reviewer: janna f. envelope: 1163836 submitted: … number: pc-2017-3856 filed in providence/bristol...

Case Number: PC-2017-3856Filed in Providence/Bristol County Superior CourtSubmitted: 8/18/2017 10:43:11 AMEnvelope: 1163836Reviewer: Janna F.

! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

&+,- -.


/ ! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

. $ 0&11 2 3 "4 - *

% 5 4

!& . 6-$ & % $-1 &’!7 $1 8 7 -9& .-$1

’ 5 )* 1 4 & :* 5 ’ ; 8 4 11 7 < ’ (4 ! 4 ’- =

’& ! * ) "5 , 5 ! > ’ ? - ’

9 ’ 5

& 5 > ( ; " ; 5 > 5 > > 5 " ; ; ) 4 ; ) 4

.5 $ 6 4 (5 5 5 > ; " > 5 " ? 5 > ; > 5 *

.5 ( " " 5 " 2 5 $ ; 0 "4 - * 5 5 ; 5 5 " ( 5 5 ; > ! # #@ A > 5 - ’ > = 4 4 ! @ A > 5 & " ’ - ! $ > = #4 @B&’-!$CA* $ ; 5 5 " 4 5 D " > . - -6 >&’-!$*

D > 5 : > * ! & D *

! 4

E E E E $ 6* F 9 > 9 G G 9 " < H ; " ; "* I $# $ $6F

&

) >> $* 4 4 J $4 .5 $ ; K 0 "4 - * @( A


! " ! # $%

LLD , , & " ************************************************ ’ ( > ) *

! * ) "5 , 5 ! > ’5 - ’

$ 6 > ) 4

5 M ; ; ) 4

& ; ) 4

"

.5 $ ; K 0 "4 - * $

& 4 ’- = # # # =

% 5


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

.$ 1& 7 7 .& .!

1$ !.$.3!

-* - .’793 .-7 ****************************************************************************************************************

--* 6$13$.-7 ’&!31.! > M & ; ) 4 ******************************************************* $ >) -4 ***************************************** $ 6 > $ G ************************************************#

---* !3% % $’M 7 1$ ’76-!-7 ! ! > ******************************************************************************************

-6* $ .3$’-$1 % &.,79! $ % 5 ************************************************************************************************* $ 6 % 5 ************************************ 5 ; - $ % 5 *****************************************************************************

6* $ .3$’-$1 $!!3% .-7 ! $ " 3 .5 M ************************************************************

7 !. 9&6&17 % & .

$ & 9-+ $ 9 " > ************************************************************************

$ & 9-+ 9 " > G *********************************************************************** #

$ & 9-+ 9 " > $ I 6 > $ ***************************************************

$ & 9-+ 9 " 9 **********************************************************************************************


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

-* - .’793 .-7

.5 " " 5 > 5 > ) 4 > 5 ! * ) "5 , 5 ! > ’5 - ’ * .5 " " " > 5 " ; ; ) 4 ; ) 4 * .5 " " > 5 "

- 5 " > 5 " * > " " G * > (5 5 ( 5 " " ; 5 "" "

> 5 " * 7 5 " 5 * ! ? 5 > ( > " ( 5 "" "

" 5 : *

.5 5 ; 5 ? ; G * > 5 NG N 5 ; > ; ( " ; " 5 " > D" ; 5 > " > < O * - ; 5 5 ( " 5 " > 5 " ; ) 4 *

.5 ( " " 5 " 2 5 $ ; K 0 "4 - * 5 5 ; 5 5 " ( 5 5 ; > ! # #@ A > 5 - ’ > = 4 4 ! @ A > 5 & " ’ - ! $ > = #4 @B&’-!$CA* $ ; 5 5 " 4 5 D " > . - -6 > &’-!$*

.5 ( " " 5 > > .5 $ ; K 0 "4 - * 5 > > " 4 ( " ; 5 " 5 " " 4 ( " " ( 5 > ; 4 ( 5 > " * E 5 " G 4 ( < " 4 5 > 5 > *

.5 5 > ; 5 > " 5 5 5 P ; 5 P > 5 > < > " * .5 ( 5 ; " 5 5 > 5 > < *

- 5 : G ! > 5 $ $ > $ 5 " 5 " 4 " 4 D" ; *

2 @ )% I% P % E % 5 4

! ’* & 4 &*$*4 % *$*$*$* 9 & $ E % E $ 6* F 9 > 9 G G 9 "


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

,* 6$13$.-7 ’&!31.!

> M & ; ) 4

% Q 4 4 #

’ Q#4 ==4 =

5 P > ; " R 5 > 5 " Q# 4 4#

! > 6 ’

"

$ # K . == 4 # ’ " 4 = 4 7 5 @ ; " " A . 4 # 4 =

9 Q Q " $ $ $ " ; > " $ $

% ?

9 Q 4 4 # Q 4 # 4 $ " ; > " $ $

$

% < 6 Q 4 4 # Q = 4# 4 # $ 6 = 4 4 #= 4# 4 = > < / * P * P > #* P * #P @ / P A


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$ > ) 4

< > $

. 6 > $

$ 6 > $

. % < 6 > $ ’

$ R $ 6

1 G

1 $

1 - $

$ 6 > $

4 #

4 4 #

4 4 #

4 4=

$

= 4 4 #=


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$ 6 > $ G

.5 " > " G > " " > " * .5 > " ( > $ ; ! G . " = @B$! = C4 " < ( ! $! A* - ; ; > ; " ; " *

.5 G; " ( " " (5 5 O 5 ; > ; ; " * .5 " 5 ( " 5 5 ( " 5 " ; 5 > 5 > 5 * .5 " 5 " " " * .5 " ; ( " G ( 5 . 4 5 -’! ; 4 ( ; 5 ;5 5 5 G; 5 ( (*

.5 > 5 5 " ! 6 > 5 " D " 5 " 5 "" *

6 > ) 4

. > 6 6

1 G G 6

$ 1 # Q 4 4 # Q = 4# Q 4 4 #

6 . - == 4= 4 # 4= 4 #

9 1

’ 1 4 = = 4 4# # = 4 4# #

7 5 @ * " " A 4 # 4 #

. 4 # Q 4 4 Q = 4# Q 4 4


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

! > 5 ; $ G

$ " > " G > 5 "

- @ A ; 5 S

5 ; "

G

- > 5 5 "

G "

@ A

$ " > " G > 5

Q 4#= 4

Q

@ 4 =4 = A

4

=4 4

@ 4 4# #A

Q @ 4 4 A

Q 4 4


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

* !3% % $’M 7 1$ ’76-!-7 ! &>> 9

9 "

& ; ? ’ :

M > ! (?S

M > ! > G $

& R 9

> G

) -4 =

.5 ; 5 5 ( 5 5 ; > ! # # > 5 ! @ A > 5 & " ’ - ! $ @&’-!$A > = #4 *

$; ! 7 M &D $ & " 5 > 7 4 ( " " 5 4 5 5 3 $ " 5 > 7 -4 *

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ! " 4 =*

G $ > > , 5 > @B , CA " " ( > ? ! " 4 *

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ) =4 #

/ 5 " " ; 5 " S > 5 (5 5 " ( 5 4 5 > ( *

! 5 : " > ( 5 5 & " * ) 4 4 > ( > 5 " (5 5 " ( " " 5 " ( " > 4 5 * 7 ) 4 5 " ( " ( 5 ;5 ) -4 * .5 > 4 5 4 5 ( *

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ! " 4 =*

G $ > > , 5 > @B , CA " " ( O ( ! " 4 *

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ) =4 #

$ ; " ( 5 " 5 G > 5 5 > ( ; " > 5 ; : 4

1 >


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

N-* !3% % $’M 7 1$ ’76-!-7 ! @ 7 .29A

’ 9

"

$ ; "

’ G

.5 G > 5 5 ( 5 D > ( ; 5 > ; 5 G> 5 > 5 " " S " " *

N$ & ; N 5 > " 4 D ; " 4 4 ; " * - 5 " > D 5 -’ " G G " @Q 4 > #A*

.5 ; > 5 G 5 ;5 $ & ; ; 5 " ; " S > " *

.5 > G " 5 > > 4 4

* > " > $ ; & ; 4

* > " > 5 ! ! G

.5 >> 5 " 5 > 5 " " S D > *

.5 G 5 Q# * " > 4 D > *

-> " ( ) 4 = 4 5 G 5 5 5 > @ A @ A (

@ A ! G * P > $ & ; " #4 " * P > $ & ; D > Q#4 4 > 5 > > *

@ A ! G * P > $ & ; > 5 > "

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ! " 4 =*

G $ > > , 5 > @B , CA " " ( > ? ! " 4 *


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

- * !3% % $’M 7 1$ ’76-!-7 ! @ 7 .29A

$ G

& ’ G

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ) =4 #*

.5 G " " " S 5 5 " R G " R $ ; & ; > 5 " > *

.5 > 5 GI 5 > 5 5 5 " R > > 5 > ; > 4 5 * .5 > D * .5 " ( > ) 4 5 ; ; ; 4 > 5 " " *

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ! " 4 =*

G $ > > , 5 > @B , CA " " ( > ? ! " 4 *

G $ > 3 " " ( > ? ) =4 #*

3" 5 " > G > 5 > ; G> G 4 " " * , 5 G > > ; ; 5 : 5 G 5 > ( ;

5 ( =P 5 5*

$ 5 O G 5 " P 5 5*

-> 5 " " 5 ;5 / G " 4 @ > ! " 4 = > / 3 " A " 5 > ; @ " 5 A4 5 5 ; > G> / G 5 5 G > > ; ; 5 : 5 G *


/ ! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

- * !3% % $’M 7 1$ ’76-!-7 ! @ 7 .29A

1 ’ G

9 >

6 ;

$ " " 5 " > 5 & " > 5 * - 5 5 ( 5 G ; > 5 *

- 5 > 5 5 > S " " (5 " G > (5 G " 5 4 ( 5 5 " " 5 " > 5 > 54 ( 5 ; 4 ; ; R / 5 > G 5 " " 2 G 4 5 > 5 *

$ " > 4 " 4 G " GI (5 5 " " ( 5 5 ; G> G *

M > 6 ; ! 4 R 5 > ( ; 5

M > ! 6 ;

1 5 P M P

( 5 ; 5 ; 5 4 " " ( P " 5 ; S ’ 9 *


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

-6* $ .3$’-$1 % &.,79!

$ % 5

.5 > " " 5 " " " ; 5 ; * $ $ % 5 4 5 5 ; 5 > " " 4 ; 5 " > * .5 & " ’ - ! $ > = # @&’-!$A " G " 5 * -’! ; ( ; 5 5 *

5 " ( 5 5 $ G @3 A 5 4 S (*

.5 5 > > 5 " " (5 5 5 5 ; * .5 > " " 5 G " > 5 " R G 5 " *

- 4 5 " (5 5 5 " 4 5 G " 4 ? > 5 G * .5 G 5 " > 5 " > 5 " R G 5 " " * .5 > 5 " " 4 5 ; * .5 > 5 >> ( 5 5 > " I

3 5 $ G @3 A % 5 4 5 ; 5 ; > D" ; 5 " " ? ( 5 > ; * - 4 5 ; " " " 5 5 ( " ? *

.5 5 5 5 ! * > - ’ # *

$ 6 % 5

.5 > 5 " ; " : 5 NG / N 5 ; > ; 5 * 3 5 5 4 ; ; ? 5 > P " 4 $ 4 5 " > "" " 5 * .5 ; 5 P ; 5 P > 5 > < > " * & (5 5 "" 5 ; BG C 5 ; 5 ( *

5 ; - $ % 5

5 ; 5 5 5 " " *


/ ! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

6* $ .3$’-$1 $!!3% .-7 !

$ " 3 .5 M

$ " 5 > G) >> ; 5 > 5 " 5 4 ( 5 ( 4 5 ; " 4 ; 4 > ; 4 D" 4 * .5 " 5 5 " 5 ; D" > 5 " * .5 ( > 5 > 5 " 4 : &’-!$*

’ - ’ * P "

’ - ’ * P "

’ % ’ / # & " @% A ( 5 ! % 0 - " >

’ % * ’ # , 5 $ @% A ( 5 ! % /

0 - " > E 5 ( ’ ! > ( 5 ( > (

% . $; % %

* * * * == * ### * # * * * * # * # * # # * = * * * # # * # * * * * * * * # * * *

- 5 4 5 > ( ; 5 > " " ( 5 > ( > (

. . ! ’ ! ’

P P =P = P P 7 P # P P P #P

-


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

6* $ .3$’-$1 $!!3% .-7 ! @ 7 .29A

9 ’

! !

. D E ;

- D*B

&D"

$ ’ $; ; ; ; G> / G 4 5 > ( ;

$;; > ’ * P = * P * P * P * P # * P * P * P = *7P * P

% ! P > " " T ( 5 ; 5 5 5 *

’ ; 1 .5 5 2 " ? > 5 2 > * -> 5 " " R 5 > 5 > 5 M 5 4 > 5 D" ; 5 5 * E 5 5 5 5 " 4 R 5 > ; : > &’-!$4 5 > ; " > ( 5 &’-!$ ; ( 5 ; 5 $ > G *


"" 5 $ ;

% 5 > 5 6 >

$

G *

!& .-7 6

*U

!&1&

.-7 7

$ .3$’-$1 $!!3% .-7 !

$

"

& E5 ! $

> $

" !

5 ; - $

"

9 ’ >

P

.5 $ ; 0 "* - *

.5 - " 5

%

> 5 S

5 "

< < > 5

I .5 > " V5 I

*

- O ’

$

$

1 W - 3 D; *

! !

$

$

G > ? "

- *

. D E

; -

$

-$

G > ? "

- D ( ; 4

V’ # # @ A@ A 1 R

$

$

R - G "

’ %

’ %

’ X # & " ( 5 ! %

; "

> @% A

.5 $ ; 0

"4 - *

.5 ! > $ " 5 >

D" 7 * I .5 ’

/

# " 5 " -5

" 5

< > 3

*!*

" " " D" 4 .5

-3 " R >

"

5 ;5 * .5 ’ #

% . 5 G ;

5 % * # " R > > (

5 " 5 N’ N *

.5 5 - " R >

> ( ( 5 - 0 R

@% A

.5

5 ; > 5 ’ #

& " ( 5 ! %

Y ;

"

> @% A > 5 "

* ) * 4 O 5

" * .5 5 ; 4 ; 5

( 5 5 5 ; "

*

5 6 :

G > 5

* ) * 4 P*

’ / # , 5 $ ( 5 ! %

X

; "

>

@% A

.5 $ ; 0 "* - *

.5 ! > $ " 5 >

D" 7 * * .5 ’

# V " 5 " -5

" 5

< > 3

" " " D" * .5

" R >

"

5 ;5 4 .5 ’ #

% . 5 G ;

5 % # " R > > (

5 " 5 N’ N I

.5 5 " R >

( ( 5 % 0 R

@% A

.5

5 ; > 5 ’ #

, 5 $ ( 5 ! %

; "

> @%- A

> 5 " 4 ) * 4 V

O 5 " 4 .5

5 ; 4 < ; 5 ( 5 5 5 ; "

* 5

6 >$

G > 5

* ) * 4

* P

; 5 5

" *

D" 5 ;

9 %

.5 $ ; W 0 "4 - *

.5

> V5

*

9 ’

.5 $ ; W 0 "* - *

.5 - > 5

*

E 5 (

’

!

.5 $ ; 0 "* - I

;; ;; " D;

’ ’

& " ( -

.5 $ ; W 0 "4 - I

.5 " ( (

>

( 5 5 ( (

D" 5 *

$;

’

$;

’ @

*

*

*

#

*

*

I

*

=

4

= *

*

*

*

%

P

>

P > >

.5 $ ; W 0 "* - *

.5 " ( (

>

*

D" 5 *

$; > !"

.5 >

"

5 .5 $ ; 0 "4 - 4

.5 " ( (

>

D" >

" *

S U

33 >I

-)!%!%!,

=Z=Z=11

7

- $

E6

11 Z 1

117[ J

1 =

" :

"

)

%

U ; "W L

W

"

JJJJS117

[ 7

) :1

==


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$ & 9-+ $ 9 " > .5 K 5 " > " G (5 5 5 " 5 $ % 5 ; * .5 > ( ; " 5 " > 5 5 5 $ % 5 4 5 5 5 " " *

* 6 > G Q $

* $ 6 > $ $

* 3 ? > $ ? @# A 3 > 1 @# #A $

#* ; ! $ @# A S > ( @# #A $

* $ ’ $ @# A $

* 6 > V@ A @ A @ A \ @#A \ @ AK $

* 6 >I " $

* " $

=* V@ A @ A D @ AK

* &D" 1 .

* . V@=A \ @ AK Q


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$ & 9-+ 9 " >

* %

*

*

*

$ > ;

* $

* $ 6 > $

* 3 G $ $ 1 @3$$1A @@ * * * * * *A4 D A

M $ ? > 3$$1

- @ * D @1 * \ * *AA

% V@ * * \ * * \ * *A4 > * * ] AK

* ’

M $ ? > 3$$1*

- @ * D @ * * \ * *AA

!

’ @; > @ A @ A4 5 A

#

) 4

4 4

= 4 4 #=

4 4

4 4 =#

=#4 #=

4 4 #

#4 4

4

#4 ==4 =

#4 ==4 =

) 4

4#= 4

4# 4 =

4 4

4 #4

4#=

4 # 4

4 = 4#

4 =

4= =4

4= =4


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

* 5 P > ; " R 5 > 5 "

) 4 ) 4 * $ ; 1

* 1 > % < 6 $ 6 >$ Q 4 4 # Q = 4# 4 #

* R ; ; > > ; 5 > @K* * * \ * * * * *A =4= 4 4 #4

* R > > ; 5 > @ * I *D * A # 4 4# 4 =4

* 5 P > ; " R 5 > 5 " # 4 4# 4 =4


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$ & 9-+ 9 " > $ 6 > $

9 " > $ 6 > $

% E ,

$ > ) 4 @E 5 X P A

% < >) 4 & " ; 5 M G " > ) 4 5 ;5 ) 4 &D" * P 5 ;5 ) 4

* @ A * 7 @ A * # >@#A @ * D" V@ A \ @ A @ AK

&D" < > ) 4 V@ A \ @ A @#A \ @ AK

$ < > ) 4

% < ; @ A > ) 4 ) 4 V@ A @ AK

’ ; > ; @ A

==* * ^

*

*

*

*

#*

M 7 ; ) 4 & ; 0 ;1 W

) 4 @=4# 4 A @ 4 = 4 A ) 4 4 4 4 # 4 # ) 4 # 4 4 4 4 # ) 4 @ 4 4 A @ 4 = 4 A ) 4 Q@=4 4 # A @=4 4 # A

.

$ ’ ; ? ) 4

@ 4 = 4 A 4

4 4 # @ 4# #4 A @ 4 4 A

Q @ 4# 4= A

$ >) 4 V@ A \ @ A @#A \ @ A \ @=>AK $ " ; > <

& " ’ $ >) 4 ; & " ’ $ > ) 4 ; & " S ’ 4 P D > P > < >) 4

4# 4 = = 4# 4 #

4 4# #

4 4

# 4 = 4###4#

= 4= 4

4 4 #

@=4 4 # A

Q= 4 4 #=

* P

Q

Q= 4 4 #=

Q= 4 4 #=


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$* ’ > " 9

. >) 4

( &

’ 5

. 6

.

( ’

( G

$ 9 5

. 6 9 5

’ G 9 5

-

$

1 " !

9 $ R

. >) 4

$ & 9-+ 9 " 9

$

@ A

@ #A

@ A

#

-

. ( 5 6 G

4 #

@# A

@ A

@ A

@ A

==

’ 8 G

4

@-A

4 =

.

4 =

@ A

@ A

@#A

4 #

$ > ) =4 # G > 3 " ( > ? * 5 G >) 4 #*


! " ! # $% & " ’ ( ) *

$ & 9-+ 9 " 9 @ A

* $; ! 9 > $ "

! $;; / # = / # = # = # = # \ .

# = / / * / /

# / / = / # = = / # / ## = / # # / #= / # / =

# = # = - = / # / / = / # / \ / /

. / #= = # # # #

reviewer: janna f. envelope: 1163836 submitted: … number: pc-2017-3856 filed in providence/bristol...

Documents