si/g in li - niscairnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/ijca 44a(5) 975-982.pdf · nano...

8
Indinn Journa l of Chcm i ,lry VoL 44A. Mny 200.\ pp. 975-982 Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications Uclay S Ka savajju la & Chunsheng Wang* Departmenl of Chem i ca l Engineerin g. Tenne ssee Teehn ologil'al Universil Y. Cookevi ll e. TN -38 505. USA Email: cswang@lnl ec h.edu Receil' ed 20 Dece/llber 2004 A composill: anode maleri al wilh a co mposili on of grap hil e- nano -s ili con-ceram i c-PEO+L iCIO. ha s been in ve sli galed for Li i on halleri es. and il s performance al differenl lemperatures (from -40°C 10 45°C) and current densilies analyzed using variou;, electrochemical melhods. Eleclrochemical behavior of compos il e anodes wilh differenl Si and cer am ic composili on s ha s been sludi ed using ga l vu nostalic cha rge-discharge cycling and AC impeda nce nna lysis. Composile anode wilh a composil ion of graphilc (50%)-nano Si ( I O%)-ccramic (20%)-PEO+ LiCl04 (20%) (WI %) shows a stable reversible capacilY oj" JOO mAh /g over 50 cycl e;, al room lemperalure and a reversible capac il Y of 160 mAh /g at -30°e. Enhanced low lemperalure performance ha s been observed du e In Ihe add ili on of ceramic. which in llIrn incr eases Ihe Li ion conduclivilY of Ihe anode resulting in improved charge transfer kinl:lic s. J PC Code: Inl. CI 7 88 2 8: I j() I M4/40: C0483517 1 At room temperature. Li ion batteries ex hibit high spec ific energy and energy density. long cycle li re . and low se lf-discharge. Due to th ese properties. Li i on batteries are widely used in portable electronic devices. rlow ever. at temperatures bel ow -20°C, commercial I R650 Li-ion battery exhibits very l ow speciric capacity compared to th e room temperature capacit/ ·:> . and hence does not sat isfy th e req uirements for aerospace applicatio ns . The main reaso ns for poor low temperature performance are: (i) red uc ed ionic conductivity of the electrolyte. and so lid el ec trolyte inter face (SE D film. ( ii) limit ed Li ion diffusion ab ility in th e anode, and ( iii ) increa sed charge tran sfer resistance leading to poor electrochemical kinetics. To Improve the l ow- temperature conductivity of electrolytes, various electroly te s for Li ion batteries ha ve been prepared and tes ted in the temperature range of O°C to -40°C (refs 3-7). It was found that certain electrolytes with propylene carbonate} ( PC ). ethyl acetateS (EA) , methyl buty rate ) (MB), etc. as so lv en ts show better low temperature performance as compared to commercial Li ion ce ll electrolytes. More detailed analys is by Hu ang el a1. 8 and Li el ai . ') have shown that th e ionic conductiviti es of the el ec trolyte and SEf film have l ess effect on low temperature performance as compared to charge transfer kinetics in the anode. This was also confirmed by AC impedance analysi slO. II. From these res ult s. it may be in ferred that th e l ow temperature performance can be improved by increasing the Li ion co ndu ctivit y of the anode. This in turn, increases th e Li ion diffu si vity and reduces the charge transfer resistance. Improving th e specific capacity of the anode is another important i ssue for Li ion batteries. Among the gro up IV elements, sil icon has high theoretical capacity 01" 4200 mAh/g ( 10 times> that of graphite) and it ca n al so reversibly alloy with· Li. However, Si exh ibit s 300% volume expansion during charge- d · h I' Th' ISC arge cyc In 6 process - IS generates enormO Ll S stress in the anode, l eading to anode decrepitation and hen ce resu lting in severe capacity f · d 13 14 Rd ' h S' . I . a e " . e uCll1g tel partlc e sIze to nan o meters can on ly red uce the pulverization to a certain extent. but cannot suppress it completely. One way to overcome this problem is to embed the nano Si particl es in a so lid el ec tronic conducting matrix. V . I Y I IS K' I 16 L' anous groups suc 1 as ang el a. , 1m el a. , III el a /. 17 , and Kim el al. ls have prepared Si/C composite anodes by pyro l ys is of Si and carhon prec urso r material s, which showed a stable reversible capacity of 700mAh/g over 30 cycles. Wang el a/. II) report ed a reversible capacity of 900mAh/g for Si/MCMB compos it e anode prepared from high energy mechanical milling. However, long cycling performance and l ow temperature performan ce fo r th ese anodes have not been reported. To meet the ASA requirements fo r aerospace app li cations, anode for Li ion battery should ha ve high specific capac it y, good cycle life in the

Upload: others

Post on 03-Nov-2019

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

Indinn Journa l of Chcm i,lry VoL 44A. Mny 200.\ pp. 975-982

Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications

Uclay S Kasavajju la & Chunsheng Wang*

Departmenl of Chem ica l Engineerin g. Tennessee Teehnologil'a l UniversilY. Cookevi ll e. TN-38505. USA Email: cswang @lnlech.edu

Receil 'ed 20 Dece/llber 2004

A composill: anode malerial w ilh a composili on of graphile-nano-s ili con-ceram ic-PEO+LiCIO. has been in vesligaled for Li ion halleri es. and ils performance al differenl lemperatures (from -40°C 10 45°C) and current densilies analyzed using variou;, electrochemical melhods. Elecl rochemical behavior of compos ile anodes wilh differenl Si and ceramic composili ons has been sludied using ga lvunostalic charge-discharge cycli ng and AC impedance nna lysis. Composile anode wilh a composil ion of graphilc (50%)-nano Si ( I O%)-ccrami c (20%)-PEO+LiCl04 (20%) (WI %) shows a stable reversible capacilY oj" JOO mAh/g over 50 cycle;, al room lemperalure and a reversib le capac ilY of 160 mAh/g at -30°e. Enhanced low lemperalure performance has been observed due In Ihe add ili on of ceramic. which in llIrn increases Ihe Li ion conduclivilY of Ihe anode resulting in improved charge transfer kinl:lics.

J PC Code: Inl. CI 7 8828: I j() I M4/40: C0483517 1

At room temperature. Li ion batteries exhibit high spec ific energy and energy density. long cycle li re. and low sel f-discharge. Due to th ese properties. Li ion batteries are widely used in portable electronic devices. rlowever. at temperatures below -20°C, commercial I R650 Li-ion battery exhibits very low speciric capacity compared to the room temperature capacit/ ·:> . and hence does not sat isfy the requirements for aerospace applicati ons. The main reasons for poor low temperature performance are: (i) reduced ionic conductivity of the electro lyte. and solid elec trolyte interface (SED film. (ii) limited Li ion diffusion ab ility in the anode, and (iii ) increased charge transfer resistance leading to poor electrochemical kinetics. To Improve the low­temperature conductivity of electrolytes, various electrolytes for Li ion batteries have been prepared and tes ted in the temperature range of O°C to -40°C (refs 3-7) . It was found that certain electrol ytes with propy lene carbonate} (PC). ethyl acetateS (EA), methyl buty rate) (MB), etc. as so lven ts show better low temperature performance as compared to commercia l Li ion ce ll electrol y tes. More detailed analys is by Huang el a1. 8 and Li el ai .') have shown that the ionic conductiviti es of the electrol y te and SEf film have less effect on low temperature performance as compared to charge transfer kinetics in the anode. This was also confirmed by AC impedance analysislO. II. From these results. it may be in ferred that th e low temperature performance can be

improved by increasing the Li ion conductivity of the anode. This in turn, increases the Li ion diffusivity and reduces the charge transfer resistance.

Improv ing the specific capacity of the anode is another important issue for Li ion batteries. Among the group IV elements, sil icon has high theoretical capacity 01" 4200 mAh/g ( 10 times> that of graphite) and it can also reversibly alloy with · Li. However, Si exh ibits 300% volume expansion during charge-d· h I' 1 ~- 14 Th' ISC arge cyc In6 process - IS generates enormOLlS stress in the anode, leading to anode decrepitation and hence resu lting in severe capacity f· d 13 14 Rd ' h S' . I . a e " . e uCll1g tel partlc e sIze to nano meters can on ly reduce the pulverization to a certa in extent. but cannot suppress it complete ly . One way to overcome this problem is to embed the nano Si particles in a solid elec tronic conducting matrix. V . I Y I IS K' I 16 L' anous groups suc 1 as ang el a. , 1m el a. , III el a/. 17

, and Kim el al. l s have prepared Si/C composite anodes by pyro lys is of Si and carhon precursor material s, which showed a stable reversib le capacity of 700mAh/g over 30 cycles. Wang el a/. II) reported a revers ible capacity of 900mAh/g for Si/MCMB compos ite anode prepared from high energy mechanical milling. However, long cycling performance and low temperature performance fo r these anodes have not been reported.

To meet the ASA requirements for aerospace applications, anode for Li ion battery should have high specific capacity, good cyc le life in the

Page 2: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

976 INDIAN J CHEM. SEC A. MA Y 2005

temperature range of 60DC to -30DC and also the abi lity to be used in so lid polymer electrolyte ce ll s. In thi s paper, a new Si /graphite composite anode with high low-temperature performance is discussed. To improve the low temperature performance. cerami c powder with high Li ionic conductivity and low activation energy was mixed w ith nano Si-graphite composite. To further improve the low temperature performance. a su itable Li ion conductive polymer binder was chosen for preparation of the anode. The influence or cerami c on the low temperature performance has also been investigated.

Materials and Methods Electrode preparation

Polyethylene oxide (Aldrich ) and LiCl04 (A ldrich) powders in 8.5: 1.5 weight ratios were dissolved in aceton itrile (Sigma-Aldrich, 99.8%) to form a homogenous polymer solution. Lithium sulfide (Aldrich) and phosphorous pentasulfide (Aldrich) powders in 8:2 molar ratios were ball milled for 12h and then heat treated at 300°C for 2h to form a high Li-i on conductive ceramic powder. Graphite ks-4 (Timcal Group, Switzerl and). Si. 80Li ~S '20P2S 5

powder, and (PEO)lr,(LiCl04)-acetonitrile solution with different composit ions were mixed and sealed in a stai nless steel vial inside the argon-fi li ed glove box . Mixing 80Li2S20P2Ss powder with G-Si-PEO compos ite anode increases the ionic conductivity of the anode. and also enhances low-temperature performance of the anode. Ceramic powder with a compOSition 80Li2S20P2Ss has a high room temperature conducti vity of 7 .2x 10-4 S/cm and a low acti vation energy «0.3e V)20. Li ion conductive LiCl04-PEO polymer was used as a binder to further improve the ionic conductivity of composite anode.

Us ing a SPEX-8000 high energy mechanical mi II, the graphite-nano-Si -ceramics-PEO-LiCI04

compos ite was mechanically milled for 5 min. to obtain a homogeneous slurry. The slurry was then rolled 4-5 times to form a high density Si/G composite thin film (50jlm). This composite film was later used to couple with solid electro lyte. It has been observed that liquid elec trolytes can hardly penetrate into high-density thin film (anode). Therefore, the Li ion mobility is highly dependent on Li ion conductive ceramics and PEO-LiCL04 in the anode. If high performance can be obtained from thi s anode using a liquid elec trolyte, simi lar performance can also be obtained from the same anode using a so lid electrolyte. It may be noted that solid electrolytes

have lower Li ion conductivity compared to liquid electrolytes. To investi gate the influence of Si parti cle size on the electrochemica l performance or the anodes, nano Si (30-70nm, Nanostructured &. Amorphous Materials Inc) and Illi cm Si ( 1-20flm. Aldrich) were used for the preparatioll of the anodes. To remove excess acetonitrile so lvent. thin rilms were dried in a vacuum oven maintained at IOO"C. Then. these dry thin fitms were pressed to enhance th e contact between the active material s and the conducti ve graphi teo

Elcctrochemical tcsting

The CR2032 coin cell s, consisting of Si/G composite anode as The working electrode. a Li metal as a counter electrode, and 1M LiPFr/EC/DEC/DMC/EMC ( I : I : I : 1:3 by vol .. Ferro Corporation) as electrolyte. were assembled inside the glove box. LiPFr/EC/DEC/DMC/EMC can be used as an electrolyte even at a temperature below -30"C. Thi . is because of the ex istence of liquid phase even at a low temperature of AODC (ref. 8). Al l the cell s wer ~

gal vanostatically discharged (Li inserti on) and charged (Li ex traction) in the range of 0-1 .5V at different current densities using Arbin battery tes ter (model BT2000). Impedance analys is of all the anodes in half ce ll s was done using a frequency response analyzer, (Solatran. FRA 1260) and an electrochemical interface (Solatran. model 1286). Before impedance rneasurements were made, all the anodes were di scharged to 0 V and were maintained at 0 V for more than 3h. Thi s process allowed th e Li ions to be full y inserted into the anode. The ac impedance of the ce ll was measured. whil e maintaining a DC potential of 10mV over the frequency range of 1000 kH z - 0.001 Hz.

Results and Discussion Influcllce of Si particle size 011 electrochemical perfol"lna ncc

Figure I shows the di scharge charge capaci ties of micro and nano Si z.nodes for 37 cyc les . These cell s were discharged and charged at a current densi ty of 20mA/g. During the initi al cycle, nano Si anode showed a di scharge capacity of 829mAh/g, and a charge capacity of 560mAh/g. This resu lted in an irreversible capacity of 47.8%. Also, micro Si anode exhib ited a di scharge capacity of 789 mAh/g and a charge capacity of 573 mAh/g, resulti ng in irreversible capacity of 37.8%. Both these anodes showed an initial charge capac ity which is nearly equivalent to the theoretical capacity (606 mAh/g). but the nano Si anode showed high irreversihle

Page 3: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

KASAVAJJULA & WA G: NANO SI/G COMPOS ITE ANODE IN Li ION BATTERY 977

900

800 6 \

700 i

~ 600 ..: .s 500 z. 'u

400 "' a.

"' U 300

200

100 o 10

• Micro 5i • Charge ·· ··· 0 ··· ·· ·· Micro 5i· Discharge

---1'--- Nano 51·Charge - " -<;1 ' -" Nano 51·Discharge

20 30 40 50

Cycle Number (N)

60

Fi g. I - Ga lvan()stali c cyclillg resullS 1'01' micro and llano Si anodes 1'0 1' -17 cycles. IAnode comp.: Graphile b ,·-I (40'7c ) - Si ( I O'k ) - ceramic (20'1() - PEO· LiCl04 (20%) I.

capacity . This can be attributed to the excess SEI film formation (resu lting from high surface area of the nano Si parti cles compared to mi cro Si particles) . Both these anodes showed severe capacity fade during the initial S cyc les. After the 51h cyc le, nano Si anode reta ined 6 1 % of the initial charge capacity while the micro Si anode retained only 53 %. After 47 cyc les, the micro Si anode exh ibited a charge capac it y o f 185 mAh/g. which is 32% of the initial charge capacity, whi Ie the nano Si anode showed 306 Il1Ah/g charge capaci ty, whi ch is 54% or the initial capacity. These results show bctrcr cyc labi lity and capac ity of the nano Si anode. Enhanced performance of the nano Si anodes is due to short di ffusion lengths and lower pu lveriza ti on of nano Si particles during charge/d ischarge. During the Li inserti on and extract ion process, large vo lume expans ion and contraction takes place. Thi s results in latt ice distortion and further leads to enhancemen t of strain . The large strain wi ll cause the particle to decrepitate, resulting in inter-parti cle disconnecti on. Hence, the active material is lost, finally lead ing to severe capacity loss. In nano Si parti cles, the diffusion lengths are short and this reduces relaxat ion ti mes and further causes the material to be uniformly strained"l .

Influence of nano Si content on clectrochcmical perfonllancc

Electrodes with different nano Si compos itions were prepared to determine the effect of nano Si content on cyc ling performance. Figure 2 shows the cyc ling performance of nano Si 10%, 15%,20% and 25 % anodes at 20mA/g current density. Among all the electrodes, nano Si 15% and 20% electrodes showed similar initial charge capacity of 770 mAh/g.

1000

800

~ 1 600

:z:-'u II 400

"' U

" e> 200 ~ (J

0

o 10

• · .. · .... 0 .... .. ..

--.."....--_ .. -v._ .. .

20

Nano 51·10%. PVDF Nano 5i·10% Nano 51·15% Nano51·20% Nano 51·25%

30 40 50

Cycle Number (N)

60

Fig . 2 - Di scharge·charge capacilics ror anodes wil h di rrc re III Si COlllen!. IAnOlk COlllp.: Graphile h ·4 ( ()()-x '7c) - nano Si (x';!) -ceramic (20%) - PEO·LiCl04 (207< ) (x = I 0.15.20.2) ). Blad. dOlled circ les : Graphite ks-4 (60 % ) - llano Si ( IO (~ ) - ceramic (200/< ) - PVDF ( 10%) 1.

However, as the nano Si con tent in the anode increased, the initial irreversible capacity increased as well. Anode with composition nano Si 25 % showed the highest irreversible capacity of 926mAh/g. and anode with nano Si 10% showed lowest irreversible capacity of 267mAh/g. As mentioned above, thi s is due to excess SEI film formation which resul ts from high nano Si content. Higher nano Si cOlltent al so rcsulted in degradation of cyc ling performancc. A node with nano Si 10% showed a stabl e reversible capacity of 302 :l1Ah/g for 50 cycles. and anode with nano Si 15% showed a stable reversible capac ity o f 260 mA h/g for 22 cyc les. Anodes w ith nano Si 2()l7c

and 25 % exhibited poor cycle lifc of 7 cyc lcs. Thi s may be attributed to the spa llati on of nano Si particlcs from the thin film, which is caused by largc volu mc expans ion. It may be inferred that PEO- LiCIO~

polymer binder is not strong enough to accommodate the volume changes during Li insertion and ext racti on cycles. To va lidate thi s, the microstructure of nano Si 15% anode was examined using SEM analysis. Arter 12 cycles, the nano Si 15% anode film was taken out and dried at 80°C in a vacuum oven and then SEM micrographs were taken which are shown in Fig. 3. It can be seen that a number o f holes (Fig. 3a) a!leI cracks (Fig. 3b) were formed on the surface and resulting in uneven surface. These holes and cracks may be formed due to either (i) some of the elec trode constituents being soluble in elec tro ly te or (ii) loss of nano Si particles during the cyc ling. To validate the reason under (i), solubi lity tests were carried out and it was found that none of the anode constituents was soluble in electroly te. Thi s indicates that the uneven

Page 4: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

978 I fDI AN J CHEM. SEC A. MA Y 20D:;

Fig. 3 - SEM images ofnano Si 15(.*, anodc surface at (a) lower magnifi ca ti \)n and (b) hi ghcr magni fi ca tion.

surface was fo rmed d ue to the loss o f nano Si partic les. As mentio ned above, d uring cycling, Si expansion and contractio n takes place. During this process, the polymer binder strands are hi ghly stretched. and these mi ght break if the stress on these s trands exceeds the breaking stra in:!"' Hence these Si parti c les may become isolated and therefo re the e lec tri cal contact will be lost. Thi s ultimate ly res ults in loss o f acti ve Si . These isolated nano Si partic les cannot be charged or di scharged whi ch results in capac ity loss . Thi s was also confirmed by mi croanalys is. Nano Si co mpositio n obta ined fro m microanalys is was ve ry low as compared to the nano Si composition used ( 15 %). Thi s justi f ies the reason under (ii ). To validate the reason under ( ii ), a nano Si 10% anode using PVDF as binder was prepared and its e lectrochemi cal performance was tested, whi ch is also shown in Fig 2 . Though this anode showed a smalle r initial charge capacity (454 mAh/g), it exhi bited higher capacity retention (88 %) co mpared to nano Si 10% anode, which showed 56% capac ity retention after 14 cycles. The bette r capacity retention shown by nano Si 10%-PVDF anodes proves the inability of the PEO-LiCI04 binder to accommodate the vo lume change du ring initi a l cyc les. Further testing is in progress to determine the cycling perfo rmance and low temperature pe rfo rmance of nano Si 10%-PVDF anode and the results will be reported later.

3.5

3.0 - kE.-4 (SO%) SI (20%) PEO-liCI04 (30%)

2.S •••• ke,-4 (40% ) SI (20% ) Cer (20%) PEO·LlCI04 (20%)

~~ 2.0 ...J .,; > 1.5 'iii E Q) 1.0 0 fl.

O.S

0.0 L... 'H"'''~:~ ..(l.S

o 200 400 600 800 1000 1200

Capacity (mAhlg)

Fig. 4 - Vo ltage versus ini t ial capacity curves for nano Si 2t)% anode w ith and w ithout ceramic content.

Influence of ceramic addition on initia l charge-discharge performance of 20 % nano-Si composite anodes at roOIll

temperature

To determine the effect o f ceramic powder on room temperature perfo rmance, two nano S i 20% anoc!es with and without ceramic content were prepared and the e lectrochemi cal perfo rmance was tes ted . Voltage vs . initi al capac ity curves for these two anodes are shown in Fig . 4 . At 20 mAh/g current density , nano S i 20% anode without ceramic content showed an ini tia l di scharge capacity of 1058 mAh/g, a charge capac ity o f 470 mAh/g and an irreversib le capacity of 124%. On additi on of 20% ceramic, thi s anode showed an initia l di scharge capacity of 11 32 mAh/g, a charge

Page 5: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

KASA VAJJULA & WANG: NANO SIIG COMPOSITE ANODE IN Li ION BATTERY 979

350 _A 1.0

...... .....- ..

300 ,..."" ,...

Oi III

/ >.

1250 I

0.8 1i ro a. ro

~ ;. U (,) I 0.6 ~ g, 200 I '" , '" U

.I:

e, 150 I U

'" I 0.4 .~ .I: / -:;; U

100 .. __ Capacity- with ceramic OJ __ Relative Capacity· with ceramic a: .. ·0 .. Relative Capacity-No ceramic 0.2

50 -60 -40 ·20 0 20 40 60

Temperature ("e)

Fig. 5 - Charge capacity and relative capacities of Graphite ks-4 (50%) - nano Si 00%) - ceramic (20%) - PEO-LiCI04 (20%) and Graphite ks-4 (60%) - nano Si (10%) - PEO-LiCI04 (30%) anodes as a function of temperature.

capacity of 707 mAh/g, and an irreversible capacity of 60%. From these results it is evident that addition of ceramic increased the initial charge-discharge capacities, and reduced the irreversible capacities. This is mainly due to high Li ion conductivity of the ceramic powder, which enhanced the Li insertion/extraction kinetics of composite anodes.

Influence of ceramic addition on charge-discharge performance of 10% nano-Si composite anodes in the temperature range of +45°C to - 40°C

Since 80Li2S'20P2Ss ceramic has a high room temperature Li-ion conducti vity and low acti vation energy , the addition of ceramic into graphite-nano silicon composite anode may not only improve the kinetics at room temperature performance but also improve the kinetics at low- and high-temperatures. Due to better room temperature performance of nano Si 10% anode amongst all the anodes (Fig. 2), this anode was considered for low temperature performance testing. Two nano Si 10% anodes with and without ceramic content were prepared, galvanostatically discharged and charged at 5 mA/g current density in the temperature range of 45 °C to -40°e. To facilitate the comparison of low temperature performance of these two anodes, a ratio of charge capacity at specific temperature to the charge capacity obtained at 25°C was defined as relative charge capacity. Figure 5 shows the relative charge capacities and charge capacities of the two anodes as a function of temperature. At 25°C, nano Si 10% ceramic 20% anode showed a charge capacity of 321 mAh/g. A slightly higher charge capacity (335 mAh/g) was obtained, when the temperature was increased to 45°e. This is due to increased

300,----------------__

250

100 200 300 400 500 600

z'(n)

Fig . 6 - Typical EIS of the Li ion half cell and the equi valent circuit used to fit the electron impedance study.

electrochemical reaction rate at high temperatures. When the temperatures were lowered to -10°C and -20°C, this anode exhibited higher charge capacities of 277 mAh/g and 222 mAh/g respectively and relative charge capacities of 0.86 and 0.69 respectively. A rapid decrease in capacity was observed when the temperature dropped below -20°C (Fig. 5) . At -30°C and -40°C, nano Si 10% ceramic 20% anode exhibited charge capacities of 160 mAh/g and 84 mAh/g respectively and relative capacities of 0.5 and 0.2 respectively. However, at _30°C nano Si 10% anode without ceramic content showed a relative capacity of only 0.13, which is much lower than that of anode with ceramic addition.

Electrochemical impedance study (EIS) To determine the reason for rapid decrease in

capacity with temperature, EIS analysis for these two cells were caITied out in the temperature range from 45°C to AO°e. Since the size of lithium foil counter electrode is much larger than the working (composite) electrode, impedance of G-nano Si-ceramic/lithium cell is mainly dependent on the composite electrodes. A typical Nyquist plot of Li ion half cells is shown in Fig. 6. From Fig. 6 it can be seen that impedance spectra of Li ion cell mainly consist of two parti ally overlapped semi circles and one sloping line. This kind of impedance spectra can be explained by drawing an equivalent circuit, which is also shown in Fig. 6. In Fig. 6, Rb represents the serial resistance, which includes resistances of electrolyte, separator, and electrodes. RSE! (1 s l semi circle) and ReI (2nd semi circle) represent the resistance of solid electrolyte interface film and charge transfer respectively. CSE !

and Cd! are the capacitance of SEI film and double layer respectively. W is the Warburg impedance related to Li ion diffusivity on the interface between

Page 6: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

980 INDIAN J CHEM, SEC A, MAY 2005

30000

25000

20000

'" u c: 5

15000

.!!! '" 10000 '" a: ~ 5000 ° f-

a

-60

° --.- With c~ramic ·· ·0 ·· WithOut ceram ic

~----.:=:~ ~ -- 0 °

- 40 - 20 a 20 40 60 Temperature (0G)

Fi g. 7a - Temperature dependence of total resi stance of Graphite ks-4 (50%) - nano Si (10%) - ceramic (20%) - PEO-LiCl04

(20%) and Graphite ks-4 (60%) - nano Si (10%) - PEO-LiCI04

(30%) anodes.

10000,-------------------,

8000

~ 6000 c: J9 '" .~ 4000 a:

2000

o

-60 -40

___ Tota' Resistance .. ·····0·· ··· Rb

--....... - - Roe, - " -'./ -- " RCI

-20 o 20 40 60

Temperature (oG)

Fig. 7b - Temperature dependence of various resistances of Graphite ks-4 (50%) - nano Si (10%) - ceramic (20%) - PEO­LiCI04 (20%) anode.

30000

25000

'" 20000

u c: J9 15000 '" 'iii II> a:

10000

5000 .

0

-60 -40

"

-20

___ Tola' Resistance ······ ·0··· ~ - - ....... -- Roe, -"'"""'Q"~ " Rei

o 20 40

Temperature (oG)

60

Fig. 7c - Temperature dependence of various resistances of Graphite ks-4 (60%) - nano Si (10%) - PEO-LiCI04 (30%) anode.

the active material s and electrolyte, which is indicated by a straight sloping line. Rei and W when combined together is called Faradic impedance which denotes the electrochemical kinetics of the ce11 8

. Higher Rei of the cell means lower kinetics of faradic reaction. Total resistance of the cell can be obtained by adding these three resistances .

From Nyquist plots obtained fro m EIS analysis , values of Rb , R SEI and Rei are obtained using an in­built program provided by Z-view software. Values of these resistances for nano Si 10% anode with and without ceramic content are plotted as a function of temperature (Figs 7a - 7c) . Figure 7a shows the total resistance of the two cells as a function of temperature. From the graph it is evident that irrespective of the ceramic addition, the total resistance of the anode increased by a large percentage when the temperature is below _20De. This explains the reason for the sudden decrease in charge capacity at -30De for nano Si 10% anode with ceramic content (Fig . 5). At room temperature, no significant difference is observed in resistance for these two cells. But when the temperature is below ODe, nano Si 10% anode without ceramic content showed higher resistance than that of nano Si 10% anode with ceramic addition. At -30De and -40De, addition of ceramic to nano Si 10% anode reduced the overall resistance four folds, which resulted in a high relati ve capacity of nano Si 10% -ceramic 20% anode compared to nano Si 10% -ceramic 0% anode (Fig. 5). To determine the influence of electrolyte, SEI and electrochemical reaction kinetics in determining the low temperature performance, individual resistances and total resistance of the two cells were plotted (Figs 7b and 7c, respectively). From Figs 7b and 7c, it is clear that total impedance of the cells is dominated by charge transfer resistance, which is in agreement with previous reported results 10. Though SEI film resistance and bulk resistance increased at low temperatures, the increase was insignificant as compared to charge transfer. Her,.::e, it can be concluded that the low capacities of these two anodes at -30De as compared to 25°e, is mainly due to the increased charge transfer resistance. This confirms the influence of ceramic on improving the electrochemical kinetics at low temperatures. Higher Li ion conductivity and higher specific capacity of this anode at low temperatures makes it suitable for solid polymer electrolyte cells.

Page 7: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

KASAVAJJULA & WANG: NANO SIIG COMPOSITE ANODE IN Li ION BATTERY 981

1.2

1.0

\ 0.8

~ ii ~0.6

'" () Q. 2 0.4 '" '.

0::

0.2

0.0

10

b

20 30

-+-At 25°C .. 0· At -30·C

40 50

Current Density (mA/g)

-

60 70 80

Fig. 8 - Rate capability of Graphite ks-4 (50%) - nano Si (10%)­ceramic (20%) - PEO-LiCI04 (20%) anode at 25°C and -30°C as a fun ction of current density.

Rate capabilities of graphite ks-4 (50%) nano Si (10%) -ceramic (20%) - PEO-LiCI04 (20%) anode at 25°C and -30°C

Electrochemical impedance studies show that the addition of high Li-ion conducting ceramic into graphite-nano silicon anodes can largely improve the reaction kinetics of the electrodes, which may result in a high rate capability. The rate capability of electrodes at room temperature is defined as the ratio of charge capacity at a specific current density to the charge capacity obtained at 20 mA/g. Similarly, for -30°C, ratio of charge capacity at a specific current density to the charge capacity obtained at 5 mA/g was defined as rate capability. At 25°C and at -30°C, graphite ks-4 (50%) nano Si (10%) - ceramic (20%) ­PEO-LiC104 (20%) anode was discharged-charged at different current densities. These relative charge capacities are plotted as a function of current density in Fig . 8. At 25°C and at 20 mA/g current density, nano Si 10% anode with the above composition showed a charge capacity of 300 mAh/g. At 60 mA/g current density, it showec1 a capacity of 263 mAh/g, and a relative capacity of 0.87. At 80 mA/g current density, it showed a capacity of 245 mAh/g and a relative capacity of 0.81. These high relative capacities of nano Si 10% anode showed a high rate capability at room temperature. This is attributed to the fast reaction k::1etics. At -30°C, when charged -discharged at 5 mA/g current density , nano Si 10% anode exhibited a charge capacity of 161 mAh/g. At 10 mA/g current density, it showed a charge capacity of 75.12 mAh/g, resulting in a relative capacity of 0.46. At 20 mA/g current density, it showed a charge capacity of 48 mAh/g, which is equivalent to a relative capacity of 0.17 . Usually, graphite anodes

cannot be discharged and charged at -30°C uS1l1g current densities more than 5 mA/g (ref. 8). High charge capacity (161 . mAh/g) and better rate capability of nano Si 10% anode at -30°C can be attributed to the improved electrochemical kinetics resulting from the addition of ceramic powder. Ceramic powder has a lower activation energy «0.3eV) which makes it highly Li ion conductive even at a temperature of -30°e. As mentioned above, at low temperatures , in high density thin films, Li io n transfer through liquid electrolyte is limited. The only way for Li transportation from liquid electrolyte to surface of the active particl es io through an ionic conducting carrier. Here, the ceramic works as a carrier because of its high Li ion conductivity at low temperature. Due to improved Li ionic transport, the kinetics of the electrochemical reactions is al so improved.

Conclusions A new Si/G composite anode .has been prepared

and its electrochemical performance tested in the temperature range -40°C to 45°e. At room temperature, anode with a composition of graphite ks-4 (50%) - nano Si (10%) - ceramic (20%) - PEO­LiCI04 (20%) shows an initial charge capacity of 560 mAh/g and a stable reversible capacity of 302 mAh/g after 50 cycles. However, it shows a severe capacity fade during the initialS cycles. This may be attributed to poor mechanical strength of polymer binder. Regardless of the low capacity of the anode at 25°C, when discharged - charged at 5 mA/g current density at -30°C, this anode exhibits a charge capacity of 160 mAh/g. The anode also shows high rate capability at 2YC and -30°e. The high rate capability and excellent low temperature performance of th e anode may be attributed to improved charge transfer kineti cs resulting from high Li ion conductivity of the ceramic powder. High rate capability and excellent low temperature performance of this anode makes it suitable for NASA aerospace applications.

Acknowledgement The authors are thankful for the financial support

of NASA (NAG3-2617) for this work .

References I Nagasubramanian G , J Appl Eleclrocilelll, 3 1 (2001) 99. 2 Fan J, J Power Sources, 117 (2003) 170. 3 Zhang S S, Xu K. Allen J L & Jow T R. J Power Sources.

110 (2002)216. 4 Plichta E J & Behl W K, J Power Sources, 88 (2000) 192.

Page 8: Si/G in Li - NISCAIRnopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/20119/1/IJCA 44A(5) 975-982.pdf · Nano Si/G composite anode in Li ion battery for aerospace applications ... V ano. us

982 INDIAN J CHEM, SEC A, MAY 2005

5 Herreyre S, Huehet 0, Barusseau S, Perton F, Bodet J M & Biensan P, J Power Sources, 97 (2001) 576.

6 Shiao H C, Chua D, Lin H P, Slane S & Salomon M, J Power Sources, 87 (2000) 167.

7 Smart M C, Ratnakumar B V & Surampudi S, J Electroehem Soc, 146(1999) 146.

8 Huang C K, Sakamato J S, Wolfenstine J & Surampudi S , J Electrochem Soc, 147 (2000) 2893.

9 Lin H P, Chua D, Salomon M, Shiao H C & He ndrickson M, Electrochem Solid-State Lett, 4(2001) A 71.

10 Zhang S S, Xu K & Jow T R, J Power Sources, 115 (2003) 137. 11 Zhang S S, Xu K & Jow T R, Electroehim Acta, 49 (2004)

1057. 12 Brousse T, Retoux R, Herterieh V & Sxhleieh D M, J

Electroehem Soc, 145 (1998) 1. 13 Beaulieu L Y, Eberman K W, Turner R L, Krause L J &

Dahn J R, Electrochem Solid-State Lett, 4 (9) (2001) A137.

14 Wu X, W ang Z, Chen L & Huang X, EleClrochel/1 Co 1/1111 WI ,

5 (2003) 435. 15 Yang J, Wang B F, Wang K, Liu Y, Xie J Y & Wen Z S,

Electrochem Solid-State Lett, 6(8) (2003) A154. 16 Kim I S & Kumta P N, J Power Sources, (in press). 17 Liu Y, Hanai K, Yang J, Imanishi N, Hirano A & Takeda Y,

Solid State fOllies, (in press) . 18 Kim B C, Vono H, Sato T, Fuse T, Ishihara T & Senna M.

Solid State fonies, (In press). 19 Wang G X, Yao J & Liu H K, EleClrochem Solid-State Lell ,

7 (8) (2004) A250. 20 Hayashi A, Hama S, Minami T & Tatsumisago M.

Electrochem Commull, 5 (2003) Ill. 21 Maranehi J P, Hepp A F & Kumta P N, Eleclrochem Solid­

State Lett, 6 (9) (2003) A198. 22 Chen Z, Christensen L & Dahn J R, Electroeherll C0111mUI1, 5

(2003) 919.