_sbi - session 5 strategy (final)
TRANSCRIPT
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 1/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Singapore
November, 2011
State Bank of India
Leadership Development Program
Session 5: Strategy Development
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 2/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Module 4: Financial Strategy
November 19th
10:30 – 12:00 Session 1 The Future of Banking: What trends are reshaping the industry.12:00 – 13:00 Lunch
13:00 – 14:30 Session 2 The Competition: How is the competitive landscape in India changing?
14:30 – 16:00 Session 3 The Value Proposition: What are we providing to meet our customer needs?
16:00 – 16:30 Break
16:30 – 18:00 Session 4 Value Proposition Alignment: What is our product / market segmentation strategy?
November 20th
09:00 – 10:30 Session 5 Strategy Development: How do we engage in right to left thinking?
10:30 – 12:00 Session 6 Performance Measurement: Forget Moody‟s are we measuring the right things?
12:00 – 13:00 Lunch
13:00 – 14:30 Session 7 Risk what risk: How are we building our risk topology?
14:30 – 16:00 Session 8 Organizational Design and Strategy Implementation: Are we organized for success?
16:00 – 16:30 Break
16:30 – 18:00 Session 9 Wrap up and discussion on steps to implement our strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 3/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Four Things to Keep in Mind During this Session
Strategies are iterative, requiring refinement
Good strategies generate a series of questions
Customer loyalty is earned, not bought
Organic growth is a process of discovery
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 4/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Strategic Thinking
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 5/83 © 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Trend: Evolution or Revolution?
2005 2015
Large Bank
Co-operativesSavings SocietiesBuilding Societies
Mid-tier Bank
Community Bank
IndustrySpecialists
Non-BankInstitutions
Universal Banks
IndustrySpecialists
Non-BankInstitutions
Middle squeeze:
Large banks makeacquisitions
Non-banks presentunique valuepropositions
Increase profitability with moretargeted offerings whileexpanding through selectedacquisitions and market entries.
Grow market share by buildingon local knowledge and deepcustomer relationships with awider range of products andservices
Expand customer base byproviding targeted products andservices for high growth nicheswhile leveraging superiorprocess capabilities
Build on existing customer baseand distribution networks with anemphasis on open sourcing oftargeted products and services
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 6/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Most Banks Employ Five Major Strategies
PursueOperational Excellence,
Reduce Costs,Optimize
Develop NewProducts
Consolidate,
Structure,Transform Processes
Regionalize
andGlobalize
Acquire & Retain
Customers,SuppliersStrategic
Initiatives
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 7/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Management Motivations for Strategy Development
New bank or new product
Cost
Revenue Cost
Revenue
Cost
Revenue
Working in a fixed butfluctuating profit margin
Losing customersor profits
Growing Bank Mature Bank Declining Bank
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 8/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Life on Earth: Companies with a growth agenda
Revenues
Costs
Growth
External factors causerevenues to plateau and or
cost to expandexponentially
Failure pointmargin
Strategies:
•Top Line:• Accelerate growth
• investments in nextgeneration growth
• organic growth
Bottom Line:
• Cost containment
• process optimization
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 9/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Life on Earth: Companies in decline
Revenues
Costs
Decline
Cost can never go to zerobut revenue can
Failure pointmargin
Strategies:Bottom Line:
• Cost containment
• process optimization
• reorganize
• cost avoidance
Top line:
• improve margin
• find new markets
• innovate or die
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 10/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
CorporateMentality
Employee Attitude
Economics
BusinessProcess
Employment
HumanResourcesOrganization
Growth Strategy Competitive Strategy Survival Strategy
R & DInvestmentInnovation
Zone of False Senseof Strategy Security
Cost containmentDownsizing
Outsourcing
Enthusiastic Optimism Next Quarter Focused Panic - Search for Next Job
Scramble for Talent
Policies & Benefits Outplacement, Terminations,Talent retention
Cost
Revenue Cost
Revenue
Cost
Revenue
Sold off
Outsourced
Process Defined
Process Refined
DownsizeRe-organize Labour
Skill Alignment
Management Attitudes and Strategy Development
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 11/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Survey: What is your Bank‟s Primary Business Strategy?
Top-line Growth
Bottom-line Savings
12
7
389
3
7
2
Source: Maris Strategies Retail Banking Survey 2011
Number of
respondentbanks
75%
25%78 Banks
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 12/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Survey: What is your Bank‟s Primary Business Strategy?
Cost Cutting Strategy
Growth Strategy
15%
46%39%
23%15%
0%
23%
39%
External
growth bymerger andacquisition
Cross selling
products andservices toexisting
customers
New
customeracquisition
Incremental
processimprovement
Broader
large-scalebusinessprocess re-engineering
Head
countreductions
Outsourcing
sharedservices
Eliminatio
ofunprofitabcustomers
75%
25%
Source: Maris Strategies Retail Banking Survey 2009
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 13/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5
Revenues
Costs
ProfitabilityFailure point
Strategy Centres on Top-Line Growth
Top-line Growth
Bottom-line Savings
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 14/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Why do some
Strategies Fail?
Electric Shaving sold by Slot
Machine 1940 in Subway
1992
2010
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 15/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
The Revenue Growth Strategy“Improve stability by broadening the sources of revenue from current customers”
The Productivity Strategy“Improve operating efficiency by shifting customers to morecost- effective channels of distribution”
Improve
Returns
ImproveOperating
Efficiency
BroadenRevenue
Mix
Increase
Customer
Confidence inOur Financial
Advice
Increase
Customer
SatisfactionThrough Superior
Execution
Increase
EmployeeProductivity
Access toStrategic
Information
Develop
StrategicSkills
Align
PersonalGoals
Financial Perspective
Customer Perspective
Internal Perspective
Learning Perspective
Cross-Sellthe Product
Line
Shift toAppropriate
Channel
ProvideRapid
Response
Develop NewProducts
MinimizeProblems
UnderstandCustomer
Segments
Balanced Scorecard Strategy Map Tells the Story of Your Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 16/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Balanced Scorecard Links Cause and Effect Hypotheses
F1 - Improve Returns
F2 - Broaden Revenue Mix
F3 - Reduce Cost Structure
C1 - Increase CustomerSatisfaction With Our Products& People
C2 - Increase Satisfaction “After
the Sale”
I1 - Understand Our CustomersI2 - Create Innovative Products
I3 - Cross-Sell Products
I4 - Shift Customers to Cost-Effective
ChannelsI5 - Minimize Operational Problems
I6 - Responsive Service
L1 - Develop Strategic SkillsL2 - Provide Strategic Info
L3 - Align Personal Goals
Return on Investment
Revenue Growth
Deposit Service Cost Change
Share of Segment
Customer Retention
New Product Revenue
Cross-Sell Ratio
Channel Mix Change
Service Error Rate
Request Fulfillment Time
Employee Satisfaction
Revenue per Employee
Strategic Objectives Strategic Measurements(Lag Indicators) (Lead Indicators)
Revenue Mix
Depth of Relation
Satisfaction Survey
Product Development Cycle
Hours with Customers
Strategic Job Coverage Ratio
Strategic Info Availability RatioPersonal Goals Alignment (%)
F i n a n
c i a l
C u s t o m e r
I n t e r n a l
L e a r n i n g
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 17/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity: Develop a Vision for 2018
Inside: Financial Services: What's Working; What Isn't
Nintendo Acquires Charles Schwab at Steep Discount
$1 1.00April 15, 2015
Financial Services/Cover StoryKey Results Headlines:
How Customers View Us:
Sidebar/Special Interest Profile:
52 FORTUNE April 15, 2015
Five years ago, who would have predictedthese would be the Critical Success Factors
for 2018:
Envision how the Media and Customers will see your Bank in 2018
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 18/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity: What are our Financial Goals and Objectives?
Goals: Objectives:
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 19/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Strategic Goals
• Increase bank‟s market share
• Overtake key rivals on quality or customer service or
product performance
• Attain lower overall costs than rivals
• Boost bank‟s reputation with customers
• Attain stronger foothold in international markets
• Achieve technological superiority
• Become leader in new product introductions
• Capture attractive growth opportunities
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 20/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Strategic Objectives
Strategic objectives convert the mission of the institution into
specific performance targets for the organization to achieve
Strategic objectives are qualified in two broad categories:
Corporate perspective quantified by measures such as Economic ValueAdded (EVA), Net Present Value (NPV), Return on Investment (ROA),
Statement of Cash Flow, and Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC);
Shareholder Perspective quantified by measures such as: Expected
return for shareholders (Return on Stock) CAPM, Return on Equity (ROE),Market Price of Share Stock policy & Dividend Policy, Price Earning Ratio
(PER), and Earnings per Share (EPS).
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 21/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Example of Strategic Goals and Objectives
Initiative Strategic Goal Specific Purpose Objectives
Improve
Communications
Less
Bureaucracy
Organic
Growth
Recognition
Accomplishments
A streamlinedeffectiveorganization with anagile response to
changes in thebusinessenvironment
Reduce unnecessarywork by streamliningprocesses andinfluencing individual
behaviour
Simple process inplace for identifyingand taking forwardincremented
improvements;Increased awareness
Reduce all businessprocess steps by 10%during next 12 months.
Reduce operating costsby 5% in 12 months
We want more staffto feel they arebeing recognized,as measured by theregular staff surveys
We want more staff tofeel they are beingmotivated
Ideas on best practicehave been shared andmanagers empoweredto provide smallmonetary incentives
Recognize staff thatimplement ideas withbonus incentive, allocate10% of cost savings and5% of revenueimprovement annually
Managers and staffbeing well informedon relevant things
Well informed managersand staff feel empoweredand can do their jobbetter
Awareness of needfor regularinformation, Financemeetings
Weekly email newsletterto all staff frommanagement
10% operating resultgrowth
Continuoussustainable growthboth by acquisitionbut also organic
Company wideorganic growthinitiatives with focuson big growth projects
Increase cross sell ratioto 3.5
Repackage 20% ofproduct portfolio
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 22/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity: What are our Strategic Goals and Objectives?
Goals: Objectives:
Valuing Customer Centricity
W k A i i E l D i G l d Obj i
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 23/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Note:Cross/up-selling, targetcustomer retention andtarget pricing strategyare the greatest value
creators in retailbanking. Average bankhas between 2.8 – 4.5products per customer
DecreaseCosts
10-30%
IncreaseRevenues
70-90%
Increase in
Overall Value
g y
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
Strategic InitiativeGoal
Objective
Next page
Tactical Objective
W k A ti it E l D i G l d Obj ti
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 24/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
Increase Revenueper Relationship
60-80 %
IncreaseRevenues
70-90%
Grow CustomerBase
20-40% Next page
Valuing Customer Centricity
W k A ti it E l D i G l d Obj ti
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 25/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Increase CustomerReferrals 20-40%
Improve MarketingEffectiveness
60-80%
Improve CustomerSatisfaction 70-90%
Set-up SwitchingCosts for Customers
10-30%
Increase TargetCust. Reactivation
20-40%
Increase TargetCust. Retention
45-65%
Attract NewCustomers
5-25%
Grow CustomerBase
20-40%
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 26/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
Increase revenueper relationship
60-80 %
Increaserevenues
70-90%
Grow customerbase
20-40%
Next page
Valuing Customer Centricity
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 27/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Increase revenueper product
Increase number ofproducts per
customer60-80%
Develop targeted pricing
strategy by customersegment 50-70%
Increase cross/ up-selling 50-70%
Foster bundling conceptswith external partners
5-25%
Develop personalizedproduct offerings
20-40%
Improve sales channelefficiency
5-25%
Increase overall pricelevel
20-30%
Increase revenue
per relationship 60-80 %
Increase volume percustomer
10-20%
Work Activity Example: Decomposing Goals and Objectives
20-40%
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 28/83
Decompose your Strategic Goals and Objectives
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 29/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Decompose your Strategic Goals and Objectives
Right way Wrong way
Work Activity: Decompose your Strategic Goals and Objectives?
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 30/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity: Decompose your Strategic Goals and Objectives?
Strategic Initiative Goal Objective
Strategic Initiative: Improve Cross-Selling
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 31/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Cross-sell remains an illusive goal for most institutions; only a few banks have
successfully created a systematic capability to grow their business
organically in this way
Leading banks are using specific tactics to increase share of wallet
• Offering tightly integrated product bundles
• Using financial planning as a sales tool
• Knowing what to offer and when based on life and other key events
• Using a local market planning approach to drive cross-sell efforts
Strategic Initiative: Improve Cross-Selling
Revenue Enhancement through Cross-Selling
Valuing Customer Centricity
Cross-Selling Example
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 32/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Increaserevenue
per product
20-40%
Increasenumber of
products percustomer
60-80%
Increase customer
referrals20-40%
Improve marketing
effectiveness60-80%
Improve customer
satisfaction70-90%
Set-up switching costs for
customers10-30%
Develop targeted pricing
strategy by customersegment
50-70%
Increase cross/ up-selling 50-70%
Foster bundling concepts
with external partners 5-25%
Develop personalizedproduct offerings
20-40%
Improve sales channelefficiency
5-25%
Increase overall pricelevel
20-30%
Reduce Marketing Cost
Reduce Selling Cost
Reduce Servicing Cost
Reduce Credit Risk Cost
Increase
revenueperrelationship
60-80 %
Increase targetcustomerreactivation
20-40%
Increase target
cust. Retention45-65%
Attract new
customers5-25%
Decrease
costs 10-30%
Increaserevenues
70-90%
Increase volume percustomer
10-20%
Increase inoverall value
Growcustomerbase
20-40%
Cross Selling Example
Tactical Agenda
Strategic Agenda
Process View Linear Techniques
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 33/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Process View – Linear Techniques
LOB
LOB
LOB
LOB
Common Techniques to ImproveProcess Efficiency
Eliminate Activities
Automate or Digitize
Create Shared Services
Global Sourcing
Parallel Processing
BEFORE AFTER
Discrete activities within a process are often replicated across multiplebusiness units or channels. Often different techniques are applied for thesame activity across different units
The component view identifies the
collection of specialist capabilities thatcan be combined as a network tosupport the full array of process
ComponeComponen
Work Activity: List your Strategic Initiatives
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 34/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work Activity: List your Strategic Initiatives
Strategic Initiatives:
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 35/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Growth Strategies
The Strategic End Game
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 36/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5
Revenues
Costs
Managing the
Service Gap
The Strategic End Game
CustomersServed Managing the
Cost Gap
Managing theCustomerExpectation Gap
The Growth Agenda
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 37/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
e G o t ge da
Growth
Agenda
OperationalAgenda
Increase Product Demand
Increase Market(s)
Organic Growth
Merger or Acquisition
Reduce Costs
Improve Quality
Retool
Leverage technology
Sell assets
New product innovationNew applications for old products
Increase knowledge of existing marketFind new markets
Sell existing customers more things
Find new things to buyBuy customers
Enhance efficiency
Improve customer service
Buy new technology
Redeploy existing technology
Consolidate resources
Brand development
Strategic Need Strategic Initiative
Characteristics of Growth in a Bank
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 38/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Product Diversity - What you sell
• Product Demand – Why is the product valuable
• Market Expansion – Where you sell
• Market Timing – When to sell
• Customer Saturation – Who buys types of products
• Operational Excellence – How to deliver on customer expectations
Directions of Growth
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 39/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Expand products orservices to existing
customer baseCreate new market
Gain share ofexisting customer
businessGain market share
New Products& Services
Existing
Not ServedServed
Product / Service
Offerings
Customers
Bank
What Questions Do We Need to Ask?
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 40/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Not Served
How can we create
new products and or
how do we find new
uses for our existing
products?
How do we findnew markets for
our current products
and for newproducts?
How do we gain a
greater share
of existing
customer business?
How do we find new
customers in our
existing markets?
Increase Market Share E x p a n d P r o d u
c t P o r t f o l i o
Ways to Grow
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 41/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Market Concentration
– More frequent use
– Larger quantities
– New uses
• Innovation
– Replacement products
– Additional features
– Complementary items
– Completely new items
• Mergers and Acquisitions
– Gain immediate market share
• Penetration
– Segmentation
– More locations
– Minimize overhead
– Export
• Diversification
– Capacity Analysis
– Crossovers
Growth by Acquisition to build Shareholder Value
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 42/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Establishing a Strategy for Growth
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 43/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Growth is:
– A process of vision, leadership, investment, and managed intentions.
• Growth is not:
– A product of intermittent actions or changes in customer demand.
• Growth is achieved by:
– Expanding a firm's value proposition (building competencies to identify,analyse and rapidly capitalize on opportunities).
• Sustaining a growth agenda requires:
– A clear set of objectives identifying how the firm will achieve growth
• Sustainable growth is: – a business process in its own right that requires careful planning,
investment, execution, measurement and, above all, management
Characteristics of Growth and Shareholder Value
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 44/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
UnprofitableGrowth
ProfitableGrowth
CostCutting
BelowAverage
AboveAverage
BelowAverage
RevenueGrowth
AboveAverage
ProfitGrowth
Absolute Market Value Growth(CAGR 2000-2011)
0%
Setting the Growth Agenda: Screening Criteria
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 45/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Market Attractiveness
–Market size
–Market growth/cyclicality
– Intensity of competition
• Direct rivalry
• supplier power
• customer power
• substitutes
• potential entrants
–Degree of segmentation –Availability of channels
–Social/regulatory constraints
• Business Strengths
–Familiarity with market and
technology
–Fit with competencies
–Shared resources (manufacturing
facilities, R&D, sales force,
distribution)
–Prospects for advantages
–Availability of partners
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 46/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Work ActivityMoving from Strategy to Action
Drivers of Market Share
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 47/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Advertising &promotion
Share ofVoice
Referral
CompetitiveConsideration
Image
Awareness
TotalConsideration
Coverage
ChannelStrategy
Non-CompetitiveConsideration
Loyalty
CompetitiveHit Rate
OverallHit Rate
100%Hit Rate
MarketShare
• Sales effectiveness• Total offer meeting
customer needs• Fees & relationships
Work Activity: Drivers of Market Share
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 48/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Map the factors that drive market share in your markets?
Use previous slide as aguide.
Note:
For banks with multiplemarkets: first develop ageneric model, then list theissues that are specific toeach market separately
Strategic Moves to Increase Market Share
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 49/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Market share: Which products in what markets?
• How can we move past close competitors or further dominate the market?
• How can we increase our visibility with customers?
• Top-of-mind awareness: Do customers remember our products? Or our capabilities
• Do customers consider us as a superior provider of banking services?
• What is the level of customer dialogue? Are Informed customers more loyal?
• Service delivery: How do we link to other products or services
• Strategic alliances: Can we partner with someone to get into new markets? – Co-
branding?
Things to consider:
How do we find new customers in existing markets?
How can we identify and sell to new markets?
Strategic Questions:
Work Activity: Strategic Moves to Increase Market Share
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 50/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
What is your strategic thinking on increase market share?
Use previous slide as aguide.
Discuss and answerquestions.
Are there any otherquestions to be answered?
Tactical Actions to Increase Market Share
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 51/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Are there opportunities to cross sell other products to our existing customers?
• How can we enhance brand quality?
• How can we enhance our product portfolio?
• How can we increase the effectivity of our marketing campaigns?
• Can any of our products be applied in new ways?
• Do we understand all the businesses our customers (SMEs & Corporates) are serving?
• How do we get closer to our customers‟ needs?
Things to consider:
How do we sell more to existing customers?
How can we find new uses for existing products?
Tactical Questions:
Work Activity: Tactical Actions to Increase Market Share
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 52/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
What tactical actions can you take to increase market share?
Use previous slide as aguide.
Discuss and answerquestions.
Are there any otherquestions to be answered?
Strategic Moves to Expand the Product Portfolio
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 53/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Are there new product innovations in the pipeline?
• Can we create product variations?
• How can we repackage our product offerings with services to increase the value?
• Do we really know our customers?
• Do we really know what are competitors will be doing next?
• How do we set fees to gain a long-term competitive advantage, rather than to maximize
short-term profits?
• What is our relative cost position to our competitors and what set us apart?
Things to consider:
How do we enhance our products to command
higher fees?
How can we improve our service and relationships
with customers?
Strategic Questions:
Work Activity: Strategic Moves to Expand the Product Portfolio
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 54/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
What is your strategic thinking on expanding the product portfolio?
Use previous slide as aguide.
Discuss and answerquestions.
Are there any otherquestions to be answered?
Tactical Actions to Expand Product Portfolio
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 55/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• How can we assist our customers (SMEs) in selling their products?
• How do we create a dialogue with our customers to better understand their needs?
• How can we increase our products‟ usability with existing customers?
• Is quality a factor in our customers‟ decision process?
• How do we change the customers‟ perception of our products?
• Can we improve our customer assistance?
• What can we do to make it easy to do business with our bank?
Things to consider:
How do we educate our customers to understandour value proposition?
What approach can we use to adjust prices without
alienating our customers?
Tactical Questions:
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 56/83
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 57/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Case Study
Rabobank Strategy 2010
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 58/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Development of new (international) growth possibilities
• Strengthen the capital base
• Cost reduction
• Revenue or organic growth
• Domestic mergers, acquisitions and alliances
Development of New (International) Growth Possibilities
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 59/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Revenue economies and synergies Cost economies and synergies Synergetic
potential
Retail Banking - Export successful products- Develop new international services
- Eliminate overlap in international retailnetwork
Low
Corporate &
Investment Banking
- Reach scale by broadening client and product
coverage (especially mid corporate investmentbanking)
- Eliminate overlap in functions (e.g. FX
trade, international payments) andinternational network
- Sharing industry expertise
High
Private Banking - Provide international services to „global‟ clients - Share part of back office costs
- Close overlapping locations
Medium
Asset Management - Cross selling to larger distribution network
- Reach scale to attract institutional investors
- Share research, product developmentand back office costs
High
Leasing - Vendor leading for Pan European clients -Share back office costs Medium
Insurances - Export successful products
- Develop commercial lines
- Risk diversification Low
Internet / M-Banking - Export successful products and concepts - Share back office costs Low
Credit Card - Export successful products and marketing
approaches
-Administration can be centralized Low
Head Office / IT (Not applicable) -Eliminate costs in overlapping functions High
Cross border economies and synergies for partnering or M&A
Cost Reduction
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 60/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Restructure organization to be customer centric
– Consolidate branches (1,445 branches)• Customer visits to branches are down 95% during last 25 years
• Customers that do visit branches fall into two broad categories
– Working professional (reengineer service delivery for speed and
convenience)
– Wealthy (design branches for upscale customers)
• Refocus support from head office
– Head office to consolidate resource to provide
targeted support services to specific customer groups
– Optimize back office activities
• Target distribution channels based on customer preferences
Revenue Growth
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 61/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Improve selling power of front line people
– Upgrade CRM capabilities
• Gain larger market share in Urban areas
– Acquire new customers: urban professionals and young people
• Develop clear market segmentation strategy
– Customers
– Products
– Channels
Five Growth Levers
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 62/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
• Wealth management: identify ways to create a tighter relationship with
wealthy consumers to increase loyalty and drive cross-selling opportunities
• Generational strategy: identify strategies to capture new segments and / or
strategies to differentiate your offerings to existing segments
• Multichannel strategy: identify ways to create a consistent customer experience
across key channels: branches, online, mobile devices, and contact centres
• Role in payments ecosystem: identify strategies for achieving success through
new business models for collaborating with retailers, and define your strategy
related to mobile payments
• Growth in Asia and Emerging Markets: identify strategies for profitable growth
in geographical regions with strong underlying GDP growth
Multiple Distribution Options to Realize Revenue Growth
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 63/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Strategy Description Pros Cons
Multi-channelling Selling products andservices of clients with
different channels,such as branchesATMs, telephone andinternet
- Customer can choose how and when contactwith the bank is wanted
- Different channels appeal to different types of
customers
- Cost savings, due to relatively cheap virtualchannels
- Customers become more anonymous
- Customers can switch more easily betweenbanks
- High investments in ICT systems
- Complexity of Control
Multi-labelling Selling identical self-made products under
different labels in themarket
- Reach different target groups
- Economies of scale in production
- Cannibalisation of existing labels
- complexity of process
- Reputation risk
- Complexity of control
Openarchitecture
Distribution of productsproduced by anotherfinancial institution
- Larger product offer for customers
- Reduce the need for customer to switch banks
- Fee income
- Customers may loose overview if too many
products are offered- Cannibalisation of own products
- Complexity of control
Co-Branding Linking two brands forthe selling of one
product or group ofproducts
- Product is also sold through the network of thepartner
- - May change the image of the brand
- -Explore new markets
- - Cooperation may lead to innovation
- - Create a bond with the customer of the partner
- - Sharing of the advertising budget
- Customer can fid the combination of brandsillogical
- - Negative publicity of the partner harms your
own brand
- - Complexity of control
White labelling Production of productsthat others will sell withtheir own label
- Increase scale of production
- Revenues from the selling of products
- Cannibalisation of your own labelled products
- - Deterioration of competitive position
- - supervisory institutions might not allow it
- - Reputation risk
- Complexity of control
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 64/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Case Study
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 65/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Vision of becoming in every manner
„the clear leader and Nigeria’s bank of First choice‟.
Our targets can be broadly broken down into:
(i) Scale (assets)
(ii) Profitability/capital efficiency
(ROA, ROE, cost-to-income)
(iii) Asset quality (NPLs) and
(iv) Service level metrics.
First Bank‟s Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 66/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
TALENT
Become a hub forthe best industrytalent; cultivate ahighly motivated,
capable andentrepreneurial
workforce.
PERFORMANCE
MANAGEMENT
Deliver unmatchedresults by creating aperformance culturewith clear individualaccountability at all
levels.
SERVICE
EXCELLENCE
Drive unparalleledservice levels by
developing world-class institutional
processes, systems
and capabilities.
GROWTH
Attain full benefitsof scale and scope
by acceleratinggrowth and
diversification ofassets, revenue and
profit.
Strategy
Growth Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 67/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Institutional/Corporate Banking:
• Redefine business unit commercial strategy (optimised productportfolio, channel strategy and marketing communications approachlinked to deep customer insights)
• Drive deeper risk asset penetration in the middle market corporate
segment, underpinned by enhanced credit analysis and processingcapabilities
• Deepen share of wallet of large corporates to enhance fee/commissionincome
• Deepen capabilities in structured finance space to enhanceparticipation in infrastructure financing.
Growth Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 68/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Retail Banking:
• Redefine business unit commercial strategy (optimised product
portfolio, channel strategy and marketing communications approach
linked to deep customer insights)
•Increase penetration and profits from consumer credit by redesigningcredit processes and tools (e.g., statistical models and credit scoring
algorithms)
• Develop a differentiated sales and service model for high net-worth and
affluent customers, and aggressively pursue this segment.
Growth Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 69/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Public Sector Banking:
• Redefine business unit commercial strategy (optimised product portfolio,
channel strategy and marketing communications approach linked to deep
customer insights)
• Aggressively pursue key accounts not presently within portfolio.
Branch Network and Expansion
• Employing global positioning system mapping to superimpose macroeconomic
data (including aggregate output of each state) on the industry‟s branch
network.
• Bank‟s existing business locations influence the „city attractiveness‟ index that
will drive business location deployment going forward.
• Accordingly, 47 branches were opened in the year, bringing the total number of
branches on our network to 570
Growth Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 70/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
General Growth Initiatives:
• Significantly but conservatively scale up risk asset deployment and optimise
treasury portfolio to increase yield on earning assets
• Engage in enterprise transformation to reposition the FirstBank brand and, over
time, drive enhanced customer consideration, acquisition, and cross-sell/up-
sell
• Optimise branch network via more targeted new branch openings, deployment
of lighter/small format branches focused on sales (versus servicing).
Inorganic growth:
• Continue to explore the Nigerian landscape for merger or acquisition
opportunities, to extend the franchise in a manner that benefits shareholders• Explore international M&A (and organic) entry options.
Growth Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 71/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Institutional/Corporate banking:
• Redefine business unit commercial strategy (optimised productportfolio, channel strategy and marketing communications approachlinked to deep customer insights)
• Drive deeper risk asset penetration in the middle market corporate
segment, underpinned by enhanced credit analysis and processingcapabilities
• Deepen share of wallet of large corporates to enhance fee/commissionincome
• Deepen capabilities in structured finance space to enhanceparticipation in infrastructure financing.
Service Excellence Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 72/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Goal: modernise the Bank‟s fundamental operating model (processes,tools/systems, and roles/capabilities).
Key initiatives to drive this objective include:
• End-to-end process redesign (centralised processing and branch process re-
engineering) focused on priority processes with the objective of
standardisation, simplification and efficiency
• Branch transformation that updates the FirstBank branch format• TouchPoint reengineering for all electronic/other customer touchpoints,
including the Bank‟s interactive website (recently redesigned), e-statements
and customer communications, etc.
• Channel optimisation and migration to optimise channel functionality while
aggressively driving migration of transactions to the most appropriate channels
• Three-year IT transformation plan designed to stabilise and improve core
elements of the Bank‟s IT infrastructure, and enhance the IT
organisation/capabilities.
Performance Measurement Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 73/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Create a performance culture
• Align individual, team and business objectives
• Clearly defined KPIs (with weightings)
• Individuals monitor performance targets
– Monthly and quarterly performance reviews with commensurate
rewards
• Dedicated business performance monitoring (BPM) unit
• Implement new operating structure to align Business Unit objectives
• Extend balanced scorecard usage to back-office/ support functions
• Expand portfolio of metrics to track critical improvement areas for the
future
Talent Strategy
„Bank of First Choice‟ must attract develop and retain the best performing
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 74/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
„Bank of First Choice‟ must attract, develop and retain the best-performingindustry talent available in the region.
• Staff productivity: wellbeing programmes for the field organisation and
critical back-office support functions
• Staff capability building: build and up-skill the competencies of the market
facing/ front office and back-office workforce - (e.g. FirstAcademy)
• Culture change: encourage entrepreneurship, leadership and a desired tochange
• Individual performance: ensure the alignment of individual KPIs targets to
job functions and corporate strategy
• FirstBank’s employee value proposition: FirstBank as a premium
employer• Career management: drive career development at all levels and sustain
organisational performance (management development programmes, student
mentoring, coaching, cross posting, secondment).
First Bank‟s Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 75/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Scale:
• Estimated 13% market share of assets (our goal is 20%).
• Views inorganic growth as a viable and appropriate growth route,
where a suitable combination and terms can be found.
• While recent regulatory statements imply that certain limits may be
placed upon the relative size of banks, we believe that FirstBank
should aspire towards a 20% market share domestically.
First Bank‟s Strategy
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 76/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Profitability/capital efficiency:
• Boost ROE by improving its leverage (with a strong emphasis on low-cost current and savings deposit mobilisation) and enhancing its share
of fee and commission income.
• Cost-cutting initiatives are ongoing
• Cost-to-income ratio improvements will come from the income side of
the equation by:
– improving its share of fee/commission income
– optimising its liquidity position (i.e., strongly incentivising growth in
the loan book versus liquid assets in the near-time)
– increasing its yield on earning assets.
First Bank‟s Strategy
Asset quality:
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 77/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
q y
• Bank experienced increase in non-performing loan ratio due to the
general slowdown in economic growth and direct or indirect exposure
to sectors affected by the 2008 –2009 decline in oil prices and the
domestic equity markets.
• The Bank made aggressive provisions and write-downs in 2009 in line
with prudential guidelines and expects that the overall asset portfolio
quality will improve shortly, all else being equal.
• As the Bank extends its franchise further in the middle-market
corporate (commercial) and consumer lending space, risk management
systems and processes will be strengthened to optimise portfolio
quality and to ensure that margins reflect and adequately compensate
for risk.
First Bank‟s Strategy
S i l l
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 78/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Service levels:
• The greatest priority of the Bank, will be improving service delivery.
• The Bank is yet to break into the top quartile of Nigerian banks with
respect to service levels, based on independent industry surveys, but
has instituted major initiatives to address this lapse.
• Long reputed for very high transaction volumes (driven in part by its
very large mass market franchise), FirstBank will increasingly strive to
improve overall service delivery quality.
• The Bank will institute incentives to aggressively move routine
transactions to alternative channels and simultaneously ensure that
premium customers (e.g., corporates, high net-worth customers)
receive first-class service.
Goal to Improve Segmentation Analysis
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 79/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Strategy to Sequence Growth Systematically
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 80/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
FirstBank Group – Priorities by growth horizon
Performance Results
TOTAL ASSETS (N Billi )
GROSS EARNINGS (NBilli )
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 81/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.
TOTAL ASSETS (N'Billions)
Mar 07 Mar 08 Mar 09 Dec 09 Dec 10
7 6 3
1 , 1
6 5
1 , 6
6 7
1 , 7
7 2
1 , 9
5 7
GROSS EARNINGS (N'Billions)
Mar 07 Mar 08 Mar 09 Dec 09 Dec 10
7 9
1 3 1
1 8 5
1 7 5
2 0 8
DEPOSIT LIABILITIES (N'Billions)
Mar 07 Mar 08 Mar 09 Dec 09 Dec 10
5 8 2
6 6 2
1 , 0 7 2
1 , 2 4 4
1 , 3 3 1
PROFIT BEFORE TAXATION
(N'Billions)
Mar 07 Mar 08 Mar 09 Dec 09 Dec 10
2 2
3 8
4 6
8 3 4
Innovation
8/2/2019 _SBI - Session 5 Strategy (Final)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sbi-session-5-strategy-final 82/83
© 2011 Maris Strategies, Ltd. All rights reserved.