self-potential and induced polarization: geophysical tools

31
André Revil (1) and Susan S. Hubbard (2) (1) Colorado School of Mines (2) L. Berkeley National Laboratory Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools to map flowpaths and monitor contaminant plumes

Upload: others

Post on 12-Feb-2022

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

André Revil (1) and Susan S. Hubbard (2) (1) Colorado School of Mines (2) L. Berkeley National Laboratory

Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools to map flowpaths and monitor contaminant plumes

Page 2: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Rocks have a complex texture and chemistry, Geophysics is sensitive to both

New science: Mechanistic understanding of the geophysical signals

Page 3: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Medical Science (electro-encephalography)

Self-potential

Geophysics (self-potential)

Network of non-polarizing electrodes connected to a voltmeter

Page 4: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Generalized constitutive equations

Chemical potential

Take-home message: any king of non-equilibrum disturbance generate an EM signal

Page 5: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Self-potential associated with a salt plume

Ag/AgCl smart electrodes

Multichannel system (256 ch., 7 kHz)

Page 6: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Time-lapse self-potential signals

Snap shots of the electrical potential distribution over time

Page 7: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Modeling Buoyancy driven saline plume

Darcy equation

Continuity equation for the mass of the fluid Continuity equation for the mass of the solute

State equations

Hydrodynamic dispersion tensor (Fickian model)

Mass density

Viscosity

Generalized Fick law

Fickian model (change with scale?)

Page 8: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Finite element simulation of the forward problem (comsol multiphysics) Salinity Self-potential field

Source term

Continuity equation

Constitutive equation

Page 9: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Self-potential time lapse tomography (deterministic)

Martinez-Pagan, Revil et al., in press in Geophysics

Data misfit Regularization over time

Page 10: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Stochastic inversion (AMA) of the permeability and dispersivities (15,000 realizations)

(the vertical bar represents the measured horizontal permeability)

Page 11: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Spectral induced polarization (complex conductivity)

Can be used as a geophysical tomographic technique (see Williams et al. Work at Rifle)

Page 12: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Excess Surface (in Siemens)

Similar values for clays and silica

Page 13: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

The spectral polarization of a granular material

Complex conductivity

Magnitude

Phase

Page 14: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Polarization of a single grain

Page 15: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Polarization of a single grain

Upscaling using DEM theory for instance

Page 16: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools
Page 17: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Application to the data of Tong et al. (2006)

Sanstones

Page 18: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Presence of a second fluid phase (immiscible, non wetting)

Page 19: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools
Page 20: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Comparison with the prediction from the model

Model prediction

Experimental data

Page 21: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Influence of a change in the composition of the aqueous phase

Page 22: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Change in the composition of the aqueous phase over time

Page 23: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

No change in resistivity

Change in the phase

Modeling with PHREEQC

Page 24: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Complexation model (with electrostatics)

Induced polarization is truly a geophysical spectroscopic tool sensitive to chemistry

Page 25: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

The effects of biofilms

Pictures: courtesy of Yuri Gorbi

Pili = 100 S/m (electron tranfer possibly by tunneling effect between the hemes packed in the pili)

Page 26: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

At the interface between sharp redox gradient

Electronic contribution to EC through biofilms

Page 27: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Self-potential anomaly associated with an oil spill

Page 28: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools
Page 29: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

From Atekwana et al. (2004)

Responsible for a conductivity increase at the water table

Page 30: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

In few weeks: Application to Oak Ridge

Cooperation with David Watson

Imaging the preferential flow-paths

Model the transport of contaminants (effect of recharge…)

Page 31: Self-potential and induced polarization: Geophysical tools

Conclusions

Get a catalog of the effect of contaminants/bacteria upon induced polarization

Develop the inverse problem (speciation using SIP)

Developing joint inversion tools for map permeability change / chemistry amendments

Use of chemical tracers to follow them using geophysical techniques

Use of electromigration / electroosmosis to bring specific chemical components

(redox active) to specific targets non-intrusively

Can we act non-intrusivey on bacteria with electrical field?

Doing all the couplings in TOUGHREACT (Nic Spycher & Magnus Skold)

We thank the DOE for Financial support

Scientific papers can be downloaded at http://www.andre-revil.com