WESTFIELD HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING FAIR JUDGE,S SCORE CARD 1 Project#: 114 J Title: Screen Protectors, Glass, and a Relatively Small Sledgehammer

Scientific or Engineering Approach Suggested Scoring Ranges:

Science Project I OR I Engineering Project D Cleary Stated Hypothesis D Identified need or problem D Logical Experiment with Control D Development of clear 0-10: 4-5 elements missing or poorly executed

D Accuracy of Data & Observations performance criteria 11-20: Z-3 elements missing or poorly executed

D Logical, Well-supported D Well-constructed & tested Z1-Z5: 1 element missing or poorly executed 26-30: Contains all required elements

Conclusions prototype

D Consideration of Future Research D Retesting & redesign D Feasibility Study

Score: (0-30 Points)

Understanding of Science or Engineering 0-10: 3-4 elements missing or poorly executed

D Application &Understanding of Scientific Method or Design Process 11-20: 1-2 elements missing or poorly executed D Conclusions are Consistent with Data or Testing 21-25: Contains all required elements

D Knowledge of Literature Relevant to Project D Connections to other Disciplines

Score: (0-25 Points)

Innovation/ Creativity /Rigor D Highly original topic and/or Creative approach to problem solving D Evidence of social impact or Scientific significance 0-7: Contains 1 or fewer elements

D Long term project/significant time requirements 8-14: Contains at least 2-3 elements 15-20: Contains at least 4/5 elements

D Much time and effort given to literature-based research D Safety Precautions Observed

Score: (0-20 Points)

Presentation D Clarity of Auditory Presentation D Effectiveness and Use of Visual Display 0-5: Missing Z+ elements

D Ability to Answer Judge's Questions Appropriately 6-10: Missing 1 element 11-15: Has all required elements

D Evidence of Equitable Collaboration (Teams)

Score: (0-15 Points)

Laboratory Notebook D Well-documented Entries (Each student in a team has their own lab 0-3: No notebook/minimal entries

notebook) 4-6: Some entries + all signatures and dates

D Signed and Dated Records 7-10: Many entries+ all signatures and dates

D Evidence of Project Development documented over extended time period

Score: {0-10 Points)

Judge's Signature: Total Score: (100 Points)

Project#: 114 I Title: Screen Protectors, Glass, and a Relatively Small Sledgehammer

Comments to Exhibitor(s):