snowden's qa on reddit

3
In case you missed it, Edward Snowden, Glenn Greenwald, and Laura Poitras recently gave a Q & A on Reddit's /IAmA. Everyone should check out the thread because it is one of the only opportunities to get to hear Snowden's own views on topics ranging from the NSA leaks to the pros of living in Russia. However, one of Snowden's replies in particular lingered with me. Here is the comment (emphasis mine): To tag on to the Putin question: There's not, and that's part of the problem world-wide. We can't just reform the laws in one country, wipe our hands, and call it a day. We have to ensure that our rights aren't just being protected by letters on a sheet of paper somewhere, or those protections will evaporate the minute our communications get routed across a border. The only way to ensure the human rights of citizens around the world are being respected in the digital realm is to enforce them through systems and standards rather than policies and procedures. Ancient by most media standards, the National Security Agencies’ systemic abuse of privacy remains a pressing and continuing issue. Despite the lack of coverage, countless organizations and individuals are still pushing for privacy reforms and Snowden’s comment touches on an issue that seems to be under-emphasized. While policy changes and enforcement are critical and necessary to make progress towards better privacy protection, creating a broad coalition and using personal privacy protection are required to create real and sustainable privacy protection. Government spying and privacy violations have seemingly fallen to the backburner for many activists and average citizens. Both Congress and President Obama feigned concern over the massive violation of American’s privacy, but have done absolutely nothing to stop it. Activists should expect any reforms that come to fruition to preserve the government’s current powers and operations while simultaneously saving face. Snowden is right that if we really want to protect our privacy, we need to make it a global issue for everyone and citizens must take it upon themselves to protect their privacy with whatever means possible. Anything short of this, and privacy protection is guaranteed only

Upload: elias-garcia

Post on 16-Aug-2015

220 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

DESCRIPTION

a short article I wrote for SFL on Snowden and Reddit, rough draft

TRANSCRIPT

In case you missed it, Edward Snowden, Glenn Greenwald, and Laura Poitras recently gave a Q & A on Reddit's /IAmAEveryone s!ould c!ec" out t!e t!read #ecause it is one o$ t!e only o%%ortunities to get to !ear Snowden's own views on to%ics ranging $rom t!e &SA lea"s to t!e %ros o$ living in Russia'owever, one o$ Snowden's re%lies in %articular lingered wit! me'ere is t!e comment (em%!asis mine)*+o tag on to t!e Putin ,uestion* +!ere's not, and t!at's %art o$ t!e %ro#lem world-wide We can't just reform the laws in one country,wi%e our !ands, and call it a day We have to ensure that our rightsaren't just being protected by letters on a sheet of paper somewhere, or t!ose %rotections will eva%orate t!e minute our communications get routed across a #order +!e only way to ensure t!e !uman rig!ts o$ citi.ens around t!e world are #eing res%ected in t!e digital realm is to enforce them through systems and standards rather than policies and procedures.Ancient #y most media standards, t!e &ational Security Agencies/ systemic a#use o$ %rivacy remains a %ressing and continuing issue0es%ite t!e lac" o$ coverage, countless organi.ations and individuals are still %us!ing $or %rivacy re$orms and Snowden/s comment touc!es on an issue t!at seems to #e under-em%!asi.ed1!ile %olicy c!anges and en$orcement are critical and necessary to ma"e %rogress towards #etter %rivacy %rotection, creating a #road coalition and using %ersonal %rivacy %rotection are re,uired to createreal and sustaina#le %rivacy %rotectionGovernment s%ying and %rivacy violations !ave seemingly $allen to t!e #ac"#urner $or many activists and average citi.ens2ot! 3ongress and President 4#ama $eigned concern over t!e massive violation o$ American/s %rivacy, #ut !ave done a#solutely not!ing to sto% itActivists s!ould e5%ect any re$orms t!at come to $ruition to %reserve t!e government/s current %owers and o%erations w!ile simultaneously saving $aceSnowden is rig!t t!at i$ we really want to %rotect our %rivacy, we need to ma"e it a glo#al issue $or everyone and citi.ens must ta"e it u%on t!emselves to %rotect t!eir %rivacy wit! w!atever means %ossi#leAnyt!ing s!ort o$ t!is, and %rivacy %rotection is guaranteed only #y 6a s!eet o$ %a%er somew!ere,7 doomed to 6eva%orate t!e minute our communications get routed across a #order7 Since t!e internet is glo#al #y nature, e8ective %rivacy %rotection re,uires su%%ort t!at transcends #orders+!is is not to say t!at a multilateral coalition does not already e5ist, #ecause it de9nitely doesGrou%s li"e 1i"i%edia, t!e Electronic :rontier :oundation, and 1i"iLea"s all wor" across #orders to !el% coordinate activists and %rotests against intrusive government surveillance1!at needs em%!asis is t!at ot!er governments are guilty o$ t!e same crimes as t!e &SA, a conce%t neglected #y media coverage and %olicy $ramingEven i$ su#stantial re$orms %ass in a country, citi.ens are still vulnera#le to t!e actions o$ intelligence agencies ran #y ot!er countriesAdditionally, de$ending %rivacy t!roug! active %ersonal met!ods o$ %rotection is integralEntrusting government, t!e same institution t!at !as !istorical violated %rivacy rig!ts re%eatedly, to %rotect %rivacy wit! laws t!at !ave re%eatedly #een ignored or annulled is na;ve and s!ortsig!tedIn t!e same /IAmA discussion, Greenwald said it #est in an e5cer%t $rom one o$ !is re%lies6+!e or internet cor%orations are ado%ting stronger %rivacy 6systems and standards7 #ecauseo$ consumer demands and to %rotect #usiness o%erations3iti.ens s!ould $ollow suit in %rotecting t!eir own %rivacyAdvocacy can never sto% i$ activists want a $uture wit! sustaina#le %rivacy %rotectionSo long as grou%s li"e t!e :ive Eyes remain, t!e tension #etweenciti.ens/ rig!ts and government %ower will remain as well+!e world 9nds itsel$ at a ma>or crossroad in !istory wit! t!e growt! o$ internet and communications? w!et!er %rivacy and tec!nical innovation can coe5ist in t!is new world will de%end on !ow its citi.ens reactLeaving %rivacy and its %rotection to t!e maw o$ government control will surely doom us to a world wit!out t!is co!a#itation 4nly once citi.ens in Germany, England, t!e