report of jaipur conference - royal society of …...3 executive summary an international workshop...
TRANSCRIPT
1
December 10-12, 2012
Sponsored by
Royal Society of Chemistry London
(North India Section)
RSC Advancing the Chemical sciences
REPORT
2
Table of Contents
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY...............................................................................................(3)
2. INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................(4)
WORKSHOP ABSTRACT......................................................................................(5)
WORKSHOP OVERVIEW.....................................................................................(6)
3. WORKING SESSIONS
INAUGURATION....................................................................................................(7)
INAUGURAL SESSION..........................................................................................(8)
SESSION I.................................................................................................................(9)
SESSION II..............................................................................................................(10)
SESSION III.............................................................................................................(11)
SESSION IV.............................................................................................................(12)
SESSION V .............................................................................................................(13)
SESSION VI ............................................................................................................(14)
4. PARTICIPANTS.............................................................................................................(15)
5. CONCLUDING REMARKS..........................................................................................(15)
APPENDIX A - WORKSHOP PROGRAMME..............................................................(16)
3
Executive Summary
An International Workshop on “Chemistry for a Sustainable Future”
sponsored by Royal Society of Chemistry, London (North India Section) was held at
Jaipur, India from December 10-12, 2012.
The main aim of the workshop was to bring together the users, policy makers,
researchers and commercial sectors for sharing their experiences to develop and
implement the green perspective of chemistry that shapes a sustainable future and
preserve our ecosystem.
One of the founders of Green Chemistry, Dr. John C. Warner (President and
Chief Technology Officer, Warner Babcock Institute for Green Chemistry, USA) and
world leaders in Green Chemistry like Prof. James Clark (Professor of Chemistry
and Director, Green Chemistry of Excellence, University of York, UK) participated
and shared their views in the workshop. Green Chemistry Centre in York, UK and its
affiliates, the Biorenewables Development Centre and the company Starbon
Technologies have also presented an exhibition covering green chemistry research,
education, outreach and commercialization.
This event was also coincided with the Celebration of Successful Completion
of 10 years of Green Chemistry Networking in India by Green Chemistry
Network Centre.
4
Introduction
An international workshop on “Chemistry for Sustainable Future” was jointly organized
by RSC North India Section, Green Chemistry Network Centre, Department of Chemistry,
University of Delhi, Delhi in collaboration with the Department of Chemistry, University of
Rajasthan, Jaipur and Malaviya National Institute of Technology, Jaipur held at Jaipur (India)
from Dec 10, 2012 to Dec. 12, 2012 with a view to bring together exceptional researchers –
all leading names in their fields for an outstanding program to provide beneficial networking
opportunities.
LefttoRight:Prof.AnshuDandia,Prof.M.M.Salunkhe,Prof.R.V.Singh,Dr.JohnC.Warner,Prof.JamesClark,Prof.A.Ranjan,ProfR.K.Sharma
5
Workshop Abstract
Green and sustainable chemistry is a new concept and research area first articulated in
the early 1990s but gained wider prevalence only in the last few years. Green chemistry
provides a framework for a sustainable future by adopting safer practices and using less
hazardous and non-toxic chemicals. It is the design, development, and implementation of
chemical products and processes to reduce or eliminate the use and generation of substances
hazardous to human health and the environment. The principles of Green Chemistry as
described by Paul Anastas and John Warner in “Green Chemistry: Theory and Practice” teach
how to design safer chemicals and products in the first place. These principles go to the very
heart of sustainability and strengthen the economy by providing the new outlook to the
chemistry, and protecting public health and planet from toxic and hazardous materials.
This workshop was organized to provide participants an opportunity to get exposed to
cutting-edge research on the development of alternative sustainable technologies and develop
relationships for future collaborations. This also benefited the various stakeholders to broaden
their horizon and learn the use of sustainability not only in academia but also in industrial
sector.
6
Workshop Overview
The workshop covered current environmental and human health issues which pose a
challenge for sustainability and chemistry solutions, especially in the context of India,
Food supply
Sustainable agriculture and integrated pest management
Metals processing
Textile processing chemicals
Tanning of animal hides
Pharmaceutical manufacturing
Natural Products and Traditional Medicines
Control of infectious diseases
Water quality
Renewable energy
Depletion of resources
Historical background on world approaches to deal with the threats to the
environment, ecosystem and biosphere
The definition and twelve principles of green chemistry
The tremendous potential of biotechnology to offer unique, efficient, eco -friendly
and economically viable options for waste treatment in situ and degradation of
hazardous toxic waste into relatively less harmful by products e.g. eco -restoration
of degraded ecosystems, mining spoil dumps, treatment of industrial effluents.
Overview of the various areas of the science and technology of green chemistry.
Case studies/ real world science in the field of green chemistry
Review of regulatory structures, enforcements systems and financial incentives
that encourage the adoption of green chemistry practice in industry.
Review of frontier science in the field of green chemistry.
7
Inauguration
The fortune of the workshop started with the traditional
and cultural lamp lighting ceremony followed by warm
hearted welcome of guests and participants.
Accompanying this, a concise yet inclusive framework of
“Green Chemistry Networking in India” was projected by
Prof. R.K. Sharma, Professor of Chemistry and
Coordinator, Green Chemistry Network Centre (GCNC),
University of Delhi. His last ten years laborious efforts
and pioneering contributions to popularize Green Chemistry via GCNC (established in the
year 2001, under the recommendation of Prof. Paul Anastas) headed the workshop towards a
constructive and motivated environment. A small section highlighting the organized trainings
and workshops for educators and researchers in India, overwhelming response of the
participants and results of his endeavour i.e. “consideration of green chemistry at senior
secondary and undergraduate level and at commercial scale” were also integrated in his
outline.
Prof. R.K. Sharma
8
Inaugural Session
At the very outset of the inaugural session, the
constructive and convincing views addressing the theme
were presented by one of the founders of Green
Chemistry, Dr. John C. Warner, President and Chief
Technology Officer, Warner Babcock Institute for
Green Chemistry, USA. The founder of Green
Chemistry fascinated participants by describing history
and background of Green Chemistry and discussed the need to evaluate the existing
analytical methods from green perspective. He described Green Chemistry as a philosophy
that seeks to reduce or eliminate the use of hazardous materials at the design stage of a
materials process. Also he stated that the materials and products can be designed with
negligible impact on human health and environment while still being economically
competitive and successful in the market. Along with this, he explained 12 principles of
Green Chemistry which are widely approved as the basis for future “Green Chemistry” (P. T.
Anastas and J. C. Warner, Green Chemistry: Theory and Practice, Oxford University Press,
Oxford, 1998).
Dr. John C. Warner
9
Session I
The session I started with second invited presentation of
Prof. James Clark, Professor of Chemistry and
Director Green Chemistry Centre of Excellence,
University of York, UK on “Green Chemistry and
Sustainability”. He emphasized on implementation of
Green chemistry on a global scale and elaborated that
industrial symbiosis seeks a closed loop approach to the
twin problems of resource and waste by making latter as the solution to former. Prof. Clark
also pointed out that the food wastes are especially useful as sources of organic chemicals for
a variety of processes and products. Further, he added that energy efficient conversion
technologies can convert a wide variety of waste streams into valuable chemicals include
low-temperature microwave processing and supercritical carbon dioxide extractive
fractionation.
During this session three eminent scientists from India who had developed Green
Technologies, which are being implemented by GCNC as motivational tool to
popularize Green Chemistry, were presented a Roll of Honour on behalf of GCNC by
Dr. John C. Warner.
Prof. James H. Clark
Dr. John C. Warner presenting mementos to Prof. M. K. Chaudhuri, Dr. Alok Adholeya, Dr.
Rakeshwar Bandichhor for their outstanding contribution to furtherance of Green Chemistry
10
Prof. Mihir K. Chaudhuri, Vice-Chancellor, Tezpur
Central University, Tezpur, India, in his presentation
talked about the necessity of Green Chemistry for
Sustainable Future and some Indian initiative taken up
in this field. He said that continuous efforts were made
to popularize Green Chemistry in India since the
inception of the year 2000 which resulted into tangible
appreciation by Indian academia, practicing scientists
and students. Further, he cited some real world cases of Indian origin including atom
economical synthesis of PVC, clean production of metal acetylacetonates, a class of
commercially significant materials based on acid base and red-ox reactions, and
environmentally benign sulfoxidations reactions leading to production of Ranitidine.
Session II
Dr. Alok Adholeya, Director, Biotechnology and
Management of Bioresources Division, The Energy and
Resource Institute (TERI), Delhi, drew the attention of the
participants towards generation of pollutants by the
industrial activities and exploration of innovative
approaches to reuse waste as resources to maintain balance
between man and nature. He emphasized on the
development different reclamation technologies for the
treatment of waste like like Fly ash, Chlor-Alkali sludge and distillery effluent. He also
mentioned about the joint collaboration TERI with Delhi University (DU) which resulted in
the successful large scale online extraction of chromium from tannery waste using biological
Prof. Mihir K. Chaudhuri
Dr. Alok Adholeya
11
agent (e.g plants and microorganisms) and subsequent recovery of the same using silica gel
based metal specific chelating resin.
Prof. S. Chandrasekaran, Honorary Professor and JC
Bose National Fellow, Indian Institute of Science, and
Hindustan Lever Research Professor, JNCASR,
Bangalore, gave a talk entitled “Transition metal oxide
impregnated MCM catalysts : Regioselective tail to tail
dimerization of vinylarnes”. He also presented the
studies on the scope and limitation of using transition
metal oxides impregnated MCM-1 and MCM-48 as
catalyst in dimerization of styrene to give tail to tail dimer (2,3-diphenyl-1butenes) with high
degree of regioselectivity.
Session III
Dr. Saurav Pal, Director, National Chemical
Laboratory and Adjunct Professor of Chemistry,
IISER, Pune, highlighted the scope of computations
and presented case studies from his recent work on
hydrogen storage materials. He introduced
Computational Chemistry as an important tool, which
is emerging as an excellent alternative to experiments
for design of functional molecules and materials.
Prof. S. Chandrasekaran
Dr. Saurav Pal
12
Prof. Maria J. Ramos, Associate Director,
Chemistry Department, Faculty of Porto, Portugal
presented molecular modelling as an integral part of
green chemistry and gathered an overwhelming
response for her great contribution for designing
Computational Strategies in Drug Development. She
beautifully showed the quantum
mechanics/molecular mechanics hybrid methods to
scan the mutagenesis of protein-protein interfacial residues, which can be very important
process for drug design since protein-protein interaction form the basis for most biological
processes.
Session IV
Dr. Sudhakar G. Reddy, Coordinator - Sustainable
Labs, Office of Campus Sustainability, University of
Michigan, USA, expressed his views on application of
Green Chemistry and pollution prevention principles to
develop an ideal sustainable laboratory. Citing the
example of western hemisphere institutions, he said that
lab operations in USA use two-third of the total energy
being consumed on campus which generates leading
opportunities to find alternatives by inculcating new ideas into practice. He further added that
simply by application of stringent administrative and behavioural controls along with the
concept of green chemistry and waste reduction principles, sustainability in teaching and
research lab can be attained. This would eventually result in reducing foot print on the
environment and increasing health and safety of lab users.
Prof. Maria Joao Ramos
Dr. Sudhakar G. Reddy
13
Dr. Kshipra Misra, Additional Director, DIPAS
(DRDO), Delhi, introduced water purification
technologies developed by Defence Research and
Development Organisation (DRDO) for the removal of
arsenic, iron and bacteria from ground water. Also, she
highlighted that while purification, the secondary waste
generated from filters/ plants is disposed off in the form
of standard grade impermeable concrete blocks which
complies with EPA’s TCLP (Toxicity characteristics and leaching procedure) protocol.
Moreover, it is further used in construction industry resulting in no waste generation and in
turn making the technology environmentally friendly and green.
Session V
Dr. Avtar Matharu, Dy. Director, Green Chemistry
Centre of Excellence, University of York, UK,
expressed his views on sustainable development and
said “It is a development that meets the needs of the
present without compromising the ability of future
generations to meet their own needs”. The talk also
included the examples of everyday materials (LCD TV,
carpets, and kitchen units) which may be recycled and
reused in innovative ways using the concept of Green Chemistry.
Dr. Kshipra Mishra
Dr. Avtar Matharu
14
Dr. Mark Gronnow, Green Chemistry Centre of
Excellence, University of York, UK, briefed the
participants about the Biorenewables Development
Centre (BDC) at the University of York, which has
helped the industries with new processes to convert
waste into high products. His presentation included a
number of case studies and examples of processes
which were being successfully worked on by his team at
the BDC and Green Chemistry Centre of Excellence.
Session VI
Dr. Rakeshwar Bandichhor, Associate Director, API –
R &D Innovation Plaza Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories,
Hyderabad, India, gave thrust on innovative and cost
effective development of Active pharmaceutical
ingredient (API) by practicing the recent advances in
Green Chemistry as a key pursuit. He further said
“Genericization of life saving medicines provides ample
opportunities to the pharmaceutical companies for
research and development to reduce the cost of API without adverse effect on quality and
prices”.
Dr. Mark Gronnow
Dr. Rakeshwar Bandichhor
15
Dr. J. S. Yadav, Director, CSIR – IICT, Hyderabad,
discussed the application of ionic liquid as Green
Solvent in various reactions like C-C bond formation,
halogenations, oxidation, three component coupling,
selective opening of epoxides, addition reaction, and
intramolecular domino Knoevenagel hetero-Diels-Alder
reaction.
Participants
The workshop was well attended by participants from Indian research laboratories,
universities, industries and R & D institutions. More than 250 participants from all over the
country participated in the workshop.
Concluding Remarks
Green chemistry plays a key role in driving the science and technology innovations needed
for achieving a sustainable future in a complex world. Green Chemistry contributes to the
reduction of risks caused by hazardous chemicals and pollutants for the environment as well
as for human health and therefore contributes to a decrease of resource consumption. In
future, ‘Green Chemistry’ should be incorporated as a fundamental aspect within the field of
chemistry. However, it requires a conscious effort by all eminent scientists for this change to
occur.
Dr. J. S. Yadav
16
APPENDIX A - Workshop Programme
MONDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2012 10:00 – 12:30
Registration at Rajasthan University
12:30 – 14:30
Registration at Conference Venue
15:00 -17:30
Inauguration
16:30 -17:30
Inaugural Lecture
Dr. John C. Warner President and Chief Technology Officer Warner Babcock Institute for Green Chemistry, USA
Green Chemistry: The Missing Element
17:30
Tea
19:00
Dinner
TEUSDAY, DECEMBER 11, 2012 9:30 – 11:00
Session I Chairperson – Prof Anuradha Mishra Co-chairs – Prof. C. P. Bhasin
9:30 – 10:15
Prof. James Clark Director, Green Chemistry Centre of Excellence, University of York, UK
Green Chemistry and Sustainability
10:15 – 11:00
Prof. M. K. Chaudhuri Vice-Chancellor, Tezpur Central University
Green Chemistry in Teaching and Research for Sustainable Future – Some Indian Initiative
11:00 – 11:15
Tea
11:15 – 12:45
Session II Chairperson – Prof. Maria Joao Ramos Co-chairs- Prof. Anshu Dandia
11:15 – 12:00
Dr. Alok Adholeya Director, Biotechnology and Management of Bioresources Division, The Energy and Resource Institute, Delhi
Amalgamation of Biotechnology and Chemistry to Mitigate Environment Problems: A Strategy for Sustainable Future
17
12:00 – 12:45
Prof. S. Chandrasekaran Honorary Professor and JC Bose National Fellow, Indian Institute of Science, and Hindustan Lever Research Professor, JNCASR, Bangalore
Transition Metal Oxide Impregnated MCM catalysts : Regioselectieve Tail to Tail Dimerization of Vinylarenes
12:45 – 14:15
Poster Session Chairperson – Dr. John C. Warner Co-chairs – Prof. K.R. Desai Dr. Nighat Fahmi Dr. D.K. Sharma
13:15 – 15:45
Lunch Break
14:15 – 15:45
Session III Chairperson – Prof. Kailash Daga Co-chairs – Prof. J.S. Rathore Dr. Neelima Gupta
14:15 – 15:00
Dr. Sourav Pal Director, National Chemical Laboratory and Adjunct Professor of Chemistry, IISER, Pune
Computational Chemistry as a tool for Design of Functional Materials: Case study for hydrogen storage materials
15:00 – 15:45
Prof. Maria Joao Ramos Chemistry Department, Faculty of Porto, Portugal
Greener Chemistry: Computational Strategies in Drug Development
15:45 – 16:00
Tea
16:00 – 18:15
Session IV Chairperson- Prof. R. D. Singh Co-chairs – Dr H. B. Singh Dr. Y. C. Joshi
16:00 – 16:45
Dr. Sudhakar G Reddy Coordinator - Sustainable Labs, Office of Campus Sustainability, University of Michigan, USA
Application of Green Chemistry and Pollution Prevention Principles to Develop an Ideal Sustainable Laboratory
16:45 – 17:30
Dr. Kshipra Misra Additional Director, DIPAS (DRDO), Delhi
A Green DRDO Technology for Water Purification
17:30 – 18:15
Prof. Lakshmikantam M. CSIR-IICT, Hyderabad
Metal Oxides in Green Chemistry
WEDNSEDAY, DECEMBER 12, 2012 9:15-10:45
Session V Chairperson – Prof. P. H. Parsania Co-chairs – Prof. P. K. Sharma Dr. Alka Sharma
18
9:15-10:00
Dr. Avtar Matharu Dy. Director, Green Chemistry Centre of Excellence, University of York, UK
Green Chemistry from Grave to Cradle
10:00 – 10:45
Dr. Mark Gronnow Green Chemistry Centre of Excellence, University of York, UK
From Gram to Kilo, Proving Green Chemical Technologies
10:45 – 11:00
Tea
11:00 – 12:30
Session VI Chairperson – Dr. Alok Adholeya Co-chairs – Dr. Sarita Varshney Dr. Devendra Singh
11:00 – 11:45
Dr. Rakeshwar Bandichhor Associate Director, API – R and D Innovation Plaza Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories, Hyderabad, India
Green Chemistry Practices in Pharmaceutical Industry
11:45 – 12:30
Dr. J. S. Yadav CSIR Bhatnagar Fellow CSIR – IICT, Hyderabad
New Methodology for Green Processes
Session VII Chairperson – Prof. Rajiv JainCo-chairs – Dr Ragini Gupta Dr. Asha Jain
12:30-13:15
Prof. A. K. Chakraborti NIPER, Mohali, Punjab
Rational Approaches towards Sustainable Chemistry Development
13:15 – 14:30 Lunch 14:30 – 16:30 Valedictory Function 16:30 Tea