sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

12
26.2 September 2014 . ISSN 0960 703X . Charity Number SC010440 . www.socantscot.org The President’s Letter Dear Fellows, My final letter as President is regrettably brief. Since succumbing to ill health at the beginning of April this year I have unfortunately been unable to take part in any Society activities or preside at meetings. Especially disappointing was missing the Rhind lectures, which, as can be seen and heard on the superb high- quality recordings available on the Society’s website, were eruditely and entertainingly delivered by Emeritus Professor John Waddell and enjoyed by many Fellows. I have also been absent from the recent important series of meetings of the Society’s Council at which complex governance issues have been subject to detailed review. No President is indispensable, however, and I am pleased to be able to thank the Society’s Vice-Presidents, especially Antoinette (Twin) Watkins and Dr Ann MacSween, for taking over my duties so competently. As I think back over the past three years there are some obvious reflections. Although this has been an exceptionally eventful period for the heritage sector in Scotland against the background of continuing recession, the Society has emerged stronger than ever and is recognised by Govern- ment as a key independent voice and advocate. As with the rest of the sector, the Society is itself changing in terms of its internal organisation to meet the new realities – at last we have our Fellowship and Development Officer post – and is also determined to keep innovating (watch out for the Dig It 2015 events) in line with its public-benefit remit as a charity. But the Society’s commitment to its underlying values in fostering and promulgating research remains – perhaps demonstrated most clearly by the achievement of realising the Scottish Archaeological Research Framework (ScARF) initiative, which is now seen as a major and innovative resource for all those involved with or interested in the archaeology of Scotland. I am also particularly pleased that the Society has increased its output of a diverse range of books, achieving a quality of content and production to rank alongside the very best international publications in our field. These books, along with the SAIR reports and the Proceedings, continue to showcase the latest and best of research into Scotland’s past. It is very reassuring on demitting office to feel confident that the Society is in such good shape, with a committed and energetic Council and an excellent staff team, and I send my very best wishes to my successor for what will I am sure be an exciting next triennium. It remains to say what an honour and pleasure it has been to serve as your President since 2012. Alan Saville FSA FSA Scot MIfA President Newsletter Society update Dear Fellows, as the President mentions in his letter, Council members, who are the trustees of the Society, have been busy examining and assessing the governance of the Society, ensuring that it is fit-for- purpose in the modern charitable world. The completion of this work will likely result in a series of proposals to Fellows for consideration and, hopefully, agreement at an Anniversary or Extraordinary Meeting. It will also include some changes to the internal management of the Society such as changes to the Committee structure and greater clarity and transparency with regard to the respective roles of trustees and staff. The aim is to ensure that the Society operates as efficiently as possible, driving towards its current Vision and ensuring that it delivers its charitable objectives on your behalf. Governance review and proposed subscription changes Our Royal Charter Seal © Society of Antiquaries of Scotland

Upload: society-of-antiquaries-of-scotland

Post on 08-Apr-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

26.2 September 2014 . ISSN 0960 703X . Charity Number SC010440 . www.socantscot.org

The President’s LetterDear Fellows, MyfinalletterasPresidentisregrettablybrief.SincesuccumbingtoillhealthatthebeginningofAprilthisyearIhaveunfortunatelybeenunabletotakepartinanySocietyactivitiesorpresideatmeetings.EspeciallydisappointingwasmissingtheRhindlectures,which,ascanbeseenandheardonthesuperbhigh-qualityrecordingsavailableontheSociety’swebsite,wereeruditelyandentertaininglydeliveredbyEmeritusProfessorJohnWaddellandenjoyedbymanyFellows.Ihavealsobeen absent from the recent important series of meetings oftheSociety’sCouncilatwhichcomplexgovernanceissueshavebeensubjecttodetailedreview.NoPresidentisindispensable,however,andIampleasedtobeabletothanktheSociety’sVice-Presidents,especiallyAntoinette(Twin)WatkinsandDrAnnMacSween,fortakingovermydutiessocompetently. AsIthinkbackoverthepastthreeyearstherearesomeobviousreflections.AlthoughthishasbeenanexceptionallyeventfulperiodfortheheritagesectorinScotlandagainstthebackgroundofcontinuingrecession,theSocietyhasemergedstrongerthaneverandisrecognisedbyGovern-mentasakeyindependentvoiceandadvocate.Aswiththerestofthesector,theSocietyisitselfchangingintermsofitsinternalorganisationtomeetthenewrealities–atlast

wehaveourFellowshipandDevelopmentOfficerpost–andisalsodeterminedtokeepinnovating(watchoutforthe Dig It 2015events)inlinewithitspublic-benefitremitas a charity. ButtheSociety’scommitmenttoitsunderlyingvaluesinfosteringandpromulgatingresearchremains–perhapsdemonstratedmostclearlybytheachievementofrealisingtheScottishArchaeologicalResearchFramework(ScARF)initiative,whichisnowseenasamajorandinnovativeresourceforallthoseinvolvedwithorinterestedinthearchaeologyofScotland.IamalsoparticularlypleasedthattheSocietyhasincreaseditsoutputofadiverserangeofbooks,achievingaqualityofcontentandproductiontorankalongsidetheverybestinternationalpublicationsinourfield.Thesebooks,alongwiththeSAIRreportsandtheProceedings,continuetoshowcasethelatestandbestofresearchintoScotland’spast. ItisveryreassuringondemittingofficetofeelconfidentthattheSocietyisinsuchgoodshape,withacommittedandenergeticCouncilandanexcellentstaffteam,andIsendmyverybestwishestomysuccessorforwhatwillIamsurebeanexcitingnexttriennium.ItremainstosaywhatanhonourandpleasureithasbeentoserveasyourPresidentsince 2012.

Alan Saville FSAFSAScotMIfA President

Newsletter

Society update

Dear Fellows, as the President mentions in his letter, Council members, who are the trustees of the Society, have been busy examining and assessing the governance of the Society, ensuring that it is fit-for-purpose in the modern charitable world. The completion of this work will likely result in a series of proposals to Fellows for consideration and, hopefully, agreement at an Anniversary or Extraordinary Meeting. It will also include some changes to the internal management of the Society such as changes to the Committee structure and greater clarity and transparency with regard to the respective roles of trustees and staff. The aim is to ensure that the Society operates as efficiently as possible, driving towards its current Vision and ensuring that it delivers its charitable objectives on your behalf.

Governance review and proposed subscription changes

Our Royal Charter Seal© Society of Antiquaries of Scotland

Page 2: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

2

A capacity audience for the 2014 Rhind Lectures© Society of Antiquaries of Scotland

SomeoftheproposalsbeingconsideredwillrequirechangestotheSocietyLawsandthustheagreementofFellows;forexampleapossiblechangeisthereductionin the numbers of trustees of the Society, from a current representationof22peopletoamorepracticablenumberofmembersandalimitednumberofco-optedmembers.Inaddition,CouncilisconsideringchangestothetenureoftrusteestoprovidegreaterstabilityandensuretheabilitytoengageeffectivelywiththelongtermgoalsoftheSociety. Councilhasalsohadtoconsidercurrentsubscriptionratesandtorecognisetheeffectofinflationsincethelastincrease in 2008. This means that a rise in subscription ratesisrequiredtosustainthisvitalincomestreamwhichprovidesthecoreoftheSociety’sindependence;theexactamountswillbecirculatedwiththeAnniversaryMeeting papers. Intandemwiththeproposalforariseinsubscriptionrates,theSocietyhasexploredwaysofrestructuringFellowshiptypes.TherewillbeproposalstointroduceanUnder26orStudentFellowshipwithareducedsubscriptionratetohelpdevelopouryoungerFellowship,andaproposaltochangetheRetiredFellowtypetoanOver65Fellowship.ThelatterwillremovetherequirementforaFellowtohavebeenamemberfor10yearsandsimplifyqualificationguidelinesforthereducedrate.TheSocietyhopesthechangeswillwidenaccessandencouragemembershipfromthesetwokeycommunities. TheproposalswillbephrasedasmotionsagreedunanimouslybyCounciltobevotedonbyFellowsandsetoutinthepaperscirculatedinadvanceofthemeetingon1December2014inGreyfriarsKirkinEdinburgh.CouncilurgesallFellowstoengagewiththisprocessandwehopetoseeasmanyofyouaspossibleatthemeetingitselfwheretherewillbeanopportunitytodiscusstheproposedchangeswithtrusteesandstaff.

Society activities

ThesecondhalfofthelectureprogrammesawtheSocietywelcomeProfessorBorisRankov,fromRoyalHolloway,UniversityofLondon,whogaveafascinatingpresentationonthereconstructionofaGreekTrireme.DrDonaldWilliamStewartgaveaflavourofthetravelsacrossScotlandofauthorMartinMartinand,inasuccessfulcollaborationwithStornowayHistoricalSociety,hislecturewasalsodeliveredonLewis.ThebiannuallecturejointwiththePrehistoricSocietyroundedofftheseriesinApril,whenDrRachelPopepresentedrecentresearchintoprehistoricround-housesinnorthernBritain.Alloftheselecturesareavailabletoviewonlinesodotaketimetovisitourwebsitehttp://www.socantscot.org/articles.asp?pubid=92. ThiswasswiftlyfollowedbyanexcellentweekendofRhindlecturesskilfullydeliveredbyEmeritusProfessorJohnWaddell,NationalUniversityIrelandGalway.TheSocietyisespeciallygratefultoRubiconHeritageLtd,whosponsoredtheseRhindLecturesandtheIrishConsulatewhosupportedthetravelandaccommodationforProfessorWaddell.ThesponsorshipwasmatchedbyaScottishGovernmentNewArtsSponsorshipGrant.Fundsfromthescheme,administeredbyArtsandBusinessScotland,allowedtheSocietytorecordtheweekendprofessionally.WehaverecentlyplacedthesefreetoviewonlinefromourwebsitethroughanewYouTubechannelwe’vecreated. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N4gU5kD9db0&feature=youtu.be.

SponsorshipandotherfinancialsupportforourcharitableactivitieswillbecomeincreasinglyimportanttoensuretheSocietycontinuestoprovideexcellentservices.WearegratefultoFellowSirAngusGrossartforsupportingtheforthcomingLectureProgramme. TheSocietyeventscalendaralsoincludedasuccessfulFellows’PrivateViewoftheScottishGoldexhibitionkindlyhostedbyTheHunterian,andmoreoftheseeventsarebeingorganisedforthenextsession. 2015isalmostuponusandtheDigIt!teamareworkingtoprovideafantasticyeartocelebrateScottisharchaeology,collaboratingwithhundredsofindividualsandorganisationstoofferahugevarietyofeventsandprojects.AspartofthisspecialyeartheRhindlectureswillfollowadifferentformat.TakingAlexanderRhind’sseminal1858publication:British Archaeology: its progress and demands asanoverarchingthemeandtitle,theweekendwillincludeakeynotelecture,talksandpanelevents.Topicswillincludearchaeologicalresilience,geneticsinarchaeology,storytellinginarchaeologyandhistory,AlexanderRhindandhisinfluence,andthefutureofarchaeology.WeexpectthistobearefreshingchangetotheRhindformatwithplentyofopportunityforaudienceparticipation.Wewillreturntotheusualformatin2016withRoeySweet,ProfessorofUrbanHistoryatLeicesterUniversity,presentingduringtheYearofInnovation,ArchitectureandDesign,followedin2017byProfessorRobertaGilchrist,UniversityofReading,presentingduringtheYearofYearofHistory,HeritageandArchaeology. Inouradvocacyrole,detailedpointsmadebytheSocietytotheScottishGovernmentonthenewHistoricEnvironmentScotlandBilltomergetheRCAHMSandHistoricScotland(seepreviousNewsletters)resultedinvariousamendmentsintheBill.TheBillhasnowpassedStage2.Stage3includesafullparliamentarydebateandsignalstheendofitspassagethroughtheScottishParliament.OnceenactedtheneworganisationwillbeinplacebyAutumnnextyear,withanewChairandBoardmemberscurrentlybeingrecruited.TheSocietywillkeepaclosewatchandcontinuetoadvocateonthisissuetoensurethattheoutcomeisbeneficialforScotland’sheritage.SocietyresponsesareavailabletoviewonourwebsiteundertheNewstab(02). Finally,ourwebsiteisalsointheprocessofbeingredevelopedtoprovideanimprovedonlinepaymentsystem,easiernavigationandaccesstoourrichbodyofresources.

Dr Simon GilmourDirector

Page 3: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

3

Forthcoming events2014–2015 Lecture Programme

Wehopeyoufindtopicstointrigueanddelightyouinthe2014–15ProgrammeenclosedwiththeNewsletter. This sessionweareparticularlypleasedtobedeliveringlecturesinDundeeandInvernessaswellasinEdinburghandAberdeen.WewillcontinuetorecordallourlecturesandmakethemfreelyavailabletoviewonlineforthoseFellowsunabletoattendinperson. TheSocietyisgratefultoFellowSir Angus Grossart QC CBE DL LLD DLitt FRSE FSA Scotforgenerouslysupportingthe2014–15lectureprogramme.SirAngussaid“TheSocietyisakeyelementoftheintellectualinfrastructurewhichbindsustogetherinScotland.Newtechnologyistransformingourabilitytouncoverandunderstandourpast,andguideourfuture.ThemarvellousworkoftheSociety,andthemembers,deservessupport.” Plansforthe2016–17programmearenowunderway.Pleaseforwardsuggestionsfortopicsandspeakerstodirector@socantscot.org.

Fellows’ private view

Tuesday28October6.00pm–7.30pmTheHunterian,UniversityAvenue,GlasgowThe Lost Tomb of Robert the BruceexhibitionFellowsandGuestsonly

DrIainFraserFSAScotprovidesafascinatinginsightintotheresearchbehindthisexhibition.InassociationwithTheHunterian,UniversityofGlasgow.Fellows£10,Guests£15.Bookingessential:[email protected],tel(0131)2474133.

Fellows’ Evening

Tuesday18November,6.00pm–8.00pmTheMcManus:Dundee’sArtGalleryandMuseumAlbertSquare,Meadowside,DundeeDD11PGFreeandforFellowsonlybutbookingessential:[email protected],tel(0131)2474133.

Fellows’EveningsprovidearelaxedatmosphereforthediscussionofSocietyplansandactivitieswithstaffandCouncilrepresentatives.ThisyearwewillbeinDundeeattheMcManus

GalleryandMuseum.TheagendawillfocusontheproposedchangestothegovernanceoftheSocietyandrevisedsubscriptiontypesandrates.PapersfortheAnniversaryMeetingwillbeissuedinadvanceoftheeveningprovidingFellowswiththeopportunitytodiscussissuesandconcernspriortovotingonthe1December. Followingthebusinesspartoftheevening,DrChristinaDonald,CuratorofEarlyHistory,haskindlyagreedtohostaprivatetouroftherecentlyrefurbished‘LandscapesandLives’gallery.HighlightsincludetheErrollogboat,findsfromMesolithicMortonandtheRomanLegionaryfortressatCarpow,thePyotdykeshoardofBronzeAgeweaponsandafacialreconstructionofoneoftheburialsfromtheearlymedievalcemeteryatLundinLinks.

3

Ethnology Crossroads

Friday5andSaturday6December2014RoyalSocietyofEdinburgh,22–28GeorgeStreet,EdinburghEH22PQ

TheSocietyandtheEuropeanEthnologicalResearchCentreareco-hostingaconferencetoexplorenewdirections,interconnectionsandtheplaceofScottishEthnologywithinaEuropeancontext.

Theeventwillalsocelebratethe25thanniversaryoftheEuropeanEthnologicalResearchCentre(EERC)andthecompletionofitsfourteen-volumeScottish Life And Society: A Compendium of Scottish Ethnology. ProfessorAlexander(Sandy)FentonHonFSAScot(1929–2014)foundedtheEERCwhichpromotesresearchinto

Scottishlifeandsociety.OriginallylocatedattheNationalMuseumsScotlandtheEERCisnowbasedattheUniversityofEdinburghhttp://www.ed.ac.uk/schools-departments/literatures-languages-cultures/celtic-scottish-studies/research-publications/research/eerc. Pleaseseetheenclosedleafletforfulldetailsandbookinginformationorvisitwww.socantscot.org.

Fischer-Lindsay Lectures in Norway

FellowDrAnneCronewillvisitStavangerandOsloinSeptembertodelivertheFischer-LindsaylecturesandaworkshoponthethemeofNorwegian timber in Scottish buildings; dendrochronological evidence for the timber trade across the North Sea in the 16th and 17th centuries? AnneisaProjectManageratAOCArchaeologyGroup,managingpost-excavationprogrammesthroughtopublication.Shespecialisesindendrochronologyandthestudyofwoodenstructuresandartefacts,andpursuesresearchintoScottishcrannogsthroughsurveyandexcavation. TheFischer-LindsaylecturesarejointlyorganisedbytheSocietyand Fortidsminneforeningen,theSocietyforthePreservationofAncientNorwegianMonuments.ThelecturesweretheinspirationofRonaldCant,apastPresidentoftheSocietywithapassionforecclesiasticalarchitecture.ThelecturesaimtoencouragelinksbetweenresearchersinScotlandandNorwayandhavebeendeliveredapproximatelybienniallyinalternatecountriessince 1980.

Dr Anne Crone FSA Scot at work in Edinburgh Castle© AOC Archaeology

Page 4: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

4

Up and coming deadlines

Murray Medal for HistoryCall for submissions

FundedthroughagenerousdonationfromourFellowDrPeterMurray,£200andamedalisawardedbienniallytorecogniseoriginalresearchpublishedbytheSocietyintothehistoryofScotlandinthemedievaland/orearlymodernperiods(cAD500toAD1700),setwithinaBritishand/orEuropeancontext.Historyisdefinedasencompassingallbranches,includingarthistory,butexcludesarchaeologyforwhichthereisalreadySocietyprovision.Submissionsfortheprize,initiallytobeconsideredforpublicationinvolume144oftheProceedings (tobepublishedinNovember2015),shouldreachtheManagingEditorby1 November 2014. Submissions from non-Fellowsarewelcome.Furtherinformationonsubmittingpapersforpublicationcanbefoundhere(http://www.socantscot.org/content.asp?Page=305&Menu=239),andadditionalinformationcanberequestedfromtheManagingEditor([email protected]).

Archaeological Research in Progress 2015 Call for Proposals

Scotland’sannualArchaeologicalResearchinProgress(ARP)nationalconferencewilltakeplaceonSaturday30May2015attheRoyalSocietyofEdinburgh,GeorgeStreet,Edinburgh.TheSocietyhostedeventaimstocoverrecentarchaeologicalprojectsfromaroundScotlandcoveringallperiods. DoyouhaveaprojectthatyouwouldliketopresentattheARPnextyear?Weareinvitingproposalsfor20–25minutepapersthatdemonstratebestpracticeandnewresearchfindings.Pleasesubmitthefollowinginformationto [email protected] by 31 January 2015:

TitleofpaperShortdescriptionMaximum35wordstobeusedinARPprogrammeandpublicityLongerdescriptionAconcisedescriptionofyourprojecttoincludethepurpose,methodsandimplicationsoftheworkandbriefbiographicalinformationonorganisationsandindividualsinvolved.Maximum400words.

OuraimistoprogrammeabreadthofchronologicalandgeographicalprojectsfromacrossScotland.Theeventwillberecordedandavailableonlinefreetoviewafterwards.Travelexpenseswillbereimbursedandaccommodationpaidfor,wherenecessary,forasinglepresenterperprojectincludedintheprogramme. ForfurtherinformationcontactSimonGilmouratdirector@socantscot.orgorcall(0131)2474115.

Buchan Lecture in Tayside

Saturday1November,9.40am–4.40pmTAFAC Annual ConferenceUniversityofAbertay,Dundee

ProfessorRichardBradleywilldeliverthe2014 Buchan Lecture*asthekeynoteaddressattheannualTAFAC(TaysideandFifeArchaeologicalCommittee)conference.Thelecturewilltracethehistoryofstonecirclesfromtheirfirstcreationtotheirsignificanceinthepresentday,andexaminesnewevidencefromrecentexcavationswhichshedsnewlightonthearchitecturalhistoryoftheseremarkablestructures. Forafulllistofspeakersandconferencedetails,visitwww.tafac.org.ukoremail [email protected]. *The Society offers grants to local societies to help fund a lecture, symposium or conference. A lecture supported by this fund is known as a Buchan Lecture after the founder of the Society. The fund aims to support events in areas of Scotland not regularly served by the Society’s meetings.

Croftmoraig© Richard Bradley

Scotland’s Community Heritage Conference 2014Saturday8NovemberandSunday9November2014CrieffHydro,CrieffThiseventprovidesaforumforvolunteersandcommunitygroupstoexchangenewsandideas,networkandlearnmoreaboutheritageprojectsacrossScotland.Delegatescanattendpresentations,takepartintrainingworkshops,seepostertalkanddisplaysandjoininthe‘oneminutemadness’sessions.AguidedwalkisplannedforSunday,9thNovember.Forfulldetailsonhowtoregistervisitwww.archaeologyscotland.org.uk/news/booking-now-open-scotland-community-heritage-conferenceoremailthem at [email protected]. Scotland’sCommunityHeritageConferenceisorganisedbyArchaeologyScotland,RCAHMS,NorthlightHeritage,theScottishCivicTrust,HistoricScotland,PerthandKinrossHeritageTrust,theSCAPETrust,theNationalTrustforScotlandandDigIt!2015.

The Murray M

edal © Society of Antiquaries of Scotland

Page 5: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

5

Fellows’ pagesResearch into the archaeology of battlefields such as Culloden and Prestonpans, provided invaluable experience for Fellow Dr Natasha Ferguson in her role with the Treasure Trove Unit.

MyfirstyearofworkattheTreasureTroveUnitwasasteeplearningcurveanddespitehavingexperienceworkingwitharchaeologicalobjectstherewerestillaspectsthatwereinitiallydaunting.WhileatabasiclevelthelegalprincipleofTreasureTroveisrelativelysimple,inthatarchaeologicalmaterialrecoveredinScotlandcanineffectbeconsiderednationalproperty,therearenumerousfacetstoensurethissystemissuccessful.HereIaimtobrieflyexploreelementsoftheUnitFellowsmaypreviouslyhavebeenunawareof,namelytheprocessbehindclaimingobjectsandouroutreach programme. MymainactivitywithintheUnitconsistsofsortingandrecordingtheobjectsandassemblagesreportedtousas‘chancefinds’bymembersofthepublicfromacrossScotland.Onaverageapproximately1700objectsarereportedeachyearrangingfromearliestprehistorytomoderntimes,resultinginaround160claimedcases.AsTreasureTrovecanincludeanyobjectregardlessofitsageorcompositionadecisionregardingclaimingisbasedonwhetherweconsiderittobeofarchaeologicalsignificance.Althoughitisimportanttobeconstantlymindfulofthevulnerabilityofthesystemtopotentialbias,thefreedomtouseourprofessionaljudgementisliberatingandIfeelencouragesamuchbroaderappreciationofallaspectsofScotland’spast.Thisrequiresacertaininvestmentoftimeinresearch,aswellastheconfidencetorecognisepotentiallysignificantmaterial,nomatterhowfragmentaryorgrottylooking.EvenalthoughbothIandStuartCampbell,HeadofTreasureTrove,bothhaveacomprehensiveknowledgeofScottishmaterialculture,theabilitytodrawonanetworkofexpertisewithintheNationalMuseumsofScotland,wherewearebased,isinvaluable. Touseanexamplewhichdrawsfrommyownresearchinterestofconflictarchaeology,weoftenrecordassemblagesofleadprojectiles(musketballs)andothermilitarymaterial,inparticular18th–19th-centuryobjectsrelatedtotheraisingofMilitiaandVolunteerUnits,animportantpartofScotland’ssocialhistory.Leadprojectilesassinglefindsnormallyholdlittlearchaeologicalvalue unlessaspartofanassemblage,however, exceptionsincludeexampleswithunusual characteristicsorcontexts.Arecent exampleincludesapieceofcanister shotfoundbymetaldetectingonthe battlefieldofCulloden(1746),althoughnotonNationalTrustforScotlandproperty.Inmypreviouscapacity as a research assistant within the Centre for BattlefieldArchaeologyIworkedonseveralassemblagesofbattle-relatedmaterial,includingonerecoveredfromCulloden.Thisallowedmetonotonlyrecognisethisobjectassignificant,butalsorecognisethespatialsignificanceofthefindspotandhowitrelatedtothewiderbattlefieldcontext.TheobjectwasclaimedandsubsequentlyallocatedtotheInvernessMuseum&ArtGalleryandcontributestotheassemblagealreadyrecoveredbytheCentrein2006. However,regardlessofthetimeinvestedinresearchthesuccessofthesystemisalsodependentonanotherimportantfactor:effectiveoutreach.RaisingawarenessofTreasureTroveandkeepingitwithinthepublic

consciousnessisofprimaryconcern.Increasedvisibility,suchasregularFindsDaysandasocialmediapresenceintheformofTwitterandFacebook,togetherwiththecreationofeasilydigestibleinformationincludingaleafletandarevampedwebsiteareessential.Thesuccessofthisapproachisreflectedinaremarkable100%increaseinreportingoveratwoyearperiod.Ouroutreachaimstobeasencompassingaspossibleandwehavespentmanyeveningsandweekendsvisitingsocieties,clubsandschools,aswellasspeakingatconferencestopromoteourwork.OuroutreachhasalsotargetedheritageprofessionalswithbespokeworkshopsformuseumstaffandarchaeologistsonTreasureTroveandartefactidentification.Furthermore,ascommunityarchaeologybecomesmoreprevalentwehavealsointroducedaworkshopdesignedtoensureprojectleadersareawareofthenuancesofTreasureTrovelaw,anditspotentialpitfalls,whenworkingwithvolunteersandthepublic. AlthoughwiderangingmuchofouroutreachhasbeenfocusedonthehobbyistmetaldetectingcommunityinScotlandwhorepresentthemajorityofreportersof‘chancefinds’.Ihavespentanumberofyearsworkingwithmetaldetectoristsonarchaeologyprojects,andbasedmydoctoralresearchontheircontributionandimpactonsitesofconflictintheUK.Weworkcloselywithmetaldetectoristsandmakesurewehavearegularpresenceatclubsandrallieswherewehelppeopletoidentifyandreporttheirfinds.Concernsraisedbyarchaeologistsregardingunder-reportingarenotunfounded,butwehavefoundthatinrealitymuchofthisissueisbasedonfindersnotrecognisingsomematerialassignificantandsoassumingreportingisunnecessary.Thisrealisationsparkedthecreationofaseriesof‘GuidetoReporting’posterswhichfocusedonmaterialwehadidentifiedashighrisk,specificallymedieval,postmedievalandconflictrelatedobjects.Thiswasalsoanopportunitytostresstheimportanceofrecognisingassemblagesofmaterialaspotentiallysignificant.Thepostershavenotjustbeenpopularwithmetaldetectorists,butalsowithprofessionalstoowithrequestsforcopiesacrossthenationalandinter-nationalheritagesector. Overallwefeelouroutreachhashadapositiveimpactandwehavebeenkeentochallengeanyperpetuatingmythsaboutthesystem,ornotionsweareanunapproachablelegalbody.Thelegalresponsibilitytoreportarchaeologicalobjectswillalwaysunderpinouroutreach,butwestressthatweareheretohelpthepublicandheritageprofessionalsnavigatethroughTreasureTrovelaw. IfyouareinterestedtofindoutmoreaboutTreasureTroveinScotlandpleasedonothesitatetocontactus,orvisitourwebsitewww.treasuretrovescotland.co.uk/ or followourvibrantTwitterandFacebookwww.facebook.com/TreasureTroveScotlandfeed.

Dr Natasha Ferguson with medieval artefacts filming the BBC ‘Quest for Bannockburn’ programme © Folko Boermans

Can

iste

r sho

t fro

m C

ullo

den

Actu

al s

ize©

Tre

asur

e Tr

ove

Page 6: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

6

Looking back ...Inspirational Rhind Lectures 2014

Brendan O’Connor, Convener of the Programme Committee, reports.

“JohnWaddell,EmeritusProfessorofArchaeologyatNationalUniversityIrelandGalway,deliveredsixfascinatinglecturesonthesubjectofArchaeology and Celtic myth: an exploration. The lectures,whichareavailableonline,weremorethanaliteralapplicationofmedievalIrishliteraturetoIronAgesitesbutrangedwidelyoverEuropeandbacktotheNeolithic.Theaudiencecamefromfarandwide,nonefurtherthanourHonoraryFellowVincentMegawfromAustralia.Hejoinedtheaudienceforthelastlecturesfreshfromacelebrationofhis80thbirthdayandwasabletogiveusaninsightintothe more recent past when he was an Edinburgharchaeologystudentinthe1950s. WemustthankVice-President,DrAnnMacSween,whohadtopresideovertheweekend,andDrKatherineForsythofGlasgowUniversityforsummingupthelecturesandgivinganinsightfulvoteofthanks.”

SponsorshipfromRubiconHeritagewasmatchedbyaNewArtsSponsor-shipGrant,fundedbytheScottishGovernmentanddeliveredbyArts&BusinessScotland.Theadditionalfundsenabledustofilmthelecturesprofessionally.Findoutwhatouraudiencethoughtbywatchingourshortintroductoryfilmhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N4gU5kD9db0 thensitdownandenjoyProfessorWaddell’sengaginglecturingstylehttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UCaBwXCoN1MKFSpgXuZcTfag.

Limited Offer First come, first served

WehavealimitedsupplyofArchaeology and Celtic Myth: an explorationbyJohnWaddellavailable.Fellowscanplaceordersbypost,phone(+44(0)1312474214)[email protected]. The bookcosts£35(£5reductionofthepublisher/Amazonprice)andwecharge£2.50forUKpostageor£7.90forinternationalpostage.Weacceptpaymenteitherbychequeorbycard.

Warm glow of Scottish gold

Dr David Gaimster FSA Scot, Director of The Hunterian, University of Glasgow, kindly welcomed Fellows to a private view of the Scottish Gold exhibition in May. Fellow Dr Jennifer Novotny reports on the evening.

Thereismuchtobesaidforpassingan hour in the company of the warm glowofgold.TheScottish Gold exhibitionattheHunterianhighlightedgoldandgoldobjectsmined,produced,orusedinScotland,fromtheBronzeAgethroughtothemodernera.ItshowcasedtheHunterian’sowncollectionswhilegatheringtogether

animpressivearrayofobjectsonloanfrominstitutionsthroughouttheUK. FellowsweretreatedtoaspecialguidedtourbytheHunterian’sexpertnumismatistDrDonalBatesonFSAScot.Highlightsincludedthe19th-centuryLawFarmhoardofBronzeAgeribbontorcs,withallbut2oftheextantobjectsfromtheassemblagebroughttogether.AnotherBronzeAgetreasurewastheForteviotdaggeruncoveredbyarchaeologistsfromtheUniversityofGlasgow.PerhapsIambiasedindrawingattentiontothisremarkableobject,asIhadthegoodfortunetobeatForteviotthedaythecapstonewasliftedandwitnessedthethrillofitsdiscoveryinsideacistburial.SeeingtheForteviotdaggerfullyconservedandondisplayforthefirsttimewasatruetreat. OtherhighlightsincludedgoldcoinsfromtheHunterian’sownimportantnumismaticcollections,includingtheearliestScottishgoldcoinage,alongwithaMerovingiancoinofauniquetypenotpreviouslyidentified.ThisimportantobjectwasachancefindmadebyametaldetectoristandreportedtotheTreasureTroveUnitandonlyrecentlyallocatedto the museum. Alongsidethearchaeologicalmaterial,theexhibitionillustratedthegeologyofgold.MapsorientatedyoutothelocationsofScotland’sgoldreserves,whiletheprocurementofthepreciousmetalwasillustratedwithsamplesofores,nuggets,flakes,andfakes.ManyofthesamplesweredrawnfromtheHunterian’sownextensivemineralogicalcollections.IwasparticularlyfascinatedbyimagesofSutherland’sBaileanOr,anephemeralboomtownfromScotland’sshort-lived1869goldrush. Inamodernculturesaturatedwithcheaplyavailablefauxgoldbling,itisimportanttostopandreflectupontheculturalimportanceofgold;theexhibitiondeftlyevokedtherarity,theprestige,andthebeautyofthispreciousmetal.Scottish Gold’sobjectsofpower,commerce,andpersonalexpressionilluminatethetimelineofScottishprehistoryandhistoryandcontinuetobeguileustoday.WhatbetterwaytoexplorethisrichculturaltimelinethaninthecompanyofFellows;IamalreadylookingforwardtotheRoberttheBruceTombReconstructioneventinNovember!” Moreinformationandselectedimagesavailableathttp://www.gla.ac.uk/hunterian/visit/exhibitions/major%20exhibitions/scottishgold/.

James V ducat bonnet piece © The Hunterian

Page 7: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

7

Blooming marvellous

Our thanks to Peter Thierfeldt for opening his beautiful garden to raise funds for the Society and Dig It! 2015. The event was in memory of Judith Craig Lyall – a great supporter of Scottish archaeology.

Wespentagloriousdaysurroundedbyblooms,enjoyinghomebakingandspreadingthewordabouttheworkoftheSociety.MoniesraisedwillfundanarchaeologyprojectforyoungpeopleintheLanarkshirearea.It is not too latetodonateonlineatbit.ly/1smRtVq.

Summer Excursion to Dumfries House

Dumfries House and the newly opened walled garden proved to be a popular destination for our Summer Excursion. Fellow Jennifer Scarce reports.

The Antiquaries tempts its members withvariedattractions–lectures,conferences,medalsandprizes,publications.Apopularactivityis

theannualsummerexcursiontoarchaeologicalandhistoricalsitesoftendifficulttoreachwithouttheSociety’stransportandorganisationalskillswhichalsoincludeacharmingaccompanyingspecialist. Thisyear’sexcursionwasadayvisittoDumfriesHouse,inEastAyrshire,accompaniedbySimonGreenFSAScot(alsoofRCAHMS)authorofarecentbookontheHousewhogaveusanexpertintroductionduringthejourneyandextrainformationduringourtour. DumfriesHouse,begunin1754byWilliamCrichtonDalrymple,5thEarlofDumfries,isremarkablefortheharmonyandgraceofitsarchitecturewhichisequallymatchedbythequalityofdecorationandfurnishing.RobertAdamdesignedthehouseandThomasChippendalewiththreeEdinburghcabinetmakers–FrancisBrodie,AlexanderPeterandWilliamMathiewereresponsibleforthefurniture.Descendantsofthe5thEarlwerecarefultorespecttheoriginaldesignwithdiscreetadditions.TodayDumfriesHouseandEstateisownedbyaconsortiumofheritagebodiesandtrustsheadedbyHRH

Vice President Twin Watkins and friends with Peter Thierfeldt in Raeburn Garden© Society of Antiquaries

Charles,TheDukeofRothesaywhobothmaintainandconservethehouseandpromoteincomegeneratingenterprises–holidayrentals,organisationofevents,restaurantsandcraftworkshopsandalsoeducationalandtrainingprogrammes. WeconcentratedontheHousewhichwetouredwithguidesPatandAlexbothknowledgeableandwittyraconteursprogressingsteadilythroughbeautifullyfurnishedandmaintainedrooms.Eachofushasourfavourites;minecurrentlyaretheTapestryRoomwherewoodcarvedintheButefamily’sCardiffworkshopsframesasetof17th-centuryGobelintapestries,andthehandsomeEntranceHall.Wewerenourishedwithshort-breadandlunchfreshlypreparedandservedbystudentsofthecateringschool. DumfriesHouseandEstateisverymuchanevolvingprojectwhichmeritsyetanothersummerexcursion?Tofindoutmorevisithttp://dumfries-house.org.uk/ ” IfyouhaveasuggestionforaSocietyexcursionpleasedoletusknow.Emailvina@socantscot.org.

Dumfries House© David Perry FSA Scot

7

Page 8: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

8

NewsChanges to Research Library access from 1 September 2014

TheNationalMuseumofScotlandMasterplanPhase3projectwillcreatetennewgalleriestodisplayScience&TechnologyandArt&Designcollections.Whilethistransformationtakesplace,accesstotheResearchLibraryfromthepublicgalleriesisunavailableuntilthenewgalleriesopeninsummer2016. Thelibrarywillremainopenasusualduringtheproject,butFellowswishingtousetheResearchLibraryshouldmakeanappointmentbeforehand. Thelibrarywillcontinuetohavefullaccesstoallofitscollections,sopleasecall(0131)[email protected] beforehandtorequestmaterialandtheywillhaveitreadyforyoutoconsultonyourarrival.

Website update

WorkonthenewwebsiteiswellunderwaythankstosupportfromInvestecandtheHeritageLotteryFund.ThenewsitewillprovideFellowswithanimprovedonlinepaymentfacilityforsubscriptionrenewals,publications,merchandiseandticketsales,clearernavigationpanelstoallowimmediateaccesstonews,updatesandonlineresourcesandamorefunctionalFellows’Onlyarea. OneimportantnewfeatureintheFellows’Onlyareawillbeanonline Fellows’ Directory.Fellow’snamesandgeographiclocationarepublishedinthePSASonelectiontotheSocietybutthereisnofulllistofcurrentmembersavailable.AFellows’Directorywillincludeyourfullname,postnominals,geographiclocationplusanemailaddressifcurrentlyontheSocietydatabase.Ifyoudonot want to belistedinthedirectorypleasecontactinfo@socantscot.orgassoonaspossible.WehopethataDirectorywillencourageFellowtoFellowcommunicationandstrengthentheFellowshiparoundtheglobe.

Research Library, National Museum of Scotland© National Museums Scotland

International news

The Second Annual Australian Fellows’ Dinner 2015JamesDonaldsonFSAScotisplanningasecondgatheringofAustralianFellows.

FollowingthehighlysuccessfulinauguralFellows’DinnerheldinMelbourneinFebruary2014,thetimehasnowarrivedtobeginmakingpreparationsforthe2015Dinner. Tofacilitatethebestchoiceofdate,citylocationandvenue,itwouldbemosthelpfulifAustralianFellows,whoareinterestedinattending,makecontactwiththeConvenor,DrJamesDonaldson,[email protected] to registertheirinterest.HewouldbepleasedtoansweranyquestionsconcerningtheDinner. Ifyouhavealreadybeencontact,buthaverecentlyalteredyoure-mailaddress,pleaseforwardyournewaddresstotheConvenor(andtheSociety)soyoucontinuetoreceiveuptodateinformation. ApartfromMelbourne,itispossiblethattheDinnermaybeheldelsewhere,dependinguponthegeographicallocationsofpotentialattendees.Itwasfeltbythosewhoattendedthe2014Dinner,thatadateinMarchorAprilmightbe more appropriate.

TheConvenorwouldwelcomeanyinputretheDinnersothatthebestpossiblearrangementscanbemadetoaccommodaterequirements.WewouldencouragetheattendanceofasmanyFellowsandtheirGuestsaspossible.”

Plans for a North American Meeting 2015/16 IanGreigBScFSAScot,hasofferedtoorganiseameetingforFellowsinTampa,Floridaduringthewinterof2015–2016ifthereissufficientinterestintheidea.ThiswouldbeanopportunityforFellowsinNorthAmericatomeetandsharetheirpassionforthehistoryandarchaeologyofScotlandorindeedthosefromfurtherafieldaspartofaholidaytrip.

Theproposedformatisaneveningreception,followedbyadayoflecturesfromexpertswithapostmeetingdinnerintheevening.ThefollowingdaycouldbeanoptionalsocialdaywithatourofthecityandvisitstootherattractionsintheCentralFloridaarea. TheprogrammewouldlooktocoverawiderangeofScottishhistory,fromprehistoriconwardswithafocusonScottish–NorthAmericanconnections.

Page 9: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

9

DIG

IT!2015

DISCOVER SCOTLAND’S STORIES

ExpertspeakerswillbedrawnfromthebodyoftheFellowship(especiallythoseresidentinCanadaandtheUnitedStates)withavideolinktoScottishbasedcontributors.WehopethatFellowsunabletotraveltoScotlandwillwelcometheopportunitytogathertogetherforthefirsttime. Toprogressplans,IaniskeentoestablishthelevelofinterestwithintheNorthAmericanFellowshipforsuchameeting.IftheSocietyhasyouremailaddressonrecord,youwillhavereceivedanemailearlierthissummer.Thankyoutothosewhoresponded.If,however,youhaveyettoregisterinterestpleasedosoby31 October 2014 by [email protected] and vina@socantscot.orgorbywritingtotheSociety.OnceIanhasestablishedthereisstrongenoughsupportfortheideahewillbeintouchdirectly.Inthemeantime,pleasesendanyenquiriestotheemailaddressesabove.

DIG IT! 2015 news

Withonlyafewmonthstogountilthelaunch,theDigIt!2015teamhavebeenworkinghardinordertoorganisetheupcomingyear-longcelebrationofScottisharchaeology. Partofthispreparationinvolvedhiring two new members of staff. ForourYouthEngagementOfficerposition,wehavebeenluckyenough

toborrowRebeccaBoydefromArchaeologyScotlandforafewdaysaweek.Herarrivalimprovesourabilitytoengagewithyoungpeopleandhelpotherstodothesame.JulianneMcGrawhasalsojoinedtheteamastheCommunicationsandAdministrationOfficerforDigIt!2015,whichmeansthatwecandedicateevenmoretimetopublicisingtheprojectandwiderScottisharchaeologicalactivities.Completelybychance,theteamhasnowbecomeoverrunwithCanadians!RebeccaisoriginallyfromAlbertaandJuliannemovedherefromOntariothreeyearsago. Wehavebeencollaboratingwithourmanypartners,ArchaeologyScotlandandofcourse,theSociety,teamingupforeventsandpromotingvariousactivities,suchastheWeavingTruthwithTrusttextilescreenunveilinginGovanandTheLivingLomondsBigDig2014.WearelookingforwardtotheupcomingNationalMuseumofScotlandGameMastersexhibition,theHighlandArchaeologyFestival,ScottishArchaeologyMonthandtheFestival

ofMuseums.TheSociety’s2015RhindLecturesandthe2015EAAConferencewillbothtieinwellwithDigIt!2015. OneofourbiggesttasksistheprojectlaunchinDecember.Asidefromkickingoffthecelebrations,thiseventwillgiveustheopportunitytorevealthefirstdigitalandhardcopyDigIt!2015programmes.Thehardcopieswillcontainusefulinformationandeventhighlights,whilethedigitalcopieswillbemorecomprehensiveandregularlyupdatedthroughouttheyear. Inordertogatherinformationandspreadtheword,theteamhasbeenoutandaboutacrossScotland.OnourrecenttriptoOrkney,forexample,weheldameet-upatasmallpubforFellowsandlocalarchaeologists,anditwasgreattospendafewhoursspeakingwitheveryone. HistoricScotlandhasprovidedfundingforDigIt!2015tosupportinterestinengagingwithyoungpeopleandadultlifelonglearners.Infact,thisisafocusfortheentiresectorsowearestartingtoconnectwithyoungpeoplethroughfuneventsandfestivals,andcollaboratingwithorganisationssuchtheScottishYouthHostellingAssociation,EducationScotlandandTheNationalTrustforScotland.Adultlifelonglearnersareimportanttoustoo.Weareworkingwithvariousuniversitiesandaimtodeveloponlineresourcessothatifsomeoneisinterestedinaspecifictopic,theycanstudyathomeorgooutandexploreontheirown‘learningjourney’. Intheend,alotofwhatDigIt!2015achieveswillbethankstotheeffortsofconnectedindividuals,suchastheSocietyFellows.Theteamcan’tbeeverywhereatonce,soweneedhelpfromFellowstogatherinformationaboutpotentialopportunities.Inadditiontobeingpartofevents,includingexcavationsandlocalheritageactivities,wewillpopupinunexpectedplaces,suchasfestivalsandtheatreperformances.Thiswillallowustoshareourkeymessage–archaeologyisforeveryoneandcontributessignificantlytoouridentity.IfFellowsarepartofanyorganisationsorcomeacrossanyopportunities,we’dbegratefuliftheycouldtipus off. Fellowscanstayinformedbysigninguptoourelectronicnewsletter.Themonthlynewslettercontainsup-to-dateinformationabouttheproject,ourpartnersandapeekintotheworldoftheScottisharchaeologicalcommunity.ThisisalsoagreatwaytospotpotentialvolunteeringopportunitiesoractivitiesforFellowsandfamilies.Justgotothewebsitewww.digit2015.com/get-involved to sign up. Ifyouhaveanyquestionsorwanttogetinvolved,pleasedonothesitatetocontactusat [email protected] orcall(0131)2474066.Welookforwardtohearingfromyou!

Dr Jeff Sanders and Julianne McGraw of the Dig It! team in Orkney with Fellow Dr Tom Rendall

9

Page 10: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

10

Publications‘Remember Now Thy Creator’Scottish Girls’ Samplers, 1700–1872Naomi E A Tarrant FSAScot

Hardback,232pp,fullcolourillustrationsISBN9781908332073Publicationdate15October2014Fellowsprice£25,rrp£30

WetoldyouaboutourforthcomingbookonScottishsamplersinthelastNewsletter,andwe’reveryexcitedtoannouncethatthebookwillbepublishedthisOctober!Packedwithhundredsofexquisitelydetailedimages,thisvolumeexploresgirls’educationandawealthofgenealogicalinformationthroughthesebeautifulworksofart. Youcanpre-orderthisbookfrom1OctoberviaBooksource:50CambuslangRoad,Cambuslang,GlasgowG328NBTel(0845)3700067,[email protected]

© Oxbow Books

Festschrift for Vincent Megaw Hon FSA Scot

TheancientCelticworldevokesdebate,discussion,romanticismandmythicism.Ontheonehanditrepresentsaspecialistareaofarchaeologicalinterest,ontheother,ithasawidegeneralappeal.Celtic Art in Europe: Making Connections isavolumeof37papersbringingtogetheratrulyinternationalgroupofpre-eminentspecialistsinthefieldofCelticartandCelticstudies.TheessaysareinhonourofVincentMegawHonFSAScotonhis80thbirthday. OxbowareofferingFellowsaspecialdiscountrateof£48(normalprice£60).Toorderyourcopy,visitwww.oxbowbooks.com orphone(01865)241249)[email protected].

Forthcoming books

Thefollowingbookswillbepublishedin2015.MoredetailsontheseandmanymoreforthcomingbookswillbeincludedinthenextNewsletter.

Scotland in Later Prehistoric EuropeFraserHunterFSAScotandIanRalstonFSAScot(editors)ChaptersbyIanArmit,BarryCunliffe,AndrewDunwell,MartinGoldberg,StratfordPHallidayScot,ColinHaselgrove,FraserHunter,FlemmingKaul,JVSMegaw&MRuthMegaw,Pierre-YvesMilcent,RachelPope,IanRalston,RichardTippingand EugèneWarmenbol

Portmahomack on Tarbat Ness: An Iron Age estate, Pictish monastery, Scots trading farm and medieval township in north-east ScotlandMartinCarverFSAScot,JustinGarner-LahireandCecilySpallFSAScot

Open access

FreeandopenaccesstoresearchhasalwaysbeenimportanttotheSociety.Asmostofyouwillknow,wehavebeenworkingwiththeArchaeologyDataServicesince2001toprovidefreeonlineaccesstooldervolumesoftheProceedings(newervolumesareaccessibleforFellowsbyusingausernameandpassword),Scottish Archaeological Internet Reports andourout-of-printbooks.

In2012theFinchReportstatedthatpubliclyfundedresearchshouldbeavailablefreelytothepublic.Sincethen,fundingbodiesliketheResearchCouncilUKandtheWellcomeTrusthaverequiredauthorstheyhavefundedtoworkwithpublisherstoofferanopenaccessversionoftheirpublications.Inresponse,theSocietyhascreatedanOpenAcessPolicyforourjournalsandbooks.AuthorswhowouldlikeacopyoftheSociety’sOpenAccessPolicyshouldcontacttheManagingEditor,ErinOsborne-Martin([email protected]). TheOpenAccessPolicywillbecontinuouslyupdatedtoreflectchangesinpolicyfromthegovernmentandfunders,andthenewestversionwillalwaysbeavailableonlineonceournewwebsiteislaunchedlaterthisyear.

Vincent visiting the Society office© Society of Antiquaries of Scotland

10

Page 11: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

11

As part of the commemorations of the 700th anniversary of the Battle of Bannockburn the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland is supporting a project to research and reconstruct the lost tomb of Robert the Bruce. The project involves partners from across the heritage sector, including the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland, Historic Scotland, National Museums Scotland, the Hunterian, the National Registers of Scotland, Fife Cultural Trust and the Abbotsford Trust.

AfterKingRobertIdiedin1329,hewasburiedinthechoirofDunfermlineAbbey.ContemporarysourcesrecordthathisgravewasthenmarkedbyamonumentcommissionedpriortohisdeathandimportedfromParis.Thismonumentwaslaterlost,probablyhavingbeendestroyedduringthedemolitionandquarryingofthemonasteryintheaftermathoftheReformation. Asiswellknown,duringthebuildingofthepresentparishchurchin1818,workmendiscoveredaskeleton,believedtobethatoftheking.WhetherornottheskeletonisactuallythatofBruce,oroneoftheotherkingsknowntohavebeenburiedinthechoir,isstillasubjectofdebate.However,otherexcavationsbetweenc1790and1820alsodiscoveredfragmentsofcarvedandgildedstone,variouslydescribedasmarbleoralabaster,whichwereidentifiedaspiecesofBruce’svanishedmonument.ThesepiecesarenowpreservedinthecollectionsofTheHunterian,NationalMuseumsScotland,andDunfermlineMuseum. Incontrasttotheskeleton,thefragmentshaveattractedrelativelylittleattentionoracademicstudy.Untilthisprojecttheyhadneverbeenbroughttogetherinonelocationforcomparison.Thefragmentsremainedlargelymute,andobviousquestionsremainedunanswered:whataretheypiecesof,andaretheyallfromthesamestructure?Whatisthestone?Canthepiecesbedated?CantheidentificationwiththetombofBrucebeconfirmed? Theprojectwassetuptoanswerthesequestions,utilisingtheparticularskillsandresourcesofthepartners.Inpartner-shipwiththethreemuseums,RCAHMSandHShavenowexaminedandrecordedthepiecesindetailwiththeaimofreconstructingtheformoftheoriginalstructure.Althoughthepieceswereallclearlyderivedfromagothicmonument,theirfragmentarynaturemeantthattheexactformofthiswasfarfromclear. IainFraser(RCAHMS)hasidentifiedtheoriginalformofthemonumentasfollowingthemodelofFrenchroyaltombsoftheearly14thcentury:anarcadedtombchestsurmountedbyaneffigyofthekingandacanopy,inblackandwhitemarble.AgenerousgrantfromtheSocietyofAntiquariesofScotlandhasallowedresearchvisitstoParistoexaminecomparablematerialattheFrenchroyalmausoleumofStDenis,andinthecollectionsoftheLouvre,andalsootherpiecesnowintheMetropolitanMuseum,NewYork.Usingthereconstructiondrawings,combinedwithdetailedphotographybySteveWallace(RCAHMS)and3-DdigitalscanningbyColinMuir(HS),AlasdairRawlinsonandCraigLoganoftheDigitalDesignStudio,GlasgowSchoolofArt,havecreatedathree-dimensionaldigitalmodelofthemonumentasitwouldoncehavelooked. AnalysisbyNationalMuseumsScotlandandHistoricScotlandhasconfirmedthestonetobeatruemarble,andtoretaintracesofgilding.Itishopedthatfurtheranalysiswillbeabletoidentifythesourceofthemarblemoreprecisely.

ExpertsattheLouvrehavesuggestedthatthestone,likethatoftheFrenchroyaltombs,ishighlylikelytohavebeenquarriedatCarrara,northernItaly. Withtheknownpiecesofthetombdispersedthroughthreedifferentcollections,itwashopedthattheprojectmightuncoveryetmore,unrecorded,fragments,possiblystillinprivatehands.Oneofthemostexcitingoutcomesoftheprojectwasthediscoveryofanadditionalpiece,hithertounrecognisedandundocumented,amongSirWalterScott’scollectionsofantiquitiesatAbbotsfordHouse.Thispiecewasalsoofcrucialimportanceinfittingandconfirmingtheaccuracyofthereconstruction.Theprojectiscurrentlyattemptingtolocateafurtherpiece,believedtohavebeendonatedtoamuseumintheUnitedStates. Thisresearch,imageryandmodelwillallowallfourcollectionstoreinterprettheirownfragmentsofthemonument,andtodisplaythemmorevisually,showinghowtheywouldhavefittedintotheintacttomb. Thedigitalmodel,togetherwithaselectionofthefragments,arethefocusofadisplay,The Lost Tomb of Robert the Bruce,inTheHunterian,Glasgow,whichwillrunfrom24June2014to4January2015.

Dr Iain Fraser FSA Scot

Interested in finding out more about the project?YoucanjoinDrIainFraseratourFellows’PrivateVieworattendadaylongcolloquium:Research colloquiumMonday 10 November 9.15 am – 4.30 pm HostedbyTheHunterian,UniversityofGlasgow.Theopportunitytoexplorethehistoricalbackground,reconstruction,scientificanalysis,andthewiderartisticcontextofthetomb.Forfulldetailsandtobookticketspleasevisithttp://conservation.historic-scotland.gov.uk/home/future-events/event-detail.htm?eventid=10818.

Research in action The tomb of Robert the Bruce

The 3D digital visualisation of Bruce’s tombLeft Detail of the canopy © Digital Design Studio

Page 12: Sasnewsletter sep2014 web (3)

12

USDollarpayments PaymentcanbetakeninUSdollars.Theratesapplicablearedetailedinthesubscriptionremindersandallowforbankandhandlingcharges.Pleasecheckyourreminderlettertoensureyoupaythe correct amount.ReceiptsReceiptswillonlybeissuedifastampedaddressedenvelopeisprovided.

Fellowship Cards PleasenotethesearenolongerissuedbytheSociety.

Support the Society

TheSociety’svisionistodevelopasacentreofexcellenceprovidinganindependentheritagehubofexpertiseandresourcestofacilitate,exchangeandpromoteresearchintoScotland’spast.

Supportfromyoucanhelpuscontinue:TochampiontheroleandvalueofresearchTodebateandinfluencepolicymakingToenhancepublicunderstandingofthepastTopromotediscussionandsharingofknowledge

How you can help

PayrollGiving PayrollGivingenablesyoutogivetotheSocietystraightfromyourgrosssalaryforimmediatetaxrelief,thuscostingyoulesstogivemore.Seewww.payrollgivingcentre.org.ukformoredetails,orcontacttheOffice.

Legacies EncouragingandfundingoriginalresearchisanimportantpartoftheSociety’smission.ByrememberingtheSocietyinyourWill,youcanhelpfundfutureresearchtodeepenunderstandingofScotland’spast.Formoreinformation contact Simon Gilmour or Vina Oberlander.

Contact us

Director Dr Simon Gilmour(0131)2474115,[email protected]

Generalenquiries Jacqueline Clabby(0131)2474133, [email protected](Mon-Wedonly)

ProjectManagerDigIt!2015 Dr Jeff Sanders (0131)2474138,[email protected]

Publicationsandsales Erin Osborne-Martin (0131)2474145,[email protected]

Subscriptionsandfinance Jan Paterson (0131)2474135,[email protected](Mon-Wedonly)

Fellowshipanddevelopment Vina Oberlander (0131)2474350,[email protected]

Visit us www.socantscot.orgFollow us Twitter @socantscotLike us Facebook /Society-of-Antiquaries-of-

Important information for FellowsFellowshipFellowsareencouragedtousethepostnominal‘FSAScot’.PleaserememberFellowsshouldnotusetheirdesignationinappropriately–forinstance,ifairingmattersofpersonalopinion in the press.

RecruitingNewFellows PleaseencouragecolleaguesandfriendswithaninterestinScotland’spasttojointheSociety.Applicationformsmaybedownloadedfromourwebsite,orobtainedfromtheOffice. Thedeadlinefor2014electionhasnowpassed.Applicationsfor2015electionarenowwelcome.Completedapplicationformsshouldreachtheofficeby1September2015.

Gift Aid FromtimetotimeHMRC requires ustoupdateourrecords.FellowspayingUKtaxareaskedtocompletetheenclosedGiftAidform.FulldetailsonGiftAidcanbefoundherehttp://www.socantscot.org/donations.asp?Menu. If you currentlypayIncomeTaxintheUK(includingonanydividendincome)theSocietycanrecoveranextra20pper£1onsubscriptionsordonations.PleasecontactJan Paterson [email protected] if you are unsure if you areeligible,orifyourcircumstanceschange.

SubscriptionsSubscriptions for 2014/2015 are due.Pleaseactpromptlyifyouhaveyettopay.FinalreminderletterswillgooutinMarch2015.Ifyouhaveanyqueriesregardingsub-scriptionspleasecontactJan [email protected](0131)2474135(Monday–Wednesday)whowillbehappytohelp.Subscription ratesOrdinaryFellow£60RetiredFellow£45FamilyFellow£30FamilyFellowsWheretwoOrdinaryFellowsresideatthesamelocation,onemaybecomeaFamilyFellowwhodoesnotreceiveacopyoftheProceedings.RetiredFellowsmusthavebeenanOrdinaryFellowfortenyearsandberetiredfromwork.

How to pay DirectDebit DirectDebit isthepreferredmethodofpaymentforsubscriptions.DirectDebitInstruction(DDI)formsareavailablefromourwebsiteortheOffice.IfyouhaveaUK-basedbankorbuildingsocietyaccount,pleasecompleteandsend to the Society,oneforeachindividualFellowship.StandingOrders Pleasenote,we cannot cancel existing Standing Orders for you.Pleasebevigilantandcheckyourbankrecordsandsubscriptionrates.CreditCardpaymentsYou can pay online through the Society’swebsite.PleasenoteweareexperiencingtechnicaldifficultieswiththeFellowsAccountarea.YoucanhoweverpaysecurelybyclickingontheDonations tab at the top righthandcornerofthehomepageandusingtheDonate buttonatthebottomofthepage.Ifyouhaveproblemspleasecontact Jacqueline Clabby at [email protected] oron+44(0)1312474133(Mon-Wed)forhelp.Cheques ChequesshouldbemadepayabletotheSocietyofAntiquariesofScotland.Pleaseincludeyourname,addressandcontactdetails.Pleasedonotsendcash.

Scotland/

Compilation and editing Society of Antiquaries of ScotlandDesign and layout Christina UnwinPublisher Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, National Museums Scotland, Chambers Street, Edinburgh EH1 1JFPrinter Alphagraphics . www.alphagraphics.co.uk

12