scope inquiry public document - foreign-trade zones board...2011/08/05 · preliminary...

A-570-504

Scope Inquiry Public Document

IA/NME/9: TL

August 5, 2011 MEMORANDUM FOR: Gary Taverman Acting Deputy Assistant Secretary for Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Operations FROM: James C. Doyle Director AD/CVD Operations, Office 9 Import Administration SUBJECT: Final Scope Ruling: Antidumping Duty Order on Petroleum Wax Candles From the People’s Republic of China (“PRC”) SUMMARY On June 11, 2009, July 7, 2009, August 20, 2009, and May 5, 2010, the Department of Commerce (“Department”) received requests from Trade Associates Group, Ltd. (“TAG”), Candym Enterprises, Ltd. (“Candym”),1 Sourcing International, LLC (“Sourcing International”), and Accent Imports (“Accent”),2 respectively,3 for scope rulings to determine whether each company’s respective assortment of candles is outside the scope of the antidumping duty order on petroleum wax candles from the PRC. See Antidumping Duty Order: Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China, 51 FR 30686 (August 28, 1986) (“Order”). The recommendations for the Department regarding which candles should, or should not, be found within the scope of the Order (all in accordance with 19 CFR 351.225(k)(1)) are listed infra. 4 Background Requestors filed the instant requests for scope rulings in proper form on the dates listed in the Summary section. On August 9, 2010, the Department issued preliminary determinations for the requests in conjunction with the preliminary results5 of its request for comments regarding the

1 Candym also submitted a scope ruling request on November 5, 2009. For the purposes of this memorandum, the Department will treat the candles from Candym’s two requests as one total. 2 Collectively, “Requestors” 3 These requests, which are the subject of analysis of this memorandum, are collectively deemed “the instant requests.” 4 The Department has a website that allows interested parties to access prior scope determinations related to the Order from 1991 to the present. It can be accessed at http://ia.ita.doc.gov/download/candles-prc-scope/index.html and is updated periodically to include newly issued scope determinations. 5 See Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Preliminary Results of Request for Comments on the Scope of the Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China Antidumping Duty Order, 75 FR 49475 (August 13, 2010) (“Preliminary Results”).

http://ia.ita.doc.gov/download/candles-prc-scope/index.html

appropriate interpretation6 of the Order.7 On October 13, 2010, the Department issued preliminary determinations for pending scope rulings that it had inadvertently neglected to include with the Preliminary Results.8 On October 18, 2010, the National Candle Association (“NCA”), an interested party in this proceeding, filed comments in which it disagreed with the Department’s preliminary determinations.9 Specifically, the NCA argued that the Department’s analysis was flawed because it entailed ascertaining whether the candles conformed to the candle shapes and types listed in the Order’s scope language. Product Description Due to the large number of candles in the instant requests, the Department has provided a description of each candle in the attached appendix rather than in the instant memorandum. See Appendix. Legal Framework The regulations governing the Department’s antidumping scope determinations are found at 19 CFR 351.225. On matters concerning the scope of an antidumping duty order, the Department first examines the descriptions of the merchandise contained in the petition, the initial investigation and the determinations of the Secretary (including prior scope determinations) and the U.S. International Trade Commission (“ITC”). This determination may take place with or without a formal inquiry. If the Department determines that these descriptions are dispositive of the matter, the Department will issue a final scope ruling as to whether the subject merchandise is covered by the Order. See 19 CFR 351.225(k)(1). Conversely, where the descriptions of the merchandise are not dispositive, the Department will consider the five additional factors set forth at 19 CFR 351.225(k)(2). These criteria are: (1) the physical characteristics of the merchandise; (2) the expectations of the ultimate purchasers; (3) the ultimate use of the product; (4) the channels of trade in which the product is sold; and (5) the manner in which the product is advertised and displayed. The determination as to which analytical framework is most appropriate in any given scope inquiry is made on a case-by-case basis after consideration of all evidence before the Department. In this case, the Department has evaluated the instant requests in accordance with 19 CFR 351.225(k)(1) and the scope interpretation detailed in the final results of this proceeding. The Department finds that the descriptions of the products contained in the petition, the initial investigation, and the determinations of the Secretary (including prior scope determinations) and

6 The details regarding the request for comments and the Department’s subsequent re-interpretation of the Order are described infra. 7 See Memorandum to the File through Alex Villanueva, Program Manager, from Tim Lord, Case Analyst, Certain Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Candle Scope Request Preliminary Determinations (August 9, 2010). 8 See Memorandum to the File through Alex Villanueva, Program Manager, from Tim Lord, Case Analyst, Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Preliminary Scope Rulings not Included in Preliminary Results (October 13, 2010). 9 See Letter from the National Candle Association to the Secretary of Commerce: Comments on Preliminary Scope Rulings Not Included in Preliminary Results of Request for Comments on the Scope of the Petroleum Wax Candles From the People’s Republic of China Antidumping Duty Order- Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China (A-570-504) (October 18, 2010).

2

the ITC are dispositive with respect to the candles of the instant requests. Therefore, for these candles, the Department finds it unnecessary to consider the additional factors set forth at 19 CFR 351.225(k)(2). Documents and parts thereof from the underlying investigation that the Department deemed relevant to this scope ruling were made part of the record of this determination and are referenced herein. The Department has explained its analysis of the record evidence in the Final Results10 and accompanying Issues and Decision Memorandum. In accordance with this analysis, the Department has found that the scope of the Order includes candles of any shape, with the exception of birthday candles, birthday numeral candles, utility candles, and figurine candles. Background In its September 4, 1985, petition, the NCA requested that the since the less-than-fair value antidumping duty investigation (“LTFV investigation”) cover:

{c}andles {which} are made from petroleum wax and contain fiber or paper-cored wicks. They are sold in the following shapes: tapers, spirals, and straight-sided dinner candles; rounds, columns, pillars; votives; and various wax-filled containers. These candles may be scented or unscented . . . and are generally used by retail consumers in the home or yard for decorative or lighting purposes.

See Antidumping Petition (September 4, 1985) (“Petition”), at 7. The Department used this same language to define the scope of the investigation in its notice of initiation. This language carried forward without change through the preliminary and final determinations of sales at less than fair value and the eventual antidumping duty order:

{c}ertain scented or unscented petroleum wax candles made from petroleum wax and having fiber or paper-cored wicks. They are sold in the following shapes: tapers, spirals, and straight-sided dinner candles; rounds, columns, pillars, votives; and various wax-filled containers.

See Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Initiation of Antidumping Duty Investigation, 50 FR 39743 (September 30, 1985); see also Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Preliminary Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair Value, 51 FR 6016 (February 19, 1986); Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Final Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair Value, 51 FR 25085 (July 10, 1986); and Order. The Department’s interpretation of scope coverage during the early history of the Order was that birthday candles, birthday numeral candles, and “novelty candles” (candles in the shape of identifiable objects, or with holiday, religious, or special-occasion themes) were outside the scope of the Order. During this time, the Department conducted PRC petroleum wax candle scope rulings under the assumption that the scope of the Order was exclusive because it only 10 See Final Results of Request for Comments on the Scope of the Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China Antidumping Duty Order, 76 FR 46277 (August 2, 2011)(“Final Results”) and accompanying Issues and Decision Memorandum (“I&D Memo”).,.

3

covered the candle shapes and types specifically enumerated in scope’s text (i.e., “tapers, spirals, and straight-sided dinner candles; rounds, columns, pillars, votives; and various wax-filled containers”) (“the enumerated shapes/types”) and excluded all other candle shapes and types, including all birthday/birthday numeral candles and novelty candles. In November 2001, the Department reconsidered this exclusive interpretation as it pertained to candle shapes. See Final Scope Ruling Antidumping Duty Order on Petroleum Wax Candles From the People’s Republic of China (A–570–504); JC Penney Purchasing Corporation, (November 9, 2001) (‘‘JC Penney’’). In this ruling, the Department reviewed the text of the scope of the Order, beginning with the first sentence, which states that covered are “{c}ertain scented or unscented petroleum wax candles made from petroleum wax and having fiber or paper-cored wicks.” See Order. The Department stated in JC Penney:

{t}he text following this broad inclusive sentence provides a list of shapes, which list is not modified by any express words of exclusivity. The result of our prior practice of excluding candles of a shape other than those listed was arguably inconsistent with the fact that such candles were scented or unscented petroleum wax candles made from petroleum wax and having fiber or paper–cored wicks.’

See JC Penney at 4–5, fn 1. Furthermore, in JC Penney, the Department stated:

We now determine that this practice was incorrect because it had the effect of narrowing the broad coverage of the first sentence of the Order’s scope. The list of shapes in the second sentence of the Order’s scope does not provide a textual basis for such a narrowing of the coverage of the first sentence of the Order’s scope.

See JC Penney at 5, fn 1.

Therefore, since 2001, the Department has interpreted the scope of the Order inclusively, finding that if a candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper–cored wick it falls within the scope of the Order regardless of shape, unless the candle is a birthday/birthday numeral candle or a novelty candle, in which case it is excluded from the scope of the Order. In the 2006 LDM Anticircumvention Determination, the Department found that a mixed-wax candle11 containing any amount of petroleum was subject to the Order (unless the candle contains 50 percent or more of beeswax). See Later–Developed Merchandise Anticircumvention Inquiry of the Antidumping Duty Order on Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Affirmative Final Determination of Circumvention of the Antidumping Duty Order, 71 FR 59075 (October 6, 2006) (“LDM Anticircumvention Determination”). On August 21, 2009, the Department solicited comments from the general public on the best method to consider whether novelty candles should or should not be included within the scope of the Order given the uncertainty of the novelty exception’s origin and the extremely large number of scope determinations requested by outside parties. See Petroleum Wax Candles from the People’s Republic of China: Request for Comments on the Scope of the Antidumping Duty 11 Mixed-wax candles are those that contain a mixture of petroleum and other types of wax, such as vegetable-based wax.

4

Order and the Impact on Scope Determinations, 74 FR 42230 (August 21, 2009) (“Request for Comments”). After a thorough analysis of record evidence from the LTFV investigation, the Department reached its final determination regarding the proper interpretation of the scope of the Order on July 26, 201112 (discussed in the Analysis section, infra). Analysis In the Final Results, the Department found that the scope of the Order should be based on “Option B,” proposed in the Department’s Request for Comments, which states:

The Department would consider all candle shapes, including novelty candles, to be within the scope of the Order, including those not in the shapes listed in the scope of the Order, as that is not an exhaustive list of shapes, but simply an illustrative list of common candle shapes.13

While including all aspects of Option B in its new interpretation, the Department added the modification that three types of candles would be excluded from the scope of the Order: birthday candles, utility candles, and figurine candles.14 The Department also found that record evidence from the LTFV investigation does not support the exclusion of candles based on holiday/religious/special-occasion themes, and therefore, that holiday/religious/special-occasion characteristics would have no bearing in determining whether a candle is included or excluded from the scope of the Order. See I&D Memo, at Comment 3.D. The Department determined that birthday candles are typically small, thin, pillar-shaped candles that range from 2 inches to 3.5 inches in height, 0.18 inch to 0.25 inch in width, and packaged in quantities of 10 to 24; and birthday numeral candles as candles that are in the shape of numbers that typically range from 2 to 4 inches in height (See I&D Memo, at Comment 3.A), and that utility candles are typically white in color, 5 inches long, 0.75 inch in diameter, and packaged in quantities of two or more (See I&D Memo, at Comment 3.B). The Department also found that record evidence best supports a scope interpretation where “figurine” is based on the definition of this term from the Webster’s Online Dictionary: “1. {a} small carved or molded figure...2. A very small figure, whether human or of an animal; especially, one in terra cotta or the like; -- distinguished from statuette, which is applied to small figures in bronze, marble, etc.” See I&D Memo, at Comment 3.C. Based on this definition, we found that the best description of a figurine candle is a candle that is in the shape of a human, animal, or deity. Id. In sum, the Department found that the scope should be read inclusively, reaffirming JC Penney,15 and that we would therefore interpret the scope of the Order as follows: all petroleum wax candles (regardless of holiday/religious/special-occasion theme), are within the scope of the Order, except for birthday candles, utility candles, and figurine candles. The Department still holds this interpretation. The Department has applied its interpretation of the Order’s scope to the candles in the instant requests below. As noted supra, the Department’s new interpretation is such that a candle’s conformity to one of the enumerated shapes/types no longer has bearing on scope coverage, 12 See Final Results. 13 See Request for Comments, at 74 FR 42231. 14 See I&D Memo, at Comment 1. 15 Though, unlike JC Penney, which relied largely on the text of the Order, the Department found that descriptions of the merchandise from the LTFV investigation also support an inclusive reading of the scope.

5

because all petroleum wax candles are within the scope of the Order, with only birthday candles, utility candles, and figurine candles excluded:

Accent Imports Product No.

Product Name

Total No. of Candles

Total No. of Unique Candles16

Within Scope?

Analysis

N22432 Rose Shaped Tea-light Candle

2 2 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Further, this product is not a birthday, utility, or figurine candle, and therefore, is within the scope of the Order.

N22418 Owl Shape Tea-light Candle

1 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, this candle is in the shape of an animal. As such, we find that this candle is a figurine, and therefore, is outside the scope of the Order.

N22423 Pinecone Shaped Tea-light Candle


N22431 Rose Shaped Candle


N22422 Pinecone Shaped Candle


N22426 Ornament Shaped Tea-light Candle


N22427 Beaded Cone Shape Tree Candle 21”H


N22428 Beaded Cone Shape Tree Candle 8.25”H


16 “Unique candles” are those in a set that are non-identical. For example, if a requestor were to submit a set of three beach ball candles, and two of those candles were exactly the same size, shape, and color, while the third was not, then the set would consist of two unique candles.

6

Candym Enterprises, Ltd. Product No.

Product Name


Total No. of Unique Candles

Within Scope?

Analysis

R3115 Hyacinth Flower Bulb Shaped Candle 4.5”H


RT3127 Tree Shaped Tealight Candles


RT3132 Buck Head Shaped Candle

1 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, this candle is in the shape of an animal, or more precisely, an animal’s head. As such, we find that this candle is a figurine, and therefore, is outside the scope of the Order.

RT3138 Tree Shaped Tea-light Candle


RT3136 Tree Shaped Candle 12.5”H


RT3137 Tree Shaped Candle 8”H






R3120 Mushroom 3”H


R3119 Mushroom (Set6)


7

R3124 Succulent (Set6)


R3126 Succulent in Pot


R0183 Stone in Tube


R3109 Rock 4”L (3ASST)


R3116 Flower Bulb 5”H


Sourcing International Product No.

Product Name



Within Scope?

Analysis

1003 6 Mini Cactus Asst.


1016 Peony Bunch


1017 Rose Bunch


1018 Anemone Bunch


1019 Gerber Daisy Bunch


1021 Sunflower Bunch


8

1029 Hyacinth Bulb


1030 Hyacinth Bulb


1031 Hyacinth Bulb


1045 Yellow Sun Cameo Candle


1010 Sunflower Floating Candles


1011 Pink Floating Daisies


1034 Yellow Sunflowers


1033 Orange Anemones


1035 Purple Zinnia


1028 Ladybug Gnome Candle

1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Furthermore, this candle is not a birthday or utility candle. Finally, this candle is not a figurine, because it represents a fictitious creature (gnome), and not a human, animal, or deity. Therefore, this candle is within the scope of the Order.

1037 Pot of 3 Sunflowers


1038 Pot of 6 White Daisies


9

1040 Pot of 3 Pink Daisies


1041 Pot of 3 Orange Tulips


1042 Pot of 3 Yellow Daffodils


1043 Pot of 3 Purple Violets


1032 Hyacinth Bulb


1004 3 Pink Roses


1005 3 Red Roses


1006 3 Yellow Roses


1002 6 Mini Flower Pots Asst. B


1001 6 Mini Flower Pots Asst. A


1036 Petite Orange Tulip Bunch


1024 Rose Flower Bouquet


1022 White Lily Pave


10

1023 Daffodil Pave


1025 Stargazer Pave


1026 Tulip Pave 1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Further, this product is not a birthday, utility, or figurine candle, and therefore, is within the scope of the Order.

1027 Sunflower Pave


1009 Small Pink Rose


1012 Large Pink Rose


1008 Floating Sunflower


1013 Red Rose Sphere


1014 Fuchsia Rose Sphere


1015 Small Pink Rose Sphere


1020 Yellow Tulip Pave


1044 Petite Pink Tulip Bunch


1007 Floating Dahlia Candle


11

Trade Associates Group, Ltd.

Product No.

Product Name



Within Scope?

Analysis

610583 White Pumpkin Candle


4325 Macintosh Apple Candle


4225 Red Delicious Apple Candle


710055 Pumpkin Candle


610582 Orange Pumpkin Candle


210003 Cupcake Party Candle


710003 Pumpkin Candles


710052 Mini Pear Candles




710056 Gourd Candle


711111 Harvest Apple


12

710053 Large Scented Pear Candle


610586 Gourd Candles


610581 Tall Orange Pumpkin


610579 Harvest Apple Candle


410182 Watering Can Candle




610512 Snowcap Taper Tree Candle


610523 Large Snowcap Tree


610588 Large Onion Candle


610066 Floating Golden Tree Glitter Candles


610543 Whimsy Snowman

1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Furthermore, this candle is not a birthday or utility candle. Finally, this candle is not a figurine, because it represents an inanimate object (snowman), and not a human, animal, or deity. Therefore, this candle is within the scope of the Order.

13



610544 Snowman Tealights


710028 Mini Ornament Tealights


610099 Floating Tree Candle




710975 Gumdrop Tree Candle


610549 Snowman Round Ornament




710030 Glitter Ornament Candle


610550 Treelight Ornament Candle


610509 Small Snowball Candle

1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Further, this product is not a birthday, utility, or figurine candle, and therefore, is within the scope of

14

the Order.

610508 Large Snowball Candle


610520 Golden Swirl Round Ornament


610482 Pinecone Round Ornament


710029 Large Whimsy Ornament Candle


610480 Berry Swirl Round Ornament


610145 Dots Metallic Ornament Candle


610333 Large Sparkle Tree


610546 Large Treelight Candle


710026 Glitter Tree Candle


610587 Small Onion Candle


710024 Bat Candle on a String Set

1 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, this candle is in the shape of an animal, and as such, is a figurine. Therefore, this candle is outside the scope of the Order.

15

710943 Pumpkin Hat Candle

1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Furthermore, this candle is not a birthday or utility candle. Finally, this candle is not a figurine, because it represents an inanimate object (jack-o-lantern), and not a human, animal, or deity. Therefore, this candle is within the scope of the Order.

410032 Mini Cupcake Candles


610403 Tall Pumkin Candle


100167 Small Firecracker Candles


711107 Floating Snowman Candle


410174 Beach Ball Candles


410048 Sherbet Candles Set


610545 Snowman Taper


610540 Snowman Floating Candles


510101 Crazy Eggs Candle


610172 Small Candy Corn Candle


16

the Order.

610585 Large Acorn Candle


610573 Brussels Sprout Candles


410079 Garden Snail Candle


419938 Large Watermelon Candle


610347 Large pumpkin Candle




610405 Small Pumkin Candle


410078 Garden Frog Candle


510008 Chick Candle


410028 Chick’n Egg Candle


710102 Floating Holiday Cookie Candles


710082 Floating Ornament Candles


17

610167 Floating Fall Leaf Candles


410068 Floating Turtle Candles


419952 Floating Leaf Candles


510092 Jumbo Flip Flop Candles


419924 Floating Small Flower Candles


610143 Heart Votives


610345 Haunted House Candle


610385 Critter Candles

4 4 No These candles are made from petroleum wax and have fiber or paper-cored wicks. However, these candles are in the shape of various animals. As such, we find that these candles are figurines, and therefore, outside the scope of the Order.

419936 Sunflower Candles


610473 Autumn 3-Wick Candle


710101 Peppermint Candy Candles


510055 3-Part Bunny Candle


18

710971 Gumdrop Candles


610584 Small Acorn Candles


610474 Autumn Leaf Candle


610170 Large Candy Corn Candle


510059 Umbrella Candle


200023 Large Chocolate Egg Candles


610330 Candy Cane Ball


610561 Peppermint Candles


100168 Large Firecracker Candle


710071 Caramel Apple Candle


No product #

Flower Bunch


No product #

Flower Bunch


No product #

Flower Bunch


19

No product #

Flower Bunch


610111 Floating Winter Sprig Candles s/2


301928 Floating Holly Candles s/4 - Green




900347 Floating Holly Candles s/4


610206 Holly Berry Floating Leaf Candles s/2 Green


610598 Small Treelight Tree Candle Green


610597 Small Treelight Tree Candle White


610547 Large Treelight Tree Candle White


610332 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Dk Olive


610295 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Red


610297 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Gold


20

610303 Large Sparkle Tree Candle - Red


610305 Large Sparkle Tree Candle - Gold


610299 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Olive


610301 Large Sparkle Tree Candle - Olive


610319 Mini Sparkle Tree Candles s/3 - Red


610321 Mini Sparkle Tree Candles s/3 - Gold


610323 Mini Sparkle Tree Candles s/3 - Olive


711073 Large Golden Tree Glitter Candle - Gold


711075 Small Golden Tree Glitter Candle - Gold


610307 Large Whimsy Tree Candle - Green


610309 Small Whimsy Tree Candle - Green


610036 Floating Whimsy Tree

5 3 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Further, this product is not a birthday,

21

Candles s/5 - Multi

utility, or figurine candle, and therefore, is within the scope of the Order.

690041 Metallic Ball Tree Candle - Multi


610101 Glitter Tree Straight Candles s/2 - Red


610103 Glitter Tree Straight Candles s/2 - Ivory


610524 Medium Snowcap Tree Candle White


610525 Small Snowcap Tree Candles White


710026 Glitter Tree Candles - Ivory


900334 Floating Jester Stocking Dark Red


100878 Mini Nutcracker Candles s/3 - Multi

3 3 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Furthermore, this candle is not a birthday or utility candle. Finally, this candle is not a figurine, because it represents an inanimate object (a nutcracker), and not a human, animal, or deity. Therefore, this candle is within the scope of the Order.

610042 Snowman Candle - White


100754 Snowman Woodcut Candle - Multi


22

711165 Happy Snowman Candle - Red


711167 Happy Snowman Candle - Green


610142 Floating Snowman Candle - Multi


610144 Dots Metallic Ornament Candle - Fuchsia


710000 Swirl Ornament Candle - Red/Green


710001 Swirl Ornament Candle - Red/White


710002 Dots Ornament Candle - White


710095 Sm Whimsy Ornament Candles s/4 - Multi


610104 Metallic Ball Candle - Multi


610095 Small Golden Ball Candle - Gold


610096 Large Golden Ball Candle - Gold


23

710022 Large Pumpkin Candles - Multi


610006 Floating Pumpkin Candles s/3 - Orange


710021 Pumpkin Tealight Candles s/6 - Multi


710945 Pumpkin Hat Candle - Orange

1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Furthermore, this candle is not a birthday or utility candle. Finally, this candle is not a figurine, because it represents an inanimate object (jack-o-lantern), and not a human, animal, or deity. Therefore, this candle is within the scope of the Order.

610025 Witch’s Hat Candle - Black


610168 Witch’s Cauldron Candle - Orange


610419 Halloween Floating Candles s/6


710935 Floating Glitter Spider Web Candle


610176 Floating Halloween Candles - Multi


610017 Small Ghost Lantern Candle

1 1 Yes This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. Furthermore, this candle is not a birthday or utility candle. Finally, this candle is not a figurine, because it represents a ghost, not a human, animal, or deity. Therefore, this candle is within the scope of the Order.

610018 Large Ghost Lantern Candle - White


24

610000 Ghost Tealights s/4 - White


610024 Ghost Taper Candle s/2 - White


610204 Ghost Candle - White


710931 Mini Floating Ghost Candle - White


610010 Floating Mini Ghost Candles s/4 - White


410922 Sweetheart Candles s/6 - Red


410904 Sweetheart Tealights s/9


610121 Hugs & Kisses Tealight s/9 - Multi


412916 Bunny w/Egg Candle Ivory

1 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, it is in the shape of an animal. As such, we find that this candle is a figurine, and is therefore outside the scope of the Order.

510054 Floating Bunny Candles s/3 - Multi Pastel


510013 Bunny Straight Candle - Multi Pastel


25

510067 Bunny Candles in a Basket s/4 - Multi Pastel


510053 Crazy Eggs Candles s/4 - Multi Pastel


510547 Egg Candle in a Cup - Yellow


510551 Egg Candle in a Cup - Pink


510555 Egg Candle in a Cup - Blue


510557 Egg Candle in a Cup - Green


510099 Robin’s Egg Candles s/3 Blue


510005 Chirping Chick Candle - Lt Green


510006 Chirping Chick Candle - Lt Pink


510007 Chirping Chick Candle - Yellow


610097 Floating Peppermint Candle s/8 red


710068 Marshmallow Candles s/4 - Multi


710057 Candy Cane Candle - Multi


26

the Order.

410972 Floating Spiral Candles s/4 - Multi


610037 Asst Sugar Cookie Candles s/16 - Multi


610400 Floating Mini Apple Candles s/9 - Multi


610579 Mini Harvest Apple Candles s/12 Dark Red


610051 Mini Sugared Apples & Pears s/6 - White


100785 Sugared Mini Fruit Candles s/9 - Multi


711115 Sugared Mini Harvest Candles s/3 - Multi


711113 Sugared Harvest Pomegranate Candle - Terracotta


4676 Mini Floating Pear Candles s/9 - Spring Green


610398 Floating Mini Pear Candles s/9 - Spring Green


711109 Sugared Harvest Pear Candle - Olive


27

419940 Small Watermelon Candle - Multi


610589 Pumpkin Cluster Candle s/16 Orange


900298 s/3 Baby Boo Candles White


610287 Baby Boo Pumpkin Candles s/3 - Multi Harvest


610196 Baby Boo Pumpkin Candle - Ivory


711117 Harvest Pumpkin Candle - Ivory


711119 Harvest Gourd Candle - Olive


711121 Harvest Gourd Candle - Terracotta


371322 Pumpkin Candle - Orange


371326 Pumpkin Candle - Green


371429 Gourd Candle - Multi


710953 Large Sugared Pumpkin Candle - Orange


710955 Small Sugared Pumpkin Candle -


28

Orange the Order.

410077 Garden Bird Candle Assortment - Multi

1 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, it is in the shape of an animal As such, we find that this candle is a figurine, and is therefore outside the scope of the Order.

900218 Bird Candle - Silver


200614 Chocolate Bunny Candles s/3 - Multi


412948 Bunny Candle s/2 - Ivory


412960 Baby Chick Candles s/3


210905 Large L’il Chick Candle - Yellow


411985 Small L’il Chick Candle - Yellow


200569 Floating Frog Candles s/2 - Green


200567 Floating Ladybug Candles s/2 - Green


200568 Floating Turtle Candles s/3 - Green


900353 Hula Girl Floaters s/2

2 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, it is in the shape of a human. As such, we find that this candle is a figurine, and is therefore outside the scope of the Order.

910735 Tiki Floating Candles s/2 Wood

2 1 No This candle is made from petroleum wax and has a fiber or paper-cored wick. However, it is in the shape of a Polynesian deity, a Tiki. As such, we find that this candle is a figurine, and is therefore outside the scope of the Order.

29

410004 Large Floating Bright Candle - Red


410005 Large Floating Bright Candle - Yellow


410006 Large Floating Bright Candle - Aqua


410007 Large Floating Bright Candle - Kiwi


200013 Assorted Flower Tealights s/9 - Multi


3709 Bright Flowers Tealight s/6 - Blue


510577 Large Zinnia Illuminating Candle - Red


510579 Large Zinnia Illuminating Candle - Yellow


510581 Large Zinnia Illuminating Candle - Kiwi


419996 Mini Floating Zinnia Candle s/3 - Multi


510074 Floating Spring Candles s/3 - Multi Pastel


610240 Floating Mini Leaf Candles s/9 - Multi


30

Harvest the Order.

710058 Falling Leaves Floating Candles s/4 - Multi Harvest


610159 Acorn Candles s/6


610208 Sugared Acorn & Pumpkin Candles s/6 - Multi Harvest


419926 Watering Can Candle - Olive


200094 Garden Birdhouse Candle - Sage


410000 Flip Flop Stripe Candle s/2 - Multi


410038 Flip Flop Polka Dot Candles s/2 Red


410039 Flip Flop Flower Candles s/2 Orange


410040 Flip Flop Striped Candles s/2 Lt Aqua


412003 Floating Flip Flop Candles s/2 Kiwi


412005 Floating Flip Flop Candles s/2 - Fuchsia


31

412964 Floating Flip Flop Candles s/2 - Yellow


510066 Floating Patriotic Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Multi


510593 Sangria Stripe Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Multi Primary


510613 Floating Flower Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Aqua


510615 Floating Flower Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Red


510617 Floating Flower Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Kiwi


900220 Flip Flop Candles Red


900221 s/2 Flip Flop Candles Blue


900351 Flip Flop Candles s/2 Orange


900352 Flip Flop Candles s/2 Pink


900220 s/2 Flip Flop Candles Red




32





910016 Floating Flip Flop Candle Orange


910725 Hawaiian Shirt Floating Candle Red/White


910723 Hawaiian Shirt Floating Candle Blue/White


910727 Shorts Floating Candle Blue


910729 Shorts Floating Candle Red


910731 Surfboard Floaters s/2 Red


910733 Surfboard Floaters s/2 Blue


910719 Woodie Car with Surfboard


710977 Large Scented Snowball Candle - White


710979 Small Scented Snowball Candles s/9 - white


33

610386 Small Snowball Candles s/4 - White


610388 Large Snowball Candle - White


610089 Snowflake Mitten Candles s/2 - Red


610090 Dots Mitten Candles s/2 - Green


900335 s/2 Floating Mitten Candles - Red


510056 Sana Stripe Lantern Candle - Red


510057 Sana Stripe Lantern Candle - Kiwi


510058 Sana Stripe Lantern Candle - Aqua


710067 Large Potted Tree Pinecone Candle Multi


710066 Sm Potted Tree Pinecone Candle - Multi


710065 Glittered Pinecone Ball Candle - Multi


711133 Small Sugared Fruit Tree Candle - Multi


711135 Large Sugared Fruit Tree


34

Candle - Multi

the Order.

711139 Lg Sugared Fruit Ball Candle - Multi


Conclusion With respect to the candles analyzed supra, the Department has found the candles that are in the shape of figurines to be outside the scope of the Order. All of the other candles under analysis are inside the scope of the Order because they are petroleum wax candles with a fiber or paper-cored wick and do not fall within any other exclusions for the Order (i.e., they are not birthday, utility, or figurine candles). RECOMMENDATION We recommend the Department find those candles listed as outside scope in the Analysis section to be outside the scope of the Order, and those candles listed as within scope in the Analysis section to be within the scope of the Order. If you agree, we will send the attached letter to the interested parties, and will notify CBP of our determination. Agree_________ Disagree_________ ____________________________ Gary Taverman Acting Deputy Assistant Secretary for Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Operations ____________________________ Date

35

Appendix: Candles Descriptions

1 “Unique candles” are those in a set that are non-identical. For example, if a requestor were to submit a set of three beach ball candles, and two of those candles were exactly the same size, shape, and color, while the third was not, then the set would consist of two unique candles.

Accent Imports

Product No.

Product Name


Total No. of Unique Candles1

Description

N22432 Rose Shaped Tea-light Candle

2 2 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like a rose bloom. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 1.75” in height and 1.5” in diameter.

N22418 Owl Shape Tea-light Candle

1 1 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like an owl with wings folded in the back. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 2.5” in height and 1.5” in diameter.

N22423 Pinecone Shaped Tea-light Candle

6 1 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like a pinecone. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 2.5” in height and 1.5” in diameter.

N22431 Rose Shaped Candle

2 2 This candle is shaped like a rose bloom. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 2” in height and 3” in diameter.

N22422 Pinecone Shaped Candle

1 1 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like a pinecone. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 5” in height and 4” in diameter.

N22426 Ornament Shaped Tea-light Candle

6 1 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like a spherical Christmas tree ornament. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 2.25” in height and 1.5” in diameter.

N22427 Beaded Cone Shape Tree Candle 12”H

1 1 This candle is shaped like a cone, and has a beaded surface pattern. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 12” in height and 2.25” in diameter.

N22428 Beaded Cone Shape Tree Candle

1 1 This candle is shaped like a cone, and has a beaded surface pattern. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 8.25” in height and 2” in diameter.


8.25”H


Candym Enterprises, Ltd.

Product No.

Product Name



Description

R3115 Hyacinth Flower Bulb Shaped Candle 4.5”H

1 1 This candle is shaped like a hyacinth flower bulb that has sprouted. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 4.5” in height and 2.25” in diameter.

RT3127 Tree Shaped Tealight Candles

1 1 This candle is shaped like a Christmas tree. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures approximately 2.5” in height and 1.5” in diameter.

RT3132 Buck Head Shaped Candle

1 1 This candle is shaped like a brown buck head. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures approximately 6” in height and 4” in width.

RT3138 Tree Shaped Tea-light Candle

6 1 This tea-light candle is shaped like an evergreen tree made of ornaments. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures approximately 2.75” in height and 1.5” in diameter.


1 1 This candle is shaped like a pine cone evergreen tree. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures 8” in height and 2.5” in diameter.

RT3137 Tree Shaped Candle 8”H

1 1 This candle is shaped like a pine cone evergreen tree. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures 12.5” in height and 2.5” in diameter.


1 1 This candle is shaped like an evergreen tree made of ornaments. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures approximately 8.5” in height and 2.5” in diameter.


1 1 This candle is shaped like an evergreen tree made of ornaments. It is made from 100% petroleum wax and measures approximately 11.75” in height and 3” in diameter.

R3120 Mushroom 3”H

1 1 This candle is shaped like a mushroom. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 3.5” in height and 3.5” in diameter.

R3119 Mushroom (Set6)

6 1 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like a mushroom. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 1.5” in height and 1.5” in diameter.


R3124 Succulent (Set6)

6 1 This tea-light candle has a top that is shaped like a succulent. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 1.5” in height and 1.5” in diameter.

R3126 Succulent in Pot

1 1 This candle is shaped like a succulent, and rests in a large, cream-colored tin pot. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 4.5” in height and 2.25” in diameter.

R0183 Stone in Tube

10 10 This set consists of an assortment of small irregularly shaped candles made to resembles stones, which are held in a clear plastic tube.. It is made from 100% petroleum wax. No measurements of these candles were provided by Candym.

R3109 Rock 4”L (3ASST)

1 1 This candle is shaped like a irregularly contoured rock. It is made from 100% petroleum wax. No measurements of this candle were provided by Candym.

R3116 Flower Bulb 5”H

1 1 This candle is shaped like a hyacinth flower bulb that has sprouted. It is made from 100% petroleum wax, and measures approximately 5.5” in height and 2.25” in diameter.

Sourcing International2

Product No.

Product Name



Description

1003 6 Mini Cactus Asst.

6 1 These candles are made from 100% petroleum wax and are in the shape of small cacti resting in clay pots.

2 Sourcing International did not provide measurements of the candles in its request.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 1016 Peony

Bunch 1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bunch

of three peonies.

1017 Rose Bunch

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bunch of three roses.

1018 Anemone Bunch

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bunch of three anemones.

1019 Gerber Daisy Bunch

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bunch of three daisies.

1021 Sunflower Bunch

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bunch of three sunflowers.

1029 Hyacinth Bulb

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a hyacinth flower that has sprouted from a bulb.

1030 Hyacinth Bulb


1031 Hyacinth Bulb


1045 Yellow Sun Cameo Candle

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a double-sided sunflower blossom.

1010 Sunflower Floating Candles

3 3 These floating candles are made from 100% petroleum wax and are in the shape of sunflower blooms.

1011 Pink Floating Daisies

3 3 These floating candles are made from 100% petroleum wax and are in the shape of daisy blossoms.

1034 Yellow Sunflowers

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a rectangular “pot” formed by three leaves surrounding the shapes of several sunflowers.

1033 Orange Anemones

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a rectangular “pot” formed by leaves surrounding the shapes of several anemones.

1035 Purple Zinnia

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a rectangular “pot” formed by three leaves surrounding the shapes of several zinnias.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 1028 Ladybug

Gnome Candle

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a sitting gnome wearing a green shirt and light green pants.

1037 Pot of 3 Sunflowers

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a flower pot with three sunflowers.

1038 Pot of 6 White Daisies

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a flower pot with six white daisies.

1040 Pot of 3 Pink Daisies

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a flower pot with three pink daisies.

1041 Pot of 3 Orange Tulips

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a flower pot with three orange tulips.

1042 Pot of 3 Yellow Daffodils

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a flower pot with three yellow daffodils

1043 Pot of 3 Purple Violets

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a flower pot with three purple violets.

1032 Hyacinth Bulb


1004 3 Pink Roses

3 1 These candles are made from 100% petroleum wax and are in the shape of rose blossoms surrounded by leaves.

1005 3 Red Roses


1006 3 Yellow Roses


1002 6 Mini Flower Pots Asst. B

6 6 This assortment consists of candles made from 100% petroleum wax, with each candle being in the shape of a particular flower in a pot.

1001 6 Mini Flower Pots Asst. A

6 6 This assortment consists of candles made from 100% petroleum wax, with each candle being in the shape of a particular flower in a pot.

1036 Petite Orange

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a rectangular “pot” formed by three leaves surrounding the shapes of several

Appendix: Candles Descriptions Tulip Bunch

orange tulips.

1024 Rose Flower Bouquet

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of seven roses.

1022 White Lily Pave

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of seven lilies.

1023 Daffodil Pave

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of six daffodils.

1025 Stargazer Pave

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of six stargazer flowers.

1026 Tulip Pave 1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of seven tulips.

1027 Sunflower Pave

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of five sunflowers.

1009 Small Pink Rose

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a rose blossom surrounded by leaves.

1012 Large Pink Rose

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a rose blossom surrounded by leaves.

1008 Floating Sunflower

1 1 These floating candles are made from 100% petroleum wax and are in the shape of sunflower blossoms.

1013 Red Rose Sphere

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of rose blossoms formed into a sphere.

1014 Fuchsia Rose Sphere


1015 Small Pink Rose Sphere


1020 Yellow Tulip Pave

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bouquet of seven tulips.

1044 Petite Pink Tulip Bunch

1 1 This candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a bunch of three tulips.

1007 Floating Dahlia

1 1 This floating candle is made from 100% petroleum wax and is in the shape of a dahlia bloom.


Candle


3 Note: All Trade Associates Group, Ltd.’s (“TAG”) candle descriptions are direct quotes from the company’s scope ruling request, with the exception of the few candles with no product numbers. See TAG’s June 11, 2009 Request, at Exhibit 1. All of TAG’s candles in this scope ruling are made from 100% paraffin (i.e., petroleum) wax. Id., at 2.

Trade Associates Group, Ltd.3

Product No.

Product Name



Description

610583 White Pumpkin Candle

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a pumpkin. The pumpkin shaped candle is characterized by its oblate shape, which includes indentations at the top and bottom where the stem and core protrude. The candle also includes well defined vertical grooves on outer surface which start at the top center and emanate downwards until they come together at the bottom center of the candle, a thick textured dark greenish brown square like stem protruding from the top center and same color core apparent on the bottom center. The candle's color with dark orange speckles and uneven texture is representative of the thick, orange skinned rind characteristic to pumpkins.

Slight variation in size (larger/wider) and color (whitish yellow)

4325 Macintosh Apple Candle

1 1 The three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a Macintosh apple. The apple shaped candle is characterized by the round, oblate yet uneven shape specific to the Macintosh apple. The candle's shape includes the appropriate indentation at the candle's top, which houses the stem (wick). The attractive dark red/crimson color with striped/speckled embellishments completes the accurate depiction of how this object is ordinarily viewed.

4225 Red Delicious Apple Candle


Slight variation in color and shape: Candle molded to be in the shape specific to the red delicious apple.

710055 Pumpkin Candle

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a pumpkin. The pumpkin shaped candle is characterized by its oblate shape, which includes indentations at the top and bottom where the stem and core protrude. The candle also includes well defined vertical grooves on outer surface which start at the top center and emanate downwards until they come together at the bottom center of the candle, a thick textured dark greenish brown square like stem protruding from the top center and same color core apparent on the bottom center. The candle's color with dark orange speckles and uneven texture is representative of the thick, orange skinned rind

Appendix: Candles Descriptions characteristic to pumpkins.

The other pumpkin candles are similar with the exception that they may be more vertically oblong in shape rather than oblate, vary in surface texture from lightly ribbed to deep grooves, and vary in color from dark green, pale green, whitish yellow, greenish orange, etc. Some pumpkins are smoother or are onlv lightlv ribbed.

Size (smaller) & slight variation in color (darker orange)

610582 Orange Pumpkin Candle



1 1 The three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a cupcake. The cupcake candle is characterized by the realistic white whipped, swirled frosting coming to a point at the top, silver sprinkles topping the cupcake, fluted cupcake shape and hand painted rigid, silver foil cup.


6 3 Miniature pumpkin shaped candles in various shapes and colors (dark orange & green)

710052 Mini Pear Candles

6 3 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a pear. Candle is characterized by the elongated bulbous shape tapering towards the top and rounded at the bottom. Candle has brownish red base with a speckled finish and sports a long brown stem and available in three other colors: brownish/green, yellowish brown, & greenish/brown representing different types of pears.

Similar to Item No. 004676. Slight variation in size and colors and quantity (SeU6)


16 1 Miniature pumpkin shaped candles, slight variation in color

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 710056 Gourd

Candle 1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a

gourd.

Variation in shape and color

711111 Harvest Apple

1 1 Set consists of both apple, pear and (Set/3) pomegranate shaped candles. Candles coated with glitter to resemble sugared fruit.

Variation in size.

710053 Large Scented Pear Candle


610586 Gourd Candles

9 9 Miniature gourd shaped candles in three different shapes

610581 Tall Orange Pumpkin


Slight variation in size (taller/larger) and color (light orange)

610579 Harvest Apple Candle


Miniature in size but apple shape and colors maintained.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 410182 Watering

Can Candle 1 1 The three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely,

a watering can. The shape of the candle is that of a typical portable watering container with a handle on one side, a spout (i.e. a long tube originating near the bottom of the container) for water flow on the opposite side of the handle, and a shield at the top of the can to prevent water spillage when watering.


1 1 The three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a cupcake. The cupcake candle is characterized by the realistic white whipped, swirled frosting coming to a point at the top, silver sprinkles topping the cupcake, fluted cupcake shape and hand painted rigid, silver foil cup.

610512 Snowcap Taper Tree Candle

2 2 This three-dimensional candle is molded in the simplest form of a tree and visually understood to be a tree and identifiable as a tree from most angles. Moreover, the tree is decorated in a holiday theme with painted silver glitter representing tinsel and painted red rounds representing tree ornaments. The top of the tree candle is decorated with the traditional gold star tree topper. The decorations surround the entire candle and when viewed as a whole, the candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a decorated Christmas tree. The decorated Christmas tree is also a recognized holiday-specific design.

Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in quantity (SeU2), shape, size, Christmas tree embellishments, color (white candle/silver embellishments).

610523 Large Snowcap Tree

1 1 This three-dimensional candle is molded in the simplest form of a tree and visually understood to be a tree and identifiable as a tree from most angles. Moreover, the tree is decorated in a holiday theme with painted silver glitter representing tinsel and painted red rounds representing tree ornaments. The top of the tree candle is decorated with the traditional gold star tree topper. The decorations surround the entire candle and when viewed as a whole, the candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a decorated Christmas tree. The decorated Christmas tree is also a recognized holiday-specific design.

Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in size, shape, Christmas tree embellishments, and color (white candle/ silver embellishments).

610588 Large Onion Candle

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, an onion. The candle is characterized by the spherical shape which becomes progressively narrower in circumference moving upwards. The top of the candle ends at the point where the onion shoots would typically appear if not removed. The candle is molded with grooves representing the dark lines apparent on the onion's peel.

610066 Floating Golden Tree Glitter Candles

4 1 Item consists of four miniature floating candles with identical embellishments appearing on viewing surface of floating candle.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610543 Whimsy

Snowman 1 1 The candle has the shape characteristic to a snowman (i.e. large torso and

small head). The candle also includes the features common to snowmen (i.e. black eyes (suggesting coal), pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot), black buttons, printed colorful hat and arms (suggesting branches)). Moreover, the snowman has a string of multi-colored Christmas lights wrapped around it, which lights are a recognized symbol of the Christmas holiday season.


1 1 The candle has the shape characteristic to a snowman (i.e. large torso and small head). The candle also includes the features common to snowmen (i.e. black eyes (suggesting coal), pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot), black buttons, printed colorful hat and arms (suggesting branches)). Moreover, the snowman has a string of multi-colored Christmas lights wrapped around it, which lights are a recognized symbol of the Christmas holiday season.

Size (larger), hat type (black brim hat), inclusion of scarf, no string of multi-colored Christmas lights. Only claim made is that candle is in the shape of an identifiable object (i.e. snowman)

610544 Snowman Tealights


Quantity (Set/4), size, variation in color and type of hats and scarves. Only one of four snowmen candles in the set is wrapped with a string of multi-colored Christmas lights.

710028 Mini Ornament Tealights

6 6 The three-dimensional figurine is in the shape of a Christmas tree ornament with features clearly identifying it as such from most angles. The candle is an actual representation of a tree ornament. The candle is round and the top of the candle houses a metallic gold fine detailed hand painted knob. The candle must be flat on the bottom so that it can burn properly on a stable surface. The ornament candle is of a pearl cream color base with hand painted embellishments of gold lines, red rounds and leaves.

Variation in size, color and embellishments

610099 Floating Tree Candle

9 9 Set of 9 miniature floating Christmas tree candles with tree stump. Slight variation in Christmas tree decorations appearing on viewing surface of floating candle.



Appendix: Candles Descriptions Identical to Item No. 610541, except for size, scarf color and hat decoration.

710975 Gumdrop Tree Candle

1 1 This three dimensional candle is in the identifiable shape of a gumdrop candy tree.

The tree covered on all sides with multicolored miniature gumdrops coated with glitter to resemble the gumdrop's sugar coating.


1 1 The three dimensional figurine is in the shape of a Christmas tree ornament with features clearly identifying it as such from most angles. The candle is an actual representation of a tree ornament. The candle is round and the top of the candle houses a metallic gold fine detailed hand painted knob. The candle must be flat on the bottom so that it can burn properly on a stable surface. The ornament candle is of a pearl cream color base with hand painted embellishments of gold lines, red rounds and leaves.

Variation in color and embellishments


1 1 Candle includes painted snowman with a multi colored string of Christmas tree lights decorating the snowman. Christmas tree light is a symbol specific to the Christmas holiday. Variation in color and embellishments.

710030 Glitter Ornament Candle


610550 Treelight Ornament Candle

1 1 The three dimensional figurine in the shape of a Christmas tree ornament with features clearly identifying it as such from most angles. The candle is round and an actual representation of a tree ornament. The top of the candle houses a metallic gold fine detailed hand painted knob. The candle must be flat on the bottom so that it can burn properly on a stable surface. The ornament candle is of a pearl white color base with hand painted embellishments of a multi colored Christmas tree light string. String of Christmas tree lights with the traditional 9-volt bulb is a Christmas holiday specific symbol.

610509 Small Snowball Candle

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a snowball. The candle is a white textured sphere consisting of protrusions, indentations and ridges that together create a surface intended to mimic the irregular surface of a loosely packed snowball that has been hand packed by scooping up snow with the hands.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610508 Large

Snowball Candle


610520 Golden Swirl Round Ornament



610482 Pinecone Round Ornament



710029 Large Whimsy Ornament Candle



610480 Berry Swirl Round Ornament



610145 Dots Metallic Ornament Candle

1 1 The three dimensional figurine is in the shape of a Christmas tree ornament with features clearly identifying it as such from most angles. The candle is an actual representation of a tree ornament. The candle is round and the top of the candle houses a metallic gold fine detailed hand painted knob. The candle must be flat on the bottom so that it can burn properly on a stable surface. The ornament candle is of a pearl cream color base with hand painted

Appendix: Candles Descriptions embellishments of gold lines, red rounds and leaves.


610333 Large Sparkle Tree

1 1 This three dimensional molded candle is in the simplest form of a tree and visually understood to be a decorated tree. The tree candle follows the form of a traditional conical Christmas tree with a wide base narrowing to a point at the top. The candle has a grooved pattern all around and is finished with hand painted glitter embellishments representing tree decorations which can be viewed from most angles.

610546 Large Treelight Candle

1 1 This three dimensional candle is molded in the simplest form of a tree but decorated in a holiday theme and visually understood to be a Christmas tree. The candle is identifiable as a tree from most angles. The candle, which is green in color is embellished with a string of hand painted multi-colored Christmas lights. The light bulbs on the string of lights are the traditional 9-volt Christmas bulbs familiar to all. The Christmas lights surround the entire candle and thus the holiday decoration can be viewed from all angles.

710026 Glitter Tree Candle

1 1 This three dimensional candle is molded in the simplest form of a tree and visually understood to be a tree and identifiable as a tree from most angles. Moreover, the tree is decorated in a holiday theme with painted silver glitter representing tinsel and painted red rounds representing tree ornaments. The top of the tree candle is decorated with the traditional gold star tree topper. The decorations surround the entire candle and when viewed as a whole, the candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a decorated Christmas tree. The decorated Christmas tree is also a recognized holiday-specific design.

610587 Small Onion Candle

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, an onion. The candle is characterized by the spherical shape which becomes progressively narrower in circumference moving upwards. The top of the candle ends at the point where the onion shoots would typically appear if not removed. The candle is molded with grooves representing the dark lines apparent on the onion's peel.

710024 Bat Candle on a String Set

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a bat. In addition, we submit that a black bat designs are specific to Halloween.

710943 Pumpkin Hat Candle

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of a carved pumpkin (i.e. Jack a' Lantern)

and identifiable as such from multiple angles. The pumpkin is either orange or black in color, includes a thick stem and has a carved and painted Jack a' Lantern face. The Jack a' Lantern is a holiday specific symbol for Halloween. Moreover, the pumpkin's painted Jack a' Lantern face coupled with the orange

Appendix: Candles Descriptions or black color clearly identifies the candle as specifically associated with Halloween.

Variation in size and facial features of Jack a' Lantern. In addition, a green witch's hat covers top of the Jack a' Lantern's head.

410032 Mini Cupcake Candles

4 4 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a cupcake. The cupcake candle is characterized by the realistic white whipped, swirled frosting coming to a point at the top, silver sprinkles topping the cupcake, fluted cupcake shape and hand painted rigid, silver foil cup.

Slight variation in design. Candles consist of multi-colored sprinkles covering frosting portion of cupcake.

610403 Tall Pumpkin Candle

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of a carved pumpkin (i.e. Jack a' Lantern) and identifiable as such from multiple angles. The pumpkin is either orange or black in color, includes a thick stem and has a carved and painted Jack a' Lantern face. The Jack a' Lantern is a holiday specific symbol for Halloween. Moreover, the pumpkin's painted Jack a' Lantern face coupled with the orange or black color clearly identifies the candle as specifically associated with Halloween.

Variation in color (green) and facial features of Jack a' Lantern. Facial features appear on two sides, opposite each other.

100167 Small Firecracker Candles

6 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a firecracker. The firecracker shaped candle is characterized by the cylindrical stick like shape, thick casing and long fuse. The firecrackers are painted red, white and blue as the items are marketed for the Fourth of July Holiday.

711107 Floating Snowman Candle

2 2 The floating snowman candle is comprised of six segments. Three white spherical discs of varying sizes comprise the snowman's torso and head. Two red pieces are in the shape of left and right handed mittens and the final piece is in the shape of a black brim hat. The hat is painted black with a red and white striped band. When placed together, the six pieces form a snowman, with clear traditional snowman features including black eyes (suggesting coal), a mouth, a pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot), and black buttons on the torso.

410174 Beach Ball Candles

6 3 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a ball. The ball shaped candle is characterized by the spherical shape that is the identifying feature of a ball. The balls are painted on all sides with bright colored thin lines and wide bands or multi colored bright dots further identifying them as beach balls, which are large inflatable balls used in various games and other recreational activities traditionally conducted on the beach.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 410048 Sherbet

Candles Set

4 4 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a sorbet scoop in a frosted cup holder. The sorbet candle is characterized by the single textured sorbet scoop protruding from a cup holder. The indentations and ridges apparent in the sorbet scoop are intentional and specially designed to resemble the actual dessert. There are four sorbet scoop shaped candles in the set, each in a color representative of traditional sorbet flavors.

610545 Snowman Taper


Quantity (set of two), size of candle, color and type of hat and scarf. Also, only one of two snowmen candles is wrapped in a string of multi-colored Christmas lights. Candles' features include the large torso and small head and other similar features common to snowmen.

610540 Snowman Floating Candles

7 7 The floating snowman candle is comprised of six segments. Three white spherical discs of varying sizes comprise the snowman's torso and head. Two red pieces are in the shape of left and right handed mittens and the final piece is in the shape of a black brim hat. The hat is painted black with a red and white striped band. When placed together, the six pieces form a snowman, with clear traditional snowman features including black eyes (suggesting coal), a mouth, a pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot), and black buttons on the torso.

Candle consists of 7 segments resulting in 2 snowmen. The candle's segments comprising the torso and head are less round but are tapered with the torso shaped segment being larger than the head shaped segment.

510101 Crazy Eggs Candle

4 4 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an egg. The egg shaped candles resemble Easter eggs as they are hand painted with different designs in multi-colored pastel colors. Decorated eggs are a well-known holiday symbol specifically associated with Easter.

610172 Small Candy Corn Candle

6 6 The candle is a three dimensional figurine in the shape of a piece of candy corn candy including proper color schemes of white, orange and yellow that band around the entire candle. The colors and designs and shape of the candle is unmistakably that of a candy corn. The candle is identifiable as candy corn from most angles.

Identical to Item 610170 with the exception of size and quantity (SeU6)

610585 Large Acorn Candle

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the identifiable shape of an oak tree acorn. The candle is representative of an acorn with its tough, leathery, scaly shell and cup shaped warty cap.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610573 Brussels

Sprout Candles

16 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a Brussels sprout. The Brussels sprout shaped candles resemble miniature cabbages in shape and color. In addition to the oddly shaped sphere, the candle includes distinct indentations and protrusions resembling veins. The item is green in color with white shading, which enhances the accurate depiction of the item.

410079 Garden Snail Candle

1 1 The three dimensional green candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a snail. The snail's form includes the shell, the body and head, and the tail. The shell forms a logarithmic spiral, the body and head with two tentacles protrudes from the front of the shell and the tail protrudes from the back of the shell.

419938 Large Watermelon Candle

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a half of a watermelon. The candle is characterized by the oblong shape, outer thick rind and fleshy pink center, which includes painted black watermelon seeds. In addition, the smooth exterior rind of the watermelon shaped candle is painted a two-toned green color.

610347 Large pumpkin Candle


Variation in facial features of Jack a' Lantern. Facial features appear on two sides, opposite each other.


1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a cupcake. The cupcake candle is characterized by the realistic white whipped, swirled frosting coming to a point at the top, silver sprinkles topping the cupcake, fluted cupcake shape and hand painted rigid, silver foil cup.

Color, slight variation in design

610405 Small Pumpkin Candle


Variation in color (green) and facial features of Jack a' Lantern. Facial features appear on two sides, opposite each other.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 410078 Garden

Frog Candle

1 1 Three dimensional green candle in the identifiable shape of a frog with readily apparent features akin to a frog.

510008 Chick Candle

1 1 The candle is in the shape of a chick perched in a decorated half egg shell. The molded and hand painted eyes, beak and wings decorating the candle and the egg shell's jagged edges identify the figurine as a chick perched in a half egg shell.

Identical to Item No. 510008, except for color (light green)

410028 Chick’n Egg Candle


710102 Floating Holiday Cookie Candles

6 3 Quantity (set of 16). Identical to Item 710102 with the exception that there are additional identifiable shapes in the set including stockings, ornaments, gingerbread men, reindeer and peppermint candies.

710082 Floating Ornament Candles

4 4 Item consists of 4 floating Christmas tree ornament candles. Variation in ornament size, shape, color, and embellishments.

Embellishments appear on viewing surface

610167 Floating Fall Leaf Candles

3 3 The candles are full, three dimensional leaves shaped like maple, oak or hazel leaves. The leaf shaped candles have clearly defined leaf edges with molded, brown colored veins imprinted on the leaf surface which are visible from multiple angles. The candles come in fall colors of dark green, red, and orange.

Slight variation in colors and shape. In addition to two leaf shaped candles, the set includes a candle in the identifiable shape of a pumpkin

410068 Floating Turtle Candles

4 4 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a turtle. The turtle candle includes features specific to turtles including an upper dome-shaped shell, and a head, tail and 4 legs protruding from the reptile's shell. The turtle appears in its natural position in its typical colors with detailed design features painted on the turtle's shell.

419952 Floating Leaf Candles


Variation in color and shape

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 510092 Jumbo Flip

Flop Candles

2 2 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a flip flop. The candle, which consists of two candles (right and left shoe) are molded in the shape of a pair of flip flops. The flip flop shaped candles are characterized by a backless, flat sole sandal that is held loosely on the foot by a Y-shaped strap that is properly proportioned to pass between the big toe and second toe and then around either side of the foot. The flip flops may have smooth, ribbed or other textured imprint on top side of candle. The candles are proportioned and shaped as left and right flip-flops to represent shoes that could fit actual feet and the strap is properly proportioned.

419924 Floating Small Flower Candles

6 6 This candle is in the identifiable shape of a flower. The flower shaped candle includes eight petals and a stigma. Each petal is carefully carved to show the most literal shape of a flower from multiple angles.

610143 Heart Votives

3 3 Set of three molded red and pink heart shaped candles set on wax filled glass votive holders. The hearts are decorated with the following sayings "Cutie Pie," "Kiss Me," and "Love You." The hearts resemble candy hearts, which are known symbols associated with Valentine's Day. Red and pink hearts viewed alone may not provide evidence that the item is solely associated with Valentine's Day. However, the red and pink colors coupled with the heart shapes and sentimental statement decorations clearly identify the candles as associated with and specially designed for use only in connection with Valentine's Day. Such candles are identical to the heart shaped candies with printed statements that are sold at every drug and grocery store prior to Valentine's Day and which immediately disappear from the stores' shelves shortly thereafter only to return the following year.

610345 Haunted House Candle

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a house. The house shaped candle is characterized by the orange structure consisting of four walls and a black stone-like textured roof. The walls include carved windows or doors on all four sides of the structure.

Alternatively, the colors of the house (i.e black and orange) combined with the hand painted embellishments of embossed black bats and rickety old black fence identify the candle as specifically associated with Halloween.

610385 Critter Candles

4 4 Set of three floating candles shaped and painted to resemble various symbols specific to Halloween. The candles include an orange pumpkin with green stem and a white hand painted jack-o-Iantern face, a black eat's head with pointed ears and a witch's head with black hair, green face, facial features and a traditional pointed black and orange striped hat. The candles are floating candles. As such, the Halloween symbol is depicted on the viewing surface of the floating candle.

Variation in quantity (Set/4) and Halloween symbols (i.e. black spider, black bat, black cat and black crow).

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 419936 Sunflower

Candles 2 1 This candle is in the identifiable shape of a flower. The flower shaped candle

includes eight petals and a stigma. Each petal is carefully carved to show the most literal shape of a flower from multiple angles.

Candle shaped in the identifiable shape of a sunflower. Flower shaped candle set on top of wax filled glass votive

610473 Autumn 3-Wick Candle

1 1 The candles are bowl shaped wax candles that include a detailed leaf pattern including stem molded on the top surface of the candle. The candles are floating candles. As such, the embossed imprint appears on the viewing surface of the candle and provides the appearance of a true leaf floating in a bowl. The candles come in harvest colors of orange, olive, purple and red.

Size. Leaf embossed imprint includes distinct vein skeletons.

710101 Peppermint Candy Candles


Set of 6 three dimensional candles in the identifiable shape of peppermint candies.

The rectangular candies have red and white stripes of different widths going across the top and two sides of the candle.

510055 3-Part Bunny Candle

3 3 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a rabbit. The rabbit candle is of an upright sitting rabbit with detailed features including distinct long ears, accurate eye, paw and nose formation and a textured body designed to represent the rabbit's hair. The rabbit represents the Easter egg as it is holding a blue colored egg between its front paws.

A floating rabbit candle consisting of three segments. One segment is a 3/4 circle shaped to resemble a fat round forward facing sitting bunny. This piece comprises

the head and body of the rabbit with painted facial features, including whiskers, a pink nose and black eyes and two visible white paws. The remaining two segments are shaped long and thin comprising the ears of the rabbit with hand painted dark pink inner ears The pieces are made of pink wax and when displayed together, the three pieces form a rabbit's head.

710971 Gumdrop Candles


Set of 16 three dimensional candles in the identifiable shape of gumdrop candies. The candles are small multi-colored gumdrop shaped candies covered

Appendix: Candles Descriptions with white and metallic colored glitter to resemble a coating of sugar

610584 Small Acorn Candles

3 3 The three dimensional candle is in the identifiable shape of an oak tree acorn. The candle is representative of an acorn with its tough, leathery, scaly shell and cup shaped warty cap.

610474 Autumn Leaf Candle


610170 Large Candy Corn Candle


510059 Umbrella Candle

1 1 The three dimensional floating candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a sun umbrella. The umbrella candle is characterized by the canopy design and pole. The canopy is in the open position and the top surface of the canopy is further embellished with hand painted stripes of varying bright colors.

200023 Large Chocolate Egg Candles


Variation in quantity (Set/3) and color

610330 Candy Cane Ball


This candle is in the identifiable shape of peppermint candies. The candle consists of the traditional spherical shape and nostalgic red and white stripes emanating outward from the top center of the candle and coming together on the bottom center of the candle.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610561 Peppermint

Candles 6 2 The candle is a three dimensional figurine in the shape of a piece of candy corn

candy including proper color schemes of white, orange and yellow that band around the entire candle. The colors and designs and shape of the candle is unmistakably that of a candy corn. The candle is identifiable as candy corn from most angles.

Set of 6 three dimensional candles in the identifiable shape of round pieces of peppermint candies. The round candies have red and white stripes or swirls emanating outward from the center.

100168 Large Firecracker Candle

2 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a firecracker. The firecracker shaped candle is characterized by the cylindrical stick like shape, thick casing and long fuse. The firecrackers are painted red, white and blue as the items are marketed for the

Fourth of July Holiday.

710071 Caramel Apple Candle

1 1 A three dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a caramel candy apple. The apple is coated with white, dark brown and dark red wax piece embellishments resembling chocolate pieces and light brown blots of wax resembling caramel.

No product #

Flower Bunch

1 1 A three dimensional candle in the shape of a grouping of flowers.

No product #

Flower Bunch


No product #

Flower Bunch


No product #

Flower Bunch


Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610111 Floating

Winter Sprig Candles s/2

2 1 This disc shaped floating candle incorporates on the top surface molded realistic wax reliefs of green holly sprigs and red berries with the berries grouped together in bunches. The holly sprigs and berries, which are a recognized symbol of the Christmas holiday season and appear over the entire viewing surface of the floating candle.


4 1 These candles are three dimensional candles molded in the identifiable shape of holly leaves with berries. As three dimensional candles, the holly ivy leaf and berry shape is identifiable from multiple angles. Moreover, the candles accurately depict holly leaves and berries in color and form. The leaves with their unusual shape and sharp edges are green in color and the berries, which are grouped together in a set of three are red in color. Each leaf is clearly distinguishable by the grooves in the candle and the candle's sharp raised outer edges.



Quantity (Set/ 2)

900347 Floating Holly Candles s/4


Quantity (Set/ 4)

610206 Holly Berry Floating Leaf Candles s/2 Green


Quantity (Set/ 2)

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610598 Small

Treelight Tree Candle Green


610597 Small Treelight Tree Candle White


610547 Large Treelight Tree Candle White


610332 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Dk Olive


610295 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Red


610297 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Gold


610303 Large Sparkle Tree Candle - Red



Sparkle Tree Candle - Gold


610299 Small Sparkle Tree Candle - Olive


610301 Large Sparkle Tree Candle - Olive


610319 Mini Sparkle Tree Candles s/3 - Red


610321 Mini Sparkle Tree Candles s/3 - Gold


610323 Mini Sparkle Tree Candles s/3 - Olive


711073 Large Golden Tree Glitter Candle - Gold



Golden Tree Glitter Candle - Gold


610307 Large Whimsy Tree Candle - Green


Slight variations in Christmas tree decorations, color (dark green), size

610309 Small Whimsy Tree Candle - Green


Slight variations in Christmas tree decorations, color (dark green), size

610036 Floating Whimsy Tree Candles s/5 - Multi

5 3 Set of 5 miniature floating Christmas tree candles. Slight variations in Christmas tree decorations, which appear on viewing surface of floating candle.

690041 Metallic Ball Tree Candle - Multi


Variation in Christmas tree decorations (multi colored painted rounds resembling tree ornaments)

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610101 Glitter Tree

Straight Candles s/2 - Red

2 1 Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in quantity (Set/2), shape, size, Christmas tree embellishments, color (red candle/gold embellishments).

610103 Glitter Tree Straight Candles s/2 - Ivory

2 1 Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in quantity (SeU2), shape, size, Christmas tree embellishments, color (ivory candle/gold embellishments). The candle's multi tiers simulate the different tiers of tree branches.

610524 Medium Snowcap Tree Candle White

1 1 Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate s the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in size, shape, Christmas tree embellishments, and color (white candle/silver embellishments).

610525 Small Snowcap Tree Candles White

1 1 Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate s the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in size, shape, Christmas tree embellishments, and color (white candle/silver embellishments).

710026 Glitter Tree Candles - Ivory

1 1 Candle consists of multi-tiers, which simulate the different tiers of tree branches. Variation in size, shape, Christmas tree embellishments, and color (red candle/gold embellishments).

900334 Floating Jester Stocking Dark Red

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a stocking. It is characterized by its foot and lower leg covering. These stocking shapes combined with the colorful designs are typical of hanging stockings left out on fireplace mantels during the Christmas holiday. Decorated Stockings in exaggerated sizes are a recognized holiday symbol of Christmas.

100878 Mini Nutcracker Candles s/3 - Multi

3 3 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a soldier. The soldier shaped candle is characterized as an upright standing soldier with hands at the sides and legs together and wearing a helmet/ hat, uniform jacket, belt, pants and boots. The soldier has been hand painted and includes detailed facial features.

610042 Snowman Candle - White

1 1 The Snowman candle is a three dimensional figurine in the identifiable shape of a snowman with clear traditional features identifying it as a snowman from most angles. The "snowman" is composed of two white concentric spheres, one larger than the other. The larger sphere forms the bottom, which represents the body, while the top sphere represents the head, which is adorned with a red and white striped brim hat. The snowman has two arms with a bird perched on its right shoulder. The snowman candle includes additional features common to most actual

snowmen, including the hat, three black buttons on the round torso, black eyes

Appendix: Candles Descriptions (suggesting coal), a mouth and a pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot). The characteristic snowman shape coupled with the additional features clearly identifies the candle as a snowman. As with an actual snowman, the candle does not have "legs."

100754 Snowman Woodcut Candle - Multi

1 1 The Snowman candle is a three dimensional figurine in the identifiable shape of a snowman with clear traditional features identifying it as a snowman from most angles. The "snowman" is composed of two white concentric spheres, one larger than the other. The larger sphere forms the bottom, which represents the body, while the top sphere represents the head, which is adorned with a red and white striped brim hat. The snowman has two arms with a bird perched on its right shoulder. The snowman candle includes additional features common to most actual snowmen, including the hat, three black buttons on the round torso, black eyes (suggesting coal), a mouth and a pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot). The characteristic snowman shape coupled with the additional features clearly identifies the candle as a snowman. As with an actual snowman, the candle does not have "legs."

711165 Happy Snowman Candle - Red


711167 Happy Snowman Candle - Green


610142 Floating Snowman Candle - Multi

1 1 The floating snowman candle is comprised of six segments. Three white spherical discs of varying sizes comprise the snowman's torso and head. Two red pieces are in the shape of left and right handed mittens and the final piece is in the shape of a black brim hat. The hat is painted black with a red and white striped band. When placed together, the six pieces form a snowman, with clear traditional snowman features including black eyes (suggesting coal),

Appendix: Candles Descriptions a mouth, a pointy orange nose (suggesting a carrot), and black buttons on the torso.

610144 Dots Metallic Ornament Candle - Fuchsia


710000 Swirl Ornament Candle - Red/Green


710001 Swirl Ornament Candle - Red/White


710002 Dots Ornament Candle - White


710095 Sm Whimsy Ornament Candles s/4 - Multi


Set of 4 miniature ornament candles. Variation in size, color and embellishments

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610104 Metallic

Ball Candle - Multi



610095 Small Golden Ball Candle - Gold


Omission of knob on top of candle. Variation in color and embellishments.

610096 Large Golden Ball Candle - Gold


Omission of knob on top of candle. Variation in color and embellishments.

710022 Large Pumpkin Candles - Multi

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of a carved pumpkin (i.e. Jack a' Lantern) and identifiable as such from multiple angles. The pumpkin is either orange or black in color, includes a thick stem and has a carved and painted Jack a' Lantern face. The Jack a' Lantern is a holiday Specific symbol for Halloween. Moreover, the pumpkin's painted Jack a' Lantern face coupled with the orange or black color clearly identifies the candle as specifically associated with Halloween.

610006 Floating Pumpkin Candles s/3 - Orange


Variation in quantity (SeU3), size and shape and slight variation in facial features. Candles are designed as floating candles.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 710021 Pumpkin

Tealight Candles s/6 - Multi

6 6 Variation in quantity (se of 6) and size. Candles consist of a set of six miniature versions of the large pumpkin candle set in tealight holders. Variation also in color (black, orange and silvery white).

710945 Pumpkin Hat Candle - Orange


Variation in size and facial features of Jack a' Lantern. In addition, a black witch's hat covers top of the Jack a' Lantern's head.

610025 Witch’s Hat Candle - Black

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a witch's hat. The hat includes features typical to a witch's hat including a tall body with a pointed top and a wide brim. The body of the hat is decorated with orange, black and white stripes and the brim includes small painted rounds of the same colors. The witch's hat is a holiday specific symbol for Halloween. The witch's hat combined with the orange and black colors clearly identifies the candle as specifically associated with Halloween.

610168 Witch’s Cauldron Candle - Orange

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a caldron. The orange caldron includes a painted green witch's head with black hat. The caldron candle with coupled with the orange and black colors and the witch's head identifies the candle as specifically associated with Halloween.

610419 Halloween Floating Candles s/6

6 3 Small disc shaped candles in the Halloween color combination of orange, black and green. We claim candle excluded as novelty candle of a holiday-specific design.

710935 Floating Glitter Spider Web Candle

1 1 A floating candle that is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a spider/cobweb. The candle includes hand painted webbing details painted with silver glitter which appear on the viewing surface of the candle. We claim candle excluded as novelty candle in the shape of an identifiable object (i.e. spider/cobweb).

610176 Floating Halloween Candles - Multi

3 3 Set of three floating candles shaped and painted to resemble various symbols specific to Halloween. The candles include an orange pumpkin with green stem and a white hand painted jack-o-Iantern face, a black eat's head with pointed ears and a witch's head with black hair, green face, facial features and a traditional pointed black and orange striped hat. The candles are floating candles. As such, the Halloween symbol is depicted on the viewing surface of the floating candle.


Ghost Lantern Candle

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a ghost. The candle is in the traditional shape of a ghost (i.e. oblong and curvy) white in color, and has ghostlike facial features cut out. The white ghost is a also a well-known holiday symbol specifically associated with Halloween.

610018 Large Ghost Lantern Candle - White


610000 Ghost Tealights s/4 - White


Quantity (i.e. SeU4) and size. Also, painted facial features are painted rather than cut out.

610024 Ghost Taper Candle s/2 - White


Quantity (i.e. SeU2) and size (longer in dimension). Also, painted facial features are painted rather than cut out.

610204 Ghost Candle - White


Variation in design in that ghost candle has outstretched arms and painted facial features

710931 Mini Floating Ghost Candle - White


Variation in size (shorter), design (inclusion of arms) and painted facial features.

610010 Floating Mini Ghost Candles s/4 - White


Variation in quantity (i.e. Set/4), shapes, and painted facial features

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 410922 Sweetheart

Candles s/6 - Red

6 3 Set of six white and red heart shaped floating candles with similar sayings.

410904 Sweetheart Tealights s/9

9 9 Red heart shaped candle set on pink wax filled votive.

610121 Hugs & Kisses Tealight s/9 - Multi

9 9 Set of nine round tealight candles in votive holders with embossed designs of hearts,"X" and "o" and the statements "Kisses," "Sweet", and "Be Mine." The pink and red colors combined with the Valentine's Day designs clearly identify the candle as specifically designed and associated with Valentine's Day.

412916 Bunny w/Egg Candle Ivory

1 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a rabbit. The rabbit candle is of an upright sitting rabbit with detailed features including distinct long ears, accurate eye, paw and nose formation and a textured body designed to represent the rabbit's hair. The rabbit represents the Easter egg as it is holding a blue colored egg between its front paws.

510054 Floating Bunny Candles s/3 - Multi Pastel

3 3 Set/3, pastel colored (pink, yellow, lime green) miniature candle shaped in the identifiable shape of a forward facing sitting rabbit.

510013 Bunny Straight Candle - Multi Pastel

3 3 Set/3 pastel colored (pink, yellow, lime green) candles shaped in the identifiable shape of a forward facing sitting rabbit

510067 Bunny Candles in a Basket s/4 - Multi Pastel

4 4 Set of 4 pastel colored (pink, yellow lime green, blue) candles shaped in the identifiable shape of a forward facing sitting rabbit.

510053 Crazy Eggs Candles s/4 - Multi Pastel


Appendix: Candles Descriptions 510547 Egg Candle

in a Cup - Yellow


510551 Egg Candle in a Cup - Pink


510555 Egg Candle in a Cup - Blue


510557 Egg Candle in a Cup - Green


510099 Robin’s Egg Candles s/3 Blue


510005 Chirping Chick Candle - Lt Green


510006 Chirping Chick Candle - Lt Pink


510007 Chirping Chick Candle - Yellow


Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610097 Floating

Peppermint Candle s/8 red

8 1 Set of 8 three dimensional candles in the identifiable shape of round peppermint candies. Similar to Item No. 610561 with slight variation in the red and white swirls emanating outward from center.

710068 Marshmallow Candles s/4 - Multi

4 1 A Set of 4, three dimensional candles in the identifiable shape of a marshmallow confection. The marshmallow candle appears in the traditional whipped spongy consistency and the surface is decorated with red and purple curved stripes and colored glitter to resemble a coating of sugar.

710057 Candy Cane Candle - Multi

1 1 This three dimensional candle is in the identifiable shape of a candy cane Christmas tree. The candle is molded into the shape of a Christmas tree with white colored wax in stick form and hand painted with red and green stripes of varying widths. The candle is coated with glitter embellishments to resemble a coating of sugar.

410972 Floating Spiral Candles s/4 - Multi

4 4 Multicolored spiral disc shaped candles in the identifiable shape of hard candy.

610037 Asst Sugar Cookie Candles s/16 - Multi

6 3 Quantity (set of 16). Identical to Item 710102 with the exception that there are additional identifiable shapes in the set including stockings, ornaments, gingerbread men, reindeer and peppermint candies.

610400 Floating Mini Apple Candles s/9 - Multi

9 9 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a Macintosh apple. The apple shaped candle is characterized by the round, oblate yet uneven shape specific to the Macintosh apple. The candle's shape includes the appropriate indentation at the candle's top, which houses the stem (wick). The attractive dark red/crimson color with striped/speckled embellishments completes the accurate depiction of how this object is ordinarily viewed.

Slight variation in colors

610579 Mini Harvest Apple Candles s/12 Dark Red

12 12 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a Macintosh apple. The apple shaped candle is characterized by the round, oblate yet uneven shape specific to the Macintosh apple. The candle's shape includes the appropriate indentation at the candle's top, which houses the stem (wick). The attractive dark red/crimson color with striped/speckled embellishments completes the accurate depiction of how this object is ordinarily viewed.

Miniature in size but apple shape and colors maintained.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610051 Mini

Sugared Apples & Pears s/6 - White

6 2 Set consists of both apple and pear shaped candles. Candles coated with glitter to resemble sugared fruit. Both candles include long thin stem sporting a thicker end point and a green leaf sporting the fine veins of a leaf of that from their fruit tree. Pear is characterized by its specific elongated bulbous shape tapering towards the top and rounded at the bottom.

100785 Sugared Mini Fruit Candles s/9 - Multi

9 9 Set consists of both apple and pear shaped (Set/9) candles. Candles coated with glitter to resemble sugared fruit.

711115 Sugared Mini Harvest Candles s/3 - Multi


711113 Sugared Harvest Pomegranate Candle - Terracotta


4676 Mini Floating Pear Candles s/9 - Spring Green


610398 Floating Mini Pear Candles s/9 - Spring Green


711109 Sugared Harvest Pear Candle - Olive


419940 Small Watermelon Candle - Multi

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a half of a watermelon. The candle is characterized by the oblong shape, outer thick rind and fleshy pink center, which includes painted black watermelon seeds. In addition, the smooth exterior rind of the watermelon shaped candle is painted a two-toned green color.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610589 Pumpkin

Cluster Candle s/16 Orange


Miniature pumpkin shaped candles, slight variation in color

900298 Baby Boo Pumpkins Candles White


Variation in shape, color and quantity (Set/3)

610287 Baby Boo Pumpkin Candles s/3 - Multi Harvest


Identical to Item No. 900298

610196 Baby Boo Pumpkin Candle - Ivory


Identical to Item 900298, except for color (white)

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 711117 Harvest

Pumpkin Candle - Ivory


Variation in shape and color and addition of dark green leaf to stem.

711119 Harvest Gourd Candle - Olive

1 1 Three-dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a gourd.

711121 Harvest Gourd Candle - Terracotta


371322 Pumpkin Candle - Orange


Slight variation in shape and color (lighter orange)

371326 Pumpkin Candle - Green


Slight variation in shape and color (light yellowish green)

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 371429 Gourd

Candle - Multi


710953 Large Sugared Pumpkin Candle - Orange

1 1 The pumpkin shaped candles are ribbed and oblate shaped. However, the top is carved out and item is slightly hollowed out to resemble the beginnings of a carved pumpkin.

710955 Small Sugared Pumpkin Candle - Orange

1 1 The pumpkin shaped candles are ribbed and oblate shaped. However, the top is carved out and item is slightly hollowed out to resemble the beginnings of a carved pumpkin.

410077 Garden Bird Candle Assortment - Multi

1 1 Three dimensional green candle in the identifiable shape of a bird, with readily apparent features akin to a bird.

900218 Bird Candle - Silver

1 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a bird with readily apparent features akin to a bird.

200614 Chocolate Bunny Candles s/3 - Multi

3 3 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a rabbit. The rabbit candle is of an upright sitting rabbit with detailed features including distinct long ears, accurate eye, paw and nose formation and a textured body designed to represent the rabbit's hair.

412948 Bunny Candle s/2 - Ivory

2 2 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a rabbit. The rabbit candle is of an upright sitting rabbit with detailed features including distinct long ears, accurate eye, nose, paw and hind leg formation.

412960 Baby Chick Candles s/3

3 1 Three dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a chick with readily apparent features akin to a chick including eyes, beak, distinct wing feathers. The chick has a textured surface representing bird's feathers.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 210905 Large L’il

Chick Candle - Yellow

1 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a chicken.

411985 Small L’il Chick Candle - Yellow

1 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a chicken.

200569 Floating Frog Candles s/2 - Green

2 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a frog lying on a water lily pad.

The frog itself is finely detailed with long hind legs, a short body, protruding eyes, and distinct toe extensions similar to that of a ground-dwelling frog. Likewise, the water lily pad is detailed with 6 half circular notched edges and dip in the middle reflecting the weight of the frog.

200567 Floating Ladybug Candles s/2 - Green

2 1 Similar to Item No. 200569, except item is a three dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a ladybug lying flat on a leaf.

200568 Floating Turtle Candles s/3 - Green

3 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a turtle. The turtle candle includes features specific to turtles including an upper dome-shaped shell, and a head, tail and 4 legs protruding from the reptile's shell. The turtle appears in its natural position in its typical colors with detailed design features painted on the turtle's shell.

900353 Hula Girl Floaters s/2

2 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a traditional Hawaiian girl. The candle is figurine of a girl with long black hair and a Hawaiian blossom placed in her hair. Distinct features are present in the figurine including fingers, toes and painted facial features. The girl is wearing a green hula skirt and a lei and is strumming a musical instrument.

910735 Tiki Floating Candles s/2 Wood

2 1 Three-dimensional candle in the identifiable shape of a Tiki. The Tiki shaped candle is characterized by the molded features of the human-like figurine including arms and hands resting on stomach, distinct fingers, torso, thick, short legs, mouth, eyes, nose, body, head and hair.

410004 Large Floating Bright Candle - Red



Floating Bright Candle - Yellow


410006 Large Floating Bright Candle - Aqua


410007 Large Floating Bright Candle - (Kiwi)


200013 Assorted Flower Tealights s/9 - Multi

9 9 Flower shaped candle set on top of wax filled glass tealight holder. Each petal of the candle is clearly identifiable and three dimensional.

3709 Bright Flowers Tealight s/6 - Blue

6 6 Similar to Item No. 200013, variation in shape and colors

510577 Large Zinnia Illuminating Candle - Red

1 1 This candle is in the identifiable shape of a flower, the zinnia. The individual small petals characteristic to the zinnia are clearly identifiable and the size, color and texture of the candle is representative of the zinnia flower.

510579 Large Zinnia Illuminating Candle - Yellow


510581 Large Zinnia Illuminating Candle - Kiwi


Appendix: Candles Descriptions 419996 Mini

Floating Zinnia Candle s/3 - Multi


510074 Floating Spring Candles s/3 - Multi Pastel

3 3 Candle set consists of two flower blossoms of 6 petals in an aqua color with a white stigma and a yellow blossom with an orange stigma. The 3rd candle is in the identifiable shape of a butterfly as it is formed with four wings where the upper wings are smaller than the lower wings and a body consisting of the head, thorax and abdomen and antennae.

610240 Floating Mini Leaf Candles s/9 - Multi Harvest


710058 Falling Leaves Floating Candles s/4 - Multi Harvest


610159 Acorn Candles s/6


Quantity (Set/6) and slight variations in size, color, shape and texture.

610208 Sugared Acorn & Pumpkin Candles s/6 - Multi Harvest

6 2 Slight variation in appearance. In addition to the acorn shaped candles, the set includes miniature candles in the identifiable shape of pumpkins.

419926 Watering Can Candle - Olive

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a watering can. The shape of the candle is that of a typical portable watering container with a handle on one side, a spout (i.e. a long tube originating near the bottom of the container) for water flow on the opposite side of the handle, and a shield at the top of the can to prevent water spillage when watering.

200094 Garden Birdhouse Candle - Sage

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a birdhouse. The birdhouse is characterized by four sage colored walls, which are painted to be representative of slats of wood, and a white roof with a black scalloped fascia. The house also includes a molded white picket fence and has a hand painted white circle representing the opening to the house for the birds

Appendix: Candles Descriptions on one of the sides.

410000 Flip Flop Stripe Candle s/2 - Multi

2 2 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a flip flop. The candles, which consist of two candles (right and left shoe) are molded in the shape of a pair of flip flops. The flip flop shaped candles are characterized by a backless, flat sole sandal that is held loosely on the foot by a Y-shaped strap that is properly proportioned to pass between the big toe and second toe and then around either side of the foot. The flip flops may have smooth, ribbed or other textured imprint on top side of candle. The candles are proportioned and shaped as left and right flip-flops to represent shoes that could fit actual feet and the strap is properly proportioned.

Slight variation in decoration

410038 Flip Flop Polka Dot Candles s/2 Red



410039 Flip Flop Flower Candles s/2 Orange



410040 Flip Flop Striped Candles s/2 Lt Aqua


Appendix: Candles Descriptions Slight variation in decoration and texture

412003 Floating Flip Flop Candles s/2 Kiwi


Slight variation in decoration and texture

412005 Floating Flip Flop Candles s/2 - Fuchsia



412964 Floating Flip Flop Candles s/2 - Yellow



510066 Floating Patriotic Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Multi


Appendix: Candles Descriptions Slight variation in decoration

510593 Sangria Stripe Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Multi Primary



510613 Floating Flower Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Aqua



510615 Floating Flower Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Red



510617 Floating Flower Flip Flop Candle s/2 - Kiwi


Appendix: Candles Descriptions Slight variation in decoration

900220 Flip Flop Candles Red






900351 Flip Flop Candles s/2 Orange



900352 Flip Flop Candles s/2 Pink



910016 Floating Flip Flop Candle Orange



910725 Hawaiian Shirt Floating Candle Red/White

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a men's colored shirt. The shirt candle is characterized by the short sleeves and open collar. The red shirt shaped candle is further embellished with Hawaiian blossoms painted on the front surface so as to resemble a Hawaiian shirt.

910723 Hawaiian Shirt Floating Candle Blue/White

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a men's colored shirt. The shirt candle is characterized by the short sleeves and open collar. The red shirt shaped candle is further embellished with Hawaiian blossoms painted on the front surface so as to resemble a Hawaiian shirt.

910727 Shorts Floating Candle Blue

1 1 The three dimensional green candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a pair of shorts. The shorts' candle is characterized by the two short pant legs and includes embossed design features including a drawstring, side pocket and white Hawaiian blossoms painted on the front surface so as to resemble a pair of Hawaiian shorts.

910729 Shorts Floating Candle Red

1 1 The three dimensional green candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a pair of shorts. The shorts' candle is characterized by the two short pant legs and includes embossed design features including a drawstring, side pocket and white

Hawaiian blossoms painted on the front surface so as to resemble a pair of Hawaiian shorts.

910731 Surfboard Floaters s/2 Red

2 1 The three dimensional floating candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a surfboard. The surfboard candle is characterized by the elongated platform with a rounded nose and tail and includes the traditional stringer running from the nose to the tail. The surfboard is further embellished with Hawaiian blossoms and leaves hand painted on the top side of the surfboard.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 910733 Surfboard

Floaters s/2 Blue

2 1 The three dimensional floating candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a surfboard. The surfboard candle is characterized by the elongated platform with a rounded nose and tail and includes the traditional stringer running from the nose to the tail. The surfboard is further embellished with Hawaiian blossoms and leaves hand painted on the top side of the surfboard.

910719 Woodie Car with Surfboard

1 1 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a car with a surfboard on its roof. The candle is characterized by the four-door station wagon resembling a wooden bodied car with a yellow painted front end, black fenders, silver bumpers (front and back) and white wall wheels with silver hub caps. The roof of the car includes black carrying racks and the car is transporting a typical elongated surfboard.

710977 Large Scented Snowball Candle - White


Scented and slight variation in size and texture

710979 Small Scented Snowball Candles s/9 - white


Scented and slight variation in size and texture

610386 Small Snowball Candles s/4 - White


Slight variation in size and texture

610388 Large Snowball Candle - White


Slight variation in size and texture

610089 Snowflake Mitten Candles s/2 - Red

2 2 The three dimensional candle is in the shape of an identifiable object, namely, a pair of mittens. The mittens' candles are characterized by the rounded top and designated thumb protrusion for a left and right handed mitten. The mitten candles are floating candles. As such, hand painted design embellishments of red/white polka dots and red and white stripes on the green mitten candles appear on the viewing surface of the candle.

Appendix: Candles Descriptions 610090 Dots

Mitten Candles s/2 - Green


900335 s/2 Floating Mitten Candles - Red


510056 Sana Stripe Lantern Candle - Red

1 1

510057 Sana Stripe Lantern Candle - Kiwi

1 1

510058 Sana Stripe Lantern Candle - Aqua

1 1

710067 Large Potted Tree Pinecone Candle Multi

1 1 This three dimensional candle is in the identifiable shape of a potted tree covered on all sides with pinecones of different types, sizes, and colors.

710066 Sm Potted Tree Pinecone Candle - Multi

1 1 This three dimensional candle is in the identifiable shape of a potted tree covered on all sides with pinecones of different types, sizes, and colors.

710065 Glittered Pinecone Ball Candle - Multi

1 1 Ball shaped candle surrounded with three dimensional pinecones of different types, sizes and colors.


711133 Small Sugared Fruit Tree Candle - Multi

1 1 Tree shaped potted candle surrounded with three dimensional miniature apples, pears, plums and peaches of varying colors. The miniature fruits are identifiable from multiple angles and are decorated with colored glitter to resemble a coating of sugar.

711135 Large Sugared Fruit Tree Candle - Multi

1 1 Tree shaped potted candle surrounded with three dimensional miniature apples, pears, plums and peaches of varying colors. The miniature fruits are identifiable from multiple angles and are decorated with colored glitter to resemble a coating of sugar.

711139 Lg Sugared Fruit Ball Candle - Multi

1 1 Ball shaped candle surrounded with three dimensional miniature apples, pears, plums and peaches of varying colors. The clearly identifiable miniature fruits are identifiable from multiple angles and are decorated with colored glitter to resemble a coating of sugar.