Report of IEC SMB SG1 Report of IEC SMB SG1 “Energy Efficiency and Renewable “Energy Efficiency and Renewable

Resources” Jean.baronas@am.sony.com Resources” Jean.baronas@am.sony.com

IEC TC100 AGS Meeting Held in May 2010 in Athens, IEC TC100 AGS Meeting Held in May 2010 in Athens, Greece Greece

IEC SMB Actions and IEC SMB Actions and DecisionsDecisions

SMB met in February, 2010 Reviewed SG1 Tel Aviv report and TC/SC

comments Concern: “vague, imprecise, and no

action” recommendations Suggest: SG1 members be assigned as

“Champions” and they develop New Work Item Proposals (NWIP)

Decisions 137/8 and 137/9 (next slide)

SMB Decisions 137/8 and SMB Decisions 137/8 and 137/9137/9

SMB Decision 137/8 Approve SG 1 recommendations 27 - 34 Request clarification: 15 revised, 18 revised,

and 20 revised Noting work ongoing in IEC TC100 and IEC

TC108 Asked SG 1 to respond to input IEC TCs/SCs

Reference: SMB/4135A/CC and SMB/4135B/CC

SMB Decision 137/9 Confirmed Mr. Jeha Kim, of Korea, as an SG 1

member Reference: SMB-SG1/0090/INF

# # SMB Approved RecommendationsSMB Approved Recommendations

2727 support production processes optimized for support production processes optimized for energy efficiencyenergy efficiency

-product TCs-product TCs

2828 develop production system simulation tools develop production system simulation tools which address energy efficiencywhich address energy efficiency

-TC65-TC65

2929 smart metering as integral to smart gridsmart metering as integral to smart grid

-SG3-SG3

3030 participate in CIE lighting vocab. Standardsparticipate in CIE lighting vocab. Standards

-TC34-TC34

# # Topics of Approved Topics of Approved RecommendationsRecommendations

3131 CIE publication adoptionCIE publication adoption

-TC34 and TC76-TC34 and TC76

3232 revise TR 15067-3revise TR 15067-3

-ISO/IEC JTC1 SC25-ISO/IEC JTC1 SC25

3333 guidelines and standards to improve lighting guidelines and standards to improve lighting energy efficiencyenergy efficiency

-JTC1 SC25, TC23, TC34, TC59, TC100, -JTC1 SC25, TC23, TC34, TC59, TC100, ISO/TC205, IEC/TC22, TC64ISO/TC205, IEC/TC22, TC64

3434 COPOLCO Rec. 2COPOLCO Rec. 2

-SG3 and IEC TC13 responsible for smart -SG3 and IEC TC13 responsible for smart meters meters

COPOLCO Rec. 5COPOLCO Rec. 5

-TC82, TC88, TC 105 active in renewables -TC82, TC88, TC 105 active in renewables

Revised Twice, Revised Twice, Recommendation 15 Recommendation 15

““Recognizing differing national and regional Recognizing differing national and regional legislation/standards in place for the legislation/standards in place for the classification and labeling of household classification and labeling of household appliances with respect to energy appliances with respect to energy consumption and energy efficiency, consumption and energy efficiency, respectively, TC 59 and its SCs should respectively, TC 59 and its SCs should prepare a Technical Report which describes prepare a Technical Report which describes and compares these requirements. and compares these requirements.

-Based on this analysis, the TR should discuss -Based on this analysis, the TR should discuss possibilities / pre-requisites for future alignment possibilities / pre-requisites for future alignment and potential support from standardization.”and potential support from standardization.”

If TC59 supports, the IEC TC100 If TC59 supports, the IEC TC100 supports. supports.

““Recognizing the huge energy saving potential Recognizing the huge energy saving potential from consumer electronic products, TC 100 from consumer electronic products, TC 100 and TC 108 should present to SMB/SG1 their and TC 108 should present to SMB/SG1 their existing standards as well as ongoing and existing standards as well as ongoing and planned standardization projects with regard planned standardization projects with regard to standby losses and off-mode losses in due to standby losses and off-mode losses in due time before the October 2010 meeting of SG1. time before the October 2010 meeting of SG1.

-Particular attention should be given to -Particular attention should be given to describing pertinent regional legislation, describing pertinent regional legislation, which is to be considered in this context; which is to be considered in this context; furthermore, the treatment of external furthermore, the treatment of external power supplies (AC/DC converterspower supplies (AC/DC converters) ) delivered with pertinent equipment is of delivered with pertinent equipment is of interest.”interest.”

Revised Twice, Revised Twice, Recommendation 18Recommendation 18

Oppose Recommendation 18Oppose Recommendation 18 Reason: The IEC TC100 expertise is in Reason: The IEC TC100 expertise is in

standardization and not legislation. standardization and not legislation. The IEC TC100 develops standards, The IEC TC100 develops standards, including DTV power measurement including DTV power measurement and set top box power measurement, and set top box power measurement, as well as ongoing and planned as well as ongoing and planned standardization projects for standardization projects for networked devices, DC power networked devices, DC power supplies, and battery chargers. These supplies, and battery chargers. These standards specify measurement standards specify measurement techniques as well as electronic techniques as well as electronic interface specifications.interface specifications.

IEC TC100 Comments, #18 IEC TC100 Comments, #18

Revised Twice, Revised Twice, Recommendation 20Recommendation 20

““Recognizing differing national and regional Recognizing differing national and regional legislation/standards in place for the legislation/standards in place for the classification and labeling of consumer classification and labeling of consumer electronic equipment (such as TV sets, set-electronic equipment (such as TV sets, set-top boxes, cable modems, DSL routers, etc.) top boxes, cable modems, DSL routers, etc.) with respect to energy consumption and with respect to energy consumption and energy efficiency, respectively, TC 100 energy efficiency, respectively, TC 100 should prepare a Technical Report which should prepare a Technical Report which describes and compares these requirements.” describes and compares these requirements.” ““Based on this analysis, the TR should discuss Based on this analysis, the TR should discuss

possibilities / pre-requisites for future alignment possibilities / pre-requisites for future alignment and potential support from standardization.” and potential support from standardization.” 

IEC TC100 Comments, #20IEC TC100 Comments, #20

OpposeOppose Reason: The IEC TC100 expertise is Reason: The IEC TC100 expertise is

in standardization and standards in standardization and standards development and not legislation. development and not legislation. Classification and labeling is out of Classification and labeling is out of the IEC TC100 scope. Preparing the the IEC TC100 scope. Preparing the requested Technical Report (TR) requested Technical Report (TR) does not appear to be useful, does not appear to be useful, because classification, energy because classification, energy consumption, and label are defined consumption, and label are defined by national statues. by national statues. 

IEC SMB SG1 IEC SMB SG1 Considerations of ISO/Strategic Considerations of ISO/Strategic

Advisory Group on Energy Advisory Group on Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy

Source (SAG E) Source (SAG E) Recommendations, 55 - 66Recommendations, 55 - 66

Source:Source: SMB-SG1/0091/INFSMB-SG1/0091/INF

Recommendations 55 -66 from Recommendations 55 -66 from ISO/SAG E Meeting 18/19 February ISO/SAG E Meeting 18/19 February

20102010 Vocabulary Vocabulary Energy efficiency in heavy industries, Energy efficiency in heavy industries,

combined heat and power (CHP), combined heat and power (CHP), boilers, buildingsboilers, buildings

Solar energy and biofuelsSolar energy and biofuels Smart gridSmart grid Water sector standardsWater sector standards Energy servicesEnergy services

Recommendations from ISO/SAG E Recommendations from ISO/SAG E Recommendation 55 Recommendation 55

Support ISO/IEC JPC/2 (terminology) planSupport ISO/IEC JPC/2 (terminology) plan More P-member involvement is requested More P-member involvement is requested

Recommendation 56Recommendation 56 Encourages energy efficiency in ISO/TC17, SteelEncourages energy efficiency in ISO/TC17, Steel Asks SAG E to investigate possible energy efficiency Asks SAG E to investigate possible energy efficiency

initiatives in cement, aluminum, and other heavy initiatives in cement, aluminum, and other heavy industriesindustries

Recommendation 57 from Recommendation 57 from ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E

Encourages further discussion Encourages further discussion between ISO TMB and IEC SMB between ISO TMB and IEC SMB secretariats on combined heat and secretariats on combined heat and power (CHP)power (CHP)

SAG E members encouraged to SAG E members encouraged to discuss CHP with national policy discuss CHP with national policy makersmakers

Recommendation 58 from Recommendation 58 from ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E

Plan to readdress efficiency Plan to readdress efficiency calculation and labeling boilers and calculation and labeling boilers and hot water systems hot water systems Includes large biomass boilers Includes large biomass boilers

Recommendation 59 from Recommendation 59 from ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E

General support for ISO/TC 163 and General support for ISO/TC 163 and ISO/TC 205 on energy and buildings ISO/TC 205 on energy and buildings Further progress to address market Further progress to address market

opportunitiesopportunities

Recommendation 60 from Recommendation 60 from

ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E Welcomes new proposals in ISO/TC Welcomes new proposals in ISO/TC

180 Solar energy180 Solar energy Including a proposal from SAC (China) Including a proposal from SAC (China)

on vacuum collectors and proposals that on vacuum collectors and proposals that address integration of solar into address integration of solar into buildingsbuildings

Recommendation 61 from Recommendation 61 from ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E

Support ISO biofuel activity Support ISO biofuel activity Ask SAG E Secretary to discuss Ask SAG E Secretary to discuss

raising awareness by DEVCO (ISO raising awareness by DEVCO (ISO policy committee to address the policy committee to address the needs of developing countries) and needs of developing countries) and UNIDO (United Nations Industrial UNIDO (United Nations Industrial Development Organization)Development Organization)

Recommendation 62 from Recommendation 62 from ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E

Ensure liaison with IEC discussions Ensure liaison with IEC discussions with Smartgridwith Smartgrid

Joint work, as appropriate Joint work, as appropriate

SAG E will develop a white paper on SAG E will develop a white paper on areas where ISO input could be areas where ISO input could be advantageousadvantageous ANSI (US), AFNOR (France), BSI (UK), ANSI (US), AFNOR (France), BSI (UK),

KATS (Korea), SII (Israel), and UNIDOKATS (Korea), SII (Israel), and UNIDO

Recommendation 63 from Recommendation 63 from ISO/SAG E ISO/SAG E

COPOLCO could review their proposal on COPOLCO could review their proposal on energy services for consideration with energy services for consideration with different policies that support the provision different policies that support the provision of energyof energy Encourages energy suppliers and policy makers Encourages energy suppliers and policy makers

support for the COPOLCO proposal support for the COPOLCO proposal Encourages consideration of “horizontal aspects” Encourages consideration of “horizontal aspects”

with other service level agreement types of with other service level agreement types of standardsstandards

Notes success of ISO/TC224, water services, Notes success of ISO/TC224, water services, in developing voluntary standards in developing voluntary standards

Recommendation 64 from Recommendation 64 from ISO/SAG EISO/SAG E

China’s (SAC) proposal on energy China’s (SAC) proposal on energy saving calculations has potential to saving calculations has potential to promote a common understanding promote a common understanding among SAG E among SAG E SAG E: ANSI, KATS, AFNOR, NEC, BSI to SAG E: ANSI, KATS, AFNOR, NEC, BSI to

finalize the SAC proposal, April 2010 finalize the SAC proposal, April 2010

Recommendation 65 from Recommendation 65 from ISO/SAG EISO/SAG E

Recommendation 65Recommendation 65 IEA’s priorities (energy efficiency and IEA’s priorities (energy efficiency and

renewable energy resources) are renewable energy resources) are notable and SAG E will determine what notable and SAG E will determine what they can contribute they can contribute

Recommendation 66 from Recommendation 66 from ISO/SAG EISO/SAG E

SAG E notes some important (energy) SAG E notes some important (energy) issues are not yet covered by international issues are not yet covered by international standardsstandards

SAG E recommends that energy saving SAG E recommends that energy saving calculation methods and practices related calculation methods and practices related to energy efficiency be handled in a to energy efficiency be handled in a flexible, coordinated, and open approach flexible, coordinated, and open approach Within existing committee structures Within existing committee structures Or by creating project committeesOr by creating project committees SAG E will continue to discuss the gapsSAG E will continue to discuss the gaps

SummarySummary

SG1 revised recommendations under SG1 revised recommendations under considerationconsideration Some supported with qualificationSome supported with qualification Some opposedSome opposed

SG1 considering ISO SAG E SG1 considering ISO SAG E recommendations recommendations IEC TC100 supports IEC TC100 supports

For further information: For further information: jean.baronas@am.sony.comjean.baronas@am.sony.com