residential, commercial, & industrial markets- emerging ... · emerging technology program >...
TRANSCRIPT
Residential, Commercial, & Industrial Markets- Emerging Technologies
ASERTTI Fall Meeting October 3, 2013
Ryan Kerr Emerging Technologies Manager, Gas Technology Institute [email protected]; 847.768.0941
2 2
Presentation Overview
>Natural Gas Market Drivers and Trends >GTI and RD&D Programs
─ GTI Emerging Technology Program (ETP) ─ Nicor Gas ETP
>Residential Technologies >Commercial Technologies >Industrial Technologies
3 3
Expanding Natural Gas Supplies and Low Prices Driving Demand
> Consumer demand growing ─ 2011: All-time high
─ 2012: All-time high
─ 2020: Likely to exceed DOE-EIA estimates (especially with future LNG exports)
Growth drivers: > Power generation > Rebounding Industrial Sector > Transportation (high growth rates)
Offsetting reliance on coal and oil
4 4
Natural Gas Demand Trends
> Residential/Commercial ─ Flat demand trends; ─ Energy efficiency, electric competition ─ Smart use: source energy policies
> Industrial ─ Onshoring trend, shale gas-driven investment ─ Led by Chemicals & Petrochemicals
> Power Gen ─ Displacing old coal plants ─ Potential for greater CHP use
> Transportation ─ NGV fuel prices driving demand ─ Strong customer pull
5 5
> Not-for-profit (501c3) RD&D organization with 70 year history
> Facilities ─ 18 acre campus near Chicago ─ 200,000 ft2,
28 specialized labs ─ Other sites in
California, D.C., Texas, Alabama,Massachusetts
> Staff ─ Approximately 250 ─ 170 engineers, scientists covering all
fields Flex-Fuel
Test Facility
GTI Overview
CHP and Renewable Energy Lab
Residential & Commercial Lab
6
Natural Gas Industry Sponsors
> GTI-led, utility supported, North American collaborative programs targeting residential, commercial and industrial solutions
> Utilization Technology Development (UTD)
> Emerging Technology Program (ETP)
> Federal & State Agencies
7
Natural Gas Industry Collaboration Emerging Technology Program
> Gas Technology Institute led, utility supported, North American collaborative targeting residential, commercial, and industrial solutions
> ETP’s principle goal is to accelerate the market acceptance of emerging
gas technologies
2013 Members Listed Above
8 8
ETP Scope & Direction ETP Mission
Accelerate the market acceptance of energy
efficient gas technologies
ETP Activities
Identify and demonstrate technologies to
(1) collect and analyze enabling program and
technical data while (2) developing marketplace
through consumer awareness and infrastructure
improvement.
Examples: Existing and New ET Program Activities
• California- Roughly 2.5% of total IOU EE and DSM budgets under 2010-2012 Portfolios
• New York- (NYSERDA) Roughly 5% of total program budget
• Pacific Northwest (NEEA)- 10% of total budget 2010-2014
• Illinois- 3% of Gas EE and DSM Program Revenue
• Canadian ETIC
ETP Results
As gas programs, regulations, and markets mature, low hanging fruit
disappears. ETP helps deliver a pipeline of new
technologies and program solutions enabling utilities
to meet tomorrow’s energy efficiency goals with less risk and more
certainty.
9 9
2013 ETP Technologies and Program Concepts
10
> $50 million/year portfolio, 3% investment in ETP
> GTI selected to implement ETP for Nicor Gas
> Formal, transparent process for project selection
> Goal to identify and demonstrate new technologies for EEP
> Close collaboration with implementation programs
Nicor Gas Emerging Technology Program
ETP is to EEP as the minor leagues is to the major
leagues
11 11
Application Scoring
> Seven key criteria evaluated at Set and Go stages: 1. Cost-effectiveness 2. Gas savings potential 3. Value to Nicor Gas portfolio 4. Non-energy benefits 5. Support/distribution in Nicor Gas service territory 6. Technological maturity 7. Ease of implementation/market adoption
> Criteria are scored on a scale of 0-5 > Different weights are applied to each criterion > Scores are totaled out of a possible 100 points
12 12
Nicor Gas Application/Project Status > 50+ applications received
─ Mix of residential, commercial, and industrial sector
> 10+ ETP projects underway, each project is different because each technology/program concept has its own set of barriers to EEP entry ─ Data Barriers
> Moving from custom to prescriptive (e.g. ozone laundry) > What about gas? (e.g. EcoFactor)
─ Market Barriers > Identifying and addressing the impacts of ‘disruptive’ technologies
(e.g. condensing HE RTUs)
> Awareness and education (boiler heat recovery workshop)
13
Source-Based Water Heating Efficiency Comparison
Pre-commercial gas heat pump water heater
14 14
ETP National Pilot Residential HE Combo Systems 94 EF condensing tankless water heater + hydronic air handler
(Rheem pictured) Improves utility/customer value proposition for water heating by
piggy-backing on larger space heating load
Multi-unit demonstrations/pilots in IL, NY, and CA At least 25 residencies with full data acquisition systems
Measured field performance, energy savings, cost analysis, and customer reaction
Contractor technical/sales training, consumer messaging, and rebate program pilot
GTI is investigating combi systems for oil or gas hydronic (e.g. radiator) replacements too
15
Technology Background
Site 4 – 2,100 sqft
Packaged combo
Cumulative: 81.4%
Condensing furnace
30-gal tank EF 0.58
ETP CONFIDENTIAL
Month System/Gas Efficiencies for each Site
1-G 2-A 3-A 4-B 5-C 6-B 7-D 8-E 9-F 10-A Jan’13 -- 76.9% -- 83.7% -- 82.6% 90.3% -- -- --
Feb’13 -- 78.8% -- 82.6% -- 83.4% 90.3% -- -- --
Mar’13 -- 78.5% -- 82.6% -- 83.6% 91.1% -- -- --
Apr’13 -- 77.3% 91.1% 81.2% 77.2% 83.5% 91.5% -- 95.2% 91.4%
May’13 -- 73.5% 91.8% 76.6% 74.0% 82.3% 86.7% -- 95.5% 89.0%
Jun’13 -- 69.4% 92.2% 70.5% 68.2% 80.8% 87.8% -- 94.5% 83.9%
Jul’13 -- 67.4% 86.5% 68.3% 60.7% 80.9% 85.1% -- 94.5% 80.4%
Aug’13 -- 63.0% 85.3% 68.3% 64.7% -- 77.4% -- 92.7% 79.5%
Cumulative -- 77.0% 90.3% 81.4% 72.9% 83.0% 90.2% -- 94.8% 87.3%
Site 7 – 1,400 sqft
Advanced AHU
Cumulative: 90.2%
Traditional furnace
40-gal tank EF 0.58
16 16
Pilot Evaluation- EcoFactor Home Energy Management
EcoFactor is based on proprietary software that analyzes and adjusts a home’s thermostat to control the HVAC operation based on weather data and other information, including home occupancy status.
Purported 36% reduction in cost to heat and cool a home 10-20% savings from automated energy efficiency 16% savings from personalized schedules
Nicor Gas is partnering with ComEd to install and monitor over 100 EcoFactor Home Energy Monitoring Systems in over 90 homes
Two tier modeling validation for heating savings Therm savings based on hourly data of actual indoor
temperature and furnace runtime versus increased furnace runtime for higher temperature setpoint
Simulation using GTI Building America PARR Team BEOpt models for representative Chicagoland homes
Essess Thermal Imaging
• Technology – Essess is a technology company focused on
improving comfort and energy efficiency in homes and buildings using high-throughput, infrared technology that rapidly identifies and analyzes sources of energy loss experienced by homes and commercial buildings across entire communities.
• Savings Potential – Essess analyses helps identify energy leaks in homes
and buildings. – Analyses can help property owners, energy auditors,
and real estate professionals identify energy upgrade solutions to enhance comfort and efficiency.
• ETP Review – The results from the Essess audit will vary from
house to house, such that any recommendations for improvements will be unique based on the case.
– Requires access to quality contractors and products within the market of the individual client.
– Homeowners themselves would be responsible for following up on recommendations made by Essess.
– It is difficult to quantify the cost/benefit in terms of return on investment; the cost of the audit is only the first step in achieving significant energy savings.
17
MARKET SITUATION
Baseline • Traditional home
energy audits Opportunity
• Energy efficiency: natural gas and electricity savings
Segment • Utilities, commercial
businesses, and residences
• Residential retrofit Status
• Mature technology available for enrollment
Next Steps • Further data on cost
savings in a variety of markets Figure 2: Audit example
Figure 1: Thermal image
18 18
Demand pump for central domestic hot water systems
System operates only when there is demand, energy savings from reduced thermal loses in recirculation loop (generally 1 - 3 years ROI before rebates)
Nicor Gas supporting two demos in Chicago area with complete monitoring, collaborative demos in DTE territory, ETIC territory too
Initial Nicor Gas results suggest roughly 2,000 therms and 750 kWh per building (roughly 40 units/building), with paybacks well below 2 years
Project goal is to develop qualitative and quantitative data to support prescriptive program
Pilot Field Assessment Multi-family Demand DHW Controls
19
Micro CHP Technology Landscape
> Variety of emerging micro CHP systems (under 50 kW)
> Engines, fuel cells, Stirling engines – some with promising electric efficiency
> Commercial activity greater in Europe & Japan due to higher energy costs, drivers
> Achieving acceptable first costs a challenge
?
Target first cost needed to achieve six-year payback in different US markets
20
Technology Landscape
Marathon ecopower Clear Edge CE5 Yanmar CP4 and CP10
Climate Energy, freewatt CFCL, BlueGen M-Cogen, Homeaire Plug Power, GenSys Blue Inspirit Energy (Disenco) Whisper Gen, Whisper Tech EC Power, XRGI 15 Energetix, Kingston Delta 2-dozen others
Increase Market Penetration
Emerging Technologies
21 21
Micro-Combined Heat and Power EC POWER XRG
> Technology ─ EC POWER XRG mCHP units utilize a internal
combustion engine (requires 4” WC minimum gas pressure)
─ Success with implemented 19 kW unit; 8 kW and 25 kW unit available in North America in 2014
> Benefits ─ Output can be modulated to match demand ─ Multiple units can be installed in parallel ─ Black-start operation ─ Long required maintenance intervals (every 7,000
hours) and requires approximately 2 hours ─ Aggressive target market installed cost of
$4,000/kW ─ All units to be CARB certified
> Potential ─ Overall efficiency exceeds 92 percent, thermal
efficiency at 61 percent and electrical efficiency at 31 percent
─ Payback expected around 4 years (dependent on application and heat utilization)
─ Requires better incentives and market push to catch on in the US market
MARKET SITUATION
Baseline • Traditional electric heat
pumps or conventional HVAC equipment
Opportunity • Energy efficiency: natural
gas and electricity savings • Possible water savings (WH) • Market potential: retrofit
existing systems and for new installations
Segment • Residential or commercial • New construction and
retrofits Status
• Technology coming to North American market Q1’2014
Next Steps • Market incentives and push
22 22
Field Assessments High Efficiency Gas PACs- RTUs Collaboration with NREL, DOE, manufacturers, national
accounts, and utilities
Large-scale monitoring shows diverse runtimes for RTUs and more therm use than energy models suggested
Dedicated outside air systems (DOAS) provide high efficiency market entry point application
“big box” retail accounts with established DOAS vendors
high heating degree day (HDD)/heating load locations
24/7 retail stores
Retail partner projected $4,400 premium, = 4.1 years ROI @ 90%TE without incentives
Northern climates see more than 2,500 therm savings/year/unit!
1234
5678910111213
1415
19 18 17 16
AHU 1
AHU 3
AHU 2
2021
22
23
24252627
282930
3132333435
36
3738
23 23
Nicor Gas ETP Walmart Pilot Project
> 3 step condensing heating module retrofit process over late September through mid-October 2012
1. Installation of condensate piping with neutralizer 2. Replacement of non-condensing heating modules 3. Completion of data acquisition system
24 24
Chicagoland ‘Big Box’ Store - Results
> Therm savings to date can be projected with statistical confidence to a full heating season AHU 1 – 2400 therms saved per year AHU 2 – 2200 therms saved per year
AHU 1 @ 90%TE, 2332
AHU 1 @ 80%TE, 2624
AHU 2 @ 90%TE, 2164
AHU 2 @ 80%TE, 2435
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
Ga
s U
sag
e (
the
rms)
Therm Savings(10/26/12 - 11/25/12 @ 817 HDD65)
AHU 1 @ 90%TE, 19623
AHU 1 @ 80%TE, 22076
AHU 2 @ 90%TE, 18210
AHU 2 @ 80%TE, 20486
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
Ga
s U
sag
e (
the
rms)
Therm Savings(Projected Full Heating Season @ 6871 HDD65)
25
Next Steps
>GTI Commercial Reference Building Model Project ─ Participating utility “billing analysis” for heating EUI ─ Influence DOE/ASHRAE model heating loads
>GTI R&D project working to enhance RTU thermal efficiency, getting beyond 90%
>Mainstreaming Actions for Condensing RTUs ─ Foster condensing gas heating specifications, i.e., Commercial
Building Energy Alliance RTU Challenge, and joint gas/electric driven market analysis of advanced RTU economics in heating dominated climates
─ Demos for other early market entry points (e.g. 24/7 drug stores with high runtime RTUs)
26 26
Condensing Heating Rooftop Units (RTUs) for Mixed Air Applications
> Technology
─ Moving beyond initial dedicated outside air system (DOAS)
market, 90 to 94%TE condensing heating RTUs are being
introduced that cover the full spectrum of OA%, from 100% to
fully recirculated or 0% OA, and everything in between.
> Savings Potential
─ Up to 15% energy savings, with paybacks directly proportional
to the OA% and runtime.
> ETP Activity
─ GTI pursuing various funding opportunities for demonstration of
50% or more OA market applications including ETP member
interest in working together to demonstrate these RTUs in high
%OA systems in movie theaters, schools, daycare centers, etc.
in Midwest cold climates.
MARKET SITUATION
Baseline • Conventional packaged gas
heating and electric air conditioning roof top units
Opportunity • Energy efficiency: natural
gas and electricity savings • Market potential: retrofit
existing systems and for new installations
Segment • Move beyond initial 100%
outside air (OA) markets for condensing heating RTUs into mixed air broader commercial applications with next market niche focused on 50% or more OA in higher occupancy buildings
• New construction and retrofits
Status • Technology is emerging
Next Steps • Collect further data on cost
savings in a variety of markets
27
Modulating Gas Dryer Retrofit Field Validation Two-stage modulating gas valve, temperature sensor, control unit Industrial-sized modulating dryers are available at a high up front cost, but
modulation is rare in smaller capacity dryers Modulation technology is very mature
Application in dryers is more recent Good fit in hospitality, laundromats,
healthcare, dry cleaners. Could be added during ozone system
installation to capture further energy savings Installation requires dryer to no longer be
under warranty Relatively modest installed cost of $525 Payback time <2 years
ETP CONFIDENTIAL
28 28
Modulating Gas Dryer Retrofit Field Validation > GTI has recruited 2 hotel sites, 1 laundromat, 1 healthcare site, and 1
dry cleaner for testing. The identification of 1 laundry/linen service site is pending.
> A total of 12 dryers will be installed: ─ Hotel (4 dryers – one 75 lb, one 120 lb, two 170 lb) ─ Laundromat (4 dryers – two 30 lb, two 45 lb) ─ Healthcare (2 dryers – two 75 lb) ─ Dry Cleaners (2 dryers – one 30 lb , one 50 lb)
> The monitoring is expected to end in Q1 2014.
> Assist the relevant EEP IC in applying the findings from the pilot assessment in work paper they would generate to propose a new energy efficiency measure
ETP CONFIDENTIAL
Commercial Food Service Technologies
• Description – The commercial food service industry is a
significant energy market with over double the energy intensity of the average commercial customer. There exist opportunities for new technologies to transform the market through increased efficiency.
• Market Barriers – Traditionally commercial foodservice
operators have been reluctant to replace existing equipment with newer models for reasons including cost and concerns over the new equipment being able to prepare the food as expected. This has made getting new gas-fired, more efficient equipment into the market much more difficult.
• New Approach – GTI and its partners are implementing new
whole kitchen assessment approach to foster better alignment with customer needs and multiple replacements for more savings
29
MARKET SITUATION
Baseline • Traditional food services
technologies Opportunity
• Energy efficiency: natural gas, electricity, and water savings
• Market potential: retrofit existing systems and for new installations
Segment • Commercial food services • New construction and
retrofits Status
• Technologies are mature Next Steps
• Further research and demonstration projects for: 1. Low volume fryer 2. Conveyor oven 3. Pilotless Range 4. See latest ETP CFS
Demonstration Menu
Low Volume Fryer
Conveyor Oven
Pilotless Range
30 30
Rheem H2AC™
> The first-of-its kind Rheem H2AC™ Packaged Rooftop Unit works by taking the heat removed from conditioned space — which would normally be rejected into the atmosphere — and uses it to pre-heat water, by switching from an air-cooled condenser to a water-cooled condenser.
> 2013 AHR Expo Product of Year Award
> 27 EER during heat recovery mode – 10 tons
ETP CONFIDENTIAL
31 31
Target Markets
> The facilities targeted for early adoption are those with cooling degree days in excess of 1800 days per year
> 1500 gallons hot water loads per day: ─ restaurants ─ food processing ─ health clubs ─ hotels ─ assisted living
ETP CONFIDENTIAL
32
Field Demonstrations
─ Six field demonstrations of H2ACTM systems planned: > Two sites in Alabama
– July 2013 Project Kickoff – Funded by:
> Alagasco > APGA Research Foundation
> Partnership with SoCal Gas, four Technology Assessment sites in Southern California Region
─ Strong partnership with Rheem on field demonstrations
ETP Confidential
33
New Markets: GHPs
> Commercial Warm Weather Gas Heat Pumps ─ Leverages technology used extensively in Japan
> Includes zone control and variable refrigerant flow ─ Focused on moving beyond ‘friendly’ installations ─ Working with Intellichoice and selected ETP members ─ High profile demonstrations or pilot program focused on
developing and vetting utility incentive/marketing program
34 34
Cold Climate Performance of NextAire™ GHP
> Objective: Evaluate the cold climate performance of the NextAire™ 15-ton Multi-Zone GHP
> Although designed to provide gas cooling in hot climates, its high heating efficiency (120%) can reduce operating costs, source energy, and emissions in colder climates
35 35
Cold Climate Performance of NextAire™ GHP
> Laboratory Tests: Evaluate GHP capacity and performance over a range of heating and cooling loads at temperature conditions typical to cold climates
> Operating Range: > 0°F-120°F > 25%-80% > 1000 cfm
> IntelliChoice and Aisin provided: > GHP outdoor unit > Air handlers and
controllers
36
Steam Systems and Energy Efficiency Improvement Opportunities
37 37
• Combines Cannon’s HTE and LTE Feedwater Heaters with TMC Technology to provide the ultimate in heat and water recovery
• Transport Membrane Condenser (TMC) technology recovers Sensible and Latent Heat from flue gas stream
• Recovers clean water from natural gas burning combustion systems
• Boiler efficiencies of 95% are possible
• Reduction in emissions is equal to the reduction in fuel consumption
Cannon Ultramizer System
Automated Steam Trap Monitoring
• Technology – Automatic steam trap monitoring
is an automated system that can identify a failing steam trap as it is becomes ineffective and notifies a web-based system instantly.
• Savings Potential – 1 year payback period
• ETP Activities – Nicor Gas looking for single high
pressure steam system site – Targeting branch with 200 traps – Coordinating with active SoCal
Gas project
38
MARKET SITUATION
Baseline • Standard steam trap with no
notification upon failure with or without manual steam trap auditing
Opportunity • Energy efficiency: natural
gas and electricity savings • Water Savings • Market potential: retrofit
existing systems and for new installations
Segment • Industrial steam traps • New construction and
retrofits Status
• Technology has been installed at a number of facilities
Next Steps • Third party verification of
benefits and market analysis
Typical monitoring program
After installation of automated steam trap
monitoring ACTIVE ETP PROJECT
39 39
Boiler Demand Monitoring Controls
> Devices that act to minimize unnecessary equipment operation & cycling to save energy ─ Boilers and other equipment
> Manufacturer claims of 10-30% energy savings ─ Limited controlled testing to quantify
> NYSERDA/Brookhaven reported 12.9% savings (+/-3.2%) at 13 sites
─ GTI conducting controlled lab testing on gas-fired boiler
Sandler
Greffen
Intellidyne
40 40
Industrial FlexCHP Power & Steam Package
> Fully integrated high-efficiency ultra-clean power and flexible steam production ─ NOx emissions below 0.07 lb/MWh (for strict California standards) ─ Power generation using
microturbine ─ Waste heat boiler fed with
turbine exhaust gas plus low emission supplemental burner
> Variable steam output ─ 85% system efficiency
41 41
Comments, Questions
Ryan Kerr Emerging Technologies Manager, End Use Solutions Gas Technology Institute 1700 S Mount Prospect Road Des Plaines, IL 60018 Email: [email protected] Phone: 847.768.0941 Mobile: 224.735.0264 Website: www.gastechnology.org/ETP