securities and exchange commission v. alcatel-lucent, s.a (sobornos hondutel)

8/8/2019 SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION v. ALCATEL-LUCENT, S.A (Sobornos HONDUTEL)

1/24

XID]HM P]L]HP MDP]UD@] @AXU]OAU ]JH PAX]JHUIMDP]UD@] AO OKAUDML

@LPH IA)6

PH@XUD]DHP LIM HZ@JLIGH@ACCDPPDAI+Rkldi}doo+

v)LK@L]HK#KX@HI]+ P)L)+

Mhohimli})

@ACRKLDI]

Rkldi}dooPh`xud}dhp lim Hz`jligh @accdppdai lkkhghp lp oakkawp6D) PXCCLUT


2/24

Ouac Mh`hcehu 522< }a A`}aehu 522=+ Lk`l}hk 'p lghi}p lim!au pxepdmdludhp rldm l} khlp}-7 cdkkdai di eudehp }a gavhuichi} aood`dlkp ao @ap}l Ud`l }a ae}ldi au uh}ldi }juhhài}ul`}p }a ruavdmh }hkhrjaih phuvd`hp di @ap}l Ud`l }a}lkdig lrruazdcl}hkt -020cdkkdai)

Ouac Mh`hcehu 5225 }a Fxih 522?+ Lk`l}hk 'p lghi}p lim!au pxepdmdludhp rldm eudehp }agavhuichi} aood dlkp ao Jaimxulp }a ae}ldi au uh}ldi odvh }hkhàccxid`l}daip ài}ul`}p}a}lkdig lrruazdcl}hkt -=: cdkkdai)[

Ouac A`}aehu 5220 }a Clt 522=+ Lk`l}hk'p lghi}p lim!au pxepdmdludhp rldm eudehp }a

gavhuichi} aood dlkp ao ]ldwli }a ae}ldi au uh}ldi l uldkwlt lzkh àxi}dig ài}ul`}vlkxhm l} lrruazdcl}hkt -57 cdkkdai)

Ouac A`}aehu 522= }a Oheuxlut 522?+ Lk`l}hk'p lghi}p lim!au pxepdmdludhp rldm eudehp }agavhuichi} aood`dlkp ao Clkltpdl }a ae}ldi au uh}ldi l }hkhàccxid l}daip ài}ul`}vlkxhm l} lrruazdcl}hkt -:8 cdkkdai)0) Lkk ao }jhph rltchi}p whuh xima`xchi}hm au dcruarhukt uhàumhm lp àipxk}dig

ohhp di }jh eaanp ao Lk`l}hk 'p pxepdmdludhp+ lim }jhi àipakdml}hm di}a Lk`l}hk 'p odili`dlkp}l}hchi}p) L klz àuraul}h ài}uak hivduaichi} ldmhm Lk`l}hk 'p dcruarhu àimx`}) Lk`l}hkoldkhm }a mh}h`} au divhp}dgl}h ixchuaxp uhm oklgp pxgghp}dig }jl} d}p expdihpp àipxk}li}p whuhkdnhkt clndig dkkd d} rltchi}p lim gdo}p }a gavhuichi} aood dlkp di }jhph àxi}udhp l} }jh mduh`}daiao `hu}ldi Lk`l}hk hcrkathhp) ]jh uhprh`}dvh jhlmp ao phvhulk Lk`l}hk pxepdmdludhp limghagulrjd`lk uhgdaip+ pach ao wjac uhrau}hm mduh`}kt }a Lk`l}hk'p hzh`x}dvh àccd}}hh+lx}jaudhm hz}uhchkt jdgj àccdppdai rltchi}p ximhu `du xcp}li`hp di wjd`j }jht oldkhm }amh}hucdih wjh}jhu px`j rltchi}p whuh+ di rlu}+ }a eh oxiihkhm }a gavhuichi} aood`dlkp di

5

@lph


3/24

vdakl}dai ao }jh O@RL) ]jhph jdgj#khvhk hcrkathhp }jhuhoauh nihw+ au whuh phvhuhkt uh`nkhpp diia} niawdig+ }jl} Lk`l}hk rldm eudehp }a oauhdgi gavhuichi} aood dlkp)

=) Et clndig }jhph rltchi}p+ Lk l}hk vdakl}hm }jh O@RL lp di`auraul}hm di}a }jhohmhulk ph`xud}dhp klwp lp Ph`}daip 02L+


4/24

}ulmhm ai }jh Ihw Taun P}a`n Hz`jligh *%ITPH%$) Lp px`j+ mxudig }jh }dch }jh uhkhvli}`aimx } a``xuuhm+ L


5/24

rhudam+ Lk`l}h< mh @ap}l Ud`l'p odili`dlk uhpxk}p whuh di`kxmhm di }jh `aipakdml}hm odili`dlkp}l}hchi}p }jl} Lk`l}hk odkhm wd}j }jh @accdppdai)


6/24

pxepdmdlut wd}j }jh `xp}achu ài}ul`} *Lk`l}hk @D] oau cap} ao}jh lguhhchi}p }jl} luh uhohuhi`hmdi }jdp àcrkldi}$+ lim ao vludaxp ghagulrjd`lk uhgdaip lkk lrruavhm }jh uh}hi}dai ao }jhàipxk}li}p)


7/24

P}limlum waxkm lx}jaudh }jhc) ]jh ài}uakp Lk`l}hk jlm di rkl`h whuh dipxood dhi} }a ruhvhi}eudehut eh`lxph Lk`l}hkhcrkathhp hd}jhu mdpuhglumhm au `du`xcvhi}hm }jhc et ruavdmdigdiàcrkh}h lim dil``xul}h dioaucl}dai }a }japh divakvhm di }jh uhvdhw rua`hpp) Odilkkt+ lk}jaxgjLk l}hk jlm l udpn lpphppchi} àccd}}hh+ d} }trd`lkkt oa`xphm ai dppxhp }jl} whuh kdnhkt }a uhpxk}di `xp}achu klwpxd}p lim ia} ai eudehut au hz`hppdvh àccdppdaip }a expdihpp àipxk}li}p)

L) ]jh @ap}l Ud`l Eudehut P`jhch52) Ouac Mh`hcehu 522< }a A`}aehu 522=+ Lk`l}hk eudehm gavhuichi} aood`dlkp di

@ap}l Ud`l }a ae}ldi }hkhàccxid`l}daip ài}ul`}p vlkxhm l} lrruazdcl}hkt -020 cdkkdai)5


8/24

_lkvhumh lim Plrpddli jduhm }jh àipxk}li}p di rlu} }a eudeh aood`dlkp di }jh gavhuichi} ao@ap}lUd`l di hz`jligh oau }hkhàccxid`l}daip ài}ul`}p)

50) _lkvhumh'p eua}jhu#di#klw awihm lim ài}uakkhm @ap}l Ud`li @aipxk}li} L)Jawhvhu+ _lkvhumh di}hi}dailkkt acd}}hm }jdp ol`} ouac }jh àcrlit ruaodkh jh ruhrluhm limpxecd}}hm }a Lk`l}hk P}limlum) Lk`l}hk P}limlum oldkhm }a àimx } lmh|xl}h mxh mdkdghi`h ai@ap}l Ud`li @aipxk}li} L lim+ }jhuhoauh+ ihvhu dmhi}dodhm d}p uhgdp}huhm pjluhjakmhup lim xk}dcl}hehihod`dlk awihu)

5=) Di Iavhcehu 5222+ rudau }a l oauclk va}h et }jh D@H Ealum ao Mduh`}aup+Plrpddli lim _lkvhumh aoohuhm l eudeh }a li D@H mduh`}au *%D@H Mduh`}au L%$ }a eh rldm }juaxgj

) +@ap}l Ud`li @aipxk}li} L) Prh`dod`lkkt+ }jht aoohuhm jdc


9/24

5?) Ouac Clu`j 522< }a Clu`j 5220+ Lk`l}hk P}limlum+ ai ehjlko ao Lk`l}hk @D]+hzh`x}hm l} khlp} odvh àipxk}dig lguhhchi}p wd}j @ap}l Ud`li @aipxk}li} L+ di wjd`j Lk`l}hk@D] ruacdphm }a rlt xr }a 4)78( ao}jh vlkxh ao lit ài}ul`} d} lppdp}hm Lk`l}hk @D] di ae}ldidigwd}j }jh D@H # l cx`j jdgjhu àccdppdai ul}h }jli iauclkkt lwlumhm }a px`j l àipxk}li}) Diuh}xui+ }jh àipxk}dig lguhhchi}p uh|xduhm @ap}l Ud`li @aipxk}li} L }a rhuoauc vlgxhkt#mhpùdehm clunh}dig lim lmvdpaut phuvd`hp) @ap}l Ud`li @aipxk}li} L ùhl}hm divad`hprxurau}hmkt oau àccdppdaip uhkl}hm }a }jh ài}ul`}p lwlumhm }a Lk l}hk @D]) D} }jhi pxecd}}hm}japh divad`hp+ }juaxgj _lkvhumh+ }a Lk l}hk @D])

57) P}lu}dig di Mh`hcehu 522


10/24

Ruhpdmhi}dlk @limdml}h -


11/24

0


12/24

0?) Di Oheuxlut 5225+ di Nht Edp`ltih+ Okaudml+ Plrpddli lim lia}jhu Lk l}hk @D]hcrkathh ch} wd}j }jh eua}jhu ao l jdgj#ulindig hzh`x}dvh euli`j aood`dlk di }jh gavhuichi} aoJaimxulp }a mdp`xpp jaw }jh eua}jhup lim Lk`l}hk àxkm lppdp} hl`j a}jhu) Plrpddli rlu}d`drl}hmdi }jdp chh}dig }a clnh pxuh }jh eua}jhup ximhup}aam }jl} Lk`l}hk'p xrrhu clilghchi} di Ouli`hpxrrau}hm lit ruacdph clmh }a }jhc) ]jh hzh`x}dvh euli`j aood`dlk'p eua}jhu uh|xhp}hm }jl}Lk`l}hk uh}ldi l prh`dod` àipxk}dig àcrlit di Jaimxulp *%Jaimxuli @aipxk}li}%$)

07) Kl}hu di 5225+ Lk`l}hk @D] dioauclkkt uh}ldihm }jh Jaimxuli @aipxk}li} limruacdphm }a rlt d} àccdppdaip ao 0( }a 8( ao }jh vlkxh ao `hu}ldi ài}ul`}p Lk l}hk @D]

ph`xuhm di Jaimxulp) ]jh Jaimxuli'@aipxk}li} uhruhphi}hm rhuoxch lim àpch}d`p àcrlidhpdi Jaimxulp lim arhul}hm lp li hz`kxpdvh mdp}udex}au ao eulim ilch oulguli`hp) ]jh Jaimxuli@aipxk}li} jlm ia ài}l`}p di+ au rudau hzrhudhi`h wd}j+ }jh }hkhàccxid`l}daip dimxp}ut diJaimxulp) ]jh hzh`x}dvh euli`j aood`dlk'p eua}jhu ài}uakkhm }jh Jaimxuli @aipxk}li} limLk`l}hk @D]'p pakh rxuraph oau uh}ldidig }jdp àipxk}li} wlp }a gldi l``hpp }a }jh jdgj#ulindighzh`x}dvh euli`j aood`dlk lim diokxhi`h }jh mh`dpdaip ao }jh Hcruhpl Jaimxuhodl mh]hkhàcxid l`daihp *%Jaimx}hk%$+ }jh Jaimxuli gavhuichi}#awihm }hkhàccxid`l}daipruavdmhu uhpraipdekh oau lwlumdig lim lmcdidp}hudig rxekd` }himhup oau }hkhàccxid`l}daipài}ul`}p di Jaimxulp)

0:) Lp l uhpxk} ao Lk`l}hk 'p lguhhchi} }a uh}ldi lim rlt }jh Jaimxuli @aipxk}li}+}jhuh wlp pdgidod`li} ruhppxuh ai Jaimx}hk+ lim ai }jh phidau gavhuichi} aood`dlkp pd}}dig ai d}pEalum aoMduh`}aup+ }a nhhr Lk`l}hk @D] lim lia}jhu Lk`l}hk pxepdmdlut lp }jh ài}ul`}aup ai odvhài}ul`}p wjd`j whuh lwlumhm ouac 5225 }juaxgj 5220+ wau}j l }a}lk ao leax} -=: cdkkdai+ diprd}h ao pdgidod`li} oldkxuhp di rhuoaucli`h }jl} àxkm jlvh uhpxk}hm di }hucdil}dai ximhu }jh}hucp ao }jh lguhhchi}) ]jhph ài}ul }p di kxmhm l -5)0? cdkkdai ài}ul`} pdgihm ai Iavhcehu


13/24

l - l -5)=4 cdkkdai `ai}ul`} pdgihm ai Mh`hcehu ?+ 5220+ lim l -


14/24

=


15/24

@) ]jh ]ldwli Eudehut P`jhch==) Ouac A`}aehu 5220 }a Clt 522=+ Lk`l}hk eudehm gavhuichi} aood`dlkp di ]ldwli

}a ae}ldi l uldkwlt lzkh `axi}dig `ai}ul`} vlkxhm l} lrruazdcl}hkt -57 cdkkdai)=8) L phidau Lk`l}hk hcrkathh+ l} }jh }dch Mduh`}au ao Di}huil}dailk Expdihpp lim

Plkhp l} L


16/24

=:) Di Clt 522=+ Lk`l}hk PHK rldm l àccdppdai ao lrruazdcl}hkt -452+222 }a]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} L }juaxgj d}p l`àxi} l} LEI Lcua Elin di Ihw Taun) L} vludaxp}dchp+ ]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} L rldm eudehp }a }wa ]ldwlihph khgdpkl}aup+ Khgdpkl}au L limKhgdpkl}au E)

=4) Khgdpkl}au L lppdp}hm Lk`l}hk di àivdi`dig }jh ]UL }jl} Lk`l}hk PHK'p ptp}hcpl}dpodhm }jh }h`jid lk uh|xduhchi}p ao }jh }himhup) Jh lkpa rxekd`kt pxrrau}hm Lk`l}hk PHK'p edmlim ruavdmhm lmvd`h }a Lk`l}hk PHK ài`huidig d}p ]UL ma`xchi}p) Khgdpkl}au E+ di }xc+ wlpuh|xhp}hm }a lk}hu }jh ]UL'p }h`jid`lk prh`dod`l}daip }a dcruavh Lk l}hk PHK'p edmmdig `jli`hp)Lk}jaxgj d} dp xi`khlu jaw cx`j ao Lk l}hk PHK'p -452+222 hvhi}xlkkt okawhm }a oauhdgigavhuichi} aood`dlkp+ }jh awihu ao ]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} L ruacdphm -


17/24

àipxk}dig lguhhchi} eh}whhi li Lk`l}hk loodkdl}h lim ]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} E+ hvhi }jaxgj]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} E wlp ihvhu hzrh`}hm }a ruavdmh lit phuvd`hp }a Lk`l}hk au d}p loodkdl}h)Li Lk`l}hk loodkdl}h rldm lrruazdcl}hkt -0?+222 }a ]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} E di 522=)

85) Khgdpkl}aup L+ E+ lim @ whuh %oauhdgi aood`dlkp% wd}jdi }jh chlidig ao }jh O@RLlim whuh di l pdgidod`li} rapd}dai }a diokxhi`h }jh rakd`t mh`dpdaip }jh ]ULclmh)

80) ]jh ohhp Lk`l}hk PHK lim Lk`l}hk'p loodkdl}h rldm }a ]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} L lim]ldwlihph @aipxk}li} E+ uhprh }dvhkt+ eauh ia uhkl}dai }a l }xlk phuvd`hp }jhph hi}d}dhp ruavdmhm}a Lk`l}hk)

8=) Ai Mh`hcehu 02+ 5220+ }jh ]UL l``hr}hm li Lk`l}hk loodkdl}h'p rud`h edm limguli}hm }jh loodkdl}h l pxrrkt ài}ul`} wau}j lrruazdcl}hkt -57 cdkkdai)

M) ]jhClkltpdl Eudehut P`jhch88) Ouac A`}aehu 522= }a Oheuxlut 522?+ Lk`l}hk eudehm gavhuichi} aood`dlkp di

Clkltpdl }a ae}ldi àiodmhi}dlk dioaucl}dai uhkl}dig }a l rxekd` }himhu }jl} Lk`l}hk xk}dcl}hktwai+ }jh uhpxk} ao wjd`j tdhkmhm l }hkhàccxid`l}daip ài}ul`} vlkxhm l} lrruazdcl}hkt -:8cdkkdai)

8?) ]hkhnac Clkltpdl dp }jh Clkltpdli gavhuichi}#awihm }hkhàccxid`l}daipàcrlit }jl} ruavdmhp }hkhàccxid`l}daip phuvD`hp+ hvlkxl}hp edmp+ lim lwlump}hkhàccxid`l}daip ài}ul`}p DD D Clkltpdl) ]jh Clkltpdli Cdidp}ut ao Odili`h awihmlrruazdcl}hkt =0( ao ]hkhnac Clkltpdl'p pjluhp+ jlm vh}a rawhu avhu lkk d}p clfauhzrhimd}xuhp+ lim clmh d}p nht arhul}dailk mh`dpdaip) ]jh gavhuichi} awihm d}p di}huhp} di]hkhnac Clkltpdl }juaxgj }jh Cdidp}hu ao Odili`h+ wja jlm }jh p}l}xp ao l %prh`dlkpjluhjakmhu)% Cap} phidau ]hkhnac Clkltpdl aood hup whuh rakd}d`lk lrradi}hhp+ di`kxmdig }jh


18/24

@jldiili lim Mduh`}au+ }jh @jldiili ao }jh Ealum ao }jh ]himhu @accd}}hh+ lim }jh Hzh`x}dvhMduh`}au)

87) Eh}whhi A`}aehu 522= lim Oheuxlut 522?+ Lk`l}hk Clkltpdl rhupaiihk rldmeudehp }a hcrkathhp ao ]hkhnac Clkltpdl di hz`jligh oau iai#rxekd` dioaiil}dai) ]jdp iairxekd` dioaiil}dai di`kxmhm dcrau}li} ma`xchi}p lim exmgh} dioaiil}dai uhkl}dig }a aigadigedmp lim àcrh}d}au rud dig dioaiil}dai) Lk l}hk Clkltpdl'p clilghchi} àiphi}hm }a }jhphrltchi}p)

8:) ]jhph eudehp lppdp}hm Lk l}hk Clkltpdl di ae}ldidig l ài}ul`} wd}j l ra}hi}dlkvlkxh ao-:8 cdkkdai)

84) ]jh ]hkhnac Clkltpdl hcrkathhp wja uh`hdvhm eudehp whuh %oauhdgi aood`dlkp%wd}jdi }jh chlidig ao }jh O@RL lim whuh di l pdgidod`li} rapd}dai }a diokxhi`h }jh rakd`tmh dpdaip ]hkhnacClkltpdl clmh)

?2) Lk`l}hk P}limlum lkpa clmh pdgidod`li} kxcr#pxc rltchi}p }juaxgj X)P) elinl`àxi}p }a }wa àipxk}li}p *%Clkltpdli @aipxk}li} L% lim %Clkltpdli @aipxk}li} E%$+rxurau}hmkt oau clunh} uhphlu j)

?


19/24

?0) ]jhph àipxk}li}p lkpa waunhm oau L pdgidig au lrruavdig pjlc àipxk}dig lguhhchi}p di }jhXid}hm P}l}hp }a ài`hlk }jh eudehut p`jhch> lim }ulipcd}}dig cldk+ hkh`}uaid` cldk+ lim ol`pdcdkhchpplghp di lim ax} ao}jh Xid}hm P}l}hp)

O) Lk`l}hk Oldkhm }a Cldi}ldi D}p Eaanp lim Uhàump?8) Lk`l}hk clmh ixchuaxp rltchi}p }a }jdum rlu}dhp D D D wltp }jl} aep`xuhm }jh

rxuraph oau+ lim }jh xk}dcl}h uh`drdhi}p ao+ }jh rltchi}p) Di rlu}d`xklu+ L


20/24

dil``xul}hkt mhpùdehm }jh phuvD`hp ruavdmhm> *=$ ghihul}dig olkph divad`hp lim a}jhu olkphma`xchi}p }a fxp}dot rltchi}p> *8$ mdpexupdig oximp di `lpj wd}j dil``xul}h ma`xchi}l}dailx}jauddig au pxrrau}dig }jh wd}jmulwlkp> *?$ uhàumdig dkkd`d} rltchi}p lp khgd}dcl}h àipxk}digohhp> lim *7$ uhàumdig eudehp lp rltchi} oau khgd}dcl}h phuvd`hp)

G) Lk`l}hk Oldkhm }a Cldi}ldi Lmh|xl}h Di}huilk @ai}uakp??) Lk`l}hk oldkhm }a dcrkhchi} lmh|xl}h di}huilk ài}uakp }a àcrkt wd}j }jh

àcrlit'p ITPH kdp}dig+ di`kxmdig }jh mh}h`}dai lim ruhvhi}dai ao vdakl}daip ao }jh O@RL)Odup}+ Lk`l}hk lim!au d}p pxepdmdludhp olkpdodhm eaanp lim uhàump+ hi}huhm di}a lguhhchi}p

uh}ual`}dvhkt+ lim aep`xuhm }jh rxuraph oau+ lim xk}dcl}h uh`drdhi} ao+ dkkd`d} rltchi}p) Lk l}hkxphm expdihpp àipxk}li}p lim di}huchmdludhp }a oxiihk eudehp di l} khlp} oaxu àxi}udhp) Lk l}hkùhl}hm lim xphm olkph divad`hp lim rltchi} ma`xchi}l}dai ximhu expdihpp àipxk}diglguhhchi}p }jl} mhp udehm phuvd`hp }jl} whuh ihvhu di}himhm }a eh uhimhuhm) Dkk d d} rltchi}pwhuh olkphkt uhàumhm lp hzrhiphp oau àipxk}dig ohhp)

?7) Phàim+ Lk`l}h< lkpa uax}dihkt `du`xcvhi}hm }jh di}huilk ài}uakp }jh àcrlitjlm di rkl`h) Lk}jaxgj }jh àcrlit di }jhaut jlm l rakd`t ao %`jh`np lim elkli`hp% }alx}jaudh }jh uh}hi}dai ao expdihpp àipxk}li}p+ wjd`j uh|xduhm phvhulk pdgil}xuhp }a lrruavh }jhuh}hi}dai ao+ lim rltchi} }a+ expdihpp àipxk}li}p+ Lk`l}hk hcrkathhp ao}hi vdakl}hm }jl} rakd`t)Di ixchuaxp dip}li`hp+ Lk`l}hk aood dlkp uhpraipdekh oau uhvdhwdig mxh mdkdghi`h uhrau}p aiàipxk}li}p oldkhm }a àimx`} lit uhvdhw ao }jh ma`xchi}p au àxkm ia} uhlm }jh kligxlgh diwjd`j }jh ma`xchi}p whuh wud}}hi) Lk`l}hk hcrkathhp lkpa hi}huhm di}a lguhhchi}p uh}ual`}dvhktlim aep`xuhm }jh lcaxi}p rldm }a expdihpp àipxk}li}p et prkd}}dig }jh rltchi}p lcaig phrlul}hlguhhchi}p *}a ài`hlk }jh jdgj àccdppdaip Lk`l}h< rldm$) Odilkkt+ Lk`l}hk P}limlum'p mxhmdkdghi`h ai expdihpp àipxk}li}p wlp dilmh|xl}h+ lim Lk`l}hk @D] ao}hi rldm expdihpp

52

@lph


21/24

àipxk}li}p wd}jax} lmh|xl}h ruaao ao phuvd`hp uhimhuhm) Lk l}hk @D] oldkhm }a hp}lekdpj uaexp}ài}uakp avhu `lpj mdpexuphchi}p+ lkkawhm clixlk rltchi}p wd}jax} ma`xchi}l}dai+ limLk`l}hk'p O@RL àcrkdli`h oxi }dai wlp ximhup}loohm lim kl`nhm dimhrhimhi`h) Lk l}hk lkpaoldkhm }a àimx`} }jauaxgj li}d#eudehut lim àuuxr}dai }uldidig)

@KLDCP OAU UHKDHOODUP] @AXI]

_dakl}daip ao Ph`}dai 02L ao }jh Hz`jligh L`}?:) ]jh @accdppdai uhlkkhghp lim diàuraul}hp et uhohuhi`h Rlulgulrjp < }juaxgj

?7)?4) Lp mhpùdehm leavh+ Lk`l}hk+ }juaxgj d}p aood`hup+ lghi}p+ pxepdmdludhp+ lim

loodkdl}hp+ àuuxr}kt aoohuhm+ ruacdphm }a rlt+ au lx}jaudhm dkkd`d} rltchi}p }a l rhupai+ wjdkhniawdig }jl} lkk au l rau}dai ao }japh rltchi}p waxkm eh aoohuhm+ gdvhi+ au ruacdphm+ mduh`}kt audimduh`}kt+ }a oauhdgi aood dlkp oau }jh rxuraphp ao diokxhi`dig }jhdu l`}p au mh`dpdaip di }jhduaood`dlk `lrl`d}t+ dimx`dig }jhc }a ma au acd} }a ma l }daip di vdakl}dai ao }jhdu klwoxk mx}dhp+ph`xudig li dcruarhu lmvli}lgh+ au dimx`dig px`j oauhdgi aood`dlkp }a xph }jhdu diokxhi`h wd}j loauhdgi gavhuichi} au dip}uxchi}lkd}t }jhuhao }a lppdp} Lk`l}hk di ae}ldidig au uh}ldidig expdihpp)

72) Et uhlpai ao }jh oauhgadig+ Lk l}hk vdakl}hm }jh li}d#eudehut ruavdpdaip ao }jhO@RL+ lp àmdodhm l} Ph`}dai 02L ao}jh Hz`jligh L`} ^


22/24

75) Lp mhpùdehm leavh+ Lk`l}hk+ }juaxgj d}p aood`hup+ lghi}p+ pxepdmdludhp+ limloodkdl}hp+ oldkhm }a clnh lim nhhr eaanp+ uhàump+ lim l`àxi}p wjd`j+ di uhlpailekh mh}ldk+l``xul}hkt lim oldukt uhokh }hm d}p }ulipl`}daip lim mdprapd}daip ao d}p lpph}p)

70) Et uhlpai ao }jh oauhgadig+ Lk`l}hk vdakl}hm }jh eaanp#lim#uhàump ruavdpdaip ao}jh O@RL+ lp àmdodhm l} Ph`}dai


23/24

OAXU]J @AXI]_dakl}daip ao Ph`}dai


24/24

Ml}hm6 Mh`hcehuX+ 52

securities and exchange commission v. alcatel-lucent, s.a (sobornos hondutel)

Documents