scholastic chess and competitive chess: how different? · mark dvoretsky, armen and thomas ......
TRANSCRIPT
Scholastic chess and competitive chess:
How different?
lecture by Karel van Delftwww.chesstalent.com www.schaakacademieapeldoorn.nl
A lot in common
Competitive chess and scholastic (educational) chess have a lot in common:
Chess lessons, methods (varia)Didactics, empathyPsychological insights
Definitions
Scholastic chess (teaching) education, personal development funempowerment if disabilitiesCompetitive chess (training)recreationaltop sport
Introduction Karel van Delft
Psychologist Chess teacher and trainerJournalist
www.schaakacademieapeldoorn.nlwww.chesstalent.com
Teacher
Book ‘Schoolschaken’ (school chess)
Trainer
Book ‘Developing Chess Talent’
Video about book DCT
� Book about developing chess talent and creating a chess culture:Coaching, training, organization, communication
� IM Merijn van Delft presents book in a videowww.youtube.com/watch?v=DGgr-NntMNs
Mark Dvoretsky, Armen and Thomas with DCT
Differences and similaritiesSimilarities� Learning rules and basis techniques� Deliberate practice (what, how, where, when, why)� Variation, participation and fascination� Empathic qualified trainer� Seventeenth chess piece (self reflection, self management, study attitude)� Social, emotional, cognitive, meta-cognitive aspects� Role of parents
Differences� Focus: result or education� Ambitions� Amount of time involved� Content training in later stages
Not often asked questions about scholastic chess benefits and transfer
� A lot of research: chess education benefits for personal development� Often unclear: what chess is teached and how
(French opening, tactics, etc)� How to teach, role of teacher
(e.g. discovery learning, frontal teaching, empathy)� Effects on social, emotional, cognitive, meta-cognitive aspects
Transfer matterChess as a subject in primary schools?
Chess players better school results
Lots of variables, several angles
In addition to social, emotional and cognitive learning effects there are also metacognitive learning effects possible as a result of chess education.What you can achieve is the result of a combination of specific chess aspects (tactics, strategy, etc.) you use in combination with specific teaching methods and the target group (age, etc.). It is therefore the combinations are crucial. Compare it with H2 and O, separately they are different from the combination: H2O water. In addition, different learning effects are possible for different students: one learns to deal with losses, another learns to think more creative. Because there are so many variables at stake, it is hard to find in quantitative research very large effects on a single dimension. Therefore, you should not just look at results of quantitative research but also at experiences in practice and qualitative research.
Why chess in schools?
� Chess is metaphor for life
� Learning by playing
� Stimulates development� cognitive� social� emotional� meta-cognitive
4 Aspects
� Cognitive, e.g. argumentation
� Emotional, e.g. dealing with losing
� Social, e.g. cooperation while analyzing
� Meta-cognitive skills: thinking about yourself and thinking about thinking
Benefits reached by
� Intrinsic qualities of the game
� Method of education
� H2O makes water
Script
� Primary school natural environment to learn chess
� Necessary: empathic adult who can teach, organize, motivate
� Important: Script, make clear what you do(for yourself and school, parents, children)
Use a method
� Interconnected activities, which are applied in a certain way with a certain goal
� Elements: structure and culture
Key factors in method
� Variation
� Fascination
� Participation
Didactical principles� Fun is main motor for learning� Success experiences� Empathy: answer questions of children, react on remarks, be supportive� Knowledge, understanding and skills� Skills development by playing and exercises� Present lectures in a attractive way� On level of child (words, examples)� Chess is an adventure full of surprises� Stimulate children to discover answers themselves, use indicative questions� Ideal maximal group 12 children: interactivity� Use various teaching techniques: explain, show, discuss, group work, game analysis, exercises� Quiz with points can stimulate� Via duos children learn to consult and formulate thoughts� Etc.
Polgar – Waitzkin elements education� Stimulate early learning performance� Accent on stimulation via environment, not innate talent� High but attainable goals� Learning via play elements� Make children selfconscious early on� Much variation in practice� Systematical approach� Realistic taxation of developmental potential and load capacity� Understand limitations regular school system� Creating stimulating environment� Qualified and empathic teachers and trainers� Children draw conclusions themselves while learning� Dosed success experiences� Develop bit by bit resilience � Accept children make unavoidable mistakes� Trust intrinsic motivation of children� Don’t project exaggerated expectations on children� Take children serious� Take in consideration personality features and developmental stage features
Education: direct and indirect transfer
DirectWhat you learn in one domain using in other(e.g. counting chess pieces, counting on school)
IndirectLearning attitudeConcentrationGrowth vs fixed mindset
Research and methodological flawsLondon Conference 2016 John Jerrim: no benefits chess teaching on math results
� Video Karel interview Jerrimwww.youtube.com/watch?v=TLWANu8mWio
� Video Sala critical on research Jerrimhttp://londonchessconference.com/giovanni-sala-comments-on-current-chess-and-education-research
� Article newsletter 41 Schaakacademie Apeldoorn (page 38)www.schaakacademieapeldoorn.nl/documenten/Nieuwsbrief%20Schaakacademie%20Apeldoorn%2041%20-%2018%20januari%202017.pdf
Explaining chess technique and psychological insights
� Connect to pupils experiences, knowledge and mental stage
� Speak language of pupils
� Not too much information at the same time
� Give practical advises how to deal with problems
Basis good training and teachingPupils co-author own upbringingDeliberate practiceEmpathy trainer-teacher
Content:� Question round� Tactics� Game analysis� Varia� Competition
What motivates children to learn?
� Curiosity� Surprises (you surprise with Réti, they you with questions)� Ambitions� Experiences� ?
What does this mean for the way we teach?
Creating a stimulating environmentBuild a concrete program and routines based on:
� Trainers, trainings� Study material� Training place� Training program � Time� Collaborating with training partners is stimulating� To have yourself influence on a process is an important success determinant� Success experiences� Positive feedback from trainers and parents (on efforts, not on result or personality)� Determine real expectations and convert them into clear goal-setting (aspects: perform, fun, learning)� Space for failures (you have the right to be wrong: failures acceptable, experiments)
Attention:- Not everyone learns and develops the same way- These factors can also work out negative if they are applied incorrectly
� Important distinction between result and performance goals
� Result goals: Comparison with competitors. Result of a game (1-0). Influence of circumstances, coincidence and opponent.
� Performance goals: Comparison with yourself. You show what you are capable of. Doing this you can control yourself.
� Doing so concentration and self-confidence will raise and fear of failure will decrease.
� It is natural if you want to win. But the paradox is by concentrating on a performance goals you are focused on your task and you can perform better.
Fear of failure: performance goals
What is chess thinking
Important aspects:
� Pattern recognition (e.g. castling)
� Rules of thumb (e.g. three golden opening rules)
� Calculation
Chess performance
Result of � Chess qualities� Mental qualities� Physical condition� Coincidence
You can influence the factorsLearning and behaviour can be more productive
Concentration
Exercise: � What is concentration?� Make a list of possibilities to destroy concentration
Reverse the listFormulate what to doCheck list regularlyBuild routines
SkillsPractice makes perfectBuild up productive routines
UCCO� Unconscious not skillful� Conscious not skillful� Conscious skillful� Unconscious skillful
Compliments
Positive reinforcement
A compliment can do wonders
Stimulates self-image, motivation of pupils
Help for searching strategiesVia words you can give help for searching strategiesE.g. Piece is attacked
� Take attacker� Put between� Go away� Support� Counter attack
Memory aid: TPGSP (In Dutch STUDT, sounds better)
Examples of Varia for
teaching and training
Chess is for everybody: Gens Una Sumus
Chess is fun
Mitrofanovwww.youtube.com/watch?v=2vgIQikkoKQ
Creative thinkingSee connections in unexpected way
Creativity: skill or gift?
What do you think?
Definition
Creativity is making connections between matters and ideas thatare not connected at first sight.
It enables you to find, use and develop more possibilities thanappear possible.
Expect the unexpected
� Creativity is a trainable way of thinking which leads to see, use and develop more possibilities
� Creativity is having big expectations of the unexpected
Einstein
‘Creativity is seeing something that others also see, but havingdifferent thoughts about it.’
Creativity is redefining
� Chess is a game of possibilities and limitations
� Define a problem in a different way
� You do not see something you do not look at
� A creative mind is open to paradoxical possibilities
� Welcome the unexpected
Watch inspiring videos
Participation in tournaments
Game with quiz questions
Tutor method
Tactics quiz: duos, forms, clock
Sites like Vuurboomhttp://jeroenvu.home.xs4all.nl/schaken
Beginners: small groups, interactive
Beginners: learn from each other
Deaf-mute consulting
Chess calendar
Chess paper download see button Leonardo schools on www.schaaktalent.nl
Immediate feedback
Humor (turn board 90 degrees)
Humor + information book Afek The Knight
Birthday present
Duo presents own game
Competition
Free pairing program Sevillawww.jbfsoftware.com multiple languages
Winner gets list of standings
Tournament games on internet
Analyse game of chess teacher
Formulate problem in words
Opening quiz: what is the decisive move
Lecture: attack with g4www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xdt0ZVy6twE
Lecture: correspondence chesswww.chess.com
Lecture: national championships
Teacher simuls to trios
Quiz: yes or no
� All kids stand up
� Simple questions: yes or no
� Wrong answer: sit
Quiz: yes or no (and why)
� A player should accept losing
� You don’t have to understand, better learn openings by heart
� If you are afraid, you see more possibilities
� It is important to practise easy and difficult tactics
� It is useful to experiment
Invite IM: questions, simuls, blitz
Chess history site Asaf Fellerhttp://assaffeller.com
Combine openings with tactics (quiz)www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Lab/7378/kg.htm
Thematic positions
Is this a terrible position for white?
White is better in 10 variations
Black to move resigned What can black play?
Black to move should not resign(Lobron – Gretarsson, Leeuwarden 1995 – 41..Dd5+ draw)
Play at home
Offer free possibilities to play chess at home
� Tactics and playing games www.lichess.org
Show more sites during lessons
Moreno: conflict? Why to beat?
Chess for everybody: looking with your fingers