selection of indicator organisms for functional ... · np cv np cv np cv np cv np: no pesticides...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
International Seminar on Enhancement Biodiversity Relevant to Sustainable Food Production in ASPAC
Tsukuba, 9-10 November 2010
Selection of Indicator Organismsfor Functional Agrobiodiversityin Paddy Ecosystems in Japan
Koichi Tanaka
National Institute for Agro-Environmental
Sciences, Tsukuba, Japan
![Page 2: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
• Environment-friendly farming systems have been developed and propagated
• Agricultural productivity is attempted to be compatible with conservation of biodiversity
• Effect of these farming systems on biodiversity in agro-ecosystems – A little is known
• A research project was started in 2008“Selection of Functional Biodiversity Indicators
and Development of Assessment Methods”
Background
![Page 3: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
VIII. Developing an indicator of biodiversity in agriculture, forestry, and fisheries
Preservation of biodiversity, which provides the footing for agriculture, forestry and fisheries is essential to ensure stable provision of safe agricultural, forestry, and fishery products of high quality to our citizens.
(Snip)
However, there has been no development of an indicator which can be used to quantitatively grasp the effects although measures
related to agriculture, forestry and fisheries including environment-friendly agriculture are taken with consideration of biodiversity, and it is necessary that an indicator be developed in effectively promoting these agricultural, forestry and fishery measures.
We shall, therefore, promote examination of development of an indicator to grasp the positive and negative effects of agriculture, forestry, and fisheries on biodiversity based on science and a biodiversity indicator to effectively promote the related measures, elucidate the roles of agriculture, forestry and fisheries in biodiversity and deepen domestic and international understanding by studying what organisms live in rice paddies, forests, seaweed beds, tidal flats, and so forth and utilizing the basic data obtained in the past including properties of biota characteristic in ecosystems formed by agriculture, forestry and fisheries and study methods.
Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Biodiversity Strategy (2007)
Need to developindicators
![Page 4: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
• To develop indicators
• The indicators can be used to evaluate the effect
• Of environment-friendly farming systems
• On conservation and enhancement of biodiversity
in agro-ecosystems or farmlands
Objectives of Project
![Page 5: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Organisms beneficial to agriculturee.g. arthropod predators and prasitoids of crop pests
• These functional groups include a great number of species.• They form intermediate trophic levels in a food web.
• Supported by diverse prey organisms at a lower trophic level• Supporting populations of a higher trophic level.
• Their biodiv. reflect biodiv. of lower and higher trophic levels
• They are useful for practicing env.-friendly farming.
Main Target Indicators
![Page 6: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Composition of arthropods in paddies
Settle et al.(1996)
No. of species byfunctional group
Predators+ Parasitoids= 64%
Indonesia(Java)
![Page 7: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
2008 – 2009• To select candidates for indicator organisms
2010 -- 2012• To develop simple techniques to survey indicators
• To develop standard methods to evaluate the accomplishment of environment-friendly farming
• To establish the indicator organisms
Period of Project
![Page 8: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
• Selection of indicator organisms• At a crop field level• At a landscape level
• Development of simple assessment and prediction methods• Simple assessment methods• Analyzing and predicting functional biodiversity at a
national scale
Composition of research
![Page 9: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Methods for selecting indicator organisms
Comparing between different cultivation fields/areas
Comparing
Environment-friendlyfield/area
Conventionalfield/area
(1) Selecting fields/areas with environment-friendly and conventional farming(2) Surveying organisms (mainly insects and spiders) in the selected fields/areas(3) Comparing species and abundance of the organisms between the two(4) Selecting more abundant organisms in environment-friendly farming as candidates
for indicator organisms
![Page 10: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
1) Hokkaido-Tohoku (northern Japan)plain paddy, sub-mountainous paddy, vegetable fields
2) Kanto (eastern Japan)plain paddy, sub-mountainous paddy, rice-wheat double cropping
3) Chubu (central Japan)plain paddy, sub-mountainous paddy
4) Kinki (western Japan)plain paddy, large-area environment-friendly
5) Chugoku-Shikoku (western Japan)sub-mountainous paddy
6) Kyushu-Okinawa (southwestern Japan)rice/vege. paddy, early-planted paddy, traditional citrus fields
7) Various agricultural areassuburban, vegetation-managed, grassland
Composition of research: At a landscape level
![Page 11: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Study sites: Selection of indicators at a landscape level
Representative landscapes (almost paddy fields)covering whole Japan
Various areas: Suburban area, Vegetation-managed area, Grassland
Kanto
ChubuChugoku/ShikokuKyushu/Okinawa Kinki
Northern Japan
![Page 12: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
2nd screening: Considering the suitability of each organismas an indicator (e.g., benefit for agriculture and representative and prevalence (not so rare) in each habitat)
12
Procedure for selecting indicator organisms
Creating a list of organisms in all study areas
1st screening: Selecting organisms significantly moreabundant in environment-friendly fields/areas than in conventional fields/areas using statistical tests
More than 2 million individuals were captured in all the study areas.
423 organisms were listed as potential indicators at several taxonomic levels (e.g. species, genus, family).
Nationwide- and regional-common organisms were selected as candidates for indicator organisms.
![Page 13: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Case study: Paddy fields in Kanto
N
Site B
Site A
Site C
Site D
Location of four study sitesin Tochigi Prefecture
24 field plots in 4 study sites
![Page 14: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Species richness (No. of species): SpidersNo. of species of insects and spiders collected > 400 spp.
Mea
n nu
mbe
r of s
peci
es
Fig. 2 Species richness of spiders. (by all sampling methods)
0
5
10
15
20
25 N K S O
Org. Conv. Org. Conv. Org. Conv. Org. Conv.0
5
10
15
20
25 N K S O
Org. Conv. Org. Conv. Org. Conv. Org. Conv.Org. Conv. Org. Conv. Org. Conv. Org. Conv.
Site A B C D
NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV
NP: No pesticidesCV: Conventional
(Tanaka et al. unpublished data)
![Page 15: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Abundance of web-building spiders
Number of Tetragnatha spiders by sweeping rice plants with a sweep net. Mean for 3 field plots (Tanaka et al. unpublished data)
ORG CONV ORG CONV ORG CONV ORG CONV0
10
20
30
40T. caudicula
T. maxillosa
T. vermiformis
Site A Site B Site C Site DNP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV
NP: No pesticidesCV: Conventional
![Page 16: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Paddy areas(1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts of rice plants
Tetragnatha spp.Araneids
All study areas (13 areas)
(2)Wandering spiders dwelling on the lower parts of rice plants and water or ground surfaces
Lycosids (Wolf spiders)
9 of 13 study areas
Nationwide-common indicatorsApplicable to most regions in Japan
Sweeping rice plants
Sticky board
![Page 17: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Regional-common indicatorsApplicable to specific regions
Kanto
ChubuChugoku/Shikoku
Kyushu
Kinki
NorthernJapan
Northern JapanPaddy: aquatic bugsOthers: parasitoid wasps, predatory
lady beetles, predatory stinkbugs,hoverflies
KantoPaddy: odonates, frogs, predatory
lady beetles, aquatic beetlesOthers: parasitoid wasps, predatory
lady beetles, staphylinid beetles
KinkiPaddy: odonates, frogs, hoverfliesOthers: parasitoid wasps,
predatory stinkbugs, staphylinid beetles, hoverflies
KyushuPaddy: odonatesOthers: predatory stinkbugs
Chugoku/ShikokuPaddy: frogs, aquatic beetles,
aquatic bugsOthers: parasitoid wasps,
ants
ChubuPaddy: parasitoid waspsOthers: parasitoid wasps, ants,
predatory mites
![Page 18: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Examples of regional-common indicatorsin paddy areas
Hoverfly ヒラタアブ Aquatic beetle水生コウチュウ
Frog カエルOdonate (Dragonfly)トンボ(赤とんぼ)
Odonate (Damselfly)トンボ(イトトンボ)
Aquatic bug水生カメムシ
![Page 19: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Further work (from this year)
1. Confirming whether the selected candidate organisms are suitable indicators
2. Developing simple, efficient techniques to survey indicator organisms
3. Developing standard methods to evaluate accomplishment of environment-friendly agriculture
Establishing the indicator organisms
Compiling a manual to survey the indicators and
to evaluate environment-friendly agriculture
![Page 20: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Utilization of indicators
1. To assess effects of agricultural programs and activities that attempt to preserve environments
by surveying the indicators in the area where such programs/activities are practiced
2. To efficiently use functional biodiversity for practicing environment-friendly farming
by surveying the indicators (including natural enemies) in farms and adjusting farming to conserve/enhance them
Environment-friendly agriculture will be popular.
Its technologies will be advanced.
![Page 21: Selection of Indicator Organisms for Functional ... · NP CV NP CV NP CV NP CV NP: No pesticides CV: Conventional. 16 Paddy areas (1) Web-building spiders inhabiting the upper parts](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051510/5ff2213738a7407aa91e0a18/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
COP10: Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD)
Side Event (Lectures)• Reason for using our indicators• Outline of the research project
Interactive Fair (Outdoor Exhibition)