sha502 transcripts - amazon s3 · !sha502:conducting!effective!hospitality!marketing!research!...

35
SHA502: Conducting Effective Hospitality Marketing Research School of Hotel Administration, Cornell University © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners. 1 SHA502 Transcripts Transcript: Course Introduction Hello, I'm Judy Sigua. Welcome to Conducting Effective Hospitality Marketing Research. This course is second in a four course series in the hospitality marketing certificate program. You will learn varying methods of data collection, market segmentation, strategic positioning, and steps in the buying process. Along with learning how to use the SWAT method of analysis, we will be using well marking situations and we'll be exploring practical solutions and approaches to marking situations and challenges. I hope you will have as much fun taking this course as the eCornell team and I had putting it together. Transcript: Marketing Research Process Case Study Hello, good to meet you! My name is Ellen Roth, I am the General Manager here at the Golden Bay Inn. Our problem is that we have noticed a downturn in business lately, and when I started looking into it, I discovered that we have very low customerretention rates. In fact we only averaged 37 percent last year and 38 percent the previous year. We seem to be able to get people in the door, but they aren't coming back. I work hard with our small, 20person staff, and I think that we are wellpositioned in the San Francisco market to compete with other small, highpriced, elegant hotels such as ours, so I need to know why this is happening. With my daily responsibilities, I don't have the time to do the indepth marketing analysis that is needed to find out the root causes of our troubles. I hope you can help us—you have come highly recommended! Transcript: What is Marketing Research? The Six Steps of the Marketing Research Process 1. Define research objectives or problem 2. Formulate hypotheses 3. Plan the research design 4. Develop the sampling plan and collect data

Upload: others

Post on 04-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

1  

 SHA502 Transcripts  

   Transcript: Course Introduction  Hello,  I'm  Judy  Sigua.  Welcome  to  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research.  This  course  is  second  in  a  four  course  series  in  the  hospitality  marketing  certificate  program.      You  will  learn  varying  methods  of  data  collection,  market  segmentation,  strategic  positioning,  and  steps  in  the  buying  process.  Along  with  learning  how  to  use  the  SWAT  method  of  analysis,  we  will  be  using  well  marking  situations  and  we'll  be  exploring  practical  solutions  and  approaches  to  marking  situations  and  challenges.      I  hope  you  will  have  as  much  fun  taking  this  course  as  the  eCornell  team  and  I  had  putting  it  together.      Transcript: Marketing Research Process Case Study  Hello,  good  to  meet  you!  My  name  is  Ellen  Roth,  I  am  the  General  Manager  here  at  the  Golden  Bay  Inn.  Our  problem  is  that  we  have  noticed  a  downturn  in  business  lately,  and  when  I  started  looking  into  it,  I  discovered  that  we  have  very  low  customer-­‐retention  rates.  In  fact  we  only  averaged  37  percent  last  year  and  38  percent  the  previous  year.  We  seem  to  be  able  to  get  people  in  the  door,  but  they  aren't  coming  back.  I  work  hard  with  our  small,  20-­‐person  staff,  and  I  think  that  we  are  well-­‐positioned  in  the  San  Francisco  market  to  compete  with  other  small,  high-­‐priced,  elegant  hotels  such  as  ours,  so  I  need  to  know  why  this  is  happening.  With  my  daily  responsibilities,  I  don't  have  the  time  to  do  the  in-­‐depth  marketing  analysis  that  is  needed  to  find  out  the  root  causes  of  our  troubles.  I  hope  you  can  help  us—you  have  come  highly  recommended!      Transcript: What is Marketing Research?

The  Six  Steps  of  the  Marketing  Research  Process  

1. Define  research  objectives  or  problem  2. Formulate  hypotheses  3. Plan  the  research  design  4. Develop  the  sampling  plan  and  collect  data  

Page 2: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

2  

5. Analyze  the  data  6. Prepare  the  final  report  

Step  1:  Define  Research  Objectives  or  Problem  

Typical  objectives  of  a  market  research  project  in  the  hospitality  industry  may  include:  

• Defining  who  the  customers  are,  what  they  want,  what  their  attitudes  toward  promotional  programs  are.  

• Conducting  a  longitudinal  study  (tracking  study)  to  track  per-­‐customer  profit,  brand  or  product  awareness,  patronage,  attitude  toward  product/brand  image.  

• Obtaining  information  about  the  company  and  its  business  environment  through  internal  research  (for  example,  sales  analysis  and  marketing  cost  analysis)  and  interviewing  company  officials.  This  method  of  research  is  called  situation  analysis.  

• An  informal  investigation  involving  interviews  with  informed  persons  outside  the  firm.  

Step  2:  Formulate  Hypothesis  

An  hypothesis  is  an  educated  guess  about  the  relationships  between  events  or  about  what  will  happen  in  the  future.  In  scientific  method,  hypotheses  are  developed  and  tested.  

Step  3:  Plan  the  Research  Design  

Create  a  plan  that  specifies  what  information  will  be  obtained  and  how.  

Step  4:  Develop  the  Sampling  Plan  and  Collect  the  Data  

The  total  group  that  the  researcher  wants  to  study  is  called  the  population  or  universe.  If  all  sources  are  contacted,  the  results  are  known  as  a  census.  If  a  representative  group  is  contacted,  that  group  is  known  as  a  sample–a  subset  drawn  from  a  larger  population.  Samples  can  be  classified  as:  

• Probability  samples:  those  in  which  every  member  has  an  equal  chance  of  being  selected.  

• Non-­‐probability  samples:  arbitrary  samples  not  subject  to  statistical  tests.  For  example  a  convenience  sample  simply  targets  respondents  who  are  easily  accessible.  

A  key  issue  in  sampling  is  determining  how  representative  the  sample  is  of  the  total  population.  

A  properly  selected  sample  will  have  the  same  characteristics  as  the  universe  from  which  it  is  selected.  

Sampling  error  occurs  when  a  sample  is  not  representative  of  the  target  population.  

Page 3: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

3  

Step  5:  Analyze  the  Data  and  Interpret  the  Findings  

• It  is  up  to  the  researcher  to  analyze  the  data  and  identify  relationships,  trends,  and  patterns.  

• This  is  frequently  done  through  the  use  of  statistical  packages.  There  are  several  easy-­‐to-­‐use  computer  programs  that  analyze  data,  such  as  SPSS  or  SAS.  

Step  6:  Write  and  Present  the  Report  

• Findings  of  marketing  studies  should  be  presented  in  such  a  way  as  to  increase  the  likelihood  of  their  usefulness  to  the  decision  maker.  

• Reports  should  be  clear  and  concise  and  directed  toward  management.  

   Transcript: Methods of Data Collection

Primary  Data  

Primary  data  is  information  specifically  collected  for  a  current  problem.  

Primary  data:  

• Must  be  collected  if  the  specific  research  question  cannot  be  answered  by  available  secondary  data  

• Answer  specific  questions  • Are  current  • Are  gathered  using  methodology  specified  by  the  researcher  • Can  be  gathered  in  such  a  way  as  to  maintain  accuracy  and  secrecy  

Sources  of  primary  data:  firm's  suppliers,  sales  people,  middlemen,  or  customers.  

The  major  disadvantage  of  primary  data  is  the  expense  involved  in  collecting  the  data.  

Primary  research  may  be  broadly  divided  into  two  types:  qualitative  and  quantitative  research.  

Qualitative  

• Qualitative  research  captures  feelings  and  behavior  motivations.  It  seeks  in-­‐depth,  open-­‐ended  responses.  

• The  use  of  qualitative,  or  psychosociological,  research  is  spreading  throughout  U.S.  industries.  

Page 4: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

4  

• One  explanation  for  this  is  that  qualitative  research  is  relatively  fast  and  may  be  less  expensive,  in  some  cases,  than  quantitative  research.  

• Qualitative  research  is  also  a  way  for  firms  to  understand  the  nuances  and  connotations  of  their  products,  particularly  in  advertising  campaigns.  

Quantitative  

Quantitative  research  provides  hard  numbers;  it  seeks  structured  responses  that  can  be  summarized  in  numbers—like  percentages,  averages,  or  other  statistics.  

• Quantitative  methods  are  still  the  most  prevalent.  • Despite  the  growth  in  popularity  of  qualitative  research,  especially  focus  groups,  survey  

research  still  remains  the  most  commonly  used  method  of  understanding  consumer  behavior.  

• Survey  research  data  collection  still  has  its  advantages,  particularly  the  ability  to  project  the  sample  results  onto  the  population  as  a  whole.  

Survey  

Survey  Research  Advantages  and  Limitations  

• Response  rate  is  often  low.  • Responses  may  not  be  representative  of  the  population.  Those  participants  willing  to  

respond  to  the  study  may  have  stronger  positive  or  negative  attitudes  about  the  issue  under  consideration  than  the  general  population.  Thus,  these  participants  may  be  eager  to  have  their  voice  heard,  but  they  may  not  reflect  the  prevailing  attitude  of  the  larger  population.  

• Structured  questioning  gives  more  objective  results.  • Surveys  are  flexible  in  that  they  may  be  conducted  by  mail,  by  phone,  in  person  or  

electronically  through  e-­‐mail  or  the  Internet.  • Questionnaires  may  be  open-­‐ended  questions,  closed-­‐ended  questions,  or  scaled-­‐

response  questions.  • Questions  must  be  clear,  concise,  and  not  double-­‐barreled.  That  is,  surveys  should  ask  

only  one  question  at  a  time;  otherwise,  the  researcher  cannot  be  sure  to  which  question  the  study  participant  is  responding.  

• Measurement  error  occurs  when  the  information  desired  by  the  researcher  differs  from  the  information  provided  by  the  measurement  process.  For  example,  the  questions  on  the  survey  may  evoke  responses  that  do  not  elicit  the  information  the  researcher  needs  to  answer  the  research  questions.  

Pros  and  Cons  of  Types  of  Surveys  

Page 5: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

5  

• Mail  surveys  are  common,  convenient,  and  cost  effective,  but  their  response  rate  may  be  low.  

• Fax  surveys  may  yield  faster  results  than  mail  surveys,  as  well  as  a  higher  response  rate.  • Mail  panels  provide  a  good  response  rate  for  those  who  agree  to  participate.  • Telephone  surveys  are  fast  and  effective,  but  respondents  cannot  see  items  under  

discussion,  and  questions  asked  must  be  very  short.  • Personal  interview  surveys  can  be  in-­‐depth,  but  are  expensive  and  time-­‐consuming.  • Computer  interviews  allow  for  faster  gathering  and  analysis  of  data.  Respondents  may  

be  more  truthful  in  responding  to  a  computer,  especially  on  sensitive  topics,  but  the  computer  cannot  explain  misunderstood  questions.    

o Response  rates  for  e-­‐mail  and  Internet  surveys  are  generally  very  low  (<10  percent),  but  electronic  surveys  are  the  most  cost-­‐effective.  

Observation  

Observational  Method  

The  observational  method  involves  actually  viewing  the  overt  actions  of  the  subjects.  There  are  three  way  of  accomplishing  this:  

• People  watching  people.  • People  watching  physical  phenomena.  • Machines  watching  people.  

Mystery  shoppers,  one-­‐way  mirror  observations,  traffic  counters,  VideoCart  (tracks  shopper  traffic  patterns),  and  passive  people-­‐meters  are  all  ways  of  using  the  observation  method.  

A  drawback  of  the  observation  method  is  that  motivations,  attitudes,  and  feelings  are  not  measured,  thereby  limiting  the  richness  of  the  results.  

Experimental  

Experimental  Method  

This  research  approach  is  one  where  researchers  compare  the  responses  of  groups  that  are  similar  except  on  the  characteristic  being  tested.  

• Marketers  can  often  only  control  one  independent  variable  and  must  assume  that  all  other  relevant  variables  remain  the  same.  

• An  experiment  in  the  field  is  called  test-­‐marketing.  • Test  markets  are  more  realistic,  but  are  also  more  expensive,  time-­‐consuming,  and  

impossible  to  keep  secret  from  the  media  and  competitors.  

Page 6: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

6  

Secondary  

Secondary  Data  

Secondary  data  are  data  previously  collected  for  any  purpose  other  than  the  one  at  hand.  Secondary  data  may  be  internal  or  external  data.  A  lot  of  secondary  data  is  available.  Sources  include:  

• Libraries  • Government,  at  all  levels  • Internet  • Private  business  firms,  such  as  Nielsen  • Trade,  professional  and  business  associations  • Advertising  media  • University  research  organizations  • Company  databases  and  records  

A  number  of  syndicated  data  sources  are  also  available.  These  include,  but  are  not  limited  to,  PRIZM;  CREST;  Technomic,  Inc.;  Gazelle  Systems,  Inc.;  and  STR  data.  

• PRIZM  Database  segments  USERS  by  zip  code  and  block  tracts,  grouping  neighborhoods  on  the  basis  of  social  rank,  mobility,  ethnicity,  family  life  cycle,  and  housing.  

• Consumer  Reports  and  Eating-­‐Out  Share  Trends  (CREST)  studies  and  reports  on  trends  in  purchases  of  food  prepared  away  from  home.  

• Technomic,  Inc.  studies  market  share  for  restaurant  chains,  and  reports  on  trends  in  food  service.  

• STR  Global  collects  and  reports  market  share  and  operational  performance  of  hotels.  

The  advantages  of  secondary  data  are  that  it  is  less  expensive  and  faster  to  obtain  than  primary  data.  For  example,  on-­‐line  computerized  databases  simplify  the  task  of  retrieving  secondary  data  so  the  needed  data  may  be  available  immediately  and  at  a  nominal  cost.  For  these  reasons,  researchers  should  first  attempt  to  use  secondary  data  to  answer  research  questions.  Only  when  the  secondary  data  prove  to  be  insufficient  in  providing  a  thorough  answer  or  if  the  secondary  data  are  suspect  should  researchers  begin  the  more  costly  primary  data  collection.  

Disadvantages  of  secondary  data  include  obsolete  data,  irrelevant  data,  and  questionable  quality  and  accuracy.  In  studying  internal  data,  remember  that  collected  data  in  summary  form  may  hide  important  evaluative  information.  

Focus  Groups  &  Other  Methods  

Focus  Group  Interview    

Page 7: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

7  

An  interview  of  6  to  l0  people  in  an  informal  group  setting.  Focus  groups  are  a  major  means  of  obtaining  qualitative  data.  

Other  qualitative  methods  often  used  in  the  hospitality  industry  include:  

• Lobby  lizard  • One-­‐question  questionnaire  • Comment  cards  • Managers'  luncheon  • Advisory  groups  • Customer  consultants  

Data  Analysis  &  Preparation  

There  are  a  multitude  of  methods  by  which  data  may  be  analyzed  so  as  to  inform  the  marketing  decisions  of  the  organization.  In  this  section,  just  a  few  methods  commonly  used  in  marketing  are  highlighted.  

Conjoint  Analysis  

• Conjoint  analysis  measures  guests'  preferences,  predicts  guests'  responses  to  new  hospitality  concepts  or  new  attributes  of  current  concepts.  Conjoint  analysis  allows  the  hospitality  firms  to  decompose  guests'  preferences  for  goods  and  services  into  the  "partworth"  utilities  associated  with  each  option  of  each  attribute  of  the  concept.  Hospitality  firms  can  reconfigure  these  partworths  to  identify:  (1)  guests'  preferences  for  any  combination  of  attribute  options,  (2)  the  most  advantageous  hospitality  concept,  and  (3)  market  segments  that  place  the  highest  value  on  a  particular  concept.  

• Conjoint  analysis  is  often  used  to  examine  trade-­‐offs:  If  the  organization  must  choose  between  two  attributes,  which  will  bring  the  guest  the  most  satisfaction  or  be  perceived  as  offering  the  greatest  value.  Or,  from  a  customer  perspective,  what  is  the  customer  willing  to  give  up  to  get  something  else.  Conjoint  analysis  can  also  be  used  to  determine  what  customers  will  be  willing  to  pay  and  what  drives  their  purchase  decision.  

• To  develop  a  conjoint  analysis,  you  must  first  list  and  name  the  attributes  under  consideration.  An  attribute  is  any  feature  that  can  be  built  into  a  concept  and  can  be  used  to  describe  the  concept.  For  the  hospitality  industry,  these  attributes  might  include  price,  segment,  décor,  amenities,  or  cuisine,  as  well  as  many  others.  Once  the  attributes  are  defined,  then  the  levels  must  be  selected.  Each  attribute  must  have  at  least  two  levels  from  which  customers  can  choose.  For  example,  if  the  attribute  is  amenities,  the  levels  may  be  pool,  spa,  gym,  gift  shop,  and  restaurants.  The  list  of  attributes  and  levels  can  be  quite  broad,  as  in  this  example,  or  far  more  refined  by  detail.  

Page 8: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

8  

• Once  the  attributes  and  levels  are  determined,  the  customers'  responses  for  their  preferences  can  be  obtained.  There  are  generally  two  methods  for  obtaining  guest  preferences:    

o Using  the  self-­‐explicated  method,  respondents  allocate  a  total  of  100  points  among  the  different  attributes,  with  more  points  representing  the  most  important  attributes,  and  then  rank  the  different  levels  for  each  attribute  in  order  of  preference.  For  example,  a  respondent  might  distribute  30  points  out  of  100  to  the  attribute  "amenities,"  indicating  amenities  are  important  and  then  assign  ranks  of  1  to  pool,  2  to  restaurant,  etc.  

• In  the  ratingsmethod,  respondents  assign  a  score  (for  example,  0  to  100)  to  a  product  concept  (or  group  of  attributes),  so  that  more  points  are  indicative  of  stronger  preferences.  The  ratings  method  is  viewed  as  a  more  involved  and  complex  task,  but  also  a  more  reliable  method  to  extract  respondents'  preferences.  The  analysis  used  for  responses  can  infer  which  attributes  and  levels  drive  customer  purchase  decisions.    

o Guest  preferences  (or  preference  partworths)  can  be  used  to  identify  market  segments,  which  have  similar  likes  and  dislikes  and  place  similar  values  on  attributes.  

• Conjoint  simulation  programs  can  be  used  in  combination  with  other  data  to  analyze  one  company's  products  against  those  offered  by  competitors,  determine  the  relationship  between  preferences  and  market  share,  or  reveal  the  bundle  of  attributes  that  will  yield  the  highest  profit  for  the  organization.  

Laddering  

Laddering  is  a  one-­‐on-­‐one  in-­‐depth  survey  technique  that  answers  the  question  "why  is  that  important?"  and  searches  for  deeper  motivations,  and  ultimately  uncovers  the  core  personal  values  that  drive  purchase  behavior.  This  method  allows  consumers  to  translate  product  attributes  into  meaningful  personal  associations  by  laddering  linkages  across  attributes,  consequences  and  values.  Laddering  is  best  used  in  industries,  like  hospitality,  where  the  purchase  of  products  and  services  are  seen  as  means  that  enable  customers  to  fulfill  important  values  or  needs.  

Laddering  data  is  analyzed  using  content-­‐analysis  procedures  and  the  creation  of  a  tree  diagram,  known  as  a  hierarchical  value  map.  The  value  of  laddering  is  that  it  allows  the  hospitality  firm  to  market  its  products  and  services  based  on  the  consequences  and  values  that  the  customers  have  identified  as  motivators  behind  their  purchase  decisions.  

Customer  Choice  Model  

The  customer  choice  model  or  Logit  model  helps  analyze  and  explain  the  choices  individual  customers  make  in  a  market.  Using  this  data  analysis  method,  the  hospitality  firm  can  

Page 9: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

9  

understand  the  degree  to  which  factors  such  as  the  price  or  location  influence  a  customer's  choice.  More  broadly,  the  individual  guest  purchase  probability  of  a  specific  brand  equates  to  the  brand's  market  share  at  the  market  level.  Customer  choice  analysis  allows  companies  to  develop  marketing  campaigns  targeted  toward  specific  market  segments  or  individual  customers.  

Following  the  customer  choice  model,  two  methods  of  collecting  data  may  be  used:  

• The  single  alternative  is  used  when  customers  face  only  one  alternative,  which  requires  basically  a  yes  or  no  decision.  

• The  multiple  alternatives  method  requires  that  customers  select  one  answer  from  a  variety  of  options,  such  as  brand  X,  brand  Y,  or  brand  Z.  

When  combined  with  demographic  data  on  customers  and  competitor  purchase  information,  the  customer  choice  model  can  also  identify  relationships  between  certain  demographics  and  the  purchase  decision,  the  effect  of  competitors'  marketing  campaigns  on  purchase  of  the  firm's  products  or  services,  and  the  impact  of  the  firm's  marketing  promotions  on  its  own  sales  performance.  

   Transcript: The Six Stages of the Buying Process

From  need  recognition  to  post-­‐purchase  behavior,  here  you  will  find  the  six  stages  that  a  consumer  experiences  during  a  buying  process.  

1.  Need  recognition  or  problem  awareness  

The  moment  when  a  consumer  realizes  the  need  for  a  product.  

Recognition  of  an  unsatisfied  need,  or  need  (problem)  recognition,  creates  tension  or  discomfort  for  the  consumer.  This  need  may  arise  internally,  such  as  feeling  hungry  or  thirsty,  or  it  may  arise  because  of  external  stimulation  through  such  things  as:  

• An  ad  for  a  product,  or  • The  sight  of  the  product  itself  

Needs  may  also  be  stimulated  through  dissatisfaction  with  a  product  the  consumer  is  currently  using.  

Unsatisfied  needs  may  cause  conflict  for  the  consumer.  

Page 10: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

10  

• The  consumer  has  to  decide  how  to  allocate  his/her  resources  of  time  and  money  between  competing  needs.  

If  this  conflict  is  not  resolved,  the  buying  process  stops.  

2.  Choice  of  an  involvement  level  

How  important  is  satisfying  this  need  to  the  consumer?  High,  medium,  or  low?  

The  consumer  decides  how  much  effort  to  exert  to  satisfy  the  need.  The  more  effort  exerted,  the  higher  the  involvement.  

There  are  three  levels  of  involvement:  

1. High  Involvement:  the  type  of  problem  solving  involved  when  a  need  is  completely  new  or  very  important  to  a  consumer  and  much  effort  is  taken  to  decide  how  to  satisfy  the  need.  

2. Limited  Involvement:  when  a  consumer  is  willing  to  put  a  moderate  amount  of  effort  into  deciding  the  best  way  to  satisfy  a  need.  

3. Low  Involvement:  when  little  time  and  effort  is  put  into  making  the  purchase  because  the  purchases  do  not  have  high  personal  importance  or  relevance  for  the  customer.  These  include  frequently  purchased,  low-­‐cost  goods  and  services.  

Involvement  tends  to  be  greater  under  any  of  the  following  conditions:  

• The  consumer  has  no  previous  experience  with  the  product  or  the  consumer  lacks  information  about  the  purchase.  

• The  product  is  viewed  as  important  or  there  is  a  high  level  of  interest.  • The  risk  of  making  a  bad  decision  is  perceived  as  high.  • Circumstances  may  change  a  low-­‐involvement  situation  to  a  high-­‐involvement  one.  • Social  visibility  of  the  product  is  high.  

It  is  important  to  remember  that  involvement  is  consumer  related  and  not  product  related.  This  means  that  a  low-­‐involvement  product  for  one  person  may  be  a  high-­‐involvement  product  for  another  person.  

Hospitality  firms  must  respond  at  this  stage  of  the  consumer  purchase  process  by  recognizing  the  importance  of  latent  needs  such  as  Check-­‐in/Check-­‐out  and  children's  programs  in  hotels.  

3.  Identification  of  alternatives  or  information  search  

What  choices  does  a  consumer  have,  how  willing  are  they  to  look  for  more  choices,  what  is  the  consideration  set  that  comes  out  of  their  initial  thinking?    

Page 11: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

11  

Identification  of  alternatives  includes  both  product  and  brand  alternatives.  This  may  be  as  simple  as  a  memory  scan  (internal  information  search)  or  an  extensive  search  (external  information  search).  

1. The  consumer  must  first  identify  which  product  categories  might  satisfy  the  experienced  need.  For  example,  a  need  for  lodging  may  be  satisfied  by  tents,  youth  hostels,  hotels  and  campers.  

2. Then  the  consumer  must  choose  which  brands  from  the  selected  category  to  consider.  Using  the  previous  example,  the  consumer  chooses  hotels  and  now  must  consider  Radisson,  Four  Seasons,  Holiday  Inn,  Ritz-­‐Carlton,  etc.  

The  search  for  alternatives  will  be  influenced  by:  

• How  much  information  the  consumer  already  has  from  past  experiences  and  other  sources.  There  are  two  sources  of  information:    

o The  commercial  environment,  which  includes  all  marketing,  organizations,  and  individuals  who  attempt  to  communicate  with  consumers.  This  includes:    

§ Advertising:  the  most  common  type  of  information  used  in  the  commercial  environment  

§ Direct  sales  effort  by  salespeople  and  package  information  o The  social  environment,  which  includes  family,  friends,  and  acquaintances  who  

provide  information  directly  or  indirectly  about  products.    § Commonly  communicated  through  word-­‐of-­‐mouth.  § Can  include  observation  of  others  using  products  and  exposure  to  

products  in  the  homes  of  others.  § Can  include  the  content  written  by  product  users  and  left  on  independent  

websites.  • The  consumer's  confidence  in  the  information  already  held.  • What  the  time  and  money  costs  would  be  to  collect  more  information  offset  against  the  

benefits  of  collecting  additional  knowledge.  

The  search  for  information  yields  an  evoked  set  (also  called  a  consideration  set)–a  limited  group  of  product  categories  or  brands  which  buyers  believe  will  satisfy  their  needs.  If  a  particular  product  category  or  brand  does  not  appear  in  the  consumers'  evoked  sets,  the  product  or  brand  has  no  chance  of  being  selected  for  purchase.  

4.  Evaluation  of  alternatives  

How  does  the  consumer  compare  the  items  within  their  consideration  set?    

Evaluation  of  alternatives  involves  establishing  criteria  with  which  to  evaluate  each  alternative  before  making  a  decision.  

Page 12: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

12  

• Consumers  often  set  minimum  or  maximum  levels  of  an  attribute  (cutoff  points)  that  determine  whether  a  product  will  be  considered  as  a  viable  choice.  

• Adding  new  brands  to  an  evoked  set  affects  the  consumer  evaluation  of  the  existing  brands  in  that  set.  

• A  wide  variety  of  factors  influence  how  a  consumer  evaluates  the  choices  and  how  quickly  he  or  she  makes  a  decision.  

• User  generated  content  on  independent  websites,  such  as  Trip  Advisor,  have  been  found  to  have  a  powerful  influence  on  consumer  evaluations.  

• An  evaluation  of  alternatives  may  or  may  not  result  in  a  purchase.  

5.  Purchase  decision  

Influenced  by  mood,  convenience,  affordability,  and  a  host  of  other  items,  consumers  make  their  choices.  

The  purchase  decisions  are  a  series  of  related  decisions  consumers  must  make  if  they  decide  to  make  a  purchase.  These  decisions  may  take  a  long  time  and  include  such  things  as:  

• Specific  features  of  the  product  • Where  and  when  to  make  the  actual  purchase  • Method  of  payment  

Purchase  decisions  may  also  be  influenced  by  the  consumers'  states  and  moods.  For  example:  

• If  you  are  hungry,  you  may  stop  at  a  fast  food  restaurant  you  would  not  otherwise  visit.  • When  you  are  shopping  during  the  holidays,  you  may  be  in  a  festive  mood  and  spend  

more  on  presents  than  you  had  originally  intended.  

6.  Post-­‐purchase  behavior  

Either  falling  into  the  categories  of  customer  satisfaction  or  post-­‐purchase  dissonance,  this  is  the  piece  of  the  experience  where  the  possibility  of  a  repeat  sale  is  also  evaluated.  

Post-­‐purchase  behavior  can  influence  repeat  sales  and  what  the  buyers  tell  others  about  the  product.  Marketers  can  improve  their  marketing  mix  through  learning  what  the  consumers  know  and  how  they  feel  after  the  purchase.  Such  feelings  generally  fall  into  one  of  two  categories:  customer  satisfaction  and  post-­‐purchase  dissonance.  

• Customer  satisfaction  is  based  upon  a  comparison  between  the  consumers'  expectations  before  using  a  product  and  their  actual  experience  with  the  product.    

o A  consumer  is  satisfied  when  the  product  experience  equals  or  exceeds  expectations.  

o A  consumer  is  dissatisfied  when  the  experience  falls  short  of  expectations.  This  feeling  also  leads  to  post-­‐purchase  dissonance.  

Page 13: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

13  

o Marketers  can  influence  consumers'  expectations  through  advertising  claims  and  sales  presentations.  

   Transcript: Factors Influencing The Buying Process

In  this  presentation,  learn  about  several  factors  that  influence  the  buying  process.  

Social/Interpersonal      

The  external  social  forces  around  us  affect  our  individual  buying  decisions.  

These  forces  include:  

• Cultural  influences  • Reference  groups  • The  family  and  household  • Class  influences  • Social  networks  

For  more  information,  see  the  resource  page  title  "More  About  Factors  Influencing  the  Buying  Process."  

Psychological      

Individual  psychological  factors  that  influence  consumer  buying  decisions  include:  

• Motivation  • Perception  • Learning  • Values,  beliefs,  and  attitudes  • Personality  • Self-­‐concept  • Lifestyle  

For  more  information,  see  the  resource  page  title  "More  About  Factors  Influencing  the  Buying  Process."  

Page 14: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

14  

Situational      

Consumption  Situation  

Consumer  needs  and  brand  preferences  are  likely  to  vary  depending  on  the  consumption  situation.  For  example,  a  consumer  might  prefer  a  decaffeinated  coffee  before  going  to  sleep,  but  regular  coffee  in  the  morning.  

Purchase  Situation  

Consumer  needs  and  preferences  are  also  likely  to  vary  depending  on  the  purchase  situation.  For  example,  a  consumer  might  prefer  a  particular  type  of  wine  to  give  someone  as  a  gift,  but  another  type  for  home  consumption.  

Time  Dimension  

Purchase  decisions  are  also  influenced  by  when  a  consumer  is  most  likely  to  purchase  a  particular  product.  For  example,  a  consumer  might  find  a  beer  enjoyable  after  an  afternoon  of  golfing,  but  likely  would  not  consider  consuming  a  beer  prior  to  meeting  for  a  7:00  a.m.  tee  time.  

Physical  and  Social  Surroundings  

Consumer's  purchase  preferences  also  are  likely  to  change  depending  on  his  or  her  physical  and  social  surroundings.  For  example,  a  consumer  may  spend  rather  freely  on  t-­‐shirts  and  refreshments  at  a  sold-­‐out  rock  concert,  but  refuse  to  linger  in  a  bar  where  he  or  she  is  the  only  patron.  

   Transcript: More about Social/Interpersonal and Psychological Factors Influencing Buying Behavior

Cultural  influences  

Cultural  influences  include  the  values,  beliefs,  preferences,  and  tastes  created  by  a  given  society  and  handed  down  from  generation  to  generation.  

• The  culture  may  influence  how  needs  are  satisfied.  For  example,  in  some  cultures,  the  consumption  of  certain  insects  is  a  normal  means  of  satisfying  hunger,  but  this  would  not  be  an  acceptable  method  of  satiation  in  other  cultures.  

Page 15: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

15  

• Subcultures  are  groups  that  exhibit  characteristic  behavior  patterns  sufficient  to  distinguish  them  from  other  groups  within  the  same  culture.  A  subculture  is  important  if  specific  purchasing  patterns  can  be  traced  to  it.  

Reference  groups  

Consumers  may  use  products  to  establish  identity  with  a  group  or  to  gain  membership  into  it.  Consumers  are  more  likely  to  be  influenced  by  word-­‐of-­‐mouth  information  from  reference  group  members  than  by  advertising  or  salespeople.  

The  family  and  household  

The  family  is  the  most  important  social  institution  for  many  consumers,  strongly  influencing  the  values,  attitudes,  self-­‐concept,  and  socialization  process  of  its  members.  Knowing  which  family  member  is  likely  to  make  the  purchase  decision  will  influence  a  firm's  marketing  mix.  

Marketers  are  also  interested  in  considering  the  buying  behavior  of  the  household  as  a  unit:  

• Who  influences  the  buying  decision?  • Who  makes  the  buying  decision?  • Who  makes  the  actual  purchase?  • Who  uses  the  product?  

Class  influences  

Buying  behavior  is  often  strongly  influenced  by  social  and/or  economic  classes.  Marketers  use  a  classification  scheme  to  help  them  categorize  class  influences.  One  such  scheme  in  the  United  States  identifies  the  following  five  classes,  within  each  of  which  are  opinion  leaders  who  serve  as  information  resources:  

1. Upper  class    o 2%  of  total  population  o Socially  prominent  old  families  and  the  newly  rich  o Live  in  large  homes  in  exclusive  neighborhoods  o Buy  expensive  products,  patronize  fancy  shops  

2. Upper-­‐middle  class    o 11%  of  the  total  population  o Successful  business  and  professional  people  o Well-­‐educated,  have  a  strong  desire  for  success,  and  push  their  children  to  do  

well  o Buy  products  that  signify  status,  belong  to  private  clubs,  and  support  the  arts  

and  various  social  causes  3. Lower-­‐middle  class    

o 36%  of  the  population  

Page 16: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

16  

o Strive  for  respectability,  are  future  oriented,  and  are  willing  to  take  risks  o Have  well-­‐cared-­‐for  homes,  save  money  to  send  their  children  to  college,  and  

buy  products  that  are  popular  4. Upper-­‐lower  class    

o 38%  of  the  population  o Clerical  and  blue-­‐collar  working  class  o Tied  closely  to  family  for  support,  have  a  local  orientation,  clearly  defined  male-­‐

female  roles,  and  are  concerned  about  security  o Live  in  smaller  homes,  drive  larger  cars,  watch  bigger  television  sets,  and  buy  

American  products  5. Lower-­‐lower  class    

o 13%  of  the  population  o Unskilled  workers,  the  chronically  unemployed,  unassimilated  immigrants,  and  

people  on  welfare  o Poorly  educated,  live  in  substandard  housing,  have  low  income  

Social  networks  

Social  networks  are  made  of  individuals  which  are  linked  by  friendship,  relationships,  or  common  interests.  Today,  these  networks  may  be  Internet-­‐based  and  include  individuals  that  the  consumer  has  never  met  in  person.  

Psychological  factors  

Psychological  factors  that  influence  consumer  buying  decisions  include:  

• Motivation:  the  result  of  a  need  sufficiently  stimulated  so  that  an  individual  is  moved  to  seek  satisfaction.  

• Perception:  a  process  of  coloring  and  processing  information  from  the  environment  through  our  five  senses.  Perception  plays  a  major  role  in  the  stage  of  the  buying-­‐decision  process  that  involves  identifying  alternatives.  The  nature  of  perception  requires  marketers  to  keep  their  messages  simple,  repeat  them  often,  and  conduct  research  to  see  if  the  messages  have  been  received  and  interpreted  as  intended.  

• Learning:  changes  in  behavior  resulting  from  previous  experiences.  Learning  plays  a  part  in  every  stage  of  the  buying  process.  Marketers  use  several  strategies  designed  to  fit  the  way  people  learn,  including:    

o Repetition,  in  which  marketing  messages  are  spread  over  time  o Family  branding—an  example  of  stimulus  generalization  in  which  different  

products  are  offered  under  the  same  brand  name  (Courtyard  by  Marriott,  Residence  Inn  by  Marriott,  Marriott  Marquis,  etc.)  

Page 17: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

17  

Values,  beliefs,  and  attitudes  

• Values  are  enduring  beliefs  that  a  specific  mode  of  conduct  is  personally  or  socially  preferable  to  another  mode  of  conduct.  Customers  with  similar  value  systems  tend  to  react  alike  to  prices  and  other  marketing-­‐related  inducements.  

• Beliefs  are  organized  patterns  of  knowledge  that  an  individual  holds  as  true  about  his  or  her  world.  Consumers  tend  to  develop  a  set  of  beliefs  about  a  product's  attributes  and  then,  through  these  beliefs,  form  a  brand  image—a  set  of  beliefs  about  a  particular  brand.  

• Attitudes  are  learned  predispositions  to  respond  to  an  object  or  class  of  objects  in  a  consistently  favorable  or  unfavorable  way.  Attitudes  do  not  always  predict  purchase  behavior,  but  they  play  a  major  role  in  the  evaluation  of  alternatives.  

• Personality  is  a  way  of  organizing  and  grouping  the  consistencies  of  an  individual's  reactions  to  situations.  

• Self-­‐concept  is  how  a  consumer  perceives  himself  or  herself  in  terms  of  attitudes,  perceptions,  beliefs,  and  self-­‐evaluations.  For  example,  a  consumer  who  perceives  himself  as  extremely  religious  may  make  purchase  decisions  based  on  this  perceived  religiousness.  

• Lifestyle  is  a  person's  mode  of  living  as  identified  by  activities,  interests,  and  opinions.  Psychographics  is  the  analysis  technique  used  to  examine  consumer  lifestyles  and  to  categorize  consumers.  

• Psychographics  have  proved  valuable  in  segmenting  and  targeting  consumers.  

   Transcript: Types of Hospitality Consumers

This  presentation  reviews  categories  of  business  and  leisure  travelers,  an  important  factor  in  creating  a  best-­‐fit  marketing  strategy.  

Types  of  Hospitality  Consumers  

There  are  two  main  types  of  hospitality  consumers:  business  travelers  and  leisure  travelers.  Hospitality  companies  need  to  understand  these  separate  groups  to  analyze  whether  a  high  percentage  of  their  customers  fit  into  one  or  the  other  of  the  profiles.  Understanding  these  groups  help  companies  meet  these  groups'  needs  more  effectively,  or  reach  out  to  new  ones.  The  most  important  lesson  is  "Know  thy  customer."  

A  Profile  of  Business  Travelers  

Without  the  constant  and  steady  income  from  the  business  travel  market,  hotels,  airlines,  and  car  rental  companies  would  have  difficulty  effectively  utilizing  their  inventory.  For  many  

Page 18: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

18  

segments  of  the  hospitality  industry,  this  is  their  bread  and  butter,  and  serving  their  needs  effectively  is  vital.  

In  general  the  business  traveler:  

• Wants  "an  office  away  from  the  office"  • Is  looking  for  enhanced  productivity  from  both  the  trip  and  the  time  spent  on  the  trip  • Thinks  technology  like  telecommuting,  web  conferencing,  online  meetings,  and  

videoconferencing  will  reduce  business  travel  in  the  future  • Prefers  full-­‐service  hotels,  airlines,  and  car  rental  companies  with  moderate  prices  • Tries  to  negotiate  best  rates.  

Business  Traveler  Preferences  

Business  travelers  have  also  shown  several  factors  that  influence  their  buying  habits:  

• They  tend  to  prefer  hotels  and  airlines  that  suggest  a  high  degree  of  prestige.  • They  are  more  likely  to  avoid  bargain-­‐basement  lodging  and  low  cost  carriers  when  they  

can.  • They  like  well-­‐known  brand  names.  

And  their  previous  experience  with  the  hospitality  product  is  also  important,  including  the  elements  of  

• Location  • Reputation  • Recommendations  of  friends/associates  • Price.  

Befitting  their  status,  senior  executives  will  generally  expect  to  stay  in  luxury  or  upscale  hotels  with  high  levels  of  service,  as  well  as  utilize  first-­‐class  airline  service  and  other  high-­‐end  hospitality  services,  while  traveling.  On  the  other  hand,  salespeople  may  stay  in  mid-­‐scale  or  even  budget  hotels  and  utilize  low-­‐cost  carriers.  

Leisure  Travelers  

Whereas  business  travelers  often  make  up  the  bulk  of  a  hotel's  midweek  business,  leisure  and  tourist  travelers  fill  the  rooms  on  weekends.  Leisure  travelers  come  in  four  types  but  there  may  be  some  overlap  among  these  groups:  

• Package  travelers  • Mature  travelers  • International  travelers  • Free  independent  travelers  

Page 19: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

19  

Package  Market  

Package  consumers  purchase  a  combination  of  rooms  and  amenities  for  an  inclusive  price.  

The  advantages  of  packages  include:  

• Low  price  • The  bundling  of  services  that  are  not  normally  purchased,  such  as  guided  itineraries  • The  fact  that  everything  is  pre-­‐planned  and  pre-­‐arranged  

Mature  Travelers  

Usually  over  55  years  of  age,  mature  travelers  are  a  force  simply  because  of  the  sheer  numbers  of  them  on  the  road.  They  tend  to  travel  extensively,  sometimes  favoring  travel  parties  or  tours.  Unlike  other  classifications,  the  mature  traveler  is  not  a  homogeneous  group.  And  finally,  they  are  a  group  of  consumers  looking  for  value  in  their  purchases.  

International  Travelers  

400  million  people  travel  outside  their  home  country  every  year,  and  international  travelers  account  for  25%  of  the  annual  tourist  spending  in  the  U.S.  As  a  group  they  tend  to  use  intermediaries  in  their  planning,  such  as  consortiums,  referral  networks,  and  tour  operators.  

Free  Independent  Travelers  

Free  independent  travelers  are  best  characterized  as  younger  travelers  or  those  with  more  travel  experience,  who  do  their  own  planning  and  make  up  their  own  itineraries.  

It  is  important  to  understand  that  these  categories  can  overlap,  and  that  different  cross  sections  of  people  and  groups  require  different  marketing  strategies  to  serve  them  effectively.  

   Transcript: Ask the Industry Expert: Implementing Market Segmentation Strategies

Why  is  market  segmentation  important?  

Ultimately,  market  segmentation  allows  you  to  differentiate  your  markets,  because  one  can't  be  all  things  to  all  people.  It  allows  you  to  focus  your  sales  and  marketing  efforts  on  those  customers,  or  those  customer  segments,  that  are  uniquely  most  likely  to  buy  your  product  or  your  service.  Also,  from  a  financial  perspective,  it  allows  you  to  optimize  your  return  on  investment,  because  we  are  all  very  focused  on  return  on  investment.  You  want  to  spend  the  

Page 20: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

20  

most  appropriate  marketing  dollars  against  the  most  appropriate  customer.  Ultimately,  the  best  segmentation  matches  the  right  product,  with  the  right  customer,  at  the  right  price  point.  And  then  finally,  it  allows  you  to  capitalize  on  diverse  market  needs.  You  certainly  don't  want  to  put  all  your  eggs  in  one  basket,  and  most  times,  one  segment  for  either  a  lodging  or  a  hospitality  business  is  not  sufficient  to  optimize  revenues  and  profits,  therefore,  you  have  to  segment  your  market.  

How  should  you  choose  the  criteria  that  are  important  for  successful  market  segmentation?  

By  focusing  on  the  individual  needs  of  a  customer,  you  will  focus  on  the  criteria  that  are  most  important  to  that  particular  customer  segment.  You  have  to  understand  the  value  proposition  of  your  product  and  service  based  on  the  needs  of  the  customer.  That  value  proposition,  in  many  ways,  is  based  on  the  demographics  of  individual  market  segments.  Is  it  a  specific  industry  type  that  you  are  interested  in,  a  specific  psychographic  of  an  individual,  or  particular  demographics  based  on  geography,  median  income,  or  other  specific  criteria?  You  also  want  to  focus  on  low-­‐cost  items  that  have  the  highest  impact  to  optimize  your  return  on  investment.  So,  ultimately,  the  criteria  is  going  to  help  you  capitalize  on  those  customer  segments  that  have  the  greatest  need  for  your  product  and  service,  and  also  yield  the  greatest  value  from  the  strengths  that  you  offer  a  particular  market.  

How  do  you  decide  which  segment  should  be  selected?  

Sometimes,  the  segments  that  you  are  going  to  focus  on  have  actually  been  pre-­‐selected  for  you  based  on  the  purpose-­‐built  nature  of  your  particular  product.  For  example,  with  the  Ritz-­‐Carlton  Hotel  Company,  we're  currently  building  two  luxury  hotels  in  the  market  of  New  York,  each  specifically  designed  to  serve  a  different  segment.  The  Ritz-­‐Carlton  on  Central  Park  South  will  be  focusing  on  high-­‐end  European  and  boutique-­‐style  travelers,  whereas  the  Ritz-­‐Carlton  in  Battery  Park  in  downtown  Manhattan  will  be  focused  on  the  Financial  District  business  traveler  and  small  meetings  and  conventions.  

Ultimately,  when  deciding  which  segment  you  should  be  selecting,  you  should  be  focusing  on  where  your  history  of  success  has  brought  you  the  greatest  return  on  investment,  where  you  have  made  previous  investments  with  customers  who  are  both  familiar  and  have  a  need  for  your  product  and  service,  and  then  ultimately,  determine  which  segment  is  going  to  bring  you  the  greatest  return  on  investment,  and  from  that  particular  investment,  which  sub-­‐segments  will  also  bring  you  additional  revenues  and  profits.  For  example,  if  you  were  planning  on  focusing  on  the  group  or  meetings  segment,  then  you  should  understand  which  sub-­‐segment,  which  in  the  meetings  world,  will  bring  you  the  greatest  yield.  Is  it  the  association  groups,  is  it  the  corporate  groups,  or  is  it  the  individual,  local,  small,  social  meetings  that  happen  in  the  individual  neighborhoods?  

Page 21: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

21  

How  should  you  use  segment-­‐of-­‐one  marketing?  

Segment-­‐of-­‐one  marketing  is  very,  very  powerful  due  to  the  unique  buying  habits  and  needs  of  individual  guests.  In  fact,  there  is  no  need  for  segmentation  if  all  people  have  all  the  exact  same  needs.  So,  the  segment-­‐of-­‐one  marketing  allows  you  to  tailor  your  message,  ultimately,  to  the  specific  requirements  of  an  individual  or  group  of  individuals.  It  also  allows  you  to  tailor  the  relevancy  and  frequency  of  your  messaging  based  on  those  unique  customer  needs.  It  in  turn  allows  you  to  mass  customize,  whether  it  is  on-­‐going  communications,  whether  it  is  the  product  and  service  you  are  delivering  to  groups  of  customers,  or  ultimately,  it  is  the  way  in  which  you  communicate  that  message.  

   Transcript: Factors Involved in and Environmental Analysis

Just  like  scientists  in  a  laboratory,  market  researchers  use  an  environment  analysis  to  evaluate  key  environmental  trends  and  to  identify  a  potential  competitive  advantage  in  connection  with  a  business  venture.  In  our  laboratory  metaphor,  the  business  venture  serves  as  the  catalyst  for  the  analytical  process,  the  result  of  which  is  the  competitive  advantage.  

Sociocultural  environment  

The  relationship  between  marketing  and  society  and  its  culture.  This  relationship  includes  the  values  and  lifestyles  of  a  population,  while  at  the  same  time  affecting  how  and  why  people  live  and  behave  as  they  do.  Examples  of  sociocultural  trends  include:  

• Americans  are  interested  in  eating  low-­‐fat  foods  yet  indulging  in  sweets.  • Many  Americans  are  more  health-­‐conscious,  seeking  an  improved  diet,  opportunities  to  

exercise.  • Nonsmokers  have  become  more  aggressive  in  demanding  smoke-­‐free  environments.  • Devices  that  save  time  and  tools  to  aid  in  relaxation  and  sleep  have  increased  in  

popularity  because  of  a  poverty  of  time.  • Americans  increasingly  dine  out  and  desire  ethnic  foods.  

Demographic  environment  

The  examination  of  the  human  population.  Marketers  often  use  the  RAGE  matrix  (Race/ethnicity,  Age,  Gender,  and  Education)  as  basis  for  demographic  analysis.  Other  factors  include:  

• Income  • Population  size  • Geographical  dispersion  

Page 22: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

22  

• Occupation  • Religion  • Sexual  orientation  

Demographics  are  often  key  variables  for  determining  market  segments  and  their  related  strategies.  

Economic  Environment  

The  conditions  that  will  affect  the  amount  of  money  that  the  people  in  a  market  have  as  well  as  their  willingness  to  spend  it.  The  primary  economic  factors  are:  

The  Business  Cycle    

• Consists  of  four  stages:  prosperity,  recession,  depression,  and  recovery  • During  prosperity,  businesses  tend  to  expand  and  marketers  benefit  by  introducing  

luxury,  high-­‐priced  products  that  target  consumers  with  rising  discretionary  income.  • During  recessions,  businesses  tend  to  retrench  and  marketers  focus  on  developing  

"value"  products  that  provide  standard  utility  at  lower  prices.  In  a  recession,  dining  out,  entertainment,  and  travel  are  the  first  things  consumers  cut  from  their  budgets.  

• During  depressions,  businesses  reduce  staffing  and  cut  all  expenses.  Many  businesses  may  close,  at  least  temporarily.  The  goal  is  to  remain  viable  until  the  economy  improves.  

• During  recovery,  the  challenge  is  to  determine  when  prosperity  will  return  and  at  what  level.  

Inflation    

• A  rise  in  price  levels.  If  prices  rise  faster  than  personal  income,  consumer  buying  power  declines.  

• Inflation  causes  consumers  to  be  less  brand  loyal,  search  for  the  lowest  price,  seek  promotions,  use  coupons,  and  stock  up  on  sale  items.  

Interest  rates    

• When  interest  rates  are  high,  consumers  and  businesses  tend  to  hold  back  on  purchases—especially  those  that  require  long-­‐term  payments,  such  as  buildings,  homes,  and  cars.  

• High  interest  rates  discourage  the  development  of  new  hospitality  products,  new  additions  or  even  costly  renovations.  

Unemployment    

• A  situation  in  which  people  who  do  not  have  jobs  are  actively  looking  for  work.  

Page 23: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

23  

• When  unemployment  is  especially  low,  service  firms  may  have  difficulty  finding  employees  for  their  lower  paying  positions.  

Income    

• Personal  income  influences  consumer  buying  power.  

Technological  Environment  

The  application  to  marketing  of  knowledge  based  on  discoveries  in  science,  inventions,  and  innovations,  can  be  put  into  one  of  five  classifications:  

• Energy  • Materials  • Transportation  • Communications  and  information  • Genetic  

Major  technological  breakthroughs—such  as  the  Internet  and  nano-­‐tecnology—can  impact  the  economy  in  two  ways:  

• Start  entirely  new  industries  • Radically  alter  existing  industries  

For  example,  technology  is  revolutionizing  the  hospitality  industry:  

• Computerized  restaurant  ordering  • Automated  check-­‐in/check-­‐out  • Web-­‐based  reservation  systems  • Faxes  • Email  • Guest  rooms  set  up  for  computers/modems/Wi-­‐Fi  and  touch-­‐screens  • Use  of  avatars  to  replace  employees  in  redundant  tasks  

Technology  has  a  tremendous  impact  on  life-­‐styles,  consumption  patterns,  and  the  economy.  For  example,  the  ability  of  today's  business  person  to  simultaneously  and  instantaneously  transmit  and  share  voice,  pictures,  and  graphics  all  over  the  world  should  reduce  business  travel  as  such  technology  becomes  more  common  place.  

Technology  also  has  the  potential  to  increase  output  and  capital.  Managers  can  forecast  trends  in  the  technological  environment  by  constantly  screening  patent  applications  related  to  the  industry.  

Page 24: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

24  

Political  and  Legal  Environment  

Environment,  legal  and  regulatory  trends  affect  marketing  opportunities  because  they  define  the  governmental  constraints  to  which  companies  are  subject.  There  are  six  general  categories  of  their  influence:  

1.  General  monetary  and  fiscal  policies  affecting  government  spending,  the  money  supply,  and  tax  legislation  

For  example,  tax  laws  may  affect  how  much  a  business  may  deduct  for  business  entertainment  and  meals,  and  this  legislation,  in  turn,  can  negatively  affect  upscale  restaurant  businesses.  

2.  Social  legislation  and  policies,  such  as  civil  rights  laws,  unemployment  laws,  and  antipollution  laws  

For  example,  the  American  Disability  Act  had  a  big  influence  on  how  hotel  rooms  are  being  designed.  

3.  Government  relationships  with  individual  industries  

These  relationships  can  manifest  themselves  in  the  form  of  subsidies,  tariffs,  import  quotas,  and  deregulation  of  industries.  In  turn,  this  type  of  legislation  can  affect  the  cost  of  goods  and  services  needed  for  hospitality  operations.  

4.  Specific  legislation  that  affects  marketing  

Such  laws  fall  into  two  main  groups:  those  designed  to  regulate  and  maintain  competition,  and  those  intended  to  protect  the  consumer.  The  three  regulatory  agencies  most  directly  involved  in  marketing  include:  

• The  Consumer  Product  Safety  Commission,  which  mandates  safety  standards  for  products.  It  can  ban  products,  recall  them,  fine  firms,  and  sentence  company  officers  to  prison.  

• The  Federal  Trade  Commission,  which  prohibits  unfair  methods  of  competition  • The  Food  and  Drug  Administration,  which  enforces  regulations  concerning  food  and  

drug  products.  In  recent  years,  hospitality  businesses  have  paid  close  attention  to  policies  created  by  the  U.S.  Department  of  Labor,  as  well  as  legislation  proposed  by  the  House  Committee  on  Energy  and  Commerce  and  the  Senate  Committee  on  Energy  and  Natural  Resources,  because  of  their  impact  on  the  industry  as  a  whole.  

5.  Provision  of  information  and  purchaser  of  products  

The  government  is  the  largest  supplier  of  secondary  marketing  information,  as  well  as  being  the  largest  single  buyer  of  products.  Through  government  documents  and  statistical  abstracts,  

Page 25: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

25  

marketers  can  obtain  much  of  the  data  they  need  to  determine  the  appropriate  market  segmentation  strategies.  For  example,  census  data  can  be  a  great  source  for  predicting  consumer  trends.  At  the  same  time,  the  government  is  a  major  purchaser  of  hospitality  products,  especially  room  nights.  For  this  reason,  many  hotel  chains  offer  special  government  rates.  

6.  Political  trends  in  foreign  countries  

In  today's  global  economy,  the  political  activities  occurring  in  foreign  countries  have  a  significant  effect  on  the  US  economy  and  US  businesses,  including  the  hospitality  industry.  For  example:  

• An  increase  in  terrorism,  regardless  of  where,  has  an  effect  on  travelers,  especially  leisure  travelers.  

• War  in  the  Middle  East  jeopardizes  oil  supplies  and  increases  energy  costs.  

Competitive  Environment  

Comprises  the  number,  types,  and  behavior  of  competitors  the  marketing  manager  must  face.  The  competitive  environment  operates  along  a  continuum  ranging  from  pure  competition  to  monopoly.  A  manager  must  identify  the  position  along  this  continuum  in  which  his  business  operates  in  order  to  develop  appropriate  competitive  strategies.  

Key  points  along  the  continuum  are:  

Pure  Competition:  

A  market  situation  that  develops  when  a  market  has:  

• Relatively  homogeneous  products  • Many  buyers  and  sellers  who  have  full  knowledge  of  the  market  • Ease  of  entry  for  buyers  and  sellers  

In  this  market,  demand  is  flat  for  each  individual  producer,  so  all  producers  must  set  their  price  at  the  equilibrium  price  in  order  to  sell  any  product.  An  individual  producer  has  little  or  no  impact  on  the  market.  

Oligopoly:  

A  small  number  of  firms  dominate  the  market.  Develops  when  a  market  has:  

• Essentially  homogeneous  products  • Relatively  few  sellers  • Fairly  inelastic  industry  demand  curves  

Page 26: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

26  

• Difficulty  of  entry  for  sellers  

In  an  oligopolistic  situation,  competitors  follow  each  other  in  their  marketing  strategies,  including  price.  

Monopolistic  competition:  

A  large  number  of  suppliers  offer  similar  products.  Develops  when:  

• A  market  has  many  buyers  and  sellers  • Each  firm  has  a  comparatively  small  percentage  of  the  total  market  • The  sellers  offer  different  products  at  a  range  of  prices  based  on  quality,  attributes,  or  

service  • Sellers  use  marketing  strategies  such  as  branding,  advertising,  promotions,  and  personal  

selling  to  convey  product  differences  to  buyers  • Buyers  recognize  differences  in  products  and  are  willing  to  pay  different  prices  

The  majority  of  the  hospitality  industry  operates  under  conditions  of  monopolistic  competition.  

Monopoly:  

A  market  situation  in  which  one  firm  dominates  and  controls  the  total  market.  

Marketers  should  be  aware  of  three  major  sources  of  competition:  

• Brand  competition:  from  marketers  of  directly  similar  products.  • Substitute  competition:  from  marketers  of  products  that  are  not  directly  the  same  but  

do  satisfy  the  same  needs  • General  competition:  from  marketers  of  all  products  competing  for  the  customers'  

limited  buying  power  

Ecological  Environment  

Marketers  must  evaluate  the  impact  of  their  product  on  quality  of  life.  This  evaluation  must  include:  consideration  of  employment  in  their  target  community;  the  effects  of  air,  water,  and  cultural  pollution;  and  the  potential  depletion  of  natural  resources.  Organizations  may  implement  programs  designed  to  minimize  or  even  enhance  the  ecological  impact  of  their  business.  For  example:  

• Six  Senses  requires  all  its  properties  to  follow  stringent  sustainable  environmental  guidelines,  including  water  conservation,  recycling,  utilization  of  low  energy  lighting,  and  protection  of  local  cultures.  

Page 27: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

27  

• The  Heritance  Kandalama  Hotel  in  Sri  Lanka  is  famous  for  its  rigorous  practice  of  the  7Rs  (regulate,  reduce,  reuse,  recycle,  recover,  renovate,  rethink),  which  has  resulted  in  no  waste.  

   Transcript: Conducting an Environmental Analysis

When  constructing  an  environmental  analysis,  marketers  should  consider  the  following  elements.  

Sociocultural  

• How  is  the  consumer's  orientation  towards  time  changing?  • What  are  the  standards  for  quality?  Are  they  changing?  • How  important  are  health  concerns  becoming?  Will  this  be  changing?  • What  are  the  trends  toward  home-­‐centeredness?  • What  are  the  personal  finance  trends  that  are  occurring?  • What  are  the  trends  in  lifestyle  diversity?  Social    

diversity?  • What  are  travel  trends?  Who  is  traveling?  

Demographic  

• What  demographic  groups  are  on  the  rise  domestically?  Internationally?  • What  is  the  population  growth  rate  domestically?  In  key  foreign  markets?  • What  key  subcultures  are  emerging?  • What  are  the  religious  trends  domestically?  In  key  foreign  markets?  • What  are  the  occupational  trends  domestically?  In  key  foreign  markets?  • What  are  the  educational  trends  domestically?  In  key  foreign  markets?  • What  are  the  trends  in  income  domestically?  In  key  foreign  markets?  Is  real  growth  in  

income  occurring?  

Economic  

• What  fiscal  and  monetary  measures  are  being  developed  domestically?  Internationally?  • What  regulation  and  management  of  the  economy  is  being  used  domestically?  

Internationally?  • In  what  stage  of  the  business  cycle  (prosperity,  recession,  depression,  recovery)  is  your  

domestic  country?  In  what  stage  are  other  key  powers?  • What  is  happening  with  world  food  production?  • Is  real  world  growth  rising,  stable,  or  declining?  • What  is  the  inflation  rate  domestically?  Internationally?  

Page 28: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

28  

• What  are  the  prevailing  views  about  free  trade?  • What  are  the  key  economic  indicators,  such  as  employment,  consumer  price  index,  

housing  starts,  auto  sales,  weekly  unemployment  claims,  GNP,  savings  rate,  money  supply,  and  retail  sales?  

Technological  

• What  new  technologies  are  available  in  the  areas  of  energy,  materials,  transportation,  communications  and  transportation,  and  genetic  (affecting  food  sources)?  How  important  are  these  technologies  to  the  hospitality  industry  now?  Five  years  from  now?  

• What  impact  will  these  technological  advances  have  on  the  hospitality  industry?  • What  technological  advances  will  create  a  competitive  advantage?  

Which  technologies  should  be  adopted  now,  which  are  still  emerging?  • Which  technologies  are  becoming  obsolete?  • What  technologies  are  already  common  among  your  competitors?  

Political  /  Legal  

• How  stable  is  your  domestic  government?  What  are  the  chances  of  revolution?  • What  are  the  economic  interests  of  the  domestic  government?  • How  dependent  is  your  government  on  foreign  capital?  • What  world  conflict  exists,  or  is  likely  to  occur?  How  will  it  impact  your  business?  

What  are  the  political  trends  elsewhere?  • What  are  the  chances  of  political  terrorism  in  your  domestic  country?  What  political  

terrorism  in  other  countries  may  affect  your  business?  • What  nations  are  gaining  political  power?  • What  revolutionary  changes  are  occurring  in  other  parts  of  the  world?  • What  government  regulations  are  on  the  horizon  that  may  affect  taxation,  employment  

benefits,  minimum  wage,  labor  laws,  handicap  accessibility,  etc.?  What  are  the  political  trends  in  these  areas  for  the  next  five  years?  

Competitive  

• Who  is  the  competition?  Now?  Five  years  from  now?  • What  are  the  strategies,  objectives  and  goals  of  each  major  competitor?  • How  important  is  a  specific  market  to  each  competitor  and  what  is  the  level  of  its  

commitment?  • What  are  the  relative  strengths  and  limitations  of  each  competitor?  • What  weaknesses  make  competitors  vulnerable?  • What  changes  are  competitors  likely  to  make  in  their  future  strategies?  • What  will  be  the  effects  of  all  competitors'  strategies,  on  the  industry,  the  market,  and  

our  strategy?  

Page 29: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

29  

Source:  Jain,  Subhash  C.  (2000),  Marketing  Planning  &  Strategy,  6th  Edition.  Cincinnati,  OH:  South-­‐Western  College  Publishing,  p.  84-­‐85.  

Ecological  

• What  are  the  trends  toward  environmentalism  domestically?  In  key  markets?  • How  is  ecological  awareness  determining  purchasing  behavior?  • What  ecological  changes  are  affecting  hospitality?  • What  ecological  pressures  on  business  exist  from  society?  From  the  government?  How  

are  these  changing?  

Environmental  Analysis  Resources  

The  Internet  is  an  excellent  source  of  information  on  trends.  Further  research  can  also  be  found  in  publications,  including:  

• UPDATE  magazine  for  latest  technology  information  • American  Demographics  for  demographic  and  socio-­‐cultural  trends  • U.S.  Census  data  for  demographic  and  economic  information—can  be  broken  down  by  

city  or  region  • www.yahoo.com/travel  for  competitive  information  

When  traveling  in  unfamiliar  terrain,  having  the  right  map  in  hand  makes  reaching  your  destination  much  more  likely.  For  a  business,  conducting  a  marketing  environmental  analysis  of  the  current  landscape  is  constructing  the  map  of  where  it  is.  This  map  will  then  help  it  navigate  toward  business  goals.  

   Transcript: Ask the Expert: Using the SWOT Model to Analyze Data

How  does  SWOT  fit  into  the  overall  marketing  process?  

SWOT  stands  for  strengths,  weaknesses,  opportunities,  and  threats.  The  strengths  and  weaknesses  categories  are  based  on  internal  issues,  while  opportunities  and  threats  are  based  on  external  issues.  

SWOT  analysis  is  really  a  decision-­‐making  tool.  Once  you  understand  the  external  environment  from  your  environmental  analysis,  you  can  combine  any  identified  significant  external  opportunities  or  threats  with  an  internal  survey  of  your  organization's  significant  strengths  and  weaknesses.  Thus,  SWOT  provides  a  framework  identifying  and  highlighting  issues  that  are  critical  in  determining  decisions  made  about  your  organization.  

Page 30: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

30  

What  do  I  do  with  it?  

The  goal  of  the  SWOT  analysis  is  to  isolate  the  most  crucial  issues  and  to  facilitate  the  development  of  your  marketing  strategy.  Therefore,  you  will  want  to  keep  the  items  you  list  under  each  SWOT  category  as  simple  and  as  concise  as  possible,  although  a  great  deal  of  research  may  underlie  each  item.  The  SWOT  analysis  will  allow  you  to  get  an  overall  view  of  the  situation  and  to  respond  proactively.  

In  identifying  your  organization's  strengths  and  weaknesses,  try  just  quickly  jotting  down  the  characteristics  of  your  firm.  Then  ask  yourself:  What  distinctive  competencies  does  your  organization  possess?  Are  there  adequate  financial  resources?  Does  your  organization  possess  cost  advantages  or  competitive  advantages?  Is  the  management  team  effective?  Is  the  organization  innovative?  Is  there  a  clear  strategic  direction?  Is  there  strong  profitability?  Good  track  record  in  implementing  strategies?  Is  there  a  strong  market  image  or  strong  marketing  skills?  Do  you  have  strong  operational  skills  or  solid  financial  capitalization?  

In  identifying  opportunities,  use  the  environmental  analysis  to  determine  what  isn't  being  done  to  meet  customer  needs.  Ask  yourself  if  there  are  additional  customer  groups  you  should  be  serving,  or  additional  services  you  should  be  offering?  Is  the  market  growing  rapidly?  Are  competitors  weak?  In  terms  of  threats,  use  the  environmental  analysis  to  identify  trends  that  might  make  your  product  or  service  obsolete.  Also  ask  yourself:  Are  new  competitors  likely  to  enter  the  market?  Are  adverse  regulatory  policies  on  the  horizon?  Is  the  organization  too  dependent  on  one  customer?  Is  the  organization  vulnerable  to  recession?  Are  current  customers'  tastes  and  needs  changing?  Are  there  adverse  demographic  changes  occurring?  

What  are  some  examples  of  typical  strengths  and  weaknesses  in  the  hospitality  industry?  

Strengths  are  the  competitive  advantages  and  unique  selling  propositions  that  the  company  has  the  ability  to  bring  to  the  market  place.  Possible  strengths  in  the  hospitality  industry  include:  

• Low-­‐cost,  high-­‐efficiency  operating  skill  • Leadership  in  product  and  service  innovation  • Efficiency  in  customer  service  • Personal  relationships  with  customers  • Effectiveness  in  sales  promotion  • Convenient,  desirable  location  

You  may  be  able  to  identify  many  more  strengths  within  your  organization.  

Weaknesses  are  factors  that  limit  the  ability  of  the  firm  to  pursue  new  opportunities  or  achieve  new  competitive  advantages.  Examples  of  potential  weaknesses  in  the  hospitality  industry  include:  

• Inadequate  understanding  of  target  market  

Page 31: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

31  

• Ambiguous  service  policies  • Lack  of  quantitative  goals  • Poor  product  design  • Lack  of  product/brand  awareness  • Laggard  in  technology  integration  

Of  course,  there  are  many  others  in  addition  to  these.  

How  do  I  evaluate  the  results?  

To  evaluate  the  results  of  the  SWOT  analysis  consider  Sources  of  Marketing  Opportunity.  There  are  three  sources  of  marketing  opportunity:  unmet  customer  needs,  competitive  weakness,  and  other  environmental  threats.  These  opportunities  are  revealed  in  a  rigorous  environmental  analysis.  Criteria  for  evaluating  opportunities  should  include  both  quantitative  and  qualitative  components  (e.g.,  consumer  needs  and  potential  profitability).  

Also  recognize  that  threats  can  result  in  opportunities.  The  increasing  proportion  of  working  women  was  a  threat  to  Avon  because  they  were  less  likely  to  be  at  home  to  receive  the  Avon  saleslady.  Avon  turned  threat  to  opportunity  by  encouraging  its  salespeople  to  sell  at  the  office,  and  Avon  is  now  beginning  to  open  retail  stores.  

However,  just  as  a  threat  can  be  turned  into  an  opportunity,  the  reverse  is  also  true.  Threats  can  come  in  three  forms:  (1)  the  firm  misreads  customer  needs,  (2)  competitors  introduce  a  similar  or  new  product,  and  (3)  the  firm  fails  to  foresee  environmental  changes  that  render  a  product  entry  obsolete.  

Finally,  remember  that  there  are  no  right  or  wrong  answers  in  a  SWOT  analysis:  like  the  environmental  analysis,  it  is  a  subjective  process  and  open  to  different  interpretations.  However,  it  is  very  important  to  put  some  thought  into  the  SWOT  analysis  because  it  will  serve  as  the  tool  to  guide  the  direction  and  focus  of  future  strategies.  Thus,  you  must  use  the  knowledge  and  expertise  you  have  acquired  through  your  research  to  deftly  define  your  strategic  focus.  Remember,  also,  that  a  SWOT  analysis  is  just  a  snapshot  at  one  point  in  time.  Situations  and  trends  will  change  with  the  passage  of  time.  You  should  routinely  perform  a  SWOT  analysis  and  the  organization  should  be  flexible  enough  to  continuously  adapt  to  opportunities  and  threats  identified  and  to  capitalize  on  the  strengths  of  the  organization  while  seeking  to  improve  the  weaknesses.  

             

Page 32: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

32  

   Transcript: Select a Target Market

A  residential  property  centrally  located  in  the  fictional  college  town  of  Centerville  is  being  converted  into  a  boutique  hotel.  As  part  of  his  initial  market  research,  the  owner  conducted  an  environmental  analysis,  which  produced  the  following  data:  

 Sociocultural  Data  

The  broader  Centerville  area  offers  seven  golf  courses,  including  a  Robert  Trent  Jones  course  located  on  the  State  University  campus.  

• Centerville  is  located  on  a  large  lake,  so  fishing  and  sailing  are  popular  sports  in  the  fall,  spring,  and  summer,  while  snowmobiling  and  cross-­‐country  skiing  are  popular  during  the  winter  months.  

• The  Centerville  area  has  a  number  of  tourist  attractions,  including  scenic  hiking  trails,  wineries,  and  fall  foliage.  

• State  University  provides  a  number  of  events  associated  with  the  performing  arts,  including  plays  and  music  and  dance  recitals.  Community  theatre  is  also  popular  and  Centerville  supports  three  community  theaters.  

• State  University  also  offers  an  art  museum,  and  Centerville  has  a  hands-­‐on  science  museum.  

• Centerville  has  103  restaurants,  ranging  from  cafés  to  fine-­‐dining  establishments.  These  dining  establishments  offer  every  type  of  food  imaginable.  

• Each  year,  Centerville  hosts  an  Apple  Harvest  Festival;  a  Chili  Cook  Off;  the  Centerville  Festival,  to  promote  art  appreciation;  and  the  Grassroots  Festival,  a  four-­‐day  music  event.  

Demographic  Data  

• The  town  of  Centerville  has  a  population  of  29,872  permanent  residents.  • Whites  make  up  81%  of  the  Centerville  population,  Asians  comprise  10%,  African-­‐

Americans  comprise  6.5  %,  and  Hispanics  make  up  3.6%.  Overall,  11.5%  of  the  Centerville  population  is  foreign  born.  Women  make  up  48.3%  of  the  Centerville  population;  51.4%  of  the  population  is  between  the  ages  of  18  and  24  years  of  age.  

• Most  of  Centerville’s  population  (86.7%)  graduated  high  school  and  approximately  50%  of  the  population  seeks  higher  education.  Currently,  42%  of  Centerville  residents  have  four-­‐year  degrees.  

• The  student  population  of  Centerville  drops  dramatically  during  the  summer  and  winter  breaks.  

Page 33: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

33  

• Visitors,  such  as  prospective  students,  parents,  alumni,  recruiters,  and  academics,  routinely  visit  the  State  University  campus  in  Centerville.  Parents  arrive  at  the  beginning  and  end  of  the  academic  year  to  assist  their  children  with  moving.  Parents  also  arrive  during  Parents’  Weekend  and  Graduation  Weekend.  Alumni  are  present  during  Homecoming  weekend.  Recruiters  arrive  in  October,  November,  February,  and  March.  During  these  times,  all  hotels  in  the  area  are  completely  booked.  Further,  during  Graduation  Weekend,  all  hotels  within  a  50-­‐mile  radius  of  the  campus  are  full.  

Economic  Data  

• The  average  Centerville  household  income  is  greater  than  $44,000;  however,  the  median  Centerville  income  is  $37,874,  slightly  lower  than  the  median  income  of  the  United  States  as  a  whole.  

• Thirty-­‐nine  percent  of  Centerville’s  population  is  employed  in  service  industries.  • The  unemployment  rate  in  Centerville  is  low  at  2.3%.  • Centerville  is  considering  instituting  a  living-­‐wage  law  that  would  require  that  all  full-­‐

time  workers  earn  a  minimum  of  $8.96  an  hour,  or  $10.58  for  jobs  without  health  benefits,  and  receive  15  paid  days  off  a  year.  

• Interest  rates  are  currently  the  lowest  they  have  been  in  decades.  

Technological  Data  

• Centerville  has  its  own  Web  site,  and  a  Web  cam  located  in  the  downtown  area  gives  visitors  to  the  Web  site  a  constant  view  of  life  in  Centerville.  

Political/legal  Data  

• Construction  plans  for  any  type  of  food  service  or  retail  establishment  must  be  approved  by  Center  County  and  by  the  Environmental  Health  Division  of  the  Center  County  Health  Department.  Plans  submitted  must  be  comprehensive,  and  should  include  the  proposed  layout  of  the  establishment,  proposed  methods  of  pest/rodent  control,  plumbing  and  sewage  specs,  and  the  manufacturers  and  model  numbers  of  any  equipment  that  will  be  used.  

Competitive  Data  

• Gates  Hotel  is  a  150-­‐room,  full-­‐service,  three-­‐star  hotel  owned  by  the  university  and  located  in  the  center  of  the  State  University  campus.  It  has  an  occupancy  rate  of  85%  and  an  average  daily  room  rate  of  $160.  The  hotel  is  a  popular  spot  for  recruiters,  visiting  academics,  and  parents  because  of  its  superior  campus  location,  but  it  also  attracts  some  corporate  meetings.  It  has  a  number  of  smaller  meeting  spaces,  capable  of  holding  15  to  75  people,  and  a  high-­‐tech  amphitheatre-­‐style  meeting  room  with  executive  seating  designed  to  hold  up  to  150  people.  The  hotel  offers  guests  Internet  

Page 34: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

34  

access  and  voice  mail.  It  has  one  large  ballroom  that  can  hold  400  guests  seated  at  tables.  The  hotel  also  boasts  an  upscale  restaurant  that  overlooks  the  campus,  but  the  food  is  average  and  the  prices  are  high.  The  restaurant  does  the  bulk  of  its  business  at  lunch  time.  

• Only  two  other  hotels  are  near  the  campus.  One,  the  Hillside  Lodge,  is  a  41-­‐room  economy  inn  located  a  mile  west  of  campus,  offering  rooms  with  televisions  and  air  conditioning.  A  free  continental  breakfast  is  available.  Rates  run  from  $30-­‐$60  per  night.  A  94-­‐room  Best  Western  motel  is  located  four  miles  east  of  campus.  Its  rooms  have  refrigerators  and  televisions;  executive  rooms  have  microwaves,  data  ports,  and  fireplaces.  Rates  run  from  $60-­‐$100  per  night.  

• Other  accommodations  in  Centerville  include  a  177-­‐room  Holiday  Inn  located  in  the  downtown  area  five  miles  from  the  university  campus;  a  121-­‐room  Ramada  Inn  and  a  106-­‐room  Clarion  Hotel  located  ten  miles  from  campus  near  several  shopping  centers  and  a  small  mall;  and  a  100-­‐room  Courtyard  Hotel  located  near  the  airport  and  approximately  20  miles  from  campus.  In  addition  to  these  major  properties,  25  inns  and  bed  &  breakfasts  are  in  the  area.  Rates  at  these  latter  properties  range  from  very  cheap  ($30  per  night)  to  expensive  ($350+).  The  largest  of  these  properties  has  35  rooms,  while  the  smallest  has  only  one,  but  most  of  the  bed  &  breakfasts  offer  two  to  four  rooms  for  rent.  The  closest  of  these  accommodations  is  five  miles  from  campus;  the  farthest  is  30  miles  away.  

Ecological  Data  

• Centerville  is  ecology  conscious  and  recycling  is  mandatory.  

   Transcript: Steps to Determine a Strategic Position

Analyze  

Analyze  product  attributes  important  to  customers.  

Attributes  should  be:  

• Salient:  top  of  the  mind  • Determinant:  actually  determine  the  choice  of  a  product  or  service  • Important:  become  important  to  customers  after  they've  made  the  choice  

Examine  

Examine  distribution  of  these  attributes  among  different  market  segments.  

Page 35: SHA502 transcripts - Amazon S3 · !SHA502:Conducting!Effective!Hospitality!Marketing!Research! Schoolof!Hotel!Administration,!Cornell!University! 1 © 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved

  SHA502:  Conducting  Effective  Hospitality  Marketing  Research  School  of  Hotel  Administration,  Cornell  University  

© 2013 eCornell. All rights reserved. All other copyrights, trademarks, trade names, and logos are the sole property of their respective owners.

 

35  

To  which  target  market  do  you  want  to  direct  your  efforts?  

What  is  the  target  market’s  perception  of  your  product  regarding  each  of  the  attributes?  

Determine  

Determine  the  optimal  position  for  the  product  with  regard  to  each  attribute.  

In  positioning  your  product,  take  advantage  of  your  strengths,  while  trying  to  avoid  direct  competitors.  

Choose  

Choose  an  overall  position.  

Try  to  position  your  product  so  you  are  competing  with  the  fewest  strong  competitors,  yet  establishing  the  position  that  focuses  on  the  attributes  that  are  most  important  to  your  target  market.