regional collaboration to reduce auto dependence: lessons from europe for sb 375

7/29/2019 Regional Collaboration to Reduce Auto Dependence: Lessons from Europe for SB 375

1/14

Urban PaPer SerieS 2013

regional Collaboration to redUCe

aUto dePendenCe

leSSonS from eUroPe for Sb 375

aUtUmn bernStein


2/14

2013 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States. All rights reserved.

No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing

rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF). Please direct inquiries to:

Te German Marshall Fund o the United States

1744 R Street, NW

Washington, DC 20009

1 202 683 2650

F 1 202 265 1662

E [email protected]

Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at www.gmus.org/publications.

gmf Pp Ss

Te GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta, ellows, and partners o the German

Marshall Fund o the United States. Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the

views o GMF. Comments rom readers are welcome; reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to [email protected].

au gmf

Te German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) strengthens transatlantic cooperation on regional, national, andglobal challenges and opportunities in the spirit o the Marshall Plan. GMF does this by supporting individuals and institu-

tions working in the transatlantic sphere, by convening leaders and members o the policy and business communities,

by contributing research and analysis on transatlantic topics, and by providing exchange opportunities to oster renewed

commitment to the transatlantic relationship. In addition, GMF supports a number o initiatives to strengthen democra-

cies. Founded in 1972 as a non-partisan, non-prot organization through a gi rom Germany as a permanent memorial to

Marshall Plan assistance, GMF maintains a strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic. In addition to its headquarters in

Washington, DC, GMF has ofces in Berlin, Paris, Brussels, Belgrade, Ankara, Bucharest, Warsaw, and unis. GMF also has

smaller representations in Bratislava, urin, and Stockholm.

On the cover: rams in orino Autumn Berstein
http://www.gmfus.org/publicationshttp://www.gmfus.org/http://www.gmfus.org/http://www.gmfus.org/publications


3/14

Regional Collaboration to ReduceAuto Dependence

Lessons from Europe for SB 375

Urban Policy Paper Series

February 2013

A B1

A B h CP, w - z wk v v C. Sh w v - SB , h S C C P A, whh q h C 8 M- P Oz v vh v. Sh w U R P Fw .

I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

C S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

T M A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

G L . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

V R S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

D . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

I Lh Mj C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

Ov C Ph M . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

Lk E Dv S T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

E C P A, L-S P . . . . . . . . . . 9

C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
http://www.climateplan.org/http://www.climateplan.org/


4/14

Regional Collaboration to Reduce Auto Dependence 1

Introduction

1

Wh h h SC C P

A (SB ) 8, whh q

h C 8 M P O-

z v

vh v, h h k

x

h. Th w w, h k

h U S,

h hk h -

w v h -

h

h. Th w z (MPO) v

h v-

w h wh

v. A , SB k

k vw wh

wh. H, C

h hw h .

C hv

xv , ,

, wh hh

h j.

Th, C h v , wh h

h .

F SB wk, w h

h

h v h

.

M E hv wk

. M h -

kw x h Skh, Sw, Ch, Dk

. I h h

h v wk

C h h

v. I, I h wh

h vv w,

- h h -

z. Wh C SB

q

,

h v. Cwh h wh SB

v h

w j.

Th, I x wh j

h , h h

wh h w h

v.

A C SB , h

E h

hv wk v . A

w wh GMF U R P

P, h , I v T, I;

L, F; S, G, x

h h

, h h hv

,

hw h h

h h w -

.

For SB 375 to work

cities and towns th

are more accustom

to competition than

collaboration must

come together arou

a common vision fothe larger metropo

region.


5/14

The German Marshall Fund of the United States2

Case Studies

2Torino Metropolitan Area

I h 99,

hv T

x . A h

h

h h

h, h C T h

, V C-

, . U h

h, h C T v v

v

hh ,

, , z h v -

h h

49 .8 .

I h h M C,

h v- F C, h

w j, C Nv

M M Mzz G.

Thh v I w k h

w T h h

C . Eh h -

j k v

h h -

v . D h h,

h T h

. Th

v h v, h

h wh h

wh h , -

v. A -

z, T I, w h

k h -

h v. Fh, w h

M M A T w -

h

h . Th w

h

v k

h . A h I

vw, h h

VMT -

h v , v

w j, k

w .

Th S P w

v w h

, h h

v wh

h h E . K h h hv h

VMT :

LaSpinaCentrale:Th h

j kv h

, j

h k h

. Th j, kw L S

C h k, w

h . Th j

v

hh h v h h - wh x- v

v .

Eh h h

v v j ,

, hh

. P w

x- v h h

hh

v v

w . Pj w

wh , h

h wh v , w

h v.

Reorganizationofthelocalbusnetwork:

Th w

wk wh

Each of these officials

cited competition

among jurisdictions

and a lack of

appropriate policy and

fiscal incentives for

collaboration as thebiggest challenges

to effective regional

planning.


6/14


v wh hx h C T

w w . (Th

6,

. Ah

.)

Highspeedtrainconnections:Th h

v h

h E v

T . Nw hh- v

w T M h h,

hh- k L .

Reclaimingpublicspacesfromautomobiles:

T hv

k k zz

. M h

h zz, k

, h k

. Th w

h , h - z,

V G, E -

. Dv T

w h

wk. Fw h L

h , T h h

h

, w v h

wk, h h w

h.

Th h hv v j

. Th h

h 99 (h

v) h w

6. B w 6 , h

h h 6. .

Th z , whh

wh h h w P

S D , x

v v .

Th S P v h v v h -

, h hv

h k v,

v w v-

, k h hh v

v. N v I vw

h h h C T -

M C, h S

Ch k h h

.

Hwv, h h

. A h I vw, T hv v h

v h vh w,

, wk

v. S, h

v h j h

w , h,

h - . Th -

h w h

wh h j

v h wh .

Th, h q

h , w h

h .

T k v w -

C:

h h L A

S F k h

h ;

h h

v

.

Greater Lyon

Th G L U C w

E. I h L 6

, h .

The Strategic Plan

envisioned the grad

evolution of a stron

governance structu

for the metropolitan

area, but initial step

in this direction havbeen hampered by

lack of appropriate

incentives, conflicts

among municipaliti

over new developm

and a lack of leade

from higher levels o

government.


7/14


h. Th v w wh

w, ww, h

k , h

h 966. I,

h C

hv h. Wh C

hv k h ,

h G L hv

v v

wh h w -

, , v-

. A wh

, h

.

G L v

v h

h h L,

wh w ,

k . Th

h

, wh h

h v v k.

Th -

, v

( ),

h v wk

. Wh w

j v ,

G L h h k v

wh .

K L :

Multimodaltransitnetworkexpansions

linkedtourbangrowthplans. I

, G L h x

h , w, wk, w

h wk F.

Nw wh

v , h

v hv h.

Linkingeconomicdevelopmentwith

transitinvestments.G L

v hz w

v wh ,

v h

h P

Gv. L w h Fh hv

hh v P h G

L w h h hh

. G L h z h v L -

hh

v.

Sh Ch G L

v h h

h L wh h

w. C hv

h h j h

M B. Nw -

v h h

L C, w j

h h h w v hh .

Bicyclesharing.G L w h

E -

h . Th Vv

v E w h . M

h h h

h h , h

Vv k hv h

. F v k Vv h

, h h k hv v . L v- h

h VV , G V,

h h h h

wh h . Vv

h h h h

k wh k ,

or every bike Velov put

on the street, another

three bikes have been

dded by private users.


8/14


v xw hv h hw

h . Th Vv

wh v

xv h h

h . Th j h

v v. Th

h

h v,

h - h

hv, v v

. Th k k h

h .

Stablefundingfortransit. G L h

-

hk

x h 6

h h wk.

Th w v h x w h

v.

Shapingnationalpolicy

tosupportregionalism.

A h x

v, G L

h

v.

S

966, G L h

v

h

. M E,

D D

CERTU, Fh h wk

,

x h G

L,

v,

h h v

v v

v . A , h

F w L

h h w v v

.

Decouplingautomobiletravelfromeconomic

growth.A G L

F v h

w. F 99

6, h v G L

.9 .6 . Nw, ,

F v

h W W II,

v

w (F ). Th h

v h

h wh x k

v. F v

Figure 1: Relationship between GDP and Vehicle Kilometers Traveled (VKT)

in France, 1990 2008. source: CERTU.

!"

#

Greater Lyon, as a

pioneer in metropo

governance,

has successfully

lobbied the nationa

government to crea

more financial andregulatory incentive

collaborative region

planning over time.


9/14


hh wk, wh v

, v w

v h

h -

.

Wh G L h h h-

vw ,

hh v v-

G L w h

wh I w h

v wk v.

Verband Region Stuttgart

I 994, h 9 h S

h V

R S (VRS), x h w

v. Th

h VRS w h

h 99, wh

E. S D,

Ph, Bh hq h v z

h

v q -

.

Th h h -

v w h C S

h - S D P. Th

h B-W

h V R S,

h h

v. Th w

h w v h

, whh w hv

WWII h v

v . Th j

G v v-

, whh w w. Th h v

h -h (h

Ch D P) h

wh h

. Th w , v h w

h

v

h .

V R S k h

h -

, h h v

h .Th w v h w

v h . Th h h

j , hk h w

:

Planningforgrowthneartransit.VRS w

v h h v

v , v wh

h . Th

w 998 9.

Th k w

: w h j

hv v

.

Developingacoordinatedregional

transportationsystem.Th

. Th

w h h

, h

. M

h

, hh VRS h k v h S-h, h

h S -

.

Openspaceplan.VRS

- h

Verband Region

Stuttgart took the

unprecedented

approach of creating

a directly elected

etropolitan parliament


10/14


. Th hw , v

v .

Wh h h

v h , h

h w v h k h

kh h h w h v-

B-W k

v h . Th S

j v, 4.8

h S . Th

k h , h v, v, h

w h h -

. P h h

v h j h

h h

S k.

J w h I v S,

h j h

v kw h .

Tv hk-

wv h k

. D v h w v, h I vw

w . C-

w h w

h , h

. Th h

v h Mh ,h CDU , whh h v h

B-W v , w

v . Th S G

wh h S j

v w v h . A k

, h w -w v w

hh wh h

S . Th v

Nv h

j v h v

j. Th w v h w

, hh h j . P hv ,

v hv

h j.

C wh v

j. B wh

h v v

k S -

G k h k

h k kh. Mh

h wh h C

S, h h j w

wh v wh w

k h h . C

C w h

h wk v v SB

.

But it is noteworthy

even a directly elec

regional governmen

like Stuttgarts in

place as transit-frie

as Germany can

make the mistakeof alienating their

constituency and

sparking a backlas


11/14


Wh h v w, vh h

h. C

wh h

h , v

C h SB .

Importance of Leadership from Major Cities

I v I v, k v

w h

h . M , h

h , , h

h . Th - h v

h , h w

h w h v, v

, h hh k, k .

B wh h

x , x v-

, v ,

h

h w -.

Wh h k h h

, h k w. I T,

v h

h

h . L L h

k h w h

h, z F h k

v h h . Th

S h -

h v,

w v

h .

I C, h h

. B h L A S F k

k z,

wh

hv w

h . A , -

hv kw whhw v v v h

h -

,

. U h h

w SB .

Overcoming Competition and Parochialism

among Municipalities

A , h w h

C. L v-

, , x v

. Wh v kw h hh, h

v

w v . I

h I , v h h

wh h v, -

v .

I L, w h

h--h wh h -

v h v. Th

v h h -

h v. I h

T , h

v w h h

h v. Hwv, v

h I v hv

w, v T h

x h.

I S, w w w v

w v .

Th wk

w hv w v

h -

v h k q j, h z hv.

Th h S h -

v

.

Discussion

3

The mayor of the main

city is, formally or

nformally, the leader of

the metropolitan area.


12/14


C h h v . SB

process

v w

v. Th h.

Hwv, v h , h

v h v-

wh v L h .

Linking Economic Development to Sustainable

Transportation

I h , v w v -

. O vw

v

w , L T

h x v-

h w v

v. L S h hv

v h

wk wh -

w v -

. Th h

h , h v-, h -

. Wh SB

v, h

h v-

.

Ensuring Community Participation in Abstract,

Large-Scale Planning

Th v v h S j w

q x h,

v wh h

wh h -

. V R S, wh

, v v-

v h v h. B h

h kh h S j

h h : hw h w-,

.

I h S, h v

. Th v

h h j -

v h ,

w hk h v w

v h j ( w

, , ).

Mh h , wk-

h, v ,

h h h .

I C, SB h

vv -

. O h v h hv

SB , h k vv-

. I , h h

h . Hwv, h

h S D , whh w h

SB . Th

S D w v O

hv -

h w , . A

v w,

h h h h

h v hv

hhw j. Th C

j h , D , S

C J Th T v h

. Th w k . Th

S D x h

S k h C

h

wh z h v SB .

Stuttgart 21 projec

...provides a cautio

tale for what can

happen when regio

planning gets ahea

its constituency.


13/14


Conclusion

4

C x x-

, h , h hv x

h h h

. S h -

v h, k, h

h h , C k

wh h SB .

Th I v E -

v h

w h --

z, E , v

, h h. A hhv , , ,

. Th wh ,

h h v

wk .

Av , I w k h h v v k

. Th h x

h. I h h x w

h wh hv ; h

h h h

. I v h ,

k h q, h v

h w.

C h

. A h ,

wh h v .

C h wh , I v h h w

hv h j h -

hw w .

uccesses demonstrate

what is possible...

failures remind us that

l governance is a work

in progress.


14/14

Off i c e s

Washington Berlin Paris Brussels BelgradeAnkara Bucharest Warsaw Tunis

www.gmu.org
http://www.gmfus.org/http://www.gmfus.org/

regional collaboration to reduce auto dependence: lessons from europe for sb 375

Documents