september 26, 2019 armadillo room, northwestern university, … · 2019-11-07 · nrt annual...
TRANSCRIPT
September 26, 2019
Armadillo Room, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL
NRT Annual ConferenceSeptember 25-27, 2019
Erica A.H. Smithwick@ericasmithwick
Professor of Geography
Director, Ecology Institute
Associate Director, Institutes of Energy and Environment
The Pennsylvania State University
Development of Trainee Leadership SkillsLandscapeU: Student-centered, transdisciplinary training
“If the world of working and living relies on collaboration,creativity, definition and framing of problems and if it requiresdealing with uncertainty, change, and intelligence that isdistributed across cultures, disciplines, and tools—thengraduate programs should foster transdisciplinarycompetencies that prepare students for having meaningful andproductive lives in such a world.” (Derry and Fischer 2005)
What is transdisciplinary
science?
• Boundary Crossing (disciplines, institutions, communities)
• Collaborative Deconstruction(methodology/practice, problem framing)
• Crossing Knowledge Systems (“ways of knowing”, cultures, co-creation)
• Solutions-oriented
Transdisciplinary Training
Learning and Leadership
Barriers
Time
(Lack of) Institutional flexibility
Inadequate rewards
systems or incentives
Credit burdens
Disciplinary Praxis Language
Lack of expertise
RegenerativeLandscape Science
Ecology SocialScience
Arts & Engineering
Human Dimensions of Natural Resources
Landscape ArchitecturePolicy &Practice
Ethics, Values& Risk
Analysis
Co-Design
• Include new disciplines • Engage local and global communities
• Shape solutions• Enable career pathways
• Self-development• Team-facilitation• Systems thinking• Strategic thinking• Ethical practice• Innovation
Cultivating Leadership
Transdisciplinary competencies
Cultivating Leadership
Ø Actionable science
Ø Student ownership
Ø Team culture
Solutions through partnerships
Individual Development Plan
Co-design
Questions?
Leadership Lessons Learned from Starting a Project Recycling Plastic Waste in Uganda
NSF Research Traineeship Annual Meeting Northwestern UniversityPaige Balcom, UC Berkeley Sept 26, 2019
Berkeley InFEWS Program
Innovations at the Nexus of Food, Energy, and Water Systems
● Interdisciplinary, actionable, impactful, scalable research● Courses, workshops, fieldwork/internships, mentoring● Like-minded community
2
My Research Story: Takataka Plastics
Leadership, confidence, & broad impacts
3
Starting a Project from Scratch
Assessment & Interviews
4
Finding partners
Defining Problem & Finding Funding
5
Defining Problem, Hypothesizing Solution & Rapid Prototyping
Big Ideas Entrepreneurship Competition
Design, Build, & Test
6
Pivot & Pilot
7
Broad Impacts
8
Environmental & Community Health Benefits from Cleaning up Plastic Waste Local Job Creation
Broad Impacts
9
Student Exchange Teaching
Importance of InFEWS Community
Balancing traditional, strict ME requirements with InFEWS
10
Leadership Lessons Learned
● Vision & Team○ How to craft a vision, recruit people
to believe in the vision, & develop into shared vision
11
● Just try attitude○ Overcome “I have no idea what I’m doing” paralysis○ Consult experts & literature, formulate idea, and try it
at small scale○ Accept failures & grow from them
Prepared for Impact
Thanks to interdisciplinary InFEWS, I have:
● Grown in leadership & confidence● Feel excited and prepared for career as a professor and to
conduct research with big impact on people around the world
12
Questions?
Please visit the UC Berkeley InFEWS poster in session 2 #210 13
NRT: Enhancing Conservation Science and Practice
A Transdisciplinary Graduate Program for the Next Generation of Conservation Leaders
University of Maine
In Maine and Elsewhere, Conservation Problems Are Rapidly Changing
o Millinocket: A Rural Forest Community Loses its Industry
o Clams: A Major Resource is in Decline
o Dams: Old Dams, New Problems
As A Result, New Forms of Training Needed to Enhance Conservation Science and Practice Leadership
How Research is Needed
When Research in Needed
Why Transdisciplinary Research is Needed
Bringing It All Together
What Would New Forms Look Like?
Teamwork is the New Leadership
Leadership as Partnership
Leadership is About Crossing Boundaries
Building the Next Generation of Leaders
Disciplines Coming Together
Wetland Ecology
Economics and Policy
Conservation Social Science
Geospatial Analysis
Environmental Communication
Remote Sensing
Social Psychology and Community Engagement
Forest Ecosystem Physiology
Forest Biometrics Modeling
Innovation Will Be Essential
Focus on Solutions (e.g., Decision Support Tools) Focus on Resilience (i.e., Drawing from Theory in Different
Disciplines) Focus on Scale (e.g., Individuals, Communities, Watersheds, States,
Nations)
The ‘Take Homes’
Leadership training must not be standalone training
Students must learn an array of leadership strategies
Students need to learn to integrate their knowledge with that of others
The situations will keep changing so capacity to innovate and reframe will be essential skill
Questions?
GAUSSIDevelopment of Trainee Leadership Skills
Floor 2: Armadillo Room
Rich Feller Ph.DProfessor Counseling and Career
Development
Career Planning ContextGAUSSI’s ProgramFindingsRecommendationsDiscussion
2
Career Planning Context1. Less stable workplace to support the “grand narrative”
2. Workers as “free agents” with portfolio careers
3. Faculty positions & tenure more competitive…gov’t $ commitments decline
4. Private sector seeks STEM talent able to EXPLAIN “value add proposition”,boundrycross, & entrepreneurial bias
5. Change…“big data” requires new skill set configurations/translations, ability to make“pitch”, self-awareness, & career management
Stuck (“I’m ah”) vs. Becoming
3
4
1. Provide assessments & experiences toexpand career options
2. Expand collaboration with industrial partners to mentor & promote career planning
3. Support self awareness to improve communication & team development
4. Support transition from graduate school
GAUSSI Career Planning Program
5
6
7
8
Performance Based not Self-Report Aptitudes
How Many Slides Should I Have?
RISIN
G ACTIO
N
CLIMAX
EXPOSITION
RESOLUTION
FALLING ACTION
SOLUTION
TRACTION
THE ASK
PROBLEM
INTRODUCTION
Storytelling Tool(Customer/You/News)|
Pain Point Why Status Quo Fails
*Hero Moment* Product Reveal|How does it
work?
Market | CompetitionTraction| Team
Proforma & AskLink to Intro Story – “Nail It.”
2-420%
1-210%
2-420%
3-740%
2-310%
Between 10-20 slides total for 10 minute pitch
10
We all tell stories & play games
What if individuals could sit with 4-5 peers playing self-directed game that led to a written Clarification Sketch ?
11
12
13
14
Findings
18
Recommendations1.On campus career planning for STEM grad students
needs to reinvent “value proposition”2. “life design” principles should complement
“job-naming & job-finding” interventions3. Connection to/networking with STEM entrepreneurs is a key
asset to “entrepreneurial thinking/aspirations beyonduniversity positions”
4. “pitch skills” observation/practice/video & peer feedbackconnect the dots for transitioning grad researchers fromcampus labs to private sector aspirations/options
5. On-line self-directed/consumer model personality and aptitudeinnovation tools are appealing
It’s not just about finishing as fast as possible!
Developing students’ professional skills to ensure future successAllie Johnson
PhD Student, Hearing and Speech Sciences
Poster #305NRT-DESE # 1449815Flexibility in Language Processes and Technology: Human- and Global-Scale
Languageat Maryland
“Don’t be like my cat.” –Colin Phillips
Develop a Vision for the Big Picture: “What do you want to do with your life?”
v Write a training planv Meet annually to discuss
v Goalsv Prioritiesv Progressv Needs
Participate in Leadership Training
Emphasizes the value of student
leadership
Gives students agency
Students develop the skills to initiate
and execute effectively
When Reality ≠ Vision
v Get buy-in from other students: “Who’s with me?”
v Take advantage of campus resources
v Create an action plan with support from peers and mentors
Case Study: Writing GroupsvVision: develop writing habits in preparation
for a career as research faculty
vReality: Writing tasks aplenty, but the process of writing was unsustainable; unhealthy, inefficient, anxious, mediocre-quality binge writing
vBuy-in from students with similar experiences
vSupport from mentors and program staff
vCampus resources (Graduate School Writing Center; Library)
vAction: Start a weekly writing support and accountability group (with snacks and coffee)
Questions?
Getting off to a good start with an early
immersive experience
Fred GouldNorth Carolina State University
Getting off to a good start with an early
immersive experience
The challenge of building interdisciplinary student teams
Agricultural Biotechnology in Our Evolving Food, Energy & Water Systems
1) Students will use Responsible Innovation approaches for design and deployment of future agricultural biotechnology products that will enhance FEW systems.
2) Students will use evidence-based approaches for elevating the level of public discourse on agricultural biotechnology
Agricultural Biotechnology in Our Evolving Food, Energy & Water Systems
Jonathan Foley 2014
“GMOs have frequently failed to live up to their potential, not because they are inherently flawed….
Jonathan Foley 2014
“GMOs have frequently failed to live up to their potential, not because they are inherently flawed…. but because they have been deployed poorly into the complex social and environmental contexts of the real world.”
CommunicationRhetoric & Digital
MediaScience, Technology
& Society
AgriculturalExtension Education
Agricultural Sciences
Agricultural Sciences
FunctionalGenomics
PlantMolecular
Biology
ResourceEconomics
BiomathematicsAgricultural
Biotechnology in FEW Systems
First Student Cohort 9 students from 45 applicants
Agriculture
Wetlands
10 Farmer Interviews
Cotton Insects
Corn Weeds
Drop This Essential
It did not meet my expectations
It surpassedmy expectations
It did not meet my expectations
It surpassedmy expectations
Getting off to a good start with an early
immersive experience
The challenge of building interdisciplinary student teams
Questions?