continues to set the bar for design
and product merchandising the Public
Market.
In 2008, Vancouver Magazine described
South China Seas’ second location as
a “beautifully designed [and] curated
culinary experience”
The focus on design extends to the
Company’s fast and attractive, user friendly,
fully scalable ecommerce website.
South China Seas relocated to the heart of the Public Market in
2015. Surrounded by several of Vancouver’s favourite producers
and purveyors, the stylish new store occupies the Market’ best
location.
“Less a store than a curated culinary experience (visit and you’ll
see what we mean), the beautifully designed (Victoria Drive) store
is a destination for foodies seeking hard-to-source ingredients for
African, Asian, Caribbean, and Middle Eastern dishes. It’s also a
place to find reasonably priced ground spices and rare produce like
lobster mushrooms, wild chanterelles, or Thai eggplant. Don’t know
what to do with such ingredients? A wall of cookbooks covering
the world’s major culinary regions offers guidance – as do the
pleasant, knowledgeable staff...” Vancouver Magazine
5
Granville Island and the
Public Market
In the 1970’s, Granville Island was
transformed from the remnants of an
industrial wasteland adjacent to the
downtown peninsula into one of the most
beloved public spaces in Vancouver, if not
the world. This shopping, entertainment
and cultural district set in a waterfront
location in the heart of the city is beloved
by locals and tourists alike, and attracts
more than 10.5 million visitors a year.
The charm of Granville Island lies in
its unexpected mix of uses. The world
renowned Granville Island Public Market
is the Island’s primary destination and its
economic driver. Its fascinating assortment
of artisanal food producers, butchers,
fishmongers, delis, produce vendors and
eateries is augmented with purveyors
of handcrafted jewelry, fashion and
decorative products. The ateliers of local
artists and designers are located in the
adjacent Net Loft building and throughout
the island. Granville Island is also home
to several theatre companies, and hosts
numerous performing arts and cultural
events year-round, including Vancouver’s
Fringe, Comedy, Writer’s and Children’s
Festivals.
Operationally self-sustaining, Granville
Island includes approximately 700,000 sf.
of net leasable area, accommodating over
300 businesses. The Island is estimated
to provide approximately 3,000 Full Time
Equivalent (FTE) jobs and generate roughly
$285 million in sales (2016).
Most visitors arrive by vehicle, bicycle or on
foot via a short causeway (Granville Island
is actually a peninsula). It is also easily
reached in minutes from several points in
downtown Vancouver and around False
Creek, by the Aquabus and False Creek
Ferry systems.
Granville Island, a breathtaking oasis in the heart of Vancouver is
anchored by the Public Market.
A presentation kitchen integrated into the store
hosts weekend cooking demonstrations and
sampling by suppliers and local producers.
6
Key Assets and Attributes
Intellectual Property
The South China Seas and Globavore
brands, and their associated positioning
statements: Life’s Too Short for Boring
Food and Celebrating the 10,000 Mile
Diet are registered trademarks. These
brands are applied to product packaging,
store signage, website graphics and
notably, on branded collateral items.
The Globavore trademark and positioning statement
captures the global scope of current product
offerings.
Only very high quality products are sold
under the South China Seas and Globavore
labels, and the brands have developed
such a strong association with quality
and desirability that these products
command much higher pricing margins
than conventional products. The brands
themselves have become desirable
commodities, as reflected in the sales of
branded T-shirts, aprons and shopping
bags.
POS and Inventory Systems
South China Seas uses LightSpeed
software, which provides a real time online
POS/Inventory connection between both
retail locations and the administrative
office. In-store and online payments are
processed by ChasePaymentec. Visa,
MC, Amex, and Interac are accepted.
Reloadable gift cards are also in use. CCTV
systems, which are monitored both in-store
and online, are installed in both stores.
Over the years, procedures governing
all aspects the Company’s activity have
been developed and are consolidated into
comprehensive Operations Manuals which
cover day-to-day operations, inventory
control, cash management, HR, shipping
and receiving, food safety and traceability,
and so on.
Collectively, these highly evolved
operational assets are implementation-
ready for a much larger multi-store retail
organization.
A POS and Inventory Management system tracks sales, customers,
suppliers and inventory in real time.
Reloadable Gift Cards are available in the stores.
Online Gift Certificates are offered on the website,
and when purchased, emails with personalized
messages and unique Promotion Codes are
generated and sent to recipients.
7
Almost all pre-packaged dry goods
and perishables, either sourced locally
(70 – 80%), from elsewhere in Canada,
or imported, are received directly at
Granville Island, where most retail sales
are generated. A few of the dozen or so
varieties of rice and grain products that
are sold are also purchased locally, and
these bulky/heavy products are received,
packaged and labeled directly at Granville
Island.
All produce is sourced from local
distributors (the majority of it, by special
order) and is received and prepped at
Granville Island. There is a small off-
premise refrigerated storage locker in the
Public Market building, plus additional
dry, refrigerated, and freezer storage in an
adjacent building.
The Victoria Drive location also provides
a venue for occasional Cooking Class
Series and culinary events, and facilitates
wholesale, bulk and food service sales
to restaurants, and increasingly, to craft
brewers.
Similarly, the website would require no
further development or modification
to handle a massive ramp up of online
sales. Its customized WordPress and
3DCart components present as a single,
handsomely designed site, and allow
for easy back-end management of blog
and ecommerce functionality. A custom
search engine is incorporated, and the
entire site (as opposed to just its payment
pages) meets the highest industry security
standards.
Manufacturing and Logistics
Most South China Seas and Globavore
branded products (herbs and spices, rice
and other grains, salts, dried chiles, etc.)
are received at the Victoria Drive retail
store/commissary for storage, processing
(grinding, blending), packaging, labeling,
etc., and are transferred as needed to
Granville Island.
Most of these products are brought in
directly by the company, usually from the
US, but some from elsewhere in Canada,
and internationally. A few Mexican herbs
and spices, a couple of specialty salts, a
few Indian spices, and several dried chiles
are purchased locally.
Popular cooking classes held at the Victoria Drive location.
The quality of South China Seas herbs and spices is unsurpassed.
8
interest in food and cooking, and for them,
the Market is the Island’s big draw. This
cohort includes many of South China Seas’
best customers. For them, South China
Seas itself is the Public Market’s big draw,
and a visit is on their itinerary every time
they visit Vancouver.
Sales categories at the Granville Island
location are dominated by dried spices
and herbs which in 2017 were over 17%
of sales followed by fresh spices and herbs
were over 8.5% of sales, then sauces and
marinades at about 8%. Chiles and chile
sauces together made up the next 13% of
sales combined. Overall, South China Seas
and Globavore branded products account
for approximately 24% of brick and mortar
sales revenue.
Online customers tend to take advantage
of the wide range of products on offer.
While herbs and spices, dried chiles,
specialty salts and so on are good online
sellers, these categories represent a
smaller percentage of overall sales. This
is probably due to two factors: Online
competition from sites exclusively selling
spices, and a demand for products that are
more widely available in larger cities, but
unobtainable in smaller communities.
“The South Seas have always been a source of intrigue. This shop
recreates a bit of that wonder, with a remarkable collection of rare
spices and hard-to-find sauces. Fresh Kaffir lime leaves, Thai basil,
sprigs of curry plant, young ginger, sweet Thai chile sauce, and
occasional exotic produce like mangosteens and rambutans are just a
few of the exotic selection of products available. Pick up recipes and
ideas from the knowledgeable staff.” Frommer’s Complete Guide to
Vancouver
The South China Seas
Customer
The online and in store customer profile
is similar, but not identical. The Granville
Island Public Market generally attracts
locals who want higher quality products
and a great selection and are willing to pay
a bit more. The majority of tourists who visit
the Island (especially in the summer) visit
the Market primarily for the experience,
and do not generally purchase much other
than meals, snacks, and handicrafts. A
significant minority however have a great
9
Competition and Industry
Brick and Mortar Competition
South China Seas has no comprehensive
competitor in Metro Vancouver.
Competition is limited to ethnic retailers
who serve specific segments of the market
– Latin American specialty stores serving
the Mexican market, Southeast Asian
stores serving the Vietnamese market,
Indian Stores serving the South Asian
Market, and so on. These retailers generally
compete on price rather than on service,
design, product presentation, location,
product quality and cleanliness. With herbs
and spices specifically, there is some price-
based competition from within the Public
Market, principally from The Grain’ry, but
South China Seas is the only purveyor
of an extensive range of superior quality
herbs and spices, as opposed to a narrower
offering of generic products.
Online Competition
There are online competitors across
Canada, some of which run retail and
online sales operations somewhat
similar to South China Seas, but, as in
Vancouver, they serve only segments of
South China Seas’ market: Spice stores
that sell only spices, Mexican stores that
sell only Mexican products, Thai stores
that sell only Thai products, and so on.
Websites that compete for segments of
South China Seas market include Silk
Road Spice Merchant in Alberta, Épices de
Cru in Montreal, Mexican House of Spice
in Victoria, The Spice Trader and House
of Spice in Toronto, and Cardamom and
Cloves in Ottawa. None are anchored by
a stunning flagship store with a 30-year
history in the heart of Canada’s second
most popular destination (after Niagara
Falls), and none can fulfill an order that
might be comprised of a diverse selection
of herbs, spices and chiles, perhaps an
organic Japanese soy, fresh Margrut lime
leaves, black mole paste, a superb Spanish
EVOO, a Thai granite mortar and pestle
or a Middle Eastern cookbook… In 2018,
the value of the average South China Seas
online order was $71.42.
“South China Seas is Now Open in Moose Jaw, Antigonish,
Wawa, Come By Chance, Medicine Hat, Iqaluit, Rimouski,
Miramachi, The Hat, The Peg, and The Big Smoke...”
South China Seas E-Commerce Launch, 2013
South China Seas Pantry-In-A-Box (Thai, Mexico,
Foodie, China, Middle East, India, Sushi) are popular
gift items packed with exotic ingredients.
10
Opportunities and
Potential
Since buying out a partner and assuming
full ownership two decades ago, the
owners have been systematically
developing the capabilities of the business.
Everything is now in place for new owners
to build on this foundation, and take next
steps on several fronts.
Physical Stores
For years, South China Seas sales growth
has been outpacing overall sales growth
in the Granville Island Public Market, and
there is no reason why this won’t continue.
The Victoria Drive location is not situated
in a prime retail area, and commissary
and order fulfillment, rather than retail, are
its primary functions. There are however
several areas in Metro Vancouver where
South China Seas would thrive – generally,
areas with a high income demographic,
such as Vancouver Westside, and the
North Shore would be most suitable.
Outside of Vancouver, promising new
locations include booming cities such
Victoria and Kelowna in B.C., and all major
Canadian cities.
Over the years, South China Seas has
received several franchise enquiries, and
opportunities for expansion with low
capital requirements through this model
are intriguing.
Other Retail Channels
Developing broader retail distribution of
proprietary brands (South China Seas,
Globavore, Junko’s) is another direction a
new owner could take. A curated selection
of South China Seas and Globavore herbs
and spices in retail packaging are already
sold at the highly regarded Dirty Apron
Cooking School and Delicatessen in
Yaletown, and Fujiya, BC’s largest retailer
of Japanese foods, has been carrying the
Company’s Junko’s salad dressings for
many years.
A Store Within a Store
At the time of this writing, a new and very
exciting opportunity for broader retail
distribution is opening up. A major regional
supermarket chain has invited South
China Seas to introduce a store within
a store concept within its soon-to-open
flagship store for its upmarket brand. The
store will be anchoring an exciting and
architecturally unique retail development
in Vancouver’s down town. The unit will
be differentiated with custom fixtures and
Globavore/South China Seas signage,
and will feature a range of SCS branded
products along with a curated selection
of upscale specialty food products from
around the world. The latter will carry
Owner/chef Don Dickson is sometimes joined by acclaimed chefs
such as Jefferson Alvarez (left) and Vikram Vij at popular cooking
classes.
11
a secondary “Presented by Globavore”
brand in the form of stickers and/or neck
tags. Staffing and inventory management
will be provided by the supermarket, and
additional South China Seas products
(such as Junko’s Salad Dressings) will be
sold in other departments within the store.
Importantly, South China Seas will not be
required to pay slotting fees.
This exciting development substantively
strengthens the South China Seas brand,
and facilitates opening up additional
distribution channels.
Online Sales
Southchinaseas.ca is far and away
the strongest website in the industry:
Beautifully designed, fully scalable,
user friendly, secure, and fast. The site
received 43,514 visitors in 2018. All of
this traffic was organic – achieved without
professional SEO, and no pay per click
advertising. South China Seas nonetheless
appears in the first page of most searches
for specific spices, herbs, chiles in most
cases, particularly when Canada, or
Vancouver is included in search terms.
To date, ownership has been focused on
the design and functionality of the site
itself, and on putting in place effective
systems to manage order tracking,
logistics, and order fulfillment.
A modest advertising and optimization
budget would bring South China Seas to
top of page in almost all searches within
the Canadian market.
This is the next step, and probably
represents the biggest opportunity for
growth.
Savvy new owners with a focus on search
optimization, online advertising and social
media promotion, plus a commitment
to scaling up order fulfillment and the
shipping process, should be able to
increase online sales exponentially:
Online grocery retail is a growth industry,
the specialty foods segment within it is
particularly promising – and the average
order value is already over $70.
The potential for expansion into the US
market is of course enormous, but unless
current Homeland Security Administration
requirements are eased, a fulfillment and
distribution centre on the other side of the
border would be required.
The South China Seas website provides a customer
friendly experience on all platforms.
12
Wholesale Operations
Bulk and food service wholesale,
particularly the sale of dried and fresh
spices and aromatics to BC’s craft
breweries, is an area of strong growth.
We have just completed the development
of a proprietary spice mix for the butchery
operations of a major supermarket chain.
The anticipated initial volume for this
initial product alone is 20 Kg per month at
$50.00 per Kg.
Financial Overview
The most recent year-end in 2018
recorded gross margins in excess of 49%.
Although Granville Island Public Market
sales were flat in 2018, in large part as
a result of parking and traffic disruptions
due to construction, recently, year over
year increases have ranged around 10%.
Leases and detailed financial statements
can be viewed upon signing an NDA
(Nondisclosure Agreement).
13
14