some observations on the use of the 'vibroseis' method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a...

32
/9a/m.5- COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA DEPARTMENT OF NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT BUREAU OF MINERAL RESOURCES GEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS 012233 SOME OBSERVATIONS ON THE USE OF THE -VIBRCSEIS - METHOD F J MOSS ECONOMIC COMMISSION FOR ASIA AND THE FAR EAST COMMITTEE ON INDUSTRY AND NATURAL RESOURCES Symposium on the Development of Petroleum Resources of Asia and the Far East Third Session: 10th-20th November 1965 TOKYO, JAPAN

Upload: others

Post on 23-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

/9a/m.5-

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

DEPARTMENT OF NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT

BUREAU OF MINERAL RESOURCESGEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS

012233

SOME OBSERVATIONS ON THE USE OFTHE -VIBRCSEIS - METHOD

F J MOSS

ECONOMIC COMMISSION FOR ASIA AND THE FAR EASTCOMMITTEE ON INDUSTRY AND NATURAL RESOURCES

Symposium on the Development of Petroleum Resources of Asia and the Far East

Third Session: 10th-20th November 1965

TOKYO, JAPAN

Page 2: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

SOME OBSERVATIONS ON THE USE OF ME "VIBROSEIS" *METHOD

by

F. J. Moss

* Trademark of Continental Oil Co.

Page 3: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

SUMMARY

INTRODUCTION

THE "VIBROSEIS" MErHOD

Principles of the method

Field techniques

Variable parameters

CONTENTS

Comparison of various characteristics of "Vibroseis"

and shot-hole methods.

TEST AREAS AND ASSOCIATED PROBLEMS

EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE

RESULTS

-Built-up-area project

Hawkesbury Sandstone project

Volcanics project

Gambier Limestone project

Sand-cover project

Effect of changing particular parameters

CON,CLUSIONS

COMMENTS

J

Page No.

1

2

2

2

4

6

8

10

11

11

12

13

13

14

15

16

18

Page 4: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

Plate 1.

Plate 2.

Plate 3.

Plate 4.

Plate 5.

Plate 6.

Plate 7.

Plate 8.

ILLUSTRATIONS "'

"Vibroseis" system.

Sketch map of S.E. Australia - location of "Vibroseis" projects.

Section - Built-up-area project.

Comparison sections ~Hawkesbury Sandstone project.

Comparison sections - Volcanics projecto

Comparison sections - Gambier Limestone.Project.

Comparison sections - Sand-cover project.

Parameter comparisons.

i

Page 5: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

SUMMARY

The Commonwealth of Australia, Bureau of Mineral Resources

employed a contractor from May to October 1964 to demonstrate the

effectiveness of the "Vibroseis" method of seismic exploration in areas

4

where conventional shot—hole methods were impractical or where they had

previously experienced difficulties in obtaining good quality re lections.,

The test areas chosen were in the Sydney and Otway Basins and

included the built—up area of the City of Maitland; areas of outcrop of

the Hawkesbury Sandstone Formation; areas of volcanics cover; an area

of cavernous Gambier Limestone outcrops; and sand covered areas. ) These

areas have problems mainly of drilling and energy transmission.

The experimental procedure consisted of recording noise tests

and testing by varying"Vibroseis" parameters, one at a time, to 'arrive

at the best recording technique with the facilities available to the

contractor; production tests were done with the best recording technique

for each area. The parameters of the "Vibroseis" method and some

characteristics which contribute to its flexibility are discussed and

compared with the parameters and some characteristics of shot—hole

methods.4

The method proved successful in the built—up area where

reflections were obtained to 1.1 seconds. It was not always possible

to use the best recording technique found because of restrictions to the

positioning of vibrators and geophones. On Hawkesbury Sandstone outcrops

the method was successful in obtaining fair quality reflection information

to 2 seconds. Fair quality shallow reflections were obtained in the

Page 6: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

volcanias, Gambter Ltmsztone and sand—covered areas, but difficulties

were found in obtaining continuous deep reflections in these area'S.

The tests demonstrated the flexibility of the "Vibrosei6"

method whereby the parameters could be rapidly changed for carrying

out a series of experiments to arrive at "optimum" techniques. Fair

quality reflections were obtained in the test areas, which were

previously designated as poor reflection areas.

Page 7: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

1.

INTRODUCTION

The "Vibroseis" method of seismic exploration, which uses as

an energy source, a signal of relatively long duration with a smciOthly

varying frequency, was described by Crawford, Doty and Lee in "Geophysics"

'Vol XXV, No. 1. The method was introduced into Australia early in 1963

In Vol. 1, Part 2ca of the "Proceedings of the Second SyMposium",

O'Donnell referred to the use of vibrators as new sources of energy in

seismic exploration work. In the section on "Petroleum Exploration

Techniques and Methods" in the "Report of the Second Symposium"

recommendation was made suggesting the use of contractors to stimulate

new advances in the industry and to show the applicability of new methods

for adaptation to areas with unusual terrain and particular seismic

problems.

In accordance with its policies for accelerated oil search,

the Commonwealth of Australia Bureau of Mineral Resources employed a

contractor, from May to October 1964, to demonstrate the applicability

of the "Vibroseis" method by conducting experimental surveys in several

areas chosen because of their specific seismic problems. The test areas

selected lie within the Otway and Sydney Basins. The objective of the

surveys was to show if reasonable quality results could be achieved in

the problem areas by making use of the inherent flexibility of the;

"Vibroseis" method. A further objective litaa.to assess the costs of

Published by permission of Director, ThWe -ati of Mineral Resources Geologyand Geophysics.

Page 8: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

2.

"Vibroseis" operations as compared with those of shot hole methods..

THE "VIBROSEIS" METHOD

Principles of 'the method

Plate 1 sholOthe "Vibroseis" system.

The method uses vibrators operating at the surface of the

ground as contolled energy sources, as an alternatWe to explosives in

shot holes. A signal of continuously varying frequencies, called a sweep,

is injected into the ground over a period of 7 seconds by the vibrators,

which are activated by servo—controlled hydraulic rams that follow a

signal transmitted by radio from the recording truck.

The maximum bandwidth of this signal is 10 c/s to 120 c/s.

However, generally, an input with a range of about two octaves is chosen.

The bandwidth is selected to contain frequencies that form the spectrum

of a normal reflection pulse; no energy is wasted by injecting frequencies

which it is known the earth will not efficiently transmit.

The signal picked up by the geophone is recorded on magnetic

tape. By a process of continuous correlation of this magnetic tape

against the recorded input signal, a record similar to a conventional

shot—hole record is obtained, i.e. the final result is the same as if •

all frequencies had been injected into the ground simultaneously.

Field techniques

• The field procedures are extremely flexible l mainly owing. to

the fact that no predetermined drilling programme is required. The

vibrators are extremely mobile but there are limits to their positioning

as they .require relatively flat surfaces for good vibrator—to—ground

Page 9: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

3.

coupling. The recording techniques used depend on desired spatial noise

filtering penetration required, and degree of compositing.

In the standard in—line method, geophones are laid out in groups

at locations along the spreads as in normal shot—hole seismic operations

and vibrators operate at the conventional shot—point positions. In poor

reflection areas where a high effort involving large numbers of geophones

and vibrations is required, this may be tedious. However, in good

reflection areas where a low effort is required, this method gives the

highest production rates.

The transposed method was used more generally in the experi-

mental surveys. With this method the geophones are grouped in two nests,

one at either end of the spread, and the vibrators operate between the

nests at the positions normally occupied by the geophones in shot—hole

methods.'

Both these methods allow the use of large geophone and/or

vibration patterns for cancellation of noise and for the compositing of

large numbers of independent ray paths. However, the transposed method

is more felxible to use and a greater degree of compositing and speed of

operation can be more readily attained by using this method in poor

reflection areas. An additional advantage of this method is that

recordings made on each trace are made at different times from those made

on adjacent traces. This tends to increase the random nature of the

noise between final traces.

Page 10: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

4.

The "Vibroseis" method is particularly well suited to the use of

a "rollalong' common depth point (C.D.P.) method using standard in—line

geophone spreads. Recordings at different offset distances, from the sarrie

subsurface point, are stacked. This increasssthe relative amplitudes of

signal to background noise and also produces cancellation of any multiple,

reflections recorded.

Variable Parameters

The flexibility of the "Vibroseis" method is due mainly to the

ease in which most parameters can be varied. The main parameters are as

follows:

Sweep frequency range Several sweep frequency ranges are

available and a choice is made to suit the particular area and

the problem being investigated.

No. of vibrations (sweeps). The results of numbers of sweeps can

be added because of the relatively uniform duplication of the

enei-from successive transmissions. The time independence of

recordings aids noise cancellation when sweeps are added. The

number of sweeps used is varied normally in steps from 5, 10, 20,

40 to 80 sweeps. The theoretical signal—to—background noise ratio

improves as the square root of the number of sweeps.

Vibrator thrust This can be varied, but the energy from-A-i-

vibrator must not exceed the elastic limits of the surface

formations. A maximum vibrator thrust of 10,000 lb is normally

applied and no damage is caused to surfaces on which the vibrators

operate.

Page 11: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

5.

No. of vibrators The number can be varied since vibrators are

synchronised. Three are normally used on a party with another

vibrator available as a spare. The theoretical signal—to—background

noise ratio is improved proportionally to the number of vibrators

used.

Vibration patterns These may be transposed to occupy the positions

of geophone patterns in shot—hole methods. The length and width of

the patterns and spacing of vibration points within the patterns are

determined from the spatial noise filtering and random noise

cancellation requirements, the objectives of the survey, the number

of vibrato's used, and sweeps required.

No, of geolihcnes^2000 geophones were available on the experimental

party. For the transposed method large numbers of geophons(up to

800) are laid in individual groups.

Geo hone pattern^The characteristics of the patterns are determined

by the same principles that define the vibration patterns.

Offset distance "Vibroseis" work requires the vibrators to be

offset from the nearest geophones since recordings are made without

automatic volume control and with gains set for 100% magnetic tape

modulation on the highest amplitude event recorded; this may be

refracted energy (as in the first breaks), coherent noise, or a

reflection event. If no offset is used the relative amplitudes of

noise interference from the vibrator and later reflection events are

likely to exceed the dynamic range of the recording instruments (aboui

45 db.). A short offset distance is necessary (to avoid refraction

Page 12: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

6.

paths) for obtaining shallow reflection information and a long offset

distance may be necessary to reduce the relative amplitudes of the

refracted or coherent noise energy, which decays with distance from

the source, and the later reflection events. Offset distances of 1,

2, and 3 spread lengths are normally used for systematic continuous

recording.

Electrical filters on playbacks^Normal electrical filtering can be

applied. to the correlated magnetic tapes. Filtering is varied to give

a final record with limited frequency pass band as is done with the

processing of shot—hole recordings. However the correlation process

normally also performs this function.

Automatic volume control (A.V.C.) on playback This is applied to the

correlated magnetic tapes. A.V.C. is varied to give uniform signal

level as with playbacks from shot —hole recordings.

Comparison of various characteristics of "Vibroseis" and shot—hole methods

The following table compares these two seismic exploration

methods.

Page 13: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

7.

"Vibroseis",method

Sweep frequency range

Sweep

No0 of sweeps

Vibration patterns

No, of geophones ma4800 fortransposed recording

Geophone pattern

Amplifier record filters - set' at limitsof the sweep frequency range.

Cross correlation - sharp cut offfiltering dependent on sweep frequencyrange

Offset distance - min.geophone-to-vibrator offset is dictated byinstrument limitations and objectives.

Electrical playback filters - as forrecord filters.

A.V.C. on playback

Easy transposition of vibrationpoints and geophones

Rapid variation of vibration point andgeophone arrays between experiments.

Weathering information not generallyavailable.

No damage to ground surfaces

C.F. Explosion

No0 of shots and/or size of charge

Shot-hole patterns

Depth of shot

No0 of geophones max.approx.98 per trace

As for "Vibroseis" in-line recording

Amplifier record filters - set as wide aspossible at limits of seismic pulsespectrum

A.V.C. and/or programmed gain on record.

Offset distance - no limit for geophone -to-shot offsets but not normally required.

Electrical playback filters narrower limitsthan for recording.

A.V.C. - rate dependent on reflectionresolution.

Difficult transposition of shots andgeophones.

Slow variation of arrays betweenexperiments

Weathering information generally available

Damage to surfaces with drilling and shots

Shot-hole Method

Page 14: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

8.

The "Vibroseis" method has clear advantages by:

i. l'imi ting the sweep frequency range to contain frequend~s-, which

contribute to reflection resolution.

-.2,. Jl4sing the cross-correlation process to provide a sharp cut-off filter

3. ..l#3ing the correlation process to discriminate against random noise.

4. the ability to employ high multiplicity of vibration points

and geophones for relatively low cost.

The "Vibroseis" method has some disadvantages by:

1. having no counterpart to varying depth of shot

2. requiring the use of an offset distance to record the signal

within the dynamic range of the "Vibroseis" system (45 d.b.);

in shot-hole methods A.V.C. or programmed gain on record is used

for this purpose. For the "Vibroseis" recordings without A.V.C.

it is necessary to ensure that the highest amplitude Signal does

not saturate the tape and cause distortion since this would

affect other signals that it overlaps in the correlation:process.

TEST AREAS & ASSOCIATED PROBLEMS

The project areas are shown in Plate 2. The areas, with particular

problems sele~ted to test the flexibility of the "Vibroseis" method, were as

follows:

Built-up-area project. Fair quality seismic information had 'been

recorded, using shot-hole methods on the east and west outskitts of

the city of Maitland. It was considered that a test of "Vibroseis"

recordings through this built-up area would illustrate the applicability

Page 15: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

9.

of the method in an area where shot—hole methods could not be ilsed.

#Hawkesbury Sandstone project.^The hard, somewhat quartzitic,

Triassic Hawkesbury Sandstone, which covers large areaiof the Sydney

Basin, transmits seismic energy poorly.

A

Drilling is difficult and expensive. Access is poor and seismic

traverse generally follow roads that run along the rugged Hawkesbury

Sandstone 'ridges. Power lines also follow these roads and give

troublesome 50 c/s. interference. The weathering on the highly eroded

surface is extremely variable.

Volcanics project.^Extensive volcanic activity during the Quiternary

period partly covered the eastern part of the Otway Basin with'basalt,

tuff, and other volcanic residue. This cover, which varies not only

in its composition but also in its thickness and depth, consti .iutes

an energy transmission problem for seismic exploration. Otherproblems

associated with the voicanics are an erratic weathering tone; probable

variations' in velocity distribution in the section due tO basalt layers;

general low average velocities in the section, which result in large

dynamic corrections and limits the lengths of geophone and source

patterns that can be used; and in some places hard drilling, Which

often makes Shot—hole drilling difficult.

Gambier Limestone project. A large part of the western part Of the

Otway Basin is covered by the cavernous Tertiary Gambier Limestone,

which is up to 500 ft thick in some areas. This limestone constitutes

Page 16: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

1 0.

an energy transmission problem as well as having associated drilling

problems with circulation losses, and often slow drilling rates due

to hard flintstone bands in the formation.

Sand-cover project Other areas in the western part of the 0tWay

Basin are covered by a sand sheet or sand dunes. These areas Of

loose sand' are troublesome for shot-hole seismic work because of

absorption of the seismic energy and difficult drilling.

EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE

The selection of areas in which to test the applicability of the

method was based on knowledge of surface geology, information from wells

drilled, and previous geophysical surveys including aeromagnetic, gravity,

and seismic. The results of previous seismic experimental work wee

studied.

Noise tests were initially recorded as a guide to further experi-

mentation. These were recorded using an in-line method with ohe

-, -- vihrator, a 10 - 120 c/s sweep and a normal recording distance out to-

approx. 4000 ft with geophonesat 20t 5 intervals. The number Of sweeps

was increased with distance from the source. The results were

illustrated in graphs of Time v Distance. Amplitude v Wave NuMber

and Frequency v Wave Number.

InillartEmling parameters were selected from previous knowledge of

recording conditions and from the interpretation of the noise 'tests

for choosing offset distance, spatial filtering requirements, and sweep

spectrum.

Page 17: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

1 1,

ILTerimentation proceeded with recordings made generally over several

spreads with the initial technique selected. Parameters Were then

changed.one at a time in order to assess the effectiveness of the-^-^-^-

changes. Record^

were generally repeated using the different

techniques in order to assess revised techniques over more than one

spread, The technique found to be best in a particular area was in

most cases tried in another area with a similar problem. Up to :- six

weeks was spent on each problem.

RESULTS

Parts only of some cross-sections recorded along the .experimental

traverses are included as illustrations (Plates 3-7) of the results of the

"Vibroseis" tests. The recording techniques are noted in the plates.

Built -up -ArEl_moi2It

• After initial testing using standard in-line recording with

•vibrator• force-levels at 25% maximum, a high-effort transposed-recording

technique was adopted for the test. Vibrators with maximum force-level

operated on -the bitumen roadways" and geophones were laid in nests as

far from the roadways and power lines as possible in order to. reduce

extraneous noise due to traffic and 50 c/s interference. Traffic Was very

heavy.

• A. high-amplitude l high velocity, near surface refractionwave

masked the reflections down to 005 second and limited the recording level

for later reflection events, which are evident in Plate 3 at times of approx.

0.7 and 1.1 seconds.

Page 18: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

12.

\0

The me~hod has been demonstrated to operate successfully in a

highly populated, built-up area without interfering with traffic. However,

it may not be possible to attain an optimum recording technique in all

built-up areas owing mainly to limitations on the offset distance and

pat terri': lengths of vibrations and geophones that can be used.

Hawkesbury Sands tone pro,i ec t

The results of a noise test indicated a high-velocity, high

amplitude, first-break interference event. Good quality shailow

reflections down to 1.0 second were obtained using 600-feet-iong vibrator

and geophone patterns with a minimum one-spread offset and a 10-40 cc/s

sweep. Deeper reflections do,m to 2 seconds were obtained, wi th r~sul ting

deterioration of the quality of the shallow information, by increa~ing

the pattern lengths to 1000 ft so that spatial filtering effects r~duced

the amplitudes of the first-break event relative to the reflectiontevents.

It was necessary to increase the number of sweeps and:'to use a: minimum two

spread offset. Comparisons with these recording techniques are shbwn in

Plate 4.

The use of a 10-40 cis sweep in "Vibroseis" recordings. on

Hawkesbury Sandstone cover is considered to be a major factor in the

attainment of good quality reflections. I

It eliminates the- generation. of

high frequency noise and the correlation process eliminates 50 cis high­

line pick-up. The test indicates that "Vibroseis" recording techniques

can be successfully applied on the hard Hawkesbury Sandstone Formation.

Page 19: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

1 3.

Volcanics Project

Transposed recordings were made along the complete traverses and

parts of the traverses were re—recorded using in—line and C.D,P. methods.

Experimentation showed that the technique yielding the best result 6 varied

along the traverse; this was probably due to extreme variations in the

surface and subsurface conditions. Fair quality reflections were 4

recorded over most of the traverse using transposed methods. Thiswas

-considered to be the result of effective compositing over 12,001Dspparate

ray paths for each trace. A comparison of ten—fold C.D.P. recording and

transposed recording is shown in Plate 5. The slower Ca.P. recording,

one mile per day compared with Imost two miles per day for transposed

recording, was successful in improving the reflection quality. The

improvement wais probably due to the vertical stacking.

Gambier Limestone project

The noise tests indicated high—amplitude interference

.events - with velocities of 2500, 3300, and 7200 ft/ s. Fair quality

reflection information was recorded at 0.8 to 1.0 second on the initial

experimental Work with a low—effort transposed method; no deep

reflections were obtained and shallower poor quality events were obscured

by the noise interference. After considerable experimentation, a •

Page 20: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

1 4.

transposed recording technique was developed using a minimum three—

spread offset, 20 sweer per trace, and a diamond shaped geophone

pattern. The effective pattern length of vibrator and geophcine

patterns was 200 ft.^All efforts made with transposed techniques.

were unsuccessful in substantially reducing the amplitude of the

noise interference; however, some success was achieved with ten-

fold C.D.P. recording as shown in Plate 6. The C.D.P. section

shows better continuity than the transposed section but the quality

of deeper reflection events was not improved, this was probably

due to the reduction of ray paths composited with the particular

C.D.P. technique used.

It would appear that the quality of "Vibroseis" recordina

is limited in this area by the high—amplitude interference waves. This

noise problem would probably be less acute for shot—hole methods aiere

the charges can be placed below the weathering layer.

Sand—cover project

The section shown for Traverse 1 in Plate 7 was recorded in an

area of fair quality reflections off the sand cover. Apart from a noise

Page 21: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

• test, only limited experimenta.tion vias carried out along Traverse 2 on the ~.

sand cover to ,the north of Traverse 10 The lengths of geophone an~ ,

~ ~

vibrator patterns represented a compromise for obtaining both shallow and .

deep reflectio'ns down to about 2 secpnds.

The 'test showed that fair quality reflection information: could

be readily obtained on the sand cover using "Vibroseis" techniques'by

increasing the number of sweeps and the offset distance (Plate' 7).'

Effect of changing particular parameters

Records shown in Plate 8 have been selected to demonstrate the

effects of changing particular recording parameters.

The transposed in-line compartson shows two recordings made on

the same profile in approximately the same recording time. The tr~nsposed

recording .has a higher signal-to-background-noise ratio maintY because of

increase -in 'the number of ray paths composi-ted per trace.

The sweep frequency comparison indicates that the 10-40 ~/s : .

sweep is superior to the 20-5Q cis sweep for recording on Hawkesbury

Sandstone. Reflection events are discernible to 2.5 seconds on the 10-40

cis sweep record compared with 0 .. 9 second on the 20-57 cis sweep record.

The number of sweeps comparison shows that although shaliow '

reflections can be recorded to 0.7 second with 5 sweeps per trace, i effective

" penetration to 2.5 seconds can be obtained with 10 sweeps per trace.

The offset comparison show high-amplitude good quality shallo'w

events to 0.8 second and poor quality events deeper, with a one-spread

Page 22: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

16.

offset. The shallow events deteriorate, whereas the deeper events are

enhanced using the three-spread offset.

The pattern length comparison illustrates the use of 400-,ft ..7long

vibrator and geophone patterns to suppress the high-amplitude first break

arrivals. The recording tape was 100% modulated on these arrivals when

200-ft-long patterns were used and the later poorer quality reflection

events, are of too low level to be clearly seen.

CONCLUSIONS

The flexibility of the "Vibrosies" method was illustrated by the

recording of fair quality seismic information in previously designated

poor pr no-reflection areas with unusual terrain.

Results were obtained in the built-up area with no resul'ting

damage to roadways, water mains, houses, etc. However, the use of an

optimum recording technique was not always possible owing to limitations

imposed by the positions of houses, road intersections, water main,

railway lines, etc.

The test on the Hawkesbury Sandstone indicated that the 6Vibroseis"

method was Capable of solving this areals problems; this was manly due to

the selection of a particular controlled sweep. The best methods

obtaining shallow and deep reflections differed.

The best recording technique was found to vary along the'Volcanics

traverses. Variations of technique were readily accomplished by "Vibroseis"

methods since no predetermined extensive drilling programme was required.

Page 23: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

17.

C.D.P. recording techniques were used to improve the results in areas where

poor quality results were obtained using transposed techniques; the

"Vibroseis" is very adaptable to the use of C.D.P. methods. The high

multiplicity of ray paths per trace inherent with "Vibroseis" recording

techniques probably contributed largely to the success of the methods in

this area.

High—energy noise, generated in the surface layers in the

, Gambier. LimPstnne area by the "Vibroseis" methodT limited the effeCtive-

ness of the method for obtaining good quality deep reflections. This

noise was attenuated by C.D.P. recording, which improved the quality of

the seismic data.

Penetration for recording deep reflections was achieved in

the sand—cover area. However, a compromise of pattern length and Offset

distance was necessary for recording shallow and deep reflections.

The quality of results was generally not adversely affecled by

the assumption of uniform weathering layer thicknesses and velocities in

the problem areas. This was probably due to the averaging of the effects

of weathering Variations by ground mixing and compositing. Some

inconvenience was experienced in the delay necessary for 'correlation of

the field,:ecordings whereby the results of the experimental work could

not be examined until some hours later; for production recording these

delays are not important.

Page 24: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

18.

COMMENTS

The ,"Vibroseis" method, by virtue of its flexibility for

rapidly carrying out a range of experiments, is able to approach an

"optimum" technique much more quickly than shot-hole methods. Shoe-

hole methods, although they may employ different parameters from tflose

of the "Vibroseis" method, are able to take advantage of experience

gained when following a "Vibroseis" survey and may thus produce better

records than a survey preceding the "Vibroseis". This has, in fact,

proved to be the case in a current survey covering the Volcanics arid

Gambier Limestone areas mentioned above.

Since the "Vibroseis" test survey, further "Vibroseis" wrirk

has been carried out on Hawkesbury Sandstone in a built-up area on the

outskirts of Sydney. Techniques adopted for the built-up area and'

Hawkesbury Sandstone projects in the test survey were combined for'

this survey. Other surveys have been carried out in the Gippsland

Basin where C.D.P. methods were used to tackle a problem of multiple

reflectionsl and in the Officer Basin where cartage of explosives,

drilling water, etc. are problems, associated with the remoteness of

the area.

Page 25: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

'., I '

" ",

lk===================== Enor;y

Orit,,,.1 , ... 'I "al

Mlcrotrack Recorder

r-__ ~Fi'ld Tape Recorde,

. .. o ..... :!! . ~

Aec.r ••• •••• , Sittl.1

-----------------,

I __ ..J

"VIBROSEIS" SYSTEM

PLATE

VIBRATOR UNIT

RECORDING UNIT

PLAYBACK CENTRE

----j I

8eOPHYSlCAL M'NCH. IUtl(AU 0' IIINltlAL .'IOUIIICIS, eEOLOgy '''D8[0''"YlI(1 G85/3-43

Page 26: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

- ... v I

PLATE 2

3Z000'- \ SOUTH AUSTRALIA NEW SOUTH

ACT''>

36000"_~:;";~-4:--t-----I"~' ----cOo ::>O""'""""'O"'"""'=-;-I_~::.!..i......,· '"i~:":'--

40000'-----t--:M;;-;-;I~-;E;-;S;--------\;-t 200 0 200 .

" '"

SKETCH MAP OF SE AUSTRALIA LOCATION OF VIBROSEIS PROJECTS

Page 27: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

I I

• ! I i I

IB77 1878 1879 1880

I:~i 1111111111 Iii 111111111

i:~ 'IIII~ '~ ~'"-I' '" ~ ~1111~~:' 1111. ~ ~ 'l~

~f.~~~, Il:~' ~ ~;~II!I 1I:i~lIlim

. ~~: ~"

~t1\!I! ttl

~! m@~:~l:, [lUI i;i

/11

;:""~r>if! ~llil :I~;!illi Iii

[1I1:!11

f~ !I:~jm! ,;i!i~ 111m :rm:

HORIZONTAL SCALE

o 1320 2640 3960 FEET ~'----~'----~I----~I

1881 1882 '1883

~1II1111

~II 11111lI11

~ f)11

i"~

~.~

~Il

illl ~I .H' "" TRANSPOSED 10-40C/S 10 1366-2574 II 132 II

IU'

400 II L, 200 flW (3 60 Geo) (Nominol)

~]1 ttl

~I

'l>.

''1 Ih II! ....

PLAT E 3

1884 E

~o.o n 0 :;0

m :;0 IT1

!II ! III!

m n -i

ill IT1 0

,;...J ~ ,.,..

~O'5 -i =E 0

=E :to iill

m -< -i . ill 3::

iii f~

~ 1'5

IT1

z (J)

m IT1 n

I~

m '0 z

m 0 (J)

ill 2'0 m

,'"

RECORDING METHOD SWEEP FREOuENCY No. OF SWEEPS OFFSET DISTANCE VIBRATOR PATTERN LENGTH GEOPHONE PATTERN

SECTION -BUILT-UP AREA PROJECT

G 438- 22

Page 28: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

1 4 0 7^1 408^14 09 N C 1107^1408 ̂1,1 0 r) N

11 I li^1 1 ' 11' 1 '0 11 1 " I^1 11 111

Ill RP I^'Ill^111111111!^i)^11)^41

i . .i l'::.i )^[1141 I 1. 1^)^1111 r) 11 I it'Ailk! ,, ,,,I,ii , - !.^1 !1}' ' 1,1 ' I^ j}l ' .1111 11111 i'.10'114/ 1111/ 11111 'il]F JP s.^)i

'it

.^" 1^1^.1^1^I i'lrillIli 01 iviOlii'

.i^Ili .

l'' '^',ItC '11 1 1 qii!t").)11,1 ^ti ifl I,

lit^l i^i,i s^.^Til 4 11114} II; ),iii^r ti 11.,1),^I ,^1.1^, )) 1• 0 ; 1 ,01 344 /1 ) .6) 1 ,

p))^, i^i

i^it i

r)1 r/r11)P't '.^jt*'

l' t „ ,^4^It^ A 11) t'- ,-qtcy^)0 4^, t , I 1 ■

-,1-,,AvERsE /^it'll! iiii; Uh I N PI iti !ki II

^‘11^C^)t)'"

ii^y,..,^

I

'^ct^)

( if! ,t2 q^41,- .,^d t 1:^-^1, j..:^I '44 .iirt^PILI ''' i '^kliOr if ';i114:; ',,^.‘,1,q, 4 t) , ot ,p) IiIt^li .^rtioi

I

b^),!irlii,d ,frk '''' !ILI!. '•NI'?:Ij'f1P2ji11111$ if?:''',..) 11), ,..',:k-'1;1•::.:'IL.' 't•' 'A' "s'`: 1',))1'''-'i:

I I I irill 11 II "I rill Ii !ill Ai 1 mird ' n 11111 iiil HI! d ill i i 11

f ' likr■iill:1)) 11 Iiililill

I'd i i I 1 4 1 i '^1 1^1^Lill !)

ili ' 4[11' '111.0 > q)) 0 41

II 1), i k :^111,iiir ,i,iv),;',1^)) ,h; ii 1111 1 t^41, 1 1

^

„)^>,. : ", so ,1"--'.,wit ql q .. 0 1,

^1487 E W 1455^1486^1487 E^.);fi ll^11111111 11 :1111IPtll{1 1 11 111 (11 11 111 111111 1111 1 1; 11(LI 11 1 111 \ill^III 0 • 0

1014V- °Phi1')1

Itil:; ^Illiil)iiill /1),^'! ^ii 11111;11 1, 1) 111,111 1),I1 1i ).111rA^Ott ) tP4iii4 "O''t h ' )

!^14) '.7 1/41

1 :1LI lqi^!'1„ .)i lw t1;)iii g"'',;ili44 1 ii 111 , A I, 11; 1 :=4,:t11!!;1..^1141i 1■ 11,...liii",mqji r)1411*-1.1 1'1111:It' !p) t.kar ') „}„,,........in ,NiA tt^, ,. „„^),),,,r..,,,,,,q :.„,,,ri t i

111 ',,ilii,' 1,1!iiii`,i'il^i'U iiT:i'w1111i1

i! ii•All^t iir4i^lit.,11,Li.it11.1i,! i ,i1,0,4 1

il1 ^.,„,,,, ii,,,,,„p1^'I'Iii!, ,,Iii iiiti t„Ltiii, .fl(iir,4 1),!U^? 111 ^.,,, 1 0^1),^,„ ,„, „^,ri

i r 1^*)}^l,

i " 'I' 11; 1I',',^I,I)iiiII!iivII,I1

Iif

i

rt 1 t^r^

111,01

^

)0)„,,j^}!

),^)0, 3 Ii4T, ?II IiIIIII H IDA

1 , 4 "ri ) 44141', ), !MI iI lir^q i^//) 1111

( r T RAVERSE 2^

ill i^ti i' I

)^

11rtv^1^1

!111.^i^ti)^r)^,)It ”'

11

05

1.0

1 .5

TR ANSPoSED10-40 c s10138G- 257.; ft600GOO ft 1.x 200 ft w

TRANSPOSED10-40 c s202706-3894111000 II1000 t L x 20011W

TRANSPOSED10-40c s201386— 2574 ft1000 ft100011 L R 200ff W

TRA 4SP0SED10-40 ci s202706-3894ft1000 It1000I IL x 2001t w

• RECORDING METHODSWEEP FREQUENCYNo. OF SWEEPSOFFSET DISTANCEVIBRATOR PATTERN LENGTHGEOPHONE PAT TE RN(360 Geo)

2.0

HORIZONTAL SCALE

9^1320^

2640^3960 FEET^

COMPARISON SECTIONS — HAWKESBURY SANDSTONE PROJECT

Page 29: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

".

S 1'78 179 180 181 182 183 !84 185 186' 187 188 N ; 90: 91

"I 1/111 III I!~~I~~II~ III ~I"~ I1111 11!111~1!lmllllllllllllllt 111111. · ru :~U tH :;~ ~ !!i Itttr.! Hii ;;~! 'II , HI ![:m

[!II

0·0

m I;;! I ~l III

!llI i". ~I~

U1i l~~f' II' t~,

:! i ~I Jt I~ Itt:; ~tl :;1 I ~~ ~~ .... ~ J!l.!

~, ~ mH~! tmll r; ,:~ 1lI',lii: t:1: t!!

t~~1

(")

0 ;:0 ;:0

0'5 rTJ (")

-..! rTJ ~ -l :E

II! I!! "I ,~ In!

!HI I!i Hi II

0

U :E

1'0 l> -< -l -s:: rTJ

-

!!lllf~ Z

(f)

1·5 rTJ (")

I~~\I III III

il i~ ~IIII~~ It I IIl1ml 1111111.

.ilH!tl!luIHIIHlI illHliH illlHlH ftl H, m!!!!! :nHHH! IHUlI! ~ ! HII!lBH tl .w",!!1

0 z 0 (f)

2'0 COMMON SUBSURFACE FOR C,D,P. ----t.1 .

HORIZONTAL SCALE

o B80 .760 2640 fEET TRANSPOS[D I I I I o 1320 2640 39GO HET C.D.P.

TRANSPOSED 20 - 57 C / 5,

20 924-171611 400 It 400" L. 200 II W (400 Goo)

10 FOLD C,O. p, 20-57</_ 10 726-3234 " 264 II 264 It (In line 40 Goo)

RECORDING'ME'THO'D SWEEP FREOUENCY No. OF SWEEPS OFFSET DISTANCE VIBRATOR PA1'TERN LENGTH GEOPHONE PATTERN

COMPARISON SECTIONS -VOLCANICS PROJECT

Page 30: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

Ill^III^I^11^(' l1111^Ifl^III^1 ilii h II iii^II^II 111 111 II

^

i^11^.^'1 r-11, rti, - , 31..:i--1 li j„ci J 4" !t. i 1 it I; -, _I' l t! 0 RII.4 ' t i'l.4 i i . 441 hill' li li` -1[i! i'yv.IiiF--:r t .'",.;

i . • r" ' .(jr 11.;[ ,,(■ 1 ,i,!,th'i• ' c„‘liV[11 t Lli.d

i i ' 1, ,i, 1..!„LA . , r„,-,, .. erh...- ' ; t: 'FIL

^

^ 11,i,ik,t-oRiii-/ Villt 1 t 1:q;i11`111. 41F__...)

,- :.,..., ,t1 .3tg . ---i,_.,.^4I;,..Itt:,-r

, .ii,:„...„,^, .. tiitl itil . It.-^ 4,11-4 4Li.,,•,-,:..,,I,LJ,411.14 q.I11.,1, 'I ..n. I tg` ";-.41111'^' 1 ■^1rt"----)..- litr;i' iltt; Pj! jil lilitj ii47 I ill 1 11 41 -L '141rir i f r) 11 [ 1 1,:ji ''' ic;1 1

1 „ 1!,tit;a1,R,)0101^kir...ICU`^0

tiEti [04. ikl!, i-...,-;$;r..,;;; ^eil /t1?■■;;.:_•?..;7;:,-1 ,;1;),; 1;-1 _ .f;t0 at tall 4 T 4.111ii

i^IltiTi' it trla=q i^''t

'P-^., t^',^, t^‘.^.11^it 1 ,,4•- t)^)^, ..;J ,,.^,1^[^

q,^t ,1 ' 1 tl' ', yriLli i^(r.,4-/ 'IT,' -

11" t

111

0 FOLD C.D. P4-57c/ s

10386-3894 ft

200112001? (In line 40 Geo)

TRANSPOSED4-57 c s.

202684 —3476 ft200 412004? (Diamond 40011diagonol)(360 00o)

NOTE SUBSURFACE COVERAGE SAME FORBOTH SECTIONS

HORIZONTAL SCALEo^1300^1760^2640 FEET TRANSPOSED

^4^^1320^2640^3960 FEET C.D P.

RECORDING ME1 HODSWEEP FREOUENCYNo. OF SWEEPSOFFSET DISTANCEVIBRATOR PATTERN LENGTHGEOPHONE PATTERN

COMPARISON SECTIONS—GAMBIER LIMESTONE PROJECT

Page 31: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

TRAVERSE 2 TRANSPOSED

•14-57 c10924 —1716 ft400 ft400ft L x 200f W 1350 Geo)

TRANSPOSED14-57 cis201386-2574 ft400ft400ft Lx 200I1W1400Geo)

RECORDING METHODSWEEP FREQUENCYNo. OF SWEEPSOFFSET DISTANCEVIBRATOR PATTERN LENGTHGEOPHONE PATTERN

TRAVERSE I

COMPARISON SECTIONS- SAND COVER PROJECTTRAVERSE 2

Page 32: Some Observations on the use of the 'Vibroseis' Method ... · eemie om e saia oise ieig a aom oise caceaio equiemes, e oecies o e suey, e ume o iaos use, a swees equie. o, o geoices

- ---- - ----_._------

\)

r » -I 1'1