sonoma county food processing industry report...
TRANSCRIPT
Economic Development Board 401 College Avenue Suite D Santa Rosa CA 95401 707.565.7170
www.sonomaedb.org
Sonoma County
Food Processing Industry
Report
2009
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
Table Of Contents
Executive Summary and Overview
Comparison of Trends: 2002 and 2008
New Trends: 2008 and 2009
Sweets
Artisan Breads
Olive Oil
Key Opportunities
Survey Results & Summary
Operations
Employment
Business Environment
Industry Specifics
Methodology and Acknowledgments
3
4
5
5
6
6
7
8
8
11
14
18
20
2 │ www.sonomaedb.org
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
3 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Executive Summary
February 2009 The Sonoma County Economic Development Board is pleased to present the 2009 Food Processing Industry Report. The survey upon which this report is based provides insight into local business activity, employment needs, job opportunities and general industry well‐being. The increased demand for organic and natural products has bolstered the food processing industry in Sonoma County, helping it to become a key regional industry. As it has grown, the relative health of the food processing industry has become an increasingly important factor in Sonoma County’s economy. While evolving into a surprisingly strong industry, changes in the local economic environment provide further opportunities for continued growth. Analysis of emerging trends and changes is included herein. The EDB conducted a survey for local food processors in order to identify issues and opportunities within the food processing industry. This report, an update of the 2002 report, presents the survey’s results and findings. Key Findings • 75% reported that the largest major industry trend was the continued increase in demand
for organic products. • 80% of respondents felt that their company was growing; 67% felt that their company’s
market share was increasing. • 70% of respondents said they plan on hiring within the next 12 months. However, 75%
indicated that they experienced difficulty in finding skilled labor. The EDB encourages interested readers to delve into these issues by contacting the agencies or organizations listed throughout this report or by visiting the EDB’s website, www.SonomaEDB.org. Ben Stone, Executive Director
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
4 │ www.sonomaedb.org
The Sonoma County Economic Development Board prepared its first report concerning the Sonoma County food processing industry in the spring of 2002. The trends that were present during 2002 can help provide a basis from which to judge the current trends and give context for the general direction of the industry. Many trends have stayed relatively stable since the last report. However, there are a few key differences that have developed since then:
• In 2002, only 48% of respondents indicated that the cost of doing business in Sonoma County was the biggest challenge to operating successfully — less than the cost of upgrading and purchasing new equipment. In 2008, 84% said the cost of doing business here was, making it by far the biggest challenge facing businesses, outweighing equipment challenges by nearly 33%.
• In 2002, 60% of respondents indicated that the increased demand for organic and natural products was a large trend. In 2008, that number rises to 74%. Similarly, only 47% of businesses carried organic products in their product lines in 2002, but in 2008, 62% of businesses carry organic products.
• In 2002, 79% of respondents reported that Sonoma County had a high or medium potential for the (then) current status and future growth of the food processing industry. In 2008, only 57% of respondents reported that Sonoma County had a high or medium potential for the current or future strength of the food processing industry.
As a whole, the trends facing the Sonoma County food processing industry are encouraging. While concerns such as the cost of doing business in Sonoma County, the difficulty of finding skilled labor for hire and the lower expectations for Sonoma County’s food processing potential, growth remains strong. A healthy number of businesses are expanding and hiring new employees. The continued growth of the organic and natural products provides an avenue that companies can utilize in order to keep business strong.
Comparison of Trends: 2002 and 2008
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
5 │ www.sonomaedb.org
In addition to the trends described on the previous page, there has been recent growth within the past year that was not present in 2002. These trends include the rise of sweets processors and retailers, artisan bakeries and the high‐quality olive oils.
Sweets
A growing number of sweet products processors and retailers have sprung in Sonoma County. Producers include Rohnert Park‐based Sonoma Toffee Works, Bert’s Desserts and Divine Delights in Petaluma, the Healdsburg Toffee Company and retailer Powell’s Sweet Shoppe in Petaluma and Windsor.
Many of the processors, such as Divine Delights and the Healdsburg Toffee Company, began as small family bakeries. The original Powell’s Sweet Shoppe in Windsor has begun to expand through locally controlled franchises throughout the Bay Area.
This investment in fine sweets may benefit the local economy: nationwide, gourmet snack sales rose 31% and candy rose 85% from 2005 to 2007, according to a 2008 specialty‐food industry report. In addition, Packaged Facts, a food and beverage market research firm, predicts that upscale chocolate sales will outperform the entire chocolate industry by five times by 2012.1
Goat Milk Sweets
In addition, Sonoma goat milk‐based sweets may gain a greater hold in 2009. Laloo’s gourmet milk ice cream company, founded in 2004, and Redwood Hill Farms, a family farm since 1968, process and distribute goat milk products.
The former, which promotes its low‐fat, low‐cal, low‐lactose, gluten‐free, hormone‐free products, will release goat milk chocolate bars and vanilla ice cream sandwiches in March. Redwood Hill Farms, the first Certified Humane Goat Dairy in the U.S., began distribution of quarts of goat milk in late 2008, and plans to add pineapple orange mango goat milk kefir to its line in spring 2009.2 1“Edible, Affordable Indulgences for 2009, ” Wall Street Journal, 17 January 2009
2“Edible, Affordable Indulgences for 2009, ” Wall Street Journal, 17 January 2009; www.redwoodhill.com and www.goatmilkicecream.com.
New Trends: 2008-2009
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
6 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Artisan Bakeries
Also expanding throughout Sonoma County and the North Bay are artisan bakeries. Sonoma County has a wealth of bakeries located throughout the region, which offer a variety of hand‐crafted, delicious and sometimes imaginative offerings. By location, a representative sample includes: Raymond’s Bakery in Cazadero; Wild Flour Bread in Freestone; Nightingale Bakery in Forestville; Costeaux French Bakery, Preston of Dry Creek and Downtown Bakery and Creamery in Healdsburg; Full Circle Bakery in Penngrove; Della Fattoria Bakery in Petaluma; Bennett Valley Bread and Pastry in Santa Rosa; Village Bakery in Sebastopol and Santa Rosa; Twofish Baking Company in Sea Ranch; and Artisan Bakers and Basque Boulangerie in Sonoma.
The bakeries have been around for various years. Some establishments, like the Costeaux French Bakery, are mature in age; others, like the Downtown Bakery and Creamery, are expanding; and the Nightingale Bakery may be the area’s newest offering, having opened in late 2008. But they all offer great loaves. For example, at Wild Flour Bread both local and out‐of‐town visitors come to enjoy fougasse, seeded french bread and sticky bun breads. At Della Fattoria one can buy anything from a baguette to Meyer lemon rosemary boule. 1
Olive Oils
Another potential area for growth in Sonoma County is olive oil. The county has an estimated 150 small‐scale olive oil producers, more than any other county in the state. While 99 percent of olive oil consumed in the United States originates abroad, the remaining percent is from California.2 Although area olive trees were originally planted in the early 1990s, the market has steadily grown. Sonoma’s olive presses include operations in Dry Creek, Glen Ellen, Hopland and Sonoma. While the cost of processing local oils is very high, the future may be in high quality artisan oils and innovative combinations. The long‐term outlook may depend on the cost of production, branding success and a strategies of local growers and harvesters.
Overall, prospects for the local food processing industry look promising. Niche marketing and an emphasis on high‐quality, specialty items that tap into new markets will help local businesses to prosper if costs of production and labor are kept reasonable.
1Of much help to this summary was “Baker’s Delight,” The Press Democrat. Food and Wine D1, D7. October 29, 2008.
2“Harvest of Hope,” The Press Democrat. A1, A9. 7 November 2008.
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
7 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Key Opportunities
• Job Creation — As the local food processing industry expands, there will be an increase in
the demand for workers, both skilled and unskilled. The Economic Development Board
could partner with local chambers of commerce, schools, job training agencies and others
to help the food processing industry meet the increased need for labor. The recent decline
in real estate prices may also have a positive impact on job creation, as the lower cost of
housing in Sonoma County may encourage potential employees to relocate to the region.
The Economic Development Board could partner with the Workforce Investment Board in
order to reach out to those individuals who are considering relocating to Sonoma for work.
• Innovation — Local food processors have relied on specialization in order to compete in a
consolidating market. In order to help the industry as a whole, a “Best Practices Guide”
could be assembled by an industry team that would highlight ways that struggling
businesses could innovate their operations successfully by documenting successful local
business practices. Successful businesses willing to share their methods of innovation can
gain recognition for their success through such a guide. Also, the creation of an annual
recognition event for the industry could help promote further innovation.
• Growth of Sector — Processors can be surveyed to determine what information might be
useful to them in order to operate effectively as changes occur over the next 10 years. This
information can be made available to both existing and start‐up businesses.
• Exhibitions — Food processors could cooperatively display their goods to the public.
Farmer’s markets could provide an opportunity to show the public available organic and
natural products, to explain their benefits, and to promote the purchase of locally
produced commodities.
• Partnerships — New partnerships created between growers and producers could prove
beneficial for both parties. Such partnerships could strengthen the ties between
processors and growers, resulting in an alliance that would help streamline both the
agriculture and processing industries. Organizations such as the Sonoma County Vintners
and Growers, the California Certified Organic Farmers, the Sonoma County Fair and Farm
Trails could prove to be useful partnerships.
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
8 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Survey Results and Summary
Pastry and baked products, dairy based products, poultry products and fruit‐based products together accounted for 71% of respondents’ operations. Of the firms that moved to Sonoma County, location was by far the biggest factor. Nearly 88% of respondents listed it as a major factor for their move. Wholesale is the most utilized form of distribution among food processors, chosen as a major method for 77% of respondents. Local and regional sales were the second most‐utilized form of distribution.
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
100.00%
Location Work Force Raw Products Other
Reason for Relocating to Sonoma County
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%
90.00%
Forms of Distribution Utilized
Operations
Primary Operations of Food Processors
0.00% 5.00% 10.00% 15.00% 20.00% 25.00%
Packa
ging
Frozen F
oodsProd
uce
Meat P
roduc
ts
Confec
tions
/Can
dies/D
esse
rts
Grain M
ill Prod
uctsMark
eting
Vegeta
ble-B
ased
Prod
ucts
Teas/C
offeeDist
ributi
ngBev
erage
s
Fruit-Bas
ed Prod
ucts
Other
Poultry
Prod
ucts
Dairy B
ased
Produc
ts
Pastry
/Bak
ed P
roduc
ts
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
9 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Respondents reported that local and regional sales were the primary level of operations, with 74% operating at this level. None of the respondents operated at an international level. 33% of executives reported expanding their operations during the last year, while 31% intend to expand their operations in the coming year. Expansion was generally undergone in order to meet increased demand. For those who did or plan on expanding, more than 64% plan to expand within Sonoma County. In addition to this, 57% of respondents plan to expand outside of Sonoma County, although none plan to expand outside of California.
Local Regional74%
National26%
International0%
Primary Level of Operations
Yes31%
No64%
Not Applicable
5%Expansion Next Year
52.00%
54.00%
56.00%
58.00%
60.00%
62.00%
64.00%
66.00%
Sonoma County Outside Sonoma County
Location of ExpansionsYes33%
No64%
N/A3%
Expansion Last Year
International
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
10 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Consumers qualified as 76% of respondents’ primary customers, while businesses qualified as 57%. None of the respondents sold to the government. Plant automation was not utilized by 45% of respondents. Of those who did use automation in their operation, 40% automated their production sections, while 30% automated their packaging operations. Regarding manufacturing issues, 53% of respondents reported input costs such as energy and labor as major issues. Food safety and sourcing and materials were also of importance.
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%
90.00%
Consumers Businesses Government Other
Primary Customers
0%5%
10%15%
20%25%30%35%
40%45%50%
Plant Automation
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
Important Manufacturing Issues
0
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
11 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Employment
Food processors taking part in the survey employ nearly 1,800 individuals in Sonoma County. According to these estimates, the mean number of individuals employed per business is just under 46 people. The median number of individuals employed is roughly 20 people per business. Nearly 30% of respondents employ individuals outside of Sonoma County, with the total number of individuals employed reaching nearly 1,300 people. Physical ability is the number one skill required by food processors, followed by customer service skills and computer skills. Nearly all skills were required by half of food processors.
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
1 to 20 21 to 50 51 to 100 100 to 200 200 or more
Size of Sonoma County Operation (Individuals Employed)
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%
90.00%
Skills Required
Yes29%
No71%
Employing Outside of Sonoma County
(By Number of Individuals Employed)
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
12 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Very Difficult5% Difficult
10%
Somewhat Difficult35%
Not Really a Problem
50%
Difficulty in Finding Unskilled Labor
Skilled Employees
49%
Unskilled Employees
51%
Percentage of Skilled Employees
Difficulty in Finding Skilled Employees
Somewhat Difficult49%
Not Really a Problem13%
Very Difficult13%
Difficult25%
Nearly 88% of the respondents indicated that they experienced at least some difficulty in finding skilled labor. The biggest challenge in hiring skilled labor was that employers couldn’t afford to pay enough to meet the cost of living in Sonoma County. Half of respondents indicated that they experienced difficulty in finding unskilled labor. The biggest challenge to finding unskilled labor was verifying the legal status of immigrants and language barriers. The proportion of skilled and unskilled labor is nearly split in half, with unskilled employees making up a slight majority of 51%. Three quarters of employees have either a basic or high school education or a GED. Few employees have some college education or more.
Employee Education Level
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
High School/ GED
Basic Education
Some College‐Level CoursesOther
College Degree
Graduate Professional Degree
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
13 │ www.sonomaedb.org
70% of respondents said they plan on hiring during the next year. More than 90% of respondents indicated that they plan on hiring fewer than 15 employees. Referrals registered as the most utilized means of obtaining entry‐level employees, followed by walk‐ins and the Internet. The largest obstacle to job placement by far was the cost of living in Sonoma County. Wage requirements were understandably another large concern as well as the lack of skills or expertise.
Yes70%
No30%
Planned Hiring Next Year
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%
Means of Obtaining Entry‐Level Employees
0.00%10.00%20.00%30.00%40.00%50.00%60.00%70.00%80.00%
Obstacles to Job Placement
Number of Employees to be Hired
Greater than 157%
Between 5‐1530%
Fewer than 563%
Fewer than 5
Between 5‐15
Greater than 15
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
14 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Business Environment
Growing67%
Stable33%
Shrinking0%
Market Share
Less than 5%63%
5% to 10%29%
10% to 25%8%
Greater than 25%
0%
Percentage Gross Revenue Spent on R&D
Four out of five respondents believe that their business is growing or expanding. Only 15% believe that their business is reaching maturity. Two‐thirds of respondents reported that their market share was growing, while none reported that their market share was shrinking.
Respondents as a whole spent very little on research and development, with a majority of businesses spending less than 5% of their gross revenue on it.
“Quality of product” registered as the largest factor of demand, followed by brand recognition and consumer loyalty.
Factors of Demand
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
Quality of Product
Brand Recognition
Customer Loyalty
Dietary/Health Benefits
Products Grown/Processed Location Ot
her
Company Life Cycle
Growing or Expanding
80%
Maturing or Maximum Capacity15%
Beginning or Emerging
5%
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
15 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Increased demand for organic products is by far the largest trend facing the food processing industry. Artisanal products are also a growing trend, as well as consolidation that fosters corporate competition.
Executives reported that 57% believe Sonoma County has a high or medium potential for the current and future food processing industry.
The largest challenge to operating successfully is the cost of doing business in Sonoma County. Other challenges include transportation, and the cost of upgrading and investing in new equipment.
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%
90.00%
Challenges to Operating Succesfully
High13%
Medium44%
Low25%
Poor18%
Sonoma County's Potential
Trends in the Industry
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
Mor
e O
rgan
ic P
rodu
ct D
eman
d
Arti
sina
l Pro
duct
s
Cor
pora
te C
ompe
titio
n
Co-
Pac
king
Just
-In-T
ime
Ord
erin
g R
etai
ler U
se
Inte
rnet
Sal
es
Per
isha
ble
Food
Spe
cial
ties
Rea
dy to
Eat
Mea
ls T
rend
Func
tiona
l Foo
ds
Eth
nic
Food
Spe
cial
ties
Oth
er
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
16 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Respondents who operated in broader national markets faced challenges in every market. These markets spanned the entire United States.
Overseas competition is a challenge to certain food processors. The competition is concentrated in Asia, which is the only continent reported to threaten the local industry.
The largest transportation challenge facing food processors are trucking and freight. These accounted for nearly three‐quarters of the transportation challenges facing respondents, alongside rail and air.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Challenging Markets
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
Asia Africa Europe Oceania South America
Location of Overseas Competition
Air9%
Truck or Freight73%
Rail18%
Transportation Challenges
0 0 0 0
0
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
17 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Across the board, respondents expect business trends to increase.
The largest increases are expected to be seen in revenues and customer base, with 74% and 83% of respondents expecting an increase respectively.
Employment, equipment needs and product lines are all expected to increase at more conservative rates.
Facility size is the most stable trend. However, even this area is expected to increase moderately.
In addition to a majority of respondents foreseeing increases in all of these areas, very few respondents foresee a decrease in any of these areas.
Stability seems to be the second most likely trend followed lastly by decreases.
Tax incentives or reductions were selected as the most helpful forms of government assistance, with 78% of respondents indicating that these would help their businesses.
Licensing and permits were the next most helpful forms of government assistance in the eyes of respondents, while financial assistance was rated as the third most helpful.
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%
90.00%
Government Assistance
0.00%10.00%20.00%30.00%40.00%50.00%60.00%70.00%80.00%90.00%
Predicted Business Trends
Increase Stable Decrease
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
18 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Industry Specifics
62% of businesses reported that they carry certified organic products in their product line. Another 67% reported that they carry natural products.
A majority of businesses indicated that less than 25% of their products are organic, while a majority of businesses indicated that over 75% of their products are natural. Yes
62%
No38%
Certified Organic Products
Yes67%
No31%
Not Applicable
2%Natural Products Line
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
Less than 25%
25% to 50% 50% to 75% over 75%
Percentage of Organic Products
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
Less than 25%
25% to 50% 50% to 75% Over 75%
Percentage of Natural Products
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
19 │ www.sonomaedb.org
A recycling program is utilized by 85% of businesses participating in the survey. Businesses with an environmental purchasing policy account for 40% of total business. Only 15% of respondents indicated that they have a Green Business Certification. Bio‐security, a relatively large concern at the national level, is a concern for 30% of respondents. The economic effects of enhanced environmental sustainability were disputed, with slightly more respondents saying that it would reduce rather than increase profitability. About 40% of respondents have received an energy or water assessment within the past five years.
0.00%
50.00%
100.00%
Yes No
Businesses with an Environmental Purchasing
Policy
Yes15%
No85%
Businesses with a Green Business Certification
Yes30%
No70%
Is Bio‐Security a Concern
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
Increased Profitability
No Change Reduced Profitability
Effects of Enhanced Environmental Sustainability
0%
50%
100%
Yes No
Energy or Water Assesment Within Last 5 years
Yes85%
No15%
Businesses with a Recycling Program
? Energy or Water Assessment
within Last 5 years
2009 Food Processing Industry Report
20 │ www.sonomaedb.org
Methodology
142 surveys were distributed to food processors in Sonoma County in 2008. 43 surveys were completed, yielding a response rate of 30%. The responses were collected into a database, which provided a framework for this analysis. This report represents a snapshot of the local food processing industry. The trends discussed in this report do not exhaust the entire list of concerns facing all food processors. Certainly the trends discussed are major and deserve recognition on merit of their acknowledgement by most of the respondents surveyed. However, there exist concerns not mentioned that deserve recognition, as they greatly affect individuals within the industry. By improving communication, these issues can be recognized and addressed.
Acknowledgements
The 2009 Food Processing Report would not have been possible without the contributions of many companies, organizations and individuals. First and foremost, the local food processors that participated in the survey deserve recognition. Their responses provided the framework for this report. Mike Simanek, a summer intern for the Economic Development Board, created the report. He combined analysis of survey results with additional research to write the report. His work was outstanding and he displayed diligence and dedication in the process of writing it. The staff at the Economic Development Board contributed a significant amount of secretarial work. Staff researched the industry, created a comprehensive and relevant survey for local businesses and compiled the data for analysis. Special thanks to Colette Thomas for coordinating survey distribution and garnering its high response rate, and to Pam Gibson and K. Min Pease for editorial duties.