rules of procedure for committees in english for iusmun 2011
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
1/18
1
RULES OF PROCEDURE FOR COMMITTEES IN ENGLISH
Rule 1. Scope
The following Rules of Procedure are valid in the Security Council andthe World Trade Organizations committees of IUSMUN 2011. These Rules
establish the debate procedures as well as the behavior that shall be
observed by the delegates. These Rules of Procedure are unique and self-
sufficient and will be considered as adopted prior to the beginning of the
first session, except for further modifications or additions made by the
Secretariat such as the President of each committee, in order to improve
the committees dynamic prior notification to the delegates.
In case of controversy in the interpretation and application of these
rules and any other matter not included in this text, the Secretariat will
have the last decision.
Rule 2. The Secretariat
The Secretariat of IUSMUN 2011 is composed by the Secretary General,
the Academic Secretary, Logistics Secretary, Linkage Secretary and the
Protocol Manager. The Secretary-General or his representative may submit
oral as well as written statements to any committee concerning any issue.
Rule 3. Language
English will be the official and working language during formal and
informal debate, thus, delegates shall avoid expressions in any other
language.
Rule 4. Composition of the Chair
The President will exercise the maximum authority of the committees.
His decisions shall be considered as final and not subject to appeal, and
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
2/18
2
among with the Moderator, Conference Officer and pages will compose the
Chair.
Rule 5. General Powers of the ChairThe functions of the Chair, including but not limited to, are:
A.The President:a) Declare the opening and closing of each session but also its
suspension, adjournment or postponement.
b) Decide whether the points and motions proposed are in order or not,as well as the Rights of Reply and take necessary disciplinary
measures whenever is needed.
c) Establish the time allocated for the delegates speeches in order tomake the most of it.
d) Notify the delegates about any communication made by theSecretariat.
e) Make recommendations in order to clarify the matters regarding aspecific topic and orient delegates regarding the rules of procedure.
f) Withdraw the points of order and personal privilege, either by theirexcessive or indiscriminate use, deciding the proper time when they
may be reestablished.
g) Suspend written communications whenever it may be considered asnecessary.
h) Request for the participation of any delegation having few or nullparticipation in the debate.
i) Approve the Working Papers using the criteria established in theseRules of Procedure.
B. Moderatora) Conduct the debate, yielding the floor in order to facilitate the flow of
it by encouraging the participation of all the delegates.
b)Announce the decisions taken by the Chair.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
3/18
3
c) Open and close the floor.d) Along with the Conference Officer, act as a consultant when
preparing Working Papers, Draft Agreements or Amendments.
C.Conference Officer
a) Call the roll every sessionb)Add to the speakers list all delegates wishing to use the floor.c) Assist in the recording of the voting results and the warnings
imposed by the Chair.
d) Facilitate the written communications between delegates and withthe Chair.
e) Monitor the Speech time of each Delegate.
Rule 6. Delegations
Each delegation shall be formed by one or two delegates who will
represent only one State, Custom Union, Person or International
Organization whether members or not of the United Nations.
Those delegations that are not members will be considered as observers
and will have the very same rights as any other delegation; however, they
will not have the right to vote neither the Draft Agreements nor the
Amendments. Each delegation has the right to only one vote. The decisions
made by one member of a co-delegation will affect both of its members.
Rule 7. Obligations of the delegates
a) Delegates shall present the Position Papers to the Chair in a timelyfashion; via e-mail by the date established by the President and in
hard copy in the first session.
b)All delegations must, at all times, show proper respect and deferencetowards any member of the Secretariat, the Chair and other
delegates.
c) Delegates badge must be worn at all time.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
4/18
4
d) Be on time and remain in order every session. Food and drinks areforbidden in the committees rooms.
e) Speak in third person at all times.f)
No delegate may use the floor without the approval of the Chair.
Rule 8. Ambassadors and Visitors
Ambassadors are the representatives, coordinators and counselors of a
group of students participating as delegates in IUSMUN 2011, they have
the purpose of establishing a link between the Secretariat and the
delegates, as well as providing advice to both.
Ambassadors and visitors may not interfere during the debate in any
form, and must following these Rules of Procedure. The Chair may
discretionally ask Ambassadors and Visitors to leave the room whenever
they breach these Rules.
Rule 9. Dress Code
Delegates shall abide the following dressing code:
Women. A dress, suit, slacks or skirts (no jeans), a blouse or sweater
will be required. Dress shoes must be worn.
Men. A suit or jacket and dress pants (no jeans), a dress shirt and tie
will be required and dress shoes must be worn.
In case a delegate decides to attend a session wearing traditional or
ethnic attire, the Chair must approve it.
The Chair will strictly supervise the above rules of dress code. Non-
compliance with these rules will merit a warning.
Rule 10. Communication
Delegates, observers, ambassadors and visitors may only communicate
with each other though written means, unless the Chair decides to
suspend this type of communication.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
5/18
5
Excepting the caucus, the direct contact between delegates is forbidden.
Ambassadors are banned from having direct contact with the delegates or
participating in the Committees working procedures. The breach of this
rule could merit a warning for the delegates involved.The Chair reserves the right to look through all written communications
that are not addressed with respect and courtesy to its recipient. Such
action will worth a warning.
Rule 11. Code of Behavior
At the Universidad Nacional Autnoma de Mxico (UNAM) is strictly
forbidden to introduce or consume alcoholic beverages as well as the
consumption or possession of narcotics, illegal psychotropic or addictive
substances. TheAntigua Escuela Nacional de Jurisprudenciais considered
as part of UNAM, therefore any vandalistic act against the facilities is
banned.
Any person committing the acts aforementioned will be expelled from
IUSMUN and sent to the proper authorities.
It is strictly forbidden to smoke, eat or drink any beverage inside the
rooms where the committees hold sessions.
Rule 12. Electronic Devices
Prior authorization of the Chair, the use of laptop during sessions is
permitted; however delegates are not permitted to access the Internet; a
delegation using these devices without approval may be warned. The use of
any other electronic devices is prohibited.
Under no circumstances the organization of IUSMUN 2011 will be
responsible for the loss or theft of such devices.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
6/18
6
Rule 13. Nature of the Debate
The debate in each committee will be divided in General Debate, in
respect to the topics at hand; and Particular Debate regarding the Working
Papers.
Rule 14. Agenda
After calling the roll and declaring the first session as open, the
committee will establish the Agenda, for that purpose the Chair shall recall
the topics that will be discussed. Then, a delegation must establish a
motion of Procedure to discuss the opening of one of the Topics, that
motion shall be seconded and voted.
Once the motion has passed, the Chair shall establish a provisional
speakers list with two delegations speaking in favor and two against the
motion. It is forbidden for delegates to refer to the other topic at hand in
their speeches.
Delegations will alternately speak in favor and against the topic chosen;
the first speaker will be the one that proposed the motion. After the
provisional speakers list is exhausted, the committee shall move into an
immediate vote. A simple majority is required for the motion to pass;
otherwise automatically the other topic will be discussed.
Rule 15. Speakers List
Once that the topic to be discussed has been established, a motion of
procedure to open a speakers list will be in order, the delegate proposing
the motion will be the first to speak and the one seconding will be the
second in the Speakers List. A delegate may request its inclusion in the list
by raising the placard. If a delegate is absent from it as-of-yet, must do it
through a written message. If the Chair considers it appropriate, a new
speakers list will be established every sessions day.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
7/18
7
Rule 16. Voting Criteria
All procedural decision have to be voted by all the delegates, and only
once, which may be in favor, against or abstention.
The delegations to propose a motion should vote in favor to avoidcontradictions.
The Specific voting criteria for the WTO committee and Security Council
will be established in the corresponding annexes.
Rule 17. Quorum
For debate to commence, the President must declare the session as open
and allow the debate to start when at least a simple majority of the
delegations that are present.
Rule 18. Sanctions
In the event a delegate breaches these Rules, the Chair or any member
of the Secretariat may issue the following sanctions:
Call to attention: A mention made by the Chair to a delegate due to a
breach of the Rules, discipline or in the development of the committees
procedure.
Warning: A measure imposed by the Chair for delegations repeating a
conduct that breaches the Rules, discipline or the development of the
committees procedure.
Suspension of the session: Delegates warned twice must abandon the
room immediately, not being able to go back until the next session.
Expulsion of the Model: Delegates accruing 3 warnings from the Chair
will be banned from the Model.
Rule 19. Points and Motions
Delegates may use points and motions in the formal debate to suggest a
situation or proposal for consideration. The type of points and motions are:
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
8/18
8
a) Point of Orderb) Point of Personal Privilegec) Point of Parliamentary Inquiryd)
Motion of Procedure
The Points of order, Personal Privilege and Parliamentary Inquiry may be
established at any time, they may even interrupt a speaker, hence must be
used with utmost discretion.
The Motion of Procedure can only be established when the floor is open.
a) Point of order:A Point of Order must relate to the inobservance of the rules of the
committee or appoint improper conducts from delegates or the
Chair. A point of order over a point of order cannot be established.
b) Point of Personal PrivilegeIf a delegate experiments any discomfort that prevents him or her
from participating fully in the proceedings may request it. This
motion must be fully heard by the Chair, however if this discomfort
is not urgent to fix, it could be sent through written means to the
Chair.
c) Point of Parliamentary Inquiry Through this point, a delegate may ask the Chair about the
procedure that must be followed; these questions must be relevant
to the procedure at hand.
d) Motion of ProcedureThis motion is used when the floor is open; it modifies the normal
course of the debate.
Rule 20. Yielding of Time
A delegate, who has been recognized to use the floor, may yield his
remaining time as described below. The delegate must communicate his
decision to the Chair at the end of his speech.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
9/18
9
a)To another Delegate. The other delegate may use the time, but maynot yield it again. In case that the delegate to whom the time is being
yielded does not accept it, the yielding delegate will be warned.
b) To Questions. Delegates allowed to present their questions will bechosen by the chair and will only be permitted to ask one. Time will
be deducted exclusively from the speakers answers.
c)To Comments. The Moderator may authorize two comments from theforum about the content of the former speakers speech. The
delegates cannot yield their time, which will be of exactly 30
seconds.
d) To the Chair. The Chair may use it or not as they consider itappropriate.
Rule 21. Extraordinary Session of Questions
After a delegations Speech, while the floor is open a delegate may ask
the Chair for an Extraordinary Session of Questions, which may not be of
less than two or more than five questions.
The delegate to be questioned must accept this Motion but could deny it
without any justification; equally the motion has to be seconded and voted,
being accepted by a Simple Majority.
Delegates proposing and seconding the motion will have the right to
make one question and whenever is needed a follow up that clarifies an
early answer.
It is the questioning Delegates prerogative to establish a brief preamble
to his question. Such right must be exercised by requesting a Point of
Personal Privilege; notwithstanding such a right cannot be applied in the
case of follow-ups.
There will not be in order two subsequent extraordinary session of
questions.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
10/18
10
Rule 22. Right of Reply
A delegate whose personal integrity or national honor has been harmed
by another delegate may request a Right of Reply by written means. The
President will announce the decision of the Chair, which is final. If theChair decides that the Right of Reply is in order, the offence shall be
recognized.
A Right of Reply over a Right of Reply is out of order.
Rule 23. Caucus
A caucus entails a space to debate without a defined format; its purpose
is to make communication more fluid between delegates, negotiate or draw
up Working Papers and Draft Agreements. A delegate may propose a
Caucus whenever the floor is open; the motion must be seconded and
voted affirmatively by a Simple Majority.
The time-limit must be specified as musts its purpose. The Moderator
may declare it out of order. A motion of procedure should be voted likewise
and could be extended for a time shorter than the one established initially.
Rule 24. Moderated Caucus
During a Moderated Caucus, the Chair shall recognize the delegates for
remarks without the use of a Speakers List; delegates may speak by only
raising their placards. The motion to ask for a Moderated Caucus shall be
seconded and voted affirmatively by a Simple Majority.
Rule 25. Working Papers
A Working Paper is a document in which delegates will present the most
condensed ideas that have been discussed; it is the step prior to a Draft
Agreement. Working Papers do not need a strict format; only the signature
of the Chair to be presented and should be sponsored by one third of the
delegations.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
11/18
11
Before their formal presentation, Working Papers shall be approved by
the Chair, who may modify their layout and format and whenever is
needed its content.
Rule 26. Draft Agreements
All Draft Agreements must contain solutions to the problem at hand and
while not approved by the chair shall be called Possible Draft
Agreements. In order to be presented to the Chair they shall have a
defined format and count with the acknowledgment of minimum 30% of
the Delegates who may sponsor only one Draft Agreement per topic.
The Chair may suggest modifications in the layout, format or content of
the Draft Agreement; such suggestions must be informed to the signing
delegates for their appraisal.
The Draft Agreement shall be distributed to all parties to be discussed,
amended and voted during the Particular Debate. No Draft Agreement
written before the simulation will be approved for discussion or voting.
Once approved by the Chair, the Draft Agreement shall be presented to
be discussed in a Particular Debate.
Rule 27. Particular Debate
The Chair will ask three delegates to present the Draft Agreement within
five minutes; five questions will then be in order.
The Particular Debate may have two modalities: Open or Closed Debate.
This situation will be put to the vote of the delegates. Being approved by a
Simple Majority, the chosen debate may and will be changed whenever the
Chair deems it necessary.
a) Open DebateThe Moderator will grant the word to the delegates by raising their
placard. The floor will not be open, thus motions will be out of order.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
12/18
12
The Chair will decide the proper moment to declare this debate as
closed.
b) Closed DebateThe Chair shall establish two Speakers Lists, one in favor and oneagainst the Draft Agreement by taking into account the regional and
ideological diversity. Each speaker will be able to use the floor for
two minutes in order to make a comment and/or propose an
amendment. Whenever an Amendment is proposed it shall be read
by the Chair to the forum. After having presented the Amendments,
the Chair might discretionally accept or reject them.
One or Two Questions could be made to each Delegation using the
floor prior to the voting of the amendment proposed. Delegations
making comments without proposing Amendments in favor or
against the Draft Agreement may yield the remaining time of their
speeches to other Delegation or the Chair.
Rule 28. Amendments
Amendments add to, delete from or modify parts of a Draft Agreement;
however they cannot transform the original essence of the document.
Proposed Amendments must be communicated to the Chair in a written
fashion and approved by the Chair during the Particular Debate in any of
its modalities.
A Friendly Amendment will require 100% of signatures from the
delegates. A Conventional Amendment shall require 30% of signatures
from the delegates. Approved Amendments shall be read by the Chair.
Votes can be collected through written messages passed viapage to other
delegates.
The voting of the amendments will not be binding and abstentions
cannot take place. Amendments are to be approved by a Qualified
Majority.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
13/18
13
Rule 29. Closure of the Debate
In order to vote a Draft Agreement, the debate regarding it and its
Amendments must be closed; thus, a motion to Close the Debate will be in
order, this motion shall be seconded. The floor will be momentarily openfor two delegates to speak against the Closure of the Debate. After the
speeches voting will take place needing a Qualified Majority to be
approved. Once the debate is closed the Draft Agreement may be voted.
Rule 30. Division of the Question
The Division of the Question implies that certain clauses of a Draft
Agreement will be voted separately, so that only the clauses that are
passed become part of the final Agreement.
Immediately after the debate has been closed, a delegate may propose a
motion to vote each Operative Clause of the Draft Resolution in an
individual manner. The floor will be momentarily opened to allow this to
happen. A Speakers List will be opened with one delegate in favor and one
against the Division of the Question, and this motion requires a Qualified
Majority to pass.
If all the Operative Clauses of the Draft Agreement are rejected, the
Agreement shall be rejected; if any passed, an Agreement on that specific
topic shall be considered.
Rule 31. Voting
Each Member has the right to only one vote. Abstentions shall not be
taken into account as votes against. Draft Agreements shall be approved
as established in the annexes for each committee. The President will guide
the delegates to vote in alphabetical order following the procedure laid out
thus:
1. First Round: Delegates may vote in favor, against, abstain or pass.Those delegations passing may define their vote in the second round.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
14/18
14
They may ask the Chair for a Right of Explanation to make an
exposition to the Council about the votes reasoning.
2. Second Round: The Council will hear the right of Explanation of thedelegates that have asked for it within 30 seconds. The delegatesthat passed must vote either in favor, against or abstain.
3.Third Round: The Chair will invite the delegates who voted againstthe Agreement to reconsider their vote, and will then call upon them
again to vote alphabetically. The votes casted in this round will be
definitive.
Rule 32. Closure of the Session
To Close the Session the floor must be open and a delegate must
propose either the closure until the next session (leading to a recess) or a
definite Closure of the simulation (if current session is the last one). This
motion shall be seconded and voted.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
15/18
15
ANNEX 1
SECURITY COUNCIL SPECIFIC RULES OF PROCEDURE
Voting CriteriaThere are three criterions to consider a vote as passed. In all cases, all
delegations present and recognized by the Chair to participate in the
session are to be considered, except for the votes reserved to members.
1) Simple Majority: More votes in favor of those who are against.Abstentions are not taken into account.
2) Absolut majority: 50% +1 (fifty percent plus one) of the attendingDelegations in the time that the decision is taken.
3) Qualified Majority: 2/3 (two thirds) of the attending Delegations inthe time that the decision is taken.
Quorum
There will be no distinction between permanent or non-permanent
members for the determination of quorum.
Draft Agreements
The correct term for the Security Council shall be Draft Resolutions.
Voting
Considering the special characteristics of the Security Council, all the
Agreements shall be adopted without vetos right of the five permanent
members (United Stated of America, Republic of France, United Kingdom,
Popular Republic of China and Russian Federation).
The vote of non-present members will be counted as an abstention. The
absence of a member will be recorded in the final text of the resolution. A
Resolution of the Security Council requires nine affirmative votes and no
negative vote of a permanent member to be approved. The voting of a
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
16/18
16
Presidential Statement in the Security Council requires the affirmative vote
of two thirds of the members.
Once the voting has started it cannot be interrupted. During the voting
procedure contained herein, doors and any other kind of access to theroom will be closed and must not open until said premises must leave the
room, equally, delegates will not be allowed to leave the room.
The voting procedures will occur as established in Rule 31; however, a
fourth round of voting will take place:
4) Fourth Round: In this round only the five permanent members canbe in the room. In this round the veto right of the five permanent
members may be exercised.
Presidential Statement
The Presidential Statement is a document expressing the opinion and
will of the Council; it does not contain operative clauses. The text of the
Statement has to be signed by two thirds of the delegations and approved
by the Chair. The approved text has to be introduced to the Council by two
or more delegations for discussion by a Motion of Procedure. The
Statement can be submitted to vote after its text has been discussed by a
Motion of Procedure.
Press Release
The Press Release is a document expressing the position of the
participants and the agreements reached during the debate. It requires a
simple majority to pass. The text has to be signed by half of the delegations
and approved by the Chair. The approved text has to be introduced to the
committee before it is voted. A delegate may request the Chair to add,
modify or eliminate a point referring to its delegation on the Press Release
by a Motion of Personal Privilege before it is voted.
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
17/18
17
ANNEX 2
WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE SPECIFIC RULES OF
PROCEDURE
Agenda
The Chair will announce the Topic that will be discussed first to the
delegates by e mail. On the first session, the Chair will remind the
delegates the pre-established Agenda
Voting Criteria
There are three criterions to consider a vote as passed. In all cases, all
delegations present and recognized by the Chair to participate in the
session are to be considered, except for the votes reserved to WTO
members.
5) Simple Majority: 50% +1 (fifty percent plus one) of the attendingDelegations in the time that the decision is taken.
6) Qualified Majority: 2/3 (two thirds) of the attending Delegations inthe time that the decision is taken.
7) Consensus: No Member, attending at the meeting when the decisionis taken formally objects to the proposed decision.
Closure of the Debate
Due to the nature of the WTO Committee, in order to vote an Agreement,
both topics in the Agenda shall be discussed in general and particular
debate and amended.
Voting
Considering the special characteristics of the WTO Committee, all the
Agreements shall be adopted by consensus (no delegate may vote against
the Agreement). In the WTO Committee only one voting will take place, the
-
8/3/2019 Rules of Procedure for Committees in English for IUSMUN 2011
18/18
18
Agreements made in both topics shall be voted simultaneously and as a
whole.
Once that the voting of an Agreement has started it cannot be
interrupted. During the voting procedure contained herein the doors andany other kind of access to the room will be closed and must not open
until said premises must leave the room, equally delegations will not be
allowed to leave the room.
Observers, Ambassadors and Visitors shall leave the room in order to
start with the voting.