risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

13
Risks and realities of a project Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it! and why we must stop it!

Upload: nathaniel-merritt

Post on 27-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Risks and realities of a project Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!and why we must stop it!

Page 2: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Impacted GA Counties:

- Stewart (Lumpkin), Webster (Preston)- Terrell (Dawson), Lee (Leesburg)- Dougherty (Albany), Mitchell (Camilla)- Colquitt (Moultrie), Brooks (Quitman)- Lowndes (Valdosta)

More maps available at www.spectrabusters.org

Sabal Trail Pipeline Route

Page 3: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Sabal Trail Transmission LLC is a joint venture of Spectra Corp and NextEra Energy

They were awarded the 465-mile interstate project in July 2013 by Florida Power & Light Company (FPL)

Estimated cost of the project is > $3 billion

The planned in-service date for the pipeline is May 2017

Page 4: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

A 36 inch pipeline would be used for this project

The pipeline would run for 196 miles through Georgia

It would carry >1 billion cubic feet of natural gas per day

A survey study of 600 feet would be taken to allow for future pipeline route refinements “if necessary”

An easement of 100 feet would be acquired from landowners along the route

Page 5: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

The project “will create significant jobs ... as well as add capital investment and tax base to all three states.”

The pipeline “will increase energy diversity, security and reliability to southeastern markets”, while providing “clean-burning, affordable natural gas.”

“Sabal Trail is dedicated to safe operation”; “our safety programs exceed regulatory requirements”; “pipeline will operate in accordance with federal safety requirements (DOT / PHMSA)”; “we will monitor the pipeline 24/7”; …

Page 6: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Fossil fuels are finite resources Current natural gas boom caused by

hydraulic fracturing (“fracking”): contamination of groundwater methane emissions health concerns

Page 7: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Justification for Sabal Trail pipeline:To help cities like Tampa switch from coal and oil to natural gas? Energy alternatives in the “sunshine state”?

Growing LNG market in Florida:For Import or Export?Currently 2 permitted export stations4 new facilities are reportedly under review

Energy Independence? Imports? Exports?

Page 8: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

At least 128 pipeline accidents nationwide since 2010Spectra Energy alone responsible for > $8 million in property damage (according to the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration)

Spectra Energy fined > $15 million for spills at 89 pipelines sites

Spectra Energy has a poor maintenance and monitoring record

Knifely, Kentucky / 2-3-2014Enon, Louisiana / 6-18-2013

Page 9: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Companies may utilize “eminent domain” under the Natural Gas Act

A 100 foot wide easement will be claimed

Landowners loose the right to use this easement as they see fit (no trees or dwellings)

Landowners will continue to pay property taxes on the virtually useless easement

Land will decrease in value

Page 10: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!
Page 11: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

What is the position of Sabal Trail LLC on fracking, property rights, and its so-called “safety record” as outlined above?

Why has Sabal Trail been unwilling to provide copies of the maps they displayed or lists of affected landowners?

How many fail safe and manual valves will be involved and what is the distance between them?

Have any elected officials or corporations petitioned for this line to run through our state? What is the amount of revenue to the state of Georgia that will come from this pipeline?

Are there any contracts to supply Georgia businesses or residents from the proposed pipeline?

Page 12: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

How much of the natural gas from the proposed pipeline will be exported?

What type of liability insurance does Sabal Trail LLC have in case of any accidents?

The top cover on a 36-inch pipeline should be at least 5 feet, yet in some areas Sabal Trail only seems to provide for 3 feet. Why?

The proposed Sabal Trail pipeline would run underneath rivers like the Santa Fe, through areas of karst topography, and above the Floridan aquifer. Can Sabal Trail guarantee the safety of our rivers, ground water aquifers and drinking water?

Page 13: Risks and realities of a project and why we must stop it!

Growing SpectraBusters Alliance: