seeing the truth about childhood schizophrenia - free ce schiz.pdf · 2 “jani’s at the mercy of...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Seeing the Truth About Childhood Schizophrenia
Elizabeth Montagnese, M.D.Adult, Child and Adolescent PsychiatristQuittie Glen Center for Mental Health in Annville, Pennsylvania
PharmCon is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education as a provider of continuing pharmacy education
Legal Disclaimer: The material presented here does not necessarily reflect the views of Pharmaceutical Education Consultants (PharmCon) or the companies that support educational programming. A qualified healthcare professional should always be consulted before using any therapeutic product discussed. Participants should verify all information and data before treating patients or employing any therapies described in this educational activity.
This program has been supported by an educational grant from Bristol-Myers Squibb
2
“Jani’s at the mercy of her mind.”
LA Times story, June 29, 2009Jani Schofield, 6 year oldSevere symptoms since toddlerhood“There is something wrong with her brain.”
Epidemiology of Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia (COS)
RARE!!!!!
1 in 40,0000
Adult-onset schizophrenia (AOS): 1% general population
M:F ratio: 1.5-2.2:1
Very rarely diagnosed before age 5
Usually diagnosed between 7-12 years old
Schizophrenia Statistics
Emil Kraeplin documented casesof COS in 1919Typical age of onset:males: 18 years of agefemales: 25 years of ageTop 10 causes of disability worldwide
Schizophrenia Statistics
Cost of Schizophrenia: 1990-accounted for 2.5% of health care expenditures+ nondirectcosts($45 billion)
2002- $62.7 billion for direct and nondirectcosts
Unemployment rate is 70-80%
10% of those permanently disabled
What is Childhood Schizophrenia?
Neurodevelopmentaldisorder
Fundamental continuity between AOS and COS
Differences in Childhood Schizophrenia
More severe illness
Worse prognosis
More insidious onset
Harder to treat
Misdiagnosis is common
Diagnostic Difficulties with COS
Complex disorder with diverse presentation
Psychosis and thought disorder are difficult to assess in children
Children’s concept of reality changes with time
Disorganized behavior/speech can be common in nonpsychotic children
Symptoms change, emerge, evolve over time
Rare disorder: lack of clinical familiarity
Diagnostic Difficulties with COS
Devastating illness
Life sentence
Clinicians don’t want to get it wrong
Large overlap with other disorders
Diagnosing COS
Mean onset of symptoms: 4.6 years
Mean onset of psychosis: 6.9 years
Mean onset of diagnosis: 9.5 years
5 year time lag
11
DSM Criteria for Schizophrenia
Two or more of following for 1 month: (A Criterion)
Delusions
Hallucinations
Disorganized speech
Disorganized behavior
Negative symptoms: flat affect, avolition, alogia
Only 1 if delusions bizarre or voice keeping commentary or 2 voices conversing
To have the diagnosis, one must exhibit 2 or more of what is termed A criteria symptoms. These include delusions, hallucinations, disorganized speech, disorganized behavior, negative symptoms of flat affect, avolition or alogia(which means lack of speech). Only one symptoms is necessary if the person exhibits bizarre delusions or hallucinations to include a voice keeping a running commentary on everything the person is doing or multiple voices arguing, conversing or giving command hallucinations
12
DSM Criteria for Schizophrenia
Social/occupational dysfunction
Disturbance for at least 6 months with at least 1 month with criterion A
Not due to substance, medical condition, mood disorder or PDD
This is a given. There is always going to be social and occupational dysfunction to some degree. The disturbance in functioning and behavior have to have been present for at least 6 months with one month of Criterion A symptoms. Symptoms must not be solely due to substances, GMC, mood (MDD can have accompanying psychosis) or part of a pervasive developmental disorder.
13
Schizophrenia Subtypes
Catatonic
Paranoid
Disorganized
Undifferentiated
Residual
There are 5 different types of schizophrenia. We will not spend much time going over the differences. Paranoid type is the most common.
14
What is psychosis?
What is real vs. fantasyThink of “A Beautiful Mind”
Let’s start with some basics about the topic of psychosis since this is the hallmark feature of schizophrenia. What is psychosis? Basically it is the inability to distinguish reality from fantasy. Not knowing if experiences are real or not real. If you have seen the movie, “A Beautiful Mind” about the life of the Nobel winning mathematician John Nash, recall the scene where John is standing outside of his classroom. He is greeting his students as they enter class. This scene was illustrating a time of his life when he became more stable. He asked a female student, “Is that person standing next to you really there?” She replied, “what person”. They both smiled and he said something like “I didn’t think so”. He was experiencing psychosis but also showed some insight by acknowledging that he understood that his experience might not be based in reality
15
Positive Symptoms
Symptoms associated with
distorted reality
Delusions
Hallucinations
Things present in those with schizophrenia as compared to those without.
What are “positive symptoms”? These are things that are present in individuals with schizophrenia as compared to those without. They include things are associated with a distorted sense of reality. These include delusions and hallucinations. These are the symptoms most responsive to medications. They are easier to treat.
16
Negative Symptoms
Affective blunting
Poverty of speech
Thought blocking
Adequate grooming
Lack of motivation-apathy
Anhedonia
Social withdrawal
Things absent from those with schizophrenia as
compared to those without.
Negative symptoms are things that are absent in those with schizophrenia as compared to those without. Eugen Bleuler, a Swiss psychiatrist prosedspecific criteria for diagnosing the disorder and actually called it Schizophrenia. Negative symptoms are known as Bleuler’s 4A’s which describe disturbance of affect, apathy, avolition, associations. Additionally included in negative symptomatology are anhendonia and social withdrawal. Basically those things that make an individual appear to check out of interacting with the world.
17
Hallucinations
Think of 5 senses: visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory, tactile
Usually frightening, morbid, macabre
Can be friendly, company
Hallucinations are distortions of experience/perception/sensation. Patients can many times described these in great detail. I recall one patient who had persistent perceptual disorder from chronically abusing methamphetamine. She had almost constant visual hallucinations that included seeing blood dripping from the trees or the branches appearing like claws. Intermixed in the trees would be faces with no eyes or dripping blood where the eyes should be. Although she had insight most of the time, they were so real and scary to her that it was quite disturbing and the question always was there underneath, “Is that real?” Patients can also experience friendly hallucinations. Once again, think of “A Beautiful Mind” John Nash had 3 repetitive hallucinations in the form of people. One was a menacing CIA agent. The other two heexperienced as friends, companions and to acknowledge that they were not real was in some respect, his abandonment of his friends.
Hallucinations in COS
Most common presenting symptom
Auditory hallucinations: 80% of COS
Visual hallucinations: 30% of COS
Tactile/olfactory hallucinations: rare
Developmental considerations
Hallucinations in isolation = schizophrenia
Imaginary friends > 7yrs old: cause for concern
21
Delusions
A fixed false belief
Bizarre-illogical
Nonbizarre- can really occur
Persecutory
Somatic
Ideas of reference
Grandiose
Religious ideas
Delusions, a common positive symptoms of schizophrenia is any fixed, false belief. Nonbizarre delusions refer to those that could really occur. I recall a patient I had at the State Hospital who always claimed that he was very rich and his money was all tied up in a trust fund that his family was trying to keep from him. Later on I saw this man as an outpatient and found out this that was not delusional as we all had thought, but was real. This illustrates the need to involve family and check out some of the patients reports. Not everything they do or say is based on delusions.An example of a bizarre delusion would include believing that you are transmitting radio signals through special brain waves or believing that your family members are really alien imposters.
Delusions
Difficult to assess in children
50-60% of COS
Childhood themes: monsters, animals, family, fantasy figures
Less complicated in childhood
Thought Disorder is disruption in flow of conscious verbal thought
that is inferred from spoken or written language.
Flight of ideas
Derailment
Thought blocking
Pressured speech
Tangentiality
Perseveration
Word salad
Neologisms
Echolalia
Illogical
The Prodrome
Onset of decline from baseline functioning
“Latent schizophrenia”
Don’t meet full criteria
Nonspecific symptoms
Important: early detection is protective
The Prodrome
cognitive functioningoverall functioningsocial isolationpersonal hygiene
Difficulties withattention Change in emotionsFlattening of affect
The Prodrome
Bizarre preoccupationsChange in sleep/appetiteAggression, anxietyNeuromotor or sensory changesAbnormal eye tracking movementsBrief, intermittent psychosis
Differential Diagnosis of COS
Pervasive developmental disorder
Affective disorders
PTSD
Conduct
Developmental language disorder
Cognitive problems
Conduct disorders
Personality disorders
Dissociative disorder
Substance abuse
Differential Diagnosis of COS
General medical causes:
Delirium
Seizures
CNS lesions
Neurodegenerative disorder
Toxins
Infections
Theories of Causation
Genetic
No family history: 1%
First degree relative: 10%
Identical twin: 50%
Gene markers: GAD1 affecting GABA and neureglin
Theories of Causation
Prenatal insults
Infection
Birth trauma
Rh incompatibility
Abnormal protein and NT Synthesis
Excessive glutamate release (excito-toxic damage)
Structural Brain Abnormalities
Hot area of researchLateral ventricular
volumeTotal and regional
gray matter volumesBasal ganglia
volumes
Structural Brain Abnormalities in COS
Gray matter loss in back to front patternWhite matter loss in front to back patternExaggerated synaptic pruningSlower brain growthLopsided brain growth
Composite MRI scan data showing areas of gray matter loss over 5 years, comparing 12 normal teens (left) and 12 teens with childhood onset schizophrenia. Red and yellow denotes areas of greater loss. Front of brain is at left.
Structural Brain Abnormalities in COS
Similar changes as AOS
Differs from other neuropsychiatric disorders
Not yet diagnostic
May predict presymptomaticadolescents
Copyright restrictions may apply.
Gogtay, N. Schizophr Bull 2007 0:sbm103v1-103; doi:10.1093/schbul/sbm103
Comparison of the Patterns of Cortical Gray Matter (GM) Loss in Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia (COS) (Between Ages 12 and 16 Years) to That Seen in Normal Cortical Maturation (Between
Ages 4 and 22 Years)
Structural Brain Abnormalities in COS
Unaffected family members: early loss of gray matter, normalizes by age 20
Help in finding genetic markers
Help in identifying trajectory influences
38
Morbidity and Mortality
People with schizophrenia that are in the public mental
health system die 25 years earlier that the general
population!!
Schizophrenia can be lethal.
People with a diagnosis of schizophrenia die, on average, 25 years earlier than the general population. This is astounding and a significant public mental health problem. Suicide is a large cause of mortality in schizophrenia with ½of those with the diagnosis attempting suicide at least once and 10% of those with the diagnosis will complete suicide. However, it is becoming more clear that the disease itself and treatments shorten the life span of those afflicted in numerous ways. Some of the ways are modifiable. Some aren’t. What is important to study thoroughly though are these modifiable aspects so we can come up with new and innovative ways to treat the disorder that will provide for high quality and quantity of life. Newer pharmacotherapies have contributed to improved control of symptoms but there has been a cost. We will talk at length about side effects of medications that contribute to several disease states that can shorten the life of those with schizophrenia.
39
Course of Disease
4 phases: prodrome, acute, recuperative, recovery/residual phase
Chronic illness
No cure
Very treatable
Without treatment-downhill course
Schizophrenia is a chronic, waxing and waning disease. There is no cure, however it is very responsive to treatment. In fact, without treatment, individuals will show a downhill course. With relapse or cessation of treatment, symptoms are harder to push into remission and it is very hard to get back to previously levels of functioning.
Diagnostic Work Up
Comprehensive diagnostic evaluation
Labs: complete metabolic panel, thyroid, urinalysis, toxicology screen, HIV, chromosomal analysis, folate, B12, RPR
Screen for infections, heavy metals (Wilson’s)
EEG
MRI
Cognitive testing
Treatment of COS
Comprehensive, multi-modal
Psychological needs
Social needs
Educational needs
Cultural needs
Family needs
Physical needs
Treatment of COS
Psychopharmacology
Psychotherapy: individual and family
Case management
Educational interventions
Social skills training
Inpatient/day treatment
Neurological/medical services
Residential treatment
Rarely, ECT
43
Now, let’s get to the meds
Antipsychotics revolutionized treatment
Chlorpromazine (Thorazine) – 1952
1st of the “Typical” antipsychotics
First used as an anesthetic
Treatment of schizophrenia was really revolutionized by the discovery of chlorpromazine in 1952. It was, like many other medication therapies, discovered by accident. It was used as an anesthetic agent. In patient with schizophrenia it was found that their psychosis improved when they were given this anesthetic and so started the pharmacological revolution in mental health.
44
How do antipsychotics work?
Target dopaminergic neurons
Increase dopamine=psychosis
Dopamine blockers
Atypicals also block serotonin
Typical agents affect nigrostriatal tract and mesolimbic tract
Nigrostriatal area also affects involuntary movements
Reason for EPS
Psychotropic target specific types of neurons. These are called dopamanergicneurons- those that produce and are affected by dopamine. Dopamine is aneurotransmitter that is associated with psychosis. Very basically, increased dopamine=psychosis. These meds therefore work by blocking dopamine at the receptors sites in neurons. There are several neuronal tracts in the brain affected by these typical agents and include the nigrostriatal tract and mesolimbic tract. It is the nigrostriatal tract that is associated with involuntary movements that are as a result of these medications. These types of effects on movement are called extra pyramidal symptoms.
Antipsychotic Use in Children
Most use in children is “off label”
Lack adequate data in children
Small sample sizes
Need more controlled trials
Younger patients are more sensitive to adverse effects of drugs as compared to adults
Antipsychotic Use in Children
Start low and go slow!
Continual monitoring
Routine labs
Baseline and serial weight, height and BMI
Dietary education
FDA Approval of Atypical Antipsychotics for COS
Risperidone and Aripiprazole are approved for childhood schizophrenia for ages 13-17 yrs.
June, 2009: FDA advisory panel recommended approving Quetiapine and Olanzapine for treatment of childhood schizophrenia for ages 13-17 yrs.
49
Atypical Agents
Newer
Affect D2 and 5HT(2A) receptors
Reason for increased efficacy
Affects positive (D2) and negative (5HT) symptoms
Don’t effect nigrostriatal tract as much-less EPS
Affect mesolimbic and mesocortical tracts
Now let’s talk about the newer agents called atypical agents. They are atypical in that they affect different neurotransmitter systems. They not affect D2- the dopamine like the typicals but also the serotonin system referred to as 5HT. They affect dopaminergic neurons in different tracts, the mesolimbic and mesocortical tracts, not the nigrostriatal which we know is the cause of EPS. We think that atypical show increase efficacy because of affecting different NT systems. This is the reason atypicals are effective in treating the negative symptoms of schizophrenia.
50
Side Effects of Atypicals
Weight gain!!!!!
Increased glucose, lipids, triglycerides: Metabolic Syndrome
Sedation and anticholinergic symptoms
Extra pyramidal symptoms: akathesia, dystonia, Parkinsonism
Common reason for medication noncompliance
Extra pyramidal symptoms include akathesia. This is when a patient experiences an uncontrolled urge to move, to pace. It is very unpleasant and can be severe. Some patients have committed suicide because of being unable to deal with this. Dystonic reactions include muscle spasms. This commonly occurs in eye called oculogyric crisis, neck called torticollus, or back called opisthonus or tongue. EPS also encompasses Parkinsonian symptoms. This includes shuffling gait, tremor or masked faces- no facial expression. EPS is unpleasant, can be very frightening. Patients may not be able to swallow or turn their heads. It can be intolerable. It is a very common reason for med noncompliance.
51
Side Effects of Atypicals
Increased prolactin levels: gynecomastia, galactorhea
Can also cause Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome and Tardive Dyskinesia
Thought to cause less EPS and less chance of Tardive Dyskinesia
Extra pyramidal symptoms include akathesia. This is when a patient experiences an uncontrolled urge to move, to pace. It is very unpleasant and can be severe. Some patients have committed suicide because of being unable to deal with this. Dystonic reactions include muscle spasms. This commonly occurs in eye called oculogyric crisis, neck called torticollus, or back called opisthonus or tongue. EPS also encompasses Parkinsonian symptoms. This includes shuffling gait, tremor or masked faces- no facial expression. EPS is unpleasant, can be very frightening. Patients may not be able to swallow or turn their heads. It can be intolerable. It is a very common reason for med noncompliance.
52
How do we choose an atypical?
Side effect profile- make them work for patient
Any absolute contraindications or medical risks
Other meds: drug-drug interactions
Cost!!!!
Insurance
Patient/family perceptions
Doctor’s own perceptions about meds
The development of atypicals has been thought of as groundbreaking in the treatment of schizophrenia. They are thought of to be more tolerable than typicals because of the lower incidence of EPS and TD. They do have many side effects and some serious ones at that. We choose medications by trying to make side effect profile work in favor of the patient. Ones that increase appetite would be a good choice for a patient who has a poor appetite or experienced weight loss. One causing sedation can help patients that experience severe agitation or sleep disruptions. In addition to looking at side effects, we have to look at contraindications. If a patient is heavy or has diabetes or hyperlipidemia, one would not pick an atypical with the highest association with weight gain. You must know every medication a patient is on. Many patients will not tell fully what meds they are on most by omission. They don’t count some things as meds or they simply forget. Cost must be a factor. I recently put a patient on an atypical that was not on her formulary and she informed me that the prescription was going to cost $600 per month. Most people could never afford this. So, we do have to work with insurance formularies. Also, patients or their families may have certain feelings about a particular medication based upon personal experience or the media and popular culture. It is important to know this before prescribing. Also, doctors get comfortable with certain meds, have their “favorites” and gravitate towards using these.
53
Atypical Agents
Generic NameGeneric Name Trade NameTrade Name Daily DosageDaily Dosage(mg)(mg)
Forms availableForms available
AripiprazoleAripiprazole AbilifyAbilify 1010--3030 INJ, soln, tabsINJ, soln, tabs--DD
ClozapineClozapine ClozarilClozaril 2525--900900 tabstabs--DD
OlanzapineOlanzapine ZyprexaZyprexa 55--2020 INJ, tabsINJ, tabs--D D
PalipaeridonePalipaeridone InvegaInvega 66--1212 tabstabs
QuetiapineQuetiapine SeroquelSeroquel 300300--800800 tabstabs
RisperidoneRisperidone RisperdalRisperdal 11--1212 tabstabs--D, soln, INJD, soln, INJ
ZiprasidoneZiprasidone GeodonGeodon 4040--160160 tabstabs
This chart shows the various atypicals we now have in our armamentarium. These are the typical doses and the forms available. INJ stands for injectableformula, soln stands for solution and tabs are tablets, and tabD are rapidly dissovling tablets.
54
Risperidone (Risperdal)
1993
Only depot form of atypical-not used in children
Depot form q 2 weeks
Weight gain, sedation and high prolactin most common
Above 6 mg daily- EPS
Now let’s talk about each one individually. Risperidone was developed in 1993. It is currently the only atypical available in a depot or long acting injectable form. This type of administration of medication has a dramatic effect on improving treatment compliance. Some of the side effects seen with risperidone include weight gain, sedation and high prolactin. In fact, increased prolactin is highest with risperidone out of all the atypical. Once 6mg daily is exceeded, incidence of EPS begins to approach that of the typicals.
55
Olanzapine (Zyprexa)
Very sedating
Excessive weight gain
Metabolic syndrome
Olanzapine is very sedating and can really pack the pounds on individuals who can go to develop a metabolic syndrome which includes diabetes, hyperlipidemia and hypertension.
56
Quetiapine (Seroquel)
Moderate for weight gain
Slit lamp eye exam recommended-cataracts, not often done
Very sedating
Used in low doses for sleep-off label
With quetiapine or seroquel, weight gain is less of an issue but sedation is more of one. In the past, there were recommendations that a slit lamp eye exam occur routinely to monitor for cataracts, but recently studies have not listed this issue as a concern. In very low doses, some practitioners may use this as a sleep aid but this is generally not recommended.
57
Aripiprazole (Abilify)
Not a full DA antagonist
“Dopamine stabilizer”
Agonist in areas of low activity
More weight neutral
Low incidence of metabolic syndrome
Aripiprazole or abilify is a newer medication that works is a different fashion. It is not entirely a blocker and acts as a dopamine agonist in areas where there is low dopamine activity. It too is more weight neutral. I have had patients, though that have experienced weight gain on this. This is anecdotal, however just recently I stopped this medication after a 25 # weight gain in a young woman. This medication also tends to be activating therefore making not as useful for acute agitation.
58
Clozapine (Clozaril)1989
Weight gain
Seizures
Excessive salivation
Agranulocytosis- serious, fatal
Weekly – biweekly WBC count
Specific protocol-complex to manage
Used in refractory cases: in children, only after failure of 2 other atypical antipsychotics
In children: 1/3 those started on clozapine discontinue due to severe side effects
Clozapine was the first atypical developed. It has some significant, serious side effects but shows great efficacy especially in treatment refractory cases. Weight gain is significant. It is associated with agranulocytosis which is a serious life threatening complication. A type of WBC is depleted making a person very susceptible to fatal infection. Therefore, weekly WBC counts are part of the treatment protocol. In fact, pharmacists cannot dispense the medication without a copy of the weekly WBC count. This is costly, time consuming and leads to noncompliance. Clozapine therefore is usually reserved for treatment refractory cases. Also there is a great increase in the risk of seizures. Patients also commonly complain excessive salivation
59
Ziprasidone (Geodon)2001
Short acting injectable available
Can be used for acute agitation
More weight neutral than other atypicals
Lower incidence of metabolic syndrome
Cardiac side effects
Ziprasidone is considered to be more “weight neutral” than some of the other atypicals. It is available in a short acting injectable form so can be useful for acute episodes. It can be used in the ER in place of haldol which was routinely used in ER setting to calm agitated patients with schizophrenia. It has much less incidence of EPS making this attractive.
Typical Antipsychotics
Still use these
Generally more second line in COS
Recent debate that risks comparable to atypicals
Much cheaper
Haloperidol, chlorpromazine, perphenazine
ReferencesDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition, Text Revision, American Psychiatric Association, 2000
Physicians Desk Reference, 2008
Schizophrenia, A Clinician’s Guide, 1995, American Psychiatric Press
Lieberman JA, Stroup TS, McEvoy JP, et al, “Effectiveness of Antipsychotic Drugs in Patients with Chronic Schizophrenia”, N Engl J Med, 2005;353: 1209-1223
NIMH, Questions and Answers about the NIMH Clinical Antipsychotic Trials of Intervention Effectiveness Study (CATIE), http://www.nimh.gov/healthinformation.catieqa.cfm
Wu EQ, Birnbaum HG, et al,“The Economic Burden of Schizophrenia in the United States in 2002”, JClinPsych, 2005, Sept;66(9):1122-1129
Practice Guidelines for the Treatment of Patients with Schizophrenia, Second Edition, 2002, American Psychiatric Association
Practice Parameters for the Assessment and Treatment of Children and Adolescents With Schizophrenia, J.Am.Acad.ChildAdolesc.Psychiatry, 40:7 Supplement, July 2001
ReferencesLieberman, J., “Metabolic Changes Associated with Antipsychotic Use”, PrimCare Companion J Clin Psychiatry 2004;6(suppl 2):8-13.
Battaglia, J., “Compliance with Treatment in Schizophrenia”, MedscapeCME.
Narasimhan, M., Bailey, S.B., “Schizophrenia, Metabolic Syndrome, and Antipsychotics Challenges, Controversies, and Clinical Management, Medscape CME.
Childhood Schizophrenia, Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 2nd Ed.,Lewis, M., 1996, M., 629-635.
White, T., Afshan, A., Schulz, C., “The Schizophrenia Prodrome,”Am.J.Psychiatry, 163(3):376-380, March 2006.
Shari Roan, “Jani’s at the mercy of her mind,” Los Angeles Times, June 29, 2009.
Russel, A., “The Clinical Presentation of Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia,”Schizophrenia Bulletin, 20(4): 631-646, 1994.
References
Gogtay, N., Rapport, J., “Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia: Insights From Neuroimaging Studies, J.Am.Acad.ChildAdolesc.Psychiatry,” 47(10) 1120-24, Oct. 2008.
Greenstein et al, “Remission Status and Cortical Thickness in Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia,” J.Am.Acad.ChildAdolesc.Psychiatry, 40 (10) 1133-40, Oct. 2008.
Rapport et al, “Autism Spectrum Disorder and Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia: Clinical and Biological Contribution to a Relation Revised,” J. Am.Acad.ChildAdolesc.Psychiatry, 48 (1) 10-18, Jan.2009.