smucker (jm) (sjm) earnings report: q4 2016 conference ... · welcome to the j. m. smucker...

30
Company Name: JM Smucker Co Company Ticker: SJM Sector: Consumer Goods Industry: Food & Beverage Event Description: Q4 2016 Earnings Call Market Cap as of Event Date: 15.88B Price as of Event Date: 144.1215 © 2014 TheStreet, Inc. All Rights Reserved Page 1 of 30 Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference Call Transcript The following Smucker (JM) conference call took place on June 9, 2016, 08:30 AM ET. This is a transcript of that earnings call: Company Participants Aaron Broholm; J M Smucker Company; Investor Relations Richard Smucker; J M Smucker Company; Executive Chairman Mark Smucker; J M Smucker Company; President & CEO Mark Belgya; J M Smucker Company; CFO Vince Byrd; J M Smucker Company; Vice Chairman Steve Oakland; J M Smucker Company; President, US Food and Beverage Barry Dunaway; J M Smucker Company; President, Pet Food and Pet Snacks Other Participants Andrew Lazar; Barclays Capital; Analyst David Driscoll; Citigroup; Analyst Chris Growe; Stifel Nicolaus; Analyst Ken Goldman; JPMorgan; Analyst Jason English; Goldman Sachs; Analyst Alexia Howard; Sanford C. Bernstein & Co; Analyst Mario Contreras; Deutsche Bank; Analyst Pablo Zuanic; SIG; Analyst Matthew Grainger; Morgan Stanley; Analyst Akshay Jagdale; Jefferies LLC; Analyst Gregory Nep; Stephens Inc; Analyst Chuck Cerankosky; Northcoast Research; Analyst Rob Dickerson; Consumer Edge Research; Analyst MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION SECTION Operator : Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now turn the conference call over to Aaron Broholm, Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead, sir. Aaron Broholm (Investor Relations): Good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us on our fourth quarter earnings conference call. With me today and presenting our prepared remarks are Richard Smucker, Executive Chairman; Mark Smucker, President and Chief Executive Officer; and Mark Belgya, Chief Financial Officer. Also joining us for the Q&A portion of the call are Steve Oakland, President US Food and Beverage, and Barry

Upload: others

Post on 24-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page1of30

Smucker(JM)(SJM)EarningsReport:Q42016ConferenceCallTranscriptThefollowingSmucker(JM)conferencecalltookplaceonJune9,2016,08:30AMET.Thisisatranscriptofthatearningscall:

CompanyPart icipants

AaronBroholm;JMSmuckerCompany;InvestorRelationsRichardSmucker;JMSmuckerCompany;ExecutiveChairmanMarkSmucker;JMSmuckerCompany;President&CEOMarkBelgya;JMSmuckerCompany;CFOVinceByrd;JMSmuckerCompany;ViceChairmanSteveOakland;JMSmuckerCompany;President,USFoodandBeverageBarryDunaway;JMSmuckerCompany;President,PetFoodandPetSnacks

OtherPart icipants

AndrewLazar;BarclaysCapital;AnalystDavidDriscoll;Citigroup;AnalystChrisGrowe;StifelNicolaus;AnalystKenGoldman;JPMorgan;AnalystJasonEnglish;GoldmanSachs;AnalystAlexiaHoward;SanfordC.Bernstein&Co;AnalystMarioContreras;DeutscheBank;AnalystPabloZuanic;SIG;AnalystMatthewGrainger;MorganStanley;AnalystAkshayJagdale;JefferiesLLC;AnalystGregoryNep;StephensInc;AnalystChuckCerankosky;NorthcoastResearch;AnalystRobDickerson;ConsumerEdgeResearch;Analyst

MANAGEMENTDISCUSSIONSECTION

Operator :

WelcometotheJ.M.SmuckerCompany'sfourthquarter2016earningsconferencecall.

(OperatorInstructions)

IwillnowturntheconferencecallovertoAaronBroholm,VicePresident,InvestorRelations.Pleasegoahead,sir.

AaronBroholm(InvestorRelations):

Goodmorning,everyone.Thankyouforjoiningusonourfourthquarterearningsconferencecall.

WithmetodayandpresentingourpreparedremarksareRichardSmucker,ExecutiveChairman;MarkSmucker,PresidentandChiefExecutiveOfficer;andMarkBelgya,ChiefFinancialOfficer.AlsojoiningusfortheQ&AportionofthecallareSteveOakland,PresidentUSFoodandBeverage,andBarry

Page 2: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page2of30

Dunaway,PresidentPetFoodandPetSnacks.VinceByrd,ViceChairman,isalsoonthelinefromanotherlocation.

Duringthisconferencecall,wewillmakeforward-lookingstatementsthatreflecttheCompany'scurrentexpectationsaboutfutureplansandperformance.Thesestatementsrelyonanumberofassumptionsandestimates,andactualresultsmaydiffermateriallyduetorisksanduncertainties.

Iencourageyoutoreadthefulldisclosurestatementinthismorning'spressreleaseconcerningforward-lookingstatements.Additionally,pleasenotetheCompanyusesnon-GAAPresultsforthepurposeofevaluatingperformanceinternallyasdetailedinthepressrelease,whichislocatedonourcorporatewebsiteatjmsmucker.com.

Asweindicatedearlierinthecalendaryear,wearetransitioningtoonenon-GAAPearningspersharemetricin2017,whichexcludesnon-cashintangibleamortization.WewillrefertothisasadjustedEPS.

Amortizationexpensewillalsoberemovedfromourdefinitionofsegmentprofit,aswellasnon-GAAPoperatingincome,andnetincome.

WewillfileaForm8-Klaterthisquartertorecastprioryearsegmentresultstoreflectthenewdefinition.

Wehavepostedtoourwebsiteacoupleofsupplementaryslides,includingabridgefromourFY16resultstoourFY17adjustedEPSguidance.Theseslidescanbeaccessedthroughthelinktothewebcastofthiscall.Thisdocumentandareplayofthiscallwillbearchivedonourwebsite.

Ifyouhaveanyquestionsaftertoday'scall,pleasecontactme.

IwillnowturnthecallovertoRichard.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Thankyou,Aaron.Goodmorning,everyone.Thankyouforjoiningus.

FY16wasadynamicandexcitingyearfortheSmuckerCompany,asourteamsdeliveredonanumberofkeystrategicinitiatives.Theseincludedsignificantlyimprovingtheperformanceofourcoffeebusiness,reflectinglaunchoftheDunkin'DonutsK-Cups,andreturningmomentumtoourmainstreamcoffeebusiness,expandingdistributionforourNaturalBalancepetbrand,executingaseamlessintegrationofthepetfoodbusiness,exceedingoursynergyandworkingcapitaltargetsfortheyear,divestingourUScannedmilkbusiness,allresultinginrecordfinancialperformanceandearnings,andcashflowthatexceededourexpectations.

Letmeexpandontheresultsfortheyear.Netsalesincreased37%to$7.8billion,reflectingthefullyearcontributionofBigHeartpetbrand.Excludingacquisitions,divestituresandforeignexchange,salesincreased3%forthefullyear.

Non-GAAPoperatingincomewasup49%to$1.28billion,withthecontributionsfrompetandstrongcoffeesegmentprofitgrowthbeingthekeydrivers.Non-GAAPearningspersharewere$6.57includingaone-time$[0.42]persharenon-cashbenefit.Thiscomparestoourmostrecentguidanceof$5.84to$5.94whichexcludedthetaxbenefit.

Lastly,theCompanygeneratedfreecashflowof$1.26billionwhichiswellaboveouroriginalestimate.Reflectingthisstrongcashflow,weexceededourdeleveragingobjectivefortheyear,reducingtotaldebtbynearly$750million.Wealsoreturnedover$750millionofcashtoshareholdersintheformofsharerepurchasesanddividends.

Therewerenumerousaccomplishmentsduringthepastfiscalyear,andthisperformanceisatestamentto

Page 3: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page3of30

thededicationofouremployees,andwethankthemfortheircontinuedefforts.Wearewell-positionedtocontinuethismomentumintoFY17.

Sincethelasttimewespoketomanyofyou,weannouncedseveralexecutiveappointmentsthatareconsistentwiththeCompany'shistoryoflong-termsuccessionplanning,andthedevelopmentofleadershiptomeetthecurrentandfutureneedsofourbusiness,andtheconstituentsthatweserve.EffectiveMay1,MarkSmuckerassumedtheroleofPresidentandChiefExecutiveOfficer.MarkandhisexperiencedleadershipteamembodythevaluesthathavecontributedtotheCompany'ssuccessandlong-termgrowth.Iamconfidentthatundertheirdirection,theCompanywillcontinuetoinnovate,evolve,andgrowintheyearstocome.

ItsbeenanhonortoserveasCEOoftheSmuckerCompany,andIamgratefultohaveworkedalongsidethemosttalentedteamintheindustry.IwillcontinuetoservetheCompanyasExecutiveChairman.Amongotherareas,myeffortswillbefocusedonBoard-relatedmatters,counselandadviceonstrategicdecisions,enhancingcustomerrelationships,andadvancingourindustryleadershipefforts.MybrotherTimhasbeenappointedtotheroleofChairmanEmeritus,andwealsolookforwardtohiscontinuedcontributions.

Lastly,IwouldliketorecognizeVinceByrd,whoisparticipatinginhisfinalearningscall,ashisretirementafter39yearswiththeCompanyiseffectivetomorrow.Vince'scontributionshavehelpedshapetheCompanythatwearetoday,andwillcontinuetobereflectedinthenumerousemployeesthathehasmentoredthroughouthiscareer.

Withthat,I'llturnthecallovertoMark.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Thankyou,Richard.Goodmorning,everyone.

Asyouknow,ourCompanyisunique,inbeingledbyonlysixCEOsinits119-yearhistory.IamhonoredtosucceedRichardasCEO,andserveasastewardofthisgreatCompany.

RichardhasledourCompanythroughaperiodofsignificantexpansionandstrategictransformation.Asaresult,ourCompanyisstrongerthanever.Iamexcitedtoleadourtalentedteam,leveragingthecontinuedcounselofRichard,Dad,andouroutstandingBoardtodrivecontinuedgrowthandshareholdervalue.IalsowouldliketoechoRichard'scommentsaboutVince,andthankhimforhiscontributionsandmentorship.

Thefocusofmycommentstodaywillbetoprovideanupdateonourbusinesssegments,includingadditionalcoloronfullyear2016performance,andinitialthoughtsonFY17.I'llstartwithourcoffeebusinesswhichfarexceededexpectationsfortheyear.Netsaleswereup8%andsegmentprofitincreased18%to$646million,representingafullrecoveryofthesegmentprofitdeclineintheprioryear.ThisoutperformancewasdrivenbyseveralfactorsincludingthesuccessfullaunchofDunkin'DonutsK-cups,theimplementationoftheplannedFolgerscanisterdownsize,amoderationincompetitiveactivities,andthenetbenefitoflowercommoditycostsandpricing.

ProvidinglowerpricingonFolgersroastandgroundcoffeeresultedinimprovedperformanceforourmainstreamcoffeebusinessin2016.Tonnageforourmainstreambrandswasup3%,whileunitsshippedwereupevenmore,giventhecanisterdownsizeearlyinthefiscalyear.Inaddition,ourdollarsharewithinthemainstreamsegmentofthecoffeecategoryincreasednearly2sharepointsto55%forthelatest52weekperiod.

Weanticipatemomentuminthecoffeebusinesstocontinuein2017.KeyinitiativesincludeFolgers'

Page 4: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page4of30

sponsorshipoftheUSOlympicteamfortheupcomingRiogames,withmarketingactivitiesalreadyunderway.Inaddition,lastmonth,weimplementeda6%listpricedeclineacrossmuchofourcoffeeportfolio,reflectingsustainedlowergreencoffeecosts.Theselowercostshavebeenreflectedinpromotionalpricingforthepastseveralquarters,andwedonotanticipatepromotedpriceschangingsignificantly.

WithregardstoFolgersK-Cups,in2016thebrandwasimpactedbytheongoingproliferationofentrantsintotheK-Cupspace,includingourintroductionofDunkin'K-Cups.Thisyear,wewillinvestfurtherintheproductlinetoimprovetrends,includinglowerpricingandnewpackagingthatwillleveragetheiconicFolgersredcanbrandequity.

TurningtotheDunkin'Donutsbrand,Dunkin'K-Cupsachievednearly$220millioninretailsalesforthelatest52weekscanperiod,andgaineda6%dollarshareoftheK-Cupmarket,givingusanoverallshareofnearly15%intheK-Cupsegment.

Initsfirstyearonthemarket,theDunkin'DonutsoriginalSKUhasbecomethenumberoneK-Cupiteminthechannelsinwhichweparticipate.Asconsumerrepeatratesremainstrong,andwithopportunitiestointroduceadditionalvarieties,weanticipatefurthergrowthin2017.

Whilechallengedformuchof2016,performanceimprovedforDunkin'Donutsbaggedcoffeeduringthefourthquarter.Supportedbyfavorableinputcosts,wehavesharpenedpricingtoimprovegapstokeycompetitorsandwelookforpositivevolumetrendstocontinue.Lastly,withincoffee,theCafeBustelobrandexperiencedasecondconsecutiveyearofdouble-digitsalesgrowthbehindstrongperformanceforbothroastandgroundandK-Cupofferings.Thisexcitingon-trendbrandremainswell-receivedbymillennials,anditsgrowthisexpectedtocontinuealsoin2017.

Turningtoconsumerfoods,netsalesdeclined3%fortheyear,mostlyduetolappingsalesfromthedivestedcannedmilkbusiness.Segmentprofitwasflattoprioryear,supportedbythegainonthemilkbusinesssalewhichoffsetplannedincreasesinmanufacturingoverheadcosts.

Lookingbrieflyatthekeybrands,wearepleasedwiththeoverallperformanceofourspreadsbusiness,asbothJifpeanutbutterandSmuckersfruitspreadsgrewvolumeshareoverthelatest52weekperiod.Inaddition,SmuckersUncrustablesfrozensandwicheshadanotherstrongyear,withvolumeup26%includinga17thconsecutivequarterofdouble-digitvolumegrowthinthismostrecentfourthquarter.

On-trendinnovationcontinuestobeafocusareafortheiconicJifandSmuckersbrands.InFY17,welooktobuildonrecentsuccessfullaunchessuchasSmuckersFruit&HoneyFruitSpreadsandJifsnackbars.Thisincludestheupcomingintroductionofnewsnackbarvarieties,andplanstoexpandintoothersnackingplatforms.Inaddition,Jif,Smuckers,andUncrustablesareallparticipatinginthe2016Olympicsponsorship,whichwillbeanintegralpartofthisyear'smarketingeffortsforthebrand.

Inthebakeaisle,theoverallcategoryremainschallengedthroughoutmuchofthispastyear,reflectingchangingconsumerpreferencesandaggressivecompetitivepricing.Ourfocusremainsonprovidingvalue-addedinnovation,suchasourrecentglutenfreeandsimpleingredientofferings.WearealsoexcitedtoannouncealicensingarrangementwiththeGirlScoutsofAmerica.Underthisagreement,wearelaunchingnewPillsburyitemsfeaturingiconicGirlScoutcookieflavors.

Withinnaturalfoods,ourleadingR.W.KnudsenfamilyandSantaCruzorganicbrandsbothachievedsolidsalesgrowthin2016.Thekeynaturalfoodscategoriesinwhichourbrandsparticipatearegrowing,whichgivesusconfidenceinmaintainingourmomentuminthisbusiness.WearealsoexcitedaboutourrecentinvestmentintheNumibrand,andtheopportunitiesthisprovidesintheorganicteacategory.

Underourfirstyearofownership,petfoodssegmentprofitof$392millionwasgenerallyinlinewithexpectations.Netsalesof$2.25billionfell1%shortoftheprojectionsprovidedatourOctoberInvestor

Page 5: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page5of30

Day,duetocompetitivechallengesinmainstreamdrydogfood.Fortheyear,mainstreampetfoodsalesdecreasedmidsingle-digits,reflectingdouble-digitdeclinesindogfood,andalowsingle-digitdeclineforthelargercatfoodbusiness.Offsettingthelowermainstreamsaleswasthestrongperformanceofourpetsnacksbusiness,whichwasupmidsingle-digitsovertheprioryear,andourpremiumpetfoodbrandswhichgrewdouble-digitsbehindexpandeddistributionoftheNaturalBalancebrand.

Asweenter2017,weanticipatecontinuedgrowthforNaturalBalance,aswelaunchthebrand'sfirstnationalmarketingcampaignalongwithadditionalin-storesupport.Withinpetsnacks,innovationfortheMilk-BoneandtheMeowMixbrandswerekeycontributorsto2016results,andweexpecttosee--tobuildonthesetrendswithnewproductintroductionsthisfiscalyear.

Wealsocontinuetofocusonopportunitiesinmainstreampetfood,drivenbyconsumerpreferenceforadditionalproteinandnaturalingredients.Lastlywithinthesegment,weareexcitedaboutourpartnershipandplannedin-storeactivitiesrelatedtotheanimatedfilm,theSecretLifeofPetswhichwillbeintheatresnextmonth.

Turningtointernationalandfoodservice,wearepleasedwiththefullyearresultsdespitethesignificanttopandbottomlineimpactsofforeigncurrency.Reportednetsaleswereinlinewiththeprioryear,astheadditionofthepetfoodbusinessandthebenefitofhighernetpricinginCanadaoffseta$[60]milliontoplineimpactrelatedtoforeignexchange.Segmentprofitwasup12%,mostlyattributabletofoodservice.

TheintroductionofSmuckersUncrustablesintoschoollunchprogramscontributedtothisgrowth.ThestrongunderlyingperformanceofourCanadianbusinesswasmostlyoffsetbytheimpactofforeignexchange.

Letmeconcludewithanupdateonourintegrationandcostsavingsactivities.WesuccessfullyachievedourMarch1integrationmilestoneforthepetfoodbusiness,andrecognizedjustover$35millioninsynergiesfor2016.Inaddition,wehaveclearvisibilityandconfidenceinrealizinganincremental$100millioninsynergiesthisfiscalyear.

Intotal,thiswouldprovideapproximately$135millioninsynergiesfor2017.Lookingahead,weremainconfidentinachievingouroriginalgoalof$200millioninannualsynergiesbytheendofFY18.

Inadditiontothe$200millionofsynergies,wearetargeting$50millionofincrementalannualcostsavingstobefullyrealizedoverthenextfewyears.Relatedprojectsincludefurtheroptimizingourmanufacturingfootprint,asoverthenext18monthswewillcloseacoffeefacilityinHarahan,Louisiana,andtwoleasednaturalfoodsfacilitieslocatedinLivermore,California,withproductionbeingconsolidatedintoexistingoperations.Inaddition,wearenearlycompletewithanorganizationalredesignaimedatfurtheroptimizingcorporateresourcescontributingtothiscostsavingstarget.

Weexpecttoinitiallyinvestmuchoftheseincrementalsavingsinseveralidentifiedareas.Wewillcontinuetoprioritizeinvestmentsthatgeneratetopandbottomlinegrowthforkeyon-trendplatforms.InFY17,theseincludeopportunitiesrelatedtoSmuckersUncrustables,coffee,andsnacks.

Wearealsoestablishinganewgrowthinnovationorganization,whichisbeingledbyamemberofmyleadershipteam.Thegroupisbeingtaskedwithfurtherbuildingcapabilitiesrelatedtoconsumerandmarketinsights,digital,innovation,targetedmarketdevelopmentstrategiesforourcustomers,includingpricingandtradespendoptimization.Lastly,weplantoinvestinnewgrowthopportunitiestoexpandourpresenceinChina.

Inclosing,2016wasahistoricyearforourCompany,andIwouldliketothankouremployeesfortheirefforts.Asweenter2017,keyprioritiesincludeachievingoursynergygoals,buildingonourproduct

Page 6: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page6of30

innovations,activities,andinvestinginnewcapabilitiestoenhancefuturegrowth.Overall,weremainconfidentinourlong-termstrategy,thestrengthofourbrands,andourabilitytodelivershareholdervaluein2017andbeyond.

IwillnowturnthecallovertoMarkBelgya.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Thankyou,Mark.Goodmorning,everyone.

Iwillbeginbyprovidingcommentaryonourfourthquarterresults,followedby2016cashflowperformance,andendingwithour2017outlook.Weconcludedthefiscalyearwithstrongfourthquarterearnings.

Non-GAAPearningspersharewere$1.86forthequarter,includingaone-time$0.42persharenon-cashdeferredtaxbenefitrelatedtotheintegrationofBigHeartintotheSmuckerCompany,aswaspreviewedduringourthirdQuartercall.

Thisstrongfinishtotheyearwasmostlyattributabletocoffee,includinghigherthananticipatedvolumeacrossourmainstreamandpremiumcoffeebrands,andafavorablepricetocostrelationship.

Thecomparisonoffourthquarterearningsbetweenyearsissignificantlyimpactedbyone-timeitemsreportedineachoftherespectiveperiods.Theseincludethedeferredtaxbenefitinthecurrentyear,aswellastheBigHeartacquisition,andfinancingrelatedactivitiesintheprioryear.Asaresult,theremainderofmyfourthquartercommentarywillbefocusedonthebusinesssegment.

Beginningwithcoffee,fourthquarternetsalesgrew9%,asfavorablevolumemixof13%wasonlypartiallyoffsetbylowernetpricing.SalesfortheDunkin'Donutsbranddoubledovertheprioryear,withK-Cupsdrivingmuchofthisgrowth.Double-digitgainsforbaggedDunkin'Donutscoffeealsocontributed.FortheFolgersbrand,netsalesdeclined5%attributabletolowernetpricerealization.Andlastly,CafeBustelosaleswereup28%,asthemomentumforthisbrandcontinued.

Segmentprofitincreased$43millionor39%.Werecognizedlowergreencoffeecostsinthequarter,whichwerepartiallyoffsetbylowernetpricing.Inaddition,highervolumemixmorethanoffsetincreaseinmarketing.

Turningtoconsumerfoods,netsaleswereup5%excludingtheimpactofthecannedmilkdivestiture,withgainsacrossthemajorityofourkeybrands.SalesforJifgrew14%behindhighervolumeandnetpricing,whiletheSmuckersbrandwasup3%asUncrustableshadanotherstrongquarter.

Inthebakeaisle,salesforCriscoincreased6%drivenbyhighervolume.Andlastly,salesforthePillsburybrandwereupmodestly,ashigherpricerealizationoffsetvolumedecline.

Segmentprofitdeclined6%,mostlyattributabletolappingtheprioryearearningsofthedivestedmilkbusiness.Plannedincreasesinmanufacturingoverheadcostsalsocontributed,reflectingthenewpeanutbutterfacilityinMemphis,aswellasunderabsorbedoverheadcostsrelatedtoourworkingcapitalinitiatives.Thesefactorsoffsetlowermarketingexpense.

NetsalesforourUSretailpetfoodssegmentswere$[563]million.Weestimatethisrepresentsanapproximate3%increasecomparedtotheprioryearfourthquarter,ofwhichsixweekswerereportedunderourownership.Salesforourpremiumpetbrandsgrewlowdouble-digitsdrivenbyNaturalBalance,whilepetsnackssalesincreasedinlinewiththeoverallsegment.

Mainstreampetfoodssaleswereflatcomparedtotheprioryear,asgrowthinourcatfoodbrandsoffset

Page 7: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page7of30

declinesindogfood.Petfoodsegmentprofitwas$117millionforthequarter.Asexpected,werealizedasequentialincreaseinsegmentprofitmarginfrom17%inthethirdquarterto20.7%thisquarter,primarilyreflectinglowermarketingexpense.Incrementalsynergyrecognitionalsocontributed.

Netsalesforinternationalandfoodserviceincreased1%inthequarter,reflectingthehighervolumemixinfoodservice.InCanada,theadditionofpetfoodwasessentiallyoffsetbytheimpactofFX.Segmentprofitwasup8%overtheprioryeardrivenbyourfoodservicebusiness,partiallyoffsetbytheimpactofforeignexchangeinCanada.

Freecashflowwas$295millionforthequarter,bringingthe2016totalto$1.26billion.Theoutperformancecomparedtoourmostrecentfreecashflowguidanceof$975millionwasattributabletoexceedingour2016workingcapitalimprovementtarget,lowerthanprojectedCapExspending,afourthquartertaxrefundof$53millionwhichisseparatefromthedeferredtaxadjustmentimpactingearningsandhighernetincome.

Expandingonourworkingcapitalinitiatives,in2016werealizedthemajorityofourfinishedgoodsinventoryreductiongoalof$200million,nearlyayearaheadofschedule.In2017,weexpecttoachievetheremainderoftheinventoryreductiontarget,alongwithmodestworkingcapitalimprovementsrelatedtoaccountspayableandreceivables,allofwhicharefactoredintoour2017freecashflowoutlookIwilldiscussinamoment.

Weendedtheyearwithdebtof$5.4billion.Basedon2016EBITDAof$1.58billion,ourleveragestoodat3.4timesatApril30,areductionfrom4.1timesatthebeginningoftheyear.

Inadditiontoexceedingourdebtpaydowntargetfortheyear,wewereabletorestartsharerepurchaseactivities,aidedbythestrongfreecashflowandproceedsfromthedivestitureofthemilkbusiness.

Duringthefourthquarter,werepurchasednearly3%ofsharesoutstandingforapproximately$430million.In2017,thelowersharecountwilloffsettheEPSimpactoftheeightmonthsoflostprofitrelatedtothedivestedmilkbusiness.

Turningtoour2017outlook,weanticipatereportednetsalestodecreaseby1%comparedtotheprioryear,aswewilllapapproximately$150millionofsalesrelatedtothemilkdivestiture.Excludingthisimpact,netsalesareprojectedtobeup1%.Favorablevolumemixacrosseachofthesegments,includingthebenefitofnewproductsisexpectedtobemostlyoffsetbylowerpricinginUSretailcoffeeandFXinCanada.Approximately$25millionoftheincremental$100millionofsynergiesfor2017areexpectedtobenefitgrossprofit.

Overallcommoditycostsareanticipatedtobelower,however,ourCanadianbusinessisestimatingaCOGSheadwindof$20millionrelatedtoFX,ofwhichaportionisexpectedtobeoffset.Asaresult,weexpectgrossmargintoapproximate39%in2017.FurtherSG&Aexpensesareprojectedtobecomparabletotheprioryear.Thisreflectsthebenefitofincrementalsynergiesrelatedtoheadcountreductionsandotheradministrativecostsavings,offsetbyincreasedmarketinginsupportofrecentlylaunchedproducts,ourOlympicsponsorship,innovationandregulatoryexpenses.

We'reprojectingnon-GAAPoperatingincomegrowthof4%in2017,comparedto$1.465billionintheprioryear,whichexcludesamortization,andtheprioryeargainonsaleof$25million.Further,excludingthe$32millionofprofitinlastyear'soperatingincomerelatedtothedivestedmilkbusiness,thegrowthwouldbe6%.

Belowoperatingincome,weexpectnetinterestexpenseofapproximately$165millionandataxrateof34%.Andlastly,aweightedaveragesharecountof116.6millionshareswasusedbasedoncurrentsharesoutstanding.

Page 8: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page8of30

Factoringinallofthis,weareguiding2017adjustedEPSintherangeof$7.60to$7.75,whichexcludes$1.18pershareofestimatednon-cashamortization.Includingtheamortization,thisyieldsarangeof$6.42to$6.57comparedtoa2016baseof$6.Thisresultsinyear-over-yearincreasesrangingfrom7%to10%.

Asillustratedonthedocumentpostedonourwebsite,wederivethe$6.00EPSfor2016,bysubtractingthe$0.42deferredtaxadjustmentandthe$0.15milkgainfromourreportednon-GAAPEPSof$6.57.WeanticipatemuchoftheEPSgrowthfortheyeartobeweightedtowardthemiddletwoquartersofthefiscalyearduetocertainfactors.Lastyear'sfirstquarterincludedthelaunchofDunkin'K-Cups.

Alsowithincoffee,thisyear'sfirstquarterwillbeunfavorablyimpactedduetotimingassociatedwiththefullquarterimpactofthepricedecreasetakeninJulyof2015,alongwiththeadditionalpricedeclinetakeninMayofthisyearascomparedtotherecognitionoflowercosts.Otherfactorsimpactingquarterlycomparisonincludethetimingofsynergyrecognition,thetimingimpactrelatedtotradespendrecognitiononaquarterlybasis,andfinally,thefourthquartercomparisontothisyear'sstrongfourthquarterfinish.

Lookingbrieflyatthesegment,coffeeprofitsareprojectedtobecomparabletotherecordFY16levels.Forconsumerfoods,reportedsegmentprofitisexpectedtobedown,giventheprioryeargainonthemilkdivestitureandthelostmilkprofit,butupmidsingle-digitswhentheseitemsareexcluded.Petfoodsegmentprofitisalsoprojectedtobeupmidsingle-digits,reflectingincrementalsynergiesandorganicgrowthincludingthecontributionsofnewproducts.Andlastly,internationalandfoodserviceisanticipatedtobedown,primarilyreflectingnetimpactofFXinCanada.

Weprojectfreecashflowwillapproximate$1billion,fromwhichweplantopaydowndebt,andfurtherreduceleverageto3.1timesbytheendofthisfiscalyear.Thisassumesprojected2017EBITDAof$(1.6)billion.Additionalassumptionsrelatedto2017includeamortizationexpenseofnearly$210million,depreciationof$215million,share-basedcompensationexpenseof$35million,capitalexpendituresof$240million,andlastly,one-timecostsof$100millionwhicharemostlycash-related.

Inclosing,weareverypleasedwithouroverallperformancein2016,asitmarkedamemorableyearinourCompany'shistory.Itiswiththismomentumandexcitementthatwelookforwardtoexecutingourplansfor2017,asweremainfocusedondeliveringcontinuedgrowth.

Wethankyouforyourtime,andwewillnowopenupthecallforyourquestions.

Operator,ifyouwouldpleasequeueupthefirstquestion?

QUESTIONS&ANSWERS

Operator :

(OperatorInstructions)

AndrewLazarwithBarclays.

AndrewLazar (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):

Goodmorning,everybody.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Goodmorning,Andrew.

AndrewLazar (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):

Page 9: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page9of30

Aquickoneforme,inthinkingabouttheunderlyingEPSgrowthguidanceforFY17,asyoupointedoutit'sroughly7%to10%orso.AndyoutalkedaboutbaseEPSgrowthinthe10%range,Ithinkfor2017and2018.SoI'mjusttryingtogetasenseofwhatleadstothat8%atthemidpointtypeofgrowthrange?

Isitjustconservatism,isitcoffeeoutperformedprettydramaticallythisyear,andthereforeweneedtojusttailorthatalittlebitinourexpectationsfor2017,orthingsthatIhaven'tmentioned?

Justtryingtoputthatinperspective.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Hey,Andrew.ThisisMarkBelgya.Thanksforthequestion.

WhatIwouldsayis,Mark,andIthinkwereiterated,wewilldeliverthe$100millioninsynergies.Wehaveaclearlineofsightonthat.Wherewelandinthat8%is,wearehavingasignificantincreaseinmarketingspendforthecomingyear,obviouslywiththesponsorshipoftheOlympics,andreestablishingsomeofthemarketingspendfromthisyear.Sothatisthebiggestdriver.

Ithinkintermsofthecoffee,Iwouldputthatmoreinthecategoryofwherewemightlandintherange.Obviously,wedidhaveastrongyear,andweneedthingstocontinue.Wefeelgoodaboutthat,butthat'sprobablyafactorthatcomesintoplayalittlebit,aswell.AndthentheotheroneprobablytoalesserdegreeisjusttheFXimpact.AsImentioned,we'rehavingabouta$20millionheadwind,andwehopetocoveratleasthalfofthat,butthere'salittlebitofthateffectin,aswell.

AndrewLazar (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):

Gotit.Thanksforthat.Andthenjustaveryquickone.

Inoticeddistributionexpense,Ithinkasapercentofsaleswasmuchlowerthanitistypicallyisthisquarter.Justtryingtogetasenseofwhythatis,andisthatamoresustainablelevel?

Thankyou.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Andrew,whatthatmightbeiswearealigningtheBigHeart--basicallytheBigHeartP&Lwherecertainthingsfallin,coststhatprobablywereconsidereddistribution,mighthavejustbeenmoved.Butwecanfollow-up,ifthere'ssomethingsignificantlydifferentfromthatresponse.

AndrewLazar (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):

Thankyou.

Operator :

DavidDriscollwithCitigroup.

DavidDriscoll(Analyst-Citigroup):

Great,thankyou,andgoodmorning.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Goodmorning.

DavidDriscoll(Analyst-Citigroup):

Page 10: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page10of30

Richard,congratulationsonyourretirement,andMarkwhatabigday.Congratulationshereforyou.AndIguess,itwasMay1,butforusitfeelsliketoday.Socongratulations,andVince,allthebest.

VinceByrd (ViceChairman):

Thankyou.

DavidDriscoll(Analyst-Citigroup):

Iwantedtoaskafollow-uponAndrew'squestionontheguidance.

SoMarkadifferentwaytolookatthiswouldbetosaythat$100millionofsynergies--Ithinkthatnumberalonegetsyousomethinglike$0.57ashareinincrementalEPSbenefitin2017.Andthatgetsyoutokindofthetopendoftherange.Somaybecouldyoutrytoanswerjustslightlydifferently,andjustsaythatifsynergiesgetsyoujusttothetopendoftherange,doesn'titsuggestthattherestoftheoperationsarereallyonbalanceflattish?

Iknowthere'sasharecountbenefit,there'samilk.There'smilkdilutionthatgoesoninthere.Butitstilljustseemsliketheunderlyingexpectationofthecoreexthesynergiesisbasicallyflat.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,David,it'sinterestingbecausewe'veobviouslywentthroughthatsamelineofthought.AndthewayIwoulddescribeitis,thatyou'reexactlyright,the$100millionisa$0.57delivery.Themarketincrease,Iwilltellyou,isasignificantincreasethere.Weareupsowefeelverycomfortabletobeabletoinvestwithmarketingdollarsbackinthebusiness.Sothere'salittlebitofadiscussionhereonwhetherornotthebusinessisflatfromaperformanceperspective,orit'sflatbecausewe'veinvestedinthemarketing.Wewouldchoosethelatter,sayingthattheMarketingincreaseisoffsettingsomeofthattosomedegree.

Theotherthingis,IthinkMarksuggestedinhisscriptedcommentsisthatwearealsoinvestingininnovationandgrowth,andalsoinChina.So,obviouslythosedollarsareembeddedinthebusinessportionofitwhenyoujustseparateitbetweensynergyandnon-synergy.Soyoucandrawtheconclusionthatitiscomingfromthebusiness.Butthosearethetwoorthreefactorsmarketing,innovationandinvestmentinChina,andalittlebitofFXasImentionedthatarereallybringingthatnumberbackdown.

DavidDriscoll(Analyst-Citigroup):

Okay,andformysecondquestion,oncoffee,backatyourAnalystDay,andIbelieveStevehadsaiditwillbeuntillike2019beforetheCompanyrecoveredtheprofitabilityseenin2014.Ithinkasoftoday,you'vealreadyrecoveredtheprofits.Sothere'stwosubtlequestionsinhere.Whydidthisoutperformsomuchrelativetotheexpectation?AndthenwhatIreallycareabout,ishowdoesthisimpactgoingforward?

Imean,youhadaverydifferentoutlookonhowprofitsweregoingtomoveinthisbusiness.I'mnotcomplainingbytheway,thisisreallywonderfultheprofitsareupsomuch.ButIthinkweallthenworry,thatthemassiveoutperformanceincoffeeprofitsin2016,willsomehowretardtheabilityofprofitstogrowin2017.Wasthatclear?

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

IthinkitisDavid.Hi,SteveOakland.

Let'stalkaboutthecoffeebusinessbriefly.Ifyouthinkaboutthenumbers,wedidgetthereayearortwoaheadofwhatweguided,right?Andwegotthereontwothings,really.Andthemostobviousoneisthis,

Page 11: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page11of30

thelaunchofDunkin'Kcups,andweallknowthatwasoneofthebestlaunchesinconsumerproductsinthelastfiveyears,right?Sothatwasawonderfulperformance.

Butreallymoreimportantly,financiallyifyoulookattheperformanceofourcoreredcanbusiness,andthat'saneffortthatstartedtwoyearsago.Imean,intheyearthatwestruggledinourcoffeebusiness,Markandhisteamwentbackanddidthedownsize,andstartedthoseprocesses.

Andthenwehadanopportunityinthislastyeartogetcoffeepricingright,tohavebothamanufacturingandahedgingstrategy,togetthisthing--togetittopricepointsthatbothexcitedtheretailerandconsumer.Andtheretailerisakeypieceofthis.You'vegottogetthatmerchandisingsupport.Sowe'rereallypleasedwithwherewearethere.

Ithinkyousaw--I'msureyousawthere,ourpressreleaseonpricingthatwejusttook.Sowithallofthatbehindus,wefeelprettycomfortablethatwecanrepeatthatperformance.Andtoyourcommentearlier,thatwillberepeatingarecordperformance.Weactuallybeatthe2014numberthisyear,right?

SoonourredcanandcorebusinessandDunkin'business,ourDunkin'K-Cupbusiness,wefeelreallygood.Lostinthat,though,thisyear,wasthetwosegmentsthatdidn'tperformancewellaswewantedto,andthat'sourbusinessinpremiumandourlegacyK-Cup,ourFolgersK-Cupbusiness.Sowhatweintendtodothisyearisdothesamethingstothose.Andso,thepricing,weleanedinearlyontheDunkin'bagbusiness.Yousawsomeofthatperformanceinthefourthquarter.Wefeelgreataboutthatgoingintothisquarter.Soweneedtoputourselvesbackonpremiumgrowthmomentum.

Wewillinvesttodothat,andweneedtomakesureastheK-Cupsegmentshakesoutanditwillshakeout.Imean,there'ssomanynewitems,there'ssomuchgoingonthere,thatvelocitiesonourcorelegacyitemsarestrong.Andweinvestedrightattheendofthequarterinthat,aswell.SoI'msayingwefeelcomfortablewecanrepeattherecordresultsinredcan.TheDuncanK-Cupbusinesswillbeverysolidthisyear.

Andthen,withwhatwehaveextraonthere,we'regoingtoinvestinthoseothertwosegments.SoIwouldhopewecomeoutofthecoffeebusinessfiringonallcylinders,versusfiringonjustthosetwobigones…

(MultipleSpeakers)

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Hey,David,thisisRichardSmucker.

Twoquickcomments.Onefroma50,000squarefootlevel,our--70%to80%ofourbusinesshasreallygoodmomentum,andwe'refiringonalleightcylinders.We'reusingthatopportunitytomake,asMarksaid,investmentsinourbusinessforthefuture,notjustfornextyearbutbeyond,andthisgivesustheopportunitytodothat.We'renotmakingthesenumbersbycuttingmarginexpenses,anditgivesustheopportunitytoinvestbackinthesebusinesses.Andso,andthesebrands.SoIthinkyouneedtolookatitfromthathighlevel.Wedo,andthat'sdrivingalotofourbusiness.It'salsopositioninguswellforgrowthinthefuture,notjustinnextyearbutbeyond.

Andthenfinally,Idon'tlikethewordretirement,soIjustwanttoletyouknowthat(laughter).Iamnotretiring.I'mjustmovingtoadifferentrole.Andmostofthefamily'seggsareinonenest,andwe'rewatchingthatnestverycarefully,so--

DavidDriscoll(Analyst-Citigroup):

Richard,thatwasawonderfulcomment,andwecertainlydon'twantyougoinganywhere.Thanks.Ireally

Page 12: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page12of30

appreciatetheanswers.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Allright.

Operator :

ChrisGrowewithStifelNicolaus.

ChrisGrowe (Analyst-StifelNicolaus):

Hi,goodmorning.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Goodmorning

ChrisGrowe (Analyst-StifelNicolaus):

Ijustwanttoask,firstifIcould,pleaseoncoffee.JustunderstandwiththelistpricedeclineandhavingreachedsomeofthesepromotedpricepointsinFY16,asinputcostscamedown,I'mjusttryingtounderstandwhycoffeeprofitswouldn'tbestrongerintheyearthantheflatexpectation?

Andalsorelatedtothat,wouldtheybestrongerinfirsthalforperhapsmorechallengedinthesecondhalfasyoustarttolapsomeofthat?Justcuriousifyoucouldgivehelponthephasingthere,ifthatwouldbeafactorforourmodels?

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Okay,Iwillstartthat,Chris,SteveOakland,andthenmaybeMarkcanhelpmeonhowwelookattheseasonalityoftheprofits.Ifyougobacktothefourthquarterof2014,whencoffeepriceshitlike$2.20apound,right,arabica.Andthenwesawitcomedownbasically$1apoundoverthattime.It'sbumpedupinthelastdayorsoalittlebit.Butifyouthinkaboutthat,thefastestmostefficientwaytogetthatpricingtotheconsumerwaswithtrade.Okay?Wecanimpactshelfpriceonapromotedperiodimmediatelywithtrade,okay?

ChrisGrowe (Analyst-StifelNicolaus):

Yes.

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Sointheshort-term,that'sveryefficient.Inthelong-term,it'sveryinefficient,becauseitpromotesallkindsofbuyin,loadit,andallthisinefficiencyinthesystem,right?Sooverthelastyear,we'vetakenacoupleoflistpricedeclinestomitigatethat,tomakethepromotionalallowanceless.Soweleanedintocurrentcoffeepricingonourpromotionalpricepoints.

Andnowthishasallowedustodrainthatout,getabetterlistpricetopromotedpriceratio,sothatoureverydaypricesgetbetter,andwemaintainthecurrentprice.Sowetriedtomakethatclearinthereleasethatwedid,togivealittlemoreclarityonthatthistime.Sothatthecostshavebeenreflectedintotalcoffeepricing.Thisdoes,Ithink,makeit,overthelongterminamoreefficientmannerso--

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Theotherthing,thisisMarkSmucker.

Page 13: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page13of30

TheonlyotherthingIwouldaddSteve,isthatjustfromacommoditystandpoint,ifyoujustlookatthetrendsoncoffeecosts,thedeclinethatwe'veexperiencedhasgoneonforoh,9months,atleast12months.Soyouhaveseenthisveryconsistentsustainedlowercoffeecostandthathasallowedustobehaveproperly,orresponsiblyifyouwill,becausewehavehadconsistencyinourunderlyingcoststructure.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Andthen,Chris,thisisMarkBelgya.

Justintermsofsortofseasonalityifyouwillofyourquestion.Wearegoingtobelappinglastyear'sfirstquarterpricingmove.AndasStevementioned,wehadthisyearpricedecline,sowehadthefulleffectofbasicallytwopricedeclines.Sowhilethecostsarecertainlygoingtobelowerthantheywereayearago,thepricedeclinesalongwiththewaysomeofthetradewillhitthroughthequarters,willprobablynegativelyimpactthefirstquarter.Andthenobviously,balanceitselfoutthroughtherestoftheyear.

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Right.Andthen,that'sreallyhowthosethingshit,notthevolumes.Wefeelgoodaboutwherethesell-throughandvolumenumbersare.Butjusthowthepricinghitsversusayearago,andhowwerecognizetradeinthoseperiodsmaysoftenthefirstquarteralittlebit.

ChrisGrowe (Analyst-StifelNicolaus):

Okay.That'sagoodthoroughanswer.Thankyouforthat.

AndIhadjustonequickfollow-upifIcould,withoutEricKatzmanonthecall,someonehastoaskaboutfreecashflow(laughter).SoIdidwanttoask,ifyoujusttoconsider,reallyforMarkBelgyathe$1billionversusthe$1.25billion,obviously,itsoundslikethemajorityworkingcapitalbenefitscamethroughinFY16withsomestillinFY17

Isthatthemainreasonforcashflowbeingdown?ItalsolookslikeCapExisgoingtobeupalittlebityear-over-year.Justtryingtogetasenseofwhatcouldbedraggingdownthecashflow,overandabovetheworkingcapitaleffect?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,Chris,thatistheprimary--thatwasprobably$100millionofit.Andthentheotherbigthingwehadthisyear,isweactuallyhadtwosignificantsizetaxrefundsthatwere,whatI'llcallone-time,thatwereprobablyroughly$100million,aswell.Sothosewouldcomeout,ifthatgivesyoubacktothebilliondollarsversusthisyear.

ChrisGrowe (Analyst-StifelNicolaus):

Okay,that'sgreat.Thankyou.

Operator :

KenGoldmanwithJPMorgan.

KenGoldman (Analyst-JPMorgan):

Hi,goodmorning.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Page 14: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page14of30

Goodmorning,Ken.

KenGoldman (Analyst-JPMorgan):

Richard,Ithinkitwasyoumentionedcoffeetickingupthelastfewdays,butatleastaswelookatthecharts,RobustaandArabicareachupmaybe20%offtheirrecentlows.SoI'mjustcuriouscanyoutalkaboutoranyonereallytalkaboutwhatyou'reseeinginthecoffeecommoditymarket,whetheryouthinkthesecurrentpricesarereasonable,givencurrentsupplydemanddynamicsandwhatyouroutlookisfromhere?

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Yes,Ken,actually,IthinkStevegavethatcomment.

KenGoldman (Analyst-JPMorgan):

Sorry…

(MultipleSpeakers)

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Ken,therecentrunup,there'salwaysvolatilityinthecoffeebusiness.WearefortunatetohaveteamsonthegroundandofficesinboththetwolargestmarketsofBrazilandVietnam.Andsoagain,thecoffeeisrelativetowherewe'repricedto,relativetowherewe'repromotedto.Andthenifwelook,ifourteamsonthegroundinthosemarketslookatthecoffeecrop,there'sbeensomeweathernoiseinthelastdayortwothathavedrivenitup.

Butitdoesappear,Ithinkouropinionis,there'sgoingtobeagreaterArabicacropthisyear.Andsowethinkthatcoffeewilltradeinapricerangethatsupportswherewearepriced,betweenourpositionandouropinion.Thegoodthingaboutthisbusinessiswehavepricingcapabilitieshere.Andnotonlydowehavegoodcoverage,butwehavetheabilitytomovepriceshouldweneedto.SowefeelprettygoodabouttheArabicacropasitgoesforward.Robustamightbealittletighter,butwethinktheArabicacropisgoingtobeabigoneandpricingshouldbereasonable.

KenGoldman (Analyst-JPMorgan):

Okay,that'shelpful.

Andthenmynextquestion,the$50millioninadditionalefficienciesoverthenextfewyears,franklythat'salittlebitofasmalleramountthanwhatIhadexpected.It'salittlebitsmaller,atleastonapercentageofsalesas,fromwhatyourpackagedfoodpeershavecomeupwith.So,Irealizeyou'realreadyleaninsomeareas,headcountandsoforth.Butaswelookatthis,what'sholdingthisnumberbackfrombeingashighaswhatwe'veseen,whatyou'veseen,whatAccenture'sseen,right,fromsomeofyourotherfoodmanufacturingpeersoutthere?

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Ken,thisisMarkSmucker,andthanksforthequestion.

I'llstart,thenifanybodyelsewantstochimein.Soacouplethings.Asyouknow,asyouthinkaboutourperformancehistorically,it'sbeenverygood,andwehavehadhistoricallyaverystrongcostdisciplineinmultipleareasofourbusiness.Partofwhatwe'veembarkedonwhichreallywas,thecatalystwastheBigHeartacquisition,wastothinkalittlebitdeeperaboutouroverallcostsavingsinitiatives,andhowwemightmaybedoalittlebitbetter.Youareright,thatourproductivitymeasuresversusourpeersare

Page 15: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page15of30

probablybetterinmanycases,andwearegenerallyleanerIwouldsaythansomeofourpeers.

Buthavingsaidthat,wehaveanobligation,obviously,toourshareholderstomakesurethatwehavethebestcostdisciplinethatwecanhave.Andso,whatwe'vebeendoing,andthisispartoftheexplanationofthe$50million,isonanongoingbasis,makingsurefromacontinuousimprovementthatwehavethedisciplineinoursupplychain,ouroperations,ourpurchasingandlongertermaswethinkabouthowdowegetmoreefficientintrade,allofthosethingsshouldhelpdrive,whatIwouldcallsomeincrementalsavingstothebottomline.

Soitisn't--wedon'tthinkaboutitastheone-timebenefit,butwearecomfortablethatwecanatleastdeliverthat.Andthenbeyondthesenextcoupleyears,weshouldbeabletocontinuetodeliverannualcostsavingsobjectives,whichweholdourteamsto.

Thegoodnewsaboutthat,isitisasRichardmentioned,itisallowingustoinvestinenhancedcapabilities.Andataveryhighlevelwhatthosecapabilitiesarefocusedonisgettingbetteratengagingwithourconsumerandgettingbetteratengagingwithourretailcustomers.Andsostrategically,havingtherightbalancebetweenourleadingnumberonebrands,whicharereallytheenginethatfuelsourgrowth,aswellashavingtherightemergingbrandsinourportfolio,ispartofthatstrategy.Andsomakingsurethatwehavedollarsthatcanfundthoseenhancedcapabilities,bothinconsumerengagementandcustomerengagementisreallygoingtohelpdriveourgrowthbothtopandbottomlinelong-term.

KenGoldman (Analyst-JPMorgan):

Thankyouverymuch.

Operator :

JasonEnglishwithGoldmanSachs.

JasonEnglish (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):

Hey,goodmorning,folks.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Goodmorning.

JasonEnglish (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):

Congratulations.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Thankyou.

JasonEnglish (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):

Iwantedtostickwithcoffeeforaminute.Youmentionedinyourpreparedremarks,moderationintermsofcompetitiveactivity.Iwashopingyoucouldexpoundonthatalittlebitmore,intermsofwhereyou'reseeingthemoderation?

Andthenalsoaspartofyourpreparedremarks,youtalkedaboutsharpeningpricepointsonsomeofyourbusinesses,IthinkyoumentionedtheFolgersK-Cups,Dunkin'.Howdoweputthosetwointermsofmoderationandcompetitiveactivity,juxtaposedwithwhatsoundslikeabitmorecompetitiveactivitycomingfromyou?

Page 16: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page16of30

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Jason,hi,SteveOakland.I'lltrytotouchonthat.

Ithinkit'sdifficulttopaintthecoffeecategorywithonebrushcompetitively.Ithinkthepreparedremarksprobablywerefocusedmoreonourmainstreamredcanbusiness,right?AndIdothinkwe'veseenwiththeArabicafalling,withthecoffeepricesfallingwheretheyare,wehavefoundthatpricepointshavegottendownintothoseranges,whereitmotivatesboththecompetitorandtheconsumerandthecustomer,right?Soallofusareinpricepointsthatreallywork,okay?Andso,we'rebackinthatzoneandIthinkeverybodyisoperatinginthatzone.

NowhavingsaidthatIwouldarguethatthepremiumsegmentwasthemostcompetitivewe'veeverseenitlastyear.Andso,theDunkin'bagbusinessasyouknow,earlierintheyearhadacoupleoftoughquarters,andwe'vetalkedabouthowweleanedintothatinthefourthquarter.Premiumgreen,it'sanotherremnantforawholeotherdiscussion,butgreencoffeeisnotallthesame.Thecoffeethatgoesintoalotofpremiumcoffeeshasamuchlongersupplychain.Youmightexpectlower--coffeecoststoimpactusatdifferenttimingbasedonthetypeofgreenthatitis.

Sointhefourthquarterthat,wewereinapositiontosupportthat,wedidandithasresponded.Soifyouthinkaboutitthecoreredcanpricinghadmoderated,thecompetitivesethadmoderated.Thepremiumbusinessprobablyisinthatspacenow.AndthelastpiecewillbeK-Cups,andwe'regoingtoleanintoK-Cups.TheproliferationofK-Cupshascausedthatwholesegmenttobecompetingforaslowergrowthbase.Andoneoftheleversthat'sbeenusedinthereisprice.We'reablenowtocompeteinthatarea.Sothat'sfor,maybethelastpieceofthepuzzle,andwefeelgoodabouttheplanweputinfrontofyoutoday,willgiveusthedollarstosupportthat,andreturnthatbusinesstogrowth.

JasonEnglish (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):

Gotit.That'sreallyhelpful.Thankyouforthat.Onemorequestion,thenI'llpassiton.Iwantedtoswitchgears,andtalkaboutpetrealquick.

First,the--whatwasroughly3%oftheorganicsalesgrowth;ifpossiblecouldyougiveusabreakonvolumeorpriceforthequarter?Andthenyourexpectationoforganicgrowthaswegointonextyear,anycolorintermsofwhatyou'reexpectingbetweenpremium,snack,andmainstreamwouldbereallyhelpful.Thankyou.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Jason,thisisMarkBelgya.

Regardingthefirstpartofthatquestion,unfortunately,becauselastyear'sfourthquarterwassplitownership,thatbreakdownisn'tquiteaseasyasitmightsoundtobe.Iwilltellyouthough,nowthatwe'reallonthesamesystemasofMarch1.AndobviouslyinFY17,we'llhavethatfulllineofanalysisforallbusinesses.SoBarry,Idon'tknowifyoucanaddanything,butfromjusttheabsolutenumbers,Ithinkthat'sprobablythecase.

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

Ithinkyou,thecoloryouprovidedMark,isthebestwecandoatthispoint.JusttoaddJason,asfarasourgrowthexpectationsfornextyear,asyouknowoursnackbusinesshastremendousmomentumbehindit.

Soweexpectoursnackbusinesstobeatthehighsingle-digitgrowthnextfiscalyear,specificallywithourMilk-BoneandPup-Peronibrands.Onthepetspecialtysideofthebusiness,we'relappingtheexpandeddistributionlastyearinthepetspecialtychannel.Butwewouldexpectmidsingle-digitgrowth

Page 17: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page17of30

thiscomingyear,aswewilllaunchanationaladvertisingcampaignbehindtheNaturalBalancebrand.

Wealso,therearetwomajorretailersinpetspecialty,butthere'salsosignificantamountofsalesthatmovethroughtheindependenttrade.WehaveapushbehindourNature'sRecipebrand.Wethinkthere'ssomerealopportunitiesthere.That'sourgatewayspecialtybrand,soweseesomegrowththere.Andthenalso,oursnacksplayasignificantroleinpetspecialty.Soourwidelydistributedbrands,alsothere'stremendousgrowthopportunitythere.

Foodisgoingtobethelowergrowththisyear,asfarastheportfolioisconcerned.Youknowwhatourchallengeswerethispastyear,specificallywithKibbles'nBits.Weareencouragedthatwe'veactuallyseennegativeconsumptiontrendsstarttodecelerateattheendofthislastfiscalyear.We'veputsomebonusbagsintothemarket.You'regoingtoseemoreofthosegoingintomarketinJune.Soalotofeffortstabilizingourdrydogfoodbusiness,andtryingto--justgetthatbusinessbackwhereitneedstobe.Sothatprovidethecoloryouwerelookingfor?

JasonEnglish (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):

Yes,veryhelpful.Thankyouverymuch,gentlemen.I'llpassiton.

Operator :

AlexiaHowardwithBernstein.

AlexiaHoward (Analyst-SanfordC.Bernstein&Co):

Goodmorning,everyone.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Goodmorning.

AlexiaHoward (Analyst-SanfordC.Bernstein&Co):

Hi,soacoupleofquestionsaboutyoure-commercestrategyinChinainvestments.Youstartedtalkingaboutthee-commercestrategyattheInvestorDaylastyear.Areyouabletodimensionalizehowbigthatisforyouasofnow;howfastitgrewlastyear?Ipresumethekeycategoriesinthereareprobablycoffeeandpetfood.Whichoneofthoseisbigger?Wouldjustliketohearcoloronthat,becausewedon'tseethatinthemeasuredchannels.AndthenyoumentionedChinainvestments.Canyoujustgiveusalittlebitofcoloronhowmuchspendingovertherenow,whatthestrategyisovertime?

Thankyou,andI'llpassiton.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Alexia,thisisMarkSmucker.I'llstart.

Thefirst,yourfirstquestionjustasitrelatestoe-commerceisthatyou'reright.Weare,Iwouldsaywe'realittlebitunderdevelopedversusourpeersinthatspace.Andso,asItalkedtoKen'squestionearlier,relativetoinvestmentsandwhatwe'retryingtoampup,thatisoneofthosethings.Andso,nottogetintotoomuchspecifics,butaswethinkabout--weactuallyhavejustreorganizedsomeofourcommercialfunctions,thatwouldincludesalesandsomeofourmarketingareas.

Butalsointhedigitalspace,wehaveactuallybeefedupourcapabilitiesthere,andarecurrentlyinprocessofreevaluatingourtotale-commercestrategy,inhowwebetterserveoure-commercecustomers.Andwhenwethinkaboute-commerce,thatincludesboththedigital-onlyretailerslike

Page 18: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page18of30

Amazon,aswellasourbrick-and-mortarcustomersthathaveasignificantonlinepresence,aswell.Soalittlebitofageneralanswer,butsufficeittosaythatitisonourradarscreen,anditisapriorityforustocontinuetodevelopthatbusiness.

AlexiaHoward (Analyst-SanfordC.Bernstein&Co):

AndthenonChina?

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

OnChina,Ithinkyouasked?Sojustintermsofthefinancialimpact,Iwouldsaythatit'sabout$0.03to$0.05forthecurrentyearinFY17.

AlexiaHoward (Analyst-SanfordC.Bernstein&Co):

Andthen,anycoloronexactlywhat'shappeningoutthere,aftertheinitialforayoutthereafewyearsago?

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Yes,Alexia,it'sstillalittlebitearlyforus,Ithink,tobegivingtoomanydetailsinthatarea.We'vetalkedaboutthefactthatwehavehadaminorityinvestmentinanoats--inanoatmealbusinessthere,andthatbusinesshascontinuedtogrowyear-over-year.Andso,we'vebeenpleasedwiththatminorityinvestment.Asitrelatestootherthings,Ithinkit'salittlebitearlyforustogiveanyspecifics.

AlexiaHoward (Analyst-SanfordC.Bernstein&Co):

Okay,thankyouverymuch.I'llpassiton.

Operator :

MarioContreraswithDeutscheBank.

MarioContreras (Analyst-DeutscheBank):

Hi,goodmorning.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Hey,Mario.

MarioContreras (Analyst-DeutscheBank):

SoIwantedtogobacktoyourcommentsfromAnalystDaylastyearwithrespecttocoffee.SomeofthecautionaroundgettingbacktoFY14coffeeEBITlevelsnotuntil2019.

SomeofthereasonforthatwasrelatedtoinvestmentaroundthePerfectMeasures.So,obviouslyyou'vealreadyachievedthatgoalofgettingtotheproperrecovery,butwantedtounderstandhowtheinvestmentisgoinginPerfectMeasures,isthatstillamajorfocuspointforyou?

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Hi,Mario.

WithregardtoPerfectMeasures,Ithinkwestillthinkithasthepotential,andstillfeelsogreataboutit.I'lltellyouthereasonyouputthingsinleadmarketsorintestmarketsistolearn,andwelearnedalot.Andourtrialnumberscandidly,werenotwhatweneededthemtobe,butourrepeatnumberswerefantastic.

Page 19: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page19of30

Andso,ittellsusthatwe'veprobablygotthepositioningalittlewrong.We'veprobablygotsomeoftheinitialcommunicationalittlewrong,butwegottheconceptright.

Andsothisyear,we'regoingtorelaunchthatwithalittlebetterpackaging,littlebettermessaging.Andwe'regoingto--it'saheavycapitalinvestment,becausethetechnologyisuniqueandwewanttomakesurewegetitjustrightbeforeweleanintoitonamorenationalscale.Westillthinktheconcepthasalotoflegs,butwe'reprobablyayearbehindwherewehopedtobeatthispoint.

ThoseinvestmentnumbersarebakedintothenumbersintheguidancethatMarkgaveearlier,socontinuedinvestmentinthat.Okay.Andthen,ithadbeenmentionedacoupletimesthatincreasedmarketingspendingandadvertisingisincludedintheguidanceforthisyear.Isthereanywayyoucanquantifyroughlywhatthat'sgoingtobe,intermsofyourdollarorpercentincrease?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,it'sgoingtobeuphighsingle-digits,whichequatestoabout$40million.

MarioContreras (Analyst-DeutscheBank):

Okay.Thankyouverymuch.

Operator :

PabloZuanicwithSIG.

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Goodmorning,everyone.

Look,acoupleofquestionsoncoffeeforSteve,andthenIhaveafollow-uponpetfood.Steve,soStarbucks,HowardSchultzthereinJanuary,hetalkedabout,prettymuchimplied,threatenedtowalkawayfromaKeurigJAB.AndthenintheAprilcall,hecameoutandsaid,atleastthreeorfourtimesintheconferencecall,thattheyhavebeenabletorenegotiateterms,atveryfavorabletermswithKeurig.Andthatthosetermsgavethemalsomoreflexibility.SoI'mwonderinghere,ifStarbuckscandothatwithJAB,whycan'tSmuckers?Soifyoucancommentonthat.I'mjustsurprisedtheywereabletorenegotiateterms,nowtherewasachangeinownershipthere,andapparentlyyouhaven't.

Andrelatedtothat,IunderstandtheideaofsharpeningpricepointsforFolgersandK-Cups.Thecategoryhasbeensticky,ofcourse,whilegroundmovesquiteabit.Butasyoudothat,IwouldexpectothercompetitorstoalsocutpricesintheirK-Cupbrands.AndthenK-Cupsasacategorywillbecomenotsticky,butpassthroughasground.

SoIseeabitofariskthere.Ifyoucancommentonthat,please?Thanks.

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Sure.Iguess,Iwouldn'tassume,Iwouldn'ttaketheassumptionthatour--thatwehaven'tdonethesamekindofworkonourK-CupcontractinourrelationshipwithJAB,becausewehavealegacyrelationshipwithJAB,fromtheSaraLeeacquisitionseveralyearsago,andnowfromtheKeurigremount.

Sothefactthatmaybewe'realittlelesspublicaboutsomeofthatstuff,Iwouldn'tassumethatthesamethingsaren'tgoingon.Sojustdifferentcompaniesmanagethosethingsdifferently,right?Sothatprocessisinprocess,andwefeelgoodaboutthatrelationship.Theyarecommittedtohavethemajorbrandsinthecategoryintheirsystems,andwereadthesamethingsyouread.Soourassumptionsaregoingintothenegotiations,ourassumptionsaresimilartoyours.Sowefeelfinethere.

Page 20: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page20of30

AndwithregardtoK-Cups,ifyoudigalittledeeperintotheIRIandNielsendata,you'llseethatK-Cupsalthoughwedon'tpassthroughgreen,becausegreenisasmallportionoftheoverallcoststructure,it'sbecomemaybethemostpromotedcategoryintotalcoffee.So,thatit'sthehighestrelying--eachoneofthebrandsreliesveryheavilyonpromotion.SomaybeI'mnotclearenoughwhenItalkaboutleaningin,we'veleanedinonourpromotionalpricepointmostly.

Andso,thosepromotionalpricepointsarebasicallydown$1aboxfromwheretheyusedtobe.It'sstillaveryprofitablebusiness,butthatmigration,thattrainhasalreadyleft.Sowearewhereweare.Wemighthavebeenalittlelatetofollow,becauseofthemomentumwehadfromtheDunkin'business.

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Understood.Andjustaquickfollow-upthere.SoyourK-Cupmarginswouldbelowerthanyourgroundcoffeemargins,right?

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Yes,alittlebit.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,alittlebit.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Ourgroundcoffeemarginsareobviously,becauseofourscalevery,verygood.AndourK-Cupmarginsarealthoughgood,byconsumerproductsstandards,byCompanystandardsaren'tquiteatthatlevel.

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Thankyou.Andthenjustafollow-uponpetfood.

Iguess,it'sbeentoucheduponalready,butcanyoutelluswheredidthemixend--afterthedeclineindrydoganddogsandsnacksandspecialty,ifyoucanjustgiveus,what'sthemix,andarunrateatthemoment?Andrelatedtothat,ifyoucanalsocommentonthechannelmix?Becausewetendtothinkthatsnacksandspecialtyproductsaremostlyinthespecialtychannel,butjustreminduswhereyouare?

IfI'mlookingtheFDMdatafromIRIorNielsen,whatpercentageofyourpetfoodbusinessisthat,andwhereareyouinspecialty?Ifyoucanprovidethatroughlyonacurrentrunrate,knowwhatitwasonaveragein2016?Thanks.

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

Soyou'relookingforthechannelmix--Iwanttomakesureweunderstandthequestion.

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Right…

(MultipleSpeakers)

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

Areyoulookingforthechannel?

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Page 21: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page21of30

Well,I'maskingtwodifferentquestionsonpetfood,right?Becauseobviously,youexplainedthatsnacksandspecialtyaredoingwellintermsofnaturalorganicbrands,andNaturalBalanceandtheotherbrandsaredoingwell,anddryisnotdoingsowell.SoI'mjusttryingtounderstand,wheredidthesalesmixendintermsofproductsinFY16?

Andthen,it'saseparatequestion,iswhatisthechannelmix,right?Becausesomeofus--drydogissoldinthespecialtychannel,right,andsnacksaresoldinboth.YourNaturalBalancebrandisonlysoldinspecialty,Iunderstandthat.ButI'mjusttryingtogetabitmorecolor,intermsofwhatyourcurrentproductmix,andseparate,what'syourcurrentchannelmix,ifyoucanprovidethat?

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

Fromachannelperspective,ofourtotalbusinessabout20%ofourbusinessisinthepetspecialty.AndMark,youwanttotake--?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,Pablo,thisisMarkBelgya.Justtomakesure--againIthinkIunderstandyourquestion,anditgoesbacktoalittlebitearlieronewasasked.Ifyoulookatthemixofproduct,okay,webenefitfromamixperspective.SowherethegrowthhasoccurredasBarrydescribedfromachannelperspective,we'realsobenefitingfromaproductmixperspective.Sowhetherit'sspecialtyorsnack,orevencatprobablymorethandog,thosearepositivemixbenefits.

Obviously,Kibbles'nBitsisaheavyproduct,it'salotofvolume,sothat'swhereit'snegative[goodsis].Soit'saverypositivemixstory,andnegativeoverallvolumestorybecauseofthedrydogsideoftheequation.

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Sorrytoinsist.Sobutdrydogwouldbewhatpercentofyoursalesnow,onarunratenow?

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

About10%oftotalsales.

PabloZuanic (Analyst-SIG):

Thankyou.That'sgood.

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

OnlyotherthingI'dreiterate,becauseIdothinkitgetslostoccasionally.BecauseparticularlyasI'veconversationsoverthelastfewquarters,clearly,Kibbles'nBitshasbeenchallenged.

Butwhenyoulookatourfoodbusiness,thecatfoodsideofthebusinessisalittlelarger,andhasdoneokay.Soithasbalancedoutalittlebit.SowhilenottryingtodownplaytheimpactoftheKibbles'nBitsandthevolume,andwhatithadoverthecourseoftheyear,butthecatfoodperformancehasallowedustomanagethroughtheoverallfoodalittlebitmorethanmaybethetakeawaywouldbe.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

TheonlyotherthingIwouldadd--thisisMarkSmuckeris--justremindingeveryonethatthebrandsthatparticipateinthosetwochannelsareverydifferent.It'sverysimilartothenaturalspaceinhumanfood,whereyou'vegotthenaturalchannelwiththeWholeFoodsandtheSproutsandthelike.Ingeneral,there'snotalotofoverlapinthebrand.Sothebrandstendtobeuniquetothoseindividualchannels.

Page 22: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page22of30

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

ThisisRichard.

Andjustaddingtothatforasecond,justanyacquisitionthatwe'vemade,andagainthisacquisitionisonly18monthsold.Oncewe'veintegratedthesebusinesseswithoursalesteams,we'veseensomeopportunitiesinchannelswhereourexistingsalesteamhavesaid,hey,we'rekindofweakinthischannel,andwiththerelationshipswehavewiththesecustomers,wecouldreallybuildthebusiness.Andthattakesusalittlewhiletoidentifythat,andthenbuildthoseadditionalsaleswiththosecustomers,andwe'rejustintheprocessofdoingthat.

Sowe'reprettyoptimisticaboutfindingthosekeycustomersthatwecanbuildourbusinesswith.Andso,weshouldseemoregrowththisyear,inanumberofthosechannels.Don'tyouagree?

(MultipleSpeakers)

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

Ido,Richard,andjustmaybetoadd-ontotheMeowMixconversationis,someofourbestinnovationthisyearisagainsttheMeowMixbrand.Andtoyourpoint,oursalesteamhasdoneanoutstandingjobgettingacceptanceofthatproductinthemarket,andespeciallyinthegrocerychannel.Sowherewehaveanoutstandingsalesteamthatcanexecutethere.

Soagain,MarktoyourpointMeowMixisoneofthelargestbrandsinourportfolio.Andwithsomeofthatinnovation,weseesomenicegrowthcomingfromthatbrandthisyear.

Operator :

MatthewGraingerwithMorganStanley.

MatthewGrainger (Analyst-MorganStanley):

Hi,goodmorning.Thanksforthequestion.

Ijustwantedtofollow-uponthenetsalesgrowthexpectation,andjusttryanddiginalittlebitmoreatthesegmentlevel.Thankyouforthecommentaryonpet.

ButIguess,MarkBelgya,isthereanymorevisibility,youcangiveusonthat1%ex-divestituresalesgrowth,howFXplaysintothat?Andhowweshouldbethinkingaboutitbysegmentacrosstherestofit?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

WhatI'dsay,Mattisthatabout--thecoffeepricingwouldbeabout1pointtheoverallCompany.Soyoucankindofdollarizethat,togethowmuchthecoffeewouldbe.That'sbyfarthebiggestdriverfromthedownsize.

Ifyoutakethemilkloss,$150millionImentionedearlier,andthen1%ofsales,callitsomewherebetween$70millionto$90milliononcoffeepricing,that'sthetwobignegatives.Sojustdothemath,andattributetotherestofthebusiness,thatwillgiveyouasense.Obviously,theFXhasalittlebitofeffect,butit'sactuallynotabigdriverintheoverall1%declinetototalnetsales.

MatthewGrainger (Analyst-MorganStanley):

Okay,allright.Thathelps,thanks.Justareallyquickfollow-upontheDunkin'K-Cupissue,youtalkedaboutsomeoftheuntappedadjacencyopportunitiesinflavoringsandlineextensions.Yourmarketshare'sstabilizedoverthepastsixmonths,andit'sprettyclosetowhereyourshareisinroastedground.

Page 23: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page23of30

Rightnow,canyoujustgiveusasenseofwhereyousee,intermsofgrowthopportunities,howmuchofthatisdependentonholdingthatshare,participatingincategorygrowth,asopposedtocontinuetopushsharehigherintothathighsingle-digitrange,andwhatyouthinkisfeasible?

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Well,Matthew,Ithinkitwillbe--itwillvarybybusiness.Ithinkthere'sstillrunwayfortheDunkin'business.There'ssomecoreflavorsonDunkin',andDunkin'tendstobeamoreflavored-drivenbusiness.Sothere'snewitemopportunityontheDunkin'brand.

Andthen,quitefrankly,nowthattheFolgersbrandisintherightpricepoints,gettingtherightsupportgrowthfromtheretailer,andtheconsumeracceptance,itwillbebetterexecutionofourpromotionstrategiesonFolgers.Sowe'llexecutebetteronFolgers.We'lllaunchnewitemsinDunkin',istheplan.

MatthewGrainger (Analyst-MorganStanley):

Okay,thankseveryone.

Operator :

AkshayJagdalewithJefferies.

AkshayJagdale (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):

Hi.Thanksforthequestion.Soacoupleof--twoquestions,oneoncoffee.Canyoujustexplaintous,orbreakoutofthe18%growththatyousawinoperatingincomeorsegmentoperatingincome,howmuchofthatwasaresultofpricingnetofcommoditycosts?Andwhatisthegeneralexpectationforpricingnetofcommoditiesfor2017?That'sthefirstquestion,andthenIhaveafollow-uponpet.

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Iwouldsayit'sabalance.Iwouldsay,partofitispricing,andthetimingofthepricingisimportanttothinkabout.Wetalked,Ibelieve,inourfirstquartercallayearago,thatweleanedinto,wetookpricingearly,wehadgoodcoverage,andwehadanopinionofthemarketthatweweregoingtogetthatmoneybackingreen,whichwedidinthefourthquarter.

Sointhefourthquarter,obviously,greenpricingtendstocostwasabiggerimpact,butwesortofspendthatmoneyupfront.SoIwouldsayit'sacombinationofthatgreenpricing,whenyougetyournumberone,yourhighvolumeitem,whenyougetvolumeuponthosecanistersinourfacilitiestoo,itreallyfallstothebottomline.

Sothat'sveryefficientforus.SoIknowMark'sdiggingfortheexactpercentagenumberaswespeak.Butit'sabalancebetweenthevolumethat'sgenerated,andtheimplicationsofthatvolumeallthewaythroughthesystemonredcans,andthenthepricing.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

It'sprobablyupalittlebitheavieronthepricecostmaybetwo-thirds,one-third-ish.ButagainIthinkthatgoesbacktowhatyousaidSteve,quiteawhileago,wasjustsortofthewaythatthetimingontheprice…

(MultipleSpeakers)

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Page 24: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page24of30

Andthevolumeallowedustobringmoregreeninattheend,andthegreenattheend,wasmorefavorable.Soit'sreallyhardtogetitdowntothenitonthat,becauseyou'llrecognizethosePBBswhenthegreencomesin.Andifyourvolumeisup,youbringmoreofthegreeninso.

AkshayJagdale (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):

Sotwo-thirdsoftheoperatingprofitgrowthyear-over-yearin2016wascommodityprice?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Thenumbersthatwejustquotedwereaquarter.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Fourthquarter.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Wasyourquestiononthefullyear,orjustthequarter?

AkshayJagdale (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):

Onthefullyear.Sorry,thatwasonthefullyear.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Okay,it'sprobablyalittlemore50/50-ishthere.

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Yes,50/50ontheyear.Anditwasbackend-loadedbecauseofthetimingofgreen.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes.Ithoughtyouwereaskingthequarterspecifically.

AkshayJagdale (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):

No,andthenonpet,excusemyvoice,onpetcanyougiveusalittlebitmorecoloronthequalityofearnings?Whathappenedwithgrossprofitgrowthfortheyear,andwhat'syourexpectationnextyear?Thanks.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

There'saqualityoftheearnings,andI'llstart,Barry,ifyouwanttojumpin.Ifyoulookoverthecourse,Imeanthisquarterspecifically,weknewmarketingwouldbedownfromalittlebitwhereitwas,becauseofthetimingofthespendintheproducts.Butwealsohadthesynergyrecognition,whichpickedupinthelatterpart.Soifyougobacktotheearlypartoftheyear,weexpectedquarter-over-quarterimprovementonmargin,whichwedeliveredoninQ2,Q3andQ4.

Ithinkfromacostperspectivegoingforward,theircostsalignedverysimilartowhatweseeinourconsumerfoods.Soifthegrainscontinuestobefavorable,IthinkasBarrymentioned,wearegoingtocontinuebonusbagsandthingslikethat,thatmighthavealittlebitofeffectongrossprofit.Butthen,ofcourse,asIthinkaswe'vesaidovertime,ofthethreesegmentsofthebusinessthenaturalhasthelowestprofitability.AndIthinkasBarryandtheteamwork,andaswellasweintegratethatintotheoverallSmuckerCompany,weshouldhaveanopportunitythere,aswell.

Page 25: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page25of30

BarryDunaway(President,PetFoodandPetSnacks):

Absolutely,Mark,yes.No,ourqualityofearningsaresolidforFY17.Andaswethinkaboutmixtoo,justasoursnackscontinuetodrivethebusiness,thatiswherethestrongestmarginsonthebusinessareaswell.We'veseenevencatsnacks,smallcategorybuttremendousupsidethere,soIthinkwehaveverysolidqualityofearningsfornextyear.Wehaven'tmadeanysignificantcutstogettoourgrowthnumberfromnextyear,year-over-year.

AkshayJagdale (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):

AndjustonelastoneforMark.Youtalkedaboutorganizationalstructuralchange.Canyougiveusmorecoloronthat?Thanks.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Hey,Akshay,it'sMarkSmucker.Notreally.Idon'tthinkwecangiveyouanymorecolor,otherthantosaythiswasahugeyear.Andnotonlydidwemakethelargestacquisitioninourhistory,butthatacquisitionwasagainthecatalysttosortofthinkaboutthingslike,arewegoingtomarketinthemostefficientway?Dowehavetherightcapabilitiestoengageourconsumerandourcustomer?Werecentlyopenedourinnovationcenterwhichisverymuchallaboutourcustomerretailpartners.

Andsothelongandshortis,aswelookedatourorganization,andwetookopportunityacrossnotonlyourcommercialfunctions,whichwouldbesalesandmarketingandthinkingabouthowwewouldorganizethosedifferently.Butwelookedacrossoursupplychainnetwork,ourfinanceorganization,someofouradministrativefunctionsaswell,justtomakesurethatwewererunningtheminthemostefficientway.

IwouldsaythatoneofthekeythingsisthatasImentionedinthescript,wehaveanindividualfromBigHeartwhoisleadingourgrowthandinnovationorganization.Andso,weareputtingarenewedfocuson--notthatwehaven't,we'vedoneagoodjoboninnovation,butmakingsurethatourmuscle,wherewe'rebuildingmuscleisreallyaroundinnovationlongerterm.Andmakingsurethatourunderstandingoftheconsumerissharpandthatwecanactagainstinsightsthatwearelearningabouttheconsumeraswegoforward.SoIthinkthat'sprobablyit.

AkshayJagdale (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):

Thankyou.I'llpassiton.

Operator :

FarhaAslamwithStephens.

GregoryNep(Analyst-StephensInc):

Goodmorning.Thisis(GregoryNep)onforFarha.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Goodmorning.

GregoryNep(Analyst-StephensInc):

Ijusthaveaquickquestion.Sogivensortoftheexcellentcashflowandsuccesstakingdownleverage,canyousharewithuswhethertheremaybeopportunitiesforfurtherM&A,andjustyourviewontheM&Aenvironmentrightnow?

Page 26: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page26of30

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,thisisMarkBelgya.I'llstart,andRichardorMark,ifyouwanttoaddmorefromastrategicperspective.Butaswelookatourdeploymentofcash,comingoutofthedeallastyear,weobviouslyemphasizedtheimportanceofpayingdowndebtoverthecourseofthreetofiveyears,whichwemadegreatprogresson.AndasIsaidearlier,itallowedustogivebackintorepurchasingshares.Wefeelverycomfortablewith$1billionoffreecashflow,thatwe'llbeabletocontinuethatdebtpaydownplan,obviouslycontinueourdividendpayoutpolicy.

Anditallowsusalittlebitofflexibilityastoaddressstrategicoptionscomingin.Sowhetherthat'sM&A,again,Idon'tthinkwearelookingatahugetransformational,likeapetwith,atleastfromaleverageperspective.Butcertainlythere'sM&Aopportunityaswellasbuyback.AndIthinkbuybacksaresituational.Sowetraditionallydonotbuildthatintoourplan.Butifyouaskme,whatisoneoftheopportunitiesforanyupsideofthatrange,you'dhavetothrowbuybackasanopportunityinthere.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

AndthisisRichard.Juststrategically,acquisitionsisakeyfactorofourgrowthoverlong-term.Andso,westillcontinuetolookforthoseopportunities.Andthefactthatwe'renowinthepetfoodbusiness,givesusanotherlaketofishin.Andso,we'llcontinuetolookthere.Andagainthosemaynotbestrategicintheshort-termbuttheymaybemorebolt-onsandsmalleracquisitions,buttheycouldbe.Soanywayjustashortanswer,butalwaysimportanttous.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Plansareinwater.

GregoryNep(Analyst-StephensInc):

Gotit.Andthereisatargetleverageratiothatyouwouldfeelcomfortablestabilizingat?

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Targetleverageratio?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

WellwhatwesaidisthatitsbeenalittlebitofmaturationforusasaCompany.Wewerealwaysprettyconservative.AndIthinknow,sortof3times,weknowisaprettygoodnumbertoworkaround.We'vebeenprettyvocaltothatinthelastsixtoninemonths.Aswegetclosertothat3times,itjustopensupthedooralittlebitmore.

GregoryNep(Analyst-StephensInc):

Gotit.Great.Thankyousomuch.

Operator :

ChuckCerankoskywithNorthcoastResearch.

ChuckCerankosky(Analyst-NorthcoastResearch):

Goodmorning,everyone.Greatquarter.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Page 27: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page27of30

Thankyou,Chuck.

ChuckCerankosky(Analyst-NorthcoastResearch):

Ifyouarelookingatyourlargestcustomer,howmuchoftheirimprovementinsalesisreflectedinsomeofthevolumeimprovementyou'veseen,especiallywithregardtopromotionalandrepricingactivity?

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Well,thisisRichard.Justfirstofall,italwayshelpswhenyourcustomersarehappyanddoingwell,anycustomer.Andsowe'regladtoseethatthey'veturnedthecorner,andthat'sgreat.Buttheydidn'tdriveourgrowth.Thisgrowthisbroad-based,sothatwasnotdrivingthis.

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

Andhi,Chuck,SteveOakland.

WehavebrandslikeFolgersthatindexreally,reallywellthere,andthoseteamsareworkingtogetherverystronglytoparticipateinthat,andliketohelpdrivetheircategorygrowth.ButIwouldarguethat,theothertraditionalretailers.Andwetypicallydon'tnamethem,butthetop10retailersifyoulookedatourtop10list,ournumbersareprettygoodacrossthatwholetop10list.Butwe'repleasedtoseethosedowell.Imean,weallasanindustry,needthemtodowelltodowelllong-term.

ChuckCerankosky(Analyst-NorthcoastResearch):

Andwhenyoulookathowconsumersarespreadingtheirmoneyacrossyourbrand'spremiumandmainstream,whatdoesthattellyouaboutwheretheconsumers'headisatrightnow?

SteveOakland (President,USFoodandBeverage):

WellIthinktheconsumerisstillsomewhatcautious.Andthegreatthingaboutourbrandsisourbrandsareprettywell-positionedtosupplyallofourconsumers.Andso,itisacautiousworldoutthere,andwe'restillagoodvalue.Imean,whetherit'sFolgers,orwhetherit'sJiforwhetherit'sSmuckers,it'sagoodvaluetotheconsumer,so.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

AndourindustryRichardhadacommoditypriceenvironmentthatallowedustomaintainourmargins,andreflectthosepricestothecustomerbase.Sowe'veallenjoyed,notjustcoffee,butothercommoditieshavebeeninaplacewherewe'vebeenabletomarketthebrands,providegreatpricepoints,andinnovate,right?

Sowe'vegotinnovationregardlessofthebusinessthat--inthingsthatareveryhighmixandhighcost,andthenprovideitemsinallofourbrands,inallofourbusinessestothediscountchannelstothegrowth,fromthedollarindustry,andthoseplaces.Sowe'vebeenabletoparticipateacrossthespectrumofchannelsprettywell,andthecostbasetoday,andaswelookforward,lookslikeithelpsustodothat.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

AndChuck,thisisMarkSmucker.

Justtoreiteratemakingsurethathave--thatwearedevelopingandgrowingourkeymainstreambrands,butalsomakingsurethatwehavetheright,thetruRoots,theSahale,theNaturalBalance.Thosearebrandsthataren'tnecessarilyasbig,butcertainlyserveaconsumerneedandareimportanttoourportfolio.

Page 28: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page28of30

ChuckCerankosky(Analyst-NorthcoastResearch):

Allright.Thankyouverymuch.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Thanks,Chuck.

Operator :

RobDickersonwithConsumerEdgeResearch.

RobDickerson (Analyst-ConsumerEdgeResearch):

Thanksalot.

Justaclarificationquestion,andmoreforMark.Soitsoundslikeyousaidinyourcommentary,thatadjustedoperatingprofitwillbegrowingabout4%.Andthen,Iknowifyouusethat116.6inyourdilutedsharesoutstanding,thatimpliesaboutanother2.5%.Sothatgetsmeto6.5%EPSgrowthin2017.

Istheassumptionherethatthereareother,belowtheline,likethetaxratecouldbealittlebitbetter?Orinterestratecomesdownalittlebit,orImean,theinterestexpensecomesdownalittlebit?Andthenlastly,ifwelookatthesharesyouboughtbackinQ4,reallyinFY16,Imean,it'sthemostamountyou'vespentonabuybackoutsideofFY14.Socouldtherebeadditionalcashoutlaysin2017toincrementalbuybacks,eventhoughyoumightnothaveasmanyoftheone-timebenefitsonyourworkingcap?Thanks.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Hey,Rob.Soacouplethings.Ithinkthewayyou'rethinkingaboutitfromapercentincreaseisprettymuchinline.Maybe,thesimplemathwouldsay4%plusoperatingprofitgrowth,3%shares,andapointtaxandinterest.Sothatkindofgetsyoutothe8%.Intermsofbuybacks,whatwe'veguidedindirect--andwehaveconversationsparticularlywiththeratingagencies,weuse2%asalong-termmodel.Sothat'sa2%buyback.Soobviously,at116millionshares,it'slookinglike2.2millionshares.SothatasIsaid,onyourearlierquestion,wedon'tfactorthatintoourplans.

Iwouldsay,ourcashdeploymentwouldallowaportionofthat,maybenotthewhole2%withoutpushingtheleveragetargetwe'regoingafter.Butcertainly,andagain,it'ssituational.SoIdon'twanttosithere,andsaywe'regoingtogooutandbuyit,butiftheopportunitywereright,Ibelievewehavethecashtodoit,anditobviouslywouldbeincremental.Certainly,whenwedoitintheyear,willhavelessofanimpact[due]furtherintotheyear.Butthat'sthebeautyofgettingtheleveragetowherewewantittobe,givesussomeflexibility.

RobDickerson (Analyst-ConsumerEdgeResearch):

Okay,great.Andthenjustaquickfollow-up.Onthe4%,ontheoperatingprofitgrowth,ifIheardyoucorrectly,yousaidthecoffeeexpectationwasaboutthesametoflat.Consumershouldbedownalittlebitjust,because,ormostlydrivenbymilk.Andthenpet'supmidsingle-digit.SoifIkindofdothatquickmath,I'mstillgettingtoprobably,I'dsaysub4%.Soisthere,areyou--I'mjusttryingtogetasenseofhowyou're--orhowIshouldbethinkingabouteachofthesegment'sgrowthrelative,tokindofthisrolledup4%number?Thanks.

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Well,Ithinkyouwillhavesomesegmentprofitgrowth.Itwillbealittlelessthan4%,becauseaswesaid

Page 29: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page29of30

inourscriptedcomments,ourSG&Aisgoingtobeflatyear-over-year.SosomeofthatSG&Aclearlygoesupintothebusinesses,butalsosomeofitfallsbelow,inwhatwewouldcalladminsupport,butit'sbelowthesegmentprofit.Soyouneedalittlebitofthatbenefittogettothe4%onanoperatinggrowthperspective.

Soyou'reright,there'salittlebit.Butagaintogoback,partofthatreasonisbecauseyouput$40millioninthemarketinginthere.SoI'mnotsaying,itdoesn'thaveaP&Limpact,butjusttomakesurewe'reallclearonwhythatisthecase.

RobDickerson (Analyst-ConsumerEdgeResearch):

Right.Soandthenabiggerpicture,ifwegobacktotheAnalystDay,andhowyou'reinvestingforgrowthetcetera.Sothenet-netofallofthisis,youhavesomeupsideonthecorporateside.You'reinvestingabunchback,butyou'renotinvestingitallback,sothatyoucanstillsqueezeoutthis3%,4%operatingprofitgrowth?That'sthegoalinternallyandexternally?

MarkBelgya(CFO):

Yes,Ithinkthat'sfair.Theothercommentonthe4%,againitgetslostalittlebit,becausewe'resayingthatthebuybackisoffsettingthemilkprofitloss.IfyoustripoutthemilkprofitthatweincurredinthefirsteightmonthsofFY16thatweownedthebusiness,we'reactuallygrowingoperatingincomeat6%.Sowe'reoffsettingit--sowe'rebeingnegativelyimpactedwhenyoulookatitonareportedbasis,butyoustripthatout,we'reactuallyupplus6%.

RobDickerson (Analyst-ConsumerEdgeResearch):

Okay,great.Thanks,guys.

Operator :

Thankyou.Iwillnowturntheconferencecallbacktomanagementtoconclude.

RichardSmucker (ExecutiveChairman):

Thankyouverymuch.ThisisRichard.Ijustwantedtoclosebysaying,thatI'veneverbeenasoptimisticaboutourbusiness,ourbrands,ouremployeesthroughouttheCompany,thebestintheindustry,andtheleadershipteam,especiallythenewleadershipteamwehave.

Ijustthinkwe'reinagreatposition,andIwanttothankeverybodyandthankouremployeesforthewonderfuljobthey'redoing.Andthankallofthepeopleonthephoneforpayingattention,andaskinggreatquestions.Sothankyouandmoretocome,bestisyettocome.

MarkSmucker (President&CEO):

Thankyou,Richard.ThisisMarkSmucker.JusttoechoRichard'scomments,appreciate,ofcourse,Richard'ssupport,butthankallofyouonthephoneforyourtimetoday,andyourthoughtfulquestions.Andagain,justouremployees.Phenomenaljobtheyhavedonetodeliverthisincredibleyear,andthefutureisbright.Sojustallofthetremendouseffortstakenplacethisyearandgoingforward,thankyou.

Operator :

Ladiesandgentlemen,ifyouwishtoaccessthisrebroadcastafterthislivecall,youmaydosobydialing855-859-2056or404-537-3406,withapasscodeof10365564.Thisconcludesourconferencecallfortoday.

Page 30: Smucker (JM) (SJM) Earnings Report: Q4 2016 Conference ... · Welcome to the J. M. Smucker Company's fourth quarter 2016 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I will now

CompanyName:JMSmuckerCoCompanyTicker:SJMSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:Food&Beverage

EventDescription:Q42016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:15.88BPriceasofEventDate:144.1215

©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page30of30

Allrightsreserved(c)2014TheStreet,Inc.

Pleasefeelfreetoquoteupto200wordspertranscript.Anyquoteshouldbeaccompaniedby"ProvidedbyTheStreet"andalinktothecompletetranscriptandwww.thestreet.com.Anyotheruseormethodofdistributionisstrictlyprohibited.

THEINFORMATIONCONTAINEDINEACHWRITTENORAUDIOTRANSCRIPT(the"TRANSCRIPT")ISAREPRODUCTIONOFAPARTICULARCOMPANY'SCONFERENCECALL,CONFERENCEPRESENTATIONOROTHERAUDIOPRESENTATION.THETRANSCRIPTSAREPROVIDED"ASIS"AND"ASAVAILABLE"ANDTHESTREETISNOTRESPONSIBLEINANYWAYNORDOESITMAKEANYREPRESENTATIONORWARRANTYREGARDINGTHEACCURACYORCOMPLETENESSOFTHETRANSCRIPTSASPRODUCED,NORTHESUBSTANCEOFAPARTICULARCOMPANY'SINFORMATION.

THETRANSCRIPTSAREPROVIDEDFORINFORMATIONALPURPOSESONLY.THESTREETISNOTPROVIDINGANYINVESTMENTADVICEORENDORSINGANYPARTICULARCOMPANY.