rudik dmitry -...

29
1 The RED-100 Search for elastic coherent neutrino scattering off atomic nuclei at the Kalininskaya Nuclear Power Plant Rudik Dmitry AAP Workshop CEA 2014 NATIONAL RESEARCH NUCLEAR UNIVERSITY MEPhI (Moscow Engineering Physics Institute) Laboratory for Experimental Nuclear Physics http://enpl.mephi.ru/

Upload: others

Post on 26-Oct-2019

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

111

The RED-100

Search for elastic coherent neutrino scattering off atomic nuclei at the Kalininskaya Nuclear Power Plant

Rudik Dmitry

AAP Workshop

CEA 2014

NATIONAL RESEARCH NUCLEAR UNIVERSITY MEPhI(Moscow Engineering Physics Institute)

Laboratory for Experimental Nuclear Physicshttp://enpl.mephi.ru/

Page 2: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

Outline:

RED Collaboration RED-1 & obtained results RED-100 & Kalininskaya Power Plant Conclusion

2

Page 3: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

2010

3

Page 4: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

D.Sc. -2PhDs – 10Faculty - 12PhD students – 6Students – 10

LENPLENP2011

4

Page 5: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

5

10-44

10-43

10-42

10-41

10-40

10-39

0 2 4 6 8 10

Cro

ss S

ect

ion

[cm

2]

Neutrino Energy [MeV]

Elastic Scattering off Ar

Proton Inverse Beta Decay

σ elastic =GF

2

4 πN2 Eν

2

≈0 .4× 10−44 cm2 A2 Eν (MeV )2

E recoil ⩽ 716 eVEν

2(MeV )

A

Large cross-section

Small recoil energies

, k

, k ’

q

N e u t r a l c u r r e n t

+

+

+

+

, k

, k ’

q

N e u t r a l c u r r e n t

+

+

+

+ +

+

+

+

Coherent neutrino scattering off heavy nuclei

Page 6: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

6IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NUCLEAR SCIENCE, VOL. 50, NO. 5, OCTOBER 2003

P. S. Barbeau, J. I. Collar, J. Miyamoto, and I. Shipsey

Recoil spectra from reactor e-antineutrino

Page 7: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

C.Hagmann and A.Bernstein. Two-phase emission detector for measuring coherent neutrino-nucleus scattering, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 51(2004)2151-2155.

LAr detector @ LLNL

7

Page 8: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

8Болоздыня 24.11.2011

7 FEU-181, MgF2

LXe RED-1 & Research reactor of MEPhI

arXiv:1212.1938

Page 9: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

9

2.5 MW Research reactor IRT MEPhI

1 – RED-1

2 – Fe/Al filter

3 – horizontal neutron channel GEK10

4 – starting point of MCNP simulations

5 – cooling water pool

6 – active zone

7 – heavy concrete shielding

Page 10: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

10

1 – detector RED-1; 2, 3 - shield 10 cm lead & 10 cm borated polyethylene; 4 — lead slice 5 cm; 5 polyethylene slice - 5 cm; 6 - paraffin; 7,8 – filter 30 cm Fe & 70 cm Al; 9 — reactor's concrete shield.

Specific ionization yield for the nuclear recoil with energy < 1 keV isn't known. Its obtainig is the main goal of our experiment at the MEPhI reactor.

Neutron total cross section of 27Al and of 56Fe (upper plot) and simulated neutron beam spectra before and after passing the filter (bottom plot).

arXiv:1212.1938

Page 11: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

11

Distribution of EL (S2) signals generated by single emitted electrons (green). Maximum of the Gauss fit is 15 ± 5 photoelectrons. Poisson distribution for 10 and 15 expectations are shown in pink and violet, respectively.

Typical gamma event in RED-1

Detection of Single Electrons

A.A. Burenkov et al Phys.Atom.Nucl. 72 (2009) 653-661, Yad. Fiz. 72 (2009) 693-701Doi: 10.1134/S1063778809040103

Page 12: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

1212

Page 13: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

Obtained results

Experimental data for the ionization yield of LXe for electron recoils and theoretical

predictions

D.Yu. Akimov et al 2014 JINST 9 P11014 doi:10.1088/1748-0221/9/11/P11014

13

Source Energy, keV

Ionization yield, e-/keV

37Ar 2.82 48.3 ± 5.7 (syst.)

241Am, Np Lβ1

17.75 44.9 ± 2.7 (stat.) +

3.3 (syst.) – 5.1 (syst.)

241Am, esc. peak (59.5-29.5 keV)

30 47.8 ± 0.7 (stat.) +

3.3 (syst.) – 3.4 (syst.)

129Xe 40 49.0 ± 0.4(stat.) ± 1.7 (syst.)

83mKr 41.5 43.7 ± 0.1 (stat.) ± 2.8 (syst.)

241Am 59.5 49.5 ± 0.1(stat.) ± 3.4 (syst.)

131Xe 80 55.6 ± 0.8 (stat.) +

1.6 (syst.) – 1.9 (syst.)

137Cs 662 63.0 ± 0.2 (stat.) +

3.2 (syst.) – 3.8 (syst.)

Page 14: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

USAKalininskaya NPP

1 m

0 . 5 m

H A M A M A T S UR 8 7 7 8

RED-100

14

Page 15: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

15

Titanium Warm vessel

Teflon Drift cage

Titanium Cold vessel

Array of 19 PMTs in Copper holder

Thermosyphon Cold Head

Copper T-screen

1m 68 cm

64 cm

RED-100

Material Mass, kg

Copper 310

Teflon 82

PMT R11410

38 pcs

Titanium

221

Array of 19 PMTs in Copper holder

Hamamatsu R11410-20

15

Page 16: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

16

0 1 0 0 2 0 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 5 0 0 6 0 0 7 0 0 8 0 0 9 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 2 0 0 1 3 0 0 1 4 0 0 1 5 0 0 1 6 0 0 1 7 0 0 1 8 0 0 1 9 0 01

1 0

1 0 0

1 0 0 0

1 0 0 0 0

O f f i c e ( 2 7 . 0 9 . 2 0 0 6 )

R o o m A 3 3 6 ( 2 9 . 0 9 . 2 0 0 6 )

γbackground under the reactorγbackground in the lab

Energy, keV

dN

\dE

, co

un

ts/k

eV

/kg

/ sKalininskaya Nuclear Power Plant (Udomlya)

GEMMA

Page 17: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

17

Signal/Noise

A: fSEE=100Hz

B: fSEE=10Hz

C: Signal

CR (>2 e) = 433/day/100 kg LXe

СR (E>1,8 MeV) = 27000/day/100kgLXe

Signal/Background

A: detector components

B: neutrons

C: Signal

Kalininskaya NPP facility: Фantineutrino = 1.35*1013 cm-2s-1

arXiv:1212.1938

Page 18: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

18

Neutrino Spectra from fusions

Monitoring nuclear reactors

Detector response

Antineutrino flux evolution Daily power monitoring

LWR, 3GWt, L = 19m

Page 19: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

19

Conclusion

• Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology to search for the Coherent Neutrino Scattering (CNS) effect

• CNS is interesting for fundamental Physics and for non-proliferation applications

• Capability to measure weak ionization from nuclear recoils below 1 keV energies is a key element toward the observation of CNS

Obtained results by RED-1 of low energy recoils region show an ability of such detectors to search for CNS effect

• RED-100 experimental installation is under development for observation of CNS and for development of a highly sensitive method of NPP monitoring

Page 20: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

Thank you for your attention!

Our contacts:

http://enpl.mephi.ru - our website E-mails

[email protected] - Dr. Yuri Efremenko

[email protected] - Dr. Alexander Bolozdynya

[email protected] - Dmitry Akimov

[email protected] - my e-mail

Page 21: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

Backup

Page 22: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

16.12.14Болоздыня 24.11.2011

Electronics: RUN2013

LXe MEPhI 2014

Signals from PMTs

Fast preamplifiers

High sensitivity channelLow sensitivity channel

8-channel Phillips Scientific 772

A remote control switch.

0.5 or 5 gain possibility

Struck SIS3350 12-bit (2 ns sampling)

CAEN V1720 12-bit

(4 ns sampling)

From a fraction of a SPE to ~105 SPE!

Page 23: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

16.12.14Болоздыня 24.11.2011

Calibration sources

LXe MEPhI 2014

Energy, keV 2.82 13.9 17.2 30 39.6 41.5 59.5 80.2 662

Isotope 37Ar 241Am 241Am 241Am 129Xe 83mKr 241Am 131Xe 137Cs

Description EC, Auger gamma gamma escape

peak n-gammaIC,

gamma, Auger

gamma n-gamma gamma

RUN2009 – + + + – + + – –

RUN2013 + – – – + + – + +

Table of energy lines and corresponding radioactive sources

83mKr line was used as a reference point to combine results of both datasets

Page 24: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

16.12.14Болоздыня 24.11.2011

Data analysis: 37Ar

LXe MEPhI 2014

Distribution of S2 signal areas of 37Ar and 83mKr events; red - events from the 83mKr runs, blue – events from 37Ar runs, green – events from the runs with

both 37Ar and 83mKr in the detector (without lifetime correction).

The evaluated from 37Ar data free electron lifetime is 16 ± 5 μs.

Weighted average of krypton to argon ratio is

13.3 ± 1.3

Page 25: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

16.12.14Болоздыня 24.11.2011

Ionization yield: Wi

LXe MEPhI 2014

Wi = 15.6 ± 0.3 eV (for MeV 207Bi electrons and γ)

T. Takahashi, S. Konno, T. Hamada et al., Phys. Rev. A12 (1975) 1771,Average energy expended per ion pair in liquid xenon

Wi = 16.5 ± 0.8 eV (for 122 keV 57Co γ)

M. Horn, V. A. Belov, D. Yu. Akimov et al., Phys. Lett. B705 (2011) 471,Nuclear recoil scintillation and ionisation yields in liquid xenon from ZEPLIN-III data

Wi = 14.27 ± 0.30 eV ← (1 + 0.06) * W = 13.46 ± 0.29 eV

T. Shutt, C.E. Dahl, J. Kwong et al., NIM A579 (2007) 451,Performance and fundamental processes at low energy in a two-phase liquid xenon darkmatter detector

Wi = 13.6 ± 0.2 eV

I. M. Obodovskii and S. G. Pokachalov, Sov. J. Low Temp. Phys. 5 (1979) 393,Average ion pair formation energy in liquid and solid xenon

Wi = 14.84 eV ← (1 + 0.06) * W = 14 eV

E. Aprile J. Angle, F. Arneodo et al., Astropart. Phys. 34 (2011) 679,Design and performance of the XENON10 dark matter experiment

Page 26: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

26

Spallation Neutron Source (ORNL)

Page 27: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

27

I n t e r f a c eL N D e w a r

Ground shielding

40 m from target

neutrino

10 m below ground level

Page 28: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

28

Signal/Noise

A: fSEE=100Hz

B: fSEE=10Hz

C: Signal

CR (>3 phe) = 1470/year/100 kg LXe

Signal/Background

A: Neutrons from cosmic rays

B: Components of RED100

C: Neutrons from SNS

D: Signal

RED-100 @ 40 m from the SNS target

Page 29: Rudik Dmitry - enpl.mephi.ruenpl.mephi.ru/download/seminars/2014-12-21_03-36-16_Rudik_RED100_AAP... · 19 Conclusion • Emission two-phase detectors are much promising technology

29

oV

V ( z )

z0

p

d N / d p

z

ze

e

e

Quasi-free electron emission from nonpolar dielectrics

oV

V ( z )

z

0

e

1V

( b )

V 1( z )=V 0−eF1 z+eA1 ,z< 0V 2 ( z )=−eF2 z+eA 2 ,z> 0

A1,2=−e ( ε1−ε 2) / [4 ε1,2 ( z+ξz /|z|)(ε1 +ε 2 )]