8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

1/12

Request for Explanation in CivilProcedure:

1

K H M E R S E M I N A R

D A T E : N O V E M B E R 0 6 2 0 0 9

M O D E R A T O R : H E N G M O L Y Y A N E T H

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

2/12

WHAT IS CIVIL PROCEDURE ?

2

- Inqu s tor a ystem:

- Adversary System: ean ng eta e spects

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

3/12

Adversary System

y

3

(Whose Duty?)

y Principle 2 : Effect of Admission

(Admission in Civil Matters=?)

y Principle 3 : Prohibition of Examination of Evidence b Own Authorit(Whose Authority?)

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

4/12

Adversar S stem--Oral Ar ument4

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

5/12

Oral Argument

ruc ura eve o v roce ure5

CLAIM

EVIDENCE S

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

6/12

Oral Argument

ases o u gmen n ase u y 6

10.000$

EVIDENCE(S)

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

7/12

Re uest for Ex lanation7

y Definition of Re uest for Ex lanation-Legal Definition: Cam. & JP Code of Civil Procedure

-

y Role of Request for Explanation

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

8/12

Cotem orar Theories 1

8

y eques or xp ana on as an ar o c v es

y Request for Explanation as Courts Authority

y Request for Explanation as Courts Obligation

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

9/12

Cotemporary Theories (1) Standard of Activities

9

-Understanding of Assertion-Le al Meanin of Asserted Fact-Disputed Points Arrangement-* one point here is skipped

y Request for Explanation Related to Extinctive

* Skip this point

y equest or xp anat on re ate to roo an v ence( )

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

10/12

Cotem orar Theories 110

y Re uest for Ex lanation as CourtsDiscretion ( p 112)

y Re uest for Ex lanation as CourtsDuty ( p 113)

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

11/12

Discussion uestionsCase of Cambodia

11

y a appens our oes no xerc se a g

to Request for Explanation?Scope of Duty

y What Happens if Court Violates Duty to Request for

Explanation ?Limitation of Authority

y Current Challenging Issues ?

y What are the Possible Solutions pertaining thereto ?

3/5/2010

8/14/2019 Right to Request for Explanation-KHZemi [Slides]

12/12

THX 4 UR ATTENTION !

12

3/5/2010