research proposal defense
TRANSCRIPT
Targeting an A on RPDABCDFExpected
Competence
Evaluators
Expectation
Evaluation
Parameters
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 2
Background and Competence
•Required minimum qualificationand some research skill
•Has adequate in design andable to execute substantial piece of research
•Supervision is more in term of definitionand design of research
Master
•Carry out substantial original researchand has appropriate background
•Make a significant contributionwithin the discipline concerned
•Supervision is expected more in self-directionand critical thought in research
PhD
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 3
Panel of Evaluators• Chairman• Main supervisor• Internal departmentMaster
• Chairman• Main supervisor• External departmentPhD
expectation
expectation
expectation
expectation
expectation
expectation
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 4
Purpose and Expectation
• RPD purposes to assess on the student’s research viability and acceptability
– Formulate the Problem– Develop the Methodology– Acquire the Preliminary Analysis
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 6
Content of Report
ICover
Title
Name
Prog
Study Level
IIProblem
Formulation
Literature Review
Objective
Problem Statement
IIIMethodology
Project Activities
Key Milestone
Study Plan
IVPreliminary
Analysis
Proof of Concept
Preliminary Result
VList of
References
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 7
Evaluation of Presentation
1.Problem
Formulation[30]
Literature Review
Objective
Problem Statement
2.Methodology
[30]
Project Activities
Key Milestone
Study Plan
3.Preliminary
Analysis[20]
Proof of Concept
Preliminary Result
4.Oral
Presentation[20]
Defense Ability
Technical Content
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 8
Evaluation on1. Problem Formulation [30]
Literature Review [10]
• Comprehensive• In-depth• Up-to-date• +Critical
analysis
Objective[10]
• Significant• Measurable• Relevant• Achievable
Problem Statement [10]
• Clear• Conclusive• Rational• High impact
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 9
Evaluation on2. Methodology [30]
Project Activities [10]
• Comprehensive• Achievable• Appropriate
Key Milestone[10]
• Achievable• Satisfactory• Relevant to
objective
Study Plan[10]
• Clear• Feasible• Structured
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 10
Evaluation on3. Preliminary Analysis [20]
Proof of Concept [10]
• Established• Viable
Preliminary Result[10]
• Analyzed• Discussed• Relevant to
literature and objectives
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 11
Evaluation on4. Oral Presentation [20]
Defense Ability[10]
• Defense ability
Technical Content[10]
• Credible
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 12
Evaluation (cont.)
Targeting an A on RPD - J.B.Ariatedja 13
References
[1] _, _, Part E – Research Proposal Defense, Centre of Graduate Studies Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS
[2] _, _, Attachment II – Guideline for Research Proposal Defense (RPD), Centre of Graduate Studies Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS
[3] _, _, Submission for Research Proposal Defense, Centre of Graduate Studies Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS
[4] _, _, Research Proposal Defense (Evaluation Form), Centre of Graduate Studies Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS
