some failures & remedies

44
Some Failures & Remedies Jagadiswar M. Shrestha Structural Engineer [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Some Failures & Remedies

Some Failures & Remedies

Jagadiswar M. ShresthaStructural Engineer

[email protected]

Page 2: Some Failures & Remedies

Some major causes of current Failures

Following one or composite are the main causes of current failures Differential settlement due to Soil conditionDifferential settlement due to Lack of Foundation DesignPoor quality of construction materialPoor quality of Detailings

•Lack of infill wall connection•Spacing of lateral ties•Hook of lateral ties•Adjacent building joint consideration (pounding effect)

Lack of Structural design •Soft storey effect•Short column effect•Size of member (rare)•Reinforcement bar (rare)

Page 3: Some Failures & Remedies

H/W=?

Page 4: Some Failures & Remedies

Differential settlement due to Soil condition

Page 5: Some Failures & Remedies

Building Structure at the same location (Macchapokhari,Balaju)

Page 6: Some Failures & Remedies

Failure near by Balkhu River

Page 7: Some Failures & Remedies

Failure near by Dhungedhara, Thamel

Page 8: Some Failures & Remedies

Tower erected building

Framed Structure, Dharmasthali Wall bearing Structure, Kapan3(No damage) (Totally damage)

Page 9: Some Failures & Remedies

Differential settlement due to Lack of Foundation Design

Footing Design for Ideal Case

Page 10: Some Failures & Remedies

Poor quality of construction material & Lack of application of Detailings

Lack of lateral ties & hook requirement

Page 11: Some Failures & Remedies

Poor quality of construction material & Lack of application of Detailings (IS 13920:1993)

Lack of Lateral ties

Page 12: Some Failures & Remedies

Anchorage of Beam bar in Column

Page 13: Some Failures & Remedies

Poor Quality of Construction

Shutter connection with Column

Page 14: Some Failures & Remedies

Proper fixing of Shutter

Page 15: Some Failures & Remedies

Adjacent building joint consideration (pounding effect)

Building Attachment Failures

Page 16: Some Failures & Remedies

Soft Storey Effect Normal Frame with inactive filler wall

EQ Force Deformation Moment

Page 17: Some Failures & Remedies

Short Column Effect(Increment in Relative Stiffness, EI/L)

Page 18: Some Failures & Remedies

Short Column Ties & Elimination of its effect

Page 19: Some Failures & Remedies

Vertical Cracks in Beam

Page 20: Some Failures & Remedies

Breakdown of Infill wall

Page 21: Some Failures & Remedies

Infill wall connection

Page 22: Some Failures & Remedies

Cracks in Masonry works• Horz. cracks just bottom of the beams

– Repairable

• Horz. cracks between the top & bottom of beam- Repairable by inserting hard wood wedge at mortar between each brick

• Vert. crack in between column & wall- Repairable

• Vert. crack- Mostly non-repairable

• Diagonal crack-Repairable by inserting hard wood wedge at mortar between each brick

• Cross diagonal crack- Mostly non-repairable

Page 23: Some Failures & Remedies

Vertical Crack between infill wall & column

Page 24: Some Failures & Remedies

Diagonal Cracks

Page 25: Some Failures & Remedies

Repair of Vertical Crack

Page 26: Some Failures & Remedies

Cross Cracks

Page 27: Some Failures & Remedies

Cracks in Reinforced Concrete– Hair cracks may be avoided if there are no cracks

seen in RCC member on removing plaster.

– After removing plaster, if hair cracks are seen in the member and crack is not prolonged up to reinforcement bar, minor repair is required.

– If crack found deepen upto reinforcement bar, special treatment of the member is required.(Strengthening of member by repair with grouting only or retroficating along with grouting, depending upon damage)

Page 28: Some Failures & Remedies

Building Configuration

Page 29: Some Failures & Remedies

Wall Bearing System

Page 30: Some Failures & Remedies

Diagonal Cracks

Page 31: Some Failures & Remedies

Temporary Supports

Page 32: Some Failures & Remedies

Masonry cracks at corner

Page 33: Some Failures & Remedies

Different types of crack & Shoring

Page 34: Some Failures & Remedies

Strengthening of Wall

Page 35: Some Failures & Remedies

Retrofication

Page 36: Some Failures & Remedies

Heavy Retofit for RCC Beam & Column

Page 37: Some Failures & Remedies

Retoficating

Strengthening for RCC Beam & Column

Page 38: Some Failures & Remedies

Retroficating of Columns

Page 39: Some Failures & Remedies

Compound Wall

Page 40: Some Failures & Remedies

Modern concept of Compound wall

Page 41: Some Failures & Remedies

28

.42

28

.42 34

.784

3

52

.17

62

.20

64

.21

43

.47

45

.81

47

.49

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Reqd.43 Prism 43 Jaypee 43 ACC 43

Stre

ngt

h, N

/mm

2

Cement Brand

28 DAYS COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH OPC43(STRENGTH VS PRODUCTION TIME PERIOD)

Old (>3month)

Fresh (1 Week)

Normal (5 Week)

Page 42: Some Failures & Remedies

Mild, TOR, TOR Cari & TMT

fy

fu

Elongation over gauge length ( 5.65Ø) %

Ten

sile

str

ess

(N/m

m )

2

fy

fufy

fu

fy

fu

MILD STEEL , Fe250

TOR STEEL , Fe415

TORCARI , Fe500

TMT , Fe500

10 20 30 40

100

200

300

400

500

600

VII. MILD, TOR, TORCARI & TMT

Page 43: Some Failures & Remedies

Worship the Professional Design & Construction Quality

Constructed on BS 2024 BS 2061

Page 44: Some Failures & Remedies

Thank You for Kind ATTENTION