scrutiny/evaluation of technical & financial … technical report.pdfcd/dvd external super drive...

26
SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALS OF “COMPUTER HARDWARE” i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including Combined Effluent Treatment Plants(CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program) ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017 iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 05 iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 04 v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore Sr. # TENDER SPECIFICATIONS M/s ICS Computers M/s FATEMI IMPEX M/s Solution One M/s TR Marketing 1. LAPTOP COMPUTER (04 Nos) Model Dell INSPIRON 5378 Convertible Or Equivalent Dell INSPIRON 5378 Convertible Hp Convertible 13U108TU X360 Dell Laptop Computer 5378 Specifications are not mentioned i. Processor Intel Core i5 – 2.5 GHz Turbo Boost 3.2 GHz 7th Generation Intel Core i5 – 2.5 GHz Turbo Boost 3.1 GHz 7th Generation, 7200u Processor Intel Core i7-7200 7th Generation Inter Core i5, 7 th Generation, Touch screen & Convertible ii. Hard Disk 1000 GB –Hard Disk Drive 1000 GB –Hard Disk Drive 5400 Rotation Per Minute 1 Tb –Hard Disk Drive 1 Tb –Hard Disk Drive iii. RAM 08 GB – DDR3 1600MHz 08 GB – DDR4 2100 MHz 08 GB 08 GB iv. CD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3” Wide -LED Intel HD Graphics 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution 13.3” Wide -LED Touch Smart Technology 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution Intel HD Graphics 13.3” – LED 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution 13.3” Wide -LED 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution vi. Other LAN (10/100/1000), WIFI (abg/n), Blue Tooth, HDMI Interface, USB 3.0 Interface WIFI (ac), Blue Tooth (4.0),HDMI Interface, USB 3.0 Interface - Wifi, Bluetooth, HD Camera 1.3 MP, Mic, Rotatable vii. O/S Windows 10-Home Edition 64 Bit – English Version Windows 10-Home Edition 64 Bit – English Version Windows 10 64 Bit – Home Edition Windows 10 (100 original) viii . Warranty 1 Year 1 Year International Warranty 1 Year Warranty 1 Year Warranty Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 97,000/- Rs. 94,000/- Rs. 94,253/- Rs. 93,100/- - Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 388,000/- Rs. 376,000/- Rs. 377,012/- Rs. 372,400/- -

Upload: others

Post on 19-Apr-2020

13 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALS OF “COMPUTER HARDWARE”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

Combined Effluent Treatment Plants(CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 05

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 04

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

Sr.#

TENDER SPECIFICATIONS M/s ICS Computers M/s FATEMI IMPEX M/s Solution One M/s TR

Marketing

1. LAPTOP COMPUTER (04 Nos)

Model

Dell INSPIRON 5378 Convertible Or Equivalent

Dell INSPIRON 5378 Convertible

Hp Convertible 13U108TU X360

Dell Laptop Computer 5378 Specifications

are not

mentioned i. Processor

Intel Core i5 – 2.5 GHz Turbo Boost 3.2 GHz 7th Generation

Intel Core i5 – 2.5 GHz Turbo Boost 3.1 GHz 7th Generation, 7200u Processor

Intel Core i7-7200

7th Generation

Inter Core i5, 7th Generation, Touch screen & Convertible

ii. Hard Disk 1000 GB –Hard Disk Drive

1000 GB –Hard Disk Drive 5400 Rotation Per Minute

1 Tb –Hard Disk Drive 1 Tb –Hard Disk Drive

iii. RAM 08 GB – DDR3 1600MHz 08 GB – DDR4 2100 MHz 08 GB 08 GB

iv. CD/DVD External Super Drive

External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive

v.

Display

13.3” Wide -LED Intel HD Graphics 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution

13.3” Wide -LED

Touch Smart Technology

1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution Intel HD Graphics

13.3” – LED 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution

13.3” Wide -LED 1920 x 1080 Full HD Resolution

vi. Other

LAN (10/100/1000), WIFI (abg/n), Blue Tooth, HDMI Interface, USB 3.0 Interface

WIFI (ac), Blue Tooth (4.0),HDMI Interface, USB 3.0 Interface

- Wifi, Bluetooth, HD Camera 1.3 MP, Mic, Rotatable

vii. O/S

Windows 10-Home Edition

64 Bit – English Version

Windows 10-Home Edition

64 Bit – English Version

Windows 10

64 Bit – Home Edition

Windows 10 (100 original)

viii

. Warranty 1 Year 1 Year International Warranty 1 Year Warranty 1 Year Warranty

Unit Price (Including GST)

Rs. 97,000/- Rs. 94,000/- Rs. 94,253/- Rs. 93,100/- -

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 388,000/- Rs. 376,000/- Rs. 377,012/- Rs. 372,400/-

-

Page 2: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Remarks

M/s T.R Marketing has not mentioned/quoted any specifications/model for Desktop Computer and Laptop Computer therefore it is not possible to technically compare specifications with Tender documents and with specifications of other bidders.

M/s ICS Computers, M/s FATEMI IMPEX and M/s Solution One have quoted specifications of Desktop Computer and Laptop Computer as per tender specifications.

M/s Solution One has quoted lowest rate i.e. Rs. 93,100/- for Laptop Computers. M/s FATEMI IMPEX has quoted the lowest rate i.e. Rs. 48,753/- for Desktop Computers.

Prepared By: Checked By

(Engr. Muhammad Imran) (Muhammad Shoaib) (Mr. Abbas Haider) (Faisal Abbas) (Mr. Fahad Ahmad)

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist Research Analyst,UU Computer Operator, EPA Computer Operator, EPA

Sr.# TENDER SPECIFICATIONS M/s ICS Computers M/s FATEMI IMPEX M/s Solution One

M/s TR Marketing

2. DESKTOP COMPUTER (02 Nos)

Model Dell 3040 or Equivalent Dell Vostro 3650 Dell Optiplex 3046 Dell Optiplex 3046 Specifications are not

mentioned i. Processor

Intel Core i3 – 3.2 GHz 6th Generation

Intel Core i3 – 3.7 GHz

6th Generation Inter Core i3, 6100, 6th Generation 3.2 GHZ

Intel Core i3 – 3.7 GHz, 6th Generation

ii. Hard Disk

500 GB –Hard Disk Drive 500 GB –Hard Disk Drive, 7200 RPM SATA

500 GB –Hard Disk Drive 500 GB –Hard Disk Drive

iii. RAM 04 GB – DDR3 1600MHz 04 GB – DDR3 1600MHz 04 GB – DDR4 04 GB – DDR4

iv. CD/DVD Super Multi Drive Super Multi Drive, DVD RW+- DVD/RW Optical Drive, DVD/RW Optical Drive

v. Display

Intel HD Graphics Intel HD Graphics Integrated Intel HD graphics 530

Intel HD Graphics

vi.

Other

LAN (10/100/1000) HDMI Interface USB 3.0 Interface

LAN (10/100/1000) WIFI (ac) Bluetooth 4.0 USB 3.0 Interface,Display Port

LAN (10/100/1000) HDMI Interface

USB 3.0 Interface

Integrated Ethernet

vii O/S

DOS (Windows 10 Compatible)

DOS (Windows 10 Compatible) DOS (Windows 10 Compatible) DOS (Windows 10 Compatible)

viii LED

DELL 1916 - 18.5” LED DELL 1916 - 18.5” LED DELL 18.5” LED Display DELL 1916(H/HV), 18.5” LED Display

ix Warranty 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year

Unit Price (Including GST)

Rs. 56,000/- Rs. 55,000/- Rs. 48,753/- Rs. 54,900/- -

Total Price (Including GST)

Rs. 112,000/- Rs. 110,000/- Rs. 97,506/- Rs. 109,800/- Rs. 4,83,000/-

Page 3: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALS OF “I.T EQUIPMENT”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

Combined Effluent Treatment Plants (CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 05

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 03

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

TENDER SPECIFICATIONS M/s ICS Computers M/s FATEMI

IMPEXT M/s Solution

One

SCANNER (1 No.)

Model HP ScanJet Pro 4500 Flatbed Scanner or

Equivalent

HP ScanJet Pro 4500 Flatbed Scanner HP ScanJet Pro

4500 FI

HP ScanJet Pro

4500 FI

Digital sending

standard features

Scan to email; Scan to PC; Scan to Network Scan to email; Scan to PC; Scan to Network As per Model

Specifications

As per Model

Specifications

Scanner Type Flat Belt, ADF Flat Belt, ADF

Resolution, Optical

Up to 600 x 600 dpi (color and mono, ADF)

Up to 1200 x 1200 dpi (color and mono,

flatbed)

Up to 600 x 600 dpi (color and mono, ADF)

Up to 1200 x 1200 dpi (color and mono,

flatbed)

Duty cycle (daily) 4000 pages (ADF), 100 pages (Flatbed) 4000 pages (ADF), 100 pages (Flatbed

Scan size,

maximum

216 x 297 mm 216 x 297 mm

Media types

Paper (banner, inkjet, photo, plain),

envelopes, labels, cards (greeting, index)

Paper (banner, inkjet, photo, plain),

envelopes, labels, cards (greeting, index)

feeder capacity 50 Sheets 50 Sheets

ADF Speed Up to 20 ppm/40 ipm (black & white, grey

and colour, 300 dpi) 2

Up to 20 ppm/40 ipm (black & white, grey

and colour, 300 dpi)

Scanning options

(ADF)

Single-pass E-Duplex Single-pass E-Duplex

Connectivity USB 2.0 and USB 3.0 (Super Speed)

Built-in Fast Ethernet 10/100/1000Base-TX

network port

USB 2.0 and USB 3.0 (Super Speed)

Built-in Fast Ethernet 10/100/1000Base-TX

network port

Warranty One Year One Year

Unit Price (Including

GST) Rs. 100,000/- Rs. 99,000/- Rs. 100,097/-

Rs. 99,900/-

Total Price (Including GST)

Rs. 100,000/- Rs. 99,000/- Rs. 100,097/- Rs. 99,900/-

Page 4: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

TENDER SPECIFICATIONS M/s ICS Computers M/s FATEMI

IMPEXT

M/s Solution

One

2. Multimedia Projector (1No.)

Model Sony VPL EW 295 or Equivalent Sony VPL EW 295 Sony VPL EW 295 Sony VPL EW 295

Brightness 3,800 ANSI Lumens 3,800 ANSI Lumens As per Model

Specifications

As per Model

Specifications Color Light Output 3,800 Lumens 3,800 Lumens

Contrast(Full

On/Off)

3,700:1 3,700:1

Data Modes MAX 1600x1200 MAX 1600x1200

Resolution 1280x800 1280x800

Aspect Ratio 16:10 (WXGA) 16:10 (WXGA)

Lamp Life(Full

Power)

4,000 hours 4,000 hours

Lamp Life(eco-

mode)

10,000 hours 10,000 hours

Unit Price (Including GST)

Rs. 150.000/- Rs. 147,420/- Rs. 119,987/- Rs. 137,500/-

Total Price

(Including GST) Rs. 150.000/- Rs. 147,420/- Rs. 119,987/-

Rs. 137,500/-

3. Printer (5 No.)

Model HP LaserJet Pro 402dw Printer or

Equivalent

HP LaserJet Pro 402dw Printer HP LaserJet Pro

402dw Printer

HP LaserJet Pro

400 M402dw

Function Printer & Duplex Printer & Duplex As per Model

Specifications

As per Model

Specifications Resolution 1200 dpi 1200 dpi

Duty Cycle 8,000 Pages per Month 8,000 Pages per Month

Print Technology Laser Laser

Display Single Line Display Single Line Display

Paper Trays 1 Paper Tray Standard 1 Paper Tray Standard

Memory 256 MB 256 MB

Paper Holding Tray 1: 150 Pages Tray 1: 150 Pages

Media Size Tray 1: 3 x 5 to 8.5 x 14 in, Tray 1: 3 x 5 to 8.5 x 14 in,

Ports 1 Hi-Speed USB 2.0; 1 Host USB; 1 Gigabit

Ethernet 10/100/1000T network; Easy-

access USB

1 Hi-Speed USB 2.0; 1 Host USB; 1 Gigabit

Ethernet 10/100/1000T network; Easy-

access USB

Print Speed 38 Pages per Minute 38 Pages per Minute

Connectivity WIFI & Networks WIFI & Networks

Unit Price (Including GST)

Rs. 50,000/- Rs. 47,970/- Rs. 35,981/- Rs. 39,900/-

Total Price

(Including GST)

Rs. 250,000/- Rs. 239,850/- Rs. 179,905 Rs. 199,500/-

Page 5: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Remarks:

All the bidders have quoted specifications of Scanner, Printer and Multimedia Projector as per tender specifications. M/s ICS Computers has quoted lowest rate for scanner i.e. Rs. 99,000/-

M/s FATEMI IMPEX has quoted lowest rate for multimedia projector i.e. Rs. 119,987/-

M/s FATEMI IMPEX has quoted lowest rate for printers. i.e. Rs. 35,981/-

Prepared By: Checked By

(Engr. Muhammad Imran) (Muhammad Shoaib) (Mr. Abbas Haider) (Faisal Abbas) (Mr. Fahad Ahmad)

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist Research Analyst, UU Computer Operator, EPA Computer Operator, EPA

Page 6: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALSOF “REPAIR OF MACHINERY & EQUIPMENT”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

Combined Effluent Treatment Plants (CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 03

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 01

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

Sr.

No. Name of Equipment Repair/Maintenance Required

Estimated Cost

M/s Linker Enterprises

1 UV-Visible Spectrophotometer

(Jasco Model V-530)

Beam Alignment, Spares, Software, Quartz Cells 10mm matched pair,

Operationalization, Calibration. 50,000 Cost not quoted

2 COD Heating Mantle (Multislot) Repair of burnt/faulty Heating Mantle Slots,

Operationalization, and Performance Check. 40,000

-do-

3 Magnetic Stirrer With Hotplate Requires Servicing, Performance Check. 2,000 -do-

4 Refrigerator (Nehom, Japan) Requires Servicing, Performance Check. 5,000 -do-

5 Water Purification System (Millipore ELIX-5) Servicing, Cartridge Replacement, Operational Check. 80,000 -do-

6 Low Temperature Incubator (LTI-700) Servicing, Calibration 10,000 -do-

7 Draft Chamber (ADP 120) Servicing, Duct Repairs, Performance check as per ASHRAE 110-1995 5,000 -do-

8 Flue Gas Analyzer-Testo 350 XL

(Quantity: 6 Nos).

Equipment overhauling, sensor replacement, battery replacement and

other repairs so as to fully operationalizethe equipment. 58,43,000 56,87,160

Remarks

Only one Firm Namely “M/S Linker Enterprises” has submitted bids for the repair of Machinery & Equipment. The said firm has quoted rate only for the repair of one

equipment mentioned at serial No. 8.

M/s Linker Enterprises does not qualify on Technical Grounds because of non-availability of Manufacturer Authorization Certificate as per TORs of Tender

Document

Prepared By: Checked By

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist Analyst (EMC)

Page 7: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALS OF “CHEMICALS”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

CombinedEffluent Treatment Plants (CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 07

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 06

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

(All Prices are in Pak Rs.including GST)

S. #

Chemical Qty Total Est.

Cost

M/s T.R Marketing

M/s Linker Enterprises M/s Deltalab Scientific Co.

M/s UH Analytical Supply

M/s Syner Tech Pakistan

M/s Fazal e Rabbi

Make

Total Cost

Make Total Cost

Make Total Cost

Make Total Cost Make Total Cost

Make Unit Price

1 12880μS/cm conductivity Standard

3000 mL 15,000

No

t m

enti

on

ed

Co

st o

f in

div

idu

al i

tem

s n

ot

men

tio

ned

Carlo Erba France

14940 - - Hanna 23094 Hanna 19656 - -

2 1413μS/cm conductivity Standard

3000 mL 15,000 Carlo Erba France

14940 VWR 26325 Hanna 23094 Horiba 17550 - -

3 84μS/cm conductivity Standard

3000 mL 15,000 Carlo Erba France

14940 - - Hanna 23094 Hanna 19656 - -

4 Aluminum potassium sulphate

2000 g 17,000 Carlo Erba France

15600 - - Merck 27588 - - - -

5 Buffer Solution pH 4 3000 mL 15,000 Carlo Erba France

10800 VWR 4914 Merck 9090 Honeywell 3510 - -

6 Buffer Solution pH 7 3000 mL 15,000 Carlo Erba France

13500 VWR 4914 Merck 9090 Honeywell 4212 - -

7 Buffer Solution pH 9 3000 mL 15,000 Carlo Erba France

12600 VWR 5967 Merck 12987 Honey well 4212 - -

8 Calcium Chloride 1000 g 11,000 ABCR Germany

10000 VWR 2574 Merck 4551 Honeywell 2340 PENTA, CZ

1574

9 Ferric Chloride hexahydrate

500 g 16,000 Carlo Erba France

14800 - - Merck 15978 Merck 4387 - -

10 Hydrochloric Acid 25000 mL 120,000 Carlo Erba France

109400 Labscan 40950 - 3308 - - - -

11 Hydrogen peroxide 2000 mL 27,000 Carlo Erba France

25000 VWR 8190 Merck 10506 Honeywell 4328 PENTA, CZ

3117

12 Mercuric Iodide 50 g 4,000 Carlo Erba France

23000 VWR 23985 Merck 27963 Icon 3276 - -

13 Mercuric Sulphate 2000 g 280,000 Carlo Erba France

208000 VWR 156078 Merck 687960 Icon 112320 PENTA, CZ

121680

14 Peroxide test strips, 1-100mg/L

100 No 5,500 Co st

of

in di

vi

du al

ite

ms

no t m en tio

ne d Machery

Nagel 5500 - - Merck 5148 Merck 5265 - -

Page 8: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

S. #

Chemical Qty Total Est.

Cost M/s T.R

Marketing M/s Linker Enterprises

M/s Deltalab Scientific Co.

M/s UH Analytical Supply

M/s Syner Tech Pakistan

M/s Fazal e Rabbi

Germany

15 Potassium Bi-iodate (KH(IO3)2)

500 g 8,000 Carlo Erba France

53500 - - Merck 386100 - - - -

16 Potassium Hydrogen Phthalate

1000 g 12,000 Carlo Erba

France 8400

VWR 20943 Merck 20999 Icon 21060 PENTA, CZ

14708

17 Salicylic Acid 1000 g 8,000 Carlo Erba France

8000 VWR 4902 Merck 34870 Icon 12870 PENTA, CZ

1724

18 Silica Gel 3000 g 7,500 Carlo Erba France

9000 VWR 14602 Commercial

2070 - - - -

19 Silver Sulphate 1000 g 400,000 Carlo Erba France

360000 VWR 360360 Merck 1071720 Icon 351000 PENTA, CZ

216440

20 Sodium Borate 1000 g 5,500 Carlo Erba France

5100 VWR 4914 Merck 7593 Honeywell 2690 PENTA, CZ

1084

21 Sodium hydroxide 2000 g 18,000 Carlo Erba France

13000 VWR 4914 Merck 4306 Honeywell 2047 PENTA, CZ

2568

22 Sulfuric Acid 50000 mL 240,000 Carlo Erba France

224000 Labscan 81900 - 66160 - - - -

23 n-Hexane 50000 mL 290,000 Carlo Erba France

276000 VWR 78390 Merck 76760 Merck 79560 PENTA, CZ

81700

24 Oxalic Acid 1000 g 8,000 Carbosynth UK

32000 VWR 3498 Merck 6997 Icon 3276 - -

25 Arsenic Trioxide 250 g 10,000 Carlo Erba France

34200 (11400 /100ML)

- - Sigma Aldrich

39195 (15678 /100 g

Ban - - -

26 Potassium Dichromate 500 g 9,000 Alfa Aesar A188722

9000 VWR 8073 Merck 7546 (15093/Kg)

Icon 2223 PENTA, CZ

1427

27 Sodium Chloride 1000 g 5,000 Carlo Erba France

4000 VWR 1112 Merck 1966 Merck 2106 PENTA, CZ

814

28 Calcium Carbonate 1000 g 5,500 Carlo Erba France

6600 VWR 4200 Merck 5382 Merck 5265 PENTA, CZ

1044

29 Lovibond ATH Solution for BOD

5 Bottle 10,000 Lovibond 25000 Lovibon

d 4095 - - - - - -

30 Lovibond KOH Solution for BOD

5 Bottle 10,000 Carlo Erba France

10000 Lovibond

4095 - - - - - -

31 Nitric Acid 5000 mL 35,000 Carlo Erba France

15000 VWR 7699 - 5476 Honeywell 5616 PENTA, CZ

5828

32 Chloroform 25000 mL 115,000 Carlo Erba France

93000 VWR 39080 Merck 32760 Merck 32760 - -

33 Isopropyl Alcohol 10000 mL 20,000 Carlo Erba France

17800 VWR 10436 Merck 9268 Icon 6552 PENTA, CZ

6548

34

ICP Multielement Standard Solutions covering PEQS Metals Range in combination.

200 mL 75,000

Carlo Erba France

72600 VWR 54756 Merck 58032 - - - -

N

o

t

m

e

n

t

i

o

n

e

d

Page 9: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

S. #

Chemical Qty Total Est.

Cost M/s T.R

Marketing M/s Linker Enterprises

M/s Deltalab Scientific Co.

M/s UH Analytical Supply

M/s Syner Tech Pakistan

M/s Fazal e Rabbi

100mL/pack

Total 1,862,000 1755000 1769220

Remarks:

M/s TR Marketing did not submit authorized distribution letter from chemical manufacturer.

M/s Delta Lab is not authorized distributor of Laboratory Chemicals, they produced authorization of another firm (Master Lab).

M/s UH Analytical has submitted authorization of M/s Merck Chemicals only whereas they have also quoted items from Hanna, Sigma Aldrich and Commercial.

M/s Syner Tech submitted authorization from Honeywell only whereas they have also quoted items from Hanna, Horiba, Merck and ICON.

M/s Fazal e Rabbi is not authorized distributor of PENTACZ, they have submitted authorization of Great Pak Lahore.

Entries in Bold Shape are for the items which are presumed to qualify on Technical Grounds.

Prepared By: Checked By

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist Analyst (EMC)

Page 10: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALSOF “GLASSWARE & OTHERS”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

CombinedEffluent Treatment Plants (CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 07

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 02

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

S.

No. Description Qty

Estimated

Cost

M/s Linker Enterprises M/S Syner Tech Pakistan

Item

Unit Rate

(Including

GST)

Total Price

(Including

GST)

Item Per Unit Rate (Including

GST)

Total Price

(Including

GST)

1

Wide-Mouth Amber HDPE

Bottle with Closure, 250

mL, certified to to meet or exceed US-EPA

performance-based

standards for metals,

cyanide and fluoride

432 240,000

Wide-Mouth Amber

HDPE Bottle with

Closure, 250 mL,

certified to to meet or exceed US-EPA

performance-based

standards for metals,

cyanide and fluoride

554 239328 Item not quoted

2

Wide-Mouth white HDPE

Bottle with Closure, 250 mL, General Purpose,

Nalgene style 2104 or

equivalent, (UK/USA/EU

origin)

192 108,432

Wide-Mouth white HDPE Bottle with Closure, 250

mL, General Purpose,

Nalgene style 2104

(origin not quoted)

564 108288

Wide-Mouth

white HDPE Bottle with

Closure, 250 mL,

Cat #

BWH0250PN,

(Azlon UK based)

Each 263.25 50544

3

Glass Fiber Filter without

organic binder, 47mm Circles, (Whatman Grade

934-AH, or equivalent)

100/pk

8 80,568

Glass Fiber Filter without organic binder, 47mm

Circles, (Whatman Grade

934-AH, 100/pk

9700 77600

Glass Fiber

47mm ,Grade 934-AH, Cat #

1827-

047Whatman

Pak/

100

9828 78624

4 Membrane Filter 0.45µm x

47mm, 100/pk 2 25,000

Membrane Filter 0.45µm

x 47mm, 100/pk 12500 25000

Nylon Membrane

Filter 0.45µm x

47mm, Millipore

Pkt 7605 15210

5

Argon Gas Refill, 99.998% minimum purity, ~2200

psig, in cylinders available

with EPA

3 87,500

Argon Gas Refill, 99.998% minimum

purity, ~2200 psig, in

cylinders

27000 81000

Item not quoted

Page 11: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

S.

No. Description Qty

Estimated

Cost M/s Linker Enterprises M/S Syner Tech Pakistan

6

Qualitative Filter Paper

Sheets, W × L: 580mm

×680mm, Whatman Grade 1

or Equivalent, 100/pk

1 15,000

Qualitative Filter Paper

Sheets, W × L: 580mm

×680mm, Whatman

Grade 1, 100/pk

15000 15000

Qualitative Filter Paper Sheets, W

× L: 580mm

×680mm, Grade

1,

Whatman

Pkt 9360 9360

7

Weighing Paper 0.03mm,

40g/m2, 5.9" × 5.9"

minimum, 500/pkWhatman Grade 2122, B-2, or

equivalent

1 35,000

Weighing Paper 0.03mm,

40g/m2, 5.9" × 5.9" minimum,

500/pkWhatman Grade

2122, B-2,

34000 34000

Weighing Paper

0.03mm, 40g/m2, 5.9" × 5.9"

minimum,

500/pkWhatman,

B-2 Cat #

10347673

Pkt 7605 7605

Weighing Paper 0.03mm, 40g/m2,

5.9" × 5.9"

minimum,

500/pkWhatman

Grade 2122 Cat #

10347890

Pkt 21060 21060

8

Ice Box for Sample Transportation, Hard

Plastic, Double Wall

Insulated, with Handle(s)

size 1ft X 1.5ft X 2ft (W X D

X H) China

8 32,000

Ice Box for Sample Transportation, Hard

Plastic, Double Wall

Insulated, with Handle(s)

size 1ft X 1.5ft X 2ft (W X

D X H) China

3900 31200 Item not quoted

9

Polycarbonate Face Shield, Adjustable, optically clear

window, Thermo scientific

Nalgene or equivalent

8 40,000

Polycarbonate Face Shield, Adjustable,

optically clear window,

Thermo scientific Nalgene

5000 40000 -do-

10

Wet and Dry Bulb

Hygrometer, Zeal or

equivalent

3 9,000 Wet and Dry Bulb

Hygrometer, Zeal 3000 9000

Item not quoted

Page 12: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

S.

No. Description Qty

Estimated

Cost M/s Linker Enterprises M/S Syner Tech Pakistan

11

Calculator Desktop, 208mm x 156mm minimum, 1 line,

12 Digit Display, Battery

and solar powered, Fixed

angle display, check and

correct, square root, percent, double zero,

change sign and memory

keys, Citizen or equivalent

5 10,000

Calculator Desktop, 208mm x 156mm

minimum, 1 line, 12

Digit Display, Battery

and solar powered, Fixed

angle display, check and

correct, square root, percent, double zero,

change sign and memory

keys, Citizen

2000 10000

-do-

12 Nitric Acid Bath Tub 10L 1 5,000 Nitric Acid Bath Tub 10L 4900 4900 -do-

13

Tool Box Containing

Assorted wrenches, Screw

Drivers, L keys, Pliers,

Cutters, Testers, Hammer,

Nose pliers, Tape measures, Claw, Drill Machine and

Drills.

1 5,000

Tool Box Containing

Assorted wrenches,

Screw Drivers, L keys,

Pliers, Cutters, Testers,

Hammer, Nose pliers, Tape measures, Claw,

Drill Machine and Drills.

5000 5000

-do-

14

Dead Weight Box for

Analytical Balance,

minimum 12 weights

ranging from 50mg to 100g

1 5,000

Dead Weight Box for

Analytical Balance,

minimum 12 weights

ranging from 50mg to 100g

4500 4500

-do-

15 Amber colored buret 50 ml

Rotaflo 1 4,000

Amber colored buret 50

ml Rotaflo 4000 4000

-do-

16 Nitrile Gloves Powder Free

Large Size 20 16,000

Nitrile Gloves Powder

Free Large Size 800 16000

-do-

17 Cotton Gloves 12/pk 10 3,600 Cotton Gloves 12/pk 360 3600 -do-

18 Laboratory Coats Gents Large Size White Color

10 3,000 Laboratory Coats Gents Large Size White Color

300 3000 -do-

19 Laboratory Coats Gents

Medium Size White Color 10 3,000

Laboratory Coats Gents

Medium Size White Color 300 3000

-do-

20 Laboratory Coats Ladies

Large Size White Color 10 3,000

Laboratory Coats Ladies

Large Size White Color 300 3000

-do-

21 Nitrile Gloves Powder Free

Medium Size 10 4,000

Nitrile Gloves Powder

Free Medium Size 400 4000

-do-

22 Plastic Measuring Jug 5 litre

4 2,800 Plastic Measuring Jug 5 litre

700 2800

Plastic Measuring

Jug 5 litre, Europe

Each 1696.50 6786

23 Pipette bulb Suckers

Germany 5 2,500

Pipette bulb Suckers

Germany 500 2500 Item not quoted

Page 13: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

S.

No. Description Qty

Estimated

Cost M/s Linker Enterprises M/S Syner Tech Pakistan

24 Water Storage Bottles plastic 10 Liters

5 2,500 Water Storage Bottles plastic 10 Liters

500 2500 Item not quoted

25 Laboratory Goggles 20 2,000 Laboratory Goggles 200 4000 -do- 26 Dust Masks 50 1,500 Dust Masks 30 1500 -do-

27 Laboratory Coats Ladies

Medium Size White Color 5 1,500

Laboratory Coats Ladies

Medium Size White Color 300 1500

-do-

28 Spatulas Assorted sizes 50 1,500 Spatulas Assorted sizes 100 5000 -do-

29 Separatory Funnel Stand,

Painted Iron, two hole 3 1,800

Separatory Funnel

Stand, Painted Iron, two

hole

600 1800

-do-

30 Face Masks 3 Ply, medical

grade 5 1,000

Face Masks 3 Ply,

medical grade 200 1000

-do-

31 Hand Sanitizers 250mL Bottle

5 1,000 Hand Sanitizers 250mL Bottle

200 1000 -do-

32

Hand vaccum pump,

polypropylene, Funnel Inlet,

Holder outlet stopper fitting

standard 1L filtering flask,

Polysulfone funnel, funnel cover, receiver flask and

cover; polypropylene holder

base, and filter support

screen; silicone stopper

8 180,000

Hand vaccum pump,

polypropylene, Funnel

Inlet, Holder outlet

stopper fitting standard

1L filtering flask,

Polysulfone funnel, funnel cover, receiver

flask and cover;

polypropylene holder

base, and filter support

screen; silicone stopper

23000 184000

-do-

33 Heat resistant arm length gloves pair for oven,

washable

2 800 Heat resistant arm length gloves pair for oven,

washable

400 800 -do-

Remarks:

Two bidders i.e. M/s Linker Enterprises and M/s Syner Tech Pakistan have participated in the Tender.

M/s Linker Enterprises has quoted 33 items as required in tender documents while M/s Syner Tech Pakistan has quoted 6 items (Sr. No. 2, 3, 4, 6, 7 & 22).

M/s Syner Tech Pakistan has quoted lowest prices for the items mentioned at Sr. No. 2, 4, 6, 7.

Prepared By: Checked By

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist Analyst (EMC)

Page 14: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALS OF “MACHINERY & EQUIPMENT”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

Combined Effluent Treatment Plants (CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 07

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 06

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

1

Laboratory Fume Hood (1 No.)

ASHRAE 110-1995 standard, 6 Feet Wide with installation, commissioning and validation.

Fume Hood for the evaporation of solvent Dimension: External Size: 72 (W) x 54 (H) x 30 (D) Inches Approximately. Internal Size: 66 (W) x 36 (H) x 25 (D) Inches Approximately. Powerful Motor and blower External Construction made on Non Magnetic Iron Sheet Gauge 16, Powder Coating. Internal Construction : Made of Stainless Steel 316, Gauge 18 Chemical Resistance Internal Wall: Acid and corrosion resistant. Electric receptacles to work inside the Fume-Hood: Inlet for: Water, Gas, and Vacuum Light insider Fume-Hood: Vapor proof Safety Glass: Heat/acid/corrosion

Fume Hood FH-1000X: Exterior Size: 1000x800x2200 mm(W*D*H) Internal Size: 800*750*745mm (W*D*H) Air Velocity: 0.3-0.8 m/s Noise:< 60dB Fluorescent Lamp: 15W*1 UV Lamp: 30W*1 Glass Window: Toughened Glass, 5mm thickness, motor control Material: Exterior Body: Cold-roll steel sheets, coated with anti-bacteria powder Side panel: glass, three sides visible Work Table: solid chemical-resistant physiochemical board Base Stand: 650mm Power Supply: 110-240V, , 50-60Hz (optional) Power Consumption: 150W Water Sink, Base Stand, Duct, active carbon filter, foot switch Net weight: 200 KG Make Biobase, China

Item not quoted

Item not quoted

Specifications not mentioned in the bid.

Item not quoted

Page 15: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

resistant Chemical resistant flat working surface Base cabinet having 30” height and same width as fume hood Wash Basin Power requirement: 220 V Safety Glass: 5 mm Tempered Ghani Glass. Make: Local According to ASHRAE 110-1995 Standard

Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 500,000/- Rs. 373,500/- Rs. 499,590/- - - -

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 5,00,000/- Rs. 373,500/- Rs. 499,590/- - - -

2

All Glass Water Distillation Unit (10 Nos.) Single distilled, All

Glass unit, Output 4L/hr, Conductivity upto 4.0uS/cm, pH 5.0–7.0, Origin UK, USA, EU, Japan, or equivalent

Glass Water Distillation Unit Single Distilled, All glass unit, Output 4 L/hr Conductivity up to 4. uS/cm, PH 5.0 – 7.0 Origin UK Manufacturer Stuart Model: W4000.

Water Distillation W4000: Output 4 liters/hr, single distilled pH 5.0 -6.5 Conductivity, UScm – 13.0-4.0 Resistivity, Mohm-cm 0.25-0.3 Temperature 25 – 35 C Pyrogen content * Pyrogen Free Water supply 1 liter/min 3-100 psi (20-700kPa) Electricity supply 220 or 240V, 50-60Hz, single phase Power Requirement 3 kW Dimensions, (wxdxh), mm 500 x 150 x 450 Make : Stuart UK

Item not quoted

Distillate output 4 litre/hour. Automatic control system. Quartz Heater. Boro glass components. Easy maintenance. EU directive complaint. Model: L304 Normax Portugal CE/ISO Approved & Marked ISO 9001:2000 ISO 13485: 2003CE

Specifications not mentioned in the bid.

Model: P710710 Make: Pobel, Spain Pack Size: Each Availability: Stock Distillation Capacity L/H: 4.2 Water Consumption L/MIN: 1 Conductivity at 20 C (uS/cm*): 1 Measure Height width x Depth mm: 450x580x170 Heaters W: 1x3.000 Electricity Supply: 230v-50/60 Hz Weight 5.1

Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 150,000/- Rs. 148,900/- Rs. 171,288/- - Rs. 129,444/- - Rs. 105,300/-

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 15,00,000/- Rs. 14,89,000/- Rs. 17,12,880/- - Rs. 12,94,440/- -

Rs. 10,53,000/-

3 Benchtop pH Meter

pH Range: -2.00 to + 20.00, pH resolution

pH Range: -2.00 to + 20.00, pH resolution 0.01,

Digital Laboratory pH Meter Benchtop 3510:

Orion Star A2115 Benchtop Meter:

Item not quoted

-do- Model: IS-128 Measuring mode:

Page 16: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

(1 No.)

0.01, minimum, three point pH calibration possible, temperature compensation, temperature range at least upto 100

oC,

Glass pH Electrode.

minimum, three point pH. calibration possible, temperature compensation, temperature range at least upto 100

oC.

Glass pH Electrode. Make: Hanna Instrument Inc. USA Model: HI5221-02

Cat # 3510 pH Range: -2.00 to + 19.999 pH Resolution: 0.001/0.01/0.1pH Accuracy: 0.003mv Temp Range: -10 to + 105 C (14 to 221 F) Resolution: 0.1 C (1 F) Accuracy: 0.5 C (+- 1 F) ATC range: 0 to 100 C (32 to 212 F) Power: 9V Power Supply Jenway, UK

8302 BNUMD Orion Ross Triode 3-in 41 pH/ATC probe 810199 Ross solution kit (475 ml each of pH 4, 7 and 10 buffers; storage solution; cleaning solution; and pH electrode storage bottle etc.) (Thermo Scientific, Part of Thermo-fisher Scientific USA)

pH/mV/ORP Range(pH): -2.00 to 18.00 Resolution (pH) 0.01/0.1 Relative accuracy(pH): ±0.01 Range (mV): -2000.0 to 2000.0 Resolution (mV): 0.1/1 Relative accuracy(mV): ±0.4 Temperature range: MTC: -5.0 to 105.0 ATC: -5.0 to 105.0 Temperature accuracy: ±0.1 Calibration: 5 predefined pH buffer recognition, user-definable buffers (1-5 points) Database: 2000 groups measuring data Output: printer (optional), IS-Link 5.0`` color, touch screen, Resolution 800X480 GLP function, continues measurement mode Others: dynamic curve display (ph vs.t; mVvst.t) Make: Insmark

Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 100,000/-

Rs. 112,000/- Rs. 85,644/- Rs. 203,322/- - - Rs. 58,500/-

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 100,000/-

Rs. 112,000/- Rs. 85,644/- Rs. 203,322/- - - Rs. 58,500/-

4

Benchtop

Conductivity/TDS

Meter

(1 No.)

Range Selectable

Electrical Conductivity

Meter, 0.001uS/cm

resolution at lowest

range, minimum

0.1mS/cm resolution

at 1000mS/cm.

Range Selectable

Electrical Conductivity

Meter, 0.001uS/cm

resolution at lowest

range, minimum

0.1mS/cm resolution at

1000mS/cm. Minimum

Conductivity TD Meter

4510:

Conductivity Range: 0 to

19.99 uS/ 0 to 199.9 uS / 0

to 1999 uS/ 0 to 19.99 mS/0

to 1999 mS

Resolution: 0.01 uS 0.001S

Orion Star A1125

Orion Star A112

Conductivity

Benchtop Meter Kit

011050MD Orion

conductivity probe,

k=1.0

Item not quoted Specifications

not mentioned

in the bid.

Model: DDF-307W

Make: Bante China

Pack Size: Each

Availability: Stock

Specification:

Model: DDS-307W

Range: 0~20.00, 200.0,

Page 17: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

Minimum three point

calibration check

possible, TDS Display,

temperature

compensation

three point calibration

check possible, TDS

Display, temperature

compensation

Make: Hanna Instrument

Inc. USA

Model: HI5321-02

Accuracy: +0.5% + 2 digits

TDS Range: 0 to 19.99

mg/I/0 to 199.9 mg/I/0 to

1999 mg/I, 0 to 19.99 g/I/

Resolution: 0.01 mg/I/0.1

mg/I/mg/I/0.01g/I/0.1g/1g

*only with cell Constant>5

Accuracy: +- 0.5 +- 2 digits

Temp Range: -10 to +105

C(14 to 221 F) F

Resolution: 0.1 C(1 F)

Accuracy: +-0.5 C(+- 1 F)

Jenway, UK

011007 Orion 1413

µS conductivity

standard

Attached electrode

stand and holder

universal power

adapter

Printed quick start

guide and literature

CD.

(Thermo Scientific,

Part of Thermo-

fisher Scientific

USA)

2000µS/cm, 20.00,

200.0mS/cm

Accuracy: ±1% F.S

Resolution: 0.01, 0.1

Calibration Points: 1 to 3

points

Calibration solutions:

10µS/cm, 84µS/cm,

1413µS/cm, 12.88mS/cm,

111.8S/cm

Temperature

Compensation: 0~1000C,

32~2120F, Manual

Temperature Coefficient:

0.0~10.0%/0C

Cell Constant: K=0.1, 1, 10

or User-defined

Connector: 6-pin Mini Plug

Power Requirements:

DC9V, using AC adapter,

220 VAC/50Hz

Dimensions:

210(L)X205(W)X75 (H)mm

Weight: 1.5 kg

Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 50,000 Rs. 112,000/- Rs. 92,781/- Rs. 140,400/- - - Rs. 29,250/-

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 50,000 Rs. 112,000/- Rs. 92,781/- Rs. 140,400/- - - Rs. 29,250/-

5

Benchtop Ion Selective Electrode Meter with compatible Electrods for Ammonia, Sulfide, Cyanide, Fluoride and Nitrate (1 No.)

mV range: ±1999 ppm range: 0.001 to 19999 Temperature Range: up to 120oC mV Resolution: 0.1 mV ISE Resolution: 0.001 at Lower end, at most 1 at higher end Calibration: 2-point

Bench top Ion Selective Electrode Meter with Compatible Elecrodes for Ammonia, Sulfide, Cyanide Fluoride and Nitrate Manufacturer Hanna Instruments Inc USA Model HI5222

Item not quoted Stara2146 Orion Star A214 pH/ISE Benchtop Meter Kit for Ammonia* 8102 BNUWP 9512 HPBNWP Orion High performance ammonia ISE 927007 MD Orion stainless steel ATC

Item not quoted Specifications not mentioned in the bid.

Model: F74BW Make: Horiba Pack Size: Each Availability: Stock Specification: Measurement Method: pH: Glass electrode method Ion: Ion electrode method Conductivity: 2 AC bipolar method

Page 18: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

possible mV Accuracy: ±0.2mV (Lower End), ±1mV (high end) Electrodes and ISE system must be complete with reference electrodes and all accessories, and must be sensitive enough to measure the specified parameters as per Punjab Environmental Quality Standards for Municipal and Liquid Industrial Effluents, and Drinking Water Quality.

probe 096019 Orion Star Stirrer probe 951007 Ammonia 1000 ppm standard 951210 Low level ammonia ISA 951213 Ammonia ISE storage solution (Thermo Scientific USA)

Resistivity, Sainity and TDS: Conversion from conductivity measurement Measurement Range: pH: 0.000 to 14.000(Display Range: pH-2.000 to 19.999) mV (ORP): ±1999.9mV Temperature: 0.0 to 100.0C

0C(Display Range: -

30.0 to 130.0C0C)

Ion:0.00µg/L to 999 g/L (mol/L) Conductivity: Cell constant 100 m-1: 0.000mS/m~19.99 S/m, Cell constant 10 m-I: 0.00µS/m~1.999S/m, Cell constant 1000m-1:0.00mS/m~199.9S/m Salinity: 0.00 to 80.00 PPT (Display Range: 0.000% to 8.000%) Resistivity: Cell constant 100 m-1: 0.00 Ω. M~199.9kΩ.m~19.99 KΩm TDS: 0.01 mg/L ~ 100 g/L Resolution: pH:0.001pH mV(ORP): 0.1 mV Temperature: 0.1

0C

Ion: Valid numbers 3 digits Conductivity: 0.05% of full scale Salinity: 0.01 PPT (0.001%) Resistivity: 0.05%F.S. TDS: 0.01 mg/L Repeatability: pH: ±0.005 pH±1 digit mV(ORP): ±0.1 mV±1 digit Temperature: ±0.1

0C±1

digit Ion: ± 0.5% ±1 digit Conductivity: ±0.5%±1

Page 19: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

digit Resistivity: ±0.5%F.S ±1 digit Power: AC adaptor 100~ 240 V 50/60 Hz Dimensions: 170(W)X 174(D)X73(H)mm (Excluding electrode stand and AC adaptor) Mass of main unit: Approximately 500g Unit Ship Weight: 4 lbs

Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 400,000/- Rs. 437,000/- - Rs. 17,55,883/- - - Rs. 747,396/-

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 400,000/- Rs. 437,000/- - Rs. 17,55,883/- - - Rs. 747,396/-

6 Magnetic Stirrer with hotplate (3 Nos.)

Minimum 7” Plate, Digital Display of Temperature and RPM, Adjustable Speed and Temperature Controls, Feedback sensor for Temperature Control, Stirrer Bar. Origin UK, USA, EU, Japan, or equivalent.

Magnetic Stirrer with Hotplate Digital Temperature Range: 350 Degree Stirrer Speed: 30 to 2000 RPM Feed back Control with PID Ceramic coated Aluminum Model TS: 14S Make Jeio tech, Korea

Hotplate with Stirrer Digital UC 152D: Plate Materials: Glass Ceramic Plate Dimensions, mm 150 x 150 Heated Area:, mm 120 x 120 Heater Power, Watt 500 Max plate Temp, C 450 Stirrer Speed, rpm 100-2000 Maximum Stirring Capacity, L*15 Dimensions (w x d x h), mm 172 x 248 x 120 Net weight, kg 2.9 Electrical supply 230V, 50 Hz, 750W IP Rating 32 UC152D Digital Hotplate Stirrer Make Sturat U.K

Item not quoted Model: MS7-H550-pro Dimension of Work Plate: 184x184 (7 inche) Work Plate Material: Brushless DC Motor Motor Type: Glass ceramic Motor Rating Input (W): 18 Motor Rating Output (W): 10 Power (W): 1050 Voltage (VAC): 200-240 Frequency (Hz): 50/60 Stirring positions: 1 Max Stirring Quantity: 20 Max Magnetic Bar: 80 Speed range (rpm): Speed Display: LCD Speed Display

Specifications not mentioned in the bid.

Item not quoted

Page 20: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr #

Name of Equipment Tender Specifications M/s Linker Enterprises M/s UH Analytical Supplies M/s SKN Technologies

M/s Sameer Enterprises

M/s TR Marketing

M/s Syner Tech

Resolution rpm: +-1 Heating output (W): 1000 Heating temperature range (C): Room Temperature 550, increment 1. Control accuracy of work plate (C) +-1 (<100C), +- 1% (>100C) Safety temperature (C): 580 Temp Display: LCD Temp display accuracy (C): +-0.1 External temperature sensor: PT 1000 Control accuracy with external temperature sensor PT 1000 (+-C): +-0.2 Heating warning (C): 50 C Time setting range: - Remote Control (Rs 323 interface): Yes Protection class: IP21 Permissible ambient temperature (C): 5-40 Permissible relative humidity: 80% Model: MS7-H550-ProScilogex USA

Unit Price (Including GST) Rs. 40,000/- Rs. 48,000/- Rs. 82,789/- - Rs. 73,700/- - -

Total Price (Including GST) Rs. 120,000/- Rs. 144,000/- Rs. 248,367/- - Rs. 221,100/- Rs. 2,599,000/- -

Remarks:

Page 21: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

M/s TR Marketing has not mentioned specifications in its bid and therefore it is not possible to compare its specifications with tender and other bidder’s specifications. The said firm has not quoted cost of each item and that’s why Financial comparison is not possible. The said firm has also not provided GST and Income Tax Registration Certificates.

The item wise technical and financial comparison is done for other 5 bidders.

Item No. 1 : Item quoted by M/s UH Analytical Supplies mentions width as 1000mm which computes to 3.28 feet whereas tender specifications require 6 feet width. The item quoted by the bidder is, therefore, undersized.

Item No. 3 : Item quoted by M/s Synertech (Pvt.) Ltd. Insmark Model IS-128 pH meter, has pH range of -2.00 to +18.00 whereas tender specifications require a pH range of -2.00 to +20.00. The measurement range of the quoted item, is therefore, narrower as compared to tender specifications.

Item No. 4 : Item quoted by M/s Synertech (Pvt.) Ltd. Conductivity/TDS meter model DDF-307W make Bante China can measure conductivity upto 200mS/cm, whereas tender specifications require measurement capability at 1000mS/cm. The measurement range of the quoted item, is therefore, narrower as compared to tender specifications.

Item No. 6 : (i) : Item quoted by M/s Linker Enterprises, Model TS-14S Jeio Tech Korea has a diameter of 5.51” as compared to tender specified value of 7”. The item quoted by bidder, is therefore, undersized. (ii) : Item quoted by M/s UH Analytical Supplies, magnetic stirrer with hotplate model UC152D,Stuart UK, is 150mm in size which computes to 5.9”, whereas tender specifications require 7”. The item quoted by the bidder, is therefore, undersized.

Prepared By: Checked By

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist Analyst (EMC)

Page 22: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL PROPOSALSOF “FURNITURE & FIXTURE”

i. Name of ADP scheme: Capacity Building of EPA Punjab for Enforcement of Environmental Standards in Punjab including

Combined Effluent Treatment Plants(CETPs) and Industrial Estates (IEs) under (J&C Program)

ii. Tender opening date: 22.05.2017

iii. No. of Tender documents Issued: 04

iv. No. of Tenders/bids received: 01

v. Indenter: Deputy Director (Labs), Lahore

Sr.

# Detail of Item Quantity Unit

M/s TR

Marketing

1. Executive Table Size: 2030 x 920 x 760 mm (H) Structure made of high density chipboard pressed with Shishamveneer on both sides. Top frame made of solid

seasoned shisham wood. With three leatherite panels. With 3 lockable

drawers. Finished with N.C. lacquer.

1 Set. Specifications

not mentioned

2. Office Table Size: 1200 x 600 x 760 mm (H) Top/side panels made of high density 25 mm thick

chipboard pressed with shisham veneer on both sides, one side drawer

box, consist of 3 drawers, top drawer lockable. Finished with N.C.

lacquer.

4 Nos. -do-

3. Executive Revolving Chair Structure made of solid seasoned wood. Finished with N.C. lacquer. Seat and back cushioned with sofa

cloth / leatherite. Back diamond cushioned style. Complete with

revolving pedestal.

1 No. -do-

4. Revolving Chair Inner structure made of solid seasoned wood. Fully

cushioned with 1st quality foam covered with green leatherite.

Complete with tilting pedestal.

13 Nos. -do-

Page 23: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr.

# Detail of Item Quantity Unit

M/s TR

Marketing

5. Visitor Chair Structure made of solid shisham wood. Seat/back with 1st quality foam covered with leatherite. Wooden part finished with N.C lacquer.

10 Nos. -do-

6. Office Chair Structure/seat and back made of solid seasoned shisham

wood. Finished with N.C. lacquer. Seat and back cushioned with

leatherite. Complete with revolving pedestal.

04 Nos -do-

7. Office Chair Structure/seat and back made of solid seasoned shisham

wood. Finished with N.C. lacquer. Seat and back cushioned with

leatherite.

08 Nos -do-

8. 3-Seater Sofa Set Inner structure made of solid seasoned wood. Fully cushioned with foam covered with leatherite. 1 Set (2 +1)

6 Nos. -do-

9. Corner Table Set Size: - 600x600x450 mm (H). Top frame made of solid seasoned shisham wood. With Glass top. Structure made of solid seasoned shisham Wood. Finished with N.C. lacquer.

2 Nos. -do-

10. Centre Table C.T. Size: - 1200x600x450 mm (H). Top frame made of solid seasoned shisham wood. With Glass top. Structure made of solid seasoned shisham Wood. Finished with N.C. lacquer.

1 No. -do-

11. Workstation Size: 4.5' x 2.5' x 4.5' mm Structure made of high density lamination board with keyboard tray, CPU Box and drawer box.

8 Nos. -do-

12. Providing and Fixing Bath Room English Type Comode with all necessary porta make complete

in all respect. 1 No -do-

Page 24: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr.

# Detail of Item Quantity Unit

M/s TR

Marketing

13. Providing and Fixing Photo Copy Wooden Table 2'-6"x 2' Shisham wood Frame Top Shisham

Veneer, Polish / Lacquar complete in all respect. 1 No. -do-

14. Providing and Fixing Wooden Partition with 8mm Glass, Shisham Wood Frame, Shisham veneer

both side with Polish / Lacquar complete in all respect. 220 Sft -do-

15. Dismantling and Removing of Wooden Table, Ceiling, Electric Item etc. Job -do-

16. Providing & fixing glass for Partition using top & bottom as per existing color aluminum H-

section with 12mm thick imported clear glass size and shape including all necessary hardware

and fittings, application of silicone for joints complete in all respects. 72 Sft -do-

17. Providing and Fixing glass door using aluminum H- section on top & bottom with 12mm thick

imported clear glass with Gaskitsize and shape including bolts,nuts,screws,handle,floor machine

, complete in all respects. 21 Sft -do-

18. Providing and installation of wooden vertical drop beam of 2"x1½"partal wood battens

horizontal and vertical using 1/2" thick imported MDF board on bottom and sides ,properly

hanged and provided over glazed partitions and doors complete in all respect. 12 Rft -do-

19. Providing and Fixing Brick work 4½" Thick 1:5 Cement, sand complete in all respect. Providing

and Fixing Brick work 4½" Thick 1:5 Cement, sand complete in all respect. 450 sft -do-

20. Providing and Fixing Plastering of wall 1:4 cement, sand mixing complete in all respect. 950 sft -do-

21. Providing and fixing Ceiling, 2'x2' Elephant Brand 1/8" Grove Chanel Patti hanging with angle

complete in all respect. 960 Sft -do-

22. Providing and painting LED Light 18w imported make complete in all respect. 40 Nos. -do-

23. Providing and Fixing MS Switch Board with light switch socket complete in all respect. 4 Nos. -do-

24. Providing and Fixing Switch Wiring 3/29 Pakistan Cable or new age make for switches sockets

complete in all respect. Job -do-

25. Providing and Fixing Bath Room W.C Indian Type with all necessary porta make complete in all

respect. 1 No -do-

26. Providing and Fixing Wash Basen with all necessary Fittings porta make complete in all respect. 2 Nos. -do-

27. Providing and Fixing Kitchen SS Steel Sink Bowl with all necessary complete in all respect. 1 No. -do-

28. Providing and Fixing Kitchen SS Steel Sink Mixture with all necessary complete in all respect. 3 Nos. -do-

29. Providing and Fixing Muslim Shower with all necessary complete in all respect. 2 Nos. -do-

30. Providing and Fixing PPR Pipe for water Supply 1/2", 3/4" with all necessary fitting complete in

all respect. 350 Rft -do-

31. Providing and Fixing UPVC Pipe 4", 6" for water Drain with all necessary fitting complete in all

respect. 110 Rft -do-

32. Providing and Fixing Kitchen RCC Slab with Plaster & Marble over Slab complete in all respect. 18 sft -do-

33. Providing and Fixing Kitchen Wooden Cabnetpartal wood lamination sheet 3/4" thick with all 20 sft -do-

Page 25: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”

Sr.

# Detail of Item Quantity Unit

M/s TR

Marketing necessary fitting complete in all respect.

34. Providing and Fixing Kitchen / Bath Room Ceramic Tiles Wall & Floor 10" x 13" Master make

with Filling, complete in all respect. 460 Sft. -do-

35. Providing and painting Three coats of (ICI) paint on walls of desired color including prime coat

of Dulux or an approved equivalent, preparation of plastered surfaces with puttine, as per

manufacturer's specifications, complete in all respects. 2100 Sft. -do

Remarks:

Only one Firm namely “M/s TR Marketing” has participated in Tender of Furniture & Fixture. The said firm has not mentioned specifications and cost of

individual items. The firm stated during the meeting of Tender opening that it will deliver the items/goods mentioned in the Tender Documents within specified

time.

The estimated Cost for Tender of Furniture & Fixture is Rs. 30,00,000/- while the said bidder has quoted rate i.e. Rs. 34,00,000/-

The firm has not provided document of GST and Income Tax Registration as the said firm is not Income Tax and GST registered which was pre-requisite in the

Tender Notice. The matter has been discussed with said firm. The management has stated that registration of Income Tax and GST of said firm is under process.

Prepared By: Checked By

Assistant Director (Imp) Procurement Specialist

Page 26: SCRUTINY/EVALUATION OF TECHNICAL & FINANCIAL … Technical report.pdfCD/DVD External Super Drive External Super Drive - Samsung/Transcent External +- RW, Super Drive v. Display 13.3”