selection and assessment. today’s session selection and assessment process defining the need...
Post on 21-Dec-2015
217 views
TRANSCRIPT
Selection and Assessment
Today’s session
• Selection and Assessment Process
• Defining the need
• Attraction
• Assessment
• Fairness
• Contracting & Induction
• Key challenges
But first…some definitions
• Selection – choosing an applicant from a pool of applicants already in the company
• Recruitment – Filling a post from a pool from outside the firm
• Two main components– Attraction– Assessment
Why does it matter?
• The best is twice as good as the worst (Hull, 1928)
The Ideal Process
1. Identification of need for new employee
2. Job Analysis – criteria determined
3. Decision to recruit or select internally
4. Format of applications and process for examining criteria
5. Job vacancy and publicity materials put into public domain
6. Applications Arrive
The Ideal Process - continued
7. Short-listing/pre-screening process
8. Assessment process undertaken
9. Final decision made and offer sent out
10. Applicant accepts and joins firm
11. Induction and ongoing socialisation process
12. Collection of performance data
13. Evaluation and review of selection process
Defining the need
• Imagine you are defining the requirements for a lecturer position– How might you go about defining what you
were looking for?– What challenges might you face?
Defining the need
• Why do a Job Analysis?– To write accurate and comprehensive job descriptions
– Aid the interviewer in identifying what’s relevant
– Distinguish between what can be selected for and what can be trained
– Choose selection tests
– Classification
– Defend choice of selection tests
– Transfer selection tests (using job families)
Job analysis techniques
• Collecting information– Video
– Written records
– Observation
– Structured questionnaires/Open questionnaires
– Diaries for job holders
– Interviews
– Group interviews
– Participation
Job analysis techniques
• Job oriented techniques– Focus on the work being done– E.g. installing cables, locating source of engine fault
• Content oriented techniques– Focus on what the worker does to accomplish the job– E.g. attention to detail, use of written materials
• Attribute-oriented techniques– Describe job in terms of attributes/or traits needed– E.g. Good eye sight, verbal fluency
Job analysis techniques
• Critical incident techniques– Flanagan 1954 – pilot training failure
• Repertory Grid Technique– Compares good, average and poor workers
• Physical Abilities Analysis– Fleishman and Mumford (1991) – 52 abilities– E.g. stamina, dynamic strength, trunk strength
Job analysis
• Should differentiate different jobs
• Should give same picture of same jobs
Assessment
• Purpose– To reliably predict work performance
The “Classic Trio”
• Application forms– How truthful is info– Overload of applicants– Bias in decision process
• References
• Interviews
Techniques
• The interview– Unstructured chat?
• Traditionally poor predictor of work performance
– Structured or Semi structured interview?– Critical incident/behavioural event interviewing
• Reduces impact of hypothetical situations
• Assumes past behaviour predicts future behaviour
• In pairs, discuss reasons why interviews sometimes have poor validity
• What could you do to address these reasons/issues?
The interview…
• Some reasons for poor validity– Interviewers differ– Interviewer motivation– Interviewee’s impression management– Interview coaching– Interviewee lying– Rating artefacts e.g. leniency– Criterion reliability e.g. supervisor ratings
Improving the interview
• Select interviewers
• Use more than one interviewer
• Use same interviewers throughout process
• Train interviewers
• Take notes
• Make ratings
Other techniques
• References and performance ratings
• Weighted application blanks and biodata
• Tests of mental ability
• Personality Tests
• Assessment Centres
• Work Samples
• Group discussions
Validity
• Face validity– Based on appearance of the test
• Content validity– Based on coverage of conceptual domain– E.g. does test for medical doctor include items
from GMC’s syllabus
Validity
• Construct Validity– Underlying construct can be measured e.g.
intelligence– Show relationships between instruments in a
similar domain
• Criterion Validity– Relates to an external criterion– E.g. job success (not another instrument)
Alternatives?
• Graphology• Astrology• Palmistry• Pseudo tests
– Short forced choice items with little info on reliability or validity
• Polygraph– Prohibited in US since 1988– BPS report 2004
Minorities, Fairness and the Law
• UK and EU Legislation– Latest on age discrimination– “enthusiastic, dynamic people looking for new
experiences and a thirst for learning”– “experienced person with gravitas capable of
influencing at board level”
• Issues of Adverse Impact– Job analysis is key!
Choosing tests/techniques for an assessment centre
Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4
Criterion 1 X X
Criterion 2 X X
Criterion 3 X X
Criterion 4 X X
Criterion 5 X X
Criterion 6 X X
Example - Assessment Centre• Personality Test Review Discussion• Timed Analysis of Business Issues• Presentation of Proposed Solution to Business Issues• Leaderless Group Discussion• Timed preparation for Negotiations• Role Play Negotiation• Timed written project plan for implementation of
development programme• Competency-Based Interview• Self reflection on Performance
Key Challenges
• Irrational decision making– Agor (1986) data for supporting decision rather
than as basis for decision– Janis (1972) group dynamics and “groupthink”– Stereotyping and bias
• If it moves, test it?– The façade of objectivity
Key Challenges
• A marginal view of individual differences– Assumes stability over time– Assumes past behaviour predicts future
behaviour– This view limits propensity to change – so what
about learning and development?
Key Challenges
• Faking a desired response– Deliberately making stuff up!
– Simplistic to assume applicants are passive participants
– Impression management techniques• E.g. ingratiation, distortion of events, positive self
descriptions,
– Or is favourable self presentation indicative of high applied intelligence and sensitivity to context?
Contracting and Induction
• Critical aspect of the selection and recruitment process
• Contracting– Formal contract
– Psychological contract
• Great recruitment and selection without supportive induction, transition management = potential waste of time and money!
Questions
References
• Chapter 5 of Millward
• Cook, M.(2004) Personnel Selection – Adding Value Through People, Wiley & Sons Ltd, Chichester
• Searle, R. (2003) Selection and Recruitment – A Critical Text, OU, Milton Keynes