rf enabled temperature monitors (may 2009)...
TRANSCRIPT
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 1 (May 2009)
RF Enabled Temperature Monitoring (Transportation Cold Chain Mgt)
Transportation & Transfer of Biologics • April 28th, 2009 • RFID Live
Dave Ulrich QA Director – GPO Distribution
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 3 (May 2009)
Agenda
– Background on RF – RF and RF-enabled temperature monitoring devices – RF – Biologic Study (FDA CPG)
– Why do the pilot and what were the goals
– RF hardware and supporting infrastructure – Implementation issues and challenges
– Time Out of Refrigeration (TOR) and Mexico goal details
– General pilot protocol
– RF-Pilot Results
– Conclusion
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 4 (May 2009)
Definition of Radio Frequency 4
Radio frequency (RF) is a term that refers to alternating current (AC) having characteristics such that, if the current is input to an antenna, an electromagnetic (EM) field is generated suitable for wireless communications at a frequency of about 3Hz to 300GHz
RF Range
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 5 (May 2009)
Active-Tag use on Airplanes
• TempTale® RF-enabled (RF) temperature monitoring devices operate within a mesh networking environment and interact only with Sensitech’s ColdStream Infrastructure components;
• RF operates within the 915 or 868 MHz ISM band (Industrial, Scientific and Medical) for optimal transmission in high water-content product situations
• While RF is a Class 4 Active Tag - it is not a beaconing tag;
– A RF monitor will never transmit until it has detected that it is within the immediacy of an active ColdStream infrastructure, i.e. an operational RF Gateway and/or Repeater;
– TempTale® RF-enabled temperature monitoring devices are compliant with Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) requirements for electronic devices.
• Lithium Ion batteries used in these active tags are exempt from FAA regulations limiting their transport
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 6 (May 2009) 6
Is RF Safe vs. a Biologic (proteins, enzymes, hormones, etc)
• FDA CPG does not support utilizing RF on biologics and proteins
• So far there has been no specific studies done to assure anyone that the use of RF technologies is safe to use on biologic products
• Executed a study with a vendor of RF antenna and reader technology
• RF – Bio Study Objective – Demonstrate that active bio-pharmaceutical ingredients would not be
affected by exposure to energy in the RF (radio frequency) range. – Two (2) syringe lots filled with a immunoglobulin were utilized to
conduct the test – All antibodies are proteins - but not all proteins are antibodies.
6
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 7 (May 2009)
Expected Results
Antibody
Active Site 1 nm wide
Radio frequency wave length for this study was 32.9 cm and the wave length of the monoclonal antibody is 1 nm.
The energy for the RF wave length cannot resonate within the active region of the monoclonal antibody.
There should be no non-heat effect on the antibody.
7 of 19
Antibody (IgG, IgM, etc) Immunoglobulin
Theory is that RF is not ionizing, therefore there should be no effect on the biologic
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 8 (May 2009)
Definition of Radio Frequency 8
Radio frequency (RF) is a term that refers to alternating current (AC) having characteristics such that, if the current is input to an antenna, an electromagnetic (EM) field is generated suitable for wireless communications at a frequency of about 3Hz to 300GHz
RF Range
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 9 (May 2009) 9
Test Materials Divided product into three (3) sets of syringes
A) Samples remained at mfg’ing site B) Samples sent to RF vendor, but not exposed to RF C) Samples sent to RF vendor, exposed to RF
Syringes were sent to RF Vendor via overnight delivery. – Total of 18 syringes were delivered, nine (9) for sample group B, nine (9) for group C – Each group contained 3 syringes from each of the product lots – Packaging ensured maintenance of the required 2°C - 8°C for preservation. – The TempTale (temperature monitor data logger) which accompanied the product indicated no out of range alarm condition.
Prior to the formal exposure process, product was stored under recommended conditions, off-site to ensure that no extraneous RF exposure occurred. – The TempTale accompanied the 18 syringes in both transit and storage.
9
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 10 (May 2009)
RF Energy Study Conclusions
• Purity & Stability analysis showed no significant affect of RF exposure on the protein (the biologic)
– There was no "non-heat" effect – Purity of the drug product from all 3 conditions were equivalent
as assessed by purity assays – The only effect observed during the RF dosing and testing was a
insignificant heat input to the product – This minor temp increase caused no measurable effect as
observed during the stability testing
• RF poses no ionizing radiation effect
10 of 19
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 11 (May 2009)
Why do this Shipping Pilot?
1. Elimination of manual manipulation of temp recording devices
2. Minimize human action of data collection
3. Leverage remote capture of temp data/alarms
4. Allow for early intervention based upon timely accurate temps/alarms
5. Troubleshoot shipping lanes
6. Observe effects of different pack-outs easier
7. Confirm manufacturing TOR is acceptable
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 12 (May 2009)
Pilot Goals
1. To automate the manufacturing TOR data collection using a RF enabled temperature monitor device;
2. To assist 1) multiple manufacturing sites and 2) supply chains to collate TOR data, with a focus on Mexico
3. Use this info for commercial supply chain temperature data management (for typical supply chain temperature excursions).
• Limited to 100 RF TempTales (approximately 20 shipments)
– Note pilot worked this commercial lane is now RF
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 13 (May 2009)
Pilot Set up and Data Review
Three Lanes:
• Mfg’ing Process
• Bulk PFS Europe to US
• Commercial Product from Europe to Mexico
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 14 (May 2009)
RF Features / Typical RF Download
RF Features • Full TempTale temperature
recording and alarming
• Location tracking
• 300 feet (line of site) read range
• Inexpensive reader infrastructure
• Automatic alarm notification by email
• Network uses data encryption
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 15 (May 2009)
Results RF-Pilot
Automatic alarm notification by email.
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 16 (May 2009)
RF Pilot Hardware
• The following hardware is used for shipments of: 1. Unfinished product from Germany to U.S. 2. Finished product from Germany to Mexico 3. Mfg’ing TOR
• 1 Signpost at Germany TPM (Marks beginning of temp recording between manufacturing and transport to Amsterdam airport)
• 1 Signpost at Amsterdam airport (Marks beginning of transport leg to U.S. or Mexico)
• 1 Gateway at Abbott Final Packaging Facility (Marks recording of packaging TOR) • 1 Repeater at Abbott bulk receiving area (Marks receiving of unfinished product
from Netherlands) • 1 Signpost at Abbott Distribution Center (Marks beginning of transport to Mexico) • 1 Gateway at Mexico 3PL Distribution Center (Marks receiving of finished product
from either Amsterdam or Abbott DC) • 1 Signpost at Mexico Airport Customs area (Marks entry into the country) • 2 Control PCs connected to Gateways at Mexico DC and Abbott Packaging
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 17 (May 2009)
1. Implementation Issues and Challenges • Installation at TPM
– TPM made it challenging to install the RF equipment;
– A site survey was completed with a spectrum analyzer;
– ColdStream training was completed in local language;
– The substitution of TempTale4 for the RFTT posed no issues with packaging and distribution – seamless transition.
• Testing of Read Rates using multiple Packaging Configurations
– Tested multiple monitor placement protocols on multiple shipments from TPM to Abbott;
– Three pack outs across three box sizes (small, medium, and large) each with two monitors 100% Read Rate.
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 18 (May 2009)
2. Implementation Issues and Challenges (cont.)
• Affiliate’s IT Department
– Established strict computer requirements – hindered installation of Gateway control PC and ColdStream software
• Regional Operations within Abbott
– Challenging communication across different groups within Abbott including: Germany, Netherlands, Mexico and US;
– Third parties involved eg. TPM, warehouses, freight forwarders, customs and airports;
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 19 (May 2009)
3. Implementation Issues and Challenges (cont.)
• Third Party Warehouse Facility
– Installation of computer went smoothly but computer (laptop) was removed by Third Party representative;
– Finding right frequency because of location close to airport;
– At delivery of RFTT-monitors in warehouse all monitors were automatically activated due to system settings;
• Obtaining RF Downloads
– To collect reads on inbound receipt to warehouse facility in Mexico needed to allow packages to remain in immediacy of reader infrastructure for a minimum of 15 min – assuming 40 or less monitors received simultaneously;
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 20 (May 2009)
4. Implementation Issues and Challenges (cont.)
• Certification of RF equipment by Mexican government – already had approval in Europe
– Charge for provisional certification – monitors, gateways, repeaters, signposts;
• Requirements to install a Signpost in Mexico Customs and Ministry of Health staging areas
– Restricted or no access to facilities;
– Not able to install equipment in advance of project start date.
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 21 (May 2009)
Focus on Mexico Goal
Allow better and quicker visibility to data • Supply chain temperature excursions are a reality
• Few seen in manufacturing shipping and control • Many seen in distribution to international facilities
• Assist with the customs import issues at our affiliate
Release Process • Product release by MOH can take up to 3 weeks. Without
RF there is no access to temp data • With RFTT we now have access to the monitor data
without opening the containers in order to make timely decisions on temp excursions
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 22 (May 2009)
Europe – Mexico
• Shipment Route (Segments Recorded)
• Amsterdam Schiphol Airport (AMS)
• Air Shipment Amsterdam, Schiphol Airport – Mexico City (Transit 1)
• Mexican Customs
• Ground Shipment Customs – Abbott Mexico (Transit 2)
• Abbott Mexico
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 23 (May 2009)
Trip Segmentation and Summary Statistics Transit 1: Schiphol Airport – Mexico City
Schiphol Airport Customs: Mexico City
Transit 2: Customs – Abbott Facility
Abbott Facility: Mexico City
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 24 (May 2009)
Internal Shipment Multi Graph
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 25 (May 2009)
External Shipment Multi Graph
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 26 (May 2009)
Observations
• With the exception of 2 spikes in the data internal monitors stayed relatively stable within the shipping lane
• Shipments at Schiphol Airport and in the Facility in Mexico see the largest amount of variability in trip length
• Mexican Customs has a very consistent time limit with the exception of two spikes
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 27 (May 2009)
TPM – Abbott Lake County Manufacturing
• Shipment Route (Segments Recorded) TPM
• Ground Shipment: TPM – Amsterdam, Schiphol Airport (Transit 1)
Amsterdam Schiphol Airport (AMS)
• Air Shipment: Amsterdam, Schiphol Airport–Chicago, O’Hare Airport (Transit 2)
Chicago, O’Hare
• Ground Shipment: Chicago O’Hare Manufacturing (Transit 3)
• Abbott Lake County Manufacturing
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 28 (May 2009)
Trip Segmentation and Summary Statistics Transit 1: TPM- Sciphol Airport
Sciphol Airport O’Hare Airport
Transit 2: Sciphol – O’Hare
Abbott LC Manuf
Transit 3: O’Hare – Abbott LC Manuf
TPM
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 29 (May 2009)
Internal Shipment Multi Graph
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 30 (May 2009)
External Shipment Multi Graph
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 31 (May 2009)
Observations
• With the acceptation of Chicago, O’Hare, all internal segments experienced temperatures below 2.0°C
• Transit 3 (O’Hare – Abbott AP-16) and Abbot AP-16 were the internal segments that experienced a maximum temperature above 8.0°C. Those excursions happened at the beginning and end of the trip.
• Monitors that were labeled external experienced very stable temperatures throughout the trips
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 32 (May 2009)
Conclusion – The Pilot was a Success
It worked! Mexico - Mexico received 8 shipments with RF monitors – first results look good - Mexico wants to proceed with RF monitoring from pilot to routine use - Effective Corrective Action capability now with early availability of
temperature monitoring results
General - Infrastructures are ready - RF-monitors generated reliable, timely data - Pilot partner, Sensitech, was a team player and provided valuable
resources throughout the entire pilot to help ensure its success
RF Enabled Temperature Monitors 33 (May 2009) rfidjournalevents.com/presentations