risk management comparison

2013/09/13 (Project Risk Management) P:1/45

� � � ��

� � ��


� � � �� A project is a unique effort

�� ! "#with defined

beginning and end,$% �& '() *+ ,

a specific deliverable,

-. �/ 01and specific resources.23 �4 56 78 “

9 :; �45< :; �= >? ? % @A B "? % C D �E FG H I” J

1. K LM G �+ NO PQ RS G

/T ,G �U P

2.

: - . �V WX C D< Y ' )*+ ,

3.

Z[ \] Q ^_ ] :S ` abc de Q fg hi jkl � m n op �q r s

=>t uv w x l y zt l y u{ uv zt |} ~�� m n op � �q r st �� t � �� ( � �� )t �� ~�


� � � �� BS-25999-1:2006Risk:

�

something that might happen and its effect

�

s

�

on the achievement of objectives �Risk is a concept that denotes the precise probability of specific eventualities. Technically, the notion of risk is independent from the notion of value and, as such, eventualities may have both beneficial and adverse consequences. However, in general usage the convention is to focus only on potential negative impact to some characteristic of value that may arise from a future event.RISK can be defined as “the threat or probability that an action or event will adversely or beneficially affect an organization's ability to achieve its objectives”[1]. In simple terms risk is ‘Uncertainty of Outcome’, either from pursuing a future positive opportunity, or an existing negative threat in trying to achieve a current. From Wikipedia

� �� ¡¢ £¤ ¥¦ §¨© � § ª« ¬ ®¯ � § °± ²³ ´µ ¶·¸ � § ¹ º» ¼½ ¾ ¿À ÁÂ ± ½ ÃÄ § Å ÆÇ È ÉÊ Ë

Ì ÍÎ Ï ÐÑ ÒÓ

klÔ Õ Ö× m n Ø Ù ��

=>t Ú m n ÚÛÜ (

ÝÞ ß | � àá

)t â à= â n+ àát àá � �=>

l y { ãä åæ Øç ä å��Ô Õ� m n Øèé �t êë ìí =>

îï � �t ð ñ � ß |òó ôõö ÷� øù


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ Ï ÐÑ ÒÓ

ú ûú ûú ûú ûüü üüþýÿ� ¥¦ � �� ¢ ��

ÿ�� ¢ � � ��

� ÿ� � �� !" # $¢ %& ' �� ( )

the cost of something is what you give up to get it

*

¥¦ + �� ,¢ -.ex:

/ 01 2 34 5 6 ¡7 8 5 6 9: ;< +� < 4 = � � �=>

� � � �>

Ex:

? � @ �4 � < AB CD E F�


� � � ��

G HI JK L

MN O PQ PR S

MN O TU VW XY ZQ [\ ]MN O R Z S ^Q ^\

MN O PQ P_ Q ` S

ab cd ef gh

1.

ij N O Z f gh kl mn ij N Oo pqN O Z f gr st uvw xy z{ N O| V}~{ �� uv �} ��

2.

��

/

�� f gh l mn �� N Oo � q N OZ f gr st �� fg{ � � f g�

�� ¡

Ì ÍÎ Ï ÐÑ ÒÓ


� � � ��

¢ £¤¢ £¤¢ £¤¢ £¤ ¥¦ § ¨© ª «¬ ® ¯ °¯ °¯ °¯ ° ±Risk ²² ²² Severity ³³ ³³ Likelihood ³³ ³³ frequency´ µ ¶· ¸v ¹ � �º » »¼ _ º ½¾ T¿ ¼ À Á �o h

Risk ²² ²² Severity ³³ ³³ Likelihood Â SafetyÃ Ä ¶· ÅÆ Ç �È ÉÊ ËÌ Í f g Z ÎÏ ÐÑ

Hint:

ÒÓ Î Ì ÍÔ Õ


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ Ï ÐÑ ÒÓ Issue

Ö× § � / � 6Øex:

ÙÚÛ ÚÜ ÝProbability § Þ ßà áâ ã� 6Ø 4 ä Þ ßå æ ;¢ 6Ø � ç

(

âè éê ëì) ex

íî ïUncertainty § � Þ ß �� 6Ø + 6Ø � ç

ð ñòóð ñòóð ñòóð ñòó(Uncertainty)

ô õöô õöô õöô õöt ÷ øù ú Ø ûü ûý �þ ÿ �� ü ý � �

(

�� ø�

=>

� ú� � � ��

)t �ü { �� ý � � Ù� ò à �ü �

(

�� u� �

+

��

+

� � { ! �

)t Unexpected Consequence(

" �� #$ %� ù� &'

)t { () ü � �* + , �� Ø-é .} /


� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 234 ô5 67 834 ô5 67 834 ô5 67 834 ô5 67 8

Risk=Likelihood*Severityt 9 : ; y �< => zt ?é @A { () �

(Uncertainty)+

B C

(Objective)=Risk D <E F { () � �{ ()ü � z

(

G : ; yHI JKL m n � �� ) M

)


� � � ��

NONO NONO P Q ¯ °RP Q ¯ °RP Q ¯ °RP Q ¯ °R STST STSTU VWX W YZ [\ ]^ _`` `` a ba ba ba bc dc dc dc d

01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2

e f ¥¦¥¦ ¢ ghi j kl:

Cause mnmn mnmnoo oo pqr st uvpqr st uvpqr st uvpqr st uv

Ex� Z&w xyz { M ! 8|}~ ��

Risk �� r� � �� r� � �� r� � �� r��

Ex� �� < � �X�1� �� ¡

Effect �� ¢ �£ ¤¢ �£ ¤¢ �£ ¤¢ �£ ¤

Ex� / ,¥¦ < §¨© ª

«¬ gh ®¯°± ² ³´ µ ¶· ¸¹ º»¼ ½¾ ¿À Á Â¹ Ã°± ² ³´ µ ¶· ¸¹ º»¼ ½¾ ¿À Á Â¹ ÃÄÅ¼ ½Æ ¾ ¿À Á¹ ÇÈÉ ÊË Ì µ ¶· ¸ÄÅ¼ ½Æ ¾ ¿À Á¹ ÇÈÉ ÊË Ì µ ¶· ¸


� � � ��

¯ °R Í Î aÏ Ð¯ °R Í Î aÏ Ð¯ °R Í Î aÏ Ð¯ °R Í Î aÏ Ð

Event A’s Risk ²² ²² Likelihood ³³ ³³ Severity

ÑÒ ÑÒ

-

ÓÔÕÖ ×Ø

/

ÙÚ ÛÜ

/

ÝÞßàáâ ãäå æç èé ê ëáâ ãäå æç èé ê ëáâ ãäå æç èé ê ëáâ ãäå æç èé ê ë ìíî ïð ñ ñóòõôöø÷

Y/N

ùõú

CPF

ûýü

NAE

þõÿ��

��

(E)15810

��

(P) 1510

��

(S)ABCD

þ ÿ � �� (

�� !)

" #$ %& '( ) *+ ,-

Visual Photonics Epitaxy Co., Ltd.

./ 01 23 45 65 65 65 67 89 :; <= >? @ AB CDDetection &

Protection E FG H I <J K LM NO ? PQ RS TU V

Likelihood W

Severity

XY

(

Z [Z [Z [Z [

&

\] ^_ à b cd ef gh ij k\] ^_ à b cd ef gh ij k\] ^_ à b cd ef gh ij k\] ^_ à b cd ef gh ij k

)

01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2


� � � ��

l m nl m nl m nl m n

Cause o pq r st u vw xy r Risk o z {| }} }} Effect ~~ ~~ ��

01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2


� � � ��


Cause

�� }} }} �� }} }} Risk ~~ ~~ � �� }} }} Effect ~~ ~~ ��

01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2Cause ��

Risk ��

Effect �� ¡� ¢ £¡� ¢ £¡� ¢ £¡� ¢ £


� � � ��


Cause

�� }} }} �� }} }} Risk ~~ ~~ � �� }} }} Effect ~~ ~~ ��

01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2


� � � ��

¤¥ ¯ ° Í ¦ R ¤¤¥ ¯ ° Í ¦ R ¤¤¥ ¯ ° Í ¦ R ¤¤¥ ¯ ° Í ¦ R ¤

Case §§ §§ ¨© Í ¦ R ¤ ª« ¬¨© Í ¦ R ¤ ª« ¬¨© Í ¦ R ¤ ª« ¬¨© Í ¦ R ¤ ª« ¬ ®¯ ° ±² ³´ µ ¶ ·¸ ¯ ¹ º

»¼

/

½¾

: ¿À

Á

Â

CPF NAE

Ã

A

ÄÅ

WS

Æ Ç

WR

ÈÉ

TA

Ê Ç

ER

ËÌ

PC

Í Î

m

Ï Ð

d

ÑÒ

ch

ÓÔe

ÕÖo

×Øv

ÙÚr

Û Üt

ÝÞ

oe

ßà

x

áâ

hãä

(N)åãä

(A)æç

(E)

èé êëì í î ïðñ ò óôõ ö÷ø ù ëì í îúû üôý þ ÿ� ��

� � �

/

��

�

:

Event A’s Risk ²² ²² frequency ³³ ³³ Likelihood ³³ ³³ Severity ³³ ³³ � ��

� �� ! "# $ %& '( )* +, -. /0 1Event

2

34 34

-

56 78 9:

/

;< =>

/

?@A BCD EF GH I JK L MCD EF GH I JK L MCD EF GH I JK L MCD EF GH I JK L M NOP QR S SUTWVXZY

Y/N

[W\CPF

]_^NAE

`WaZbcWdZe

fWgh_i

jWkZlm

(E)15810

nZopmWqWr

(P) 1510

stWuvZw x

(S)ABCD

` a b cyz

(

{|} b~ st uv w x��

)

� ��

Visual Photonics Epitaxy Co., Ltd.

01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2


� � � ��

� � ��

event

�� ¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� ��

� �� -. � �, � "¡ ¢£ ¤¥ ¦, § ¨ ¤2455VPEC

© ª« ¬ ®¯ ° � ¦ � � -. ±² ¤³ ´ ¤

2455VPEC

µ¶ ¬ ®¯ ° � · � � -. ±² ¤³ ´ ¤Risk ²² ²² Severity ³³ ³³ Likelihood ³³ ³³ frequency

¸¹ Risk ²² ²² Severity ³³ ³³ Likelihood º Safety

Hint:

»¼

/

½¾ ¿À »Á

Detection/Protection=>

Â Ã

SafetyEvent:

ÄÅ ÆÇ È É

½¾ ½Ê

/

ËÌ ÍÎÏ ÐÑ ÒÓ ÔÕ

=>Â Ã

FrequencyEvent:

ÔÕ Ö× ØÙHow ? Improvement

Ú ÛÜ ÝÚ ÛÜ ÝÚ ÛÜ ÝÚ ÛÜ ÝÞÞ ÞÞ Ú ßà áÚ ßà áÚ ßà áÚ ßà á ââ ââ


� � � ��

� � ��

event

�� ¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� ��

½¾

/

»¼ ¿À ÄÅ ãä åæ ç èé ç êë ìí îï ðñ Éò ó ô¹

Risk ²² ²² Severity ³³ ³³ Likelihoodõ Â Ã

Safety

g h ög h ög h ög h ö

=>Detection/

÷ø ùú # � ûüûü ûüûü ý ± /þ , ÿ� � �ÿ� � �ÿ� � �ÿ� � �

=>Protection

� �� 1� � 2# � � � � � ý ± /þ ÿ� �� ÿ� �� ÿ� �� ÿ� �� Hint:

»¼/

½¾ ¿À »Á


Â Ã

SafetyEvent:

ÄÅ ÆÇ È É

½¾ ½Ê

/


=>Â Ã

FrequencyEvent:



� � � ��

� � ��

event

�� ¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� �¯ ° Í Î� ��

½¾ ½Ê ÔÕ

/

»¼

PM

�� Ï ÐÑ ÒÓ ÔÕ ãä � Ô �� ò �� ì� Õ �í îïðñ Éò ó ô� �Ñ ¹

Risk ²² ²² Severity ³³ ³³ Likelihoodõ Â Ã

Frequency

g h ög h ög h ög h ö 1 ! ( ", #$ ¦% « & '( ) 2

=>

ÔÕ * +, -

/

ÔÕ ./ , �/

0 12 ÔÕ

/

34 5 ôò 67 89 ý ± :; , ÿ� � �ÿ� � �ÿ� � �ÿ� � �

=>

ÒÓ <= >? � ÔÕ @A <= BC í D E 2 89 ý ± :; /þ ÿ � � �� ÿ � � �� ÿ � � �� ÿ � � �� »¼

/

½¾ ¿À »Á


Â Ã

SafetyEvent:

ÄÅ ÆÇ È É

½¾ ½Ê

/


=>Â Ã

FrequencyEvent:



� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2

Documentation Reviews

FG HI

1.1J BK L FG

(

M NO PQ RS

/

TUFG òSOP=Risk)

1.2

J FG V/ ì WX ç YZ [ò \ ]

1.3

J � Ô^ _/ ì WX

(WBS: work breakdown structure)

PS

¹@ 3 ì` ab c d ef gh F ij

c k ìl mn o <p q r Ps tu vwx 0 ðy í îb z [

*

{ |} ~


� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2

Checklist Analysis@ 3 ì` a� B� L�� b � � Â


� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2

s �� ç �» �G <= b z��

( �What if )


� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2

�� } ��

: 4M+1E(

�� ¡ ¢

…)


� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2

5.

£ ¤¥ó ô �¦

event tree

¸

why tree § � ¨© ª« ì¬ £ ¤u v

b c ® ¯meta language analysis


� � � �� 01 Ô Õ Ì Í 2 °±

• SW

< ² ` ç ³´ �´ l• OT

<µ ` w ¶ . �·•

§S

¸¹O

•

º»T

Ð¼W

½¾ ¿À ¸ÁÂ• SWOT

� <Ã Ä � P h 5± ÅÆ

• SWOT

V/ Çp _ È ìÉÊ Ô §


� � � �� Ì ÍÔ Õ ËÌ Î ÍÎ

1


� � � �� Ì ÍÔ Õ ËÌ Î ÍÎ

1

d e P h ìí îÏ A w ÐÂ ÑÒ

(

ÓÔ ÕÖ× ì

)

Ø É

@ 3 ì` aw Ù < ¨© Pb ÚÛ í îÜ c ÝÞ

…


� � � ��

ß �à ¨© � ì � � Pstu vw á �» â� ãäå æ Íd e P h �ç ìí îè [Ü cu é

Ì ÍÔ Õ ËÌ Î ÍÎ

2


� � � �� Ì ÍÔ Õ ËÌ Î ÍÎ

2


� � � ��

êë � ì íî ï

ðòñ ó ôõ ö ÷ø ù úû üýþ ÿ ��

�ñ �� ý

Ì ÍÎ � �


� � � ��

� �� ¯ °R �� ¯ °R �� ¯ °R �� ¯ °R �� ø ! " üý # $% &' ( )* + ,

Ì ÍÎ � �


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ � �

- ./ T d0 R 12 34- ./ T d0 R 12 34- ./ T d0 R 12 34- ./ T d0 R 12 34

Avoidüü üü 567 8

=>

9: ;< ;=> ? @A BC(

DEFG

)

Transferüü üü HIJ KL

=>

MNO P QR HST U VWJ XYZ [\ ] ^_ `ab c Q

Mitigateüü üü de <f g @ ?hi jk lJ m no pqr

=>

`st J u vwxAcceptüü üü yzJ {|

=>

}~ �J �� V�� J ��(

� ��

)


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ � �

-� � R 12 34-� � R 12 34-� � R 12 34-� � R 12 34


� � � ��

� ��

Further Thinking

¯ °± ²³ ´ µ± ¶ � · ¸¹ º» # ù « % ÷ª õ ¥ ¬


� � � ��

� ��

Further Thinking


� � � ��

ì í¼ ½� ¾ � ¿ ÀÁ ÂÃ Ä ÅÆ Ç ÈÁ ÂÃ Ä ÅÆ Ç ÈÁ ÂÃ Ä ÅÆ Ç ÈÁ ÂÃ Ä ÅÆ Ç È

Further Thinking


� � � ��


Further Thinking


� � � ��


Further Thinking

É ®¯ ÊË Ì Í $ ÎÏ ÐÑ ÒÓ ÔÕ Ö × ¯ Ø Ù -. , Ú ( ÛÜ ¤

É ÝÞ ßà áâ ãä å æ å ç &è é é æè é éê ë $ ìí -. î ï , ðñ ò ¤

É ®¯ ÊË $ "ó , ôõ -. ¤ ö á, -. ÷ø " ùú ûü ý �, þ ¨ ¤


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ ÿ �

�� í î ��Ð� � �� ç u Á ç u ��

Â� P h � Õ ª� ç �� F· ç ÕÖ ì ° Ð [ ç Ô Ó ì� Ë

….d e P h �ç ìí îè [Ü cu é


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ ��


� � � �� Ì ÍÎ ��

Ò [ �� ç P� � P� �


� � � �� Ì Í ÒÓ Î ��

� ! "

#$! "

! "%&

'() * + ,-. / 012

! "

(

3 +

=

3 "

+

+ ,

)

456 7 * 89 :; (

<=) >?@ A

B

CDE F * GHI HJ K LM

Uncertainty + Goal=Risk R=f(Probability N Impact)

#OP Q

+

4 $R 3S

R=S*L TU 9 V

Meta-Language+ Cause, Risk, Effect Documentation Reviews Checklist Analysis Assumptions Analysis WXY

Z[Y

SWOT

\]

^_! "`a Ab O

cd efg hij * Uk j l

Semi, FM, NFPA What If

FTA/ETA FMEA * HazOp mn b Oo p

^_! " Aqr

st AuwvLx

! "yz {|} * c d ~� * �� * �� * ��

! " yz {|} * cd ~� * �� * �� * �� cd T�

^_ ` a �� A|�

^_ `a t� A ��


� � � �� Questions

risk management comparison

Business

project risk management

nopmqr p

hi p cause risk effect

notion of risk

risk h2

hi p s q

hi p sw

event ef d