running head: academic success skills group 1 · 2018. 9. 9. · academic success skills group 2...

46
Running head: ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 1 Group Counseling Proposal: Academic Success Skills for At Risk High School Sophomores Sara Brame, Michael Muse, Jessie Roney, Sarah Oertel The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Upload: others

Post on 15-Feb-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Running head: ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 1

    Group Counseling Proposal: Academic Success Skills for At Risk High School Sophomores

    Sara Brame, Michael Muse, Jessie Roney, Sarah Oertel

    The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 2

    Group Counseling Proposal: Academic Success Skills for At Risk High School Sophomores

    This group, focused on promoting academic success, will consist of 8-10 diverse

    sophomores who failed at least two core classes during their freshman year. This group will

    focus on topics related to academic success, including individual learning styles, time

    management, study strategies, and coping with test taking anxiety.

    Rationale for Group/ Literature Review

    There is a growing amount of research that shows that academic achievement during

    ninth grade can be used as a predictor for potential dropouts. According to the work of Hickman,

    Bartholomew, Mathwig, and Heinrich (2008) “the first-semester GPA of ninth-grade students

    who dropped out was significantly lower than the first-semester GPA of ninth-grade students

    who graduated” (p. 12). They also found that “dropouts took significantly more core courses than

    did graduates during their ninth-grade year” (p. 12). Hickman et al. (2008) suggests the reason

    students who eventually drop out take more core courses their ninth-grade year could be due to

    the fact that they are trying to recover from previously missed credit, which puts them further

    behind their classmates and more at risk of dropping out (p. 12). While the Hickman et al. study

    was not exhaustive and only sampled 119 students in northwestern Arizona, there is support for

    their findings from other studies that involve cities on the East Coast. Neild, Balfanz, and Herzog

    (2007) found that “among students who sent their first serious distress signal in 9th grade, those

    who earned fewer than two credits or attended school less than 70 percent of the time had at least

    a 75 percent chance of dropping out of school” (p. 30). Neild, Balfanz, and Herzog (2007) used

    data from studies they conducted in Philadelphia, Indianapolis, and Boston to come to their

    conclusions. Using both of these studies provides a much larger sample size and underscores the

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 3

    importance of academic success during a student’s ninth-grade year in predicting whether a

    student will drop out of school.

    Ninth-grade academic success has been shown to be a predictor for which students could

    potentially drop out of school. Research also shows that students do not drop out immediately

    after ninth grade. Neild, Balfanz, and Herzog (2007) also found that “Most of these students did

    not drop out immediately but attempted 9th grade courses for another one or two years before

    finally giving up on school altogether” (p. 30). Hickman et al. (2008) were more specific stating

    “59 students who dropped out of school did so between their sophomore and junior year” (p. 6).

    These findings suggest that there is a window between a student’s ninth-grade year and the time

    the student drops out of school. During this window, there is an opportunity for school

    counselors to implement strategies to remediate students and prevent dropouts. Based on this

    information a student’s sophomore year is the ideal time to target potential dropouts and

    implement a remediation program.

    By targeting students during the sophomore year to implement a group counseling based

    remediation program, students will have the opportunity to get back on track before their junior

    year of high school. Bemak, Chung, and Siroskey-Sabdo (2005) initiated a school counseling

    group called Empowerment Groups for Academic Success (EGAS) in a midwest inner-city high

    school. This group intervention was more successful than remediation programs previously

    implemented for the students in the intervention program, as demonstrated by student feedback,

    school performance, and attendance rates. Additionally, the self-reported impact of the

    implementation of EGAS was more impactful for students than previous interventions. For

    example, one student reported that the most important thing learned in group was the ability to

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 4

    communicate, whereas another reported that her grades improved after the group had concluded.

    Previous failed interventions included detention, suspension, disciplinary warnings, counseling

    targeted to specific behaviors, linking to families, and behavior modification programs (p. 383).

    The EGAS approach was more successful due to its emphasis on interpersonal dynamics that

    allowed group members to engage in discussions about ways to succeed academically (Bemak et

    al., 2005).

    Using the EGAS approach allowed group members to establish their goals for school

    performance and academic success, as well as supporting group members throughout the group

    process. Group counseling is often beneficial for academic success groups, especially in schools

    with a high academic achievement gap. Bruce, Getch, and Ziomek-Daigle (2009) supported

    group counseling as a method for academic success interventions. Their study utilized a group

    counseling intervention approach designed to minimize the academic achievement gap in the

    English and math sections of the high school graduation test for African-American students at a

    rural high school in Georgia. Twelve out of fifteen eleventh-grade participants in the study

    received passing scores on all four sections of the end-of-year examination following the

    intervention. After the group counseling sessions concluded, 100% of participants received

    passing scores on the English and math sections of the test. The group counseling approach

    additionally allowed participants to provide feedback and data about school climate and teacher

    expectations, and led to the discovery that these participants seemed to have positive interactions

    with their school counselors, however “their general perception of teachers and administrators

    seemed slightly negative in regard to fairness and expectation” (p. 454).

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 5

    By working with students on academic skills, school counselors are able to use groups to

    increase academic achievement. Berger (2013) found that after a group on self efficacy and

    academic skills student achievement outcome goals moved in the positive direction. The results

    of the pre-and post- assessments showed that grade point average increased, behavior referrals

    decreased, and unexcused absences decreased for the students who participated in the group. The

    study revealed that by working with a diverse population of underachieving students during their

    early high school years, they were able to quickly show improvement. In a study assessing

    factors influencing high school dropout, Nield, Stoner-Eby, and Furstenberg (2008) found that

    failing a class during the ninth grade year was the largest predictor for a student leaving high

    school (p. 558). Through working with students during the early high school years, school

    counselors are able to increase student performance and prevent future dropout. For students that

    have participated in small group interventions, this increased academic performance can be

    long-term and sustain throughout high school (Kayler & Sherman, 2009).

    A student’s potential for success can also be affected by personal belief systems and other

    external factors. Counselors must help students build education as part of their value system.

    This can be accomplished through group counseling that focuses on students’ individual

    academic attributes and beliefs (Lemon & Watson, 2011). School counselors also have an

    integral role in establishing an inclusive school climate. An inviting school climate can help

    promote the value of education. In this case, school climate encompasses the way in which

    students perceive their ability to be accepted by teachers, staff members, and peers (Bruce et al.,

    2009). Small group counseling can help these students develop a sense of inclusiveness and a

    connection to the larger school community. This improved attitude towards school climate and

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 6

    being included can inspire students to feel empowered to make improvements in their academics

    (Cook & Kaffenberger, 2003). Students report that school counselors can help them succeed by

    focusing on individual learning styles and making a greater personal connection with their

    students (Berger, 2013).

    Multicultural and Social Justice Considerations

    When addressing student success and academic achievement in school, it is important to

    consider multicultural and social justice implications. While gender, socioeconomic status, and

    race present many gaps in student performance and achievement, Nield, Stoner-Eby, and

    Furstenberg (2008) reveal the importance of a student’s successful transition to high school. All

    students make the transition from middle school to high school, and they all need a varying level

    of support. During the early years, school counselors can play a key role in prevention by

    running groups for underachieving students. Each student has a unique reason for not living up to

    their potential, and it is the responsibility of the group counselor to address these differences in a

    positive manner during the group. Rowell (2013) discusses strategies to help students increase

    their academic motivation, and he emphasizes the importance a student’s level of self-efficacy.

    Successful students know they are capable, and group counseling is a positive way to show each

    student his or her strength and ability.

    SMART Goals

    Students will explore their unique learning style, time management skills, study strategies

    and test-taking anxiety coping skills to assist them in achieving academic success by the end of

    the first semester. Over the course of 6 weeks, students should demonstrate an increase in their

    confidence towards academic success as well as have an understanding of basic skills towards

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 7

    improving academic performance. This will be measured through a pre- and post- assessment at

    the beginning and end of the group counseling sessions. Students will be asked to rate on a scale

    of always to never questions relating current academic success strategies. (see Appendix C).

    After learning these strategies and skills during each fifty minute weekly session, every student

    should be able to recognize their opportunities for growth in the four domains: learning styles,

    time management skills, study skills, and test-taking anxiety coping skills. Success of the

    academic success group will be demonstrated through improvement of GPA and a passing grade

    in all of their core classes.

    Objectives

    ASCA Standards

    1.5 Belief in using their abilities to their fullest to achieve high-quality results and

    outcomes.

    2.LS.3 Use time-management, organizational, and study skills

    2.SMS.1 Demonstrate ability to assume responsibility

    2.SMS.2 Demonstrate self-discipline and self-control

    2.SMS.5 Demonstrate perseverance to achieve long- and short-term goals

    2.SMS.8 Demonstrate the ability to balance school, home and community activities.

    2.SMS.10 Demonstrate ability to manage transitions and ability to adapt to changing

    situations and responsibilities

    2.SS.3 Create relationships with adults that support success

    NCGES Student Standards

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 8

    I.SE.3.2 Use communication strategies that emphasize clarity and precision to achieve

    desired outcomes.

    P.C.1.1 Understand how to make adjustments to strategies that are not effective in

    making decisions or solving problems.

    P.C.1.2 Analyze strategies you have used in the past to determine the most appropriate

    strategies for solving a current academic problem

    P.C.2.2 Use time-management and task-management skills to complete academic work of

    high quality in a timely manner.

    P.CR.4.1 Compare the effects of personal and academic decisions upon career goals and

    life expectations.

    Techniques

    The proposed group lesson plans will apply techniques from Cognitive Behavioral

    Therapy. According to Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT), a person’s behavior is influenced

    by some preceding event or cognition and is sustained by the consequences that particular

    behavior elicits. The following lesson plans are designed with the intention of modifying

    pre-existing behaviors related to academic success. The lesson plans apply CBT by identifying

    the cognitions students have regarding these particular behaviors and by teaching new techniques

    that create positive consequences.

    Logistics

    It is the responsibility of the school counselor to collaborate with teachers, administrators,

    and staff to determine practical and productive ways to run groups. This plan assumes that the

    school counselor will be able to pull eight to ten students out of class for fifty minute sessions.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 9

    The sessions will occur six times throughout the first semester of the school year. The school

    counselor will screen all sophomore students that failed at least two core courses during their

    freshman year to determine who shall be the members of the group. Core courses for high school

    students are considered to be English, math, science, and history. The group will consist of

    students who come from various cultural backgrounds, and it will include both male and female

    students. The school counselor will take precaution during the screening process to ensure the

    members of the group will be support one another, maintain confidentiality, and work to improve

    their current academic habits. Students in the group will vary in multiple ways, but through this

    group they will learn skills and find common ground.

    Projected Behavioral Outcomes

    The school counselor will evaluate the behavioral outcome of the group using the

    process, perception, and outcome data from the group. Each group member will take a pretest

    and posttest to assess their academic skills at the beginning of the group and at the end. The

    school counselor will also assess the students’ skills during and at the end of each lesson of the

    group session. Each lesson will focus on a certain academic skill, so this will provide the school

    counselor the ability to assess specific behaviors as well as the overall academic improvement.

    The skills include learning styles, time management, study strategies, and test taking skills. The

    school counselor will check for progress at the end of each session. Upon successful completion

    of this group, the group members should be able to apply the knowledge they have gained in

    each of these skills to their academics. By applying these skills, the students’ grades should

    improve and reduce the chances that the students’ will drop out.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 10

    Appendix A

    ASCA National Model School Counseling Program SMART Goals Worksheet  Specific Issue What is the specific issue based on our school’s data?

    Student dropout rates

    Attainable What outcome would stretch us but is still attainable?

    Group members will pass all core courses during the first semester of sophomore year.

    Time Bound When will our goal be accomplished?

    By the second semester of sophomore year.

    Measurable How will we measure the effectiveness of our interventions?

    Pre- and post- assessments of academic success skills Passing grade in all courses

    Results-Oriented Is the goal reported in results-oriented data (process, perception and outcome)?

    Perception data: Pre- and post- assessment for group Outcome data: Students’ grades for 1st semester of sophomore year

     School: ___________________________________________Year: 2016-2017  

    School Counselor(s): Sara Brame, Michael Muse, Jessie Roney, Sarah Oertel  

    Based on the information above, write a single goal statement sentence 

    By the beginning of the second semester of their Sophomore year, all group members will pass 

    all of their core classes.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 11

    Appendix B

    Lesson Plan Template #1

    School Counselor: Jessie, Michael, Sara, Sarah Date: Week 1

    Activity: Introduction to Academic Success Group

    Grade(s): 10th

    ASCA and NCGES Student Standards (Domain/Standard/Competencies):

    ASCA

    2.SMS.5 Demonstrate perseverance to achieve long- and short-term goals

    2.SS.3 Create relationships with adults that support success

    NCGES

    I.SE.3.2 Use communication strategies that emphasize clarity and precision to achieve desired

    outcomes.

    P.C.1.1 Understand how to make adjustments to strategies that are not effective in making

    decisions or solving problems.

    Learning Objective(s):

    1. Identify goals of group

    2. Establish Group Norms

    3. Students begin building relationships with other group members

    Materials:

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 12

    Pencil, Paper, Markers, Whiteboard, Building Skills for Academic Success Preassessment, “I am

    Poem" handout

    Procedure:

    1. Group will start off with introduction of facilitators and group members and purpose of group

    (2 mins)

    ● This group is designed to help you improve your academic skills.

    2. Facilitators lead discussion of Confidentiality and Informed Consent and ensure that group

    members understand their rights and responsibilities (5 mins)

    ● What does confidentiality mean to you?

    ● How are we going to keep confidentiality in this group?

    ● What should be the consequences of breaking confidentiality?

    3. Group discussion of group norms (5-10 mins)

    ● What would you like the group to look like?

    ● How are we going to handle disagreements in group?

    ● How are we going to support each other?

    4. Activity - I am poem (20 - 25 mins)

    ● Anyone want to share their poem? (leader may share to engage group)

    ● Any thoughts about your poem?

    ● What did you learn about someone else?

    5. Pre-assessment - Building Skills for Academic Success Inventory and discussion - (5-10 mins)

    ● How do you feel about the results?

    ● Did you learn anything new today?

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 13

    ● Which topic interests you the most from the questionnaire?

    Plan for Evaluation: How will each of the following be collected?

    Process Data:

    8-10 students meet for 50 mins

    I am Poem

    Building Skills for Academic Success Preassessment

    Perception Data:

    Building Skills for Academic Success Preassessment

    Outcome Data:

    Agreed upon group norms

    Follow Up:

    Wrap up session by discussing next sessions focus on learning styles and finding group members

    individual learning styles.

    Revisit group norms to start next session.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 14

    Lesson Plan Template #2

    School Counselor: Jessie, Michael, Sara, Sarah Date: Week 2

    Activity: Learning Styles

    Grade(s): 10th

    ASCA and NCGES Student Standards (Domain/Standard/Competencies):

    ASCA

    1.5 Belief in using their abilities to their fullest to achieve high-quality results and outcomes.

    2.SMS.1 Demonstrate ability to assume responsibility

    NCGES

    P.C.1.1 Understand how to make adjustments to strategies that are not effective in making

    decisions or solving problems.

    Learning Objective(s):

    1. Students identify their preferred learning style

    2. Students learn to apply their learning to improve academic performance

    Materials:

    Pencil, Paper, Learning styles handouts - see appendix C, calculator

    Procedure:

    1. Opening and review of confidentiality and group norms. (5 mins)

    ● Do you remember about confidentiality in our group?

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 15

    ● What were some of our agreed upon norms from last week?

    ● How is everyone doing today?

    2. Introduction of learning styles - group members read handout about different learning styles

    and discuss what we have learned. (10 mins)

    ● What learning style do you think you are?

    ● Why do you think you are that learning style?

    ● How can this information help you with your school work?

    3. Group members complete learning styles inventory and determine their dominant learning

    style. (10 mins)

    4. Discuss information learned from learning styles inventory and how group members can apply

    new information to academics. (15 mins)

    ● Was your learning style different than you expected?

    ● What are some things you can do during class to better meet your learning style?

    ● Give me an example of how you are going to apply this knowledge?

    ● Is this helpful information?

    ● What might you do differently now?

    5. Reflect on session (10 mins)

    ● How are you feeling about the group after two sessions?

    ● Has this session been helpful?

    ● How are you going to use this information?

    ● Any questions on group counseling so far?

    ● What are you most looking forward to this week?

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 16

    Plan for Evaluation: How will each of the following be collected?

    Process Data: 8-10 Students completing learning styles inventory and discussing results

    Perception Data:Student’s preferred learning style and ways to apply that style to an

    educational setting

    Outcome Data: Student’s quarter and semester grade

    Student’s GPA

    Follow Up: Ask students to try and incorporate their learning styles into their academic

    behaviors for the next week and check in to start the next session.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 17

    Lesson Plan Template #3

    School Counselor: Jessie, Michael, Sara, Sarah Date: Week 3

    Activity: Time-Management Skills

    Grade(s): 10th

    ASCA and NCGES Student Standards (Domain/Standard/Competencies):

    ASCA

    2.SMS.8 Demonstrate the ability to balance school, home and community activities.

    NCGES

    P.C.2.2 Use time-management and task-management skills to complete academic work of high

    quality in a timely manner

    Learning Objective(s):

    1. Develop skills that enhance planning, studying, communication and critical thinking.

    2. Students learn strategies to manage time effectively for a successful school-work-life balance.

    3. Establish connections for support in time management processes.

    Materials:

    Paper, pencil, Time Management box worksheet, Time Management Self Assessment worksheet

    - see Appendix C

    Procedure:

    1. Opening and review of confidentiality and group norms. (5 mins)

    ● What do you remember about confidentiality in our group?

    ● How are you feeling this week?

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 18

    2. Assess current strategies (10 mins)

    ● Talk about a time that you finished a project before it was due.

    ● How did you feel after accomplishing that goal?

    ● What do you do now that allows you to finish work on time?

    ● What are some barriers that prevent you from finishing work on time?

    ● What other things require you to be conscious of how you use time?

    3. Complete the Eisenhower Time Management Activity Box (10 mins)

    4. Discuss thoughts about completing the box and steps to take in the future (15 mins)

    ● What was surprising to you when you completed the box?

    ● What do you normally prioritize that is actually not urgent?

    ● What can you do to make sure all urgent tasks are completed on time?

    5. Reflect on session ( 10 mins)

    ● What will be different after learning these skills?

    ● On a scale of 0 to 10 with 0 being the worst and 10 the best, how do you feel about your

    time management skills right now.

    ● When you successfully manage your time, what positive outcomes do you experience?

    Plan for Evaluation: How will each of the following be collected?

    Process Data:8-10 students meet for 50 minutes

    Eisenhower Time Management box

    Time Management Self Assessment

    Perception Data:Time Management Self Assessment

    Outcome Data:Student’s quarter and semester grade

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 19

    Student’s GPA

    Follow Up: Ask students to use the Time Management box to prioritize their school work for the

    next week and check in next week to get feedback. Additionally follow up after the group

    sessions have ceased with the Time Management Self Assessment worksheet.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 20

    Lesson Plan Template #4

    School Counselor: Jessie, Michael, Sara, Sarah Date: Week 4

    Activity: Study Strategies

    Grade(s): 10th

    ASCA and NCGES Student Standards (Domain/Standard/Competencies):

    ASCA Standards

    2.LS.3 Use time-management, organizational, and study skills

    2.SMS.2 Demonstrate self-discipline and self-control

    NCGES Student Standards

    P.C.2.2 Use time-management and task-management skills to complete academic work of

    high quality in a timely manner.

    Learning Objective(s):

    1. Students will learn how to use Cornell Notes.

    2. Students will learn a strategy to critical reading.

    3. Students will learn a strategy to study for tests.

    Materials:

    Pencil

    Lined Paper

    3 R Handouts (See Appendix C for a copy of the handouts)

    SQ3R Handout (See Appendix C for a copy of the handouts)

    Individual Students will need to bring the textbook for one of their classes

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 21

    Procedure:

    1. Introduction: Producing Positive Self Talk(10 minutes)

    a. Students are given stems written on notecards with “Negative Self Talk”

    statements, and they reframe using a positive statement they will tell

    themselves.

    b. “Negative Self Talk” Stems

    i. “This is too hard”

    ii. “I can’t make this any better”

    iii. “I give up”

    iv. “I’m not good at this”

    v. “I just can’t do it”

    vi. “I will never get it”

    vii. “It’s good enough”

    viii. “My plan didn’t work”

    2. Activity 1: Cornell Notes (10 minutes)

    a. Group leader discusses the to taking “Cornell Notes.”

    b. Group discusses benefits for using this strategy when taking notes in class.

    c. Students take out 4 blank sheets of paper and fold them, so they can use

    these papers in class to take Cornell Notes.

    3. Activity 2: 3 R Strategy for Reading (10 minutes)

    a. Group leader reviews the “3 R’s for Academic Survival” with the group.

    b. Group discusses benefits for using this strategy when reading textbooks.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 22

    c. Students take out textbook for current classes, and they turn to the current

    chapter they are reading.

    d. Students read through a paragraph and practice describing what is in the

    paragraph.

    4. Activity 3: SQ3R Method to studying (15 minutes)

    a. Group leader reviews the “SQ3R Method for Thorough Study” with the

    group.

    b. Group discusses benefits for using this strategy when studying for exams.

    c. Group discusses time needed to thoroughly study for an exam.

    i. What are the results if this method is used for studying?

    5. Closure/ Process: Session Summary and Discussion (5 minutes)

    a. Name a time during the next two weeks you will use the 3 strategies we

    learned today.

    b. Rate how effective these strategies will be in helping to prepare for an

    exam on a scale from one to ten. One means ineffective. Ten means very

    effective.

    i. How were you able to get to this rating?

    Plan for Evaluation: How will each of the following be collected?

    Process Data: 8-10 students for 50 minutes

    Cornell Notes, 3 R’s Strategy, SQ3R Method handouts

    Perception Data: Student positive self talk discussion

    Cornell Notes, 3 R’s Strategy, SQ3R Method discussion

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 23

    Students response to rating effectiveness of strategies

    Outcome Data: GPA and Final Quarter, Semester, Year Grades are improved because students

    are able to use study strategies to score higher on assessments.

    Follow Up: Group leader and students will monitor their use of the strategies and scores on

    upcoming exams.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 24

    Lesson Plan Template #5

    School Counselor: Jessie, Michael, Sara, Sarah Date: Week 5

    Activity: Test-Taking Anxiety

    Grade(s): 10th

    ASCA and NCGES Student Standards (Domain/Standard/Competencies):

    ASCA

    1.5 Belief in using their abilities to their fullest to achieve high-quality results and outcomes.

    NCGES Student Standards

    P.C.1.2 Analyze strategies you have used in the past to determine the most appropriate strategies

    for solving a current academic problem

    Learning Objective(s):

    1. Students will reflect on past experiences with test anxiety and discuss previous coping

    mechanisms.

    2. Students will learn to identify physical and mental symptoms of test taking anxiety.

    3. Students will engage in an activity to learn skills to cope with physical and mental symptoms

    of test taking anxiety.

    Materials: Pencils, paper, index cards, Test-Anxiety Self Assessment worksheet, “What Causes

    Your Test Anxiety?” handout, and “Test Anxiety: Causes and Eliminators” handout (see

    Appendix C for a copy of this worksheet and handouts)

    Procedure:

    I. Introduction: (~10 minutes)

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 25

    A. Brief confidentiality review

    B. Discussion: Talk about a time when you were worried about a test. How

    did you handle it? What was the outcome?

    II. Activity #1: Test Anxiety Self-Assessment (~15 minutes)

    A. Group leader hands out assessment and explains directions.

    B. Students complete assessment independently.

    C. Group leader passes out test anxiety handouts for students to keep.

    Students can read over handouts as they finish their assessment.

    D. Group reconvenes and discusses test anxiety symptoms and differences in

    physical and mental symptoms.

    1. Discussion questions (cover as many as time allows): Have you

    ever experienced any of the listed symptoms in response to a test?

    Did you realize at the time that you were experiencing test anxiety

    symptoms? Do you have more physical or mental symptoms? Do

    any of the causes of test anxiety on the handouts fit you?

    III. Activity #2: Test Anxiety Coping Strategies (~15 minutes)

    A. Deep Breathing

    1. Students will engage in deep breathing for 5 minutes. Group leader

    will instruct students through breaths and releases.

    B. Note to Self Activity

    1. Students will be given an index card to write a positive message to

    themselves to read right before they take their end-of-course tests.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 26

    2. Group leader will demonstrate an appropriate message to write on

    the note cards.

    3. Students will share the messages they wrote.

    IV. Reflection on Group Session (~10 minutes)

    A. How did you feel about today’s activities?

    B. How can you use the coping activities when you feel anxious in a real test

    setting?

    C. How do you feel about next week being the final group session?

    Plan for Evaluation: How will each of the following be collected?

    Process Data:

    8-10 students who have failed at least two core classes will meet for 50 minutes

    Perception Data:

    Test Anxiety Self-Assessment results

    Outcome Data:

    Students’ test scores for rest of semester and beyond, students’ GPAs (this data will be available

    after the group has finished its last session).

    Follow Up:

    Group leaders and students will monitor students’ test scores. Individual counseling sessions

    regarding test taking anxiety can be scheduled, particularly leading up to EOCs.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 27

    Lesson Plan Template #6

    School Counselor: Jessie, Michael, Sara, Sarah Date: Week 6

    Activity: Conclusion/ Termination of Academic Success Skills Group

    Grade(s): 10th

    ASCA and NCGES Student Standards (Domain/Standard/Competencies):

    ASCA Standards

    2.SMS.5 Demonstrate perseverance to achieve long- and short-term goals

    2.SMS.10 Demonstrate ability to manage transitions and ability to adapt to changing

    situations and responsibilities

    NCGES Student Standards

    P.C.1.2 Analyze strategies you have used in the past to determine the most appropriate

    strategies for solving a current academic problem

    P.CR.4.1 Compare the effects of personal and academic decisions upon career goals and

    life expectations.

    Learning Objective(s):

    1.Students will be able to discuss their growth during the quarter.

    2. Students will be able to identify their own strengths and the strengths of other group members.

    3. Students will know how to implement the strategies learned in group during the upcoming

    quarter.

    Materials:

    Pencils/Pens

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 28

    File Folders

    Paperclips

    Copies of Post Test (See Appendix C for a copy of the handouts)

    Procedure:

    1. Warm Up: Discussion of what went right and wrong for the semester. (10 minutes)

    a. Group leader asks group members to discuss times this quarter they made choices

    that helped them learn material and achieve goals.

    i. What helped them make this choice?

    b. Group leader asks group members to discuss times this quarter they made choices

    that were not helpful in achieving goal.

    i. What helped them make this choice?

    2. Activity 1: Celebration of student accomplishments. (15 minutes)

    a. Each student shares an accomplishment they made during this quarter

    b. Group claps for student

    c. Other group members are able to ask questions or make supportive comments

    3. Activity 2: File Folder Motivators (15 minutes)

    a. Group leader prepares File Folders by writing the name of each student on one

    File Folder.

    b. Students walk around and write “comments” for other students on the inside of

    the File Folders.

    c. “Comments”

    i. Write one strength that you see in this person.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 29

    ii. Write one time this individual was successful.

    iii. Write one time this individual said or did something that motivated you.

    d. Group leader paperclips the File Folders shut.

    e. Group leader explains to students that they should keep these folders closed until

    the following quarter. During the next quarter, if there is a time a student is

    feeling unmotivated, they can open up folder and remember all the things they

    learned and practiced during group.

    4. Closure: Post Assessment and Discussion (10 minutes)

    a. Students will complete the Post Assessment and discuss their responses to the

    open ended questions.

    Plan for Evaluation: Post Test and Discussion

    Process Data:8-10 students for 50 minutes

    Perception Data: File Folder Motivation, Post Assessment

    Outcome Data:Final Semester and School Year Report Card, Final Semester and School Year

    GPA

    Follow Up: Student’s quarter, semester, yearly grades will be monitored by counselor.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 30

    Appendix C

    Group Counseling Informed Consent Form

    I, _____________________________, agree to adhere to the following norms and expectations

    of this group:

    ● I will not discuss anything shared in group with others outside of group.

    ● I will strive to be on time to each session.

    ● I will be respectful of others’ thoughts, emotions, and behavior.

    It is essential that members know that whatever they say or how they act in group remains in the

    group and that members will not discuss these things with anyone outside the group. I understand

    that this is the best way to create a safe and inclusive space and where members can trust one

    another. I understand that the co-facilitators will break confidentiality under the following

    circumstances:

    ● Indications of harm to self or others

    ● Awareness of harm being done to child, elder, or a person with a disability

    In signing this consent form, I acknowledge that the co-facilitators have provided the opportunity

    for group members to discuss and ask questions about the importance of confidentiality and

    expectations of the group.

    Student Signature________________________________ Date__________________

    Leader Signature_________________________________ Date__________________

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 31

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 32

    3 R's for Academic Survival

    Here is a lean and wiry system containing all the essential techniques for mastering textbook assignments. This is

    an "exam passer".

    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    R1 READ. Read the chapter paragraph by paragraph. Read and re-read until you can answer

    the question: "What did the author say in this paragraph?"

    R2 RECORD. Once you are able to describe what is in the paragraph, you will want to retain

    that learning by underlining, making notes in the margin, or making notes in your

    notebook.

    R3 RECITE. Cover up your notes or printed page and recite aloud. Remember! If you can't

    say it now, you won't be able to say it tomorrow in class, nor write it in a week on an exam;

    so while you still have a chance, try and try again, until you can say it.

    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 33

    SQ3R Method for Thorough Study

    Step 1: SURVEY - Look over material critically. Skim through the book and read topical and

    subtopical headings and sentences. Read the summaries at the end of chapters and books. Try to

    anticipate what the author is going to say.

    WRITE these notes on paper, in sequence; then look over the jottings to get an overall idea or

    picture. This will enable you to see where you are going.

    Step 2: QUESTIONS - Instead of reading paragraph headings such as "Basic Concepts of

    Reading," change to read, "What are the Basic Concepts of Reading?" These questions will

    become "hooks" on which to hang the reading material.

    WRITE these questions out; look over the questions to see the emphasis and direction; then attempt to give plausible

    answers before further reading.

    Step 3: READ - Read with smoothness and alertness to answer the questions. Use all the

    techniques and principles demonstrated in class.

    WRITE notes, in your own words, under each question. Take a minimum number of notes-use these notes as a

    skeleton.

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 34

    Step 4: RECALL** - Without looking at your book or notes, mentally visualize and

    sketch, in your own words, the high points of the material immediately upon completing the

    reading.

    a. This forces you to check understanding.

    b. This channels the material into a natural and usable form.

    c. This points up what you do not understand.

    d. This forces you to think.

    Step 5: REVIEW - Look at your questions, answers, notes and book to see how well you did

    recall. Observe carefully the points stated incorrectly or omitted. Fix carefully in mind the

    logical sequence of the entire idea, concepts, or problem. Finish up with a mental picture of the

    WHOLE.

    **Note: More time should be spent on recall than on reading.

    Adapted from F.P. Robinson. Effective Study. New York:Harper and Bros. 1946. Chapter II.

    ÓAcademic Skills Center, Dartmouth College 2001

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 35

    Pre/Post-Test for Building Skills for Academic Success Small Group

    Please answer the following questions:

    Always Often Sometimes Rarely Never

    I feel prepared before I

    take a test.

    I use my learning style to

    inform my study habits.

    I feel comfortable taking

    notes in class.

    I am satisfied with my

    grades on tests.

    I utilize academic

    resources at my school.

    I feel comfortable asking

    for assistance with

    homework.

    I feel stressed when taking

    a test.

    I effectively use my time.

    I am satisfied with my

    grades on my report cards.

    (Pre-survey) What would you like to learn from this group?

    (Post-survey) What would you change about this group?

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 36

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 37

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 38

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 39

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 40

    TEST ANXIETY SELF-ASSESSMENT

    Check the response that seems most characteristic of you.

    Never Sometimes Usually

    1. Have trouble sleeping the night before a test. ___ ___ ___ 2. Before a test, I get a headache. ___ ___ ___ 3. I lose my appetite before a test. ___ ___ ___ 4. Because of panic, I have cut class on a test day. ___ ___ ___ 5. My heart pounds just before or during a test. ___ ___ ___ 6. During a test, my palms sweat. ___ ___ ___ 7. During a test, I have become nauseated and had ___ ___ ___ to leave the classroom. 8. I have had pains in my neck, back, or legs during ___ ___ ___ a test. 9. I feel nervous and jittery when I am taking a test. ___ ___ ___ 10. During a test, my chest feels tight and I have ___ ___ ___ trouble remembering. 11. I make careless errors on tests. ___ ___ ___ 12. My mind goes blank during tests. ___ ___ ___ 13. I worry when other students are finished ___ ___ ___ before I am. 14. I feel pushed for time when I am taking a test. ___ ___ ___ 15. I worry that I am doing poorly on a test and ___ ___ ___ that everyone else is doing well. 16. When I am taking a test, I think about my ___ ___ ___ past failures. 17. During a test, I feel as if I studied all the ___ ___ ___ wrong things. 18. I can‘t think clearly during tests. ___ ___ ___ 19. I have a hard time understanding and ___ ___ ___ remembering directions when I am taking a test. 20. After a test, I remember answers to questions ___ ___ ___ I either left blank or answered incorrectly. Questions 1-10 on the self-assessment refer to physical symptoms of test anxiety. Questions 11- 20 refer to mental symptoms. If you checked “sometimes“ or “usually” ten or more times, you may have some test anxiety. Test anxiety is a learned response; and because you learned it, you can unlearn it.

    Q:shared/Debbie/studyskillsbooklet Adapted from: https://www.fredonia.edu/counseling/pdf/test%20anxiety.pdf

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 41

    WHAT CAUSES YOUR TEST ANXIETY?

    If you are like most test-anxious students, your anxiety results from several common causes: 1. Being afraid that you won‘t live up to the expectations of important people in your life; worrying that you will lose the affection of people you care about if you don‘t succeed; 2. Believing grades are an estimation of your personal worth; 3. Placing too much emphasis on a single test; 4. Giving in to guilt feelings or anxiety as a result of inadequate preparation for tests; 5. Feeling helpless, believing that you have no control over your performance or grades. Expectations. Many students‘ perceptions of what their parents or important others expect are inaccurate. If you worry that you will alienate people you care about unless you do well in college, you may become fearful and anxious that you will disappoint them or make them angry. If you believe that you can‘t live up to the expectations of others, tests may make you especially anxious. Grades and Self-Esteem. A grade of D, F, or even C for some students translates into “I‘m stupid“ or “I‘m not college material.“ These feelings may lead to a loss of self-esteem and more anxiety. Students who equate test grades with self-worth are assigning more importance to grades than they deserve. One real value of testing is that it gives you an opportunity to find out what information you understand well enough to associate with material that you will learn later. Before your next exam, you can give this material a quick review. Mistakes on a test pinpoint areas that you need to study more thoroughly for the next exam. Feelings of Helplessness. If you have an external locus of control, you may not see the connection between study and grades. You may become anxious because you cannot predict the outcome of a test. Even if your locus of control is internal, you may feel temporarily helpless in a testing situation when you know you have not studied enough. Feeling guilty for not meeting your responsibilities may cause you to experience test anxiety. Once you have identified the cause of your test anxiety, you can take steps eliminate it. The chart on the following page shows you how to start.

    Q:shared/Debbie/studyskillsbooklet Adapted from: https://www.fredonia.edu/counseling/pdf/test%20anxiety.pdf

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 42

    Test Anxiety: Causes and Eliminators

    Causes Eliminators

    1. Trying to meet other people‘s expectations

    Decide whether living up to these expectations is something you want to do for yourself. Set your own goals and live up to your own expectations.

    2. Fearing loss of affection Understand that people like you and value your presence in their lives for many reasons, none of which is the grade you made on a test.

    3. Letting grades determine your self-worth

    Realize that a grade is only an approximate measure of your performance. Grades have nothing to do with you as a person but are a helpful guide to what you need to review.

    4. Placing excessive emphasis on a single test

    Your semester grade may include, in addition to tests, quizzes, homework, papers, presentations, lab reports, and class participation. Keep up with the material as if you must take a major test every week to demonstrate what you are learning and how to apply information.

    5. Giving in to guilt or anxiety due to lack of preparation

    College requires a commitment of time and money. If you are truly well prepared, you will “forgive” yourself for a few mistakes due to stress or anxiety. If you do feel guilty, it may be because you have not really done your best to make school a priority and focus in your life.

    6. Underpreparing and “going blank“

    The purpose of tests and exams is: (1) to evaluate your retention of course material and (2) to apply the information to demonstrate understanding or to solve new problems. Failing to properly prepare and doing poorly on the exam becomes a self-perpetuating cycle of low effort leading to low grades.

    7. Feeling helpless, with no control over what happens

    Take charge by developing an internal locus of control. Improve your study habits. Prepare for your next test, starting NOW. Observe the connection between the amount and quality of your studying and the grade you earn.

    Q:shared/Debbie/studyskillsbooklet Adapted from: https://www.fredonia.edu/counseling/pdf/test%20anxiety.pdf

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 43

    References

    Bemak, F., Chung, R. C., & Siroskey-Sabdo, L. (2005). Empowerment groups for academic

    success: An innovative approach to prevent high school failure for at-risk, urban african.

    Professional School Counseling, 8(5), 377-389. Retrieved from

    http://libproxy.lib.unc.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/213334456?acc

    ountid=14244

    Berger, C. (2013). Bring out the brilliance: A counseling intervention for underachieving

    students. Professional School Counseling, 17(1), 86-96. Retrieved from

    http://libproxy.lib.unc.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/1558312662?ac

    countid=14244

    Bruce, A. M., Getch, Y. Q., & Ziomek-Daigle, J. (2009). Closing the gap: A group

    counseling approach to improve test performance of african-american students.

    Professional School Counseling, 12(6), 450-457. Retrieved from

    http://libproxy.lib.unc.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/213270636?acc

    ountid=14244

    Building skills for academic success small group. (2013, January 11). In Loyola Academy.

    Retrieved July 7, 2016, from http://loyolacademyramblers.weebly.com/forms.html

    Cook, J. B. & Kaffenberger, C. J. (2003). Solution shop: A solution-focused counseling and

    study skills program for middle school. Professional School Counseling, 7(2), 116-123.

    Retrieved from

    http://libproxy.lib.unc.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/213262660?acc

    ountid=14244

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 44

    Fink, L. S. (n.d.). Writing an "I am" Poem. In Read Write Think. [Handout]. Retrieved from

    http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/lesson_images/lesson391/I-am-poem.pdf

    Fleet, J. & Reaume, D. (1994). Power over time : student success with time management.

    [Handout]. Harcourt Brace Canada, Toronto. Retrieved from

    http://people.okanagan.bc.ca/ddoige/files/time%20management%20files/Time%20Mana

    gement%20Self%20Assessment.doc

    Southern Utah University Trio Talent Search. (n.d.). Got Styles Learning Styles Inventory.

    [Handout]. Retrieved from https://www.suu.edu/trioets/pdf/learningstylesassesment.pdf

    Hickman, G. P., Bartholomew, M., Mathwig, J., & Heinrich, R. S. (2008). Differential

    developmental pathways of high school dropouts and graduates. The Journal of

    Educational Research, 102(1), 3-14. DOI: 10.3200/JOER.102.1.3-14

    Retrieved from

    http://www.tandfonline.com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/doi/abs/10.3200/JOER.102.1.3-14#aHR

    0cDovL3d3dy50YW5kZm9ubGluZS5jb20ubGlicHJveHkubGliLnVuYy5lZHUvZG9pL3

    BkZi8xMC4zMjAwL0pPRVIuMTAyLjEuMy0xNEBAQDA=.

    Kayler, H. & Sherman, J. (2009). At-risk ninth-grade students: A group approach to increase

    study skills and grade point averages. Professional School Counseling, 12(6), 434-439.

    Retrieved from:

    http://libproxy.lib.unc.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/213315919?

    =14244

    Lemon, J.C. & Watson, J.C. (2011). Early identification of potential high school dropouts: an

    http://people.okanagan.bc.ca/ddoige/files/time%20management%20files/Time%20Management%20Self%20Assessment.dochttp://people.okanagan.bc.ca/ddoige/files/time%20management%20files/Time%20Management%20Self%20Assessment.dochttp://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/lesson_images/lesson391/I-am-poem.pdf

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 45

    investigation of the relationship among at-risk status, wellness, perceived stress, and

    mattering. Journal of At-Risk Issues, 16(2), 17-23. Retrieved from

    http://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ960073

    McKay, B. & McKay, K. (2013, October) The Eisenhower decision matrix: How to distinguish

    between urgent and important tasks and make real progress in your life. [Handout].

    Retrieved from

    http://content.artofmanliness.com/uploads/The%20Eisenhower%20Decision%20Matrix.p

    df

    Neild, R. C., Balfanz, R., & Herzog, L. (2007). An early warning system. Educational

    leadership, 65(2), 28-33. Retrieved from

    http://new.every1graduates.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/Early_Warning_System_Nei

    ld_Balfanz_Herzog.pdf

    Neild, R. C., Stoner-Eby, S., & Furstenberg, F. (2008, July). Connecting entrance and departure:

    The transition to ninth grade and high school dropout. Education and urban society,

    40(5), 543-569. Retrieved from

    http://eus.sagepub.com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/content/40/5/543.full.pdf+html

    Rowell, L., & Hong, E. (2013). Academic motivation: Concepts,

    strategies, and counseling approaches. Professional School Counseling,16(3), 158-171.

    Retrieved from

    http://libproxy.lib.unc.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/1368152287?ac

    countid=14244

  • ACADEMIC SUCCESS SKILLS GROUP 46

    SUNY Fredonia Counseling Center. (n.d.). Test anxiety: causes and eliminators [Handout].

    Retrieved from https://www.fredonia.edu/counseling/pdf/test%20anxiety.pdf

    SUNY Fredonia Counseling Center. (n.d.).Test anxiety self-assessment [Assessment

    instrument]. Retrieved from https://www.fredonia.edu/counseling/pdf/test%20anxiety.pdf

    SUNY Fredonia Counseling Center. (n.d.). What causes your test anxiety? [Handout]. Retrieved

    from https://www.fredonia.edu/counseling/pdf/test%20anxiety.pdf