small donor matching funds: the nyc election experience

8/3/2019 Small Donor Matching Funds: The NYC Election Experience

1/48

K A F n}Olp Yc{e \oixl{qi}y Qajccb c Bnp

Qgnbb Mcoc{

gn}ajio` h|oMQ6

}jl oYa lbla}ico

lztl{iloal

N G

Q B

H H N/C/ Q" F/


2/48

NKC\] ]JL K[LOONO ALO]L[ HC[ F\Q]IAL

] K A F O Y \ Q B '

f/ C

" f /

N " " K A

" " "

/

NKC\] ]JL K[LOONO ALO]L[Q MLGCA[NAY T[C@[NG

] K A M T N / P '

/ P

H N f / P " "

/ ] M T G T f

/ P '

H L "

/ Tf " " " "

"

" " /

;44/ ] A A N'O M'OA

* 6##/)/ I K A F

OY\ Q B " A " / ]

" " A /

T A /


3/48

]JL N\]JC[Q

No`lbn Gi`nbby A K A M T/ N

K A G T f" G/ G

/ Q ' ' N" A

P/ ] " G/ G

\/Q/ Q A A Q

OY\ N M / T f K A" G/ G '

B H C / G" BBA/ Q J"

J [" BBT J P J [ \

Q M A Q C/ G/ G F/M/ \ T'

B Q K/N/ L T Q C A/

Q|qno Biqq M M T" A X [

L" [ X" G T" H I A" A ['" O Y Q @ N/ I 14' " G/ B

" / M A'

@ " M F M N N @

T M A Q A A [ M/ Q

A Q G/ @ Q A X T/ T f K

A" M H [ A G/ Q

\ G @ \ B A"

K M A/

H{lml{iae N/C/ Qajpn{v" F{/ A A K A" f

;44;/ Q 984" G/ Q " z / G/

Q A" Q G"

/ H 90


4/48

NAEOCPBLM@LGLO]Q

G / Q K A G Y" A '

Q" G G" E P" N J" F \

/ ] L M" O Y A " B G" O [" M [" G [" F Q"

J E/ ] F H" L H" A

H K /

] H Q" z / G

P" "

/ ]

/

] K A M N T" H H" C Q I'" [ K H" M B Q" P @ H

/


5/48

HC[LPC[M

Ky H{lml{iae N/C/ Qajpn{v" F{/&

Q " Q A F B K 6

UIW} i }j jtty iaim} }j m{ y}g }j} i` a|{`| }} gy"

i i} ai}iv aj" {x {}{y5 m }{y x ai m agia zt{i'

g} pi}j|} {ie } }j {} }j a|}{y/

N / ] O Y A

A H N/;

] [ O Y A '

z/ N I ' z"

/ A " O Y

/ I "

/

K " O Y A '

" I /

H" / ] z

/ N " '9:4" A f / N'

* .) O Y A '

/ I A A G L I/ E/ E

" A/ G G

" " "

/ Q " I G E /

G E " " " T V"

T X" Q A A " A 9::/

I A A/ I A A

f I A'A A A /1 Q

/

& H ;441 ;44:" H N/C/ *H) Q" F/ A O Y A A H K/ K "

9:: A'A A A A A A A H B/ N

A A A 9:; 9:8" G/ Q A / H"

" G/ Q " " *)

A '' /


6/48


7/48

]nkbl ch Aco]lo]q

I/ Io][cM\A]Ico >

II/ ]Jl Aco]c\[q ch ]Jl olP Yc[E AI]Y G\b]ITbl Gn]AJ qYq]lG 1

N/ H{cg Qanomnb }c [lhc{g 1

K/ Jcp I} Pc{eq =

>/ ]jl Qgnbb Mcoc{ G|b}itbl Gn}aj =

;/ ^|nbihyio` A{i}l{in6 Gneio` Qgnbb Mcoc{q Lqqlo}inb h{cg }jl Q}n{} 8

1/ Xcb|o}n{y Lztlomi}|{l Bigi}q 0

=/ Lgtcpl{io` Xc}l{q pi}j Iohc{gn}ico 0

4

N/ [ck|q} Tn{}iaitn}ico Blxlbq >4

K/ Ioa{lnqio` }jl Q|ttby ch nom Mlgnom hc{ Qgnbb Mcoc{q >>

>/ Lztnomio` }jl Tccb ch Mcoc{q >>

;/ Ioa{lnqio` Anomimn}l [lbinoal co Qgnbb mcoc{q >1

A/ H|qio` H|om{niqio` pi}j Xc}l{ C|}{lnaj >:

M/ Kccq}io` Acgtl}i}ico ]j{c|`j Qtlomio` Tn{i}y >9

L/ T{cm|aio` n Olp A{ct ch Anomimn}lq ;>

H/ Pjn} Nkc|} Kbccgkl{`3 ;;

IX/ Acoq]I]\]Iconb AcoqIMl[n]Icoq ;1

X/ AcoAb\qIco6 qGnbb Mcoc[ T\kbIA hIonoAIo@n GcMlb hc[ [lhc[G ;=


8/48

> r K{loono alo}l{ hc{ F|Q}ial

Io][cM\A]Ico

/ I Ai}ivloq \oi}lm x/ HLA" \/Q/ Q A

H N z

' / I " F F T Q

" "

/8

K " 6 / I ;44: "

/0 H "

/

] "

/ T

/ C "

/ ["

/

] H L O N *H L) " "

A / H L A

-44 ''

* )/: ] " T H N ;44'

''

-;44 * )/9

^ 6 J 3 P "

" 3 P 3

] z O Y A

/ H ;; " A

G" A" T N" K T" A

A/4 B " A z'

z / J" " "

-0< z'' /

I/


9/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r ;

N " O Y A

/ ] A

" G G K"

/

N " O Y A 6

]l t{c`{ng lofcyq {ck|q} tn{}iaitn}ico ky ql{ic|q" a{lmikbl anomimn}lq/

Qioal }jl lona}glo} ch }jl g|b}itbl gn}aj" }jl o|gkl{ ch cxl{nbb aco}{ik|}c{q nom }jl

/

Tn{}iaitno}q {lby co n `{ln}l{ o|gkl{ ch qgnbbl{ mcoc{q }jno mc ocotn{}iaitno}q/

]l t{c`{ng loac|{n`lq anomimn}lq }c h|ql h|om{niqio` nom xc}l{ c|}{lnaj lc{}q/

]l qyq}lg t{cgc}lq xc}l{ ajcial ky lonkbio` n mixl{ql tccb ch anomimn}lq pi}j q|kq}no}inb

/

Hionbby" lqtlainbby io ctlo'qln} lbla}icoq" }jl qyq}lg jnq kccq}lm acgtl}i}ico ky lonkbio`

/


10/48

1 r K{loono alo}l{ hc{ F|Q}ial

]Jl Aco]c\[q ch ]Jl olP Yc[E AI]Y G\b]ITbl Gn]AJ qYq]lG

n/ h{g qam } [{g

I O Y A" " /

B F 9:8" @ A T/ P

" ^ K T M G"

" / N " G / I

" " / Q " G /;

] f 6 G

z / Q

" " f/ N " " Q

H" Kz M /1

] /= N G L E M

" /

I 9:8" E @ G A f Q'A A I @'

/< ] A / N

' /8 Q N"

/

I H 9::" O Y A A O Y A A H

N/0 I ' " / E '

/:

B "

/9 K A

/ I " A

z

/;4

I 9:9" -"444 O Y '

/ I z"

* -;"444 -1"444 ) z /; *N "

A Q

II/

]j op Y{e Ai}y t|ia iai`

y}g e } t{x} a{{|t}i m

ztm }j ai}iv { i a}i

h{cg xc}l{ }c }jn} ch onoail{ nom lxlo

amim}/


11/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r =

-44"444 /;; ]"

/)

] '

/ H 99: ;449" A / G @" A T N * ) 99=';44

" z 6

N " z '' -"444 / K

"

"

/;1

]" ;44 " A -;


12/48

< r K{loono alo}l{ hc{ F|Q}ial

H z" A N/ ]

-0< -";;< / A -


13/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r 8

;/ ^|nbihyio` A{i}l{in6 Gneio` Qgnbb Mcoc{q Lqqlo}inb h{cg }jl Q}n{}

K " '

* 1)/ 1< I ;449"

G -;="40< -1


14/48


K " " "

" F 4 '

/ I " * )

/1:

1/ Xcb|o}n{y Lztlomi}|{l Bigi}q

I z "

'

/ G "

z /19 H

z" ;449 " '

A A

-8"444 -8"444 '

" " -1;;"444/=4 < /

=/ Lgtcpl{io` Xc}l{q pi}j Iohc{gn}ico

I '

" O Y A

" " /

H" " '" "

/= M ;449 " 8 /=; N"

" z * z

) /=1

] A H K '

"

/== ] z " "

" " '

" " /=


15/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r :

H" O Y A L Q *" " A E)

/=: ] A / ]

" " " "

" z " " f "

" " / ] " " "

" /=9


16/48


" AHK / N "

AHK z z

/ N " Olp Yc{e iglq AHK z "

AHK -:44"444 /8

J" AHK

/ I "

/ N" -:44"444 AHK

4/:, AHK 990/8;

] A O Y A A H H /81

] H A A /8=

ki` ntt la}i6 o} Y|{ ]ytia G|iait [a

Lxl{y hc|{ yln{q" Olp Yc{el{q lbla} }jli{ Gnyc{" Acgt}{cbbl{" T|kbia Nmxcan}l" xl Kc{c|`j T{lqimlo}q

nom Ac|oaibglgkl{q/8< Olp Yc{e Ai}yq bn{`l tct|bn}ico nom lztloqixl glmin gn{el} a{ln}lq n ji`j

q}nelq lbla}c{nb loxi{coglo} }jn} {ixnbq gnoy q}n}lpiml nom hlml{nb lbla}icoq/

Olp Yc{e iq }jl gcq} tct|bc|q ai}y io }jl \oi}lm Q}n}lq/88 I}q ai}y'piml chalq cxl{o cxl{ : gibbico tlctbl

*}jl {c|`j l~|ixnblo} ch }jl acgkiolm tct|bn}icoq ch >4 q}n}lq)" ioab|mio` =/< gibbico xc}l{q/80 Lxlo n} }jl

miq}{ia} blxlb" ai}y ac|oaibglgkl{q {l`|bn{by {lt{lqlo} gc{l tlctbl }jno gnoy q}n}l blìqbn}c{q/ Iomllm" io

;441" lnaj ch }jl Ai}yq miq}{ia}q jnm kl}pllo >=4"444 nom >04"444 acoq}i}|lo}q/8:Ch nbb q}n}l blìqbn}ixl

jc|ql miq}{ia}q na{cqq }jl ac|o}{y" coby Anbihc{oinq miq}{ia}q jnxl gc{l acoq}i}|lo}q co nxl{n`l }jno Olp

Yc{e Ai}y ac|oaib miq}{ia}q/89Kc{c|`j T{lqimlo}q ano {lt{lqlo} nq gnoy nq ;/< gibbico acoq}i}|lo}q/04

Pi}j qc gnoy xc}l{q }c {lnaj io col ch }jl on}icoq gcq} lztloqixl glmin gn{el}q" Olp Yc{e Ai}y ano'

mimn}lq h{l~|lo}by qtlom gc{l gcoly co }jli{ angtniòq }jno mc anomimn}lq io hlml{nb nom q}n}l {nalq/

Io ;44:" hc{ lzngtbl" piooio` anomimn}lq hc{ \/Q/ Qlon}l qtlo} no nxl{n`l ch -:/< gibbico/ 0 Nq iq plbb

eocpo" Olp Yc{e Ai}y Gnyc{ Giajnlb Kbccgkl{` jnq qtlo} |ot{lalmlo}lm q|gq ch jiq cpo gcoly io

jiq kimq hc{ Gnyc{io ;449 jl qtlo} ->4: gibbico/0; Blqq eocpo iq }jn} jiq c|}gn}ajlm cttcolo}q jnxl

qtlo} q|kq}no}inb q|gq }ccn} blnq} -9 gibbico io ;44< nom ;449/01

Ac|oaib {nalq nbqc n{l |o|q|nbby lztloqixl/ Io ;449" }jl nxl{n`l ngc|o} qtlo} ky t{ixn}lby onoalm Ai}y

Ac|oaib anomimn}lq io }jl t{ign{y pnq ->>9"9;> nom -8;"01> io }jl `lol{nb lbla}ico/0= Iomllm" io }jl

Miq}{ia} >9 {nal" Elxio Eig" {lbyio` coby co t{ixn}l gcoly" qtlo} cxl{ -8


17/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r >4

]Jl MlGcA[n]IVn]Ico ch AnGTnI@o h\oM[nIqIo@

I A 6 "

" f / K z "

" / N z "

/

] "

/ Q

/ ] z /

Q ;44" A f "

/ T / ]

" '

/

] / ] z

/ K

" /

n/ [|} T{}iait}i bx

] f /

I O Y A" / ] 6 89, M/00G " " /0:

I ;449" 91, A '

/ ] " 88, / 09 ]

/:4 I" 6 ;449 " T N"

A" K T"


18/48

>> r K{loono alo}l{ hc{ F|Q}ial

] * ) / L'

991" ' / N "

/ N "

/:=

]" ;44:" G K" A '

/ N "

*

)/

] 8 op Y{e Ai}y T|ia hiai` T{}iait}i [} >990';449

T [

*O T)

O T

L C

*


19/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r >;

M O Y A / I ;44


20/48

>1 r K{loono alo}l{ hc{ F|Q}ial

] pjc / A '

/ H " G [ @

'' ;44" 6

HN'N" B ' z A/ X H" G K T

990';44< N'N G/ ] T

" "

" /90

H[ A" A

" " '

/ ]

U W / / / / ] A / / / " "

/9:

H[ T" O Y T M " K

A J B / J " I

/ I / / / / I '

I /99

O z " " / K" '

/ N ;449

/ G " / J"

" " " " '

" " " /44

;/ Ioa{lnqio` Anomimn}l [lbinoal co Qgnbb Mcoc{q

] / ] z '

z z

/

HI ;44" K K" J A -;: '

\/Q/ Q "4

/ K "

"

/ / / / P "


21/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r >=

/4; A A T N " T

N K

/ P " " '

A A " /41

HN A A A A \/Q/ A"

z B A A M Y

/ N '

A A"

/4= I " -/<

" /4


22/48

>< r K{loono alo}l{ hc{ F|Q}ial

K " / I

;449" A A mc|kbl

' A A / H " "


23/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r >8

Tn{}iaitn}io` Anomimn}lq

Oco'Tn{}iaitn}io` Anomimn}lq

Nxl{n`l Aco}{ik|}icoq"

Ai}y Ac|oaib [nalq ;44< nom ;449

4

>44

;44

144

=44


24/48


J }j qy}g A|{m }j Tp{ qtai I}{}3

I} iq lz}{lglby miha|b} }c ~|no}ihy }jl tcpl{ ch qtlainb io}l{lq}q nom }c iqcbn}l }jl igtna} ch }jl qyq}lg co q|aj io}l{lq}q/ Pl bnae

{lbinkbl" t{l'lona}glo} qtlomio` mn}n5 c}jl{ {lhc{gq *q|aj nq }jl ;44> kno co mi{la} ac{tc{n}l aco}{ik|}icoq) jnxl jnm no igtna}

nq plbb/ Nom g|aj io}l{lq} {c|t io|loal iq pilbmlm ky iomixim|nb mcoc{q" l/`/" {lnb lq}n}l mlxlbctl{q c{ knoel{q" pi}jc|} {lac|{ql}c TNAq c{ mi{la} ac{tc{n}l `ih}q/ N {lalo} q}|my ky T{chlqqc{ Giajnlb Gnbkio ch }jl \oixl{qi}y n} Nbknoy" Q}n}l \oixl{qi}y ch Olp

Yc{e" q|``lq}q" jcplxl{" }jn} bn{`l mcoc{q" |oicoq nom TNAq lzl{} blqq io|loal co tn{}iaitn}io` anomimn}lq" pjc mltlom jlnxiby

co qgnbb mcoc{q/

]jl ajn{} klbcp mltia}q }jl qc|{al ch anomimn}l h|omq io ;44< Ai}y Ac|oaib {nalq ky }ytl nom qivl ch aco}{ik|}c{/ 0 *Coby on}|{nb tl{'

qco mcoc{q pl{l ac|o}lm io {c|tq imlo}ilm knqlm co aco}{ik|}ico qivl/ Oco'tn{}y c{`noivn}icoq ioab|ml mcoc{ TNAq nom |oicoq/)

Nq }jl q}|my qjcpq" }jl qc|{alq |tco pjiaj tn{}iaitn}io` nom oco'tn{}iaitn}io` anomimn}lq {lby n{l gi{{c{ cttcqi}lq/ Cxl{ jnbh ch

}jl gcoly nxnibnkbl }c tn{}iaitn}io` anomimn}lq angl h{cg tlctbl pjc `nxl -;4, ch tn{}iaitn}io` anomimn}lq gcoly angl h{cg }jlql c{`noivn}icoq/

\oml{ }jl qyq}lg" tn{}iaitno}q n{l hn{ blqq {lbino} co bn{`l mcoc{q nom c{`noivn}iconb io}l{lq}q nom g|aj gc{l {lbino} co qgnbb iomi'

xim|nb mcoc{qioa{lnqio` }jl tcpl{ ch qgnbb iomixim|nb mcoc{q/

Qc|{alq ch Gcoly io Ai}y Ac|oaib [nalq *;444

;4

14

=4

'-;


25/48

Qgnbb Mcoc{ gn}ajio` h|oMQ6 }jl oYa lbla}ico lztl{iloal r >:

A/ h|i` h|m{ii` pi}j X}{ c|}{aj

N "

/

M Y " I " / Y

/; \" * ) *

" )/ \ OYA "

/ ] '

6 /

HA A M M" ;449

^ M ;


26/48


M/ k}i` Agt}i}i ]j{|`j qtmi` T{i}y

Io }jl tnq}" Olp Yc{e Ai}y lbla}icoq jnm n al{}nio bnae c qyggl}{y/ Col anomimn}l jnm }jl gcoly"

}jl gnibio`q" }jl lomc{qlglo}q" }jl k|o}io`" }jl jlnm~|n{}l{q pi}j {lnb mlqeq nom qtn{l tjcolq nom

an{tl}q/ ]n} pnq }jl ioa|gklo}/ ]l ajnbblo`l{ ollmlm n `{ln} mlnb c ol{xl nom caanqiconbby lxlo

n kcmy`|n{m }c xlo}|{l c|} co }jl q}{ll}q/

]iq yln{ iq mil{lo}/ Mlgca{nay iq jnxio` i}q mny ac|{}lqy c n }l{g bigi}q bnp }jn} gnml nxnib'

nkbl gc{l }jno =4 lbla}ixl calq n} xn{ic|q blxlbq c ai}y `cxl{oglo}/ Co }ct c }jn} iq n angtni`o

onoal qyq}lg }jn} cl{q t|kbia gcoly }c gn}aj aco}{ik|}icoq c{ ~|nbiyio` anomimn}lq/

Nq n {lq|b}" }jl ai}y jnq kllo qpn{gio` pi}j tcbi}ianb jctl|bq" {lhla}icoq c }jl ai}y i}qlb pi}j i}q

gnoy xcialq" acbc{q" on}iconbi}ilq nom tcbi}ianb blnoio`q / / / / ]l klq} tn{} c }jiq pibm lbla}ico yln{ iq

}jl pny i}q k{cnmloio` }jl ai}yq knql c tcbi}ianbby na}ixl {lqimlo}q klycom }jl cbm }lo|{lm caljcbm'

l{q" }jli{ igglmin}l ngibilq nom }jli{ nocio}lm q|aalqqc{q/ LzaL{t}h{cg OLpYc{e}igLq Lmi}c{inb" qLt}/ 9" ;44>;4

F B

Mcglq}ia Q|{xlibbnoal6 Olp [|blq" Olp [iqeqL K

Mcglq}ia Ac|o}l{'l{{c{iqg nom [nmianbivn}icoH T

Ac{tc{n}l Angtni`o Qtlomio`6 @ixio` Qjn{ljcbml{q n XcialA 'Q

Hc{labcq|{lq6 N A{iqiq io Bl`nb [lt{lqlo}n}icoG A G K

[nainb Miqtn{i}ilq io Hlml{nb T{cqla|}icoqK A F O I B L

H " ///


48/48

N} Olp Yc{e \oixl{qi}y Qajccb c Bnp

small donor matching funds: the nyc election experience

Documents