sept 20, 2010 appeal book. the court of appeal of n.b. file number 82/10/ca andre murray v. betty...

Upload: justice-done-dirt-cheap

Post on 04-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    1/129

    Court of Appeal File Number: 82 10 - CA

    (Court File Number: F/C/104/09)

    IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW BRUNSWICK

    BETWEEN:

    ANDRE MURRAY

    APPELLANT (Plaintiff)

    - and -

    BETTY ROSE DANIELSKI

    RESPONDENT (Defendant)

    Appeal Book

    Filed by self represented

    APPELLANT

    ANDRE MURRAY

    Andr Murray

    APPELLANT

    (Plaintiff)

    31 Marshall Street,

    Fredericton,

    New Brunswick,

    E3A 4J8

    Telephone Number:

    (506) 472 - 0205E-mail address:

    andremurraynow@

    gmail.com

    Solicitor for

    RESPONDENT (Defendant)

    Betty Rose Danielski

    E. Thomas Christie, QC

    CHRISTIE LAW OFFICE

    Suite 306,

    212 Queen Street

    Fredericton,

    New BrunswickCanada

    E3B 1A8

    Tel: (506) 472 2090

    Fax: (506) 472 2091

    E-Mail: [email protected]

    Betty Rose Danielski

    RESPONDENT (Defendant)

    Apt 603

    166 Carlton Street

    Toronto, Ont.

    M5A 2K5

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    2/129

    i

    Appellants Appeal Book

    (Rule 62.13)

    INDEX

    Page

    1. (a) an index, ___________________________________________________

    2. (a.1) a Certificate of Readiness (Form 62HH),_________________________

    3. (b) a copy of the Notice of Appeal

    Notice of Appeal August (Form 62B) _______________________________

    4. (c) a copy of any order granting leave to appeal

    DECISION- COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW BRUNSWICK-

    - Date of decision August 11, 2010

    - Court Filed Date stamped August 11, 2010

    The time for filing a Notice of Appeal is extended to August 20, 2010.___

    5. (e) a copy of the pleadings as amended, including particulars and admissions,

    Copy of Amended Notice of Motion, Dated the 31st day of May, 2010,

    Court File Stamped Dated the 31st day of May, 2010 ___________________

    6. (f) a copy of the order of the trial court appealed from

    Decision of The Honorable Justice Garnett, Dated Jun 10. 2010 __________

    7. (g) a copy of the certificates or agreement referred to in Rule 62.10, and

    Certificate of Appellant (Form 62F) Dated the 2nd

    day of September 2010,__

    8. (h) a copy of any affidavit evidence,

    9. Copy of a Affidavit of Service by George Mallai Dated November 9th,

    2009__________________________________________________________

    10. Copy of a Claim for Lien Dated April 16, 2009________________________

    11. Copy of a Certificate of Pending Litigation Dated April 21, 2009________

    12. Copy of a Notice of Action (Form 16 B) Dated April 21, 2009. ___________

    i

    1

    2

    11

    13

    16

    17

    21

    22

    26

    27

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    3/129

    2

    13 Copy of a Statement of Claim (Form 16 C) Dated May 20, 2009._________

    14. Copy of a Amended Statement of Claim (Form 16 C) Dated Aug 21, 2009._

    15. Copy of Affidavit of Service by Andre Murray Dated April 20, 2010._____

    16. Copy of a Notice of Motion Dated April 20, 2010._____________________

    17. Copy of Affidavit of Andre Murray Dated April 20, 2010._______________

    18. - Exhibit A - Copy of the Certificate of Pending Litigation________

    19. - Exhibit B- Copy of a e-mail from George LeBlanc of Cox and

    Palmer regarding entrance to the subject Property sent October 26,

    2009 ____________________________________________________

    20. - Exhibit C- Copy of a Power of Attorney dated November 14, 2002 __

    21. Copy of Affidavit of Service by Andre Murray Dated May 31st, 2010._____

    22. Copy of Amended Notice of Motion Dated May 31st, 2010.______________

    23. Copy of Affidavit 2 of Andre Murray Dated May 31st, 2010._____________

    24. - Exhibit D- Copy of a 6 page Service New Brunswick Print of ParcelInformation / Property Information report, dated Aug 8, 2009____________

    25. - Exhibit E- Copy of a Deed Dated October 24, 2000 ________________

    26. - Exhibit F- Copy of a letter from George Mallia, of CANADIANPROCESS SERVING INC. Toronto Office, Dated November 8, 2009______

    27. - Exhibit G- Copy of the invoice, dated November 23, 2009 fromCANADIAN PROCESS SERVING INC._______________________

    28. - Exhibit H- Copy of a UPS Services Waybill Tracking numberE838 688 798 9 Dated October 20, 2009_____________________________

    29. - Exhibit I - Copy of a UPS Services Proof of Service Digital SignatureTracking number E838 688 798 9 Dated October 20, 2009_______________

    30. - Exhibit J- Copy of a UPS Services Waybill Tracking numberE838 688 792 5 Dated October 20, 2009_____________________________

    31. - Exhibit K- Copy of a UPS Services Proof of Service Digital SignatureTracking Number E838 688 792 5 Dated October 20, 2009______________

    31

    35

    39

    42

    45

    52

    53

    54

    55

    58

    61

    65

    71

    77

    78

    80

    81

    82

    83

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    4/129

    3

    32. - Exhibit L - Copy of a UPS Delivery Service Invoice, regarding twosuccessfully delivered packages Dated October 31, 2009______________

    31. - Exhibit M - Copy of the envelope containing a letter from BettyDanielski to Andre Murray Dated April 1, 2009_____________________

    32. - Exhibit N - Copy of a letter from Betty Danielski to Andre MurrayDated April 1, 2009____________________________________________

    33. - Exhibit O - Copy of Lease for 29 Marshall Street 31 Marshall Streetproperty, Dated September 1, 2005_________________________________

    34. - Exhibit P - Copy of REVOCATION OF POWER OF ATTORNEYDated May 29th, 2008 __________________________________________

    35. - Exhibit Q - Copy of the Order from the Court of Queens Bench

    Trial Division, Moncton, Dated: October 20

    th

    , 2009____________________

    36. Copy of the Affidavit of service of the Plaintiff Andre Murrays letter to the

    Defendant requesting Documents pursuant to the Mechanics' Lien Act,

    R.S.N.B. 1973, c. M-6, section 32(1), Dated: May 31, 2010._______

    37. Copy of Andre Murrays letter to the Defendant requesting Documents

    pursuant to the Mechanics' Lien Act, R.S.N.B. 1973, c. M-6,

    section 32(1), Dated: May 31, 2010._______________________________

    38. Copy of The Plaintiff Andre Murrays Affidavit of Service of the Plaintiff

    Andre Murrays letter to the Defendant requesting Consent to a

    Continuance Dated: May 31, 2010._________________________________

    39. Copy of Plaintiff Andre Murrays letter to the Defendant requesting

    Consent to a Continuance Dated: May 31, 2010._______________________

    40. Copy of Affidavit of Andre Murray, Dated: June the 17th day of June, 2010_

    41. - Exhibit A - Copy of Decision of the Court Dated: June 10, 2010.__

    42. - Exhibit B- Copy of the fax cover page which was received

    with the Decision of the Court Dated June 10, 2010._______________

    43. - Exhibit C- Vendor RBC - Bidding Papers & Terms of SaleDated July 16, 2009_________________________________________

    44. - Exhibit D- Copy ofthe Property Information Report for PID number1548650, printed from Service New Brunswick, on Queen Street,

    Fredericton, N.B., dated June 17, 2010.____________________________

    84

    87

    88

    89

    94

    96

    97

    100

    103

    106

    109

    117

    118

    119

    121

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    5/129

    4

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    6/129

    (a.1) a Certificate of Readiness (Form 62HH),

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    7/129

    (b) a copy of the Notice of Appeal,

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    8/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    9/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    10/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    11/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    12/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    13/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    14/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    15/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    16/129

    (c) a copy of any order granting leave to appeal,

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    17/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    18/129

    (e) a copy of the pleadings as amended,

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    19/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    20/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    21/129

    (f) a copy of the order of the trial court appealed from.

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    22/129

    (g) a copy of the certificates or agreement referred to in Rule 62.10, and

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    23/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    24/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    25/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    26/129

    (h) a copy of any affidavit evidence, or

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    27/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    28/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    29/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    30/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    31/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    32/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    33/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    34/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    35/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    36/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    37/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    38/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    39/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    40/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    41/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    42/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    43/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    44/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    45/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    46/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    47/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    48/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    49/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    50/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    51/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    52/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    53/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    54/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    55/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    56/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    57/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    58/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    59/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    60/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    61/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    62/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    63/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    64/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    65/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    66/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    67/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    68/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    69/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    70/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    71/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    72/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    73/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    74/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    75/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    76/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    77/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    78/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    79/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    80/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    81/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    82/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    83/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    84/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    85/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    86/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    87/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    88/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    89/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    90/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    91/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    92/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    93/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    94/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    95/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    96/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    97/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    98/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    99/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    100/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    101/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    102/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    103/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    104/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    105/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    106/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    107/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    108/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    109/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    110/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    111/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    112/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    113/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    114/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    115/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    116/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    117/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    118/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    119/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    120/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    121/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    122/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    123/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    124/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    125/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    126/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    127/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    128/129

  • 7/30/2019 Sept 20, 2010 Appeal Book. The Court of Appeal of N.B. File Number 82/10/CA ANDRE MURRAY v. BETTY ROSE D

    129/129