regional enhancement of the mean dynamic topography using goce gravity gradients matija herceg 1 and...

1
Regional Enhancement of the Mean Dynamic Topography using GOCE Gravity Gradients Matija Herceg 1 and Per Knudsen 1 1 DTU Space, National Space Institute, Department of Geodesy, Copenhagen, Denmark Introduction The main objective of this study is to study how gradients can be used to extract more short wavelength information of the gravity field and to use this enhancement to improve modelling of ocean circulation, i.e. MDT in regional area. This is done by development of a method for regional gravity field recovery by using GOCE gradients in addition to the global models. The Least Squares Collocation method requires the solution of as many linear equations as the number of data, so GOCE gradient data needs to be thinned prior to applying the method. To overcome this thinning, a Reduced Point Mass (RPM) method is developed as a part of this study. The RPM is based on the reduced point mass response. The results presented in this study are based on all available GOCE gradient data in the GOCINA region, i.e. 18 months of observations. Poster number: EGU2012-9196 (XL148) References O. B. Andersen: The DTU10 Global Gravity field and Mean Sea Surface - improvements in the Arctic. 2011. P. Knudsen: GOCINA: Geoid and Ocean Circulation in the North Atlantic. Technical report, 2005. N. Maximenko, P. Niiler, M. H. Rio, O. Melnichenko, L. Centurioni, D. Chambers, V. Zlotnicki, and B. Galperin: Mean dynamic topography of the ocean derived from satellite and drifting buoy data using three different techniques. J. Atmos. Oceanic Tech., 26(9):1910–1919, 2009. M. Herceg: GOCE data for Ocean Modelling, PhD thesis, 2012 European Geosciences Union, General Assembly 2012, Vienna, Austria, 22 – 27 April 2012 [email protected] Discussion A comparison of the GOCE Direct MDT and the GOCE Direct enhanced MDT doesn’t show significant difference. Thus, even though GOCE data provides a better estimation of the MDT in the GOCINA region than any previously obtained using only satellite observations, it could not be concluded whether the regionally enhanced geoid model estimated using GOCE gradients contribute to a further improvement of the determination of the MDT in the GOCINA area. The surface geostrophic currents calculated from the GOCE Direct MDT current speeds reveal that all of the gross features of the general circulation in the region are clear. However, the MDT calculated in the GOCINA project shows the smallest scale details, which makes it the best ocean circulation representation in this region. RPM method Point-mass functions or multipole base-functions are harmonic functions, which may be used to represent the (anomalous) gravity potential T either globally or locally. The functions may be expressed by closed expressions or as sums of Legendre series. In both cases at least the two first terms must be removed since they are not present in T. For local applications the effect of a global gravity model is generally removed. This is later on restored. Then, more terms need to be removed or substituted by terms similar to the error- degree variances. The Earth anomalous gravity field at one point is modeled by a set of base functions, each obtained as the anomalous gravity potential from each point. Results 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 tan cos 1 r V V r V r V r V r V r V r V r V Power spectrum of the geoid height anomaly prediction when EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted. The prediction is done by the LSC and the RPM methods with different datasets Closed expressions for gravity gradients when using point masses Expressions for gravity gradients when using reduced point masses 5 2 2 2 3 3 2 5 2 3 2 2 5 2 ) ( 3 1 1 )) cos( cos sin sin (cos 3 1 ) ( sin cos 3 l t r r l V l l r V l l r V q p q p p q q q q 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 tan cos 1 p p p p p p p p p p p p p p r V V r V r t t V t t V r V r V r t V t r t t V t t V r V Geoid [m] predicted using the LSC method Geoid [m] predicted using the RPM method Difference between prediciton GOCINA geoid (contribution from the EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted) Figures are showing geoid height anomaly predicted by the LSC and the RPM methods, when the EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted. Power spectrum of the geoid height anomaly prediction when EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 240 is subtracted. The prediction is done by the LSC and the RPM methods with different datasets Power spectrum of the difference between geoid height anomaly prediction (when EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted) and EGM2008 based geoid height anomaly GOCINA project MDT Maximenko MDT DTU10 MDT GOCE Direct MDT GOCE Direct enhanced MDT DTU10 MDT 2: difference between DTU10 MSS and EGM2008 Power spectra of different MDT estimates GOCINA project MDT current speed Maximenko MDT current speed DTU10 MDT current speed GOCE Direct MDT current speed GOCE Direct enhanced MDT current speed DTU10 MDT 2 current speed The GOCE Direct MDT current speeds reveal all of the gross features of the general circulation in the region are clear. However, the GOCE Direct enhanced MDT does not show improve-ment over the GOCE Direct MDT.

Upload: valerie-turner

Post on 19-Jan-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Regional Enhancement of the Mean Dynamic Topography using GOCE Gravity Gradients Matija Herceg 1 and Per Knudsen 1 1 DTU Space, National Space Institute,

Regional Enhancement of the Mean Dynamic Topography using GOCE Gravity Gradients

Matija Herceg1 and Per Knudsen1

1DTU Space, National Space Institute, Department of Geodesy, Copenhagen, Denmark

Introduction The main objective of this study is to study how gradients can be used to

extract more short wavelength information of the gravity field and to use this enhancement to improve modelling of ocean circulation, i.e. MDT in regional area. This is done by development of a method for regional gravity field recovery by using GOCE gradients in addition to the global models. The Least Squares Collocation method requires the solution of as many linear equations as the number of data, so GOCE gradient data needs to be thinned prior to applying the method. To overcome this thinning, a Reduced Point Mass (RPM) method is developed as a part of this study. The RPM is based on the reduced point mass response.

The results presented in this study are based on all available GOCE gradient data in the GOCINA region, i.e. 18 months of observations.

Poster number: EGU2012-9196 (XL148)

ReferencesO. B. Andersen: The DTU10 Global Gravity field and Mean Sea Surface - improvements in the Arctic. 2011. P. Knudsen: GOCINA: Geoid and Ocean Circulation in the North Atlantic. Technical report, 2005.N. Maximenko, P. Niiler, M. H. Rio, O. Melnichenko, L. Centurioni, D. Chambers, V. Zlotnicki, and B.

Galperin: Mean dynamic topography of the ocean derived from satellite and drifting buoy data using three different techniques. J. Atmos. Oceanic Tech., 26(9):1910–1919, 2009.

M. Herceg: GOCE data for Ocean Modelling, PhD thesis, 2012

European Geosciences Union, General Assembly 2012, Vienna, Austria, 22 – 27 April 2012 [email protected]

Discussion A comparison of the GOCE Direct MDT and the GOCE Direct enhanced MDT

doesn’t show significant difference. Thus, even though GOCE data provides a better estimation of the MDT in the GOCINA region than any previously obtained using only satellite observations, it could not be concluded whether the regionally enhanced geoid model estimated using GOCE gradients contribute to a further improvement of the determination of the MDT in the GOCINA area.

The surface geostrophic currents calculated from the GOCE Direct MDT current speeds reveal that all of the gross features of the general circulation in the region are clear. However, the MDT calculated in the GOCINA project shows the smallest scale details, which makes it the best ocean circulation representation in this region.

RPM method Point-mass functions or multipole base-functions

are harmonic functions, which may be used to represent the (anomalous) gravity potential T either globally or locally. The functions may be expressed by closed expressions or as sums of Legendre series. In both cases at least the two first terms must be removed since they are not present in T. For local applications the effect of a global gravity model is generally removed. This is later on restored. Then, more terms need to be removed or substituted by terms similar to the error-degree variances. The Earth anomalous gravity field at one point is modeled by a set of base functions, each obtained as the anomalous gravity potential from each point.

Results

2

2

2

2

2

22

2

22

11

1tan

cos

1

r

VV

r

V

r

V

rV

r

V

r

V

r

V

rV

Power spectrum of the geoid height anomaly prediction when EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted. The prediction is done

by the LSC and the RPM methods with different datasets

Closed expressions for gravity gradients when using point masses

Expressions for gravity gradients when using reduced point masses

5

222

3

32

5

2

322

5

2

)(3

1

1))cos(cossinsin(cos3

1)(sincos3

l

trr

lV

ll

rV

ll

rV

qp

qppqq

qq

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

22

11

1tan

cos

1

p

ppppp

pppp

p

ppp

r

VV

r

V

r

t

t

Vt

t

V

rV

r

V

rt

Vt

r

t

t

Vt

t

V

rV

Geoid [m] predicted using the LSC method

Geoid [m] predicted using the RPM method Difference between prediciton

GOCINA geoid (contribution from the EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted)

Figures are showing geoid height anomaly predicted by the LSC and the RPM methods, when the EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted.

Power spectrum of the geoid height anomaly prediction when EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 240 is subtracted. The prediction is done

by the LSC and the RPM methods with different datasets

Power spectrum of the difference between geoid height anomaly prediction (when EGM2008 up to harmonic degree and order 100 is subtracted) and

EGM2008 based geoid height anomaly

GOCINA project MDT

Maximenko MDT

DTU10 MDT

GOCE Direct MDT GOCE Direct enhanced MDT

DTU10 MDT 2: difference between DTU10 MSS and EGM2008

Power spectra of different MDT estimates

GOCINA project MDT current speed

Maximenko MDT current speed

DTU10 MDT current speed

GOCE Direct MDT current speed GOCE Direct enhanced MDT current speed

DTU10 MDT 2 current speed

The GOCE Direct MDT current speeds reveal all of the gross features of the general circulation in the region are clear. However, the GOCE Direct enhanced MDT does not show improve-ment over the GOCE Direct MDT.