robert mc bride

14
DISARMAMENT, DISMANTLING AND DISBANDMENT LESSONS FROM THE SOUTH AFRICAN PROCESS ROBERT MCBRIDE

Upload: lokarri

Post on 30-Jul-2015

631 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Robert mc bride

DISARMAMENT, DISMANTLING AND DISBANDMENT

LESSONS FROM THE SOUTH AFR ICAN PROCESS

ROBERT MCBRIDE

Page 2: Robert mc bride

THE BEGINNING

• 50 years of peaceful resistance• 30 years of armed struggle• Prison talks, July 1986• Secret Channels• Harare Declaration• Unbanning , Feb 1990

Page 3: Robert mc bride

RELEASE OF MANDELA

• Temporary Indemnity for ANC Negotiators returning to South Africa

• Temporary firearm permits to protectors of ANC Leaders

• Return of Exiles

Page 4: Robert mc bride

GROOTE SCHUUR MINUTE 4TH MAY 1990

• First direct public negotiations between Government and ANC (“talk about talks”) – setting the rules

• Common commitment towards ending a climate of violence and intimidation as well as a commitment to stability and to a peaceful process of negotiations

• Definition of Political Offences• Establish effective channels of

communication

Page 5: Robert mc bride

PRETORIA MINUTE, AUG 6TH 1990

• Establishment of Working Groups• Prisoners• Violence• Review of Security Legislation• Paragraph 3 • Unilateral Suspension of armed activity• Establishment of Working Group to deal with above

decision

Page 6: Robert mc bride

PARAGRAPH 3 WORKING GROUP REPORT

• The Working Group agreed on the following

• No armed attacks, no infiltration of men or materials, no creation of underground structures, no incitement of violence, no threats of armed action and no training in South Africa• Agreed on the principal that no political party or movement

should have a private army• Recognise that MK is no longer an unlawful organization• Noted the historical fact that MK had weapons and cadres in the

country• Agreed that control over such cadres and arms be excercised• Move towards legalisation and normalisation of arms issues• Security forces must take cognisance of the suspension of armed

action and related activities

Page 7: Robert mc bride

SOUTHERN AFRICA: ANC BASES AND WEAPONS

Page 8: Robert mc bride

EXTERNAL DISARMAMENT AND VERIFICATION• 1991 process of decommissioning

MKs external arms caches• Weapons surrendered to host

countries• This involved description of

weapons, numbers, and working condition

• Verification by MK Commanders and host Governments

• All external weapons surrendered• Joint secret working groups, MK

and Government

Page 9: Robert mc bride

EXTERNAL DISARMAMENT AND VERIFICATION

COPY OF ACTUAL VERIFICATION DOCUMENT

Page 10: Robert mc bride

EXTERNAL DISARMAMENT AND VERIFICATION

COPY OF ACTUAL WEAPONS VERIFICATION RECEIPT

Page 11: Robert mc bride

NEGOTIATIONS, FRUSTRATION & BREAKDOWN• CODESA I

• Government political point-scoring & Mandela’s response… “Now he is attacking us because we have not dissolved Umkhonto. He is not even telling you, … that we agreed, …at the beginning of this year on Umkhonto we Sizwe. We then had an agreement in terms of which we had to hand over our weapons for joint control by the Government and ourselves, but we linked that to the development of the political process. You are asking us to commit suicide, because when your Government is not prepared to intervene to stop the violence; when the perception amongst our people is that it is elements in the Security Forces that are killing our people; when our people demand to be armed, what political organisation would had over its weapons to the same man who is regarded by people as killing innocent people.”

• Violence, Prisoners, harassment of ANC &MK

• BREAKDOWN

Page 12: Robert mc bride

BREAKTHROUGH

• Record of Understanding, Sept 1992

• CODESA II

• November ‘93 Election date

• December 16•Disbanding of MK

• April 27, 1994•First Democratic Elections

Page 13: Robert mc bride

ARMS & AMNESTIES

August ‘94•Main stockpile of ANC arms surrendered , 40 trucks worth

October ’94First post-apartheid amnesty to cover activists who had possession of weapons

A number of subsequent amnesties were declared

Integration of armed forces. New Defence Force

Non-Statutory

Demobilisation and Normalisation

Page 14: Robert mc bride

LESSONS FROM SOUTH AFRICA

• Peace making is a process fraught with risk and frustration

• Acknowledgement that alternative means, other than armed conflict, need to be pursued

• Political will for a just and equitable solution. Free political activity

• Arms must be removed from the equation, equally so, repression

• Disarmament and decommissioning is a significant part of the process. Directly liked to building confidence in the process

• Must be formalised and verified. Independent/ neutral honest broker