research positions...1. samantha copeland “on serendipity in science: discovery at the...

13
Samantha Marie Copeland, PhD (Philosophy) Postdoctoral Fellow, Centre for Applied Philosophy of Science School of Economics and Business, Norwegian University of Life Sciences Handelshøyskolen; Postboks 5003; NMBU 1432 Ås (Canadian Citizen) saco[at]nmbu.no www.samofserendip.wordpress.com orcid.org/0000-0002-6946-7165 AOS: Philosophy & History of Science and Medicine, Epistemology, Ethics/Bioethics AOC: Philosophy of Science in Practice, Philosophy of Mind, History of Philosophy, Feminist Epistemology, Resilience Research Positions Postdoctoral Fellow: 2015-present, Causation, Complexity and Evidence in Health Sciences (CauseHealth) Project, Norwegian University of Life Sciences (PI: Rani Lill Anjum) Research Associate: 2014-2015, NTE Impact Ethics, Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University (PI: Françoise Baylis) Research Assistant: 2003, Department of Philosophy, Queen’s University, Kingston ON, Topic: Contemporary Disability Theory (Jerome Bickenbach); 1997, College of Humanities, Carleton University, Ottawa ON, Topic: Trends in Religion and Technology (Peter Emberley) Education PhD Philosophy, Dalhousie University; Successfully defended September 2015 Dissertation: The Case of the Triggered Memory: Serendipitous Discovery and the Ethics of Clinical Research. Recipient of the Dalhousie Doctoral Thesis Award (Fine Arts, Humanities & Social Sciences) May 2016 Supervisor: Françoise Baylis; Committee members: Kirstin Borgerson, Lisa Gannett; External Examiner: Walter Glannon MA Philosophy, Queen’s University; Defended and granted autumn 2003 Thesis: Conceiving Depression: A Study of Conceptions of Psychiatric Disease and The Role of the SSRI Antidepressants in the Changing Face of Psychiatry. Supervisor: Jerome Bickenbach BHum (Bachelor of Humanities), College of Humanities, Carleton University Graduated with Honours 2001, concentration in Liberal Arts

Upload: others

Post on 23-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Marie Copeland, PhD (Philosophy)

Postdoctoral Fellow, Centre for Applied Philosophy of Science School of Economics and Business, Norwegian University of Life Sciences

Handelshøyskolen; Postboks 5003; NMBU 1432 Ås

(Canadian Citizen)

saco[at]nmbu.no www.samofserendip.wordpress.com

orcid.org/0000-0002-6946-7165

AOS: Philosophy & History of Science and Medicine, Epistemology, Ethics/Bioethics AOC: Philosophy of Science in Practice, Philosophy of Mind, History of Philosophy,

Feminist Epistemology, Resilience

Research Positions

Postdoctoral Fellow: 2015-present, Causation, Complexity and Evidence in Health Sciences (CauseHealth) Project, Norwegian University of Life Sciences (PI: Rani Lill Anjum) Research Associate: 2014-2015, NTE Impact Ethics, Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University (PI: Françoise Baylis) Research Assistant: 2003, Department of Philosophy, Queen’s University, Kingston ON, Topic: Contemporary Disability Theory (Jerome Bickenbach); 1997, College of Humanities, Carleton University, Ottawa ON, Topic: Trends in Religion and Technology (Peter Emberley)

Education

PhD Philosophy, Dalhousie University; Successfully defended September 2015 Dissertation: The Case of the Triggered Memory: Serendipitous Discovery and the Ethics of Clinical Research. Recipient of the Dalhousie Doctoral Thesis Award (Fine Arts, Humanities & Social Sciences) May 2016 Supervisor: Françoise Baylis; Committee members: Kirstin Borgerson, Lisa Gannett; External Examiner: Walter Glannon MA Philosophy, Queen’s University; Defended and granted autumn 2003 Thesis: Conceiving Depression: A Study of Conceptions of Psychiatric Disease and The Role of the SSRI Antidepressants in the Changing Face of Psychiatry. Supervisor: Jerome Bickenbach BHum (Bachelor of Humanities), College of Humanities, Carleton University Graduated with Honours 2001, concentration in Liberal Arts

Page 2: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e2

Honours, Awards, Grants

2016 Dalhousie Doctoral Thesis Award (and Dalhousie nominee for 2016

CAGS/PROQUEST-UMI Distinguished Dissertation Awards in Fine Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences)

Principal Investigator: CIHR Café Scientifique, “Out of the Lab, Onto the Web?” (May 7, 2013)

Isaac Walton Killam Predoctoral Award, PhD Scholarship (nominated) (2011-13) President’s Award, Dalhousie University (2009-2011) Joseph-Armand Bombardier CGS Doctoral Scholarship (2009-2012) (National competition for award, granted on basis of project proposals) Isaac Walton Killam Predoctoral Award, MA Scholarship (nominated) (2008-2010) Canadian Bioethics Society Student Travel Award (2009) Ontario Graduate Scholarship, Ontario Provincial Government (2002-2003) Dean’s List, Carleton University (1997, 1998, 2000, 2001) Senate Medal for Outstanding Academic Achievement, Carleton University (2001) Scholarships, Carleton University (1996-2000), incl. Harry H. Southam, Lester

Bowles Pearson, Gerhard Herzberg & President’s Scholarship

Publications, Presentations

Peer Reviewed Publications

1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of

Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

2. Samantha Copeland “Unexpected Findings and Promoting Mono-Causal Claims, A Cautionary Tale” Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 23, 2017, pp. 1055-1061.

3. Samantha Copeland “Psychiatric Applications for DBS: Using Epistemology to Assess Ethics in Research” Journal of Ethics in Mental Health Vol. 6, 2011/12 Supplement: Neuroethics. ISSN: 1916-2405

Non- Peer Reviewed Publications

1. Rani Lill Anjum, Samantha Copeland, Stephen Mumford, Elena Rocca. “CauseHealth: integrating philosophical perspectives into person-centered healthcare,” European Journal for Person Centered Healthcare 2015, Vol.3, Issue 4, pp. 427-430. (invited guest editorial)

2. Alana Cattapan, Samantha Copeland, Dave Snow. “Meeting Report: Biobanking Eggs and Embryos for Research,” The Gazette, Society for the Social History of Medicine February 2015, No.68. 6-7. www.sshm.org/sites/all/docs/gazette/gazette68.pdf

Page 3: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e3

3. Samantha Copeland “Problems with Seeing DBS Recipients Primarily as Research Subjects,” American Journal of Bioethics, AJOB: Neuroscience Vol.4, Iss. 2 (April 29) 2013. 50-52. (Peer Reviewed Abstract)

4. Samantha Copeland “The Ethical Import of Patient Selection,” American Journal of Bioethics, AJOB: Neuroscience Vol. 4, Iss. 1, (January) 2013. 42-43. (Peer Reviewed Abstract)

5. Samantha Copeland “The Eating Disorders Inventory in Developing Countries: The Ethics of Research on Subjects in Cultural Transition: Commentary on a Case Study in the Ethics of Mental Health Research,” Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 200(3):272-273, March 2012. (Invited)

Blog Posts

1. “Expertise is More Than Authority” on causehealthblog.wordpress.com, March 13, 2017. https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/2017/03/13/expertise-is-more-than-authority/

2. “Analogies and High-Stakes Inferences” on causehealthblog.wordpress.com, December 16, 2016. https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/2016/12/16/analogies-and-high-stakes-inferences/

3. “Why do we care about the foundations of evidence-based medicine (‘EBM’)?” on causehealthblog.wordpress.com, May 24, 2016. https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/2016/05/24/why-do-we-care-about-the-foundations-of-evidence-based-medicine-ebm/

4. “Serendipity and the value of networks” on causehealthblog.wordpress.com, December 3, 2015. https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/2015/12/03/serendipity-and-the-value-of-networks/

5. “Suckers and Quacks: The Canadian Homeopathy Debate” on ImpactEthics.ca, July 11, 2015. https://impactethics.ca/2015/06/11/suckers-and-quacks-the-canadian-homeopathy-debate/

Book Review

1. “Moral Textures: Feminist Narratives in the Public Sphere, by Maria Pia Lara,” in Symposium: Journal of the Canadian Society for Hermeneutics and Postmodern Thought. Vol. 8, No. 1 Spring, 2004 pp154-156.

Policy Submissions

1. Katharine Browne, Angel Petropanagos, Samantha Copeland. “Recommendations for the UNESCO Revision of the 1974 Recommendation on the Status of Scientific Researchers,” submitted November 1, 2014.

Page 4: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e4

Peer Reviewed Conference Presentations

1. “Innovation as Serendipity: Distinguishing Between Novelty and Progress”, as part of

The ‘Future of Serendipity’ in a Changing World Symposium of the Serendipity

Society, World Humanities Conference, Liege, August 9, 2017

2. “Effectual and Mechanistic Reasoning in Medical Research, the Case of Deep Brain Stimulation” at Philosophy of Medicine Roundtable 7, June 23 in Toronto, 2017

3. “Strategic Serendipity: Inferences and Institutions that Enable Scientific Discovery”

at Nordic Network for Philosophy of Science, April 21 in Copenhagen, and Canadian

Society for History and Philosophy of Science, May 29 in Toronto, 2017

4. “Was Fleming’s Discovery of Penicillin a Paradigmatic Case of Serendipity, or Not?” at the Nordic Network for Philosophy of Science Annual Conference at Tartu, April 23, 2016

5. “The Value of Valuing Ignorance” at Science, Technology & Gender: Challenges & Opportunities, CSWIP & FEMMMS, University of Waterloo, August 2014

6. “Desiring Discovery: the Sagacity of Serendipity,” at Atlantic Regional Philosopher’s Association, Dalhousie University & CSWIP, Trent University, & Dalhousie Philosophy Colloquium 2013

7. “Categorizing Complexity: The Ethics of Translational Research,” at BrainMatters III, Cleveland Ohio, 2012

8. “Categorizing Complexity in Research Ethics,” at Atlantic Regional Philosopher’s Association, University of Prince Edward Island, 2012

9. “Saying What You Mean: Epistemic Intent in Imperfect Communication,” at Atlantic Regional Philosopher’s Association, Mount Allison, 2011

10. “Who is an Expert on My Mental Health?” Atlantic Regional Philosopher’s Association, University of King’s College, 2010

11. “Clinical Expertise as Scientific Method: A Brief History of Psychopharmacology,” International Association of Women in Philosophy Conference, Feminism, Science and Values, University of Western Ontario, 2010

12. “Clinical Practice and the Origins of Psychopharmacology,” Canadian Society for the History and Philosophy of Science annual meeting, Concordia University, 2010

13. “Psychopharmacology and the Nature of Psychiatric Disorder,” Disorderly Conduct, an Interdisciplinary Conference on the Nature of Disorder, University of Waterloo ON, 2009.

14. “Just Evidence? The Merits of an Embodied Approach to Psychopharmacology,” 20th Canadian Bioethics Society Conference, Hamilton ON, 2009.

15. “You are What You Pop? Prozac as Enhancement Technology,” Annual Meeting of the Atlantic Regional Philosopher’s Association, St. Francis Xavier University, Antigonish NS, 2008.

16. “Poised: Time and identity in Gadamer, Shrag and Derrida,” Annual Meeting of the Canadian Society for Continental Philosophy, University of King’s College NS, 2003.

Page 5: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e5

Non- Peer Reviewed Presentations

1. “Effectual Reasoning in the Clinical Context – Thinking Strategically About Guidelines,” at The Guidelines Challenge: Philosophy, Practice, Policy, October 4, 2017, Oxford UK

2. “Strategy and the Single Case” at Causal inference in context: evidence, experts and

disagreement, held by the Normative Inferences and Interferences in Scientific

Research group, Madrid, May 9, 2017

3. “Organizing for Unexpected Innovations” Brown Bag Seminar at the School of Economics and Business, NMBU Norway, December 7, 2016

4. “Analogical Thinking in Clinical Research and Guidelines Development” at CauseHealth workshop on Philosophy and Guidelines, London UK, October 24, 2016

5. “The Structure of Scientific Serendipity” at Dalhousie Philosophy Colloquium, August 5, 2016

6. “From the Particular to the General, and Back Again – Pitfalls and Precautions” at N=1 - Causal Reasoning and Evidence for Clinical Practice, NMBU Norway, January 12, 2016

7. “From Chance to Causes and Cases: Adventures in the Epistemology of Medicine” at Dalhousie Philosophy Colloquium, September 11, 2015

8. “The Case of the Triggered Memory: Serendipity and Functional Neurosurgery,” at Dalhousie Philosophy Colloquium, 2013

9. “Assessing Expertise as a Novice: the Role of Tacit Knowledge,” at Dalhousie Philosophy Colloquium, 2010

Posters

1. “Making Knowledge Explicit: From Evidence to Practice in Neuroscience & Psychiatry” at Brain Matters II. Montreal, 2011. Presented.

2. “Categorising Complexity in the Ethics of Translational Research, Pitfalls and Precautions” for 11th World IAB (International Association of Bioethics) Congress, Rotterdam 2012. Accepted but unable to present.

Invited Lecturer (Public)

1. Forthcoming, April 2018 a CAPS Presents lecture, NMBU - “Science by Accident” 2. “Organizing for Unexpected Innovations – Serendipity and Open Science” for

NINA (The Norwegian Institute for Nature Research) lunchtime seminar, Oslo/Trondheim/Tromsø, December 14, 2016.

Page 6: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e6

Conference Organization & Administration

Society Chair

1. The Serendipity Society Design and creation of website, maintenance of twitter feed Organization of Symposium (5 speakers) at World Humanities

Conference, August 9, 2017, “The ‘Future of Serendipity’ in a Changing World”; Organization of meet & greet and virtual meeting, at ASIS&T (Association for Information Science & Technology) annual meeting, Washington DC, October 30, 2017; quarterly virtual meet-ups

Newsletter, distribution of relevant events notices, blog, Google group

Conference Organization

1. Organizer (program, speakers, venue, marketing, registration), CauseHealth conference, The Guidelines Challenge, Oxford, England, October 3-4, 2017

Keynote speakers: Nancy Cartwright (Phil of Sci, Durham), Trish Greenhalgh (MD, Oxford), Mike Kelly (NICE), Brian Broom (MD, NZ)

https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/the-guidelines-challenge-a-causehealth-event/

Forthcoming section in 2018 Philosophy Thematic edition of the Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice (JECP)

2. Organizer (program, participants, venue), CauseHealth workshop, Philosophy and Guidelines Development (Thinking about Guidelines), London UK, October 24, 2016 https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/2016/12/01/thinking-about-guidelines/

3. Local organizing team member, CauseHealth workshop, N=1 - Causal Reasoning and Evidence for Clinical Practice, NMBU Ås Norway, January 12-13, 2016 https://causehealthblog.wordpress.com/n1-causal-reasoning-and-evidence-for-clinical-practice/

4. Local Organizing Committee member for HOPOS (History of Philosophy of Science) International Society conference and meeting, University of King’s College (June 21-24 2012)

5. Organization Committee Member, “Science without Data: The Role of Thought Experiments in Empirical Investigations,” workshop, Dalhousie University, June 2010

Administration & Project Management

1. CauseHealth project, weekly meetings 2. Research Associate, NTE Impact Ethics, 2014-2015

Editing: Editorial Team, Academic Journal

1. The Guidelines Challenge special section, 2018 Philosophy Thematic Edition of the Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice

Page 7: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e7

Editing: Editorial Assistant, Anthology

2. “Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women”, Francoise Baylis & Angela Ballantyne (eds.), Springer 2016

3. “Thought Experiments in Science, Philosophy and the Arts”, Melanie Frappier, Letitia Meynell & James Robert Brown (eds), Routledge 2012

Website Design & Social Media

1. www.theserendipitysociety.wordpress.com Design of website and maintenance of resource and members pages, blog

posts, etc., twitter account and society newsletters (as chair) 2. www.causehealthblog.wordpress.com, @Cause_Health

Website design, blog maintenance Facebook group for Philosophy Friday monthly events

3. www.dal.ca/sites/noveltechethics.html Collaboration with team for migration of website to new server and

principal programmer for design and maintenance (2014-2015) Twitter news feed for @ImpactEthics (multiple posts per day) (2014-

2016) Maintenance of email subscribers list, regular emails for Impact Ethics

events (using ThinkMail email design program with html)

Institutional & Community Service

Referee 1. Synthese 2. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 3. Proceedings of the Nova Scotian Institute of Science 4. Canadian Philosophical Association paper selection committee, annual Congress

(March 2011, February 2012, February 2013, February 2016) 5. Corvus: an Undergraduate Journal of Philosophy, Dalhousie University, Halifax

NS (April 2009, March 2011, February 2012) 6. Canadian Bioethics Society abstract selection committee (December 2012)

Committees, Societies and Groups

1. Philosophy Fridays at NMBU: Organizing team member (2015-present) 2. NTE Impact Ethics: Novel Tech Ethics, Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University

(PI: Françoise Baylis); Work in Progress group, active member (2009-15) 3. Co-ordinator, Graduate Students’ Publication Support Group (PSG) Dalhousie

University Philosophy Department, Halifax NS (2009-11), Executive Committee member, Dalhousie Philosophy Graduate Student Society, Co-ordinator and Founding member of Dal Phil Grad Society (co-ordinator for ratification of former Publication Support Group) (2011-13)

4. Women in and Around Philosophy, social group; member (2009-15), principal event co-ordinator (2011-13)

Page 8: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e8

5. Evolutionary Studies Group, reading list co-ordinator (F/W 2010-11), member (2009-13)

6. Student Abstract Selection Committee for the Canadian Bioethics Society Conference Just Evidence, Hamilton ON (February 2009)

Additional Service

1. Volunteer Moderator for Dalhousie History Graduate Conference, 2012 2. Volunteer Situating Science Halifax Node, Science Fiction Film Series, 2010 3. Volunteer Research Assistant, Neuroethics internet resource for Novel Tech

Ethics website, Dalhousie University, Halifax NS, 2010 4. Volunteer International Hume Society Annual Conference, Dalhousie University,

Halifax NS, 2009 5. Student Volunteer Canadian Bioethics Society Conference Just Evidence,

Hamilton ON, 2009 6. Rotary International Student Exchange Program (Hon. Member), 1994-2002 7. University of Toronto Foodbank, Toronto ON, 2001-2002; Centretown

Foodbank, Ottawa ON, 2000-2001 8. Carleton University GLBT Centre, Library Co-ordinator, 1999-2000

Academic Society Memberships

1. The Serendipity Society (Chair) 2. Philosophy of Medicine Roundtable 3. Canadian Society for the History and Philosophy of Science 4. European Society for Person-Centred Healthcare 5. Society for the Metaphysics of Science 6. Canadian Society for Women in Philosophy (2013-15) 7. Situating Science, Halifax Node (2010-14) 8. International Association of Women Philosophers (2010-2011) 9. Canadian Philosophical Association (2009-12) 10. Canadian Bioethics Society (2009-10) 11. Atlantic Regional Philosopher’s Association (2008-13) 12. Canadian Society for Hermeneutics and Postmodern Thought (2003-2006)

Other Education & Training

1. Knowledge Translation: Introduction (Dr. J Curran), KT: Synthesis (Dr. J

Hatchette), KT: Exchange & Application (Drs. J Sargeant & D Emberley), and KT: Dissemination (Dr. J Curran); series by Integrated Health Research Training Partnership, Dalhousie University, Halifax (cert. avail.), 2012, March

2. Languages: Portuguese (Brazilian): Spoken fluency, written comprehension French: Intermediate, spoken, reading and writing Norwegian: Intermediate, Study in progress German: Beginner Italian: Beginner

Page 9: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e9

Comprehensive Exams (PhD)

Ancient Philosophy Ethics Philosophy of Mind Epistemology

Graduate Courses

Dalhousie University 2008-2010

Topics in Ethics (Virtues & Vices) Stephen Burns & Greg Scherkoske Philosophy of Emotions Susan Campbell Directed Readings (Personal Transformations) Susan Campbell Personal Identity Nathan Brett 20th Century Philosophy Duncan MacIntosh Philosophy of Science Letitia Meynell Theory of Rational Decision Making Duncan MacIntosh Normative Theory (Liberalism & Identity Pol.) Fuat Gursozlu Philosophy of Language Micheal Hymers Ethics Greg Scherkoske The Mind-Body Problem Darren Abramson Ethics & Health Care (Ethics of Med. Research) Kirstin Borgerson

Queen’s University 2002-2003

Epistemology I (Perception) D.L.C. Maclachlan Hermeneutics Paul Fairfield Philosophical Methods Sergio Sismondo Philosophy of Culture Jacqueline Davies Philosophy of Art Deborah Knight Special Directed Studies (Foucault) Carlos Prado

University of Toronto 2001-2002

Moral Philosophy Daniel Goldstick Philosophy of Mind (Carruthers) William Seager Seminar: History of Phil. (Deconstructivism) Robert Gibbs

Page 10: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e10

PhD Dissertation

Title:

The Case of the Triggered Memory: Serendipitous Discovery and the Ethics of Clinical Research

Abstract:

Should researchers take advantage of unexpected opportunities to make valuable discoveries when these opportunities arise in the context of research involving human participants? The pursuit of knowledge sometimes requires human beings to participate in research as the subjects of study. This is particularly the case when it comes to the pursuit of knowledge about the brain. In this dissertation, I consider the potential value of serendipitous discoveries in the context of clinical research involving humans, with a narrow focus on deep brain stimulation (DBS) – a technology that enables clinician-researchers to access and manipulate the living human brain.

Along the way, I accomplish three goals. First, I provide an account of serendipitous discovery in science. Serendipity consists of three elements—chance, sagacity and a valued outcome—that come together in a single process of discovery. Second, I apply my analysis to a case of potential serendipity in early phase medical research involving humans. Third, I explore the epistemological and ethical implications of both the analysis and its application. Serendipitous discoveries, for instance, are made by members of scientific communities, rather than by individuals in isolation. Thus, features of communities can enhance or constrain the making of serendipitous discoveries. Specifically, I argue that communities that perceive the unexpected as potentially valuable, that support the epistemic agency of their members, and that encourage the sharing of knowledge, foster serendipitous discovery. I closely examine a recent case from clinical research with DBS—the case of the triggered memory—as a case of potential serendipity. The tripartite account of serendipity I articulate provides a lens through which I draw out several epistemological and ethical implications of pursuing serendipitous discovery within the context of clinical research, when human participants in research are the source of unexpected observations. In conclusion, I propose recommendations for pursuing serendipitous discovery in clinical research without compromising ethics. http://dalspace.library.dal.ca/handle/10222/63140

Page 11: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e11

Teaching

Courses Taught at Dalhousie University Syllabi and assignments available upon request.

1. Ethics and Health Care: Patient Care - PHIL 2805 Fall term (Sept.-Dec.), 2013 – 3 hrs lecture/week Second year course Syllabus authored by K. Borgerson, adapted to accommodate:

a. Changes in national policy (Canada Supreme Court decision on medically assisted suicide)

b. Student feedback (on contemporary medical practice in regard to intersex born individuals)

c. Updated case studies Supervised one teaching assistant Enrolment: 74

2. Existentialism – PHIL 2710

Winter term (Jan.-April), 2012 – 3 hrs lecture/week Second year course Self-authored syllabus No teaching assistant Enrolment: 29

3. Philosophy of Sex and Love – PHIL 2170

Summer term (July), 2012 – 9 or 12 hrs lecture/week Second year course Self-authored syllabus Supervised one teaching assistant Enrolment: 42

Winter term (Jan.-April), 2011 – 3 hrs lecture/week Second year course Self-authored syllabus Supervised two teaching assistants Enrolment: 140

Page 12: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e12

Additional Teaching Experience 1. PhD Mentoring

One-on-one assistance with preparation of article for publication & submission as requirement for PhD

a. K.M.E. (2017-2018) – PhD student, CauseHealth & University of Oslo “Job Related Burnout – A Phenomenological Study of the Lived

Experience of Burning Out” b. K.J.A-B. (2017) – PhD student, School of Economics and Business,

Norwegian University of Life Sciences “Averting Multiple Catastrophes in a More Complex World”

c. F.C. (2017) – PhD student, School of Economics and Business, NMBU “Behavioural predictors of accidental fires in the Brazilian

Amazon: preferences and perceptions in coordination and predictors external validity”

2. Writing Tutor

a. Dalhousie University Writing Centre (2011-2013), Killam Library Trained as peer tutor and in ESL (English as a second

language) Recorded & submitted notes for each session with students Frequently requested by students for follow-up sessions Philosophy & Social Sciences for upper level students, and all

subjects for introductory level

3. Tutorial/Seminar Leader

a. Environmental Ethics, Dalhousie University, Philosophy Fall (Sept.-Dec.), 2010 Second year course

b. History of Science and Technology, University of King’s College, HOST Fall & Winter (Sept.-April), 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 Introductory course Cross-listed as either Science or Arts credit In 2010 appointed tutor leader

c. Introduction to Humanities: Myth and Symbol, Carleton University, Humanities

Fall & Winter (Sept.-April), 2005

Page 13: Research Positions...1. Samantha Copeland “On Serendipity in Science: Discovery at the Intersection of Chance and Wisdom” Synthese (forthcoming, DOI 10.1007/s11229-017-1544-3)

Samantha Copeland

[email protected]

Pag

e13

4. Teaching Assistant & Grader

a. Dalhousie University: Philosophy of Sex and Love, Fall 2011, Second year course Introduction to Philosophy, Fall & Winter, 2007/8, 2008/9, 2009/10 Ethics in Health Care: Social Policy (Philosophy), Winter 2008, Second year course Ethics in Health Care (Health Sciences, online), Winter 2008, Second year course Philosophy of Religion, Summer 2008, Second year course Philosophical Issues in Feminism, Summer 2007, Second year course

b. Carleton University: Women in the Christian Tradition (Rel.), Winter 2005, Second year course Introduction to Eastern Religions (Religion), Summer 2005 Introduction to Judaism, Christianity and Islam (Rel.), Fall & Winter 2004/5

c. Queen’s University: An Historical Introduction to Philosophy, Fall & Winter 2002/3

5. Invited Guest Lecturer

a. Ethics & Health Care: Social Policy - PHIL 2810, Dalhousie University, 2013 “Research Ethics: Therapeutic Misconception”

b. Introduction to the History of Science – HSTC 1200, University of King’s College, 2009

“Enough with Aristotle! Ancient Atomism” c. Political Thought 1651-1778 – POLI 2710, Dalhousie University, 2009

“Rousseau’s Social Contract” d. Feminist Philosophy – PHIL 4585.2, St. Mary’s University, 2009

“Foucault Goes to Weight Watchers: Cressida Heyes’ Self-Transformations”

e. Women in the Christian Tradition – RELI 2003, Carleton University, 2005

“The Feminist Movement and Women in the Christian Tradition”

6. Planned Guest Lectures

a. Introduction to Philosophy, NMBU, Feb. & April 2018 Aristotle’s ethics

b. Causation in Science (MA/PhD course), NMBU, June 2018 Inferring Causation in Scientific Discovery