sheikh zayed - punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/evaluationreport/3754_angiography...website of sheikh zayed...
TRANSCRIPT
SHEIKH ZAYEDMEDICAL COLLEGEIHOSPITAL
Rahim Yat KhanTel 068 9230442-165 Ext: 115 Fax. 068 9230162Website [email protected]
Ref. No(f/~(99oJ/SZH
Dated 1--'] ..-l/( ~ /20 I6
To,
1. MIS. Ferroz Sons Laboratories, 197-A, The Mall, Rawalpindi.2. MIS. Cardiac Care, 848-C Shadman-1 Lahore Tel:(92-42) 37422038.3. MIS. Pak Punjab, Plot No.257-k,Phase-I, DHA, Lahore Tel:+9242357099214. MIS. Health Tec, 10-B Street 24 Valley Road Westridge I, Rawalpindi
Tel:+92(0)51 5158145.5. MIs. ACP System, 13 &23, Naval Fleet Club, Iqbal (SJ) Shaheed Road
Karachi.6. MIs. Decent Surgical, Canal Road, Rahim Yar Khan7. MIs. B.Braun, J Block Model 108/4, Town, Lahore Tel:(+92)(42)5911571-3
Subject:- ANNOUNCEMENT OF TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION REPORT ANDFINANCIAL BID OPENING & FINALIZATION OF RATES FOR THEBULK PURCHASE OF ANGIOGRAPHY FINANCIAL YEAR 2016-17.
It is hereby informed that Technical Bid Evaluation Report for the bulk
purchase of Angiography items tender year 2016-17 has been uploaded at the
website of Sheikh Zayed Medical College/Hospital, Rahim Yar Khan
(www.szmc.edu.pk [email protected]) & PPRA www.ppra.punjab.gov.pk on 23-
11-2016. All the participating bidders can check their status on this website and
submit their grievances if any about their quoted items within 10 days up to
02-12-2016 and attend the meeting of Grievances Committee on 03-12-2016
at 10:00 am in committee room of this institution.
Financial Bid Opening & Finalization of Rates:-
All the qualified bidders are also informed to attend the meeting for the
financial bid opening & finalization of rates for the bulk purchase of Angiography
Items tender year 2016-17 on 05-12-2016 at 10:00 am committee room of
Sheikh Zayed Medical College/ Hospital.
C.C.1. The Principal, SZMC/SZH, R.Y.Khan.2. The Chairman Grievances Redressal Committee.
~J4E.9fiCAl S ENDENTSheikh Zayed Hospital~7fKhan
,. " Sheikh Zayed Medical College/ Hospital Rahim Yar KhanBidder Wise Technical Evaluation (Angiography Items) Financial Year 2016-17
12345 76MIS Decent
Mis B.BraunSr.# Detail Mis. Ferroz Sons Mis Cardiac Care Mis Pak Punjab MIs HealthTec Mis ACP SystemSurgical
Original receipt for purchase of tender. Attached Attached Attachedphotocopy
Attached Attached AttachedAttached
2Acceptance of :e'ms and condition, tender documents duly
Followed Not complete Followed Followed Followed Followed Followedsigned and stamped.
An affidavit on stamp paper 0 RS.1001- submitting followingclauses: i) replacerrent of unconsumed I expired I Attached but not Attached but not Attached but not Attached but not
3 substanda-d so.i-lo.is d'ugs I stocks free 0" cost, ii) tr-at the o'ope' (orly clause Attached Attached Attached prope- (clause I proper (only clause proper (only clausefirm is never blacklisted on a1Y g ounds whatsoever. Iii) ii mentioned) not ment oned) ii mentionea) ii mentioned)Price Reasonable certificate
4 Call deposit I Bid Security required Attached Attached Attached Attached Attached Not Attached Attached
National tax number and General Sale Tax number NTN & STNSTN & FBR form NTN & STN FBR fo m FBR for STN & FBR orm
NTN & STN5
certificate At achedattached having Attached attached having attached having attached having
AttachedNTN number (Duplicate) NTN number NTN nu ber NTN number
6 Professional Tax Attached Attached Attached Attached Attached Attached Attached
7Valid Drug Sales License I Valid Manufacturing License in DSL DSL DSL DSL DSL DSL DSLcase of lrr1 itself a: form 11 a: to-rn 11 at form 11 at form 11 at for 07 a form 11 at to-rn 07
8Expe ience Certificate I Pro'orrnance Certificate (as per
S.O Attac-ied S.O Attached S.O AttachedPast Performance,
S.O Attached No: Attached S.O Attachedspecimen prcforma attached) S.O Attacned
9 SaT pie p-ovided as oe- Pro'orrna attac'ied No: Atacred Attact-eo No: Attached Atached No: Attached Not Atacred Not Attacr-eo
10He Origiral o,'ce ts: of :'1e f indicatinq t-ie irc'usion 0"
Not Applicao e Not Applicab'e Not Applicable Not Applicab e Not Applicao e Not Applicab e Not Applicab'e:1e i:e'l' I orod.ici of ouoted i:e (Latest)
Tt e o'dde- is required to orovide Finar ca Prooosal wit1 tne11 rar-ie of i:eTs, teroer n.irnber and se-:a rur-ioe- ir the Follcwed Followed Followed Followed Followed Followed Followed
exact Tanner as quoted in the Tec'mcal Proposa'
12 Price shculc not oe me-iticr-ec 01 tecbnica' bia. Followed Followed Followed Followed Followed Followed Followed
13Certfcates (FDAlISO/CE/GMP/Bio-Eauiva,e1ce S:udy
Not Applicao e Not Applicao e Not Applicab.e Not Applicao'e Not Applicao e Not Applicab e EC,ISO AttachedReport)
1': Va"d lr1001 t.'cer-se w-ie-e applicao e Attact-ec At.act-ec Attact-ec At.acr-ec At:acrec Not Applicao e Attacbec
'"'. Sr. # Detail Mis. Ferroz Sons Mis Cardiac Care Mis Pak Punjab Mis HealthTec Mis ACP System MIS Decent
Mis B.BraunSurgical
15 Sole Agency I Foreign Principal Let er in case of Importer Attached Attached At ached At ached Attached Not Attached Not Applicable
16 Letter of Intention (as per specimen proforma a tached) Sign & Stamp Attached Sign & Samp Sign & Stamp Sign & Stamp Sign & Stamp Sign & Stamp
17 Affidavit (as per specimen proforma attached) Sign & S amp Not Attached Sign & Stamp Sign & Stamp Sign & Stamp Attached Attached
l-Pendra Care2-Blue medical
Valid Manufacturers Authorization (as per specimenBoston Scientific
1·Proactive 3-Cardionovum18 Peroforma attached) (Any authority letter other than as per 2-E-Line J&J 4-SPMedical Medtronic USA Genus Not Applicable
specimen peroforma will not be accepted) USA3-lnsightra 5-Comed
6-Perouse Medical7-Qualimed GmbH
Non ResponsiveRemarks Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive due non Responsive
provision of COR
~Dr. Nazish Mustafa
PharmacistProcuremen Cell
.ffif-Dr. Mohammad Ashraf
A.M.S. (Stores)
S1f==--Mrs. Rahat Ramzan
DirectorTechnical / Drugs Conroller
Dr. Nousheen MunawarPharmacist
Procuremen Cell
D' AbdJs,,~~ A",.Prof. D,.i'~dChief Consultant, Chest Physician Angiography Dept.
~VProf. Dr. lrshad-ul-Haq
Head of E.N.T. Dept.
~-~~\
~'f.1fr.Shoukat Ali Rao
Head of Cardiology Dept.
~~ r':~Of. Dr. Mohammad Ab~ ~rof. ~~. Tariq N1j~~«l Rehan
Head of Pathology Dept. Surgery DepartmentChairman Technical Scrutiny Committee.
Prof. . Ghulam ~reedMed cine Department
Prof. Dr. MoHammad AzeemHead of Ortho Dept.
-
1 2 3 4 5 7
Sr #Name of lime DruglMedicines and Its
MIS FEROZSONS MIS PAKPUNJABSpecifications MIS CARDIAC CARE MIS HEALTH TEC MIS ACP SYSTEM MIS B.BRAUN
LABORATORIES CARDEX
Angiodyn-Manifold (high
pressure manifold 2/3I 2 Point Manifold part)
B.Braun GermanySample Approved
Intradyn Punctureneedle(Diameter
2 ARP needleI.3mm(18G)length 70mm
18G length 73mm.B.Braun Germany
Sample Approved
I-Accot(l50cm)SPMedical
Angiodyn (PTFE-CoatedDenmark
2-Accot(260cm)stainless nickel-chromium
Emerald (J tiplstraight steel 150CM wire lengthtip)cordis USA
SP Medical Medtronic (0.038 145cm)0.038/0.97 wire
3 Guidewire (0.38)CSIEU/Mexico
Denmark USAdiameter(inch/mm)
Sample Approved3-Imported China (150cm) Sample Approved
0.035/0.89 wire diameter)4-lmported China (260cm)
B.Braun PakistanRejected due to multiple
Sample Approvedquoted brands against
single item.
SHEIKH ZAYED MEDICAL COLLEGE/HOSPITAL, RAHIM YAR KHAN.Technical Comparative Statement for the Bulk Purchase of Angiography Items, Financial Year 2016-17.
(9
~
••.f'
~~J,. it ~
~
/hj
~
Name of Itme Drug/Medicines and ItsSpecificationsSr#
4 Guidewire (0.35)
5 Judkin Right Catheter 6F Size
6 Judkin Left Catheter 6F Size
7 Pressure Line (Alliune Medico) 180cm
8 Priority Pack
~\ '~,
'\
2 3 4 5 7
MIS FEROZSONSLABORATORIES
ImpulselExpoBostan Scientific USARejected as difficult in
manipulation due tostiffness of catheter.
Impulse/ExpoBostan Scientific USARejected as difficult in
manipulation due tostiffness of catheter.
~
M/S CARD lAC CARE
ProactiveItaly
Rejected as the pressureline is :00 hard & difficult
for handling.
I\I/S PAK PUNJABCARDEX
Emerald (J tip/straighttip)cordis USA Mexico
Sample Approved
Infinit,Super TorqueCordis USA
USIEU/Mexico(All sizes)
Sample Approved
Infinit,Super TorqueCordis USA
US/EU/Mexico(All sizes)
Sample Approved
;\lIS HEALTH TEC
I-Accot(150cm)SP Medical
Denmark2-Accot(260cm)
SP MedicalDenmark
3-lmported China (150cm)4-Imported China (260cm)
Rejected due :0 multiplequoted brands agains
single item.
Pointer (Hydrophiliccoated)
Pendra Care NetherlandRejected as difficult in
manipulation due tostiffness.
Pointer (Hydrophiliccoated)
Pendra Care NetherlandRejected as difficult in
manipulation due tostiffness.
tf 'MAv-r-e~ ~~
M/S ACP SYSTEM
Medtronic (0.038 145cm)USA
Sample Approved
Bicakcilar/ TurkeyRejected as the pressureline is :00 r.a:-d & diffic •..•:~
for handling
Everest! Mcdtronic/ ;;SA(Everest ir f.ation Device
Kit Mexico)Rejected cue to poorclinical experience
M/S B.BRAliN
Angiodyn (PTFE-Coatedstainless nickel-chromiumsteel 150CM wire length
0.038/0.97 wirediameter(inch/mm)
0.035/0.89 wire diameter)B.Braun GermanySample Approved
Diagnostic CatheterJR(AII type)
B.Braun GermanySample Approved
Diagnostic Catheter JL(AIItype)
B.Braun GermanySample Approved
High Pressure tubing(length 100cm or I50cm)
B.Braun GermanySample Approved
1 2 3 4 5 7
Sr#ame of lime Drug/Medicines and lis
MIS FEROZSO;\,S I\I/S PAK PCI'iJABpecificationsLABORATORIES
I\I/S CARDIAC CARECARDEX
;'oIlS IIEALTH TEC ;\IIS ACP SYSTDI MIS B.BRAt! 1
Avanti + l-ComedInput TSI Medtronicl USACordis(USA) Netherland
Mexico 2-Imported China (6Fr II ern) Mexico9 Arterial Sheath Femoral 6F
USIEUlMexico Rejected due to two Rejected due to hardness
(All sizes) brands quoted for theof arterial sheath causing
Sample Approved single item.arterial injury.
Avanti + l-ComedCordis(L;SA) Netherland
Mexico 2-Impo:ted China10 Arterial Sheath Radial 6F
L;SIEUlMexico Rejected due to two(All sizes) brands quoted for the
Sample Approved single item.
Champion SP medicalMedtronic/ L;SA (zinger
Denmark light,zinger Navitas plus
Rejected due to poor marker,zingermedium,zing (length 17Scm,profileII PTCA Wire BMW 0.14"
quality of wire and noter support, Intiuation, 0.014 inch)AII type
user friendly diffic It to Provia Dominican B.Braun Germany
manipulation. Republic Sample ApprovedSample Approved
Champion SP medicalDenmark
12 P CA WireBHW Rejected due 0 poorquality of wire and nOIuser friendly difficult to
manipulation.
Vista Brite Tip Primium (HydrophilicRunway/Mach I
Cordis(USA) coated) Launcherl Medtronic/Bostan Scientific USA
Mexico Pendra Care L;SA (EBU 3.0 6Fr)13 XB 3 G icing Catheter 6 F Rejected due :0 hardness
L;S/EC/MexicoNetherland Rejected as catheter is 100
and poor quality 0:(All sizes) Sample Rejected as hard & sti ft to
materia'.Sample Approved
catheter is 100 hard and manipulation.stift 10 manipulation.
Vis:a Brite Tip Primium (Hydrophi.icRunwav/Mach :
Cordis(L;SA) coated) Launcher/ Medtronic.Bostan Scic-tific USA
Mexico Pendra Care ~SA (EBU 3.5 6Fr)14 XB 3.5 Guiding Catheter 6 F Rejected cue :0 caroness
~SIEClMexico I\etherlaed Rejected as catheter is 100
and poor quality 0: (All sizes) Sample Rejected as hard & sti ft tomatcr.a.,
Sample Approved catheter .s too hard aed manipulation.stift to rnanipc.ation.
Name of Itme Drug/Medicines and ItsI 2 3
Sr #
4 5 7
Specifications MiS FEROZSONS J\[/S PAK PUNJABLABORATORIES
liS CARD[AC CARE .\1/S HEALTH TEC MIS ACP SYSTE:\,[CAROEX
MIS B.BRALIN
SeQuentl\eo(2,Ox 1O)
Everes (Semi compliant(Sequential tip to pass the
16 PTCA Balloon 2,OxIO
EmergefMeverick 2ball on)
Sprinter RX/ Legend most challanging lesion
Bostan Scientific USABlue medical
Medtronic/ USA (Dia 2,Ox Dia 1,25, 1,5,2,0,2,5,
Sample ApprovedNetherland l Omm) Lowest tip profile of
Sample Rejected due toIreland/ Mexico 0,0 16,5f guiding catheter
poor quality of balloonSample Approved compatible, Esp design for
tigh: and CTO)
R Braun GermanySample Approved
SeQuent Neo(2,Ox IS)
Everes (Semi compliantSprinter RX/ Legend
(Sequential tip to pass the
17 PTCA Balloon 2,0 x 15EmergefMeverick 2
ball on)most challanging lesion
Bostan Scientific USABlue medical
Medtronicf USA (Dia 2,Ox Dia 1.25,1.5,2,0,2,5,
Sample ApprovedNet eland
15mm) Lowest tip profile of
Sample Rejected due toIreland/ Mexico 0,016,5fguiding ca heter
poor q ality of balloonSample Approved compatible, Esp design for
tight and CTO)RBraun GermanySample Approved
SeQuen eo(2,Ox IS)
Everest (Semi compliantSprinter RX/ Legend
(Sequential tip to pass the
18 PTCA 3a1:00", 1.5 x I0Emerge/Meverick 2
ballon)1:10st challenging lesion
Bostan Scient: fie USABlue medical
Medtronicl USA (Dia 1,5x Dia 1.25, I ,5,2,0,2,5,
Sample ApprovedNetherland
l Ornrn) Lowes: tip profile of
Sample Rejected cue :0Ireland/ Mexico 0,0 16.5f guiding ca:heter
poor quality of ba.loonSamp.e Approved co.npatible.Esp design for
tigh: and CTO)3,B~aur. GermanySa.r: pie A pproved
.r
~
cr
1 2 3 4 5 7
Sr#Name of Itme Drug/Medicines and lIS
MIS FEROZSO:\,S MIS PAK PUNJABSpecificationsLABORATORIES
IVUSCARDIAC CARECARDEX
j\I/S HEALTH TEC MIS ACP SYSTEM MIS B.BRAlIN
SeQuentl\'eo(2.0x 16)
(Sequential tip to pass theSprinter RX/ Legend most challanging lesion
Ernerge/Meverick 2 Medtronicl USA (Dia 1.5x Dia 1.25,1.5,2.0,2.5.19 PTCA Balloon 1.5x 12 Bostan Scientific USA 12mm) Lowest tip profile of
Sample Approved Irelandl Mexico 0.0 16,5f guiding catheterSample Approved compatible. Esp design for
tight and CTO)B.Braun GermanySample Approved
SeQuent Neo(2.0x 15)
Everest (Semi compliant(Sequential tip to pass the
ball on)Sprinter RX/ Legend most challanging lesion
Emerge/Meverick 2 Blue medicalMedtronicl USA (Dia 1.5x Dia 1.25,1.5,2.0,2.5.
20 PTeA Balloon 1.5xl5 Bostan Scientific USA Netherland15mm) Lowest tip profile of
Sample Approved Sample Rejected due to Irelandl Mexico 0.016,5f guiding catheter
poor quality of balloonSample Approved compatible. Esp design for
tight and CTO)B.Braun GermanySample Approved
Coroflex Blue Neo &
Track (cobalt chromiumUltra(All sizes)
s:ent)Alternate Cobalt
Omega (platinum Blue medicalChromium.strut thickness
chromiu:n) Netherland:ntegri:yl Medtronic/ CSA 60u:n en.ry profile 0.016
21 Bare Metal Stent B:vtS Ireland inch, very flexiablc strutBoston Scientific CSA Rejected due to non
Sample Approved thickness 50llln low
hfZ·OO. availability of sample aswell as poor quality 0: profile. ve~y flexible CS
B1V:S marked.8.Braun GermanySample Approved
/\~.~~ ~
fd1(~ r--~(JJ
c
1 2 3 4 5 7
Sr#Name of Itrne Drug/Medicines and Its
M/S FEROZSONS M/S PAK PUNJABSpecifications J\'US CARDIAC CARE M/S HEALTH TEC M/S ACP SYSTEM M/S B.BRAUNLABORATORIES CARD EX
Coroflex ISAR Coronary
Xlimus (sirolimusStent System (sirolimus
Prom us Element Plus biodegradable)Cardinovu Resolute Integrity/release polymer free
22 Drug Eluting Stents DES(platinum chromium) m Medtronic/ USA Ireland
coronary stent system strutBoston Scientific USA thickness 0.0025 inch
Sample ApprovedGermany Sample Approved'
entry profile 0.0 16inch.Sample Approved
B.Braun GermanySample Approved
J' ETO Paper 10cmE-Line Italy
_JSample Rejected
24 ETO Paper 20cmE-Line Italy
Sample Rejected
25 E.TO. Paper 30cmE-Line Italy
Sample Rejected
26 ETO Gas Cartridge
27 ACT Cartridge :v1ini-II
28 Intra Aortic Balloon CatheterInsightra Medical USA
Sample Approved
Impulse/ExpoInfinit.Super Torque
Pointer (HydrophilicCordis USA Diagnostic Catheter Pg
Bostan Scientific USAMexico
coated)Tail All sizes.29 Pigtail Catheter Rejected as catheter is too
USIEUlMexicoPendra Care
B.Braun Germanyhard & sti It to Netherlandmanipulation.
(All sizes)Sample Approved
Sample ApprovedSample Approved
ImpulselExpo Infinit,Super TorqueBostan Scientific USA Cordis USA
30 Lima Catheter Rejected as catheter is too Mexicohard & sti ft to (All sizes)manipulation. Sample Approved
Impulse/Expo Infinit.Super Torque Pointer (HydrophilicDiagnostic Catheter AI!
Bostan Scientific USA Cordis USA coated)3: IVP Catheter Rejected as catheter is too Mexico Pendra Care
Types
hard & sti ft to (All sizes) NetherlandB.Braun Germany
manipulation. Sample Approved Sample ApprovedSample Approved
Impulse/Expo !r.f:r.;:,Super Torque Pointer (HydrophilicJ:agnos::c Catheter All
Bostan Scier tific USA Cordis USA coated)32 JR 5" Rejected as catheter .s too Mexico Pendra Care Types
hard & stift to (A:I sizes) I\et~erlacd3.B:-atl~ Ge-rnany
manipulation. Sample Approved Samp.e Approved Sample ApprovedI
~ ~ y11 d ~~W ~- fJ~
~/ y
1 2 3 4 5 7
Sr#Name of Itme Drug/Medicines and Its
I\VS FEROZSONS M/S PAK PUNJABSpecificationsLAB01v\ TORIES I\'US CARDIAC CARE
CARDEXM/S HEALTH TEC M/S ACP SYSTEM M/S B.BRALIN
Impulse/Expo lnfinit.Super Torque Pointer (HydrophilicDiagnostic Catheter AllBostan Scientific USA Cordis USA coated)
33 JL5F Rejected as catheter is too \1exico Pendra CareTypes
hard & stift to (All sizes) NetherlandB.Braun Germany
manipulation. Sample Approved Sample ApprovedSample Approved
Avanti + I-Comed
Cordis(CSA) Netherland
34 Arterial Sheath (Femoral)5F Mexico 2-lmported China
(All sizes) Rejected due to two
Sample Approvedbrands quoted for the
single item.
Pointer (HydrophilicImpulse/Expo Infinit.Super Torque coated)
Diagnostic Catheter AllBostan Scientific USA Cordis USA Pendra Care35 JL 3.5 Rejected as catheter is too Mexico Netherland Types
hard & stift to (All sizes) Rejected due to twoB.Braun Germany
manipulation. Sample Approved brands quoted for the Sample Approved
single item. »<.
~?rt~ __ J
~~-- .Dr. MOhakraf
--- lj./MI.I \::::mill ~ ...J/AA' >Dr. Nazish Mustafa Dr. i\ousheen Munawa r . wdu~ahid -;I" Dr. Abdu S ArshadPharmacist Pharmacist Director Technical/ Drugs Conroller A.\1.S. (Stores) Sr. Procurement officer Chief Con , Chest Physician
Procuremen Cell
A,,,p,", i!~'dAngiography Dent
Procuremen Cell
P",. D,. Sh'~'j;d Khan P,,'.D~lEi.q p, r. D,. Gh"'.mF,,, r~G 0 Head o~E."I.T. Dept. Medicine Department ro . Dr. Mohammad Azeem
ynea 'P' ~'"p f 0 ') ~I I \bd I R~I' ..• ~,"r. D~"d O'::h:,~:\- ror, ,. "",,,.m,,, " "moo l p ,.~,
Head 0:Paiho.ogy Dept. Surgery DepartmentChairman Technica. Scru.iny Co-rrnittee.
~~(~
Prof. Dr. Shoukat Ali RaoHead of Cardiology Dept.
\,