rio madeira run-of-river hydro projectssome examples of run-of-river hydro projects • in france on...

31
RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS SEDIMENT TRANSPORT MANAGEMENT Sultan Alam Independent Consultant

Upload: others

Post on 27-Feb-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVERHYDRO PROJECTS

SEDIMENT TRANSPORT MANAGEMENT

Sultan AlamIndependent Consultant

Page 2: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

MAIN CHARACTERISTICS OFRUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS

• Water and sediment transport through the upper pool is very similar to the initial river flow conditions

• Practically no stagnation zone in themain channel

• Ensure long project life without any significant sedimentation in the upper pool unlike large dams and reservoirs

Page 3: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

SOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVERHYDRO PROJECTS

• In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20 to 50 years ago with 10 to 50 m head

• Pak Mun in Thailand was built 25 years ago

• Sidney A. Murray off the Mississippi River in Louisiana was built 16 years ago

• All of them are operatingsatisfactorily

Page 4: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 5: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 6: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 7: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 8: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 9: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

PARTICLE SIZE DISTRIBUTION

Composição granulométrica da carga Sedimentar do rio Madeira na região dos AHE Santo Antônio e Jirau

%

85

141

Argila e SilteAreia Fina (< 1 mm)Areia Média e Grossa (< 2 mm)

Page 10: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

SEDIMENT TRANSPORT MECHANISM

• Under existing conditions andwith the proposed hydro projectssilt and clay component of thesediment materials are alwaysmoving in suspension

• This means that sands depositedon the river bed will always benon cohesive and will be put intosuspension as soon as the local shear velocity is adequate

Page 11: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 12: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

C0NTINUOUS SEDIMENT SAMPLING

• Since 1991 a continuous sedimentsampling installation is being used atOld River Complex on the LowerMississippi River and at Sidney A. Murray run-of-river hydro station

• These installations have enabled us to obtain precise information on thetotal sediment transport process ofthe Mississippi River at this location

Page 13: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 14: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 15: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

0

5 000

10 000

15 000

20 000

25 000

30 000

35 000

40 000

45 000

50 000

01/01

/8201

/02/82

01/03

/82

01/04

/8201

/05/82

01/06

/8201

/07/82

01/08

/82

01/09

/8201

/10/82

01/11

/8201

/12/82

Data

Vazõ

es (m

³/s)

Guajará-MirimAbunãAbunã - Guajará-MirimPorto Velho

Page 16: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

0

500

1.000

1.500

2.000

2.500

3.000

3.500

4.000

0 5.000 10.000 15.000 20.000 25.000 30.000 35.000 40.000 45.000 50.000

Descarga Líquida (m³/s)

Con

cent

raçã

o (m

g/l)

ANA FURNAS (Segunda Campanha)

Page 17: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

0

5 000

10 000

15 000

20 000

25 000

30 000

35 000

40 000

45 000

50 000

01/01

/8201

/02/82

01/03

/82

01/04

/8201

/05/82

01/06

/8201

/07/82

01/08

/82

01/09

/8201

/10/82

01/11

/8201

/12/82

Data

Vazõ

es (m

³/s)

Guajará-MirimAbunãAbunã - Guajará-MirimPorto Velho

Page 18: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 19: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

Shear velocity u* = (ghi)0.5

• In computing the shear velocities we have used the energy gradient i correspondingto steady flow conditions.

• For variable flow with the increasing flood discharge the instantaneous value of i andconsequently u* will be much more andsand particles will go into suspension earlier with lesser discharges

• So the values of w/u* in the report are rather conservative

Page 20: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

FLUSHING OF FINE SANDS

• Non cohesive fine sand can beflushed very quickly as shown by the continuous recording of thesediment concentration at theauxiliary sediment diversion channel at the Old River Complexof the lower Mississippi River

Page 21: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 22: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 23: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 24: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

CONCLUSION

• The sediment transport patterns of Rio Madeira will not be radically modified due to the construction of the proposed lowhead run-of-river hydro projects

• Annual sediment deposition and erosionwill continue to occur as at present and a new equilibrium of sediment transport from upstream to downstream will beestablished

Page 25: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 26: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

• As sediment and hydrologicalcharacteristics are the same at bothSant Antônio and Jirau projects theywill be subjected to same kind ofevolution with minimum negativeenvironmental impacts

Page 27: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20
Page 28: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

PLANTA DO RESERVATÓRIO DA AHE JIRAU

Page 29: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

MITIGATION MEASURES

• Necessary site specific measureswould have to be developed to mitigate local drainage and floodingproblems

• In the long run a new main channelcross section will be established withbankfull flow conditions

Page 30: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

STATE-OF-THE-ARTHYDRAULIC MODELLING

• ADEQUATE HYDRAULIC MODEL STUDIES MUST BE CARRIED OUT TO ESTABLISH THE BEST PROJECT LAYOUT AGAINST SEDIMENTATION NEAR THE STRUCTURES

• TO DEFINE OPTIMUM FLOATING DEBRIS HANDLING ARRANGEMENT

• TO AVOID AIR ENTRAINING VORTEX FORMATION

Page 31: RIO MADEIRA RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTSSOME EXAMPLES OF RUN-OF-RIVER HYDRO PROJECTS • In France on the Rhône River and its tributaires there are 22 run-of-river projets built 20

MANY THANKS