shops located in the strand, gzira. (route indicated in ... · 1 commission for the rights of...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Commission for the
Rights of Persons with
Disability
G5 Offices
Salvu Psaila Street
Birkirkara BKR9077, Malta
+356 2226 7600
Gozo Office: C/o Sannat Primary School, Sannat Road, Sannat, and Gozo
+ 356 2155 6002
[email protected] l www.crpd.org.mt
Date:
Commencing date of survey: 19th November, 2018
Location:
The Strand – Gzira
EOCU Reference:
AC048/18
Findings of Site Inspection:
Following various EOCU complaints regarding the general accessibility within all the outlets/shops (Public
Buildings) located at The Strand area of Gzira, CRPD performed an onsite audit to verify the above
mentioned.
Hereunder listed is what was observed during such audit.
Shops located in The Strand, Gzira. (Route indicated in red below).
2
Outlet: SEALINK
Two Steps: 130/110mm
Total Threshold: 240mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 870mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2300mm
Outlet: ISTANBUL KEBAB
Flash Level Entrance.
Main Entrance Clear Width: 770mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2300mm
Outlet: UNDER CONSTRUCTION
Threshold: 25mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: N/A
Pavement Clear Width: 2500mm
3
Outlet: CITADEL INSURANCE
Two Steps: 170/160mm
Total Threshold: 330mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2120mm
Outlet: BELAIR REAL ESTATE
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1m
Pavement Clear Width: 2120mm
Outlet: GRANDS PROPERTIES SERVICES
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1030mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2180mm
4
Outlet: EX – YATCHT HELP LTD.
Two Steps: 120/120mm
Total Threshold: 240mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 760mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1970mm
Outlet: EX-REMAX
One Step: 270mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1030mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1970mm
Outlet: GAUCI BORDA LTD.
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1m
Pavement Clear Width: 1970mm
5
Outlet: KFC LTD. (EOCU CASE)
One Step: 210mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1m
Pavement Clear Width: 1970mm
Outlet: UNICAR CAR HIRE
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 750mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2380mm
Outlet: AQUA MARINA
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2140mm
6
Outlet: C&H BARTOLI
Ramped Access - Flash
Main Entrance Clear Width: 980mm (Automated Door)
Pavement Clear Width: 2140mm
Outlet: DEYMA
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (Closed)
Pavement Clear Width: 2140mm
Outlet: FEEL WELL BARBER SHOP
Two Steps: 100/130mm
Total Threshold: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 860mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1520mm
7
Outlet: REMAX ALLIANCE
Two Steps: 170/160mm
Total Threshold: 330mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1750mm
Outlet: C&H BARTOLI LTD.
Two Steps: 90/120mm
Total Threshold: 210mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:780mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2130mm
Outlet: CHERTOP MEN’S FASHION WEAR
Outer Step: 230mm
Inner Step: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 830mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2130mm
8
Outlet: UNKNOWN
Outer Step: 220mm
Inner Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (Found Closed)
Pavement Clear Width: 2130mm
Outlet: UNKNOWN
Outer Step: 220mm
Inner Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (Found Closed)
Pavement Clear Width: 2130mm
Outlet: UNKNOWN
Outer Step: 220mm
Inner Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (Found Closed)
Pavement Clear Width: 2130mm
9
Outlet: BROWN JUG
Outer Step: 200mm
2 Inner Steps: 120/150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1040mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2050mm
Outlet: PIROTTA FISHING CENTRE
Outer Step: 180mm
2 Inner Steps: 130/130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 700mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
Outlet: MALTA DEALS 4U.COM
Outer Step: 200mm
Inner Step: 220mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
10
Outlet: BONNICI INSURANCE AGENCY
One Step: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
Outlet: BANK OF VALLETTA
Ramped Access - Flash
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
Outlet: ST. MATTHEW’S PHARMACY
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 810mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
11
Outlet: UNKNOWN
Threshold: unknown
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter (Closed)
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
Outlet: CAFE’ JUBILEE
Two Steps: 130/190mm
Total Threshold: 320mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1850mm
Outlet: MOUNT CARMEL BAND CLUB
One Step Outside: 160mm/ Stairs Inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf (Both Open: 980mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1850mm
12
Outlet: WORKS IN PROGRESS
Threshold: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door -1800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1850mm
Outlet: PIZZA AMORE & FANTASIA
Threshold: 30mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door -1805mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1850mm
Outlet: PROPERTY WANTED
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
13
Outlet: HOUSE OF BEAUTY
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
Outlet: NOVI BAR
Threshold: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2230mm
Outlet: THE CHANDLERY
Flash Entrance.
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:700mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2230mm
14
Outlet: ALPHA STATIONERY & SOUVENIERS
Threshold: 30mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2230mm
Outlet: BEVERLY HILLS (Med – Aesthtic Ltd.)
Ramped Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: Outside – 1m/Inside – 960mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2230mm
Outlet: HSBC
Flash Entrance – (ATM Side – Automated Door/Flash)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:840mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2230mm
15
Outlet: HIMU
Two Steps: 150/95mm
Total Threshold: 245mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1040mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2230mm
Outlet: SOFA TABBAH
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1620mm
Outlet: FOUR T’s
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1620mm
16
Outlet: YUMMY GELATO
Two Steps: 130/120mm
Total Threshold: 250mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:900mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
Outlet: OHEA
One Step: 135mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:900mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3m
Outlet: VARIOUS OFFICES
Two Steps: 200/190mm
Total Threshold: 390mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1630mm
17
Outlet: MAHARAJA
Two Steps: 140/ 130mm
Total Threshold: 270mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 1180mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
Outlet: SISTINA LOUNGE BAR
Two Steps: 190/ 190mm
Total Threshold: 380mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1640mm - Shutter Door
(Works in Progress).
Pavement Clear Width: 1630mm
Outlet: Mr. MAXIMS
Two Steps: 170/ 140mm
Total Threshold: 310mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
18
Outlet: BALANCE BOWL
One Step: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 960mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
Outlet: 4 AMICI RISTORANTE
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding Door – 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
Outlet: EMMANUEL STUDIO
Two Steps: 50/150mm
Total Threshold: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 980mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2800mm
19
Outlet: MOO’S
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (No Door)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1600mm
Outlet: JUNO FOOTWEAR
One Step: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:730mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
Outlet: THE TOOLBOX
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1370mm)
Accessible Clear width (Between Displayed items: 550mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
20
Outlet: WAREHOUSE SALE
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:600mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3200mm
Outlet: DHALIA
Two Steps: 180/ 160mm
Total Threshold: 340mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 4210mm
Outlet: CINNABON
Threshold: 20mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1740mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1450mm
21
Outlet: WAREHOUSE SALE
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1m)
Pavement Clear Width: 2800mm
Outlet: EEET WELL
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (No Door)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1450mm
Outlet: CENTRAL PET STORE
One Step: 165mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1m
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
22
Outlet: RDJ IMPORTERS & DISTRIBUTERS
Two Steps: 90/ 130mm
Total Threshold: 220mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 2400mm
Accessible Clear width (Between Displayed items: 800mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
Outlet: G.B. JEWELLERY
Ramped with a threshold of 70mm.
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 950mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3310mm
Outlet: ANCIOVA
Threshold: 20mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1650mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
23
Outlet: STORIE & SAPORI
One Step: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1600mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 4330mm
Outlet: TTT’S FRUIT & VEGETABLES
One Step: 90mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 600mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2370mm
Outlet: POSH TURKISH
One Step: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (No Door)
Access Route: (Between Counter and Tables: 1m)
Pavement Clear Width: 2370mm
24
Outlet: AURUM GIOIE
One Step: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3070mm
Outlet: SUBWAY
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:880mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3070mm
Outlet: NAILS AND ACCESSORIES – BAYVIEW HOTEL
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3070mm
25
Outlet: NAILS AND ACCESSORIES – BAYVIEW HOTEL
Flash Entrance
Alternative Entrance inside Door: Blocked
Outlet: ST BAYVIEW HOTEL & APARTMENTS
Ramped Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:890mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2070mm
Outlet: BISTRO CAFE’ – BAYVIEW HOTEL
Two Steps: 150/ 120mm
Total Threshold: 270mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1700mm
26
Outlet: LOTUS CROWN
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1802mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: CHICKO’S RENTALS
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (both open: 1500mm)
Access Route from counter: 1020mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3070mm
Outlet: SMOKEHOUSE
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 2480mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1480mm
27
Outlet: TCB TATTOO MALTA
13 Steps outside with threshold of 140mm each
Main Entrance Clear Width: 990mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5m
Outlet: RED DRAGON CHINESE RESTAURANT
Three Steps Down: 140/140/150mm
Total Threshold: 430mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5m
Outlet: PURA
13 Steps outside with threshold of 140mm each
Main Entrance Clear Width: 990mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5m
28
Outlet: BELLA SICILIA
Three Steps Down: 140/140/150mm
Total Threshold: 430mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5m
Outlet: TIM TRAVEL – EUROSTAR (Closed)
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter - 1Leaf Door: 860mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3070mm
Outlet: MARBLE ARCH (Closed Down)
Two Steps: 120/ 240mm
Total Threshold: 360mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door - Closed
Pavement Clear Width: 3100mm
29
Outlet: ITALIAN CHEF
Two Steps: 180/ 190mm
Total Threshold: 370mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1m
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1490mm
Outlet: GLOBAL GAMING
Two Steps: 190/ 150mm
Total Threshold: 340mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf: 1m)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5m
Outlet: FERRATUMBANK
Two Steps: 180/ 150mm
Total Threshold: 330mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1460mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 4450mm
30
Outlet: HOTEL KENNEDY NOVA
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:750mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1260mm
Outlet: NICE THINGS
Two Steps: 110/ 120mm
Total Threshold: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2340mm
Outlet: 115 THE STRAND
Five Steps: 110/110/175/175/170mm
Total Threshold: 740mm
Wooden Ramp: 760 wide x 2460 length (Not Conform)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:800mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
31
Outlet: BOOKBITES CAFE
Two Steps: 130/ 110mm
Total Threshold: 240mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 840mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1110mm
Outlet: PIAZZA D’ORO
Two Steps: 130/ 130mm
Total Threshold: 260mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1110mm
Outlet: VISTRA
Two Steps: 110/120mm
Total Threshold: 230mm
Ramp at Entrance measured to be 940 length x 750 wide
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:1m)
Pavement Clear Width: 1645mm
32
Outlet: THE NEW HOTEL VERDI
Works in progress
Construction site
Outlet: THE WATERFRONT HOTEL (Side Entrance)
Two Steps: 160/160mm
Total Threshold: 320mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Automated Door: 1400mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1300mm
Outlet: THE WATERFRONT HOTEL (Main Entrance)
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: Automated Door: 1500mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5m
33
Kiosk: MALTCO LOTTERIES
Counter Height: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width: 550mm
Kiosk: TOPSY TAKE-AWAY
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width:
Shutter Door 2200mm
Pavement Clear Width till
Umbrellas: 1400mm
MANOEL ISLAND
SERVICE STATION
(As per photo)
34
Outlet: BUS STOP LOUNGE
Counter Height: 850mm
PUBLIC
CONVENIENCE
Threshold: 15mm
Main Entrance
Clear Width: 1070mm
Toilet measured to be:
1400mm x 1840mm
With clear width of: 990mm
35
Conclusion
This survey concludes that outlets’ thresholds leading in, vary from approximately 20mm to
270mm respectively not mentioning stepped entrances (these can be seen in here above
photos). Clear entrance widths vary from 700mm to over 2480mm while pavement clear width
vary from 1110mm to over 5 meters. Only a small fraction of premises do conform to AADG
2011 as the vast majority do have either a step / threshold more than 15mm or, on the other
hand lack the minimum clear width of 900mm as per the AADG2011.
33
Commission for the
Rights of Persons with
Disability
G5 Offices
Salvu Psaila Street
Birkirkara BKR9077, Malta
+356 2226 7600
Gozo Office: C/o Sannat Primary School, Sannat Road, Sannat, and Gozo
+ 356 2155 6002
[email protected] l www.crpd.org.mt
Date:
26th November, 2018
Location:
The Strand – Sliema
EOCU Reference:
AC048/18
Findings of Site Inspection:
Following various EOCU complaints regarding the general accessibility within all the outlets/shops (Public
Buildings) located at The Strand area of Sliema, CRPD performed an onsite audit to verify the above
mentioned.
Hereunder listed is what was observed during such audit.
Shops located in The Strand, Sliema. (Route indicated in red below).
34
Outlet: MILLENIUM TURKISH FOOD
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 1900mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 2200mm
Outlet: MILLENIUM CAFE’
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: (Found Closed)
Pavement Clear Width: 3560mm
Outlet: WATER POINT LTD.
Construction Site
Works in Progress
35
Outlet: GAMMA ENTERTAINMENT BLOCK A 110
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1 Fixed & 1Leaf:970mm)
Pavement Clear Width till Yellow Poles: 2570mm
Outlet: GAMMA ENTERTAINMENT BLOCK B 110
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1 Fixed & 1Leaf:970mm)
Pavement Clear Width till Yellow Poles: 2570mm
Outlet: HAIR FASHION
Flash Entrance
Outlet: 2 Leaf Door (1 Fixed & 1Leaf:970mm)
Pavement Clear Width till Yellow Poles: 2570mm
36
ONEONEO
Outlet: 1 -6 No Names
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1160mm
Pavement Clear Width till
Yellow Poles: 2570mm
Shop 1 Shop 2 Shop 3
Shop 4 Shop 5 Shop 6
37
Outlet: CHEQUERS
One Step: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter
Pavement Clear Width to
Tables and Chairs: 1660mm
Outlet: RUIN PUB
Outer Step: 80mm
Inner Step: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1200mm (Sliding)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: KRISHNA
One Step: 210mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
38
Outlet: IL-MALTI (Maltese Cuisine)
Outer Step: 150mm
Inner Step: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1400mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: BLACK GOLD SALOON
Outer Step: 140mm
Two Steps Inside: 210/180mm
Total Threshold: 390mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1460mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: TRE ANGELI
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1460mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
39
Outlet: FAIRYTALE BEAUTY SALON
Side Ramp as per photos
Outlet: MedASIA
One Step: Ramp at Main Entrance including Platform lift
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1200mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: TEX MEX
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding – 2140mm
Pavement Clear Width to Ramp: 1500mm
40
Outlet: TEX MEX
Temporary Wooden Ramp measured to be 600mm long x 730mm wide
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding – 2140mm
Pavement Clear Width to Ramp: 1500mm
Outlet: PEBBLES BOUTIQUE HOTEL
One Step: 170mm – Outside
Stairs Inside as shown in photo
Main Entrance Clear Width: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2900mm
Outlet: JACKPOT.COM
Outer Step: 160mm
Inner Step: 110mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1100mm
Pavement Clear Width: to Tables and Chairs: 2900mm
41
Outlet: AMIE’S
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 900mm – Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: FIFI’S NAIL STUDIO
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1m
Pavement Clear Width: 2750mm
Outlet: PRETTY THINGS
One Step: 90mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 3400mm - Sliding
Pavement Clear Width: 2750mm
42
Outlet: QUICK SHOP
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 940mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2750mm
Outlet: THE BREW
Threshold: 25mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1600mm – Folding Sliding Door
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: THE BLACK SHEEP BAR
One Step: 60mm – Outside
Stairs Inside as shown in photo
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1240mm (Between Chairs)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
43
Outlet: HUNGARIAN RESTAURANT
Threshold: 20mm – Outside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1130mm
Inside Clear Width: 2 Leaf door (1Leaf:830mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1500mm
Outlet: ISLAND TRENDS
Threshold: 20mm – Outside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 920mm between stands
Shutter + Folding Door
Pavement Clear Width from stands: 1740mm
Outlet: NOODLE BOX (Opening Soon)
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1100mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width: 2960mm
44
Outlet: OTTICA RANDAZZO
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 960mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2960mm with Uneven Surface
Outlet: STIVALA RENTALS
Threshold: 30mm – Outside + Wooden Ramp inside which is not
conform to AADG2011
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2460mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width: 2960mm
Outlet: MOBILE WORLD MALTA/SCITEC NUTRITION
One Step:70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 780mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
45
Outlet: DIALOGUE CAFÉ
One Step:80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1730mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1650mm
Outlet: CETTINA ARGENTI
One Step: 90mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 870mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1650mm
Outlet: SLIEMA HOTEL
Threshold: 30mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1650mm
46
Outlet: MASSAGE SALON
Two Steps + Stairs Inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 770mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1650mm
Outlet: THE MICS
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1120mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width from Stands: 1280mm
Outlet: EAT - ALI
One Step: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 910mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2810mm
47
Outlet: CONSTRUCTION OF SHOP,
OFFICES AND APARTMENTS
Outlet: CAPTAIN MORGAN
Two Steps Inside: 180/15mm
Total Threshold: 295mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:470mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2660mm
Outlet: SLIEMA MINIMARKET
One Step: Ramped Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door
(Both open: 1250mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2660mm
Pavement Clear Width to Stands: 1750mm
48
Outlet: TCHIBO
Threshold: 40mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:900mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2660mm
Outlet: STRAND TOWERS
One Step: 110mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 960mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2660mm
Outlet: HARVARDS (X2)
One Step: 110mm
Main Entrance Clear Width:
1Leaf Door: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2660mm
49
Outlet: CELIO/TOM TAILOR
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door
(Both open: 1670mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
Outlet: INGLOT
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door Automated: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width to Stand: 1700mm
Outlet: STRAND SUPERMARKET
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1050mm between displays –
Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width from Stands: 3450mm
50
Outlet: FRANS GREENGROCER
One Step: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 800mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width from Stands: 2350mm
Outlet: LINEN & CO.
Threshold: 40mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 940mm - Shutter Door
Clear Width from Stands: 940mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2900mm
Outlet: ANASTASI BROS.
One Step: 90mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 4mtrs
51
Outlet: SOLID GOLD
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Sliding Door + Shutter
(Both open: 1620mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 4mtrs
Outlet: L’OCCITANE EN PROVENCE
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1550mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 4mtrs
Outlet: STRAND FASHION ACCESSORIES
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1250mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width: 4150mm
52
Outlet: URBAN JUNGLE
Permanent Ramp not conform to AADG2011 measured to be
width 840mm x length 1100mm
Two Steps: 140/140mm
Total Threshold: 280mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1680mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2780mm
Outlet: THE MICS
Two Steps: 160/130mm
Total Threshold: 290mm
Main Entrance Clear Width between Displays: 670mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3700mm
Outlet: BOV (ATM)
Flash
Pavement Clear Width: 3700mm
53
Outlet: CONSTRUCTION OF APARTMENTS &
UNDERLYING SHOP & ATM
AS PER PA/03533/13
Outlet: STRAND GIFTS & MORE
Ramped Access
Main Entrance Clear Width between Displays: 870mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1150mm - Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width from Stands: 1780mm
54
Outlet: OPTIKA
Ramped Access
Threshold: 20mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1200mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
Outlet: MARKS & SPENCER
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door
(1 Leaf: 820mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Bus Stop: 3820mm
Outlet: HSBC (ATM)
Flash
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
55
Outlet: TONY’S BAR (CLOSED)
One Step: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door -1200mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
Outlet: DOROTHY PERKINS
Two Steps: 130/130mm
Total Threshold: 260mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door -1460mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
Outlet: STERLING
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -980mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
56
Outlet: MATALAN
Ramped Entrance – Flash Inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1580mm
Pavement Clear Width: over 5 mtrs.
Outlet: TONY’S BAR
Threshold: 40mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1700mm)
Pavement Clear Width between Poles: 1240mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 3130mm
Outlet: ROBERTS
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -1200mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5mtrs
57
Outlet: ROBERTS
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door
(Found Closed)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 3130mm
Outlet: ZARA
Flash Entrance (x3)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1680mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2950mm
Outlet: ARMY & NAVY
Threshold: 20mm - Slopped
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door – 1180mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1540mm
58
Outlet: CAFE’ CUBA
Threshold: 15mm
One Step Inside: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:720mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1540mm
Outlet: CAFE’ CUBA
Flash Entrance
Two Steps Inside: 40/140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 840mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1540mm
Outlet: GIORGIO’S
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding Door – 2440mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1400mm
59
Outlet: TIFFANY’S BISTRO
Threshold: 15mm - Slopped
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding/Folding Door – 3500mm
Clear Width Inside: 1200mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1550mm
Outlet: CAFFE OASIS
One Step: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1300mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1550mm
Outlet: McDONALD’S
Main Entrance Clear Width: Lift at Main Entrance
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 2300mm
60
Outlet: CAFE’ SICILIA
One Step: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width:
1 Leaf Door -940mm
Pavement Clear Width to
Tables and Chairs: 1700mm
Outlet: AĠENZIJA SAPPORT & DE PORRES PASTORAL and
CULTURAL CENTRE
Ramped Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -1140mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1600mm
Outlet: SLIEMA MARINA HOTEL
One Step: 220mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:910mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1700mm
61
Outlet: OGGI CAFE’
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both open: 1670mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1650mm
Outlet: BURGER KING
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door - 870mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1700mm
Outlet: DUMNIKANI
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door
(1 Leaf: 880mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 mtrs.
62
Outlet: KNISJA NAZZARENU
Ramp at Entrance not conform to AADG2011 as shown below.
5 Steps: 150mm each + 1 Extra of 150mm at Main Entance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1 Leaf: 520mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 4070mm
Outlet: PORTOPALO
Two Steps: 180/120mm
Total Threshold: 300mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door - 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1240mm
63
Outlet: HAMMETT’S
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 4 Leaf Door (1 Leaf: 480mm)
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1480mm
Outlet: IL GALEONE
Three Steps: 100/180/170mm
Total Threshold: 450mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door - 780mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1500mm
64
Outlet: FRANCIS BAJADA
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -800mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1570mm
Outlet: JUNCTION
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -1020mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 1570mm
Outlet: THE LAND’S END HOTEL
Under Construction.
65
Outlet/Offices: SEPCO LIMITED,
DE MATTOS AND SULLIVAN,
COMMUNICATION ENTERPRISES
Outside Step: 230mm
Inside Step: 180mm/Stairs Inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -900mm (outer door)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -900mm (inner door)
Pavement Clear Width: 1540mm
Outlet/Offices: DR. MARIO SCERRI
(Clinical Forensic Physician)
Two Steps: 160/160mm + Stairs Inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1300mm
Outlet/Offices: REMAX ALLIANCE
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door -850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2880mm
66
Outlet: BONAVIA OFFSET PRINTERS
Outside Threshold: 40mm
Inner Threshold: 25mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door
(1Leaf:750mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1280mm
Outlet: DROP IN RESTAURANT (No name at the moment)
One Step to Tables and Chairs: 85mm
One Step to Restaurant: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1550mm outside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1mtr – 2 leaf door inside
Pavement Clear Width: Vary from 1mtr to 670mm
Outlet: X AZURE
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:1060mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3160mm
67
Outlet: CAPTAIN MORGAN CRUISES
5 Steps: 80mm, 120mm, 130mm, 130mm and 110mm
Total Threshold: 570mm
Threshold: 20mm inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door - 1mtr
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
Outlet: IL GIARDINO
4 Steps: 170mm, 190mm, 260mm and 120mm
Total Threshold: 740mm
Fixed Timber Ramp Provided
(2 mtrs long x 780mm wide)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door
1600mm + 1 Fixed
Pavement Clear Width: 2850mm
Construction Site: Ex-Fortina
68
Outlet: THE SEAFRONT TOWER
Main Entrance Clear Width:
1 Revolving Door
1 Flash Entrance with clear width
of 940mm.
Side Ramp Provided
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
Outlet: THE TERRACE
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1070mm
Pavement Clear Width to planters: 2420mm
69
THE ROSE SHOP FLORIST
Counter Height: 960mm
THE MALTA
SOUVENIER BUS
Not Accessible (Steps)
GELATERIA CREAM POWER
Counter does not conform
To AADG2011 (See Photo)
70
MALTA PUBLIC TRANSPORT (Ticket Booth)
Counter Height does not conform to AADG2011
(See Photo)
TANTI JUNIOR
PARADISE GELATERIA
KIOSK
One Step
Counter Height does not
conform to AADG2011
(See Photo)
NEW KIOSK
(Under Construction)
71
TICKETING BOOTHS: 40 in Total
Counter Height: Varies between 820mm and 1170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: N/A
Pavement Clear Width: Varies between 1920mm and 5000mm
Photos hereunder show the above stated:
72
Conclusion
This survey concludes that outlets’ thresholds leading in, vary from approximately 20mm to
230mm respectively not mentioning stepped entrances (these can be seen in here above
photos). Clear entrance widths vary from 470mm to over 3400mm while pavement clear width
vary from 670mm to over 5 meters. Only a small fraction of premises do conform to AADG
2011 as the vast majority do have either a step / threshold more than 15mm or, on the other
hand lack the minimum clear width of 900mm as per the AADG2011.
73
Commission for the
Rights of Persons with
Disability
G5 Offices
Salvu Psaila Street
Birkirkara BKR9077, Malta
+356 2226 7600
Gozo Office: C/o Sannat Primary School, Sannat Road, Sannat, and Gozo
+ 356 2155 6002
[email protected] l www.crpd.org.mt
Date:
25th February, 2019
Location:
Tower Road, Sliema
(Plaza Area)
EOCU Reference:
AC048/18
Findings of Site Inspection:
Following various EOCU complaints regarding the general accessibility within all the outlets/shops (Public
Buildings) located at Tower Road Sliema, CRPD performed an onsite audit to verify the above mentioned.
Hereunder listed is what was observed during such audit.
Shops located in Tower Road, Sliema. (Route indicated in red below).
74
Outlet: ALHAMBRA CLINICS
Threshold: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 760mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
Outlet: SOLARIS
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding Door: 1500mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
Outlet: VICTOR’S PHARMACY
Outer Step: 220mm
Inner Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
75
Outlet: COCCINELLE
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
Outlet: DARMANIN FOOTWEAR
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:900mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
Outlet: SWAROVSKI
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1090mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
76
Outlet: FURLA
Outer Step: 220mm
Inner Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 930mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2040mm
Outlet: K-OPTICS
Threshold: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2040mm
Outlet: SLIEMA WANDERERS F.C.
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:630mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2040mm
77
Outlet: BONELLO STORE
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door -1320mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2040mm
Outlet: CELIO
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf (Both Open: 1640mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2040mm
Outlet: MONROE
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf (Both Open: 1290mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2040mm
78
Outlet: ENGLISH LANGUAGE ACADEMY
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door: 1500mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1890mm
Outlet: A. AGIUS (BULOVA)
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (1830mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1890mm
Outlet: YAMAMAY
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1mtr
Pavement Clear Width: 1890mm
79
Outlet: ENGLISH LANGUAGE ACADEMY
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door: 1mtr
Pavement Clear Width: 1890mm
Outlet: WOMAN’S SECRET
Threshold: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1890mm
Outlet: BAGSWORLD
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (1100mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1890mm
80
Outlet: MINGZ
One Step: 210mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2400mm
Outlet: DISTEFANO’S PHOTO STUDIO
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 690mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2400mm
Outlet: CAMPISI (No Name at present)
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 930mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2400mm
81
Outlet: TM TOURING MEDITERRANEO
Outer Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
Outlet: TM TOURING MEDITERRANEO
Outer Step: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door: 850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1540mm
Outlet: VINE VERA
Flash Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door: 1050mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1740mm
82
Outlet: DESIGUAL
One Step: 180mm + stairs inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 930mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
Outlet: H. VASSALLO & SONS
One Step: 75mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 840mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2080mm
Outlet: CONSTRUCTION SITE
See Photo
83
Outlet: LADYLAND
Four Steps: 260mm/190mm/200mm/150mm
Total Threshold: 800mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 830mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2060mm
Outlet: RONNIE’S STUDIO
One Step Outside: 220mm/ Stairs Inside
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 860mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2060mm
Outlet: TOPSHOP - TOPMAN
Ramped Entrance: 160mm long x 400mm high
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf (Both Open: 1520mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
84
Outlet: NAU (Italian Eyeware)
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 830mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm
Outlet: CHARLES CHILDREN’S WEAR
Five Steps: 210mm/210mm/215mm/140mm/120mm
Total Threshold: 895mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 850mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1750mm
Outlet: STONES JEWELLERY
One Step: 220mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (1000mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1660mm
85
Outlet: CLARKS
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 950mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1810mm
Outlet: STERLING
One Step: 90mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Automated Door: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1810mm
Outlet: NO NAME
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1m
Pavement Clear Width: 1830mm
86
Outlet: GEOX
One Step: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1830mm
Outlet: NYX
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Automated Door: 1040mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1830mm
Outlet: JEANNIN
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 950mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1350mm
87
Outlet: PROMOD
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1200mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1300mm
Outlet: PLAZA
LHS: One Step:250mm
RHS: Two Steps: 260mm/150mm
Stairs and Escalator
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Shutter Doors: 1800mm/3420mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1300mm
88
Outlet: GALA
One Step: 180mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1320mm
Outlet: MISS SELFRIDGE
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf (Both Open: 1600mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1320mm
Outlet: WASABI
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1000mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1320mm
89
Outlet: CARPISA (Under Costruction)
One Step: 60mm
Total Threshold: 270mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 1460mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1320mm
Outlet: OKAIDI
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 1700mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1160mm
Outlet: CHAMP
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door (1860mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1160mm
90
Outlet: L’ALLÉE (Side Entrance)
Two Steps: 180mm/180mm
Total Threshold: 360mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1440mm
Outlet: IL VICOLO
One Step: 240mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 890mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1600mm
Outlet: CALZEDONIA
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 1120mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
91
Outlet: CHEMIMART (Under Construction)
One Step: 200mm approx.
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width to Tables and Chairs: 2020mm
Outlet: CALZEDONIA (New Premises)
See Photo
Outlet: UNO DE 50
One Step: 125mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 3400mm
92
Conclusion
This survey concludes that outlets’ thresholds leading in, vary from approximately 50mm to
260mm respectively not mentioning stepped entrances (these can be seen in here above
photos). Clear entrance widths vary from 630mm to over 1830mm while pavement clear width
vary from 1160mm to over 2400mm. Only a small fraction of premises do conform to AADG
2011 as the vast majority do have either a step / threshold more than 15mm or, on the other
hand lack the minimum clear width of 900mm as per the AADG2011.
93
Commission for the
Rights of Persons with
Disability
G5 Offices
Salvu Psaila Street
Birkirkara BKR9077, Malta
+356 2226 7600
Gozo Office: C/o Sannat Primary School, Sannat Road, Sannat, and Gozo
+ 356 2155 6002
[email protected] l www.crpd.org.mt
Date:
Completion date of survey 15th April, 2019
Location:
Bisazza Street, Sliema
(Plaza Area)
EOCU Reference:
AC048/18
Findings of Site Inspection:
Following various EOCU complaints regarding the general accessibility within all the outlets/shops (Public
Buildings) located at Bisazza Street Sliema, CRPD performed an onsite audit to verify the above mentioned.
Hereunder listed is what was observed during such audit.
Shops located in Bisazza Street, Sliema. (Route indicated in red below).
94
Outlet: SANDRO FERRONE
Two Steps: 170mm/170mm
Total Threshold: 340mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 870mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters
Outlet: CAMICISSIMA
Under Construction (See Photo)
Outlet: PHONE REPAIR
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm till Planter
95
Outlet: REGENT HOUSE
One Step: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:840mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm till Planter
Outlet: GOLD LION HOLDING
13 Steps to Main Entrance (See Photo)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 860mm
Lift not Conform to AADG2011
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
Outlet: OROGOLD
Threshold: 50mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 980mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
96
Outlet: MOO’S DELI
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 2440mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
Outlet: Under Construction
One Step: 150mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:860mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
Outlet: LYONS RANGE
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 650mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
97
Outlet: VERSO
One Step: 240mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 800mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
Outlet: DICKENS
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 950mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
Outlet: MUSCAT JEWELLERY
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 1840mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
98
Outlet: MUSCAT JEWELLERY (Closed)
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 2130mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2020mm
Outlet: LET’S SEE
Two Steps: 120mm/140mm
Total Threshold: 260mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1750mm
Outlet: TREND
Two Steps: 150mm/150mm
Total Threshold: 300mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 830mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1920mm
99
Outlet: PLAZA
Four Steps, Concrete Ramp and Lift at side.
See Photos
Pavement Clear Width: 1920mm
Outlet: DR.JUICE
Two Steps: 130mm/120mm
Total Threshold: 250mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 4300mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1280mm
100
Outlet: MALTCO LOTTO OFFICE
Outside: Flush
Inside Threshold: 30mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 950mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1830mm
Outlet: ROMMS
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width:1 Leaf Door: 860mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters (Pjazza)
Outlet: GARB
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 1150mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters (Pjazza)
101
Outlet: ICE WATCH
Two Steps: 130mm/160mm
Total Threshold: 290mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: Sliding Door: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1900mm (Pjazza)
Outlet: LA FAMILIA TATOO
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1 Leaf Door: 1 meter
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters (Pjazza)
Outlet: MATRIX
One Step: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 930mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters (Pjazza)
102
Outlet: CLOSED (NO NAME) – Moved to SUNLAB PLAZA
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:800mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 3300mm
Outlet: NEXT HOME
One Step: 70mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1040mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2200mm
Outlet: MELITA
Four Steps: 230mm/180mm/180mm/180mm
Total Threshold: 470mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding: 1Leaf Door: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
103
Outlet: ULTIMATE
Seven Steps: 6x160mm, 1x100mm
Total Threshold: 1,060mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding: Shutter Door: 1060mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
Outlet: ST. ANNE COURT
Eight Steps: 6x160mm, 1x200mm, 1x150mm
Total Threshold: 1,310mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 970mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
Outlet: GUESS
One Step Outside: 90mm
Inclined Platform Lift provided
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1200mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2060mm
104
Outlet: MOONSOON
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1630mm
Outlet: MOONSOON CHILDREN
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1630mm
Outlet: ACCESSORIZE
One Step: 80mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2030mm
105
Outlet: REIKER
One Step: 190mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 950mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2030mm
Outlet: MUMUSO
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 1600mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1960mm
Outlet: NARA CAMICIE
Four Steps:100mm, 180mm, 190mm,210mm
Total Threshold: 680mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1960mm
106
Outlet: GAUDA
Two Steps: 170mm, 150mm
Total Threshold: 320mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1960mm
Outlet: TA’ KRIS
Eleven Steps to Main Entrance: See Photo
Pavement Clear Width: 1960mm
Outlet: PIZZA HUT
Ramped Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 980mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1960mm
107
Outlet: GO PHONEBOX
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 720mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
Outlet: VASCAS
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 720mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
Outlet: MARELLA
Outer Step: 90mm
Inner Step: 100mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
108
Outlet: VODAFONE
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding Automated: 2100mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
Outlet: LABEL
Stairs: 180mm x 19 Steps (See Photo)
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
Outlet: UNDER CONSTRUCTION (No Name)
One Step: 120mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 4 Leaf Door (2 Leaf Open: 870mm)
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
109
Outlet: E-JEWELS
Two Steps: 120mm, 110mm
Total Threshold: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 900mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2140mm
Outlet: SHOESHACK (Display Window)
One Step: 230mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2Leaf Door: 1570mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2400mm
Outlet: SHOESHACK
Stairs at Side: 1 x 110mm, 13 x 190mm
See Photo
Pavement Clear Width: 1460mm
110
Outlet: MONOPOLE (Found Closed)
Two Steps Outside: 150mm, 120mm
Total Threshold: 270mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door
Pavement Clear Width: 2460mm
Outlet: MERLIN LIBRARY
Three Steps: 110mm, 130mm, 180mm
Total Threshold: 420mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 1 meter
Pavement Clear Width: 2460mm
Outlet: FLYING TIGER
One Step: 160mm
Ramp Access: 650mm wide (Not Conform)
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 1940mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1400mm
111
Outlet: TIMBERLAND
Two Steps: 180mm, 180mm
Total Threshold: 360mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (Both Open: 1meter)
Pavement Clear Width: 1400mm
Outlet: ELISABETTA FRANCHI
One Step: 200mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 920mm
Pavement Clear Width: 1700mm
Outlet: OFFICINE PHONE REPAIR
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 2 Leaf Door (1Leaf:800mm)
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters
112
Outlet: CLOSED SHOP (No Name)
Two Steps: 140mm, 120mm
Total Threshold: 260mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 880mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters
Outlet: SORBINO
One Step: 130mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 930mm
Pavement Clear Width: Over 5 meters
Outlet: CLASSIC JEWELLERS
One Step: 160mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 760mm
Pavement Clear Width: Vary from 2440mm to 870mm
113
Outlet: DOLCE SICILIA
Two Steps: 150mm, 140mm
Total Threshold: 290mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1Leaf Door: 820mm
Pavement Clear Width: 2440mm
Tables and Chairs: Stepped (Not Accessible) See Photo
Outlet: DIESEL/LEVI’S/FRED PERRY
One Step: 140mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: 1360mm
Pavement Clear Width: Pjazza
Outlet: SOFRA KEBAB
Ramped Entrance
Main Entrance Clear Width: Automated Door: 1 meter
Pavement Clear Width: Pjazza
114
Outlet: MOTHERCARE
Threshold: 60mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Sliding Automated: 1600mm
Pavement Clear Width: Pjazza
Outlet: PJAZZA GELATERIA
One Step: 170mm
Main Entrance Clear Width: Shutter Door: 2meters
Pavement Clear Width: Pjazza
115
Conclusion
This survey concludes that outlets’ thresholds leading in, vary from approximately 50mm to
770mm respectively not mentioning stepped entrances (these can be seen in here above
photos). Clear entrance widths vary from 650mm to over 4300mm while pavement clear
width vary from 870mm to over 5000mm. Only a small fraction of premises do conform to
AADG 2011 as the vast majority do have either a step / threshold more than 15mm or, on
the other hand lack the minimum clear width of 900mm as per the AADG2011.
*Above report is based and subject to situation found on site at date and time of inspection.
*Detailed information/diagrams can be viewed in the Access for All Design Guidelines 2011 (AADG 2011) which can be
downloaded from www.crpd.org.mt
Clayton Block Joseph Farrugia Assistant Manager / Technical Officer Editor
Statistic of findings.
Following onsite inspections carried out at Gzira and Sliema between Monday
the 19th of November 2018 till the 15th of April 2019 regarding the accessibility
(Main entrance clear width) of all outlets located within The Strand Gzira and
Sliema (The Strand, Tower Road and Bisazza Street). Hereunder please find
table of results with statistic of findings.
*Offer Alternative
The Strand - Gzira 3
The Strand - Sliema 9
Tower Road – Sliema 1
Bisazza Street - Sliema 2
Ticketing Booths 0
Works in Progress 0
Total 15
Conform to AADG 2011 Not Conform to AADG
2011
*The Strand - Gzira 14 75 *The Strand - Sliema 24 75 *Tower Road - Sliema 1 46 Bisazza Street - Sliema 3 50 Ticketing Booths 0 40 Kiosks 0 6 Works in Progress 18 N/A N/A
Total 42 292
The Strand - Gzira
The Strand - Sliema
Tower Road - Sliema
Bisazza Street - Sliema
Kiosks
Ticketing Booths
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
The Strand - Gzira The Strand - Sliema Tower Road - Sliema Bisazza Street - Sliema Kiosks Ticketing Booths
Accessible 14 24 1 3 0 0
Not Accessible 75 75 46 50 6 40
Offer Alternative 3 9 1 2 0 0
Works in Progress 3 5 4 5 1 0
Gżira - Sliema Audit Report
Accessible Not Accessible Offer Alternative Works in Progress
Threshold up to 360mm - To provide TemporaryRamp
Minor Works to be implemented - Installation ofInclined Platform Lift/Alterations in Main Entrance
Door
Major Works to be implemented -Demolition/Installation of Passengers Lift
Under Construction/Closed
Conform to AADG2011
Ticketing Booths
020
4060
80100
120140
160180
200
187
55
11
23
42
40
Gżira & Sliema Shops
Audit Report