solutions for obtaining composite material properties ebook
TRANSCRIPT
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 1/13
BETWEEN THE PLIES Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional
Composite Material Properties for a
FEA Simulation
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 2/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
1 of 12
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction .......................................................................................... 2 Properties Needed to Define a Unidirectional Composite Material ...... 3 Solutions ............................................................................................... 4
Scenario #1: Limited Lamina-Level Material Property Data ........ 5 Scenario #2: No Lamina-Level Data, Only Constituent-Level
(fiber/matrix) Data ...................................................................... 7 Summary ............................................................................................ 11 About Firehole Composites ................................................................. 11 References .......................................................................................... 12
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 3/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
2 of 12
INTRODUCTION
A major component of conducting accurate simulations of composite materials used in an
increasing number of light-weight structures is gathering the required material properties to
fully define a composite material. Composite materials have the unique characteristic of having
different stiffness and strength values depending on the direction the composite is being
loaded. For unidirectional composites, higher stiffnesses and strengths are observed in the
direction parallel to the fibers as compared to perpendicular to the fiber alignment direction.
This document describes some methods for determining the
required material property data for a finite element analysis
simulation of unidirectional composite materials.
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 4/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
3 of 12
PROPERTIES NEEDED TO DEFINE A
UNIDIRECTIONAL COMPOSITE MATERIAL
Unidirectional composites can be assumed to be transversely isotropic and are therefore fully
defined by 5 material constants:
• E11 – longitudinal elastic modulus (fiber direction)
• E22 – transverse elastic modulus (perpendicular to fiber direction)
o Because of transverse isotropy, E33 = E22
• ν12 – longitudinal Poisson ratio
o Because of transverse isotropy, ν13 = ν12
• G12 – longitudinal shear modulus
o Because of transverse isotropy, G13 = G12
• ν23 – interlaminar Poisson ratio
o Because of transverse isotropy, G23 =E
2(1+υ)
Additionally, unidirectional composites have 6 strength values that will fully define the material:
• S11+ – tensile longitudinal strength
• S11- – compressive longitudinal strength
• S22+ – tensile transverse strength
• S22
-
– compressive transverse strength• S12 – in-plane longitudinal shear strength
o Because of transverse isotropy, S13 = S12
• S23 – transverse shear strength
However, sometimes the data a user has access to has “holes” in it. This leaves the user unable
to fully characterize a material based upon the data they have immediate access to.
There are two common scenarios that are encountered when trying to fully
characterize a composite material:
1. Limited lamina-level material property data.
2. No lamina level data, only constituent (fiber/matrix) level data.
To assist in the process, Firehole has developed methodologies to fill in these “holes”. This
eBook will present a solution for both of these scenarios. It is noted, however, that engineering
judgment should always be used when characterizing a composite material.
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 5/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
4 of 12
SOLUTIONS
As part of the solution, Firehole has developed tools to assist in determining material properties
for composite lamina and fiber/matrix constituents. The scenarios below include descriptions on
how to use these tools to help obtain the data needed.
Helius:CompostiePro is a desktop software package that offers an array of tools to assist in
composite material design and analysis. Included in this tool suite is an extensive material
database of pre-characterized material files and a high-fidelity micromechanics module
that calculates lamina material properties from input fiber and matrix material properties.
http://www.firehole.com/products/comppro/
Helius:MatSim is a free, online micromechanics-based composite material simulator. It
enables the user to calculated lamina properties based on supplied fiber and matrix
volume fraction and elastic constants. This tool additionally offers the following options:
• Pre-populate fiber and matrix data from a built-in material library• Calculate lamina density based upon fiber and matrix density
• Enter data as orthotropic, transversely isotropic, or isotropic
http://www.firehole.com/products/matsim
Prospector:Composites is an online, searchable database of composite material data
sheets. It provides subscribers with a single location to obtain material data as well as the
ability to quickly locate, compare, and evaluate alternative candidate composites. In
addition to manufacturer’s supplied data, the database is populated with quality data from
some of the world’s foremost testing labs and research institutions, giving users
information they can trust.
http://composites.ides.com/
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 6/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
5 of 12
Scenario #1: Limited Lamina-Level Material Property Data
Often times, engineers can gather lamina (ply) material property data from suppliers of the
material, but this data can be less than complete. The two most commonly missing values that
prevent an engineer from fully characterizing a unidirectional composite areν23 and S23. Steps 1and 2 below provide recommendations for obtaining these two values. In the event that even
less material data is available, Step 3 will provide sources to use to find comparable
unidirectional data to use as a starting point.
Step 1: Determine ν 23 if it is not provided.
The interlaminar Poisson ration is often not provided by a manufacturer. Through
experience, Firehole has determined that common values for this constant are 0.5 for carbon
fiber and 0.41 for glass fiber composites.
Step 2: Determine S23 if it is not provided.
The transverse shear strength is often not provided by a manufacturer. Through experience,
Firehole has determined that appropriate values for this constant are obtained from the
equation below:
23=
1
3(
22− )
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 7/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
6 of 12
Step 3: Determine any remaining elastic constants/strengths by comparing the material
being characterized with a similar, fully-characterized material found in Prospector:
Composites.
Prospector:Composites contains numerous, analysis-ready data sheets of similar materialsthat provide multiple references (Figure 1). Users can determine the missing elastic
constants/strengths based upon the ratios evident in similar materials.
Figure 1 – Prospector:Composites (composites.ides.com) can be used to determine
missing lamina-level material properties by comparing the material being characterized
with similar materials.
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 8/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
7 of 12
Scenario #2: No Lamina-Level Data, Only Constituent-Level
(fiber/matrix) Data
Engineers also face the challenge of not having any lamina data for a unidirectional composite
that they wish to use, or they have lamina data but spcified at a different fiber volume fraction
than the material used in their design. In this case, an analysis method commonly referred to as
“micromechanics” can be used to derive lamina-level data from material properties of the fiber
and matrix constituents composing the unidirectional material. There are 2 methods available
for using fiber and matrix material properties to calculate lamina level unidirectional properties:
1. Analytical micromechanics calculations – Use equations to calculate lamina
properties from constituent properties.
o Pros
Can be used without specialized software or a computer
o Cons
There are multiple equations for calculating lamina properties (no
consensus on which equation to use)
Not all composite lamina properties have analytical solutions
Time consuming
Error Prone
2. Simulation micromechanics calculations – Use finite element methods to
simulate a unidirectional composite microstructure.
o Pros
Fast and efficient
More accurate than analytical calculations
Easy to perform design comparison studies when multiple combinations
of fibers and matrix materials are being considered
o Cons
Requires specialized software
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 9/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
8 of 12
Method 1: Analytical micromechanics calculations
E11 (longitudinal elastic modulus)
11 = 11 + (McCullough, 1989)
Ef11 fiber longitudinal elastic modulus
Vf fiber volume fraction
Em matrix elastic modulus
E22 (transverse elastic modulus)
22 = 1− 1−
(Chamis, 1984)
Ef22 fiber transverse elastic modulus
G12 (longitudinal shear modulus)
12 = �1+++1+ (Hashin, 1979)
Gf12 fiber longitudinal shear modulus
Gm matrix shear modulus
Vm matrix volume fraction
ν12 (longitudinal Poisson ratio)
12 = 12 + (McCullough, 1989)
νf12 fiber longitudinal Poisson ratio
νm matrix Poisson ratio
S11+ and S11
- (tensile and compressive longitudinal strength)
11+ = 11+ (Chamis, 1984)
11− =
11− (Chamis, 1984)
Sf11+ Fiber tensile strength
Sf11-
Fiber compressive strength
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 10/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
9 of 12
S22+ and S22
- (tensile and compressive transverse strength)
22+ =
1.55 (Tsai, 2009)
22− = 0.65 (Tsai, 2009)
Stmatrix tensile strength of neat resign
Scmatrix compressive strength of the neat resign
Method 2a: Use Helius:CompositePro to determine lamina level material properties
from the fiber and matrix properties.
Helius:CompositePro uses micromechanics to calculate the properties of the new composite
material based on known properties of the fiber and matrix constituent materials.
Helius:CompositePro’s micromechanics module utilizes a detailed finite element model of a
fiber/matrix unit cell that features a uniform hexagonal distribution of parallel fibers
embedded in a matrix material. The micromechanical model utilizes the properties of fiber
and matrix materials specified by the user, in addition to the fiber volume fraction specified
by the user (Figure 2). Helius:CompositePro determines the composite material’s elastic
properties (moduli and Poisson ratios) and strengths by using the micromechanical finite
element model to simulate the various fundamental load/deformation relationships of the
composite material.
Figure 2 –The micromechanics calculator available in Helius:CompositePro
can derive lamina properties based upon constituent properties and ratios of
fiber and matrix content.
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 11/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
10 of 12
Method 2b: Use Helius:MatSim to determine remaining lamina-level material
properties from the fiber and matrix properties.
(This is the same calculator that is available in Helius:CompositePro except that the calculator in
Helius:CompositePro derives lamina strengths from fiber and matrix properties while theHelius:MatSim calculator does not.)
Helius:MatSim (Figure 3) is a free online calculator that calculates lamina constants (moduli,
Poisson ratios, coefficients of thermal expansion, etc.) from matrix and fiber material
properties (http://www.firehole.com/products/matsim).
Figure 3 – Helius:MatSim is a free, online calculator that calculates lamina material
constants from fiber and matrix material properties
(http://www.firehole.com/products/matsim).
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 12/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
11 of 12
SUMMARY
Firehole Composites has assembled these tools to provide useful solutions for composite
analysis. We are happy to answer any questions regarding the above scenarios or any other
composite material characterization questions. Contact Firehole Composites at
[email protected] or call us at 307-460-4763.
ABOUT FIREHOLE COMPOSITES
Firehole Composites provides innovative software tools and engineering services designed to
significantly improve structural design and analysis with composite materials. Their mission is to
help engineers create lighter, stronger, safer and more efficient composite designs through
superior analysis capability. Firehole’s team of engineers has extensive study and experience in
analysis of composite materials and software development. For more information, visit
www.firehole.com.
8/13/2019 Solutions for Obtaining Composite Material Properties eBook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/solutions-for-obtaining-composite-material-properties-ebook 13/13
Solutions for Obtaining Unidirectional Material Properties for a FEA Simulation
12 of 12
REFERENCES
Chamis, C. (1984, January). Simplified Composite Micromechanics Equations for Strength,
Fracture Toughness, and Environmental Effects. NASA Report TM-83696 .
Hashin, Z. (1979). Analysis of Properties of Fiber Composites with Anisotropic Constituents.
Journal of Applied Mechanics , 546-550.
McCullough, R. (1989). Mechancial Materials Modeling, Delaware Composites Design
Encyclopedia, Vol. 2. Micro-Models for Composite Materials-Continous Fiber Composites , pp. pp.
64-68.
Tsai, S. W. (2009, March 31). Opportunities in Composites, Composite Design Tutorial 4.
Aeronautics & Astronautics .