service commissions department · 2018. 11. 17. · 4 the teaching service commission (tsc) was...
TRANSCRIPT
3
1.0 ExecutiveSummary 42.0 OverviewofAccomplishments 6 2.1. Appointments 6 2.1.a Promotions–AdministrativeOffices 7 2.1.b Appointments–PrimaryandSecondarySchoolTeachers 9 2.1.c OtherActivitiesRelatedtoAppointments 12 2.2 Discipline 12 2.2.a MisconductandOtherDisciplinaryIssues 12 2.2.b IrregularityandUnpunctuality 13 2.3 TheRegulatoryFramework 16 2.4. TheConcordat 16 2.5. Accommodation 17 2.6. Administration 17 2.7. Stakeholders 183.0. IssuesandChallengesFacedin2012 19 3.1. Appointments 19 3.2. TrainingandDevelopment 20 3.3. Discipline 21 3.4. OtherIssues 214.0 PlansandProgrammesfor2013 22 4.1. Appointments 22 4.2. Discipline 22 4.3. StakeholderRelationships 23 4.4. AdministrativeProcess 235.0. Acknowledgements 24Appendix1–Chartsandgraphsrelatedtoappointments,selectionanddiscipline 25
Table of Contents
4
TheTeachingServiceCommission(TSC)wasestablishedundertheConstitutionoftheRepublicofTrinidadandTobago(Section124)anditsmandateisstatedinSection125:
Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, power to appoint persons to hold or act in public offices in the Teaching Service established under the Education Act, including power to make appointments on promotions and transfer and to confirm appointments, and to remove and exercise disciplinary control over persons holding or acting in such offices and to enforce standards of conduct on such officers shall vest in the Teaching Service Commission.
ThemembersoftheCommissionareappointedforathree-yeartermbythePresidentoftheRepublicofTrinidadandTobago,afterconsultationwiththePrimeMinisterandLeaderofOpposition.ThemembersoftheCommissionfor2012were:
Ms.HyacinthGuy ChairmanDr.AnnaMahase MemberProfessorRameshDeosaran MemberMr.AlwynDaniel MemberDr.GillianPaul Member
Ms. Yvette Phillip, Executive Director, Human Resource Management, represented the Director ofPersonnelAdministration(DPA)atmeetingsandMs.JanetGopie,SeniorHumanResourceAdvisor,servedasSecretarytotheCommission.TheExecutiveDirectorpresidedovertheSecretariatwhichprovidedadministrativeandadvisoryservicesthatenabledtheTSCtoeffectivelydischargeitsmandate.
During the reporting period, the Commission held twenty-three (23) statutorymeetings and six (6)specialmeetings.Inaddition,itmetwithvariousstakeholdersonfour(4)occasionstopresentitsplansandprogrammesandheartheirconcerns.AtitsstrategicplanningsessionheldinDecember2011forthe2012period,theCommissionidentifiedfour(4)specificareasonwhichitwishedtoplaceemphasis.
1.0 Executive Summary
5
Thesewere:• Continuingtoacceleratetheselectionprocessandmakesuitableappointments
o The Commission introduced a standardised application form for vacant offices, making it easier for retrieval and collation of information and so reducing the time for processing applications by the Ministry of Education.
o The Commission revised the special report used to evaluate candidates and this gave it the opportunity to obtain more specific and relevant information on candidates to determine suitability. The Commission made this special report a requirement of the application process as it must be submitted together with the application form in the same manner certificates should be submitted.
o The Commission designed a request for proposal for widening the selection process to include psychometric testing of candidates wishing to enter the teaching profession.
• Improvingthedisciplineprocesstimelineandaddressingirregularityandunpunctualityo The Commission conducted an orientation session with various stakeholders with the
objective of engaging in discussions on how the disciplinary process could be made more efficient and effective.
o The Commission put systems in place for obtaining, analysing and dealing with reports from the Ministry of Education of teachers with high levels of unpunctuality and irregularity.
• DevelopingthenewregulationsfortheTeachingServiceCommissionandimprovingadministrativesystemo The Commission completed the review of the new regulations and began the process of
consulting with stakeholders. The amended regulations include provision for conducting parallel investigations, establishing one person tribunals and improving efficiency in the recruitment and selection systems.
• Strengtheningitsrelationshipswithrelevantagenciesandstakeholdergroups.o In 2012, the Commission continued its meetings with various stakeholder groups and
extended its outreach efforts to meetings with Principals and Schools Supervisors in the various educational districts.
Whatfollowsarethedetailsoftheseaccomplishments,anassessmentofthechallengesandplansandprogrammesfor2013andbeyond.
6
ThesuccessoftheCommissioninachievingitsmandateundertheConstitutionofTheRepublicofTrinidadandTobagodependsheavilyontheabilityoftheCommissiontoengagethevariousstakeholdersintheactivitiesneededtoachievethismandatewhileatthesametimemaintainingitsindependentstatus.KeysupportisrequiredbytheMinistryofEducation(MOE)whichmustsubmitinformationonatimelybasistoallowtheCommissiontoactonissuesintheTeachingService.TheCommissionmetwiththeMOEofficialsonseveraloccasionstodiscusshowtheobjectivesoftheeducationsystemcouldbeachievedandhowtoaddressthechallengesfaced.
2.1. Appointments
Over the2012period theCommission further accelerated thepaceoffillingof vacantoffices in theTeachingService.TheCommissionhasbeenapproachingtherecruitmentandselectionprocessfromastrategicperspectivebyfirstengagingthestakeholdersinestablishingaHumanResource(HR)Planandthenexecutingbyliaisingwiththosestakeholderswhoaretobeinvolvedintheprocess.TheHRPlanninginvolvesidentifyinginadvanceandinconjunctionwiththeMOE,thevacantofficeslikelytooccurintheservice,advertisingthosevacanciesandthenundertakingtheselectionprocess.Severalselectionpanelscomprisingexperienced,retiredandactivepublicofficersareutilisedtomakerecommendationsforthefillingoftheoffices.
Theapplicationformforpromotionwhichwasdesignedin2011wasutilisedin2012andprovedtobeinstrumentalinreducingthetimetakenbytheMOEtoanalyseandcollateinformationonapplicationsforsubmissiontotheCommission.Therevisedspecialreportisalsoprovingtobebeneficialinthatitprovidesmorerelevantinformationtoassistintheselectionprocess.Itisnowarequirementforthisspecialreporttobesubmittedtogetherwiththeapplicationformandthishasresultedinthereductionintimetakentoprocesstheapplicationsasthere isno longeranywaitingtimeforspecialreportstobesubmitted.Applicantshavebeenadvisedthat inamannersimilar tohowcertificatesare treated,applicationformswouldnotbeacceptedifthespecialreportisnotincluded.
2.0 Overview of Accomplishments
7
2.1.a Promotions–AdministrativeOffices
ThesystemofpromotionforadministrativepositionsofPrincipal,VicePrincipal,HeadofDepartment,DeanandSeniorTeacherintheTeachingServicenowincludesthefollowing:
o Planned vacant offices for the upcoming year, e.g. due to retirements, are identified by the MOE and verified by the Commission.
o These projected vacant offices, together with vacancies that occurred as a result of promotions, resignations and other unplanned events, are advertised in the second and fourth quarter of each year. Those vacant offices that are advertised in the last quarter of the year include offices that are currently vacant and those that would become vacant in the first half of the next year. Those vacant offices that are advertised in the second quarter of the year include offices that are currently vacant and those that would become vacant in the second half of the current year.
o Vacant offices are advertised for a one month period. These applications are received and reviewed by the MOE, who then shortlist qualified candidates and make recommendations for selection to the Commission. The Commission verifies from the overall listing that this short-list is accurate and meets the requirements of the Job Specifications.
o The Commission arranges the selection process for suitable candidates. At this time the selection process includes a structured interview conducted by a panel of three persons, and in some cases, a written assessment which is undertaken prior to the candidate being interviewed.
o Candidates found suitable for selection are placed on an Order of Merit List and offered appointments as the vacant offices arise.
o As it becomes necessary, the Commission confers with the various denominational boards to discuss the suitability of candidates recommended for placements to the denominational schools.
ThisprocesshassignificantlyimprovedtheefficiencyandeffectivenessofmakingappointmentstovacantofficesintheTeachingService.In2012,93%ofalloftheofficesofPrincipalsandVicePrincipalsthatwerevacantattheendof2011andthatbecamevacantin2012werefilledandthosenotfilledwerescheduledtobefilledearlyin2013.
ThefillingofvacantofficesofHeadsofDepartment,DeansandSeniorTeachers,proceededthroughout2012.ThesecategoriesprovedmorechallengingtofillasthecapabilityatthelevelofTeacherIII,fromwhichthesepositionsareselected,islimited.In2012,37%ofthevacantofficesinthesecategorieswerefilled.TheMOEwasrequestedtore-advertisetheofficesnotfilledandinterviewscontinuedthroughout2012inanefforttofilltheseoffices.
8
The Commission also filled the following de-linked offices during 2012 – CurriculumOfficer, SchoolsSupervisor,GuidanceOfficer,EducationalFacilitiesPlannerandconducted interviewsfortheofficeofChiefEducationOfficer.AnOrderofMeritListwaspreparedfortheofficeofSchoolsSupervisorIIIandthiswaspresentedtotheMOEsothatvacantofficescanbefilledastheyarose.TheofficeofSchoolsSupervisor Iwas advertised and the selection process planned in anticipationof vacancies expectedthroughout2012and2013.Theotherofficeswereadvertisedandfilledasthevacanciesarose.Table1presentsthisinformationinmoredetail.
Table1
Promotions/AppointmentsMadetoAdministrativeandDe-LinkedOffices
OFFICE Offices Officesthat Offices Comments vacant became filledin 31/12/11 vacantin 2012 2012
Principal(Secondary) 13 16 26 Alloutstandinginterviewsalready scheduledfor1stquarter2013
VicePrincipal(Secondary) 24 27 25 Alloutstandinginterviewsalready scheduledfor1stquarter2013
Principal(Primary) 73 60 91 Alloutstandinginterviewsalready scheduledfor1stquarter2013
VicePrincipal(Primary) 15 34 15 InterviewswillcommenceMarch2013
Total 164 211 152
Dean(Secondary) 273 Noinfo 72 Interviewsconductedandonly72offices filled.TheMOEwasaskedtore-advertise in2012
HeadofDepartment 265 Noinfo 3 Interviewsconductedandonly72 (Secondary) officesfilled.TheMOEwasasked tore-advertisein2012
HeadofDepartment(Primary) 93 51 72
SeniorTeacher(Primary) 124 115 131
SeniorSpecialEdTeachers 3 3 0
Total 758 169 278
CurriculumOfficer 64 0 31
SchoolsSupervisorIII/II/I 6 0 6 OrderofMeritListinplaceforSSIII
GuidanceOfficerII/I 64 0 2 Interviewsscheduledfor2013
EducationalFacilitiesPlanner 1 0 0 Interviewsscheduledfor2013
CurriculumCo-ordinator 8 0 0
ChiefEducationOfficer 0 1 0 InterviewsscheduledforJanuary2013.
Total 139 0 36
9
TheinformationinTable1aboveincludesthefillingofvacantofficesthatoccurredinTobago.TheseareextractedanddetailedinTable2asfollows:
Table2:TeachersAppointedtothePrimaryandSecondarySchoolsinTobagoin2012
Principal VicePrincipal Principal VicePrincipal HeadofDepartment SeniorSecondary Secondary Primary Primary Primary Teacher
3 1 8 1 4 16
2.1.b. Appointments–PrimaryandSecondarySchoolTeachers
Primary
TherecruitmentandselectionsystemforentrylevelPrimarySchoolTeachersisdelegatedtotheMOE.Atthistime,itinvolvesthefollowing:
o TheMOEplacesadvertisementsinthenewspapersfromtimetotimeandalsoacceptsunsolicitedapplicationsfromTeacherswishingtoenterthePrimarySchoolsystem.
o AnindividualwhoisregisteredasaTeachermayapplytotheMinistryofEducationforthepositionofTeacherinaprimaryschool.
o TheMinistryofEducationassessestheapplicationtodeterminewhethertheindividualmeetsthestatedcriteria.Atthispoint,apersonwithpassesinatleast5CSECsubjectsmayapplyandbeselectedtobeanAssistantTeacherbutthisisaninterimmeasure.TheMOEisonadrivetoprofessionalisetheserviceandisplacingallprimaryschoolteachersondegreeprogrammestobecomequalified.Oncesufficientcapacityisinthesystem,noonewithoutafirstdegreeineducationwouldbeselectedtoteach.
o TheMOE conducts interviews using a structured instrument designed by the TSC, toidentifycandidateswhomeettherequirementtodeterminetheirsuitabilitytoteachinaprimaryschool.
o TheTSCauditstheselectionprocessatleastonceperyear.o Suitable individuals are placed on anOrder ofMerit List for future placementswhen
vacantofficesarise.
ThissystemisintendedtoensurethattheMOEhastheflexibilitytoappointpersonstovacantofficesinatimelymannerandso,avoidtheteachingservicebeingnegativelyaffectedasaresultoflackofresourcesintheclassroom.In2012,theCommissionapproved499personsforplacementontheOrderofMeritListfortheofficeofTeacher/AssistantTeacher.
10
Sixty-eight(68)temporaryappointmentsweremadetovacantofficesintheTeachingServiceand153permanentappointmentsweremadetoofficesintheprimaryschoolsystem.Onehundredandfortynine(149)personslefttheTeachingServiceforvariousreasons.Table3detailsthisinformation.
Table3TeachersAppointedtoPrimarySchoolsin2012
No.ofPersonsNo.ofTemporaryNo.ofPermanentNo.ofOfficersPlacedonthe Appointments Appointments LeavingtheServiceOrderofMeritList499 68 153 149
Secondary
Theexisting recruitment and selectionprocess for entry level secondary school teachers include thefollowing:
o AnindividualwhoisregisteredasaTeachermayapplytotheMinistryofEducationforthepositionofTeacherinasecondaryschool.
o TheMinistryofEducationassessestheapplicationtodeterminewhethertheindividualmeetsthestatedcriteriaforthesubjectarea.Theminimumcriteriaareadegreefromanaccreditedtertiaryeducationestablishmentandaminimumageof18.
o Inordertodeterminethecandidate’sproficiencylevelandabilitytoteachthecurriculumoftheparticularsubject,thisapplicationissenttotheCurriculumDivisionoftheMOEforassessment.
o TheCurriculumDivisionassessesthecandidateandcertifieshim/herasbeingcompetenttoteachataparticularlevel.ThiscertificationmaybeateitherthelevelofaTeacherIIIorII.
o ThefileoftheindividualisthensenttotheCommissionwhereaninterviewisconductedsoastoascertainthecandidate’ssuitabilityandfitfortheprofession.
o If theCommission is satisfied that thecandidatemeets the requirements for selectionasaTeacher,his/hernameisplacedonanOrderofMeritListandsenttotheMOEforsubsequentplacementinaschool.
TheCommissionin2012interviewed542personsfromvarioussubjectareasandplaced481onOrderofMeritListsforvarioussubjectareas.Ofthese,88or18%wereforMathematics,67or14%wereforNaturalScienceand63or13%wereforEnglish.ThiswasinkeepingwiththeneedsidentifiedbytheMinistryofEducation.TheTSC,inconjunctionwiththeMOE,hasworkedtoensurethatthosesubjectareaswherethereisashortageofteachersareaddressedinanexpeditiousmanner.TheareasidentifiedashavingashortageofteacherswereMathematics,NaturalScience,VisualandPerformanceArtsand
11
PhysicalEducation.TheCommissionensuredthatOrderofMeritListswerewellpopulatedwithteachersfromthesedisciplineswhilealsoensuring that theotherareascontinued tobeserved. In2012,176temporaryappointmentsweremadetovacantofficesinsecondaryschools,174permanentappointmentsweremadeand64officerslefttheTeachingService.DetailsareoutlinedinTable4below.
Table4a
CandidatesbySubjectAreas-Secondary
SubjectArea Interviewed Successful PercentageMathematics 110 88 18NaturalScience 67 60 12.5AgriculturalScience 12 12 2.5VisualArts/TheatreArts/Music/Dance 43 39 8History/SocialStudies 47 44 9English 63 57 12Spanish/French 40 37 8Geography 30 28 6BusinessStudies/Accounts/Economics 14 12 2.5ComputerScience/InformationTech.Technology 18 12 2.5PhysicalEducation 32 32 7Allotherareas 66 60 12AllSubjectArea 542 481 100
Table4b
CandidatesbyOrderofMeritLists;Appointments;Separations-Secondary
No.ofPersonsNo.ofTemporaryNo.ofPermanentNo.ofOfficersPlacedonthe Appointments Appointments LeavingtheService
OrderofMeritListforSecondarySchools
481 176 174 64
12
2.1.c OtherActivitiesRelatedtoAppointments
TheCommissionwasmindfulofthefactthatinadditiontoincreasingtheefficiencyoftherecruitmentandselectionprocesses,itwasalsoimportanttohandleotheractivitiesrelatedtoappointmentswithadegreeofefficiency.TheCommissionassignedateamtoworkonbringinguptodatetheconfirmationof teachers in their positions after probation, acting appointments, transfers, releases, andmedicalboarding.Bytheendof2012,significantprogresshasbeenmadeinthisarea.Table5hasthesedetails.
Table5:OtherActivitiesRelatedtoAppointments
Activity Acting Temporary Confirmation Transfers Release Medical Other BoardTotal 313 244 380 179 26 14 10
2.2. Discipline
2.2.a. MisconductandOtherDisciplinaryIssuesImproving theadministrationofdisciplinarymattersand improving standardsofdiscipline in schoolswereidentifiedaspriorityareasfortheCommission.In2012,theCommissionintensifieditseffortstotreatexpeditiouslywithdisciplinarymattersanditspearheadedanorientationprogrammewithofficersoftheMOE,facilitatedbymembersfromtheDisciplineUnitoftheServiceCommissionsDepartment,todiscussandalignhowallpersonsinthesystemshouldfunction.Thishasresultedinsomeimprovementstotheefficienciesinthehandlingofdiscipline.
During2012,theCommissionhandled61disciplinarymatters.Attheendoftheyear,42ofthesewereatvariousstagesofthedisciplinaryprocessand19matterswerecompleted(SeeTable6).Thirty(30)ofthe61matterswererelatedtoallegationsofmisconduct,18werebeforedisciplinarytribunalsand10wereabandonments.Itistobenotedthatofthe30allegationsofmisconduct,only2hadinformationoutstandingfromtheMOEattheendoftheyear.Thisisachangefromthe16mattersthathadinformationoutstanding fromtheMOEat theendof2011and isan indicationof theco-operationbetween thesecretariatoftheTSCandtheHRMDepartmentoftheMOEinmovingthesematterstocompletion.ThelatesubmissionofinvestigativereportsfromInvestigatingOfficerscontinuestobeamainfactorinthetimetakentohandleissuesofmisconductintheTeachingServiceandtheCommissioncontinuestoworkwiththeMOEtoimprovethis.
13
Ofthe18mattersbeforedisciplinarytribunals,nine(9)werecompletedandnine(9)wereoutstanding.Ten (10) cases of abandonmentswere handled in 2012; the process of handling abandonments hasbeensignificantlyimprovedthroughcollaborationwiththeDisciplineUnitoftheServiceCommissionsDepartmentandtheMOE(seeChart7atAppendix1).Table6detailsthedisciplinarymattershandledin2012.
Table6–DetailsonDisciplinaryMatters-2012
Category No.ofMatters beforethe Commission Completed Outstanding
CourtCharges 2 1–Indecentassault 1–possessionofmarijuana
DisciplinaryTribunals 18 8–completed 9–tribunalsongoing 1–officerresignedAbandonments 10 1–officerresigned 6–beingprocessedbyTSC 2–declaredtohaveresigned 1–allowedtoresumeduty
Allegationsofmisconduct 30 2–examinedbyMed.Board 16–chargespreferredand movedtotribunalstage 1–retirementonillhealth 5–beingprocessedbyTSC 1–foundunfitbyMed.Board 2–additionalinfofromMOE 1–nofurtheraction 1–allowedtoresumeduty 1–mattercompleted
OngoingHCActionmatters 1 1-outstanding
Total 61 19 40
2.2.b.IrregularityandUnpunctualityThe Commission was concerned about the very low number of reports on teacher irregularity andunpunctualitythatcametotheCommission.Assuch,acomprehensivereportonthelevelsofattendanceandlate-comingofallTeachersinthePrimaryandSecondarySchoolsystemswasrequestedfromtheMOE.Thedatareceivedwasanalysedandinformationsharedwithvariousstakeholders.
The2012reportshowedthattherewere442primaryschoolteacherswhoexceededtheirsickleaveof14daysfortheyear.Ofthese49orabout11%wereabsentonsickleaveformorethan100daysintheyear;64or14%wereabsentforbetween50and99days;113or26%wereabsentforbetween25and49daysand216or49%wereabsentforbetween14and24daysintheyear.Inaddition,48teacherswerelateformorethan1,000minutesintheyear.
Comments
14
Chart1
IrregularityintheTeachingServicebyDistrict–PrimarySchools
IntheSecondaryschoolsystem,the2012reportshowedthattherewere755teacherswhoexceededtheirsickleaveof14daysfortheyear.Ofthese,444orabout59%wereabsentbetween15and24days;18or24%wereabsentforbetween25and49days;86or11%wereabsentforbetween50and99daysand43or6%wereabsentforgreaterthan100daysintheyear.Inaddition,472teacherswerelateformorethan1,000minutesintheyear.
TheMOEwasrequestedtoprovidedataonalllate-comingintheserviceincludingthoseteacherswithlessthan1,000minuteslateintheyear.TheMOEhasalsobeenrequestedtoinvestigatetheindividualcasesofexcessiveabsencesandlatecomingandrecommendwhetherdisciplinaryactionshouldbeinitiatedagainst thoseteachers.TheTSCcontinues toworkwith theMOEandall stakeholders toensurethatsickleaveisutilisedforthepurposeforwhichitwasintendedandthatteachingtimeintheclassroomismaximised.TheTSCplanstocontinueitspursuitofaddressingthoseofficerswhohaveunacceptablelevelsofabsencesinkeepingwithitsmandateundertheregulations.
49
64
113
216
Greater than 100 days 49Greater than 50 days 64Greater than 25 days 113Greater than 14 days 216
15
ThisinformationforSecondarySchoolsfortheyearending2012iscontainedintheChartsbelow.
Chart2
IrregularityintheTeachingServicebyDistrict–SecondarySchools
0
100
200
300
400
500
43
86
182
444
Greater than 100 days 43Greater than 50 days 86Greater than 25 days 182Greater than 14 days 444
No.ofSickDaysbyDistrict–Secondary
0
20
40
60
80
100
Victoria St Patrick S/Eastern Caroni St George East N/Eastern PoS/Env
5 7 8 9 7 5 2
11 9 14 11 15 7 19
27 30 30 23 19 8 45
56 60 71 65 56 52 84
>100
>50
>25
>14
0
100
200
300
400
500
43
86
182
444
Greater than 100 days 43Greater than 50 days 86Greater than 25 days 182Greater than 14 days 444
16
Greaterthan1,000MinutesLate–Secondary
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
63
24
39
8490
68
104
Victoria
St Patric
k
South Eastern
Caroni
St George East
North Easte
rn
POS/Environs
2.3. TheRegulatoryFrameworkThe review of the regulatory framework governing the TSC continued in 2012. By the end of 2011,thedraftTSCregulationsweresubstantiallycompletedanddiscussionswith thevariousstakeholderswere continuing. Further discussionswere requestedbymajor stakeholders in 2012 and thesewerefacilitatedbytheTSC.Bytheendof2012,thenewTSCregulationswerecompletedandreadytobesenttotheParliamentaryCommitteein2013.ThemajorchangestotheregulationsincluderevisionsinaccountabilityandtimelinesandtheintroductionofOne-ManTribunalsandparallelproceedingsinthedisciplinaryprocess.
2.4. TheConcordatThe Concordat of 1960 subtitled “Assurances for the Preservation and Character of DenominationalSchoolsasapprovedbyCabinet”statesinpart:
A teacher shall not be appointed to a school if the denominational Board objects to such an appointment on moral or religious grounds. Similarly, if a teacher be found unsatisfactory on these grounds, moral or religious, the denominational authority shall have the right to request his removal to another school after due investigation.
TheCommissionhascontinuedtoworkwithinthestipulationsoftheConcordat,andonmanyoccasionshasinvitedrepresentativesofdenominationalboardstoitsofficestodiscusstheproposedappointmentofacandidatetoadenominationalschoolandtoheartheheldviewsoftheBoardonsuchappointments,
17
especiallywheretheBoardhasadifferentviewtothatoftheCommission.Partieshavebeenabletoresolveissuesinmostcases,butthislong-standingagreementbetweenChurchandStatestillconstitutesoneofthemanychallengesfacedbytheTSC indelivering itsmandatetothepeopleofTrinidadandTobago.
2.5. AccommodationTheCommissioncontinuedtoconducttheselectionprocessattheSelectionCentreat62QueenStreet,PortofSpaineventhoughthefacilitiesandamenitiesarenotalwaysuptothestandardexpectedtomeetbasicneeds.TheCommissionhasfacedchallengessuchaslackofproperwashroomfacilities,poorair-conditioningandanon-functioningescalator.ThismatterhasbeenbroughttotheattentionoftheDPAandtheCommissionwasinformedthatalternativeaccommodationwasbeingsoughtfortheSelectionCentre.ItistobenotedthattheCommissionwasinformedthattherewerepossibleviolationsoftheOccupationalSafetyandHealthguidelinesinthebuildingandhassoughttheguidanceoftheDPAonthematter.Meanwhile,theCommissioncontinuestobenegativelyimpactedbythepooramenitiesandinappropriate infrastructural issuesof this locationandthis ishamperingthepaceatwhichselectionactivitiescanbeconducted.
2.6. AdministrationTheadministrationoftheTSCisvestedintheOfficeoftheDirectorofPersonnelAdministration.Thisofficeprovides information and advice to theCommission, to examine the effects of policies and toquestiontheeffectivenessofdecisionsmade. Inthedischargeof itsresponsibilities,theOfficeoftheDPAhasdevolvedcertainadministrativeservicesviacentralisedandcommonservices.Theseservicesrelatetolegaladvice,auditing,policyandresearch,informationtechnologyandcorporateservices.TheCommissionishamperedbythelackofeasilyavailableinformationfromtheresearchdepartment.Thisisbecausethesystemsforretrievalofinformationaremanualandpaperbased.TheCommissionalsosuffersserioussetbacksinitsabilitytoconsistentlypublishitsquarterlynewsletterasthereisnotsufficientinternalsupportserviceforthisfunction.ThecommonservicesofLegal,DisciplineandtheTribunalsaresharedamongthevariousCommissionsandthismeansthattheCommissionhastowaitinlineforitsmatterstobehandled.Thisresultsinlongadministrativedelays.TheCommissionmetwiththeDPAanddiscussedvarious issueswhichcouldbringbetterefficiencies to itsadministrativeprocesses.HighontheagendawastheassignmentofaLegalOfficerdedicatedsolelytoCommissionmatters,tribunalforhearingsoftheCommissionandthestaffingoftheinvestigativeunitattheSCDsothatofficersofthisunitcanbeusedtoinvestigatemattersonbehalfoftheCommission.
18
2.7. StakeholdersIn 2012, the Commission extended its outreach programme to include presentations and meetingswithvarious fraternitygroupsat thedistrict level.Membersmetregularlywith fraternitygroupsanddiscussedissuessuchastheroleofperformancemanagementintheselectionprocessandtheprocessofmanagingdisciplineinschools.TheseoutreachprogrammesallowedtheCommissiontheopportunitytoshareitsplansandprogrammeswithawiderstakeholdergroup(SupervisorsandPrincipals)andheartheirissuesandchallenges.TheCommissionalsometwiththePermanentSecretary,MOEtodiscussthepolicydirectionoftheMinistryandsoensurethatindischargingitsmandate,itwasalsoachievingthenationaldevelopmentgoals.TheExecutiveDirectorandHRstaffoftheCommissionmetregularlywiththeHROfficialsoftheMOEtodiscussandplanfortheexecutionofthestrategicplansoftheCommission.Thescheduleofmeetingsfor2012isoutlinedatTable7below.
Table7–StakeholderMeetingsHeldin2012
Date Stakeholder
February29 MeetingwiththeTrinidadandTobagoUnifiedTeachers’Association
May16 MeetingwithAssociationofDenominationalBoards
May28 MeetingwithMinisterofEducationandSeniorExecutiveOfficersattheMOE
June13 MeetingwithPermanentSecretaryandSeniorExecutiveOfficersattheMOE
July27 MeetingwithAssociationofDenominationalBoards
August15 WorkshoponDisciplinaryPolicyandProcedures
August22 SixthAnnualSchoolsSupervisorsWorkshop
September19 MeetingwithStakeholdersinTobago–SchoolSupervisors,HRMstaffoftheTHA
andrepresentativesoftheDenominationalBoards
September29 FacilitatedworkshoponPerformanceAppraisalatSt.PatrickEducationalDistrict
November1 FacilitatedworkshoponPerformanceAppraisalatCaroniEducationDistrict
19
3.1 Appointments: While the TSC is satisfied for themost part that there are improvements inthe systemof appointments, there still remain significant issues and challenges thatmustbeaddressediftheimprovementsaretobesustainedinthelongterm.Theseinclude:
• Human Resource Planning - there isnoHumanResourcePlanevidentat theMOEwhichcanassisttheCommissioninmakingtherecruitmentandselectionprocessmoreeffective.HumanResourcePlanningistheprocessofidentifyingfutureHRMneeds,determininghowthoseneedsshouldbemetandmakingaplanformeetingthoseneeds.TheCommissionhassoughttobridgethisgapbyinitiatingthisprocessannuallywiththeMOEinordertoidentifythosevacantofficeslikelytooccurintheadministrativeareas.However,asitstands,whilethisprocessgivesinformationfortheofficesofPrincipal,VicePrincipal,HeadofDepartment,DeanandSeniorTeacher,itdoesnotgiveinformationforthenumberofvacantofficesthatexistorarelikelytooccurintheTeachingestablishmentatthePrimaryandSecondarylevels.Asaresult,thereisalonglagtimebetweenvacanciesoccurringandpersonsfromtheOrderofMeritListbeingselectedtofillthesevacancies.
WhilestaffreturnsaresubmittedtotheMOEbyPrincipalsonamonthlybasis,thereisnoindicationthatthisinformationiscollatedintoacomprehensivereportwhichcaninformthesystemofhowbesttoplanforresourcecontinuity.TheCommissiontriestobridgethisgapbyensuringthattheOrderofMeritListsforbothPrimaryandSecondaryschoolsarewellpopulatedandthattherearesufficientpersonsapprovedtoteachandwhocanbeplacedontheOrderofMeritListtoreplacethosewhohavelefttheservice.
TheMOEhasadvisedthatitwasundertakingateacherrationalisationprocessinordertostreamlinetheallocationofresourcesamongthevariousschoolsinkeepingwithastatedpupiltoteacherratio.TheMOEwasrequestedtoprovidethisinformationtotheCommissionand discussions on the issue continue. It is also important for theMOE to analyse theinformationonpersonsleavingthesystemtodeterminethereasonsfortheturnoverandtoimplementsystemstomitigatetheriskoflosingqualifiedpersons.
TheCommissionisawarethatthesubstituteteachersystemwhichwasimplementedsomeyearsagointheSecondaryschoolsystem,isnotworkinginaneffectivemanner.TheMOEisadvisedtoreviseandre-establishthissystemsothatSchoolsSupervisorscanhaveaccesstoresourcesfromaqualifiedpoolofpersonsintheeventtherearetemporaryshortagesintheservice.TheMOEisalsoadvisedtoextendthissystemtotheprimaryschool.
3.0 Issues and Challenges Faced in 2012
20
• Performance Appraisal – the new performance appraisal system for teachers andadministratorshasnotyetbeenimplementedintheTeachingService.TeachersarepresentlyappraisedwiththeuseofaninstrumentknownastheConfidentialStaffReport.Thissystemis somewhat dated and is not sufficiently transparent to serve the needs of a modernTeachingService.Aneffectiveperformanceappraisalsystemshouldprovideevidentialbasisfortheratinggivenanditshouldprovideinformationwhichcanbeusedinmakingdecisionsaboutateacher’sconfirmationintheposition,promotiontoanewposition,andon-goingcontinuousprofessionaldevelopment.Assuch,theCommissioncontinuestousetheSpecialReportasarequirementintheapplicationforvacantofficeprocess,inordertoselectthemostsuitablepersonforappointment.
TheMOE has informed the Commission that it has completed discussions with variousstakeholdersanditintendstointroducearobustperformancemanagementandappraisalsystem.Thisnewsystemwillbetransparentandacollaborativeprocessandwillfocusonobjectives,performancestandards,behavior,anddevelopment.TheCommissionwelcomesthisinitiative.
• School profiles–atemplateforcapturinginformationontheprofileoftheschoolwasmadeavailabletotheMOEtocollectdataonschoolswhichwouldassist inmakingabetterfitbetweenapotentialcandidateandaschool.InformationonsomeschoolshasbeenprovidedtotheTSCbutinformationonseveralschoolsremainsoutstanding.
3.2. TrainingandDevelopment–theTSCischallengedinfillingtheofficesofHeadsofDepartment,Secondary andDeans, Secondary as there is proving to be insufficient capability in the ranksofTeacherIIItofillthe538vacantofficesinthesecategories.TheCommissioncompletedtheselection process for these categories and filled just about 14% of those offices as suitablyqualifiedcandidatescouldnotbefoundforallthevacantoffices.Officerswhoaspiretotheseofficesneedtohavemoreexposureineducationadministrationwithintheschoolandtobetterunderstand the regulationsandpolicies in theTeachingServiceTheywouldalsobenefit fromtraining programmes in management and leadership put on by theMOE as preparation forassuminghigherresponsibilitiesintheTeachingService.TheMOEwasrequestedtore-advertisethevacantofficesin2012butattheendofthatyearhadnotyetdoneso.TheCommissionplanstoundertaketheselectionprocessagainin2013.
21
3.3. Discipline–Itisexpectedthatthenewregulationswhichhavebeencompletedwillsignificantlyimprove the administration of discipline in the Teaching Service. It is proposed to givemoreaccountability to Principals and Supervisors and to institute one-person tribunals. It is alsoproposedtoimplementparallelproceedingsforissuesthatgobeforethecourtsothatallegationsofmisconductcanbeaddressedalongsidecourtproceedings.
The Commission continues to be challenged by the long time taken by Investigating Officersto investigate allegations of misconduct. It has included accountability measures in the newregulationstoaddressthisissue.TherealsoneedstobestandardguidelinesgiventoschoolsbytheMOEfordealingwithissuesofirregularityandunpunctualityofTeachers.SchoolsSupervisorsandPrincipalscontinuetoreportondifferingstandardsindealingwiththisissue.
TheCommissionhasbeeninsistingthattheMOEinvestigateteacherswhoconsistentlydonotmeettheteachingrequirementsandbringthistotheattentionoftheCommissionsothatanappropriatedetermination canbemadeas to theabilityof those teachers todischarge theirduties.
3.4. OtherIssues:Theissueoftheappointmentofapproximately743primaryschoolteacherswhoenteredtheUniversityofTrinidadandTobago(UTT)in2006topursueaBachelorofEducation(B.Ed.)degreewasdiscussedand issuesresolvedwiththeMOE in2012.Therealsocontinuesto be the need for the MOE to review the educational requirements for the office of VicePrincipal-Primary.Atpresent,notertiarylevelqualificationisrequiredforthisofficeandassuch,advertisementsattracthundredsofapplicantshopefulofbeinginterviewedfortheoffice.ThissituationisananomalysincetheofficeofPrincipal-Primarycallsforarelevantundergraduatedegreeandassuch,itdoesnotmakeforgoodsuccessionplanningfortheofficeofVicePrincipal-Primarytonothavethesamerequirement.ItalsomeansthatSeniorTeachers,TeachersandHeadsofDepartments in primary schoolswhohave a relevant degree canbe considered fortheofficeofPrincipal-Primaryaheadofasubstantiveofficeholderwhodoesnotholdsuchaqualification.
SeveralofthejobdescriptionsintheTeachingServicearedatedandneedtoberevisedtomaketheroleandresponsibilitiesalignedwiththecurrentrealitiesoftheoffice.ThisincludesSchoolsSupervisorsandGuidanceOfficer.
22
4.1. Appointments:TheCommissionaimstofocusonimprovingtheefficiencyinthefillingofvacantofficesforteachersinthePrimaryandSecondarySchoolsystem.Itsaimistofillthosevacancieswithinonemonthofvacantofficesarising.Somestrategiesare:o Map the recruitment process and identify areas which add no value and revise this
process.o Expandtheselectionprocesstoincludepsychometrictestingandawidersetofselection
activitiesinordertogetthebestfitforofficesintheteachingservice.o ObtainaconsolidatedquarterlyreturnofstaffmovementfromMOEandusethisinformation
to project the number of vacant offices likely to occur and plan for filling those vacantoffices.
o Expand thereachofadvertisements forvacantoffices in the teachingservicebyplacingtheadvertisementsontheSCDandMOEwebsites,emailingdirectlytoschoolsandplacingnoticesinthedailynewspapers.
o DelegatesomeareasofrecruitmentactivitiestoMOEo WorkwiththeMOEtoreviseoutdatedjobdescriptionstomaketheselectionprocessmore
relevant.
4.2. Discipline:TheCommissionaimstofocusonreducingthetimeittakestoprocessadisciplinaryissuefromthepresenttimeframeofapproximately3yearstolessthan6monthsfromthedateofoccurrence. Itsgoal, in thefirst instance, is to initiatethedisciplinaryprocess for teacherswithirregularityandunpunctualityofgreaterthan14dayssickleave,14dayscasualleaveandinexcessof1,000minutesperterm.WhiletheCommissionisoftheviewthatnoleveloflatecomingshouldbesanctioned,itisguidedbytherealitythatthereisahighlevelofunpunctualityintheTeachingServiceandithasdecidedthatapracticalapproachtodealingwiththisistoaddressinthefirstinstance,theworstoffenders.Thisisdefinedatthistimeasthosepersonswithmorethan1,000minuteslateintheyear.Somestrategiesandactivitiesforachievingthisinclude:o Maptheprocessandidentifyareaswhichaddnovalueandwhichcanbeimproved.o EstablishprocedureforobtaininginformationonissuesofdisciplinefromSchools.o Identifyteacherswithhighlevelsofabsencesandlatecomingandinitiatetheinvestigative
process.o DelegatemoreareasofdisciplinetoPrincipalsandSupervisors.o WorkwiththeSCDanditsdisciplineunittoestablisharegisterofdisciplinaryissuesand
trackandreportontheseateverymeeting.o WorkwiththeDPAtoensuretheestablishmentandstaffingofaninvestigativeunitatthe
SCDwhichwillundertakeinvestigationsinanexpeditiousandthoroughmanner.o WorkwiththeDPAtoaddressissuesregardingthelengthoftimetakenbytribunalstohear
issuesandproducereportstotheCommission.o WorkwiththeDPAtohaveassignedtotheCommissionafocusedTribunalandadedicated
LegalOfficerforCommissionmatters.
4.0 Plans and Programmes For 2013
23
4.3. StakeholderRelationships:TheCommissionwillfurtherimproverelationshipswithitsstakeholders.Todosoitwould:o Havemore interactionwith district fraternity groups both in Trinidad and in Tobago in
aneffort tocommunicate itsvision for theschoolasaprofessional learningcentrewithattributesofcollaboration,effectivecommunication,andanenvironmentwhichembracesalltypesoflearners.
o Continue to build more effective relationships with the MOE and with the Division ofEducation,YouthAffairsandSport(DEYAS)inTobagotobetterintegrategovernmentpolicyforeducationintotheworkoftheCommission.Inparticular,theCommissionwishestoseetheimplementationofaneffectiveperformancemanagementandappraisalsystemtoaidintheselectionprocessandstrengthenaccountability.
o Buildbetter relationshipswith themedia toget theworkof theCommissionout to thepublic.
o Continuediscussionswiththedenominationalboardsinordertoreconcilesituationswithdiffering recommendations to positions in thedenominational schools. TheCommissionwillaskthevariousboardstodefine,intheirowncontextandsituation,therequirementsformeetingthe‘moralandreligious’standardsforappointments.
4.4. AdministrativeProcess:TheCommissionwillimproveitsadministrativeprocessbyadopting thefollowingstrategies:
o GetregulationsanddelegationordersspecifictotheCommissionapprovedandimplementappropriately. Use the regulations as an avenue to empower Schools Supervisors andPrincipalstomanagetheirdistrictsandschoolseffectively.
o WorkwithMOEtohaveinplaceamanualofpoliciesandproceduresthatareapplicabletotheteachingserviceandmakethisavailabletothosewhoneedtoknow,intheservice.
o Process confirmations, transfers and other administrative issues within one month ofinformationreachingCommission.
o DevelopsystemsusingInformationTechnologytoimproveadministrativeprocesses.o Issue guidelines on Commission functioning and its expectations of stakeholders as
necessary
24
The Commission wishes to express its gratitude to the Director of Personnel Administration, Mrs.GloriaEdwards-Joseph,theExecutiveDirector,Ms.YvettePhillip,theSecretary,Ms.JanetGopie,theinvaluablemembersoftheselectionpanels,otherstaffwhoassistintheselectionprocessandallthestaffoftheSecretariatoftheCommissionfortheirloyaltyandfullsupportoverthereportingperiod.TheirdedicationtodutyandfocusonthegoalsoftheCommissionwereinstrumentalincontributingtoitsprogressin2012.
5.0 Acknowledgements
25
Appendix 1Graphsandchartsrelatedtoappointments,selectionanddiscipline
OfficesVacantandFilledin2012
Chart3–SecondaryAppointments
Chart4–PrimaryAppointments
2010 2011 2012
13 19 2628 28 25 69 3 1 72
PrincipalVicePrincipalHODSecDeanDec
2010 2011 2012
52 26 9157 13 1578 0 720 62 68
PrincipalVicePrincipalHODSecDeanDec
26
Chart5–OtherAppointmentsSchools Supervisor
Curriculum
Guidance O�cer
Other
Chart6–TeacherSecondary
Schools Supervisor
Curriculum
Guidance O�cer
Other
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
No. Interviewed
No. Successful
Percentage
2010 2011 2012
658 523 542
598 459 481
90.88 87.76 88.75
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
No. Interviewed
No. Successful
Percentage
2010 2011 2012
0 20 6
0 9 31
0 32 20 5 0
27
Chart7–MattersofDiscipline
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
201020112012
8
15
2
10
12
18
24
38
10
5
38
30
32
1
Court Charges
Disciplinary Tribunals
Abandonments
Allegations of Misconduct
High Court Matters
28
Notes
29
Notes
30
Notes