search marketing master class - kevin lee, didit
TRANSCRIPT
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
2-Hour Search Marketing Master Class
Presented byKevin Lee
Executive Chairman
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential @kevin_lee_QED
Kevin Lee founded Didit in 1996, and has grown it beyond SEM PPC campaign optimization with nine acquisitions.
Didit offers an advanced stand alone bid management platform at Bidit.Didit.com.
Kevin has written three books, over 550 columns in ClickZ and other publications, and spoken at over 400 conferences.
At Didit, we believe “Marketing is Everything” for any business and that why we made 9 acquisitions to become fell service.
2007
2007, 2008, 2009
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Why am I here?Over the last 18 years I’ve hired and interviewed hundreds of PPC, SEO Content Marketing and Social Media “specialists.”
• Many of you get REALLY important things WRONG.
• I don’t want you to be caught doing something wrong.
• SEO and SEM may be the most powerful tool in your marketing toolbox.
Objective: Get you promoted, a raise or a better job because you’ll remember me when you need digital marketing help. You can’t do everything yourself!
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Your Greatest Enemy!
Time!
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential @kevin_lee_QED
What’s the best use of your time. Paid or Earned Media? Testing? • What should you do yourself?• What should you hire others to do?• How long will earned media investments take to pay back?Figuring out what to do first every day and what will deliver the biggest improvement in KPIs @ scale is the key.
What should you do first today?
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential @kevin_lee_QED
There are multi-day multi-track conferences on SEM & SEO. But I’ll condense it down to: • Paid Search • SEO Basics / Webmaster Tools / Search Console• SEO Content Marketing• SEO Content Promotion• Video SEO• SEO for Mobile• Reputation Mgmt. / Content Syndication
Elements of Search Marketing
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential @kevin_lee_QED
For Paid Placement & PLAs you have choices: • Google AdWords including lots of extensions• Google PLAs a few extensions• Bing adCenter• Bing PLAs• Yahoo Gemini• Others: International (Yandex, Baidu)
PPC (Paid Placement / PLAs)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Keyword Clicks Too Expensive?
Wall Street is confused. Are you?
Mobile Shift and New Ad Types
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential @kevin_lee_QED
Media Auctions Can Be Painful,
The Winner’s Curse There are only two kinds of marketers at the top of the PPC search results:• Brilliant Marketers• The idiots. Irrational bidders, even in a recessionSuccess requires figuring out how to either:a) Be the brilliant marketer that can AFFORD a top position (WHEN IT MATTERS)
b) Deal effectively with those buying market share irrationally When irrational bidders bid very high on broad match terms long tail keyword expansion strategies fade in effectiveness.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Leverage is Power, Profit
• Pre-click leverage = Quality Score• Larger Shopping Cart or > lead quality• Conversion Rate increases
Each of these provide you with leverage.
lev·er·age lévvərij 2. mechanical advantage: the mechanical advantage gained by using a lever3. power to get things done: power over other people, especially something that gives an advantage but is not referred to openly
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
The Math Behind Compound Impact
Every improvement you make raises the possible maxbid…
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Bid Management Matters Most in your top 10%We analyzed our top 25 clients, see what we found. The top 10 % spending keywords spend 80% of $
spend 80 percent 90 percent total keywords with spendPercent of keywords spending 80 Percent of spend
Percent of keywords spending 90 Percent of spend
$913,655.01 910 1633 9515 9.56% 17.16%
$692,437.78 13 30 5190 0.25% 0.58%6 10 11093 0.05% 0.09%
29 171 3598 0.81% 4.75%440 788 4187 10.51% 18.82%
15 40 1118 1.34% 3.58%
2679 5225 50734 5.28% 10.30%73 180 6264 1.17% 2.87%
897 2770 26196 3.42% 10.57%
246 447 3863 6.37% 11.57%
7 11 2194 0.32% 0.50%39 79 1314 2.97% 6.01%
135 259 1740 7.76% 14.89%
31 64 1034 3.00% 6.19%
123 269 4837 2.54% 5.56%
1140 2205 11315 10.08% 19.49%281 548 5256 5.35% 10.43%
7 23 1794 0.39% 1.28%51 88 670 7.61% 13.13%58 113 1122 5.17% 10.07%
137 275 16058 0.85% 1.71%101 195 1269 7.96% 15.37%474 868 4365 10.86% 19.89%
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Your top 10%
Nearly ALL your efforts should be deployed against the top 10 percent of spending keywords.
• Have the right bids REAL TIME!• Have the best campaign structure• Have the right settings in Mobile and Desktop• Best possible ad copy and ad extensions• Best possible landing pages• Best images in PLA ads (similar distribution)• Optimal Geography (overlays on national)• Time of Day (in TV it’s Drive-time vs Daytime)• Day of Week (do weekends have an effect?)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Top down sort is the most powerful free tool you have
Tactical, opportunity identification
Impressions = opportunityPosition may not be “affordable”
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Chasing the Long Tail, the Wrong Tail
In PPC the long tail is DEAD if you want a raise and promotion focus on the head of the keyword distribution.
• Going long won’t work because someone
with broader match type will likely prevail• What do you actually win when your
adrank is high enough for you to serve?
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential @kevin_lee_QED
“How many Segments are you running?”
Segmentation levers are best used on power keywords. So, use targeting against the power keywords!
Pick the clicks you want most and target to segment predicted profitability. Your levers:
• Syndication, Content vs Search (same creative? different?)• Syndication site targeting in content networks (image ads?)• Geography (overlays on national campaigns)• Time of Day (in TV it’s Drive-time vs Daytime)• Day of Week (do weekends have an effect? certain days?)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Strategic Bidding, Dayparting
Not bidding based on daypart and day of the week?Congratulations, your bid is right as often as a broken clock is correctUse API-based tools or use the GUI to do the best you can.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Dayparting, Out Of Stock, Feedback Loop
Dayparting is only one reason why you might want a real-time bid management solution.Faster reaction time to:• Inventory issues• Site outages• Broken tracking
Why we never did the Google Analytics API integration with Maestro or Bidit.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
USER
User served displayAd User Searches
User served displayAd
User VisitsWebsite User Converts
Touch Point Analysis
Attribution Modeling isn’t enough.Media mix modeling, Marginal Elasticity
Marginal elasticity of every media option is key!!In economics, elasticity is the ratio of the percent change in one variable to the percent change in another variable. It is a tool for measuring the responsiveness of a function to changes in parameters in a unit-less way. Frequently used elasticities include price elasticity of demand, price elasticity of supply, income elasticity of demand, elasticity of substitution between factors of production and elasticity of intertemporal substitution.
Elasticity is one of the most important concepts in economic theory. In addition when understanding how to allocate media dollars, nothing beats knowing the elasticity of the market in every direction.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Elasticity: Google can’t tell the full storyElasticity estimates assume complacent competitors.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
What keywords are more or less elastic?
Think about how keyword elasticity impacts your optimization strategy.
If a keyword is inelastic, less reason to move to improve:
a) Quality score / CTRb) Conversion rate
Sure more conversion would be great but if it doesn’t have the multiplier effect of higher position, might be best to focus elsewhere.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Is your bid management “hooked up” correctly?
Many bid management / campaigns management platforms “make it easy” - use your GA tags to communicate conversion rate by keyword.
Remember that averages don’t reflect reality.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
SEM and the Buying CycleCampaign Goals and Objectives should line up with the profile of the searcher. Some people also classify the keywords based on commercial intent (how interested in commerce are the searchers?) Problem with letting Google run the bids for you.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Microconversions - Avinash Kaushik
Which of these apply to you? What value?• E-mail Newsletter Registrations•Visits To The Contact Us Page •Phone Calls •Deep Navigation from the landing page•Facebook Likes or Apps Twitter Follows / Tweets•LinkedIn Share (particularly for B2B)•Google G+ Engagement
Will management give you credit for these? Sell them on it. (It will empower your marketing)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Sort by different variables. Top Down or Bottom Up
Top Down within Geo-Analytics too
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
- Average conversion rate: 1.5%
- New York City DMA conversion rate: 2.1%
→ You can bid over 25% more for NYC DMA clicks.
Geotargeting: Conversion Rate
Differences
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Geotargeting: higher spenders
Las Vegas DMA shopping cart: $178
Average shopping cart: $122
→ you can bid 45%+ more for Vegas metro clicks.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Geotargeting: higher LTVChicago DMA customers from search order more often and for more years
Average number of orders over 3-years: 10
Chicago DMA number of orders over 3-years: 15
→ you can bid 50% more CHI
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
B-to-B? Can you Predict Lead Quality?
What targetable variables predict lead quality?
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Have enough budget and time? Split the country (or other geography) • Raise spending in some areas but keep control groups• The bigger the spend the less time you’ll need for data• Watch for increases in brand search impression counts• Watch for increased CTR on brand and category ads• Re-normalize the geographies • Repeat switching the on and off geographies to be able to validate both lift and decay.Was there Brand lift, Quality Score lift?
Assist KW or Mobile Assist - Prove it! Interaction Test - Mini Mix Model
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
If you’ll be repeating an analysis a lot: • Check to see if you can do the optimization with an
AdWords script (lots of preexisting ones).• Check with your bid management platform to see what
they facilitate.• Ask your agency if they have a solution (although for
many of these best practices, I’d hope they proactively are doing them.)
How do you do all this
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
The POWER SEGMENT:A Perfect Storm of large, divergent Segments.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
SEO: You need the right site strategy
There’s a major algorithmic shift happening at Google and the other engines. To achieve a strategy that works for immediate results and future ranking requires that we understand the rapid evolution of the algorithms.So, I’ve highlighted the collective wisdom of the industry, from Google to Moz.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
SEO is a MeritocracyDon’t expect to rank / positions you don’t deserve. Search engines are on a mission.Find the SEO “white space”
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Before Delving Into Specific Recommendations
There’s a major algorithmic shift happening at Google and the other engines. To win now and also get future ranking requires understanding the evolution of the algorithms PLUS things that haven’t changed.
So, I’ve highlighted the collective wisdom of the industry, from Google & SearchEngineLand to Moz.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
SEO is Chemistry meets CookingMostly science with a bit of art (SearchEngineLand periodic SEO chart)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Goog/Bing decided
links > contentI doubt Rand’s %
could be that accurate
Courtesy: Rand Fishkin, Wizard of Moz
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
From Language, Comes Intent. Not Just Keywords
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Comingling of data sources. Beyond universal search
Google has separate databases for images, news, videos, etc. That’s universal search.But they have gone beyond that to use shema and other data to understand the relationships between the data sources.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
When Does Freshness Matter? Google Knows!
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Google Imputes Likely Intent
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Google admits to using Machine Learning for Image Recognition & Classification
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Machine Learning in Image Recognition & Classification
Via Jeff Dean’s Slides on Deep Learning; a Must Read for SEOs
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
ML in Image Recognition Emotion/Behavior
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
“Watson” Style Learning:
Via: IBM PPT on Slideshare
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Google’s RankBrain is taking over.
Google’s RankBrain
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
No Human Will Know Why Something RanksMetrics Drive The Algo
Long to Short Click Ratio Relative CTR vs. Other Results
Rate of Searchers Conducting Additional, Related Searches
Metrics of User Engagement on the Page
Metrics of User Engagement Across the Domain
Sharing/Amplifcation Rate vs. Other Results
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Still need the old ranking inputs
There are two major classes of factors:On-The-Page: factors that are largely within the control of site ownersOff-The-Page: factors are influenced often by others or not directly tied to a site
Within these two classes are seven categories of factors, which are:Content – factors relating to the content and quality of your materialArchitecture – factors about your overall site functionalityHTML – factors specific to web pagesTrust – factors related to how trustworthy & authoritative a site seems to beLinks – factors related to how links impact rankingsPersonal – factors about how personalized search results influence rankingsSocial – factors on how social recommendations impact rankings
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Layer in Searcher Behavior Outputs
• Visits (search, direct and other)• Time on site• Bounce rate• Pageviews per session• Sharing via Gmail?• Repeat visits
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Classic On-Site SEO(ranking inputs)
New On-Site SEO(searcher outputs) via Moz
Keyword Targeting Relative CTR
Short vs. Long-Click
Content Gap Fulfillment
Amplification & Loyalty
Task Completion Success
Quality & Uniqueness
Crawl/Bot Friendly
Snippet Optimization
UX / Multi-Device
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Get your CTR up, your position will rise
A click (and low bounce) is a signal of relevance. So, get your CTR up.
Via Philip Petrescu on Moz
So, is this why sites that get more site traffic rank higher?Causation and correlation aren’t the same ;-)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Every Element Counts (Inspired by Moz)
Is the title compelling? Is the URL aligned?Is your domain relevant
Did you get organic sitelinks?
Does the description support action &
relevance?
Brand dropdown?
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Why does social activity predict SEO success?
Google is clearly looking for things it can see that correlate with social media metrics, if not the social data directly:
• Dwell time• Bounce rate• Deeper navigation from the landing page• Email data (look for shared links in Gmail?)• Google G+ Engagement
Will management give you credit for these? Sell them on it. (It will empower your marketing)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Google doesn’t use raw social shares as a
ranking input.We share based on
publisher and headline.
Via Chartbeat
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Google Could Be Using a Lot of Other Metrics/Sources to Get Data That Mimics Social Shares. From Moz
Clickstream (from Chrome/Android)
Engagement (from Chrome/Android)
Branded Queries (from Search)
Navigational Queries (from Search)
Rate of Link Growth (from Crawl)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Buzz Index: Social Engagement Per 1,000 Visits
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Return Visitor Ratio Over Time
Total Visitor Sessions
÷
# of Returning Visitors
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Knowing What Makes Our Audience (particularly influencers) Share is Essential
From an analysis of the 10,000 pieces of content receiving the most social shares on the web by Buzzsumo.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Keyword Targeting Relative CTR
Short vs. Long-Click
Content Gap Fulfillment
Amplify & Return Rates
Task Completion Success
Quality & Uniqueness
Crawl/Bot Friendly
Snippet Optimization
UX / Multi-Device
Engines People
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
From Theory to Strategy
How do we create great content that humans love enough to send Google and the other engines the ranking signals that the AI will react to?How do we continue to double down on the ranking actors that while less important in the future are still important now? Links in particular are still tie-breakers.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Departments Can Lend a Hand
SEO isn’t purely a marketing function.Other departments have information that makes for great content and relationships that help SEO.The key is having the right strategy.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Where should content live?
SEO may be superior when content “lives” elsewhere.• LinkedIn• Medium• Industry Magazines• Influencer Blogs• Op-Ed pieces
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Content & Profiles for Reputation Management
Reputation management problem for company or exec name?• LinkedIn• Twitter• Facebook• Medium• Industry Magazines• Influencer Blogs• Op-Ed pieces
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Department List
Some departments may be able to help SEO with little additional effort on their part.
1. Buyers / Supply Chain2. HR3. Talent Relations4. Store / Store Managers5. Facilities / Real Estate6. Customer Service7. Product Development
8. IT9. Public Relations10. Purchasing (non resale)11. Investor Relations12. Operations10. Marketing
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Explore Ideas
Each department may be able to move the ranking needle in very different ways. By understanding Google’s current and likely future algos, we can brainstorm. How can the department contribute to:a) Delighting customers / UX (online and off)b) Creating contentc) Driving links and other ranking signals
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Supply Chain
Who is your supply chain?
Links does it also help them if they link to you?
Hosting your co-created content?
Are they influencers? Or socially active?
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
HRLinks: Job board links aren’t worth much. Links from a recruiter are & if you let the recruiter mention you, get a link.
Content: HR can facilitate creation of content by staff outside the marketing department. Have a system to steward that content and reward creators.
Buzz: Happy employees probably delight customers, create positive buzz.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Facilities / Real Estate
Links: Most stores have a landlord. Often a mall operator. Links from mall sites will strengthen both local SEO and overall.Content: Partner with malls to create content that delights customers. Use that content and get buzz and links.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Customer Service
Links: While customer service delighting customers might result in links, it’s more likely to generate positive buzz socially.
Content: Customer Service knows how customers are using products or services and the problems and challenges they face.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Public Relations
Links: Press release links are not seen as very valuable by search engines. However hard links from publishers or broadcasters are still valuable.
Content: That’s what PR does, tell stories and create content.
Buzz: Influencers of all types are being solicited by PR teams (internal and external)
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Investor Relations
Links: Links from research reports, sites that list the ticker and company bio and investing press.
Content: There may be some content opportunities.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Marketing
Links: Links from agencies and all those providing marketing services including sign makers, printers.
Content: Agencies like to brag. They also create content for a living.
Buzz: Are they influencers?
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
SEO Conclusion
Strategic SEO requires initiatives driving quick results, plus assure future success.Sometimes a third party can:1. Do SEO training across the enterprise2. Facilitate and organize3. Help prioritize based on both SEO and non-SEO
value4. Provide continued strategic and tactical
guidance.
© 2016 Didit – All Content is Sensitive and Confidential
Conclusion
Stay Educated, best practices.Focus on the head of every data set.Use the right bid management technology and strategy.
Be a mad scientist, an inventor! I am ;-)