solicitation information - ofccofcc.ohio.gov/portals/0/documents/bids/2016/tab-dot-130010.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
Solicitation Information
Ohio Facilities Construction Commission
Solicitation Number
DOT-130010
Deadline
12/07/2016 02:00 PM EST
Advertised
11/04/2016 03:56 PM EDT
Revised
12/02/2016 12:58 PM EST
Description
Ohio Department of Transportation DOT-130010.1 Coshocton Full Service Maintenance Facility (FSMF) 233 RivercrestDrive Coshocton, Ohio 43812 And DOT-130010.2 Tuscarawas Full Service Maintenance Facility (FSMF) 2201 ReiserAvenue New Philadelphia, Ohio 44663
DOT-130010 Page 1 of 42 12/07/2016
Bidders
Business NameBusiness Name AddressAddress PhonePhone
Robertson Construction Services, Inc. 1801 Thornwood Drive Heath, OH 43056 (740) 929-1000
Vaughn Industries, LLC 1201 E. Findlay StreetCarey, OH 43316 (419) 396-3900 x109
Charter Hill Construction, Inc. 10200 Busey RdCanal Winchester, OH 43110 (614) 862-1812
Regency Construction Services, Inc 14600 Detroit AveLakewood, OH 44017 (216) 529-1188
York Mahoning Mechanical Contractors, Inc. 724 Canfield RoadYoungstown, OH 44511 (330) 788-7011
The Knoch Corporation 1015 Schneider Street, SENorth Canton, OH 44720 (330) 244-1440 x201
Hilscher Clark Electric Company 519 4th St NWCanton, OH 44703 (330) 452-9806
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. 88 South Second StreetNewark, OH 43055 (740) 349-9411
Abbott Electric, Inc. 1935 Allen Ave. SECanton, OH 44707 (330) 452-6601
Peterman Plumbing & Heating, Inc. 525 West 15th StreetDover, OH 44622 (330) 364-4497
MIKE COATES CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. 800 SUMMIT AVENUENILES, OH 44446 (330) 652-0190
Jeffrey Carr Construction Inc. 4164 Erie Ave S Massillon , OH 44646 (330) 879-5201 x205
Wood Electric, Inc. 210 - 11th Street NWNew Philadelphia, OH 44663 (330) 339-7002
Fire Foe Corporation 999 Trumbull Ave.Girard, OH 44420 (330) 759-9834
De-Cal Inc. 8392 tod AveBoardman, OH 44512 (330) 727-3784
R.T. Hampton Plumbing and Heating, Inc. 1225 Industrial Ave. SWMassillon, OH 44747 (330) 809-6200
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 2 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package C102 - General Trades (Lead) Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C102 - General Trades (Lead) Contract - Coshocton FSMF
Allowance C1Allowance C1Water Tap FeeWater Tap Fee
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C4Allowance C4CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C5Allowance C5Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Unit Price U-C1Unit Price U-C1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Agency Estimate: $37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $37,576.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
$37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $73,200.00
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $73,200.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $68,930.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $191,906.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$37,950.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $36,600.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 3 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package C102 - General Trades (Lead) Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C102 - General Trades (Lead) Contract - Coshocton FSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $5,420,795.80 $0.00 $0.00 $200.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$5,294,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $200.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
$5,150,286.00 $0.00 $0.00 $250.00
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$5,609,000.00 $18,275.00 $9,200.00 $100.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $5,389,900.00 $0.00 $0.00 $180.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$6,023,434.00 $0.00 $0.00 $150.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$5,843,058.00 $0.00 $0.00 $175.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 4 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package C103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMF
Allowance C2Allowance C2Water MeterWater Meter
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C3Allowance C3Aid to Construction fo...Aid to Construction fo...
Lump SumLump Sum
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $2,500.00 $8,219.15 $469,582.97 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $2,500.00 $8,219.15 $538,516.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$2,500.00 $8,219.15 $552,000.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$2,500.00 $8,219.15 $597,650.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 5 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package C103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMF
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package C104 - Fire Suppression Contract - CoshoctonBid Package C104 - Fire Suppression Contract - CoshoctonFSMFFSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $82,867.58 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $21,648.00 $0.00 $56,800.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$7,500.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$12,415.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 6 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Bid Package C104 - Fire Suppression Contract - CoshoctonBid Package C104 - Fire Suppression Contract - CoshoctonFSMFFSMF
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package C105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMFBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $280,829.03 $5,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
$264,500.00 $11,700.00
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $0.00 $221,820.00 $7,757.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$350,000.00 $10,000.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 7 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package C105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package C106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMFBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $874,713.37 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC $990,900.00 $0.00
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
$780,000.00 $1,200.00
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc. $827,747.00 $547.00
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 8 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package C106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMFBid Package C106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMF
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Combination Bid C103/C105 - Plumbing and HVAC ContractCombination Bid C103/C105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract- Coshocton FSMF- Coshocton FSMF
Allowance C2Allowance C2Water MeterWater Meter
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C3Allowance C3Aid to Construction fo...Aid to Construction fo...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $71,820.00 $1,500.00 $2,500.00 $8,219.15
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC $109,500.00 $2,900.00
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
$99,000.00 $2,000.00
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $2,500.00 $8,219.15
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$2,500.00 $8,219.15
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc. $141,471.00 $1,874.00
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$2,500.00 $8,219.15
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 9 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C103/C105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMFCombination Bid C103/C105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMFBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $750,412.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $752,732.00 $7,679.00 $21,431.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$852,000.00 $7,500.00 $7,500.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$848,925.00 $0.00 $12,415.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 10 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102, C103, C104, C-105, C106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Combination Bid C102, C103, C104, C-105, C106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,and Electrical) Coshocton FSMFand Electrical) Coshocton FSMF
Allowance C1Allowance C1Water Tap FeeWater Tap Fee
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C2Allowance C2Water MeterWater Meter
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C3Allowance C3Aid to Construction fo...Aid to Construction fo...
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C4Allowance C4CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $37,950.00 $2,500.00 $8,219.15 $65,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 11 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102, C103, C104, C-105, C106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Combination Bid C102, C103, C104, C-105, C106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,and Electrical) Coshocton FSMFand Electrical) Coshocton FSMF
Allowance C5Allowance C5Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Unit Price U-C1Unit Price U-C1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $5,000.00 $7,128,788.74 $5,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 12 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102, C103, C104, C-105, C106 - AllCombination Bid C102, C103, C104, C-105, C106 - AllTrades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, FireTrades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, FireProtection, HVAC, and Electrical) Coshocton FSMFProtection, HVAC, and Electrical) Coshocton FSMF
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package T102 - General Trades Lead Contract -Bid Package T102 - General Trades Lead Contract -Tuscarawas FSMFTuscarawas FSMF
Allowance T1Allowance T1CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance T2Allowance T2Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $71,820.00 $1,700.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$65,000.00 $5,000.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$65,000.00 $5,000.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$65,000.00 $5,000.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$65,000.00 $5,000.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 13 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package T102 - General Trades Lead Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFBid Package T102 - General Trades Lead Contract - Tuscarawas FSMF
Unit Price U-T1Unit Price U-T1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $5,382,621.22 $219,780.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$293,055.00 $5,382,000.00 $247,600.00 $0.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$418,650.00 $6,358,000.00 $259,000.00 $9,200.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $394,228.75 $5,785,430.00 $219,900.00 $0.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$1,097,560.75 $6,184,047.00 $238,518.00 $0.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$362,830.00 $5,874,000.00 $227,000.00 $0.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 14 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Bid Package T102 - General Trades Lead Contract -Bid Package T102 - General Trades Lead Contract -Tuscarawas FSMFTuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package T103 - Plumbing Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFBid Package T103 - Plumbing Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $200.00 $11,900.00 $454,228.37 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$200.00 $7,370.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$100.00 $7,200.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $180.00 $7,390.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $625,360.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$600,000.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$105.00 $6,825.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$175.00 $6,950.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$556,650.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 15 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package T103 - Plumbing Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFBid Package T103 - Plumbing Contract - Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package T104 - FireBid Package T104 - FireSuppression Suppression Contract -Contract -
Tuscarawas FSMFTuscarawas FSMFBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $90,688.91
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $8,180.00 $0.00 $0.00 $55,400.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$12,415.00 $0.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 16 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package T104 - Fire Suppression Bid Package T104 - Fire Suppression Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFContract - Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 17 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package T105 - HVAC Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFBid Package T105 - HVAC Contract - Tuscarawas FSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $158,713.16 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
$186,800.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $143,452.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$200,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 18 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Bid Package T105 - HVACBid Package T105 - HVACContract - Tuscarawas FSMFContract - Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Bid Package T106 - Electrical ContractBid Package T106 - Electrical ContractBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $872,791.07 $0.00 $10,710.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC $996,600.00 $0.00 $12,000.00
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
$0.00
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
$872,000.00 $0.00 $20,000.00
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc. $724,807.00 $0.00 $12,080.00
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc. $741,700.00 $0.00 $12,977.00
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 19 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameBid Package T106 - Electrical ContractBid Package T106 - Electrical Contract
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Combination Bid T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract -Combination Bid T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract -Tuscarawas FSMFTuscarawas FSMFBase BidBase Bid
All Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $1,500.00 $0.00 $612,941.53 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC $2,900.00 $0.00
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
$2,000.00 $0.00
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $761,123.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc. $2,080.00 $0.00
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$709,000.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc. $2,147.00 $0.00
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$703,525.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 20 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Combination Bid T102, T103,Combination Bid T102, T103,T104, T105,T106 - All TradesT104, T105,T106 - All TradesContract - (General Trades,Contract - (General Trades,Plumbing, Fire Protection,Plumbing, Fire Protection,
HVAC, and Electrical) -HVAC, and Electrical) -Tuscarawas FSMFTuscarawas FSMF
Allowance T1Allowance T1CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $65,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $8,098.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
$12,415.00 $0.00 $0.00
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 21 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid T102, T103, T104, T105,T106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Combination Bid T102, T103, T104, T105,T106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,and Electrical) - Tuscarawas FSMFand Electrical) - Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance T2Allowance T2Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Unit Price U-T1Unit Price U-T1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $5,000.00 $6,959,042.73 $219,780.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 22 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid T102, T103, T104, T105,T106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades,Combination Bid T102, T103, T104, T105,T106 - All Trades Contract - (General Trades,Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC, and Electrical) - Tuscarawas FSMFPlumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC, and Electrical) - Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Combination Bid C102/T102Combination Bid C102/T102General Trade - Lead -General Trade - Lead -
Contract - Coshocton FSMFContract - Coshocton FSMFand Tuscarawas FSMFand Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance C1Allowance C1Water Tap FeeWater Tap Fee
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $10,710.00 $1,700.00 $11,900.00 $37,950.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$37,950.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$37,950.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $37,950.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$37,950.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$37,950.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 23 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance C4Allowance C4CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C5Allowance C5Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance T1Allowance T1CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance T2Allowance T2Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00 $5,000.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 24 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Unit Price U-C1Unit Price U-C1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Unit Price U-T1Unit Price U-T1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $10,803,417.20 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$37,576.00 $293,055.00 $10,494,000.00 $0.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$73,200.00 $418,650.00 $11,867,000.00 $18,275.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $68,930.00 $394,228.75 $11,065,200.00 $0.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$191,906.00 $1,097,560.75 $12,207,481.00 $0.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$36,600.00 $362,830.00 $11,699,000.00 $0.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 25 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $219,780.00 $0.00 $0.00 $200.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$247,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $200.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$259,000.00 $9,200.00 $9,200.00 $100.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $219,900.00 $0.00 $0.00 $180.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$238,518.00 $0.00 $0.00 $105.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$227,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $175.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 26 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - ContractCombination Bid C102/T102 General Trade - Lead - Contract- Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF- Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Combination Bid C103/T103 - Plumbing Contract -Combination Bid C103/T103 - Plumbing Contract -Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCoshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance C2Allowance C2Water MeterWater Meter
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C3Allowance C3Aid to Construction fo...Aid to Construction fo...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $200.00 $11,900.00 $2,500.00 $8,219.15
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
$200.00 $7,370.00
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
$100.00 $7,200.00
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation $180.00 $7,390.00
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $2,500.00 $8,219.15
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$2,500.00 $8,219.15
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
$105.00 $6,825.00
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
$175.00 $6,950.00
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 27 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C103/T103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C103/T103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $923,811.34 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $1,152,237.00 $0.00 $0.00 $21,648.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$1,094,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $7,500.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 28 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C103/T103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C103/T103 - Plumbing Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $8,180.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 29 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid Package C104/T104 - Fire Suppression Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid Package C104/T104 - Fire Suppression Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $173,556.49 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $112,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation $127,745.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 30 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid Package C104/T104 - Fire Suppression Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid Package C104/T104 - Fire Suppression Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 31 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid Package C105/T105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid Package C105/T105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $439,542.19 $5,000.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
$448,300.00 $11,700.00 $0.00 $0.00
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $361,619.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$550,000.00 $7,500.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc. $425,272.00 $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 32 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid Package C105/T105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid Package C105/T105 - HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc. $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 33 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid Package C106/T106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid Package C106/T106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $1,747,504.44 $0.00 $0.00 $71,820.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc. $1,540,000.00 $547.00 $0.00 $141,471.00
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 34 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid Package C106/T106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid Package C106/T106 - Electrical Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service Generator.Full Service Generator.
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $10,710.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc. $12,977.00 $1,874.00 $2,147.00 $0.00
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 35 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C103/C105/T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C103/C105/T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance C2Allowance C2Water MeterWater Meter
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C3Allowance C3Aid to Construction fo...Aid to Construction fo...
Lump SumLump Sum
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $2,500.00 $8,219.15 $1,363,353.53 $5,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $2,500.00 $8,219.15 $1,506,285.00 $7,679.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$2,500.00 $8,219.15 $1,480,000.00 $7,500.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 36 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness NameCombination Bid C103/C105/T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFCombination Bid C103/C105/T103/T105 - Plumbing and HVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $21,431.00 $8,098.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $7,500.00 $0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 37 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C103/C105/T103/T105 - Plumbing andCombination Bid C103/C105/T103/T105 - Plumbing andHVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFHVAC Contract - Coshocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All TradesCombination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All TradesContract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,
and Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFand Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFAllowance C1Allowance C1
Water Tap FeeWater Tap FeeLump SumLump Sum
Allowance C2Allowance C2Water MeterWater Meter
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $0.00 $0.00 $37,950.00 $2,500.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc. $0.00 $0.00
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
$0.00 $0.00
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 38 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,and Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFand Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance C3Allowance C3Aid to Construction fo...Aid to Construction fo...
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C4Allowance C4CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance C5Allowance C5Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Allowance T1Allowance T1CPM Scheduling ConsultantCPM Scheduling Consultant
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $8,219.15 $65,000.00 $5,000.00 $65,000.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 39 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,and Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFand Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Allowance T2Allowance T2Partnering FacilitatorPartnering Facilitator
Lump SumLump Sum
Unit Price U-C1Unit Price U-C1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Unit Price U-T1Unit Price U-T1Unsuitable SoilsUnsuitable Soils
Cubic YardsCubic Yards
Base BidBase BidAll Labor and Material...All Labor and Material...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $5,000.00 $14,087,831.47
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 40 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades, Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC,and Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFand Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 1Alternate 1Backdraft Welding TableBackdraft Welding Table
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 2Alternate 2Additional PavementAdditional Pavement
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 3Alternate 3Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 4Alternate 4Full Service GeneratorFull Service Generator
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $5,000.00 $219,780.00 $71,820.00 $10,710.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 41 of 42 12/07/2016
Business NameBusiness Name
Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades,Combination Bid C102 to C106 and T102 to T106 All Trades Contract (General Trades,Plumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC, and Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMFPlumbing, Fire Protection, HVAC, and Electrical) Coschocton FSMF and Tuscarawas FSMF
Alternate 5Alternate 5Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 6Alternate 6Additional Control Sta...Additional Control Sta...
Lump SumLump Sum
Alternate 7Alternate 7Additional Guard Rail ...Additional Guard Rail ...
Lump SumLump Sum
Agency Estimate: $1,700.00 $1,700.00 $11,900.00
Robertson ConstructionServices, Inc.
Vaughn Industries, LLC
Charter Hill Construction,Inc.
Regency ConstructionServices, Inc
York Mahoning MechanicalContractors, Inc.
The Knoch Corporation
Hilscher Clark ElectricCompany
Gutridge Plumbing, Inc.
Abbott Electric, Inc.
Peterman Plumbing &Heating, Inc.
MIKE COATESCONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
Jeffrey Carr ConstructionInc.
Wood Electric, Inc.
Fire Foe Corporation
De-Cal Inc.
R.T. Hampton Plumbing andHeating, Inc.
16 Bidders16 Bidders
DOT-130010 Page 42 of 42 12/07/2016