saving nhs money the first uk dietetic led primary care gastroenterology clinic january 2012

2
fuepuoces 'slrsrn de peleede; r.uo:1 sOurnes luecllruOrs ur llnsor plnoc slq-L ]alp dvl^Col eq1 0urpnlcur 'ect^pE SBI lsrlerceds eJoLl ;oJ aclnlos i{6o1o.talueorlseO pa1-cr1e1erp mau aL1+ 01 paroler ete 'Ilessaceu 1r 'uaq] puE uEllrlarp i(1runLuLuoc ereue6 e ol outl +si!] E se ]uas e,te sOe11 pel ou r1llm sluotled 1eq1 6u rnsue uo snco] plnoqs uorlecrlrlsnI lEtcueuU aLll 'ocrAros ggl lsrlerceds erec fueu.Lud e Ourneq lo slgouoq aq1 o1 lqbram uenrO eneq s1lnsel ase{f 16s1 '}elp dVt/\COl Mol eq1 6ursn ueqm lueuuenordurr uolduu{s q}tl uot}ceJst}es %91 e pa^ otls qc!Ll/v\ 'f LoZ jeqolco ut lP 10 Jor.{cepnE}s {q peqsrlqnd Illuecet osoql o} relrLLils ere ]as.reutos ul eroq elep lpne aq1 '[16ur1sele1u1 '6urure;1 srql o^rocar ol suerltlslp zL +slu eq] lo ouo s^ I 'sBl lol luol.xlEal] dvy\ooj poseq-ocuopr^a ^ eu alll ur uopuol e6elloC s6uty le osrnoc ,suEtltlotp yn ]slu eql qlrl poplculoc srLlf (6) uorltpuoc srql 6ur1ee.r1 o1 qceordde reelc e suer+tlerp 6urnr6 I11eu11 'peqsrlqnd aro/1^ ,s]lnpV ut SEI 1o lueure6eueyl cllalatO aql ro] seurloprnc ectlcPJd pese8 -ocuopr^1. vc8 ,ry\eu 3q+ 0 Loz ur roAeMoH lueLle6eueuu s1r o1 Llceordde +seq oql uo snsuesuoc olull qll.M +Eer] 01 uorltpuoc 6ur1er1snr1 e ueaq sELl Sgl 1r,'sbe11 po, ou qlrm pe,uolor 6ureq sluerled ]o %0 01 q]lm '}sn{ uor}Epunoj sHN ll^oe^ IE pUnO] usoq e^eq sllnsel relru.rrg uorleDilsoAUt eiec l{lepuoces snornerd auoOiepun osle pELl dno.rb srql p %/-V 1r1 "ernlrpuedxe Aresseceuun ur 000'6ZtJ o1 elenbe,(11er1ua1od plnoc +eql ';elrdsoq euo lsnl ur .,tEeI E raAO liluoLU auo +snt ur 611'0LJ SHN aq] ]soc s+uerled eseql suorle6r:senur Il1soc ro1 erec fuepuocas o1 per;eieJ {;uessaceu un e;er'r sluerled gg1,{6olote1uaor1se0 p yoe'Vl\e..1] puno, rls1,1 sHN losralUos pue uoiunel 1? lsr6olorelueorlsEO ]uEli nsuoC '6terg euur-u3 ^q) I IOZ ur lrpnE tl+uoul-ouo { 1s1 'orEO fuepuoces ol porrele.l 6ureq eseqi p %AZ punore quM 1r) de lleqi Llo.Jl ocr^pe loes ;1rin eldoed uorl;rr.r.r fs'l 1q) 'urnuue lad uotllru g'gt3 ro^o lo lsoc e +e sgl qll^ slo#ns uorlelndod yn oll] ]o o/o1l )eAO ea)r^ras ^l,au slrll roJ uorlBrlJllsnl IeI)uEuIJ aql sI lEqM 'I6re11e an.r1 L{}tM 6ullefns +cel ur ore pue Sgl 1o srsou6erp +caJjocur ue a^eLl sluetled Jo %8 lsoule +Etll s/1\otls Ilpne luecor rno 'suollellnsuoc ol l serrnbe.r {1uo {11eLulou }uotu}Eo{ 'suorleOrlsanul e;ec I.lepuoces pue sltstn dC 'suo+durIs Jo ,roop 6urn;oaer, 111soc eq1 qbno;q1 ssed o+ popuel o^Eq '^\ou ltlun dn 'oqru sluotlpd esoLll ioJ {emqled }uotu}eol} crlrceds e slello ctutlc oql 'sree{ 1o eldnoc lxau aLl} uLl}tm eprrrn-rilunoc ]t elEtu o+ Lule eA lnq lesrauros qlnos slonoc lsnl : ecr^res aq+ '1uese;d iy '1e1rdso6 , Ilrunurr-uo3 uopoqlod rllnos : eLl+ le 'Llluour led slep olnl sunr qsrLlM 'oct^los Meu srql o+ suerltletp Ilrunutuoc pue s6g . ]asreuros qlnos ^q pollalor ale I6re1;e 1g ro Sgl qlr^ s1uer1e6 '{elcreg ouuol1 la6euer-u : crlolorp Au-r 1o poddns 1e1rn eq1 ' L1lrl crurlc [6o1o;e1ueol1se6 elec ^reurud pel-ctloletp yn 1slll eq1 dn 6ut11es uo peyeqtlo I 'f L0z roqLueldos ut 'acuaH 'sHN OLl+ urqlrm sournes letcueulrr luecgru6rs eIeLU dlorl ol pue ouop ere s6urlll feru eq1 o6uelleL]c ol {lunyoddo leopl ue se^ oleL{} +Eq] reolc euecoq ]l ',,oltl ^ur po6ueL{c,, peLl uor}uenle}ur &e1erp 1eq1 6ur1e1s sluotled {ueuu qlrrrn 'olej ssoecns %69 e A oqs ol elqe sel ; ftrunu.iuuoc eq1 ur sgl jo lueLuleel] orll uo elep 6urlrpne ]o reol E 6urmo11o3 (r,e) ']SoC eL{} lo UollCel] e }e lo}CAS erec fueuud eq1 ur Ilengcege pue I;eles suorlrpuo3 eolql Iie L1lt/v\ Ieep uec sercueledutoc lceroc or-{l q}Uv\ uetularp E '10^ pue'erec fuepuoces ol polraler sluerled {uer-u qlrm ggp oq] ol lsoc luec4tu6ts e sesod uorlrpuoc Ucel rs,z,o'sueras{qd erec fueul.rd {q poolsepun 11errn rillereueb ]ou elE Llctr.lm seote ole oorLll llE pue oseostp cetleoc uo^o ro (9911 er-uorpu{s ;amoq e;qelurr '16re1p (g) leurlselurotlseb 1o su6rs eq lle uec eserl+ :uorledrlsuoc l{eue6-rn :eoqretp lured ;euru-ropqe :pur^A :6utleolq :Eosne sHN aql puo stua\ad lilauaq uDT lt /t4,ot4 puo tl pu!4aq suosaa) at4l sa^tD aqs a,rcH ztutp L6ololayaulsoD uo) fuautud paf)Uatatp Xfi ls,uj at4l dn las ':{.DnIIa puo Sil ul $ilalw loDads o t4lll uotlttat1 rfitunruwo) o swaqIL4A auuDUaN'Lt1Z )aqwaldas uI 0fi! b rva .+Ltyaurd ?3-[-a!+"+"w NW +s r!* ayl :A&xxoru SHN ffi'mfAES

Upload: marianne-williams-bsc-hons-rd-msc-allergy

Post on 30-Mar-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Saving nhs money the first uk dietetic led primary care gastroenterology clinic january 2012

fuepuoces 'slrsrn de peleede;r.uo:1 sOurnes luecllruOrs ur

llnsor plnoc slq-L ]alp dvl^Coleq1 0urpnlcur 'ect^pE SBI

lsrlerceds eJoLl ;oJ aclnlosi{6o1o.talueorlseO pa1-cr1e1erp mau

aL1+ 01 paroler ete 'Ilessaceu 1r

'uaq] puE uEllrlarp i(1runLuLuocereue6 e ol outl +si!] E se ]uase,te sOe11 pel ou r1llm sluotled

1eq1 6u rnsue uo snco] plnoqsuorlecrlrlsnI lEtcueuU aLll

'ocrAros ggl lsrlercedserec fueu.Lud e Ourneq lo slgouoq

aq1 o1 lqbram uenrO eneq s1lnselase{f 16s1 '}elp dVt/\COl Mol

eq1 6ursn ueqm lueuuenordurruolduu{s q}tl uot}ceJst}es

%91 e pa^ otls qc!Ll/v\ 'f LoZjeqolco ut lP 10 Jor.{cepnE}s

{q peqsrlqnd Illuecet osoql o}relrLLils ere ]as.reutos ul eroq

elep lpne aq1 '[16ur1sele1u1'6urure;1 srql

o^rocar ol suerltlslp zL +slu eq]lo ouo s€̂ I 'sBl lol luol.xlEal]dvy\ooj poseq-ocuopr^a

^ eu

alll ur uopuol e6elloC s6uty leosrnoc ,suEtltlotp yn ]slu eql

qlrl poplculoc srLlf (6) uorltpuocsrql 6ur1ee.r1 o1 qceordde

reelc e suer+tlerp 6urnr6 I11eu11

'peqsrlqnd aro/1^ ,s]lnpV ut SEI1o lueure6eueyl cllalatO aql

ro] seurloprnc ectlcPJd pese8-ocuopr^1. vc8 ,ry\eu 3q+ 0 Loz

ur roAeMoH lueLle6eueuu s1r o1

Llceordde +seq oql uo snsuesuocolull qll.M +Eer] 01 uorltpuoc

6ur1er1snr1 e ueaq sELl Sgl1r,'sbe11 po, ou qlrm pe,uolor

6ureq sluerled ]o %0 01 q]lm'}sn{ uor}Epunoj sHN ll^oe^

IE pUnO] usoq e^eq sllnselrelru.rrg uorleDilsoAUt eiec

l{lepuoces snornerd auoOiepunosle pELl dno.rb srql p %/-V

1r1 "ernlrpuedxe Aresseceuun ur

000'6ZtJ o1 elenbe,(11er1ua1odplnoc +eql ';elrdsoq euo lsnl

ur .,tEeI E raAO liluoLU auo+snt ur 611'0LJ SHN aq] ]soc

s+uerled eseql suorle6r:senurIl1soc ro1 erec fuepuocas o1

per;eieJ {;uessaceu un e;er'rsluerled gg1,{6olote1uaor1se0

p yoe'Vl\e..1] puno, rls1,1

sHN losralUos pue uoiunel 1?

lsr6olorelueorlsEO ]uEli nsuoC'6terg euur-u3

^q) I IOZ ur lrpnE

tl+uoul-ouo { 1s1 'orEO fuepuocesol porrele.l 6ureq eseqi p %AZ

punore quM 1r) de lleqi Llo.Jlocr^pe loes ;1rin eldoed uorl;rr.r.r

fs'l 1q) 'urnuue lad uotllru g'gt3ro^o lo lsoc e +e sgl qll^ slo#ns

uorlelndod yn oll] ]o o/o1l )eAO

ea)r^ras ^l,au slrll roJ uorlBrlJllsnlIeI)uEuIJ aql sI lEqM

'I6re11e an.r1 L{}tM 6ullefns+cel ur ore pue Sgl 1o srsou6erp

+caJjocur ue a^eLl sluetled Jo%8 lsoule +Etll s/1\otls Ilpne

luecor rno 'suollellnsuoc ol lserrnbe.r {1uo {11eLulou }uotu}Eo{

'suorleOrlsanul e;ec I.lepuocespue sltstn dC 'suo+durIs Jo

,roop 6urn;oaer, 111soc eq1qbno;q1 ssed o+ popuel o^Eq

'^\ou ltlun dn 'oqru sluotlpdesoLll ioJ {emqled }uotu}eol}crlrceds e slello ctutlc oql

'sree{ 1o eldnoc lxau aLl} uLl}tmeprrrn-rilunoc ]t elEtu o+ Lule eA

lnq lesrauros qlnos slonoc lsnl :

ecr^res aq+ '1uese;d iy '1e1rdso6 ,

Ilrunurr-uo3 uopoqlod rllnos :

eLl+ le 'Llluour led slep olnlsunr qsrLlM 'oct^los Meu srql o+

suerltletp Ilrunutuoc pue s6g .

]asreuros qlnos ^q

pollalor aleI6re1;e 1g ro Sgl qlr^ s1uer1e6

'{elcreg ouuol1 la6euer-u :

crlolorp Au-r 1o poddns 1e1rn eq1 '

L1lrl crurlc [6o1o;e1ueol1se6 elec

^reurud pel-ctloletp yn 1slll

eq1 dn 6ut11es uo peyeqtlo I

'f L0z roqLueldos ut 'acuaH'sHN OLl+ urqlrm sournes letcueulrr

luecgru6rs eIeLU dlorl ol pue ouopere s6urlll feru eq1 o6uelleL]c ol{lunyoddo leopl ue se^ oleL{}

+Eq] reolc euecoq ]l ',,oltl ^ur po6ueL{c,, peLl uor}uenle}ur &e1erp

1eq1 6ur1e1s sluotled {ueuu qlrrrn

'olej ssoecns %69 e A oqs olelqe sel ; ftrunu.iuuoc eq1 ur

sgl jo lueLuleel] orll uo elep6urlrpne ]o reol E 6urmo11o3

(r,e) ']SoC eL{} lo UollCel] e }e lo}CASerec fueuud eq1 ur Ilengcege pue

I;eles suorlrpuo3 eolql Iie L1lt/v\ Ieepuec sercueledutoc lceroc or-{l q}Uv\

uetularp E '10^ pue'erec fuepuocesol polraler sluerled {uer-u qlrm ggp

oq] ol lsoc luec4tu6ts e sesoduorlrpuoc Ucel rs,z,o'sueras{qd

erec fueul.rd {q poolsepun 11errn

rillereueb ]ou elE Llctr.lm seote oleoorLll llE pue oseostp cetleoc uo^oro (9911 er-uorpu{s ;amoq e;qelurr

'16re1p (g) leurlselurotlseb 1osu6rs eq lle uec eserl+ :uorledrlsuoc

l{eue6-rn :eoqretplured ;euru-ropqe

:pur^A :6utleolq :Eosne

sHN aql puo stua\ad lilauaq uDT lt /t4,ot4 puo tl pu!4aq suosaa) at4l sa^tDaqs a,rcH ztutp L6ololayaulsoD uo) fuautud paf)Uatatp Xfi ls,uj at4l dn las ':{.DnIIa puo

Sil ul $ilalw loDads o t4lll uotlttat1 rfitunruwo) o swaqIL4A auuDUaN'Lt1Z )aqwaldas uI

0fi! b €rva .+Ltyaurd ?3-[-a!+"+"w NW +s r!* ayl:A&xxoru SHN ffi'mfAES

Marianne
Marianne
Page 2: Saving nhs money the first uk dietetic led primary care gastroenterology clinic january 2012

,,

c{,=+=v. fu *a " ac k = * *eaa

-6i:r4ril ti

-:i,'l"_,,,1;+rl,.l:eti,i:;j

-

NHS'. (r3) Assuming that thespecialist community dietitianhas the necessary competenciesand follows protocols statingwhen to refer a patient on forfurther investigation. then incombination with new andeffective evidence-basedtreatments they potentiallyhave an innovative recipe forsignificant NHS savings. dS

(9) British Dietetic AssociationGastroenterology Specialist Grou p'Professional Guideline: UK evidence-based practice guidelines for thedietetic manaoement of iritable bowelsyndrome (lBS) in adults': Birmingham.September 2O1O

Q0) Skudacher H, Whehn K, lNing PM,Lomer M (201 1 ), Comparison of symptomresporee following advice for a diet low infementabte carbohydrules (FODM APs)ve6us standard dietary advice in patientswith idtable bowel syndrcme. Journal ofHuman Nutritian & Dietetis:24: 487-4gs

(l 1) Gupta R et al. e004. Review: Burdenof allergic disase in the UK: secondaryanalyses of national databases. Clin ExpAilergy: 34; 520-526

(12) Levy ML, Walker S, Woods A, SheikhA (2009), Seruice evaluation of a l.JKprimary cffi-based ailergy clinic: qualityimprovement repoft: Pimary CaeBspiatory Journal: 1 8; Ahead of pint- Micle in pres

(13) Depaftment of Heahh" NHS White Paperpresented to parliament by the Secetaryof State for Health by Command of HerM4esty July 2010. 'EquW and exellence:Liberating the NHS'; The StationeryOffice: Repotl No: Cm 7881; ISBN97801017881 20

'e fffi,stroe,yrterotoffW e,(i *ti*

care referrals, unnecessaryinvestigations, complicationsand associated conditions andmedicatjons. ln addition, treatingpatients who have been givena diagnosis of IBS after red flaginvestigation can also reducethe substantial 'revolving door'costs. This is a potential win-winscenario, with a proportion of themoney saved being channelledto support the new communitygastroenterology dietetic service.

Should this service includeGI allergy?Allergy effects 1-2% ot the adultUK population. (r1) Allergy as awhole costs the UK NHS overt1 billion pounds per annum(rr) with a significant proportionof referrals to allergy clinicsbeing related specifically to foodallergy. r- However. there is aUK-wide lack of specialist adultallergy servicesl,'and there is noadult allergy service in Somerset(with the nearest solutionbeing expensive secondary ortertiary care referral to Bristol orSouthampton). Despite the new201 1 NICE guidelines on allergy,

which clearly state that allergydiagnosis and treatment couldpredominantly take place inprimary care (a), speclalist allergyclinics within primary careremain almost non-existent.

lnterestingly, all the patientsin our audit were referredwith IBS and yet almost B%improved when given dietaryintervention for Gl allergy andnot lBS. A further 26%o weresuccessfully treated usinga combination of advice forfood allergy and IBS (althoughfollow-up needs to be donewith this group to determinethe true cause of theirimprovement).

Not only is there a need forspecialist adult food allergytreatment within primary care,but there also appears to bea significant issue with thediagnosis of Gl symptoms. TheSomerset audit results highlightthat it is vital to run a clinic thatcovers both disciplines with aspecialist dietitian who has theskills and competencies to beable to differentiate betweenthe conditions.

FinallyAs the pressure increasesthroughout the NHS to reducereferrals to secondary care,dietetic community services areideally placed to set up specialistclinics to bridge the gap. Wecan "challenge the way thingsare done", fitting perfectly withthe 2010 White Paper, 'Equityand excellence: Liberating the

References(1 ) Beltlini M, Iosetfl C, Costa E B/agt S, Stasl

C, Del Punta A, Monicelfi e Mumolo MG,Rlcchiuti A, Bwi n Marchi S (2005)'The genetal pactlioneri appr@ch toiriable bowel sydrome: From intention topectice , Jourrut of Dig5tive and LiverDisease: 37(7 A: 934-939

'2t Boyal College of Physicians Allergy: Theunmet need'. London: Royal Colege ofPhysicians of London: (200q. Repoft No:/sBN 7 86076 783 9.

& NICE: ltritable Bowel Syndrcme: Costingrepoft implementing NICE [email protected] 2008. Londan

4) NICE: Food alergy in children and youngp@ple: NICE clinical guideline 116;February2011, London

6) lnadomi JM etat. (2003). Systematicreview: the economic impact ot iftitablebowel syndrcme. Alirent PmacolTher:1 8; 671 -682

(6) Thompson WG, Hffiton KW SmylhGT Smyth C (2000)'hitable bowelstndrome in gensal pructice: prevalence,characteristics and referaf , Gut 46; 78-82

A Greig E (201 1), Audit of gastroenterotogyoutpatients clinic data fu May 201 1;Taunton & Someret NHS Irust

(8) Gore S (201 1 ), Audit o! gastroenterologyoutpatients clinic data for May 201 1 ; Y&vilNHS Foundation Trust