soljer soljer : book review by branwyn

24

Upload: sneha-gupta

Post on 25-Nov-2015

35 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

SOLJER SOLJER is a book written by Colonel Mahip Singh Chadha. Here is a critical study of the book done by Branwyn Magazine in the book review format.

TRANSCRIPT

  • Contents :

    1. Colonel Mahip Chadha : An introduction

    2. SOLJER SOLJER : A general overview

    3. Significance of the title 4. Major Characters 5. Plot Construction 6. SOLJER SOLJER : An

    emotional document of Indian

    Army

  • Chapter 1

    Colonel Mahip Chadha : An

    introduction

    Colonel Mahip Chadha is a retired army officer who

    lives in New Delhi, India. A graduate of the Indian

    Military Academy, Col Chadha served in the Indian

    Army for nearly 34 years. He was commissioned in the

    Third Gorkha Rifleshis inspiration for the novel. Colonel Chadha is the author of GRIT GUTS and

    GALLANTRY-which motivates the youth of India to

    consider the Army as a viable career option. This is a

    motivational book and serves to act as a much needed

    career counseling requirement, for students of classes 9

    to 12, so that they can consider the Armed Forces of

    India as a viable career. It also assists children in the

    National Cadet Corps to understand the Army better.

    Other Ranks seeking a commission will also benefit

    from it!

    He has now published the sequel-the Second Edition,

    encompassing the three services,wherin he has includes

    all the information required by a student, boy or girl to

    join the defence services with almost 180 pictures

    designed to motivate the children. Many people write

    their autobiographies to boast about their achievements,

    or to show others in poor light, or to jot down their

  • memoirs for posterity to read, but here the authors aim is to make the Indian youth aware of the Defense Forces

    the rank structure, the selection process, the hardships the soldiers endure, excruciating physical training and

    adherence to rules and regulations along with a mix of

    masti and adventure - and encourage the youth to join

    the Services where the uniform and the insignia of a

    particular regiment or battalion has a deep meaning and

    where he can learn three basic values NAAM,NAMAK and NISHAAN!.

    One has to read only the first few pages when one

    gets tempted to read the book in one go and this is

    because of the very humorous style of narrating the

    simplest and most ordinary of events in his life and

    career.

    He has now started a new helpline for young first

    time authors under the banner of YS Books

    International. The website for this company can be found

    at : ysbooksinternational.com

    This book reminds Indian youth about the dignified,

    disciplined life in uniform. And no, this isn't your

    archetypal, preachy guidebook. Instead, read a no-holds-

    barred, humour-tinged take on life in the Army. This

    book describes the writers journey through the National Defence Academy and the Indian Military Academy.

    Colonel Chadha dispels many myths surrounding life in

    the armed forces to provide students on the threshold of

    their careers an unadulterated view of what to expect in

    the army.

    He also wrote two more novels -SOLJER SOLJER

    in which he describes the tough but rewarding life in the

    infantry. His book SOLJER SOLJER is a story based on

  • an imaginary infantry battalion of the Third Gorkha

    Rifles - the Sixth battalion. The composition, training,

    camaraderie, and duties in all the other infantry

    battalions of our Army are almost the same except that

    certain customs undergo a change as they adapt to the

    ethnicity of the troops in that Regiment. So the visible

    changes would be the manner of the battle cry,

    salutation, greeting, decorum in festivity with the troops,

    or ceremonials in the Officer's Mess. There is no

    difference in the dogged determination or the ferocity in

    the will of troops of these troops in completing any

    mission allotted to their battalions! The author has very

    clearly brought out the joys of the simple infantry life

    and the deeply embedded love, affections and stoic

    ethnic involvement that officers enjoy with their men.

    This is brotherhood in its purest form.

    .He also authored GIN and LIME WHISKEY or

    WINE? a spotlight on how veterans find themselves very uneasy when they hang up their uniform and boots

    but continue with their zest for quality life by ignoring

    their twilight years, failing health and take umbrage by

    using humour as a new weapon against Alzheimers or dementia! This is also how they get over loneliness

    waiting in the twilight zone!

    Asked about why he has only written about the

    defence forces-Colonel Chadha replies with a twinkle in

    his eyes-A common Indian citizen has little or no idea of

    the Indian Armed Forces, he says .Its important that I give readers an inside look at what its truly like to be a soldier in the Indian infantry, and the brotherhood and

    sacrifice involved.

  • No other Army is as diverse in nature, as the Indian

    Army which has its infantry battalions, considered the

    teeth of the battle; comprising of twenty three ethnic

    groups each with its own traditions, religious beliefs,

    values and historysome having been raised as far back as the seventeenth century or amalgamated from the

    erstwhile armies of princely states! However, their

    training, goals and objectives are the same and the

    Indian Army, an efficient machine; continues to be the

    most secular armies in the world in which Sikh, Muslim,

    Hindu, Christian and some with tribal beliefs fight side

    by side against the aggressor!

    It is ironic, that Pakistan chose one of the

    Commanding officersof The Third Gorkha Rifles, Sir

    Douglas Gracey, hero of the Admin Box in the Burma

    Campaign, to be its first Commander in Chief! Colonel

    Mahip Chadha also served in General Graceys battalion-The Second Battalion The Third Gorkha Rifles.

    Colonel Chadha was married to Kiran ,who passed

    away tragically in April 2010.

    They have two daughters-Ganiv the elder, is married

    to Inderjit and has one son Jaskirat; while Jyotan lives in

    Australia with her husband Daljit and two sons Jaskaran

    and Jaskabir.

    Mahip lives with his mother in law Mrs Gurdip Sethi

    who actually encouraged him to write!

  • Chapter 2

    SOLJER SOLJER : A General

    Overview

    If somebody says that he is not afraid of death, then either he is lying or is a Gurkha. Field Marshal Sam Maneckshaw.

    Colonel Mahip Chadha , has presented a never

    before heard account of the travails and hardships

    experienced cheerfully by the soldiers of his Gorkha

    battalion --which is just like any battalion except for

    certain peculiarities in handling the troops and adherence

    to customs and traditions linked to the ethnicity of the

    troops.

    Humor and a rigid adherence to the prevailing rules

    and regulations, is a unique phenomenon followed to the

    letter in the Indian Army; which follows the perfect

    example of secularism and unity in diversity It is this

    principle which endears officers of any outfit to link

    themselves with the traditions of their troops throughout

    their lives --during their service and during retirement.

  • Colonel Mahip Chadha transports the reader to a

    world where the Commanding Officer is a veritable God

    ,who holds the lives of 800 men in his hands - whom he

    loves like his own children, punishes them when they err

    like a parent and mourns with them when they suffer!

    Many troops of the West, would find it difficult to

    adapt to our condition of service! There are no air

    conditioned barracks or offices in the desert or the

    jungles and mountainous terrain. Neither are there any

    heating arrangements for the troops in high altitude --just

    a kerosene burner to be used in a barrel like apparatus

    called a bukhari! There are regions where the highest

    rainfall has been recorded--leeches, scorpions, snakes

    and others like the dim dam flies which penetrate

    mosquito nets are our companions! Choppers are rarely

    used only for senior commanders for reconnaissance or

    emergent requirements.

    Heat dust, cold, rain, riverine terrain and the moist

    jungles of the Eastern regions are our hazards--but the

    soldiers of the INDIAN ARMY adapt and become adept

    in consonance with the challenges of nature!

    SOLJER SOLJER combines compelling fiction with

    the actualities of life in the Indian Armed Forces,

    centering on the tale of a father and son who serve in the

    same battalion, though at different periods in the Sixth

    Battalion The Third Gorkha Rifles. Certain events

    threaten to separate them forever. Weaving in

    memorable characters and events from his past, the

    author highlights both the joys and hardships of military

    life.

    The story is of Brigadier Surinder Singh Sahni and

    his son Jaskaran. Brigadier Sahni resigns from the Army

  • due to domestic issues while his son enjoys a brief

    courtship and very modern marriage thanks to

    considerate parents. Brigadier Sahni has to face terms

    with reality when he reads about the Indian POWs and

    later when his son is declared missing believed killed

    after a skirmish with militants from POK. His misery is

    compounded when his daughter in law has to suffer

    further privations, till she decides to fight the

    establishment by becoming a lawyer. The sacrifices

    made by the cowherds in rescuing Jaskaran are poignant

    and noble. The book has a sprinkling of humour and the

    reader laughs at the follies of life. Mahip has told his

    story as an infantry officer would - straight, to the point

    and without beating about the bush and this makes

    enjoyable reading!

  • Chapter 3

    Significance of the title

    SOLJER SOLJER can be remembered for its

    phonetic title. Instead of using the exact word soldier, Col. Chadha opts for the use of the pronounced word

    SOLJER! This is because the word soldier is pronounced as SOLJER. And Col. Chadha keeps it that way itself, to attract attention to the book! The basic

    responsibility of the title of any book is to drag the

    readers attention towards it which has definitely been achieved.

    SOLJER SOLJER is a book about the infantry. Unfortunately, in our country, books related to defense

    contain difficult jargon and use terms which the reader

    can neither understand nor co relate with and therefore

    cannot enjoy such books!

    Many of such books do not connect with civilians,

    especially those who do not have even the faintest idea

    of life in the defense forces!

  • SOLJER SOLJER has actually been written with the idea to make this connect. SOLJER SOLJER lightens the subject of the book. It is not only catchy but

    also creates curiosity. Besides all these, the title speaks

    the language of Young India. And with this, the author

    succeeds in his motive of telling his story. Thus

    SOLJER SOLJER proves to be a successful title and Col. Mahip Chadha manages to tell you the story making

    you laugh and cry or feel contempt for our politicians

  • Chapter 4

    Major Characters

    SOLJER SOLJER is the saga of a soldier, his valour

    and his dignity interwoven with his emotions. Colonel

    Chadha has sketched the characters in a very lively way.

    Not only they deliver the very just account of being our

    guardians, but there is a realization that they are human,

    have families who miss them and their emotional angle

    get unveiled in the book.

    Brigadier Surinder Sahni

    Brigadier Surinder Sahni is one of the four

    protagonists of the book. He is a straightforward man.

    There are more than one incident in the book when we

    come across the different phases of his personality. He is

    not only a strict commander but also an affectionate

  • leader. He is a strategist, an efficient commander and a

    man on whom his seniors can depend. We also come

    across the humourous side of Surinder Sahni when he

    directs his soldiers to complete a task where they try to

    outsmart him but are caught red-handed. [pg.85]

    We also come across the strict nature of Surinder

    Sahni when his favourite junior commits a mistake and

    is confronted by him. But here we also witness the

    calmness of Surinder when he handles the situations

    without losing his wits Sahib, you are right hand. If I order my right hand to break a morsel of food and put it

    in my mouth, but the hand disobeys and shoves the spicy

    food in my nostril then I wouldnt do anything with this hand it needs to be severed and I should learn to use my left hand. [pg.78] He does not try to ignore the issue of the JCOs misbehavior but tackles the matter firmly on the spot.

    Besides being a soldier with a tough attitude,

    Surinder Sahni is also a loving husband and a caring

    father. There are several instances where he not only

    fulfills his duty towards the nation but also meets his

    responsibilities as a son, husband and a father

    equivalently. These qualities altogether make him a very

    lovable hero.

    Preeti Sahni

    Preeti Sahni is the second protagonist of the book.

    She is the wife of Surinder Sahni. She is a very

    understanding and mature lady. She not only joins her

    hands with her husbands professional commitments but also proves to be his complementary counterpart in his

  • domestic life. Besides being the devoted wife of a

    courageous soldier, she is also a loving mother and a

    social person. Her involvements in the betterment of her

    surroundings also indicate her delicacy towards the

    society. Her motherly affection also extends towards her

    husbands juniors. Preeti has also been sketched as a very amiable lady.

    The way she adjusts in the army life of her husband is

    very notable. It is not that easy for a girl who has been

    brought up in a civilian background, to adjust the quickly

    to the nuances of life of army. But, Preeti proves herself

    the true soul-mate of her husband and walks along with

    him on the every road of life, with the desired decorum.

    Jaskaran Sahni and Tanveer Sahni

    Jaskaran Sahni alias Jas is the third protagonist of the

    book. He is the son of Surinder Sahni and Preeti Sahni.

    He has been sketched as the exact replica of his father,

    whether in the courage, the discipline, the presence of

    mind or his tactical genius. His charming nature adds

    grace in his personality. He is a loving son, a great

    soldier, a caring husband and an affectionate father. He

    is that character of the book that goes through the most

    traumatic situations but overcomes them with his

    courage.

    Tanveer Sahni is the wife of Jaskaran Sahni. She

    adds colour to the story. Her accidental meeting with

    Jaskaran gives the book a romantic flavor. Later on,

    when she marries Jaskaran, an amiable phase of her

    bubbly nature is exposed. She gives the example of

    extreme courage when Jaskaran is considered dead. Not

  • only does she console herself but also takes care of Jass parents who treat her as their own daughter> At one

    stage Surinder even thinks of her re marriage for he

    knows how hard it is for a young widow, but does not

    have the courage to ascertain Tanveers views! . Here Col. Chadha has introduced that part of Indian women

    which is known as Shakti. Tanveer takes the charge of the care of her family, pursues her studies, becomes a

    lawyer and looks after her son. And she does all these

    things after losing that person whom she loved the most.

    Here Tanveer has been sketched as the wife of a true

    soldier. This is the moral fiber Army wives are expected

    to possess!

  • Chapter 5

    Plot Construction

    One thing which makes SOLJER SOLJER out of

    the crowd is its plot structure. Colonel Chadha has

    intriguingly woven each and every concern of a soldier

    and his family be it their social concern or patriotism for the country. Reading the book actually catalyzes the

    nerves to send a thrilling sensation directly through the

    spine.

    The plot of SOLJER SOLJER also deals with several social and political issues which deserve separate

    elucidation

    Wedding Ceremony

    Col. Chadha through his character Surinder Sahni

    suggests several changes in the wedding ceremony:

  • 1. Lunch should be at a venue to be decided at the discretion of the brides family. Refreshments were not required because there was no need.

    2. Flowers would not be showered on the bridal couple, after the fourth phera in the presence of

    the holy Guru Granth sahib.

    3. During the pheras, the bride would walk without any escort.

    4. There would be no speeches, lectures or recital of poems.

    5. The groom would not have the ritualistic turmeric bath.

    6. There would be a joint reception and guests from both sides would attend. Expenses would be

    shared.

    - [pg.17] Thus Col. Chadha suggests an alternative for the big

    fat Indian weddings which are more or less planned to

    upset the financial status of the brides family. Colonel Chadha also throws light on the general

    gender discriminative mentality of Indian society so much excitement over a boy seemed warranted on the contrary she would have meekly informed him in a

    hushed tone that it was a girl! Typical Indian enthusiasm

    for a male child. He would have been equally happy if it had been a daughter [pg.50]

    Colonel Chadha also tells an anecdote as a satire on

    the political structure of India I was in Patna once an as I sat in a rickshaw, the

    rickshaw puller spoke about politics to another

    colleague of his who had hailed him. I asked if the

    people in Bihar were politically conscious and the

  • rickshaw wala told me politics was in blood but the confusion occurred because there too many parties!

    When asked who he will vote for, he replied I will vote for the Congress because they are full upto their

    throat, others will start from the stomach. [pg.81] Colonel Chadha recalls the forgotten soldiers of

    1971. He also questions the Governmental bodies for

    their coldness towards their own soldiers who sacrificed

    their lives for the country. The pathetic account of Mrs.

    Kanwal Jit Sandhu is enough to bring tears in anybodys eyes In army parlance, these valiant soldiers had been written off! That night Surinder couldnt sleep. He woke up shuddering in a sweat thinking of the shoddy

    treatment these poor guys would be receiving at the

    hands of the Pakistanis. If some were dead were they thrown into an unmarked grave forgotten for posterity

    except to their loved ones? Why was the Government of

    India sleeping over this issue? WHY WOULD A

    SOLDIER FIGHT IF NO ONE WANTED TO RECOVER

    HIM FROM THE CLUTCHES OF THE ENEMY OR AT

    LEAST RECLAIM HIS BODY AND CREMATE OR

    BURY HIM WITH DUE RESPECT? [pg.160] Colonel Chadha makes a blunt confrontation Was

    all the money in Swiss banks that of the political parties?

    Was that the reason why no serious attempt was being

    made to recover it? Why was the judiciary not cleaning

    up their act why had a tainted Judge been appointed the Chief Justice of a state? Why were jail birds having a

    great time? Why was the stock Market in the hands of

    unscrupulous elements? [pg.161] The most pathetic part of the book comes when there

    is deep rooted corruption in the allotment of land and

  • petrol pump of the martyrs widows is unraveled Sardarji, the ten acres of land which has been allotted to you is divided in eleven parts and each has a land

    mafia sitting on it. Please leave if you value your

    lives.. So, they have allotted you this petrol pump. They

    have reserved it for our martyrs. You are the fifth

    allottee. It helps them get headlines in the newspaper

    and television and that is the end of the story. [pg.231] Colonel Chadha has been very candid in his thoughts

    and views. Besides, having the defense background, his

    disciplined and decision making attitude reflects in the

    plot of SOLJER SOLJER and that is what makes it unique.

    Undoubtedly, the plot and structure of the book are

    unbeatable but the craft and format also deserves

    appreciation. The book starts with a Dedication and then the Introduction to the flower Narcissus/Nargis. Every chapter of the books starts with an image of the

    Nargis flower which adorns many a grave in the state of

    Jammu and Kashmir where a proxy was is being fought.

    After the introduction, there is A Tribute to a Gorkha, a beautiful poem written by Maj. Gen. W. Ross Stewart. The poem beautifully defines the nature and

    nurture of a Gorkha which gives the readers a fine idea

    of what they are going to read.

    The crafting makes the book a very artistic read.

  • Chapter 6

    SOLJER SOLJER : An emotional

    document of Indian Army

    Soljer Soljer stirs the soul of the readers. Right

    from the start, it travels through each and every phase of

    a soldiers life appointment, transfers, promotions, marriage, children, retirement, hardships and much

    more.

    It unfolds those phases which have been unknown to

    the civilians of our country. Though it has been

    categorized as fiction, it could be taken as a documented

    account of the life of an Indian soldier because each and

    every person could relate to the plot and characters and

    peep into defense life.

    What makes Soljer Soljer best among all defence books is it lacks manipulation. Colonel Mahip Singh

    Chadha has been very careful in sketching the accounts,

    the incidents and all its details which emerge as a book

  • of a soldiers life- dipped deep into emotions and which pokes the readers in the ribs and commands them to

    wake up from their slumber

    I dont think anybody in our country really

    understands your sacrifices, because soldiers die and

    fade away only their widows, parents or children

    weep for them nobody else has time to cry for you. And our country cares nothing for you or they

    would have raised hell for our prisoners of war

    languishing in Pakistani jails or for the soldiers who

    were mutilated by the Pakis or that matter those who

    fell in Kargil.

    After all a politician can give ten times the

    compensation to the hooch tragedy but fails to

    acknowledge the sacrifices of the countrys soldiers it does not provide them political mileage!

    Someday, they will be shaken from their slumber

    and account for their misdeeds!

    ~ A Branwyn Book Review Project ~

  • A book review by Branwyn